What do you think?
Rate this book
City of Liars
On a rare night out, Liv, a divorced single mom, meets Theo, a gifted pianist with a past he’s fought hard to outrun. Their connection is instant, electric, undeniable. But by morning? Out of the question.
Because Theo is a Dressler, and Liv Carter knows exactly what that means.
In 1920s New York City, two little girls vanished: one from a glittering world of privilege, the other from a crowded tenement. When a single child reappeared, her memory erased, two families claimed her. Wealth won, and the Carters kept the girl. The Dresslers were left with nothing but grief…and a wound that never healed.
Now, decades later, Liv and Theo find themselves on opposite sides of an unfinished story, with a legacy of loss they both carry. As their forbidden love deepens, so does the mystery binding their families together. Secrets surface. Relationships shatter. Fate draws Liv and Theo closer together, leaving them to decide how much of the past they’re willing to uncover. Especially when the truth could either break the cycle…or tear them apart for good.
Perfect for fans of Rebecca Yarros’s The Things We Leave Unfinished, Evie Woods' The Lost Bookshop, and Emily Henry's Great Big Beautiful Life.
Because Theo is a Dressler, and Liv Carter knows exactly what that means.
In 1920s New York City, two little girls vanished: one from a glittering world of privilege, the other from a crowded tenement. When a single child reappeared, her memory erased, two families claimed her. Wealth won, and the Carters kept the girl. The Dresslers were left with nothing but grief…and a wound that never healed.
Now, decades later, Liv and Theo find themselves on opposite sides of an unfinished story, with a legacy of loss they both carry. As their forbidden love deepens, so does the mystery binding their families together. Secrets surface. Relationships shatter. Fate draws Liv and Theo closer together, leaving them to decide how much of the past they’re willing to uncover. Especially when the truth could either break the cycle…or tear them apart for good.
Perfect for fans of Rebecca Yarros’s The Things We Leave Unfinished, Evie Woods' The Lost Bookshop, and Emily Henry's Great Big Beautiful Life.
- GenresRomance
416 pages, Paperback
First published July 9, 2026
About the author
Emily Colin
15 books360 followersEmily Colin is a New York Times and USA Today bestselling author whose books blend romance and the supernatural. Her debut novel, The Memory Thief, was a Target Emerging Authors Pick, and her Slavic-inspired romantasy, Fate and Fury, was named a 2024 Foreword INDIES Award finalist and Indie Author Project Select Pick. Emily’s young adult dystopian romantasy series, The Seven Sins, won the Gold Moonbeam, Silver IPPY, and North Carolina Indie Author Project Awards. This series has also been a two-time Foreword INDIES Award finalist and was shortlisted for the Manly Wade Wellman Award for Science Fiction and Fantasy.
A former indie bookseller who spent years in the field of community arts engagement, Emily believes deeply in the power of the arts to transform lives. In her work as an editor, Author Accelerator-certified book coach, and instructor, she focuses on helping authors develop a sustainable writing practice while bringing the books of their dreams to life. She’s served as a Pitch Wars and Kiss Pitch mentor and is currently a Duke University Arts Studio mentor. A native Brooklynite, Emily lives in coastal North Carolina with her family. When not crafting her next novel, she can be found chasing her chaotic pets or drinking mochas by the sea.
Visit her online at www.emilycolin.com or @emilycolinbooks.
.
A former indie bookseller who spent years in the field of community arts engagement, Emily believes deeply in the power of the arts to transform lives. In her work as an editor, Author Accelerator-certified book coach, and instructor, she focuses on helping authors develop a sustainable writing practice while bringing the books of their dreams to life. She’s served as a Pitch Wars and Kiss Pitch mentor and is currently a Duke University Arts Studio mentor. A native Brooklynite, Emily lives in coastal North Carolina with her family. When not crafting her next novel, she can be found chasing her chaotic pets or drinking mochas by the sea.
Visit her online at www.emilycolin.com or @emilycolinbooks.
.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews
July 5, 2026
Review of an advance copy received from author
What fascinates me the most about this book is three things.
First, the overall concept. When I see a mystery that seems to have stopped in one timeline, only to be brought back to the surface ninety years later, I feel like all my curious guesses are tied into something neat.
I become fully invested in the truth hiding itself across generations, making the past and the present feel like scattered puzzle pieces until they finally point to huge answers, revealing layers of secrets.
Second, I guess I’d like to thank the ghostly dreams and paranormal experiences that slowly drop the clues. Witnessing paranormal experiences that transcend the logical boundaries of people who don’t believe in spirits is truly remarkable.
Liv doesn’t believe in them, and neither does Theo. Yet they both keep picking up the signs, and I think that’s brilliant. It makes the paranormal feel like something that doesn’t need your belief to exist.
It simply exists to communicate with you, showing its presence and helping you in its own way, whether you’re ready to accept it or not.
And third, the shocking twist surrounding Liv’s family, especially her narcissist dad. The twist stays hidden beneath years of parental control and obsession with reputation. But what truly hits me is not only the secret itself. It’s also the realization that every attempt to stop Liv from searching suddenly makes sense. Every warning, every argument, every threat… all of it leads back to one decision that quietly steals eighteen years from a family that deserves to be reunited.
This is not only a romance. It is not only a mystery either. This is a story where family secrets, disappearances, generational trauma, and love grow together into one tangled knot that slowly unties itself chapter after chapter.
⸻
The story moves between New York in 1927 and present-day North Carolina.
Long ago, two little girls disappeared around the same time. Ella Carter belonged to a wealthy family. The other, Lily Dressler, came from a poor family living in a tenement. When one child was finally returned, one question never really stopped.
Is she Ella? Or is she Lily?
That question echoed through decades, leaving scars on both families.
Years later, Liv, a trauma therapist, and Theo, an attractive pianist, unexpectedly become part of that unfinished story. As they develop feelings for each other, they also find themselves walking deeper into a mystery that has shaped their families long before they were even born. The more they uncover, the more they realize that some lies don’t disappear with time. They simply wait for someone brave enough to uncover them.
⸻
Another thing to appreciate the most is how naturally the author blends everything together. The romance never steals attention from the mystery. The mystery never overshadows the emotional weight carried by every family. And the dual timeline never feels confusing. Instead, every return to the past feels like receiving another missing puzzle piece until everything finally connects.
The story explores generational trauma without making it feel like a lecture, because you simply watch how a decision ripple through decades, affecting the lives of people across generations. If you enjoy romance wrapped around family secrets, dual timelines, paranormal touches, and a mystery that patiently unfolds piece by piece, this book is absolutely worth picking up.
What fascinates me the most about this book is three things.
First, the overall concept. When I see a mystery that seems to have stopped in one timeline, only to be brought back to the surface ninety years later, I feel like all my curious guesses are tied into something neat.
I become fully invested in the truth hiding itself across generations, making the past and the present feel like scattered puzzle pieces until they finally point to huge answers, revealing layers of secrets.
Second, I guess I’d like to thank the ghostly dreams and paranormal experiences that slowly drop the clues. Witnessing paranormal experiences that transcend the logical boundaries of people who don’t believe in spirits is truly remarkable.
Liv doesn’t believe in them, and neither does Theo. Yet they both keep picking up the signs, and I think that’s brilliant. It makes the paranormal feel like something that doesn’t need your belief to exist.
It simply exists to communicate with you, showing its presence and helping you in its own way, whether you’re ready to accept it or not.
And third, the shocking twist surrounding Liv’s family, especially her narcissist dad. The twist stays hidden beneath years of parental control and obsession with reputation. But what truly hits me is not only the secret itself. It’s also the realization that every attempt to stop Liv from searching suddenly makes sense. Every warning, every argument, every threat… all of it leads back to one decision that quietly steals eighteen years from a family that deserves to be reunited.
This is not only a romance. It is not only a mystery either. This is a story where family secrets, disappearances, generational trauma, and love grow together into one tangled knot that slowly unties itself chapter after chapter.
⸻
The story moves between New York in 1927 and present-day North Carolina.
Long ago, two little girls disappeared around the same time. Ella Carter belonged to a wealthy family. The other, Lily Dressler, came from a poor family living in a tenement. When one child was finally returned, one question never really stopped.
Is she Ella? Or is she Lily?
That question echoed through decades, leaving scars on both families.
Years later, Liv, a trauma therapist, and Theo, an attractive pianist, unexpectedly become part of that unfinished story. As they develop feelings for each other, they also find themselves walking deeper into a mystery that has shaped their families long before they were even born. The more they uncover, the more they realize that some lies don’t disappear with time. They simply wait for someone brave enough to uncover them.
⸻
Another thing to appreciate the most is how naturally the author blends everything together. The romance never steals attention from the mystery. The mystery never overshadows the emotional weight carried by every family. And the dual timeline never feels confusing. Instead, every return to the past feels like receiving another missing puzzle piece until everything finally connects.
The story explores generational trauma without making it feel like a lecture, because you simply watch how a decision ripple through decades, affecting the lives of people across generations. If you enjoy romance wrapped around family secrets, dual timelines, paranormal touches, and a mystery that patiently unfolds piece by piece, this book is absolutely worth picking up.
July 11, 2026
This wasn't just a book... it was an experience.
I closed City of Liars with tears streaming down my face and immediately wanted to text everyone I know: "READ. THIS. BOOK."😭🫶🏾
Emily Colin absolutely blew me away.
This was a breathtaking dual timeline novel filled with generational trauma, forbidden love, ghostly whispers from the past, heartbreaking family secrets, and plot twists that completely knocked the wind out of me.🤯
And when I say I didn't see those twists coming...
BABES. I DID NOT SEE THEM COMING.
Especially THAT LAST ONE.
My jaw was literally on the floor.
The way Emily slowly peels back nearly a century of lies had me questioning every single person. Because every chapter felt like another puzzle piece clicking into place... until suddenly the entire picture changed.
Liv and Theo were two broken people carrying generations of pain neither of them created while trying to build something beautiful anyway.
Then there's the historical timeline...I became completely invested in Ella and Lily's story. Every time the book jumped back to 1920s New York, I couldn't turn the pages fast enough because I was DYING to know the truth.
The paranormal elements weren't there to scare you. They were there to remind you that love, grief, and truth don't disappear just because time passes.
As someone who loves books about healing, family, and breaking generational cycles, this one absolutely destroyed me. It explores how one decision….one lie…can echo through generations, shaping people who weren't even alive when it happened. I cried. Like... ugly cried. Especially during those final chapters.
This is one of those books that reminds you the truth has a way of surviving, even when people spend decades trying to bury it.
If you love: 📚 a new women's fiction book with unforgettable characters 🕰️ a beautifully written dual timeline novel ❤️ forbidden romance 👻 subtle paranormal elements 🗝️ family secrets 🏙️ historical New York City 🧩 generational mystery 💙 emotional healing ✨ shocking plot twists 📖 stories that stay with you long after the final page...
Please, please add City of Liars to your TBR babes🤌🏾🔥.
This is hands down one of my favorite books of the year and one I'll be recommending over and over again.🫶🏾
Thank you so much @emilycolinbooks and @katerockliteraryservices for trusting me with this incredible story. It completely stole my heart.💛
#CityOfLiars #EmilyColinAuthor
I closed City of Liars with tears streaming down my face and immediately wanted to text everyone I know: "READ. THIS. BOOK."😭🫶🏾
Emily Colin absolutely blew me away.
This was a breathtaking dual timeline novel filled with generational trauma, forbidden love, ghostly whispers from the past, heartbreaking family secrets, and plot twists that completely knocked the wind out of me.🤯
And when I say I didn't see those twists coming...
BABES. I DID NOT SEE THEM COMING.
Especially THAT LAST ONE.
My jaw was literally on the floor.
The way Emily slowly peels back nearly a century of lies had me questioning every single person. Because every chapter felt like another puzzle piece clicking into place... until suddenly the entire picture changed.
Liv and Theo were two broken people carrying generations of pain neither of them created while trying to build something beautiful anyway.
Then there's the historical timeline...I became completely invested in Ella and Lily's story. Every time the book jumped back to 1920s New York, I couldn't turn the pages fast enough because I was DYING to know the truth.
The paranormal elements weren't there to scare you. They were there to remind you that love, grief, and truth don't disappear just because time passes.
As someone who loves books about healing, family, and breaking generational cycles, this one absolutely destroyed me. It explores how one decision….one lie…can echo through generations, shaping people who weren't even alive when it happened. I cried. Like... ugly cried. Especially during those final chapters.
This is one of those books that reminds you the truth has a way of surviving, even when people spend decades trying to bury it.
If you love: 📚 a new women's fiction book with unforgettable characters 🕰️ a beautifully written dual timeline novel ❤️ forbidden romance 👻 subtle paranormal elements 🗝️ family secrets 🏙️ historical New York City 🧩 generational mystery 💙 emotional healing ✨ shocking plot twists 📖 stories that stay with you long after the final page...
Please, please add City of Liars to your TBR babes🤌🏾🔥.
This is hands down one of my favorite books of the year and one I'll be recommending over and over again.🫶🏾
Thank you so much @emilycolinbooks and @katerockliteraryservices for trusting me with this incredible story. It completely stole my heart.💛
#CityOfLiars #EmilyColinAuthor
June 18, 2026
Nothing like going home with the piano player from the bar, only to find out the next morning your families are mortal enemies. But Liv and Theo have too much chemistry to stay away from each other, and are determined to find the answers needed to heal their families' past trauma. I like how the story is told in dual timelines from multiple points of view, and I loved the blend of romance, mystery, and the paranormal.
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
I think City of Liars might be Emily Colin’s best book yet. At the very least, it is absolutely my favorite of hers.
The setup immediately hooked me. In 1926 New York City, two little girls disappear on the same snowy night: Ella Carter, daughter of a wealthy socialite family, and Lily Dressler, a child from a tenement family. A year later, one girl is returned after being adopted from an orphanage. The Carters claim her as Ella. Lily’s mother is certain she is her daughter. The Carters have money, power, and influence. The Dresslers do not. You can imagine how that goes.
From there, the novel unfolds across dual timelines, moving between the glittering, ruthless world of 1920s Manhattan and the present-day lives of Liv and Theo, two people tied to opposite sides of this century-old family tragedy. Colin brings New York vividly to life from multiple perspectives and classes, making the city feel like a character in its own right: growing, changing, devouring, remembering, and holding tight to its ghosts.
The mystery is deliciously suspenseful. We truly do not know whether Liv’s grandmother was Ella or Lily, and the emotional stakes are just as strong as the plot stakes. Would knowing the truth heal these families or destroy them all over again? That question gives the book so much weight.
I also loved the way the story explores class, both in the past and present. Would things have turned out differently if Lily’s family had money? Almost certainly. The injustice at the heart of the story is painful because it is so believable. This is also a book about generational trauma, where we watch one terrible decision ripple through decades, shaping lives long after the original players are gone.
And then there is the romance. Liv and Theo are wonderful together. Liv is a recently divorced single mother and psychologist who still can’t quite see the toxicity in her own family 9her dad is a walking red flag), while Theo is a brilliant pianist who has fought his way out of poverty but is terrified to let anyone truly in. Their chemistry is intense. Much spicier than I expected, honestly. Not necessarily my personal cup of tea, but for readers who love heat, there is plenty here. Let’s just say there is a modern-day Bridgerton Polin carriage scene, so maybe don’t read certain chapters during a heatwave.
City of Liars is romantic, haunting, suspenseful, and emotionally rich. If you enjoy family secrets, dual timelines, ghostly interventions, class tension, and romance wrapped around a mystery that unfolds piece by piece, this book is absolutely worth picking up.
The setup immediately hooked me. In 1926 New York City, two little girls disappear on the same snowy night: Ella Carter, daughter of a wealthy socialite family, and Lily Dressler, a child from a tenement family. A year later, one girl is returned after being adopted from an orphanage. The Carters claim her as Ella. Lily’s mother is certain she is her daughter. The Carters have money, power, and influence. The Dresslers do not. You can imagine how that goes.
From there, the novel unfolds across dual timelines, moving between the glittering, ruthless world of 1920s Manhattan and the present-day lives of Liv and Theo, two people tied to opposite sides of this century-old family tragedy. Colin brings New York vividly to life from multiple perspectives and classes, making the city feel like a character in its own right: growing, changing, devouring, remembering, and holding tight to its ghosts.
The mystery is deliciously suspenseful. We truly do not know whether Liv’s grandmother was Ella or Lily, and the emotional stakes are just as strong as the plot stakes. Would knowing the truth heal these families or destroy them all over again? That question gives the book so much weight.
I also loved the way the story explores class, both in the past and present. Would things have turned out differently if Lily’s family had money? Almost certainly. The injustice at the heart of the story is painful because it is so believable. This is also a book about generational trauma, where we watch one terrible decision ripple through decades, shaping lives long after the original players are gone.
And then there is the romance. Liv and Theo are wonderful together. Liv is a recently divorced single mother and psychologist who still can’t quite see the toxicity in her own family 9her dad is a walking red flag), while Theo is a brilliant pianist who has fought his way out of poverty but is terrified to let anyone truly in. Their chemistry is intense. Much spicier than I expected, honestly. Not necessarily my personal cup of tea, but for readers who love heat, there is plenty here. Let’s just say there is a modern-day Bridgerton Polin carriage scene, so maybe don’t read certain chapters during a heatwave.
City of Liars is romantic, haunting, suspenseful, and emotionally rich. If you enjoy family secrets, dual timelines, ghostly interventions, class tension, and romance wrapped around a mystery that unfolds piece by piece, this book is absolutely worth picking up.
July 10, 2026
Thank you Kate Rock Literary Services for the gifted copy of City of Liars by Emily Collin.
“A night of passion unleashes a century of secrets…”
Liv, a single mother, wanders into a bar and meets Theo, a handsome piano player. After a romantic night, they discover that they are from families that have been feuding for generations!
In 1920’s New York City, two toddler girls were taken. One was Ella from the wealthy Carter family while playing in Gramercy Park, the other was Lily from the poor Dressler family while playing in the tenement courtyard. A year later, a young girl found in Chicago was identified as the missing girl from a newspaper article and was claimed by the Carter family, but the Dresslers always suspected she was really theirs. This led to a public battle in court and dire consequences for both families.
Liv and Theo manage the tension and inexplicable pull of their forbidden romantic feelings while
working together to uncover family secrets and truth in an effort towards reconciliation and healing of generational trauma.
I really enjoyed that this was a historical mystery and I liked the flashbacks to the 1920’s and the supernatural encounters that provided clues to guide Liv and Theo in their search for information. I appreciated that Liv’s career and field of study addressed how the past influences the present and how trauma can be passed down not just through behavior but literally through genetics. I found it interesting to consider the ways people define family, identity and belonging.
Sometimes the animosity between the families felt overdramatic and the way the mystery was ultimately resolved, I felt the book could have been up to 100 pages shorter.
I would recommend this book to readers who enjoy a historical mystery that includes supernatural elements intertwined with romance.
“A night of passion unleashes a century of secrets…”
Liv, a single mother, wanders into a bar and meets Theo, a handsome piano player. After a romantic night, they discover that they are from families that have been feuding for generations!
In 1920’s New York City, two toddler girls were taken. One was Ella from the wealthy Carter family while playing in Gramercy Park, the other was Lily from the poor Dressler family while playing in the tenement courtyard. A year later, a young girl found in Chicago was identified as the missing girl from a newspaper article and was claimed by the Carter family, but the Dresslers always suspected she was really theirs. This led to a public battle in court and dire consequences for both families.
Liv and Theo manage the tension and inexplicable pull of their forbidden romantic feelings while
working together to uncover family secrets and truth in an effort towards reconciliation and healing of generational trauma.
I really enjoyed that this was a historical mystery and I liked the flashbacks to the 1920’s and the supernatural encounters that provided clues to guide Liv and Theo in their search for information. I appreciated that Liv’s career and field of study addressed how the past influences the present and how trauma can be passed down not just through behavior but literally through genetics. I found it interesting to consider the ways people define family, identity and belonging.
Sometimes the animosity between the families felt overdramatic and the way the mystery was ultimately resolved, I felt the book could have been up to 100 pages shorter.
I would recommend this book to readers who enjoy a historical mystery that includes supernatural elements intertwined with romance.
July 9, 2026
From page one, Emily Colin’s City of Liars pulls you in and doesn’t let go. This dual timeline story balances a compelling mystery with a romance that tugged my heartstrings.
With vivid prose, Emily sweeps us into 1920s New York City where two little girls, Ella Carter and Lily Dressler, go missing. Only one is found, but who is she? That question haunts these two families, sparking a feud that ripples through generations.
In present day North Carolina, Theo and Liv, meet one fateful night and fall hard for each other, only to find out they’re caught in this generational feud, forcing them to choose between family loyalty and an attraction that just won’t quit. But is what they have more than just good sex…I mean, really good sex? 😉 Drawn together by a sense of justice, they decide to work together to find out the truth of the missing girls. And the more they work together, the more they reveal their true selves…and feelings for each other.
What stands out about City of Liars is the humanity with which Emily treats every single character. Each angle and participant in the feud, even a potential kidnapper, is portrayed with nuance and compassion, making an already compelling story irresistible and relatable.
I also deeply appreciate Emily’s exploration of class disparities and mental health issues. I loved that she explored anxiety and depression in Theo. Normalizing discussion around mental health issues and well being for men is so important!
A huge thank you to Emily Colin for the opportunity to read an advance copy. I love City of Liars and highly recommend!
With vivid prose, Emily sweeps us into 1920s New York City where two little girls, Ella Carter and Lily Dressler, go missing. Only one is found, but who is she? That question haunts these two families, sparking a feud that ripples through generations.
In present day North Carolina, Theo and Liv, meet one fateful night and fall hard for each other, only to find out they’re caught in this generational feud, forcing them to choose between family loyalty and an attraction that just won’t quit. But is what they have more than just good sex…I mean, really good sex? 😉 Drawn together by a sense of justice, they decide to work together to find out the truth of the missing girls. And the more they work together, the more they reveal their true selves…and feelings for each other.
What stands out about City of Liars is the humanity with which Emily treats every single character. Each angle and participant in the feud, even a potential kidnapper, is portrayed with nuance and compassion, making an already compelling story irresistible and relatable.
I also deeply appreciate Emily’s exploration of class disparities and mental health issues. I loved that she explored anxiety and depression in Theo. Normalizing discussion around mental health issues and well being for men is so important!
A huge thank you to Emily Colin for the opportunity to read an advance copy. I love City of Liars and highly recommend!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
City of Liars is a beautifully woven dual‑timeline mystery that blends romance, family secrets, and a touch of the supernatural into a story that feels both sweeping and intimate. From the moment the two little girls disappear in 1920s New York, the novel casts a spell — one that lingers all the way into the present‑day chapters with Liv and Theo.
The historical storyline is rich and atmospheric, capturing both the glamour and the grit of Manhattan as two families are torn apart by tragedy and a courtroom decision that echoes for generations. The modern timeline is just as compelling: Liv and Theo’s connection is magnetic from the start, and the emotional weight of their shared history adds a poignant tension to every scene they share.
What really stands out is how seamlessly the mysteries of the past and present intertwine. Each clue Liv and Theo uncover feels meaningful, and the ghostly nudges guiding them forward add a lovely, haunting layer without overwhelming the human story. The themes of identity, injustice, and the long shadow of family trauma are handled with sensitivity, giving the novel real emotional resonance.
The settings — from glittering 1920s Manhattan to the windswept Carolina coast — are vivid and immersive, and the pacing keeps you turning pages as the truth slowly, beautifully comes into focus.
A captivating, atmospheric read perfect for anyone who loves generational mysteries, star‑crossed romance, and stories where the past refuses to stay silent.
With thanks to Emily Colin, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
The historical storyline is rich and atmospheric, capturing both the glamour and the grit of Manhattan as two families are torn apart by tragedy and a courtroom decision that echoes for generations. The modern timeline is just as compelling: Liv and Theo’s connection is magnetic from the start, and the emotional weight of their shared history adds a poignant tension to every scene they share.
What really stands out is how seamlessly the mysteries of the past and present intertwine. Each clue Liv and Theo uncover feels meaningful, and the ghostly nudges guiding them forward add a lovely, haunting layer without overwhelming the human story. The themes of identity, injustice, and the long shadow of family trauma are handled with sensitivity, giving the novel real emotional resonance.
The settings — from glittering 1920s Manhattan to the windswept Carolina coast — are vivid and immersive, and the pacing keeps you turning pages as the truth slowly, beautifully comes into focus.
A captivating, atmospheric read perfect for anyone who loves generational mysteries, star‑crossed romance, and stories where the past refuses to stay silent.
With thanks to Emily Colin, the publisher and netgalley for the ARC
Review of advance copy received from Author
I met Emily not as an author but as a teacher when I attended one of her online courses, which I found very useful. This is my first experience reading an author's ARC and having the chance to review in advance of its release and I'm happy to say I fully enjoyed it and I'd do it again in a heartbeat.
I am a huge fan of dual POVs and timelines in general, I find that as a literary tool they can add dimension to a tale, especially a mystery. The possibilities of intertwining the two are endless and the author certainly takes advantage of this to drop hints, open hypotheses and keep you guessing from start to finish. More seasoned reviewers have shared their synopsis of the plot so I'll keep this review brief and full of my own personal opinions.
I enjoyed the family-feud drama, the wide cast of characters and the well-painted scenery overall and now I'm curious to go back and read more of Colin's books (which I had not done before.) I thought the historical elements were accurate and descriptive and it was suspenseful enough that I blazed through it in three readings, so it's definitely an "oops I might have burned dinner" page-turner.
Does anyone have another Emily Colin favorite (besides this, which is getting rave reviews from her longterm fans) that I should check out?
I am a huge fan of dual POVs and timelines in general, I find that as a literary tool they can add dimension to a tale, especially a mystery. The possibilities of intertwining the two are endless and the author certainly takes advantage of this to drop hints, open hypotheses and keep you guessing from start to finish. More seasoned reviewers have shared their synopsis of the plot so I'll keep this review brief and full of my own personal opinions.
I enjoyed the family-feud drama, the wide cast of characters and the well-painted scenery overall and now I'm curious to go back and read more of Colin's books (which I had not done before.) I thought the historical elements were accurate and descriptive and it was suspenseful enough that I blazed through it in three readings, so it's definitely an "oops I might have burned dinner" page-turner.
Does anyone have another Emily Colin favorite (besides this, which is getting rave reviews from her longterm fans) that I should check out?
July 9, 2026
I first met Emily when I took a writing workshop she was offering many years ago. I found her feedback very kind and encouraging, and I was excited to read City of Liars and offer my heartfelt review.
I received an ARC copy through Bookfunnel, and my words are my own.
First off, the opening chapters had me hooked from the beginning. Right away, I was drawn into the story, and found the characters well-developed and engaging. The writing itself is a bit spare for my tastes, but others will find Emily's prose straight forward and tight. Personally, I enjoy a more denser narrative, like Donna Tartt's, The Goldfinch, but I believe most readers will appreciate the way Emily keeps the story ticking along, and her writing style will appeal to those looking to read a fast-paced mystery, all tangled up in generational trauma.
I found the ending satisfying, though a bit convenient. And the spice seemed a little out of place for a 'literary' themed novel. It's for those reasons that I took one star off. Of course, this is just my own personal opinion. Others might thoroughly enjoy the heat between the two protagonists.
All in all, I would happily recommend City of Liars. I applaud Emily's success and achievements, and I wish her well on her publishing journey.
I received an ARC copy through Bookfunnel, and my words are my own.
First off, the opening chapters had me hooked from the beginning. Right away, I was drawn into the story, and found the characters well-developed and engaging. The writing itself is a bit spare for my tastes, but others will find Emily's prose straight forward and tight. Personally, I enjoy a more denser narrative, like Donna Tartt's, The Goldfinch, but I believe most readers will appreciate the way Emily keeps the story ticking along, and her writing style will appeal to those looking to read a fast-paced mystery, all tangled up in generational trauma.
I found the ending satisfying, though a bit convenient. And the spice seemed a little out of place for a 'literary' themed novel. It's for those reasons that I took one star off. Of course, this is just my own personal opinion. Others might thoroughly enjoy the heat between the two protagonists.
All in all, I would happily recommend City of Liars. I applaud Emily's success and achievements, and I wish her well on her publishing journey.
July 10, 2026
Review of advanced copy received from author
It is refreshing to read a romantic book which doesn't revolve entirely around the actual romance.
The mystery kept my attention, and the way it was drip fed through historical chapters was very engaging. In fact I think those chapters were probably my favourite. I was invested in finding out what happened and resolving this 100 year old family mystery.
The characters were nuanced and fleshed out, and the romance made sense. Two broken people being brought together by circumstances, working through their difficulties together. Some scenes were quite difficult to read (the toxic parents and ex husband for example), but I felt it accurately reflects the way narcissistic people manipulate conversations. I enjoyed the growth of the MCs and how they dealt with this conflict as the book went on.
There were some things I struggled with, for example keeping track of what clues had been revealed, and having some unanswered questions. Dead mystery girl? I also was a bit confused about why there was a supernatural element, I didn't think it needed it. But that's just my preference!
Overall, this is definitely one to pick up if you're tired of the samey romance novel.
It is refreshing to read a romantic book which doesn't revolve entirely around the actual romance.
The mystery kept my attention, and the way it was drip fed through historical chapters was very engaging. In fact I think those chapters were probably my favourite. I was invested in finding out what happened and resolving this 100 year old family mystery.
The characters were nuanced and fleshed out, and the romance made sense. Two broken people being brought together by circumstances, working through their difficulties together. Some scenes were quite difficult to read (the toxic parents and ex husband for example), but I felt it accurately reflects the way narcissistic people manipulate conversations. I enjoyed the growth of the MCs and how they dealt with this conflict as the book went on.
There were some things I struggled with, for example keeping track of what clues had been revealed, and having some unanswered questions. Dead mystery girl? I also was a bit confused about why there was a supernatural element, I didn't think it needed it. But that's just my preference!
Overall, this is definitely one to pick up if you're tired of the samey romance novel.
Review of advance copy
There’s much to like about Emily Colin's City of Liars. Fans of steamy romance scenes won't be disappointed. However, there is a depth to the story that forbids categorizing it solely as a romance. City of Liars’ appeal extends well beyond its magnetic love scenes. The heart of the book lies in its mystery surrounding the disappearance of two toddler girls at almost the same time in 1927 New York City, one girl from upper-class Gramercy Park, the other from the poverty-ridden Lower East Side. An agonizing year passes before one child is found and returned to the wealthy Carter family. But the Dressler family, especially Mother May, believes the found girl is theirs. An epic feud that will span decades and ultimately affect and threaten Liv and Theo, our modern lovers, is born, grows and festers. Colin weaves separate timelines and multiple points of view together to tell a gripping story of family, individual, and generational trauma. City of Liars swept me along from start to finish like the sentient wind that moves through the characters’ lives in this deftly-told tale. An engaging, satisfying read and a haunting story.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I planned to read City of Liars on vacation; instead, I had to put on the brakes so I wouldn’t finish the whole book on my flight! Emily Colin’s page-turner immersed me in mystery, romance, historical fiction, and supernatural, and I could not get enough of any of it.
The book’s multiple timelines and the voice of the wind drew me in initially, but Colin’s beautifully developed characters and emotional mystery kept me reading. The romance was spicy but not distracting – and this book might make me finally admit that I do like romance novels. I appreciated how well-researched the historical components were and how easily Colin transported me between New York City and North Carolina and between the 1920s and Liv and Theo’s 21st-century lives. Her depictions of each time and place were vivid, and the transitions were smooth. The plot twists guaranteed that there were no simple solutions; the complexity of the ending was deeply satisfying: It was layer after layer of "wait! there's more...." -- so artfully done!
This is the first book of Colin’s that I’ve read, so my only question now is: which Emily Colin book do I read next?
The book’s multiple timelines and the voice of the wind drew me in initially, but Colin’s beautifully developed characters and emotional mystery kept me reading. The romance was spicy but not distracting – and this book might make me finally admit that I do like romance novels. I appreciated how well-researched the historical components were and how easily Colin transported me between New York City and North Carolina and between the 1920s and Liv and Theo’s 21st-century lives. Her depictions of each time and place were vivid, and the transitions were smooth. The plot twists guaranteed that there were no simple solutions; the complexity of the ending was deeply satisfying: It was layer after layer of "wait! there's more...." -- so artfully done!
This is the first book of Colin’s that I’ve read, so my only question now is: which Emily Colin book do I read next?
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
City of Liars is an amazing blend of mystery and romance, with a touch of the supernatural and a dual timeline story that unravels across 1920s New York and present day North Carolina. I've loved everything I've read from Emily Colin so far and I love a blend of genres so I was really excited to read City of Liars, and it didn't disappoint!
I was sucked into the story straight away because the main characters felt so real. Main characters Liv and Theo had amazing chemistry when they meet at the start of the book, and then we get to discover more about them and their families as the plot develops. It delves into the impacts of intergenerational trauma in a really sensitive but emotional way. The central mystery had me guessing throughout, and I was so invested in both Liv and Theo's romance and in how the mystery's reveal would affect their families. I just enjoyed everything about it!
Disclaimer: I received an Advance Reader Copy from NetGalley, but this is my voluntary and honest review.
I was sucked into the story straight away because the main characters felt so real. Main characters Liv and Theo had amazing chemistry when they meet at the start of the book, and then we get to discover more about them and their families as the plot develops. It delves into the impacts of intergenerational trauma in a really sensitive but emotional way. The central mystery had me guessing throughout, and I was so invested in both Liv and Theo's romance and in how the mystery's reveal would affect their families. I just enjoyed everything about it!
Disclaimer: I received an Advance Reader Copy from NetGalley, but this is my voluntary and honest review.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I was fortunate to read an advance copy of this book.
New York Times bestselling author, Emily Colin, has created a genre-defying tale that intertwines romance, generational trauma, and mystery with a dash of the supernatural in this haunting modern-day saga with distinct Romeo and Juliet vibes.
When the two star-crossed lovers meet, they soon learn that they are the descendants of two feuding families—one privileged beyond measure, the other—broken and ruined due to the actions of the former. What follows is their quest to unlock a decades-old mystery to bring closure to their respective families, so their own love can finally take root.
Delving into New York City's past, much of it inspired by the author's own family history, Colin builds a suspensefully layered romantic journey with enough twists and turns to have your head spinning. She is a master storyteller and you will relish every beautifully crafted sentence!
This book has something for everyone, whether you are a romance reader, history buff, or a lover of book club fiction.
New York Times bestselling author, Emily Colin, has created a genre-defying tale that intertwines romance, generational trauma, and mystery with a dash of the supernatural in this haunting modern-day saga with distinct Romeo and Juliet vibes.
When the two star-crossed lovers meet, they soon learn that they are the descendants of two feuding families—one privileged beyond measure, the other—broken and ruined due to the actions of the former. What follows is their quest to unlock a decades-old mystery to bring closure to their respective families, so their own love can finally take root.
Delving into New York City's past, much of it inspired by the author's own family history, Colin builds a suspensefully layered romantic journey with enough twists and turns to have your head spinning. She is a master storyteller and you will relish every beautifully crafted sentence!
This book has something for everyone, whether you are a romance reader, history buff, or a lover of book club fiction.
Review of advance copy received from Author
OMG I think this is my FAVORITE book by Emily. Five stars is no where near enough! This book had soo many things, dual POV, historical throwbacks, romance, spice, mystery, plot twists, and so much more. I literally could not ask for anything to be added.
This book covers Olivia and Theo and their mission to solve a family secret/mystery that has plagued both families for generations. The plot twists this book had, I was guessing the entire time trying to solve the mystery too.
The spice and romance is done so well and doesn't take away from the story like those scenes sometimes do in other books.
The settings are described so beautifully that I could fully imagine I was in the places that the story was happening. The characters are so detailed that they felt real, even down to the wind which is its own character. For an author to make me feel the emotion of the wind takes true talent and skill.
When the plot twist hits and the mystery is solved I verbally shouted and was so excited. This book is everything and is a definite must read by anybody and everybody!!
This book covers Olivia and Theo and their mission to solve a family secret/mystery that has plagued both families for generations. The plot twists this book had, I was guessing the entire time trying to solve the mystery too.
The spice and romance is done so well and doesn't take away from the story like those scenes sometimes do in other books.
The settings are described so beautifully that I could fully imagine I was in the places that the story was happening. The characters are so detailed that they felt real, even down to the wind which is its own character. For an author to make me feel the emotion of the wind takes true talent and skill.
When the plot twist hits and the mystery is solved I verbally shouted and was so excited. This book is everything and is a definite must read by anybody and everybody!!
July 7, 2026
*Review of advanced copy received from author*
City of Liars completely pulled me in from the very first chapter.
I’m always a little nervous when a story jumps between timelines because it can be hard to keep everything straight, but this one did it beautifully. Every chapter revealed just enough to keep me guessing, and watching the different storylines slowly weave together was so satisfying.
The mystery kept me hooked, but what really made this book stand out were the characters. They felt like real people with real motivations, and each of their stories mattered. By the end, every thread came together in a way that felt earned, and I closed the book feeling completely satisfied.
You can also tell how much research went into this novel. The historical details added so much depth without ever slowing the story down, making it easy to get lost in the world.
If you love historical fiction with a touch of mystery, a little romance, and characters you’ll genuinely care about, I’d definitely recommend picking this one up.
This was an easy ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ from me.
City of Liars completely pulled me in from the very first chapter.
I’m always a little nervous when a story jumps between timelines because it can be hard to keep everything straight, but this one did it beautifully. Every chapter revealed just enough to keep me guessing, and watching the different storylines slowly weave together was so satisfying.
The mystery kept me hooked, but what really made this book stand out were the characters. They felt like real people with real motivations, and each of their stories mattered. By the end, every thread came together in a way that felt earned, and I closed the book feeling completely satisfied.
You can also tell how much research went into this novel. The historical details added so much depth without ever slowing the story down, making it easy to get lost in the world.
If you love historical fiction with a touch of mystery, a little romance, and characters you’ll genuinely care about, I’d definitely recommend picking this one up.
This was an easy ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ from me.
July 9, 2026
City of Liars is one of the most emotionally beautiful pieces of fiction I have read in a long time.
The novel is centered around a devastating trauma that haunted two families for generations. I
found the pieces about identity, family, and the way pain is inherited incredibly powerful.
I also loved the feel of the setting and the dual timeline structure. Colin nailed the historical
chapters by bringing you straight into the scenes and the emotions while delicately balancing out
the narrative with the present-day relationship of Theo and Liv.
By the end, it felt like the story wasn't just about uncovering the truth...it was about healing what had been broken for generations. That's the kind of emotional impact that readers will remember long after they finish this book. I know I will.
The novel is centered around a devastating trauma that haunted two families for generations. I
found the pieces about identity, family, and the way pain is inherited incredibly powerful.
I also loved the feel of the setting and the dual timeline structure. Colin nailed the historical
chapters by bringing you straight into the scenes and the emotions while delicately balancing out
the narrative with the present-day relationship of Theo and Liv.
By the end, it felt like the story wasn't just about uncovering the truth...it was about healing what had been broken for generations. That's the kind of emotional impact that readers will remember long after they finish this book. I know I will.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
A good mix of mystery and romance. The characters are well-developed and I liked both the main characters. The story had a good pace and was easy to read; the mystery made me want to continue on so I could find out what happened. My only critiques are that I felt like the opening scenes with Liv were slightly out of character for her as I got to know her better (she seemed judgy and impulsive on her date, which I didn't see later in the book) and I found some of the character's names to be similar enough that I had some trouble keeping them separate in my mind as the mystery unfolded. I was glad I kept reading, because I liked how the story progressed and concluded, and felt that the characters were multi-dimensional and realistic, which is always preferred.
Review of advance copy received from Author
What a wonderful ride! 🥹
Thank you Emily Colin, for putting this beautiful story out there, for the opportunity of reading before release.
It sure is a roller coaster of emotions, always keeping you wondering, I wanted, needed to keep reading!
I loved the different POVs, the timelines, how deep the story went and specially how it ended. The glimpses of magic, the wind, the struggles, the emotions, I loved every single thing!
There’s so much in this book, the mystery, the romance, the tragedies, the morals, the strength of these characters, I can keep going because I truly enjoyed every second, but from a bookish friend to another, just ✨ PLEASE READ IT! ✨ 🫶🏻
Thank you Emily Colin, for putting this beautiful story out there, for the opportunity of reading before release.
It sure is a roller coaster of emotions, always keeping you wondering, I wanted, needed to keep reading!
I loved the different POVs, the timelines, how deep the story went and specially how it ended. The glimpses of magic, the wind, the struggles, the emotions, I loved every single thing!
There’s so much in this book, the mystery, the romance, the tragedies, the morals, the strength of these characters, I can keep going because I truly enjoyed every second, but from a bookish friend to another, just ✨ PLEASE READ IT! ✨ 🫶🏻
Review of advance copy received from Author
I received an ARC of City of Liars; this was my first go around with this author, and I can honestly say it won’t be my last! I’m sure to find another book of hers soon to peruse.
If you like steamy books, this one is for you, the romance scenes will have you running for a cold shower. But the story’s depth doesn’t rely solely on the romance. At its core is the disappearance of two children at almost the same time in 1927 from upper-class Gramercy Park, and the poverty ridden Lower East Side. The author uses different timelines and points of view together to tell the story of this traumatic event. This book kept me entertained and engaged throughout; highly recommend it
If you like steamy books, this one is for you, the romance scenes will have you running for a cold shower. But the story’s depth doesn’t rely solely on the romance. At its core is the disappearance of two children at almost the same time in 1927 from upper-class Gramercy Park, and the poverty ridden Lower East Side. The author uses different timelines and points of view together to tell the story of this traumatic event. This book kept me entertained and engaged throughout; highly recommend it
Review of advance copy received from Author
Thank you to the author Emily, for an ARC of this book. I have been fortunate to receive a lot of ARC’s of her books and every single time, they are great!! I thoroughly enjoy them, and once again another book by her that I have enjoyed. I loved the romance, mystery, family drama and it was just such an engaging story. The mystery was so intriguing and it just kept you guessing as to what was the truth. Then mixing it in with a little bit of romance was perfect. Liv and Theo were great and I loved how it was the whole family feud thing and how they shouldn’t be together because of their families, but there was still that pull, that attraction between the two of them.
Review of advance copy received from Author
💫ARC REVIEW💫
It's very rare for me to finish a book in under 24 hours but Emily's writing will completely suck you in! Starting in 1927 & bouncing around between times made this story even more intriguing. The mystery was so complex & ran so deep, I felt like I was walking alongside Liv & Theo as they investigated. Trying to piece my OWN theories together is something I do often in books but these stakes felt so much higher.
As always, thank you FOREVER to Emily Colin for sending me an ARC copy. This will go down as one of my favorite reads!
It's very rare for me to finish a book in under 24 hours but Emily's writing will completely suck you in! Starting in 1927 & bouncing around between times made this story even more intriguing. The mystery was so complex & ran so deep, I felt like I was walking alongside Liv & Theo as they investigated. Trying to piece my OWN theories together is something I do often in books but these stakes felt so much higher.
As always, thank you FOREVER to Emily Colin for sending me an ARC copy. This will go down as one of my favorite reads!
Review of advance copy received from Author
Haunting, atmospheric, and ultimately hopeful, City of Liars is a story about what we inherit through blood, family, and secrets. Emily Colin masterfully blends mystery, romance, and the supernatural into a novel where corruption and greed collide with justice, longing, and the enduring possibility of love. As the truth bubbles to the surface, so does the reminder that some voices will not rest until they are heard. Filled with richly human characters, aching tenderness, and the strange beauty that defines Colin’s work, City of Liars will have you believing in romance…and ghosts.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Review of Advanced Reader Copy
City of Liars was such a refreshing read. A romance with a mystery woven throughout. The dual timeline had my interest from the first page and kept me guessing and questioning. I loved Emily’s writing style and will say that it felt very immersive. The romance in this one was lighter than what I usually read but still felt so real. The concept of multiple pov as well as the separate timelines helped to create a quite nicely executed story. The nod towards generational trauma and carrying choices of the past down to the present.
City of Liars was such a refreshing read. A romance with a mystery woven throughout. The dual timeline had my interest from the first page and kept me guessing and questioning. I loved Emily’s writing style and will say that it felt very immersive. The romance in this one was lighter than what I usually read but still felt so real. The concept of multiple pov as well as the separate timelines helped to create a quite nicely executed story. The nod towards generational trauma and carrying choices of the past down to the present.
July 9, 2026
The dual timelines are woven together seamlessly, gradually revealing a decades old family secret with satisfying twists and emotional depth. I loved how the romance complemented the mystery rather than overshadowing it, while themes of identity, generational trauma, and classed added real and relatable weight to the story. Suspenseful and heartfelt, this is a great pick for readers who enjoy family secrets, richly layered mysteries and characters whose lives are shaped and influenced by their past.
July 9, 2026
5/5 RIVETING STARS!
This dual timeline read had me completely captivated! I was absolutely hooked and couldn’t turn these pages fast enough.
Emily Colin blew me away with this fascinating read. This book literally has a little bit of everything; mystery, romance, paranormal aspects, and so much suspense!
I honestly feel like this book had a heartbeat, it felt so real. I was mesmerized by these characters and I couldn’t get enough. This is a MUST read.
My favorite read this year!
This dual timeline read had me completely captivated! I was absolutely hooked and couldn’t turn these pages fast enough.
Emily Colin blew me away with this fascinating read. This book literally has a little bit of everything; mystery, romance, paranormal aspects, and so much suspense!
I honestly feel like this book had a heartbeat, it felt so real. I was mesmerized by these characters and I couldn’t get enough. This is a MUST read.
My favorite read this year!
July 13, 2026
Oh wow - this was quite a story! I haven’t read a book like this in awhile but I loved all of the mystery and is Liv’s grandma really her grandma or is she Lily Dressler? I loved Liv and Theo’s chance meeting and I really liked their connection as it grew. This was a fantastic book - I also really loved the pieces of Jewish heritage and stories woven in to the story. I now need to read more Emily Colin books! Thank you to the author for the copy of this book - and Katie rock literary services. I wouldn’t have found this book without them!
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
How does a steamy fling with a gorgeous piano bar owner end up turning Liv’s life upside down? When she learns he comes from the family hers has feuded with for a century.
A City of Liars by Emily Colin completely blindsided me as I tried to untangle the truth from the lies alongside Liv Carter-Brentwood and her family sworn enemy, Theo Dressler.
What I loved about this book:
Multiple POV and timelines
Mysterious circumstances
A hint of the paranormal
Lost and Found family
Enemies to lovers
Thank you Emily Colin and NetGalley for sharing an advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
A City of Liars by Emily Colin completely blindsided me as I tried to untangle the truth from the lies alongside Liv Carter-Brentwood and her family sworn enemy, Theo Dressler.
What I loved about this book:
Multiple POV and timelines
Mysterious circumstances
A hint of the paranormal
Lost and Found family
Enemies to lovers
Thank you Emily Colin and NetGalley for sharing an advanced copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
Review of advance copy received from Author
Reminiscent of the stories of Anastasia…”Is she” or “isn’t she” and it continues throughout the book. So magnificently written. Who but Emily would write the wind as one of the key characters. All the characters are so deliciously developed. I found myself stopping quite often to say, “Emily, this is brilliant! You are brilliant!” The only thing to add to this review is, if I didn’t already have the love of my life, I would pay Emily good money for her to create one for me.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews