The town of Luna Vista is hoping for a peaceful return to normalcy after two twelve-year-old detectives, Grace Yang and Sophie Young, discovered a fugitive working at the local middle school. Unfortunately, as preparations get underway for the annual Winter Sun Festival, another crime is uncovered - this time, it’s the murder of festival president Jim Steptoe, whose body is found on a partially finished parade float. Though Grace has expressed her desire to stop solving crime, Sophie, along with the girls’ friend, Trista Bottoms, convinces her to take on just one more case. As they follow clues and identify suspects, the girls find themselves signing up to serve as festival pages alongside some of the mean girls who have tormented them in the past. While they do their best to keep up their official page duties, and investigate evidence at every available moment, the girls must also take care not to fall into any of the traps laid out for them by the murderer.
A worthy sequel to a great story, The Tiara on the Terrace is sure to satisfy those readers who wish for more middle grade murder mysteries. Just like the first book, The Wig in the Window, Young and Yang’s second adventure is marked by a memorable setting populated by interesting and quirky people. The Winter Sun Festival, with its ceremonies, parties, parade floats, and traditions is the perfect backdrop for a mystery, as well as just an interesting, uncommon setting for a middle grade novel. The suspects are well-developed, with lots of great annoying habits and qualities that make the reader extra suspicious of their motives. The best one is Barb Lund, whose use of outdated slang and obsession with Winnie-the-Pooh make her seem so obnoxiously real. Not since Dolores Umbridge has it been so much fun to hate a character. Also wonderful is Trista Bottoms, who is the most engaging supporting character of the entire story. Her cargo vest, loud, booming voice, and deep knowledge of science and engineering give her a unique personality that is almost deserving of its own book.
The only drawback to this story is the lack of resolution to the tension in Grace and Sophie’s friendship. The foundation is laid for a major disagreement: Grace no longer wants to spy, and Sophie accidentally reveals one of Grace’s innermost secrets to a room full of catty girls. Grace forgives Sophie way too easily for her transgression, while the issue of Grace feeling like she is beyond crime solving is abandoned once the mystery takes off. It would have been more satisfying if the friendship storyline had received the same careful treatment as the mystery itself.
Make sure to read The Wig in the Window before The Tiara on the Terrace, as the second book includes spoilers for the first. Readers who enjoy Young and Yang might also want to read Murder is Bad Manners, the first title in a series about another team of girl detectives, Wells and Wong.