After losing her job, Lucie Brown returns to her home village of Winterbourne, only to discover that everything she ran away from a decade ago is still waiting there for her. Hoping for a distraction while she figures out where she is heading next, she takes a Christmas job as an elf at nearby Winterbourne Hall.
Frances Delaney, the CEO of The Winterbourne Hall Trust and granddaughter of the late owner, the Marquess of Brackley, is under pressure to deliver a flawless festive season while trying to care for her mother. An interfering Christmas elf is the last complication she needs, and yet she may be the only person who can help.
As Lucie is drawn into Frances's world, what begins as a temporary escape sparks a connection they both struggle to ignore. But with responsibilities and ambitions pulling them in different directions, will their moment fade away with the snow, or will they discover that some endings are really just beginnings?
The bestselling and award-winning author of the South Downs Romance series and the Nunswick Abbey series returns with an enchanting festive sapphic romance set on a picturesque Elizabethan estate, where losing your footing could mean losing your heart.
Emily Banting is an award-winning and bestselling author of contemporary sapphic romance featuring LGBTQ+ characters and plenty of British humour. History obsessed, she throws her sapphic leading ladies into historic buildings and environments at every opportunity, and believes strongly in representing women over forty in literature.
Broken Beyond Repair received the following awards:
GOLDIE WINNER 2024: AUDIOBOOK NARRATOR (ANGELA DAWE) GOLDIE WINNER 2023: THE ANN BANNON POPULAR CHOICE BRONZE AWARD WINNER OF THE LESFIC BARD AWARD 2022: ROMANCE WINNER OF THE LESFIC BARD AWARD 2022: COVER DESIGN WINNER OF THE QUEER INDIE AWARDS 2022: CONTEMPORARY ROMANCE
And a 2023 GCLS Goldie finalist in CONTEMPORARY ROMANCE LONG NOVEL
The second book in the South Downs Romance Series was a 2024 GCLS Goldie finalist in CONTEMPORARY ROMANCE LONG NOVEL 2024
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️1/2 (4.5 stars, this one was SOO close to the 5 stars)
I’ve enjoyed Emily Banting’s books for quite a while now, and I know I’m guaranteed a quaint British setting, a slow-burn romance with a touch of spice. This one gave me all that, plus a depth I wasn’t expecting from a Christmas book. Lucie is back in the UK after ten years in Botswana, which wasn’t part of her life plan, and she needs work to settle back into village life. She takes a seasonal job as a Christmas elf at Winterbourne Hall, where her new boss, Frances, happens to be the CEO and a member of the family who built the place. Frances, meanwhile, is running herself into the ground and keeping a secret from her loyal staff. When Lucie, however, offers her a lifeline (one she turns down at first, might I add) the two slowly give in to a growing attraction. There’s a countdown too since Lucie is due to leave when the season ends. Can Frances finally do something for herself rather than what’s expected of her? First of all, the romance is SUCH delight. Like just imagine, stolen looks, literally falling into the arms of your future lover and sparking an instant attraction, and flirting over hot chocolate and cream...this one was really built into real chemistry. It is also told through both women’s perspectives. I think Frances’s commanding energy was a big part of the appeal, plsu there’s an age gap and a heroine who spends part of the book dressed as an elf (who doesn’t love that? especially now when winter and christmas season is right around the corner). What lifted this beyond a cozy read for me was how it handles real-life challenges specifically Alzheimer’s. Frances is caring for her mother, who has Alzheimer’s, and the author’s note at the start is a thoughtful reminder that this reflects one person’s journey. I became as invested in that storyline as in the romance. It’s woven in with care and realism, and the ramifications of that caregiving take up so much of the characters’ time and energy. Yet the romance still finds room to slip in. There’s also a conversation around the 40% mark, where the two see the parallels in what brought each of them to that moment..this scene in particular was SOO beautifully written. Generally the book is written amazingly but this scene really stood out to me, as did another between Lucie and her dad which was also full of warmth and humanity. Moreover, the book also kept me guessing (or should I say hoping?) specifically WHEN the two finally acknowledge what’s between them!! I couldn’t see how they would get their happy ending with so little book left. The solution isn’t out of left field, but it never occurred to me which, in turn, made me admire Emily Banting even more. Gosh, I think I could go on and on about this book and especially the characters. I loved all of them, not only the leads. And I truly think that Rose for instance has a special place in my heart from now on, and so does Frances, Lucie, Lucie’s dad and Mandy. This story literally absorbed me so completely that I kept thinking about the characters when I had to put it down. If you want a cozy, festive story about family, the sacrifices we make for the people we love as well as the idea that we can’t do it all alone, grab a hot chocolate and read this one! I highly recommend!!
The Christmas Elf sees Lucie Brown return to her hometown after a decade abroad and lands a job as an elf at Winterborne Hall. The Hall's Christmas event is hoping to draw in visitors to help fund essential repairs, putting the CEO, Frances Delaney, under plenty of pressure.
I really enjoyed the quintessentially English setting and a peek behind the scenes of a historic hall at Christmas. Lucie and Frances were both likeable characters, although I felt their romance lacked a little of the chemistry I was hoping for. The real standout for me was Frances' mother. Her story was touching and stayed with me after I finished the book. Hats off to Emily Banting for keeping it real when talking about Rose’s illness.
I received an arc in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
ALC! If you want an easy, spice-free sapphic elf romance, then this is exactly what you need. It’s a nice story nothing mind blowing but cute. One FMC helps the other FMC with a parent struggling with an illness who she cared for her grandparent for. It was cute. But the audio wasn’t great for me, the narrator was very gently spoken and she felt like she was whispering all the way through. It was off putting but that’s a personal preference!
I loved seeing Frances and Lucie getting close; it was slow and careful. Lucie is like a sweet balm on Frances's wounds. Despite the fact that I didn’t feel the chemistry between them on a visceral level, I found them sweet. Lucie and Rose's relationship was also sweet to read, despite the heartbreak that accompanies every one of Rose's scenes. If Alzheimer's is a soft spot for you, be aware that it is a big part of the book. Seeing Lucie being able to help Frances was really heartwarming, and I couldn't help but put myself in their shoes and ache for them. The book was easy to read, but the pacing was a bit uneven. The slow burn was really good, but the ending felt rushed; they went from "we have no future" to moving in together in two minutes. With Frances and Rose being a package deal, I wished the impact on Lucie was more developed in the end. And I admit I didn't realize Frances was so rich that she could drop her job without a thought. Overall, a very sweet but not light read for the holiday season.
Lucie Brown returns home after spending ten years in Africa working for a non-profit. Deciding to take time to figure out what she wants to do next she takes a seasonal job as an Elf at the nearby Winterbourne Hall. Frances Deleaney, is the CEO of the great manor house. It once belonged to her family but is now owned by a historical trust. The holiday season will give them the tourism boost that will help pay for improvements like a new roof. There is an age gap of 12 or 13 years with Lucia in her 30s to Frances 40s. Lucie makes friends with an older woman and recognizes that she has memory issues similar to her own grandmother. The woman turns out to be the mother of Frances. While nothing can happen between Lucie and Frances while she is an employee a friendship begins between the two. Especially when Lucie volunteers to keep the mother company at times while Frances is working.
This is a lovely, slow burn, age gap, romance. There are a lot of emotional extras in caring for a person with memory issues and it is handled with care and dignity. And anyone who has been a caregiver can relate to the added stress it brings into your life. Lucie also helps her dad move forward after being widowed for many years. I love how British Banting writes. There is lots of tea and picking up rucksacks or mentioning knickers. I thought the romance was lovely and perfectly themed for the holiday season. (It does cover more time than Christmas.) I could envision the hall, village and pub having traveled a lot through England.
Reading this reminded me that I have a few Banting novels I have purchased and not yet read. I listened to the audio book and enjoyed the narration by Lulu Russell. Thank you to NetGalley and Tantor Media for the audio book and I am leaving an honest review.
Lucie has been working in Southern Africa for about ten years, when the non-profit she works for suddenly loses its funding and folds, and her work visa is revoked overnight. This means a very short notice flight back to the UK, and a return to her childhood home, the village pub in Winterbourne, in rural England. Her father is surprised to see her back; she left ten years before after the death of her grandmother and then university, and hasn’t been back since. Frances is CEO of the Winterbourne Hall trust, managing the massive eighteenth century hall and grounds in the village, now a tourist attraction. Her elderly uncle is the Marquess, the title that goes with the hall, but he escaped to Canada fifty years before, leaving Frances’ parents to look after the family pile. Now, her father is gone, and her mother Rose has Alzheimer’s, leaving her to manage the hall with its 450 staff and also look after her mother, a total task she can’t quite manage. Lucie gets a temporary job at the hall as a Christmas Elf, but ends up also helping Frances with her mother Rose, a task that brings back memories of caring for her grandmother a decade before. This is a gentle romance, slow burn, but hot when it happens! I really like the descriptions of village life in England, and also the really thoughtful depiction of dealing with dementia. A well written, warm and insightful story.
Emily and her magical touch for writing slow burn stories with insane chemistry and the unmissable age gap make you fall in love and captivate you from the very first chapter. But that's not all, the story keep you on edge, in fact despite the attraction at first sight and the meet cute, the two MCs come to be almost enemies only to reconcile ad making delicius sparks 🔥.
Happiness, joy, sadness and grief combine beautifully with each other, bringing a smile to your face in one chapter and some tear the next (please read the cw).
It's a wonderful story that captures the blossoming of love amidst life's difficulties, present and past. In case you were wondering, Yes I cried - It landed a bit too close to home.
Overall it's a 4 ⭐ and 3🔥.
In the book you'll find: -Attraction at first sight -Slow Burn -Age gap -Staring over -Forced Proximity -Workplace Romance -Wealth Gap -Contemporary Christmas Romance -U-Haul -CEO × Christmas elf -Femme × femme -Almost kiss -Lesbian × lesbian -Cin lifts -Comforting after a bad dream
CW: character living with Alzheimer’s - dead relatives - suicide - post partum depression - generalized homophobia
I usually find Banting's novels romantic and interesting. Went into this book thinking it was a romantic, holiday story, when in fact it was a story about caring for a loved one with Dementia/Alzhemiers. Not my favorite
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I love Emily Banting’s books! They often include these gorgeous English countryside estates and reading them makes me feel like I’m in a modern era Downton Abbey setting, imagining the grandeur and beauty of the surrounding grounds. They also include really interesting characters where the age gap is present but never an issue.
While a book titled “The Christmas Elf” might seem like a light and fluffy read, it’s much deeper than that.
Both main characters are in a time of transition. Frances Delaney is the CEO of the Winterbourne Hall Trust and it’s incumbent on her to deliver on the estate’s annual grand Christmas Festival, but she is struggling with something behind the scenes she’s kept only to herself. Hired to be a Christmas Elf for the annual holiday event, Lucie Brown unwittingly stumbled upon the reason why and genuinely wants to help. Frances is her boss for the holiday season, yet both women felt a spark the moment they met. But Lucie doesn’t plan to stay in her hometown long term. What could possibly come of their growing attraction and care for one another when Lucie has dreams that will take her away in a matter of months?
This is a lovely, thoughtful holiday romance with beautiful family dynamics at the center. More than a beach read, it’s one to add to your list. I look forward to experiencing this on audio as well!
I've really enjoyed relaxing with Emily Banting's books over the years. I know I'm guaranteed a quaint British setting, slow burn romances and a touch of spice.
So, two women falling in love while working at a Christmas Wonderland? I needed a bit of festive whimsy! 🎄
Back in the UK after years abroad, Lucie needs a job to help her settle back into village life. She finds seasonal work as a Christmas Elf at the local Winterbourne Hall. From there, the story unfolds through the dual perspectives of Lucie and Frances, the CEO and her new boss 👀
Stolen looks, instant attraction and a growing chemistry... the flirting over hot chocolate and cream even had me 🫠 I loved watching their bond develop, along with the sexual tension. And the 🌶️ in Chapter 19! Lines like "come here", "take them off" and "on the bed" are 🔥! And so is Frances' commanding energy!
There's also a countdown of sorts, with Lucie due to leave at the end of the season. And there's emotional depth too, with the story touching on loss, mental health and Alzheimer's, as Lucie supports Frances while she cares for her mum ❤️
Overall, it's a lovely festive story about two women connecting with family and finding their Christmas joy! There's even a Castle Winter Wonderland near me in Ireland, and this book has me well in the mood for dark evenings, hot drinks and light shows!
Emily writes such beautiful stories and this was no different! She’s a fantastic storyteller. I tandem read with the audiobook, Lulu always does a great job with Emily’s books! Bringing the character to life 😍
This was so cute and I loved every second! France’s was caring for her mother and trying to juggle working full time, when Lucie falls into their life! Emily did a wonderful job with these characters, they were both so likeable and I was so invested in lives. I also think she did a great job of covering the difficult subject of Alzheimer’s, I’ve worked with a lot of people with memory issues and I personally think it was done accurately and with care.
Written in Third Person with 2x POV’s. Narrated by Lulu Russell. Return to Hometown, Caring for a Relative, Age Gap, Slow Burn. 2x Spicy Scenes.
Good start. Neither character has got an easy time of it. There is an authors note at the start stating that there is a character with Alzheimer’s and that this reflects one persons journey. I know that it is a truth that you know one person with Alzheimer’s, you know one person with Alzheimer’s. A truth actually that should be acknowledged in more situations….. anyway, it probably feels I’m not talking about the book…… but actually I am invested in that character and what will happen next as much as the romance. I think that is one of the strengths of this writer. She often has the ramifications of real, common challenges that her characters are dealing with, and actually that takes up all their time, focus and energy….. yet despite that, somehow, the other main slips in. All this is done in a realistic and for me, consuming way. I love a light, amusing romance. This however has a depth that I am loving. There is a conversation just coming up to 40% that is really well written where we see similarities in the characters situations and events that led them to that moment and understanding. This is a book that doesn’t give me a quick touch of escapism but does absorb me and take me away completely from my life, so completely that even when I stop reading for adulting reasons (boo!) I am still a wee bit in the book world and my thoughts drift back to the characters and situations they are in. As compared to some other books that I enjoy when reading but struggle to remember the plot when I pick it back up. The depth and humanity and connection is again so well written in a conversation between one main and her dad. When the mains finally acknowledge what is between them, I am torn, not because of them but because I cannot see how they can have their happy ever after…… and there isn’t that much of the book left! To be honest I didn’t see the solution….. and my admiration for the writer kind of grows because of that. Being in the situation one main is in, it is absolutely understandable that to stay on that road seems the only possible path…. Yet there is another solution, it is not left field, but it never once occurred to me, as I was trying to work out how my mains could possibly get their happy ever after. It was sooo emotional on both sides, and actually the most emotional scenes weren’t necessarily between the mains but enabled the mains….. Gosh….. you don’t expect a Christmas book to totally blow your mind ….. but this did in a way that may have spoiled me for all other Christmas books going forward! And to be honest…. Just all books going forward.
Emily Banting’s The Christmas Elf offers the familiar pleasures of a holiday romance while reaching for something more substantial beneath its festive exterior. When Lucie Brown loses her job, she returns to the village of Winterbourne, the place she left behind a decade earlier, uncertain of what comes next. Taking a temporary position as a Christmas elf at Winterbourne Hall seems like a welcome distraction while she regroups. There she encounters Frances Delaney, CEO of the Winterbourne Hall Trust, whose professional responsibilities and family obligations leave little room for complications. Their initial differences provide the spark for an engaging romance, but the story’s appeal lies in the individual journeys unfolding alongside it.
One of the novel’s strengths is its attention to character development beyond the romantic relationship. Lucie and Frances are not simply two women finding their way toward one another; they are individuals navigating questions of identity, belonging, responsibility, and personal fulfillment. Lucie’s homecoming brings her face to face with a past she may have thought she had left behind, while Frances must contend with the expectations attached to her position and the demands of caring for her mother. Banting also gives attention to the quieter possibilities of love and companionship through Lucie’s father and his longtime friend Mandy. There is an unmistakable affection between the two, and Lucie’s encouragement of a potential romance speaks to her generosity and her desire to see happiness extend beyond her own life. It is a lovely reminder that the possibility of new beginnings is not limited by age or circumstance.
Banting does a particularly nice job of integrating family responsibilities into the emotional fabric of the story. Frances’s relationship with her mother, who has Alzheimer’s disease, is handled with considerable sensitivity. The challenges of understanding the disease, adjusting to its progression, and navigating the emotional demands of caregiving are given meaningful attention. Lucie brings her own experience to this relationship, having lost her grandmother to Alzheimer’s and having helped care for her. That history allows her to recognize some of what Frances is experiencing and to respond with genuine kindness, patience, and empathy as Frances finds her way through the challenges of caring for her mother. This shared experience adds another dimension to their developing connection, while also giving the novel an opportunity to explore the often difficult realities of loving and caring for someone whose illness gradually changes the relationship. The professional responsibilities and family obligations throughout the story are not simply convenient obstacles designed to delay the romantic resolution. They help define the characters, reveal their priorities, and shape the decisions they must make.
The developing relationship between Lucie and Frances benefits from this broader characterization. As they become increasingly drawn to one another, their connection grows out of more than attraction or the familiar friction between two contrasting personalities. Each has qualities the other can appreciate, perhaps even recognize as something missing in her own life. Their relationship creates opportunities for both women to reconsider their assumptions and make room for possibilities they might not otherwise have entertained. Because the romantic resolution is grounded in their individual growth and the realities of their circumstances, it feels emotionally earned rather than simply dictated by the conventions of the genre.
At its heart, The Christmas Elf is a story about coming home, discovering that life can take unexpected turns, and finding the courage to embrace a different future. Banting delivers the warmth and romantic appeal readers look for in a Christmas romance, but she also gives the story a more thoughtful foundation through characters whose lives and personal struggles extend beyond their developing relationships. The novel reminds us that reinvention does not always require leaving the past behind; sometimes it means returning to familiar places with a changed perspective and recognizing possibilities that were not visible before. It is that combination of seasonal charm, personal growth, compassion, and emotionally satisfying relationships that gives this story its appeal.
Strengths…
Multidimensional, authentic character development Portrayal of family relationships and caregiving is nicely scripted Thoughtful exploration of love and connection The romance is grounded in personal growth and emotional authenticity
I swear, Emily Banting’s stories just make me so happy! I know that when I pick up one of her books I’m going to have a good time and finish it with a smile on my face. So when I saw she had a Christmas romance coming out (one of my fave book themes!), I knew I had to get my hands on it ASAP. I absolutely adore a sweet sapphic romance, especially when you throw in all those cozy winter vibes and Christmas charm and The Christmas Elf was a perfect read for me. I had such a good time getting lost in the story and all the holiday festivities!
The story follows Lucie, who has recently returned home after years away and ends up working as a Christmas elf at the gorgeous Winterbourne Hall. That’s where she meets Frances, who’s trying to keep the estate running while also dealing with her mom’s Alzheimer’s diagnosis. Frances already has more than enough on her plate, but then Lucie comes along and unexpectedly becomes a pretty important part of her life. And I really loved these two together! There was so much yearning and I’m such a sucker for a good slow burn, so I was absolutely eating it up! While the romance was obviously a big part of the story, I really enjoyed everything going on with the families of both women too. Frances’ relationship with her mom brought some genuinely touching moments, and I loved seeing how Lucie fit into it all. Emily did a lovely job bringing everything together.
And I have to give some love to Lulu Russell because I absolutely loved her narration! She has such a lovely voice, and I could honestly listen to her all day. She did a wonderful job bringing each character to life and has a very natural story telling talent. Overall it was an enjoyable audiobook from start to finish!
Thank you so much to Emily Banting and Tantor Media for the early ALC!
This is a very gentle and, in a way, tranquil and cozy story written by Emily Banting. It deals extensively with good, bad and sadly lost memories, grief, and finding one’s place in life. The "Christmas elf" in this tale is Lucie—sweet, truly kind-hearted Lucie. She has returned from Botswana, where she spent a long time working with women and children in a Programm. A role that allowed her to put her training as an actress and her drama to very good use. But when the funding ran out, she headed back to her hometown. There, she is flooded with memories of her late grandmother, whom she had cared for until the very end as she struggled with Alzheimer’s. Everyone in her life is overjoyed by her return, as she had been away for far too long. This sense of happiness also touches Frances—though perhaps not right from the start! Frances manages Winterbourne Hall, a family legacy from days gone by that must be protected—much like the secret Frances keeps regarding her mother. It would be disastrous if anyone discovered that the former CEO of Winterbourne Hall has Alzheimer’s , as it could have devastating consequences for the management of the estate. How fortunate, then, that a "Christmas elf" suddenly arrives to help. It is a warm, slow-burn romance—one that is emotional and poignant, yet offers much more than just reminiscing and sad moments. There are not just the two MC’s you’ll find yourself rooting for, but you’ll have to discover who they are for yourselves! A beautiful Christmas romance from Emily Banting—exactly what one would expect. Thank you very much for giving me your book to read in advance.
The Christmas Elf is classic Emily Banting in many ways: a charming small village setting, the historic Great Hall, an aspiring Ice Queen CEO - Frances, and a super kind, caring ‘Christmas elf’ - Lucie. But there's so much more going on than your typical festive sapphic romance.
Emily is a master of the slow burn and as always she really makes readers work for it. I spent much of the book willing Frances and Lucie to get out of their own way and finally get together. Their journey is worth every moment of anticipation. Alongside the romance, there's a beautifully developed relationship between Lucie and Frances' mother, Rose, that adds real depth and warmth to the story. I’d say this was the star of the show.
The book also tackles some very real health and emotional issues with a gentle, respectful touch that never feels heavy-handed. I thoroughly enjoyed the journey this story took me on, and I won't pretend I didn't shed a tear during the epilogue.
The only reason this isn’t a 5 is that I felt some of it was a bit rushed (the last few chapters mainly)- but also the intimate moments between Frances and Lucie - one of which just read awkwardly. There were some very sweet moments too but I would have liked just a little bit more insight/emotional depth between them. That said, I couldn’t put it down so it’s definitely worth a read.
✨ she has a sarah waters collection and dvd box sets of the l word... could she be any gayer?
✨ "her previous relationships had been with more butch women, and this one appeared more feminine than a pink bus full of feminists on their way to a paris paloma concert" LMAO so stereotypical but it made me lol
✨ not the eau de try-hard 😭😭😭😭
✨ I love how subtly it discusses the gender pay gap through humor
✨ "she accepted that some people were heterosexual, no matter how icky she found that" PREACH
✨ it might seem like a light, festive read, but it's so much more than that. it's actually quite an intense book, and it's packed with grief and feelings that are incredibly hard to navigate (I shed a few tears, which almost never happens)
✨ it's impossible not to get attached to every character and their stories, I actually found myself missing all of them as soon as I finished the book
Many thanks to the author for providing this ARC 🧡
A sapphic Christmas romance with a grumpy CEO, a Christmas elf, a gorgeous estate, and all the festive vibes? Sign me up! I absolutely loved the cozy Christmas atmosphere in The Christmas Elf by Emily Banting. Lucie and Frances were such a fun pairing, and I loved the idea of Lucie coming back home and finding something she never expected along the way. Give me two women trying to figure out their lives while catching feelings for each other, and I’m sold. This was such a lovely holiday listen, and Lulu Russell did a fantastic job with the narration. The whole thing just put me in the mood for Christmas, and I already know I’ll be listening to this one again in December. Honestly, is there anything better than finding a sapphic holiday romance you want to revisit every year? Five stars from me! Thank you to NetGalley and Tantor Media for the ALC in exchange for my honest review.
Loved this book so much. I was a bit hesitant to read it as the topic of dementia and Alzheimer’s runs through it, but I am so very glad I did.
Emily’s books are so beautifully written and so incredibly sensitive and hard topics are tackled with care and consideration. It was such a refreshing feeling to read something where the story was real. My Nan had dementia and everything in this book I recognised. It was cathartic.
If you’re looking for slow-burn (with some really great spice 🌶️) and amazing characters and arcs, then this is for you!!
This must read will tug at your heart strings and make you smile/cry The Christmas Elf is a sweet and charming standalone romance but with drama and angst in part due to a secondary character with Alzheimer's. I loved both main characters and their family members (blood and chosen), rooted for the romances and for everything to work out for all of them by the end. You can't help but care about the cast of characters and find them relatable to some degree. I'd read one series of books by Emily Banting prior to this and loved her storytelling style, so I'm gratified to see her write a standalone and seasonal story in one. There is still a stately home and estate in the UK for part of the story's setting (and some wonderful scenes take place there) and mains who are from different parts of the socio-economic ladder; it's not a rich girl/poor girl dynamic and more nuanced than that, a refreshing take on the trope in my view. There's some steaminess between mains Lucie and Frances but otherwise you can read this in public without issue; there is an age gap between them if those kinds of romance stories are your jam. There is humor and plenty of moments to awwww, smile while reading, dab at tears certain scenes will inspire, and to feel your heart strings being tugged by characters and their interactions. Be sure to have facial tissue at hand for tear dabbing (and perhaps nose blowing for some moments in the story). Heads up that in addition to Alzheimer's, grief and loss, changes in family dynamics and relationships are also themes in the story, and some verbal insensitivity from one or more characters to another does occur (briefly) if those are issues for you. The ending is a good one and although it is a standalone story I'd happily read a follow up story about Lucie and Frances or one where they make a cameo appearance. If you've read Emily Banting's work before, this delivers what you expect (and more) without having to wait for the next book in a series to be published; if you're new to her writing and hesitant to dive into a series, The Christmas Elf is the perfect way to sample Banting's writing while enjoying a charming heart string tugging feel good (most of the time) romance with characters that are easy to get attached to and invested in. I highly recommend you check out The Christmas Elf for the holiday season, or any time of the year, along with her other books. I look forward to reading whatever she publishes next.
One of my favourite things about this author is her ability to create the cosiest British sapphic romances and this was no different!
The story follows two main characters, Lucie, who has spent over a decade working in Botswana after leaving to heal from the loss of her grandmother, and Frances, the CEO of Winterbourne Hall, spreading herself too thin after taking her mother’s position due to an Alzheimer’s diagnosis. Frances main concern is not wanting anyone from the trust to find out.
When Lucie returns, she’s in desperate need of a job and applies for a seasonal position as a Christmas Elf at the hall. After she’s hired, she unintentionally discovers Frances’s secret, after finding her mum roaming around the grounds looking lost.
The story has some angst towards the beginning as Lucie knows all too well how much care is needed and Frances does not take kindly to being vulnerable and admitting she needs help.
When they meet, the attraction is instant, however, the author did a great job with a slow-burn romance. The last thing Frances wanted was any interference, especially from someone under her employ, however, after Lucie’s experience with her own grandmother, she cannot stand idly by and watch Rose suffer. Frances’s biggest issue is that Rose takes to her almost immediately, making it difficult for her not to accept the help.
After some reluctance, Lucie quickly becomes someone who Frances relies on, a friend and a support system. However, Lucie won’t be around forever because the job is only seasonal. When reading the book, I was unsure how they would overcome the obstacles faced because there was only one way forward, but a bittersweet HEA was delivered!
I loved how the author wrote their experiences in a way that felt authentic. The story is full of moments that make you laugh, that make you swoon and that make you cry.
I really enjoy this author’s work overall, and this standalone is another 5⭐️ read.
Thanks for starting my Christmas reading off with this lush one!
What can you say about The Christmas Elf
It's an Emily Banting book!!! You know it's going to be good 😏
So, snuggle down, grab a hot chocolate, and meet Lucie & Frances
Emily gives us not only the most delicious Christmas book/vibes, strong female characters, but also what it means to be family and sometimes the sacrifices we make to support them. That sometimes we can't do it all alone!
Lucie is finally back home after 10years away in Botswana, this wasn't in her life plan.
And being an Elf wasn't either! But you have to make money where you can till you figure out what you actually want. Winterbourne Hall is about to offer her a new path, but will she take it?
Frances, CEO and a member of the original family that built Winterbourne is struggling to keep a secret from her loyal staff & running herself into the ground!
When Lucie offers her a lifeline, all be it one she refuses originally, the two of them slowly acknowledge the building attraction.
But will Lucie stick around after the holidays? Can Frances finally do something for herself and not what's expected of her?
I love the fact this is another age gap from Emily 😜 and one of them is dressed as an elf on and off 😂
The Christmas Elf is a holiday-themed sapphic romance which primarily takes place in a small English town named Winterbourne. The main characters, Lucie and Francis, have an amusing meet-cute and then fight attraction because Francis is indirectly Lucie's boss.
I was surprised at how much heart there is in this story. I don't want to spoil anything, but I will say that Banting handles being the caretaker of an aging parent extremely well. Have a tissue or two on hand, just in case. I'd also suggest a cup of tea, as it made me look forward to colder weather and the holidays.
The narration by Lulu Russell started off a bit mellow (for my taste). It set the tone for the story, but as all of the characters became more animated, so did her narration. I could feel various emotions as Russell voiced the two main characters; she was especially effective with conveying joy. This helped me become even more invested in Lucie and Francis, and their slow-burn relationship.
Thank you to NetGalley and RBmedia for the opportunity to listen to the ALC of this book.
Poignantly beautiful. Center stage, a Hall of requirements as long as a bloodline that cares little for the lives it had, has, and will shape. 425 staff members, but only one family born into serving its whims and needs at an indeterminable expense until its foundations are shook by a Christmas elf.
The brain is as wondrous as it is treacherous and seated between delicate synapses is who we are. When those synapses begin to fail, when the basic chemistry degrades, we are left defenseless- cracks in the foundations of personality, of memory, of self with little to be done as the mind continues down a path of no return. The disease is handled with such grace and humility in this book that you will be left thinking about these women long after you close the final page.
From postpartum to dementia, to overbearing in-laws and a life cut short, to reaching out before reaching in, to the music we loved to dance to, the smells that tear us from the now and flash us to the past, this book is a journey with a bittersweet HEA that you run to and run from in equal measure. My heart is as tired as it is full and it’s the benchmark I’ve come to expect from an Emily Banting book.
I had such a good time reading this book and literally flew through it! It's such a sweet holiday romance with two lesbian main characters, age-gap and a delicious slowburn. Emily Banting did such a wonderful job in combining happiness, grief and love in a way that will touch your heart.
I think you should know going into this book that while it's very sweet and heartwarming, you should be aware that it does speak about some more difficult topics. For example, alzheimer is a really big part of the book and it explores a lot of different aspects of it, like grief and guilt. It could possibly be triggering to some readers so just a heads up!!
My only issue with this is the pacing felt a little bit off which made the end of the book feel very rushed.
Big thank you to Emily for being so kind and generous by offering me an arc of this!
A delightful book appropriate for any time of year! While meant to be a Christmas novel, there is so much more packed into this wonderful sapphic story. I absolutely adore the depth and tenderness with which the author wrote Rose’s character and her living with Alzheimer’s. It takes up a large part of the story, but doesn’t overtake it. Both Frances and Lucie are warm and easy to like. They each have their own challenges, but I really like that they communicate well and are willing to grow. The setting of an old English estate all dressed up for the holidays is a perfect backdrop for this sweet sapphic romance. The side characters are all written well and bring so much life to the story. A great representation of grief, loss, and the challenges caregivers face.
This is the slowest of slow burns I’ve read in quite some time but I always enjoy Emily Banting.
I’m really glad that Frances was able to find and accept help, first from Lucie and later on from Mara. She didn’t have to go through the process of her mother’s illness alone, both her and her mom were loved and respected and there were people who could have supported her.
This story felt so cozy and cute for the couple it really gets you in the mood for Christmas, however it can also be bittersweet when we’re presented with Rose’s unfortunate situation and the passing of Lucie’s mother and grandmother.
For me, the narrator was spectacular. Lulu Russell has a voice that just soothes you.
Thank you to Emily Banting and Tantor Media for providing me with an eARC and an ALC.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
The Christmas Elf by Emily Banting is a charming, heartwarming, slow burn romance perfect for the Christmas season or really any season! I loved the contrast between the two women, with Lucie's more easy-going nature bringing an unexpected spark into Frances's busy, complicated world. Their developing connection, the slow-burn romance and the challenges they each face make this an enduring love story of fresh starts, second chances and finding happiness when you least expect it. A delightful read with plenty of heart, warmth and Christmas charm!