This is the fascinating story of a successful con man, a beautiful corpse, and a murder that almost went unpunished.
In traditional mysteries, crimes are solved by brilliant private or amateur detectives and police officers are corrupt, buffoonish, or both. Police work is a necessary evil, but far too boring to sell books, right? Starting in 1949, Hillary Waugh turned that idea on its head with a series of crime novels set in small Connecticut towns. His heroes are small town police chiefs who solve crimes, not with strokes of brilliance, but with persistence and relentless attention to detail.
Waugh liked and admired cops and spent a great deal of time studying them. He saw himself in the role of a reporter who chronicled the reality of police work in a fictionalized form. His cops sift evidence, conduct interviews, and follow up leads and hunches. Their strength is their intimate knowledge of their town and its people and they have the intuitive understanding of human psychology that doesn't come from a book, but from experience. Slowly and steadily, they chip away at extraneous material until they arrive at the truth. It may be routine, but it's never boring to read about.
Waugh's most frequently recurring character (and my favorite) is Chief Fred Fellows of Stockton. Both Fellows and Waugh were family men and the author gave his son's name (Larry) to Fellow's oldest son. I think Waugh put a lot of himself into Fred Fellows and perhaps that's what makes him such a successful character.
In this book, Fellows is faced with a cop's worst nightmare - a murder with no clues. The beautiful young woman found strangled beside a lake is a stranger in town. Both her name and her background story are false and no one was seen with her before her death. Using a few insignificant clues from her possessions, the Stockton Police Department follows one lead after another to dead ends until one finally pays off.
Instead of being bored, the reader shares Fellow's frustration and his elation when a hunch DOES pan out. The moment when he realizes that he finally has a particularly cold-blooded murderer in his grasp is one of the most satisfying things I've read. And the "perp" isn't just a successful murderer, but one of the slickest con artists you'll ever meet.
It's a crime that Waugh's books aren't available on Kindle, but Harper & Row published this one and LAST SEEN WEARING as Perennial Library paperbacks and you can easily find good used copies for a few dollars. Believe me, if you love a good mystery, it's well worth the effort.