Worth a read.
I always read self-help books with a critical eye since with self-help it is easy to be overwhelmed by the feeling that a solution is possible while reading, only to find that the author's method does not apply, or is not sufficient in itself, and this is how I read this book. I have read quite a few books on alcohol and addiction, I have used different services myself (from counseling to NHS, to hypnosis to to a year in AA), and while I can't be 100% sure, I have a feeling people need to be ready somehow to stop drinking before they do, so this book may not 'work' for everyone but having it might be good so you can go back to it. Before buying this (on kindle, considerably cheaper), I read the first chapters on his website for free. He also has a QA on Facebook if you're interested. This book was recommended to me by an NHS mental health worker. Full disclaimer I am not and never was physically addicted to alcohol, but was physically unwell and extremely dependent, drinking spirits most days, with a 15 year long history of problem drinking when I read this.
I'll be short about what worked in this book. First it is repetitive, and why it's got zero style and limited vocabulary, I wouldn't say it is badly written. This book is hugely accessible. I'm sorry healthcare professionals, but when we're low on ourselves and over using booze, we want to read something like what William Porter wrote, regardless of education level. When reading a book it is easy to forget what we've just read as we go through the chapters, so for the author to constantly reference what he has said before, or what he will explain later, is helpful. It's lazy to dismiss this book as over simple when it is not. It actually it packs quite a lot.
Secondly, at some point the author implies that people spent years trying to work out why they're miserable in counseling when the answer is in their alcohol use. Fine, after reading the book I see his point, but I had to take this with a pinch of salt. It's a lot more complex than that.
Now, what worked for me: 'Alcohol Explained' educates the reader without trying to control her, something that I rarely felt while reading or seeing professionals before. I'm sorry but often when using NHS or other substance misuse services, there's a feeling the professionals are gatekeepers of the knowledge, and despite the patient-centered culture, the approach is still very much a top-down one. Same goes with reading books by experts or journalists there's often a bias, or an overindulgent academic tone. On the same level, a people run group like AA implies a consequent, quasi lifelong reliance on AA itself, as well as its dogma (or program). Not for me.
'Alcohol Explained' doesn't sugar coat, but it doesn't patronize the reader or scare him into compliance; what I mean is it empowers and informs the reader and gives her the credit to succeed or fail. I felt fairly safe and held when reading this book, and I appreciated the author shared about his experiences sparsely as to not dominate, but enough for me to trust him. Yes some of the knowledge in it might be refuted later, so? I'm hoping I'll have done more of my own research or sought help from other sources by then.
Even though the author uses some of the 'this method will work if you follow' rhetoric, I never believed he was my saviour. It's far from perfect and I had to roll my eyes a few times but that's a sign I can be critical and still give his advice a go.
A side note: before any healthcare professional out there feels attacked, I am well aware they'll have studied for years, and may be overworked or suffering from carer's fatigue, and also actually do help people, not to mention being, unlike a book author, held accountable via duty of care if something happens to one of their patient. I am just saying stepping away from being the patient who's bounced between services or the victim of a 'disease' can actually go well.
Yes the book implies calling alcoholism a disease is problematic (a fair point he's not the only one making), but guys calm down he's not going on a campaign to get it scrapped off either (and he could, he's a lawyer). He also specifies the reader should go see their doctor if physically addicted, before stopping.
'Alcohol Explained' gave me solid info I, as a problem drinker and patient / service user, had never had access to before, and touched upon a few hard truths in the social and emotional realms. Just had to take it with a grain of salt when needed, and be patient with the repetitive tone. What I am mainly saying here, is that I loved this book and it's helped me deal with my Achilles' heel, which is experiencing cravings probably for the rest of my life. I wanted to explain why I loved this book. The rest is up to you, it's a free country.