Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Panguan: The Twelfth Gate #1

Panguan: The Twelfth Gate (Novel) Vol. 1

Rate this book
From the author and universe of Copper Coins and Three Hundred Years of Longing comes a modern-day, supernatural danmei (Boys' Love) story about a man without a soul and the one determined to save him at all costs.As a panguan, a cultivator tasked with putting the dead to rest, Wen Shi has spent a thousand years sending souls on to their next life. But without a soul of his own, he's trapped in an endless cycle of rebirth, desperately searching for the lost pieces of himself.
Now, reborn for the twelfth time, he feels a constant hunger that can only be satisfied by consuming the dark miasma that clings to the dead. So when failed panguan Xie Wen responds to Wen Shi's ad for a roommate, Wen Shi is taken aback by the dense miasma cloaking the handsome young man. Smug and irritating, Xie Wen instantly becomes Wen Shi's most tempting meal. Yet the longer Wen Shi spends with Xie Wen, the more mysterious he seems. Xie Wen appears to know things about Wen Shi even Wen Shi has forgotten--things that could end his millennium of lonely wandering.

423 pages, Kindle Edition

Published September 15, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Mu Su Li

103 books230 followers
Associated Names:
* Mu Su Li (English)
* 木苏里 (Simplified Chinese) / 木蘇里 (Traditional Chinese)
* มู่ซูหลี่ (Thai)

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
54 (45%)
4 stars
51 (42%)
3 stars
12 (10%)
2 stars
1 (<1%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews
Profile Image for Alexia.
476 reviews
September 20, 2026
This danmei was an incredibly enjoyable read and exactly what I needed to lift my spirits after experiencing a disappointing previous book.

I have a strong fondness for all the danmei this author has written, and I wasn't surprised to find myself loving this one as well; she has a remarkable talent for depicting couple dynamics that are exactly to my taste.

I particularly appreciated how the horror elements genuinely conveyed a sense of dread; at times, I had to set the book down because the creepy atmosphere became too intense, especially during the first arc. I really dislike creepy children in horror stories; they always give me the chills.

I also cried because many of these arcs are profoundly emotional, as they deal extensively with themes of death and loss, especially in the poignant moments when characters bid farewell to their loved ones.

Wen Shi is portrayed as a blank protagonist, and when I say blank, I mean that he lacks a soul rather than being an empty character. He lost his soul, or it simply vanished some time ago, and now he is on a quest to find it. His internal thoughts are hilarious; he constantly roasts everyone while appearing cold and distant.

Then there's Xie Wen, the mysterious love interest whose true identity is revealed early on because the story doesn't hide it. He remains an enigma because his personality is quite subdued, and there's still a lot we don't know about him. Despite this, he possesses such charisma that it's hard not to like him.

Their relationship can be succinctly described with one word: Yearning. Throughout the entire story, they are making eyes at each other, and their chemistry is palpable. While they maintain unwavering eye contact that seems destined to last forever, their connection is unfolding gradually, embodying the slow, evolving nature of a slow-burn romance. They share a past, but Wen Shi doesn't remember it; however, his heart still recognizes Xie Wen instinctively. Their playful bickering adds humor to the narrative, and I love how gentle and caring Xie Wen is with Wen Shi.

In conclusion, this is a danmei novel that masterfully balances emotional depth with creepy atmospheres, achieving both with great skill.
Profile Image for GloomyKiwi.
32 reviews4 followers
September 21, 2026
4.5 Stars!! I really liked this one! The dynamics/banter is really good and i like the mystery vibes. Good start! (Also i love my little crybaby..)
Profile Image for Poisonivy_Seastars.
111 reviews6 followers
October 12, 2026
“Many, many years ago, someone had once told him: This is destined to be an arduous line of work. You will bear witness to too much sorrow and suffering. In time, you'll learn that most of it stems from a reluctance to say goodbye. Once you understand this, you'll have truly entered the world of mortals.”

This finally scratched that Guardian series itch I’ve been having since I first read it 🙂‍↕️🙂‍↕️ It had just the right amount of humor and mystery and I need December come to come fasterrrrr

(It’s also making me nosy enough to wanna keep going with the authors other books…I dnf’d Copper Coins cause the pacing was a little slow but I might have to pick it up again)
Profile Image for Khael.
111 reviews
September 21, 2026
(chapter 27)
Amid the swirling snow, the man was still patiently holding out his hand, waiting for Wen Shi to take it.
The black mist was too filthy. Wen Shi hesitated, then moved to tuck his hands behind his back, but halfway through the motion, the man caught one of them and held firm. "Why are you shrinking back?"
His hand was not only large but warm. Wen Shi fought his own instincts, then gave in; meekly, he allowed himself to be led up the path.
They walked for a long time before Wen Shi spoke. His sulky, childlike voice came out scarcely above a whisper. "My hands are really dirty."
Many people had said he was like an evil spirit. Yet after a brief silence, the man said, "no, they're not."
Wen Shi looked at the snowy ground, his voice thickening. "That bird—I just wanted to touch it." But instantly, it had stiffened and dropped dead, eyes vacant, as though its life had been drained away. The other children had scrambled away from him in fear, like he was a malevolent ghost, a demonic creature of stories.
In reality, no one was more scared than him.
"I know," the man said.

I've gotten hooked into this story since the moment I read chapter 1, which this is so rare for me. What helped me into reading this so soon was because I heard that there's a shizun x disciple trope and both a historical and modern setting, which I haven't read that one before. I really liked how they showed Wen Shi learning new inventions from throughout his last lives to his current one, like him being so shocked of a vacuum. Wen Shi and Xie Wen's conversations are so cute and silly together, and how when he finally moved into the house, he bought the entire floor so that he could move in his workers, a tree, and other furniture there, which I still don't know how the hell he moved that tree. It was cute how he got a dream of the past the moment Xie Wen moved in, like he subconsciously remembers but his body isn't letting him to. I'm liking his and Xia Qiao's brotherly relationship, despite them knowing each other for maybe a week or two. I'm loving the two twins so far, I've saw some art of them and it's so cute how they look like they have cat ears.

It was sad how Xie Wen took Xia Qiao and Wen Shi for dinner in chapter 15 and that Wen Shi couldn't even eat it for whatever reason, knowing that he was treated to food that he once loved in his first life. This is what I'm talking about:
Noticing the flicker of confusion on Wen Shi's face, Xie Wen contemplated for a moment. "I once took in a..." He paused, as though searching for the right words. Only after Wen Shi shot him a second look did he continue: "I took in a child who loved this meal."
"Where is he now?" Wen Shi asked.
"He's not here anymore." Xie Wen kept his gaze on the cup in his hands, lashes lowered. "It was a very long time ago."

It was hilarious how Xia Qiao just said that Xie Wen will pay for Wen Shi's phone for when he moved in, not only that but a kitten as well, when all he wanted was the 2nd floor. This is what he gets for being so secretive and cramped now. I also liked how when a woman asked for Wen Shi's name, and he, of course, had to fake one because everyone knew of him from the past, he used the same surname as his shizun as his first thought without meaning to. I'd like to think that they were married in the past, either secretively or open to the other disciples. He even shocked Xie Wen too for when he said that name, I wonder if bro was blushing at the time, since he was right at the door when it was said, and left after. Anyways, I'm loving Wen Shi and Xie Wen's relationship, which I need them to kiss, and I hope that Wen Shi and Xia Qiao becomes more brotherly.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for V~.
131 reviews29 followers
Review of advance copy
March 31, 2026
2.5/5 🌟

This is strictly if I were to divide the novel in 4 books. Giving me 30/117 chapters for this volume, and for the first 30 chapters, I was very disappointed. But I will keep my thoughts to myself in fear of people just being cruel for me having an opinion.
This style of writing feels so "tell, don't show." I feel like I've learned I like and prefer "Show, Don't Tell" more.
One thing I did like is the endings of the gates. It was touching to see those who have died be able to release their burdens and move on.
I didn't like how long it took to get there... But at least we got to the end of the gates!
I am still reading this whole novel and hope to gain love for the story as a whole. As I'm writing this review, I'm 43% of the way in and am definitely enjoying it more now. So there's hope.
(ˊᵒ̴̶̷̤ ꇴ ᵒ̴̶̷̤ˋ)♡

I loved Copper Coins in the same universe, and gave it such a high rating. But this specific volume of Panguan... I just didn't feel it.

Main Characters: ★★☆☆☆
Plot potential: ★★★★☆
Deliverance: ★☆☆☆☆
Side Characters: ★★★☆☆
Romance/Emotions: ★☆☆☆☆
Writing style: ★☆☆☆☆
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Queens Love Books.
642 reviews26 followers
October 5, 2026
“All phenomena are impermanent, all emotions beget suffering, hence all beings bound by worldly attachments. Occasionally, there arise those who are wholly untainted. These, we call panguan.”

description

Just when the story was getting really good and interesting, it ended! Ugh! I was so invested by the time I got to the end, so of course I wanted to keep going. But honestly, I think ending the volume where it did was a good choice. It left me interested without making the ending feel anticlimactic, and I actually like that I’m going into the next volume with so many questions. There’s still a lot that I don’t understand, and I kept having these little questions sitting at the back of my mind while I was reading. One thing I really like was how early the author started laying out the mystery surrounding the characters. When Chen Bu Dao was first mentioned and Xie Wen was introduced, I immediately felt like there was some kind of connection there. I had a feeling about it, and the author didn’t drag it out for ages before letting me see what that connection was. My hunch was right! I really enjoyed that. The thing about the gate is still bothering me, though. I kept waiting for more of an explanation, and I feel like that’s one thing I would have liked to understand by the end of this volume. But I guess that’s something we’ll have to uncover in the next ones.

I also really enjoyed Mu Su Li’s writing here. This is my fourth series by the author, so I went back and looked at my reviews for the other first volumes, and I think this is probably my favorite one as an introduction to one of their stories. I feel like Mu Su Li is really good at sensory writing, and I noticed it a lot while reading this. The freezing rain, foggy corridors, desolate suburban estates, creeping black mist, all those little details made the setting so easy for me to picture. What I especially loved was how the story could go from eerie gothic horror to something much warmer and almost domestic without it feeling weird. I really like those quieter moments. The humor worked for me too because it didn’t feel forced or like the story was stopping just to make a joke. Also, Wen Shi and Xie Wen had me confused at first. I kept having to remind myself which name belonged to which person, but eventually I got used to it and stopped thinking about it. And now that I have four Mu Su Li series in my collection, plus “A Certain Someone” that I just received, I’m starting to think I might need a separate shelf/panel for this author. My shelves are already getting ridiculous.

I almost forgot to talk about the art! I really love the cover of this volume, and I like the colored illustrations inside too. The poster that came with the book was done by st, who is one of my favorites, and I love that poster so much. The black and white illustrations were more hit or miss for me this time, though. I’m not saying they weren’t good because they obviously are, but I just didn’t personally like most of them, especially the ones of Wen Shi. It’s one of those things where I can recognize that the art is well done while also knowing that it just isn’t what I personally want to see for the characters. Also, I had to check how many volumes this series is going to have because I hadn’t looked before starting it, and apparently we’re getting four! I swear we keep getting so many four-volume series lately! I honestly like three better. There’s something about an odd number of books in a series that appeals to me so much more, and I don’t even know why. Anyway, now I just need the next volume because I have questions and I want answers.

Date Read: 2026.10.04
Profile Image for Rae.
756 reviews
November 16, 2026
This was a really fun book! I had some plus sides and some mild sides but overall it was a fun read and I look forward to the next book in a few weeks. I enjoyed the mystery surrounding Wen Shi and Xie Wen. I'll enjoy learning more about their story. Xia Qiao is a great little silly goose to have around to diffuse tension. I really enjoyed how the story was very reminiscent of a horror unlimited flow with them repeatedly going into cages and solving the mysteries within while dealing with the horrors within. It really helped put me back into the mood for youkai/ghost/onmiyouji stories (I know Japanese versus Chinese but you get the vibes). I think what was kind of mid to me was just that these characters are SO similar to a couple in another series she has written (Global Examination) so they didn't feel as original and unique to me as some of her other couples. Maybe when we get further into the series my feelings about that will change. And the amnesia. She loves amnesia. Every book of hers I read somebody has to have amnesia. I don't dislike the trope but like, maybe something a little different? Overall fun and I await book 2's release in the coming weeks.
Profile Image for Em.
203 reviews2 followers
September 21, 2026
Absolutely devoured this. The only thing better than fated lovers are lovers who defy fate for each other mwah
Profile Image for Akansha.
885 reviews11 followers
October 3, 2026
My Ge eats Xie Wen to survive.

If Guardian by Priest and Hotel Del Luna, the Kdrama had a baby it would be something like Panguan.

It can't get more romantic than this, can it?

Panguan is one of the most loved Mu Su Li works I think. Or at least that's what I have seen online. I had high hopes from this and it delivers.

If I am being honest though I prefer the world building of Three Hundred years of Longing (it’s also release month for the final volume) but I feel like the lore in this one is going to hit more. I fear Xie Wen might be coming for the number one yearner crown. We will see.

The plot is filled with creepy, scary things that made me keep the book down multiple times, not joking I didn’t read this after dinner. Mirrors, creepy dolls, escape room and dead teenage girl with tragic story...everything that could scare the shit out of me did.
Profile Image for akira.
205 reviews1 follower
October 11, 2026
panguan volume 1 is the start of something so interesting and likely devastating. the book starts with wen shi, waking up for the twelfth time, after his last death in 1995. wen shi is a panguan, a type of spiritual cultivator that deals with the resentment left behind by the unfulfilled dead. but unlike most of his kind, wen shi has been undergoing a relentless cycle of rebirth.

things get even more complicated with the arrival of xie wen, a mysterious man that has ties to wen shi's long and tragic past.

i really enjoyed this one. it's got a lot of charm and wit and a cast of side characters that add so much humour to tense and downright horrifying situations.
Profile Image for SSA.
480 reviews8 followers
October 13, 2026
I liked the three mysteries covered in this volume. They were sufficiently creepy and the world was very atmospheric. It took a bit of time for me to understand the magic systems of this world but it was very unique to me and I can't wait to learn more.

I liked Xiao Qiao. He was pretty adorable and a fun comic relief and his internal commentary helped to cut the tension.

The relationship between Wen Shi and Xie Wen is compelling and I liked the easy camaraderie they had. There was some small reveals in this volume to suggest a much deeper history between them and I look forward to reading about it in the next volumes. The tension between them was so strong and intriguing. “It’s fine. I can identify him,” Wen Shi assured him without turning.
Xia Qiao shot a confused glance at Lao-Mao. “How?”
“I’ll taste him,” said Wen Shi calmly.
Xia Qiao gaped at him. But after a moment, understanding dawned. Oh right. How could I forget? My ge eats Xie Wen to survive, he thought, face wooden.”
OMG. Wen Shi was so straightforward and serious.
Profile Image for Shaun "AceFireFox".
329 reviews3 followers
October 8, 2026
Woo my first review since the half and quarter stars were introduced!!

So I was a bit conflicted going into it. Mu Su Li also wrote Three Hundred Years of Longing and because of that I had high hopes because I absolutely love that story and I can't wait for book 4. I also heard really great things on Reddit it was recommended a lot and I was told I would love it. However, when I read the synopsis and saw it was contemporary, I was worried. Not because I don't like contemporary danmei, Silent Reading and Desire are two of my favourite danmei stories I've read, but because it wasn't what I expected. Despite that, I went into it anyway.

I absolutely love this. That's all I can really say. I love the characters, I think the whole world and lore is interesting, and I can only imagine it'll get more interesting going forwards. I didn't actually expect to enjoy it this much, it almost feels like it pulled me out of a minor slump I felt like I'd gotten into.
Profile Image for Monica Gunther.
31 reviews
October 7, 2026
I had no idea this was going to have so much focus on puppet masters?
After reading the summary, I thought I was going to love this. I think my main issue was the pacing. It felt slow while reading, maybe because most of the story was solving the cages and not about the character development/relationships, but when thinking back, the actual plot moved very fast. I wish the author had included the brief explanation of the puppetry art at the beginning, not during the third and final cage of this book. The third cage (escape room) was the best part by far and I found myself finally enjoying this story. Hopefully the rest of the books in the series continue this trajectory.
Profile Image for A.
451 reviews8 followers
September 30, 2026
So happy this is the first (licensed) danmei I read! This was so good!!! Just the right blend of hilarious, spooky and mysterious. I was so into the story I didn't notice I was already at the end (I screamed a little at that cliffhanger lol) Cannot wait to read the next volume!
Profile Image for Len.
154 reviews
Review of advance copy
May 26, 2026
I enjoy the main characters dynamics but I not really enjoying the cages thing.
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews