Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Age of Fury: Peaky Blinders meets Brooklyn in a historical epic from New York Times bestselling author

Rate this book
A fierce seventeen-year-old Irish girl joins forces with a notorious gangster to hunt down her sister's killer.

1907. New York City. A glittering world built on lies - and one murdered girl who could expose them all.

Caitlin Quinn crosses the ocean from Ballykelly with nothing but a desperate letter from her missing twin, Mary. New York is meant to hold answers - but instead it offers a sprawling metropolis with a brutal underbelly of crooked deals, criminal empires and forces who'd kill to keep Mary's truth hidden.

Then there is William Furey - a feared gangster haunted by a rage he can't explain. He has his own orders to find Mary, and when his search collides with Caitlin's, their unlikely alliance sparks something fierce and undeniable.

As the walls close in, Caitlin and William realise the truth will cost them far more than they ever imagined. To uncover what happened to Mary, they must risk their loyalties, their futures, and the fragile trust growing between them. Because love, like justice, exacts a price. And some sacrifices are paid in blood . . .

The producer, director, and writer of shows including Gossip Girl, Gilmore Girls, The O.C., and Gotham turns his attention to the underworld of Gilded Age New York in this riveting suspense novel that blends tension and humanity - and deftly showcases a heart-stirring exploration of truth, identity, and love.

481 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 20, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

John Stephens

13 books597 followers
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.

John Stephens spent ten years working in television and was executive producer of Gossip Girl and a writer for Gilmore Girls and The O.C. He holds an MFA from the University of Virginia. John and his wife have a dog named Bug and live in Los Angeles. His debut book 'The Emerald Atlas' is the first in a series of books.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
21 (24%)
4 stars
44 (51%)
3 stars
14 (16%)
2 stars
6 (7%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews
Profile Image for Natalie  all_books_great_and_small .
3,402 reviews204 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 6, 2026
I received an advance reader copy of this book to read in exchange for an honest review as part of the book tour hosted by Insta Book Tours.

The Age of fury is a captivating, dark murder mystery thriller set in 1907 in New York City.
We follow the POV of Caitlin Quinn, a young Irish girl whos crossed the ocean from Ireland in search of her beloved twin sister Mary. The second POV is William Furey, a notorious gangster in New York with a darkness inside he cannot explain or often control. When his search for the same missing person, Mary, crosses paths with Caitlin the pair are brought together as an unlikely team to solve the mystery of Mary's murder and for Caitlin to get her revenge.
The book takes many unexpected twists and turns and was deliciously dark and gothic in its settings which I'm always down for.
Caitlin was such a character - she had me giggling all the way through with her humor and wise cracks and I just loved her character and spirit so much and could picture her so vividly as a real person during that time period. The pair do get themselves into a few scrapes which had me holding my breath as to if they would survive them.
The ending was so lovely and brought a tear to my eye as well as a good few giggles to boot.
This is the first novel I've read by John Stephens and definitely will not be my last!
Profile Image for Camille.
199 reviews25 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
September 25, 2026
Historical fiction and mystery/thrillers were my favorite genres growing up. I read them everywhere: the school bus, family holidays, and even when I had tickets to national football and hockey games. To put it simply, I was obsessed. While I’ve crossed to the dark side in the years since (Hello, Feyre darling), I still have a special place in my heart for the two genres that helped me get into reading.

The Age of Fury is a window into those genres. The story follows Caitlin, an American immigrant. Caitlin leaves her homeland, Ireland, after receiving a letter from her twin sister begging for help. Unfortunately, Caitlin arrives too late—her sister has been murdered, and the police are doing little to investigate the case. Caitlin is determined to catch her sister’s killer, and she doesn’t care how many gangsters and corrupt policemen she has to cross to do so.

Caitlin is a character that readers can root for. Some of her lines had me laughing out loud! I think it can be difficult to write a main character with blunt language and brash decisions while still making them likable to the reader. This is one of the only books I’ve read that has accomplished it.

I also appreciate the author’s attention to detail with the time period and setting. This book takes place during the Gilded Age (circa 1900 in New York). I love how different ships, ports, and historical figures (some fictional, some real) are drawn into the story.

The main reason I’m rating this book 3 stars instead of 4 is because I found it unrealistic that a handsome gangster would abandon his life’s work—not to mention the gang leader who saved him as a child and raised him to be his second-in-command—for a girl he’d just met. That, combined with the story’s slow pacing, lowered my rating to 3 stars. That said, I still think it’s a good book!

I haven’t read a historical mystery in a while, and I’m glad The Age of Fury changed that. I can see fans of gritty, upper YA stories enjoying this. Overall, I had a wonderful reading experience.

I received a copy of The Age of Fury as a #GetUnderlinedPartner from Penguin Random House. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Nafeesa ♡.
420 reviews6 followers
November 14, 2026
Having not read anything by this author before, I went in with no expectations. After finishing the book, I was completely blown away. In the best way possible.

This story had me hooked from the very first page. Told from the perspectives of Caitlin, a young Irish girl looking for her sister, and William, a notorious gangster also searching for the same missing girl, this dark story was utterly captivating.

I really enjoyed the way Caitlin was talking to Mary about everything that was happening. This conversational style of writing was engaging and showed a great deal of emotion. Caitlin had me giggling throughout the story, with her humour and sharp wit.

The pacing was perfect, the suspense had me on the edge of my seat and the romance was unexpectedly sweet. There were a few twists that I didn't see coming at all, one in particular that left me shocked. The ending was so wholesome and even had me a little emotional.

This is the first book I've read by John Stephens, but it certainly isn't the last.
Profile Image for Ink.
1,008 reviews29 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 15, 2026
The Age of Fury by John Stephens is deeply immersive historical fiction that had me gripped tightly throughout

I am not usually captivated by YA fiction, but this book is at the upper age of the genre due to it's close attention to research and factual accuracy of the era, A time when people had to be hard headed and hard fought to survive

It's the gilded age in New York. A time of excessive wealth for those that had it and extreme poverty for those that did not (making this novel even more timely and relevant) Caitlin Quinn is on a desperate journey from Ballykelly, (Londonderry, Northern Ireland) to find her twin sister Mary after she received an ominous letter from her. Caitlin finds not a city of glitz and glamour, but a labyrinthine metropolis full of danger and deceit, perfidy and peril.

Caitlin crosses paths with William Furey, a gangster who is also searching for Mary and as the pair team up to find her they unearth not only a deep connection, but a seething mystery that will not only risk their future together, but their lives

The Age of Fury is stunning. The book captures the era perfectly, from the glitz and glamour to the desperation and poverty of the working classes and immigrants that built New York from the ground up. John Stephens creates not only a strong storyline and relatable characters, but places them in a narrative that is highly illustrative and authentic. The careful, meticulous (and clearly extensive) research that has gone into this book is immediately apparent and is consistent throughout, making it highly immersive and immensly enjoyable

A fantastic introduction to this author and will be adding them to my 'must buy' list. I would highly recommend this author to fans of John Boyne. While the two authors have different styles, the skill of placing the reader within the story is executed with a quiet finesse that is hardly noticable until you come up for air after losing hours and hours in history and mystery

Thank you to the author, Hot Key Books (Bonnier Books) and InstaBookTours for this outstanding novel. My review is left voluntarily and all opinions are my own
Profile Image for Jillian.
59 reviews3 followers
November 12, 2026
It's been a long time since I thoroughly enjoyed a book and thought about the characters when I wasn't reading. I can't say there is anything provocative or nuanced about the actual story, but the author just does an excellent job with immersing his reader into the America of 1907. Like many reviewers I absolutely LOVED Caitlin. She was feisty, hysterical and ultimately vulnerable which made her such a well-rounded character. Don't even get me started on our young hot tempered mobster William Furey. He definitely is one of my top five favorite literary characters. I think of the term- Still waters run deep- when it comes to him.

The action and twists never stopped but were believable at the same time. I'm looking forward to more of the same from this author, hopefully!
Profile Image for Sonia S.
82 reviews1 follower
October 20, 2026
Think gangsters, murder, revenge and love…mix in the dark underworld of 1907 Manhattan with the grit and determination of the Irish, and you have the makings of a gem of a book!

I really enjoyed this historical romantic thriller. We meet Caitlin, young, fearless and determined to find her sister's killer, and William Furey, a young gangster whose loyalty lies with his boss, also fatherly figure, Frank. Thrown together in their search for the truth, can these unlikely allies trust each other as their feelings begin to change, or is something deeper developing between them? Swipe to slide 2 for the blurb.

The dual POVs kept the pace steady, with new revelations that made me want to keep reading. I loved Caitlin and William's flawed, determined characters and the subtle shift in their feelings towards each other. Their interactions made me smile, while the gritty, atmospheric setting and Irish-American influences brought the story to life.

This was so much more than a gangster novel. It's an intriguing murder mystery that explores trust, loyalty, revenge and love, all woven into a compelling historical setting.

Thank you @johnstephenswriterguy @instabooktours @hotkeybooks for the advanced copy and for having me on this tour!

📚 Out tomorrow, 20 October 2026!
Profile Image for Ashley Brown.
66 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
October 13, 2026
I absolutely loved this book! I was so excited to read The Age of Fury because I've loved John Stephens's previous work, especially his work connected to Gilmore Girls, and this did not disappoint. Once I sat down to read, I could hardly put it down!

The pacing was fantastic, the suspense kept me on the edge of my seat, and the twists kept me guessing. Caitlin was a standout for me. I loved her fiery personality, her honesty, and her sharp wit. I related to her so much, and I have a feeling I'll be quoting some of her lines for a while! William Fury was another favorite, and I loved learning more about his backstory and watching his character develop.

The character development throughout the book was wonderful, and the setting was so vivid that I felt like I was right there in the gritty streets of early 1900s New York. Historical fiction isn't usually my go-to genre, but give me gangsters, crime, mystery, and a story this good, and I'm hooked!

An easy five stars from me. I highly recommend this one and would happily read more from John Stephens!

Thank you, Random House Children's Books and NetGalley for providing me with an advance copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Sandra.
182 reviews
August 2, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 I have never watched Gilmore Girls which John was a writer on and not read any of his other books so wasn’t sure what to expect with this book but I really enjoyed it. It was very fast paced and filled with very compelling characters. Caitlin is so fiery and determined it’s incredible, I wish I had had her tenacity at that age. There are numerous laugh out loud moments especially when she goes up against William Furey, whom she meets while looking for her sister’s killer. Their relationship is compelling from the start as they are brought together trying to find a killer. We see as they slowly integrate into 1907 New York City society, see the lies it is built on and find a secret that can bring them all down.
As mentioned earlier the book is very fast paced but I felt that it slowed a bit in the middle area and some bits felt a bit drawn out and not really needed. But I felt that the characters were so well done they were strong enough to keep me entertained and interested. You can really tell the author has done their research as you are completely immersed in both worlds of this book, high society and the immigrant communities at the lower end of the hierarchy. It was really well done I thought.
Overall a really good solid four and a half star read and if you enjoy stories of New York’s Gilded Age, criminal gangs or Irish communities, you will enjoy this. I would definitely recommend this book.

Thanks to Netgallery for a ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Tiffany.
74 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 18, 2026
Yes! Yes to everything. Every twist. Every almost figured it all out plot line. Yes!
It was almost like watching it as a movie, and I couldn’t turn away. To have a sibling who is willing to do whatever to find my killer. Caitlin you chameleon, butterfly, shapeshifter, you were my favorite. William, thank you for doing whatever felt necessary to your (the) cause. Such an honorable man amongst snakes.
Profile Image for Saundra Wright.
3,112 reviews11 followers
October 20, 2026
A great amount of the action in this novel is expressed through the thoughts of a seventeen year old Irish girl fresh off the boat in NYC. Her voice is authentic, alluring and utterly unique. It reads very quickly with the pace of the best thrillers. The plot is intriguing and complex. Be prepared to be swept away in excitement of the city in the late 1800s from the slums to the sumptuous.
758 reviews53 followers
Did Not Finish
October 4, 2026
Why the fuck are we still allowing men to write women? And then publishing them?

In no circumstance is someone calling their sister “my love” 🤢
Profile Image for Janine.
2,898 reviews42 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 18, 2026
Propulsive YA historical mystery - worthy of readers of all ages.

It’s 1907 and seventeen year old Caitlin Quinn arrives in New York with a letter from her sister, Mary, telling her of a “terrible decision.” Upon arrival Caitlin learns her sister is dead and she vows to find out more. Meanwhile William Furey, nineteen, is charged by gang leader, Frank Shannon, to quietly look into Mary’s death since the police aren’t having labeled Mary a prostitute. A chance encounter brings the two together and they join forces in finding a long list of suspects in New York’s criminal underworld to check into. To be sure the investigation is dangerous abounding in near misses and close calls but a romance starts to simmer.

The suspense of finding out what happened to Mary is good. This is helped by short chapters and letters that add lots of twists. The descriptions of the Gilded Age settings are authentic in detail - which I enjoyed. While there is a cynicism and darkness in the story, it’s not too heavy which is helped by humor in the telling. I liked Caitlin - she’s tough, driving, and will go up against the odds. William is nicely drawn - a character questioning who he is and who he wants to be.

This book is thematic in exploring contrasts between the worlds of the haves and have nots, in telling an immigrant story of ideals and disillusionment, and corruption in the police force prevents justice from being given. While the writing is more for younger readers, these themes can resonate with an adult reader as well.

My thanks to NetGalley and Knopf Books for Young Readers for allowing me access to this ARC.
Profile Image for William de_Rham.
Author 0 books99 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 12, 2026
“The Age of Fury” is a lively historical novel and murder mystery set in New York City in 1907. It stars Caitlin Quinn, a courageous, indomitable 17-year-old who crosses the Atlantic to rescue her twin sister, Mary, who left Ireland with a man she’d fallen in love with, but who is now in some sort of serious trouble.

Soon after arriving in Manhattan, Caitlin learns that Mary is dead, brutally murdered in an alley. Determined to avenge her twin, she hunts for the person(s) responsible throughout the city and a variety of classes, including its poor, its criminal element, and its wealthiest, most powerful citizenry. Along the way, she meets William Furey, right-hand henchman to one of New York’s most notorious crime bosses who is currently at war with another gang over control of the docks.

Author John Stephens has written a novel featuring compelling characters. I found Caitlin to be very enjoyable, especially since, despite whatever danger she might be in, she’s often laugh-out-loud funny, and more than a match for William Furey. Mr. Stephens also makes good use of a variety of period settings, including New York’s developing west-side docks, various Catholic institutions, and a stunningly opulent estate overlooking the Hudson.

While the book grabbed me at the very beginning, the second half’s plotting struck me as sometimes drawn out, convoluted, and even melodramatic, making the 480-page novel seem overlong by about 15-20%. However, I found the characters strong enough and entertaining enough to hold my interest. Mr. Stephens has been quite successful in creating characters readers can care about.

I was surprised to find that the promotional materials set the “reading age” at “14 years and up.” I suppose that’s because Caitlin and William are 17 and 19 respectively. Nevertheless, parents and educators of readers at the younger ages of the range may wish to know that the novel includes scenes of violence and a number of references to prostitution. There are, however, no graphic sex scenes.

All in all, I thought this a solid four-star read suitable for anyone who enjoys stories about New York during or just after “The Gilded Age,” its “robber-barons,” its Irish community, or its criminal gangs. Indeed, the novel reminded me of films like “Far and Away,” “Gangs of New York,” and even “The Road to Perdition” (even though that takes place in Depression-era Chicago).

"The Age of Fury" is scheduled to be published on October 20, 2026.

My thanks to NetGalley, author John Stephens, and publisher Knopf Books for Young Readers for providing me with a complimentary electronic ARC. All of the foregoing is my honest, independent opinion.
1,535 reviews
October 22, 2026
I debated a bit on how to rate my thoughts on this book. To be honest I waffled between 3 or 4 stars. But in the end, I did enjoy the book overall so I'm leaving it with the higher number. Taking place in Gilded Age New York, this book contains family dynamics (both blood and found), murder, gang territory machinations, bravery, treacherous secrets, extreme villains, corruption, greed, and lots and lots of determination especially on the part of the heroine seventeen-year-old Caitlin, an Irish girl who journeys to New York to find her runaway twin who sends a letter pleading for help. Yes, there's a lot going on, but I still felt the pacing at times was a bit uneven...sometimes too slow, sometimes speeded up. Our hero, William Furey, is a nineteen-year-old former street urchin-turned-enforcer for a gang who is infamous for his bloody "fury" and is often described as being something like a "berserker" character. Caitlin and William meet and work together to solve her twin's tragic murder.

The style of the writing is interesting for Caitlin's narrative as it's told through letters/inner dialogue with her murdered twin Mary. Caitlin is a foul-mouthed, irreverent young woman with a sense of humor that earned some chuckles from me. William is a stoically serious young man who is shaped by his devotion to his savior (Frank), the gang lord who rescued him from the street. Both of these characters come from gritty, harsh backgrounds and felt much older in their descriptions and life experiences than they were written, and I must admit that sort of threw me throughout the book. I would venture that this book should be marketed for a more adult audience for the language and violence...but that's just me.

The plotline was absorbing and took surprising (sometimes unbelievable) turns and kept me entertained. As I've mentioned there was a lot to cover, but while there was a lot to cover, I felt that the relationships between Caitlin and Mary and William and Frank were a key proponent in establishing our mains backgrounds, motivations and growth. There is an exciting denouement on board a luxury liner and a very satisfying and heartwarming ending which left me with a smile.

All in all, I found this an enjoyable read with just a couple of personal caveats.

My sincere thanks to the author, NetGalley and Random House Children's Books / Knopf Books for Young Readers for providing the free early arc of The Age of Fury for review. The opinions are strictly my own.
Profile Image for Cindy Huskey.
811 reviews79 followers
October 24, 2026
The Age of Fury surprised me. In the best possible way, naturally, because I do enjoy a book that manages to exceed my expectations without first requiring me to lower them to the basement.

description

Set in 1907 New York, this historical mystery delivers crooked deals, criminal empires, a missing twin, a murdered girl, and enough corruption to make you wonder if anyone in this city has an honest job. Caitlin Quinn arrives from Ireland searching for her missing sister, Mary, and finds herself entangled with William Furey, a notorious gangster with anger issues that could probably benefit from several years of therapy and a very long vacation.

Their unlikely alliance, the increasingly dangerous search for the truth, and the tension between them kept me invested. The mystery had enough twists and intrigue to hold my attention, and the atmosphere made the city feel like a place where trusting the wrong person could be a genuinely terrible career move. The relationship added another layer to the story without completely overshadowing the mystery, which I appreciated.

There is some coarse language, much of which is used to characterize the lower-class Irish characters. It fits the gritty atmosphere the author is creating, but it's worth knowing about if that's something that factors into your reading choices.

There were moments when the story leaned a little heavily into the drama, but honestly, when your plot involves gangsters, murder, family secrets, and a city built on lies, subtlety probably wasn't invited to the party.

Nevertheless, a compelling historical mystery with plenty of intrigue, a richly drawn setting, and characters who make questionable life choices for a living. If you enjoy historical fiction with crime, romance, and a healthy serving of danger, this one is worth picking up.

Many thanks to GetUnderlined and Knopf Books for Young Readers for this gifted copy.
Profile Image for Joanna.
514 reviews5 followers
October 20, 2026
I received this as an ARC in exchange for my honest review.

The Age of Fury had so many ingredients that should have worked perfectly for me — a missing twin, murder, gangsters, secrets and the dangerous underbelly of 1907 New York.

I really liked Caitlin’s determination to find out what happened to her twin, Mary, especially after travelling all the way from Ballykelly with very little to go on. Her search quickly throws her into a world of corruption, crime and people willing to do almost anything to keep their secrets buried.

William Furey was probably the character I found most intriguing. A dangerous gangster with plenty of his own demons, his unlikely partnership with Caitlin added another layer to the story, and I enjoyed watching the trust and attraction slowly develop between them.

Unfortunately, despite loving the premise, I struggled to fully connect with the story. There were moments that really pulled me in, but the pacing felt uneven and I found my attention wandering in places. I wanted to feel more invested in the mystery surrounding Mary and the relationship between Caitlin and William than I ultimately did.

That said, I really enjoyed the historical New York setting and the darker atmosphere. There’s plenty of danger, corruption and family secrets woven throughout, and I can definitely see this appealing to readers who love historical fiction with crime and romance mixed in.
Not quite the read I hoped it would be, but there was still plenty to appreciate.

2.5⭐ — atmospheric, dark and intriguing, just missing that extra something to completely hook me.
Profile Image for Linda Hutchinson.
1,933 reviews67 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 15, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐

The Age of Fury
Author: John Stephens
Source: NetGalley
Publication Date: October 20, 2026

RICH VS POOR
IRISH IMMIGRANTS
1907 NEW YORK
ROMANCE

Firstly, this book is being marketed as a Young Adult (YA) novel, which I strongly disagree with. The excessive violence depicted in this book is not suitable for my teenage grandchild to read.

Secondly, the narrative begins with the captivating and affectionate twin sisters, Caitlin and Mary, residing in Ireland. Their parents have passed away, leaving them with a modest farm in the Irish countryside that provides them with food and shelter. However, their lives take a dramatic turn when Mary decides to flee to New York City in pursuit of a wealthy man and a promising future. The premise that a wealthy, high-society neighbor in Ireland imparts the skills of a “pretend lady” to these girls is unconvincing. This is not a retelling of “My Fair Lady.”

Mary sends a letter to sister Caitlin in Ireland from the United States, asking her sister to join her in New York City to rescue her from an unspecified predicament. The story delves into the challenges faced by Mary, who becomes an example of a young girl with ambitious dreams that unravel upon her arrival in the United States, ultimately leading to her abandonment.

While the first 57% of the book is engaging, the subsequent chapters deteriorate into a series of unbelievable events. The language employed in the book is excessively vulgar. Although I am not easily offended by profanity, it is evident that the Irish society depicted in the novel lacks the affluence of the Gilded Age. Instead, it portrays impoverished orphan girls who subsist on potatoes and engage in slaughtering pigs until they become pretend ladies.

It could have been better.

@netgalley
@aaknopf
#theageoffury

I received a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own. Thank you to the publisher, Netgalley, and the author for the opportunity to read this novel.
Profile Image for Alina.
306 reviews5 followers
October 26, 2026
I'm so glad I got to read this book!

I absolutely adored the setting of the book (gritty New York with gangsters and murders and people fighting for power) and the way Caitlin shared a part of her story with us in letters.

A historical romantic thriller with a dual POV, Caitlin and William fight to figure out who murdered her sister and why. William doing so at his boss's instructions, he becomes even more involved when he meets Caitlin and discovers her fiery personality and how much of a badass she really is.

She does a perfect job of pretending to be her sister to catch her killer, even pretending to be a British lady.

I loved all the twists and turns we got in the book! I was so sad to see that her sister was murdered, but then the entire book plot's evolves around her murder and finding her killer :( Still sad about it though.

I loved how William slowly fell for her, even when he didn't realize he'd done so. Everything evolved so slowly, he was blindsided when someone basically told him that he's in love with her. I also loved how he had a soft spot for the abandoned children from the city, calling them his Sparrows, asking them for help just so he could also help them. Hiding it because he considered it a weakness. He was just so sweet. 🥹 And the paper violets that he got from that one kid and hiding them in his pocket? That scene broke me.

I was so happy with how things turned out at the end!!

Thank you John Stephensx, Insta Book Tours and Hot Key Books for the advanced copy and for having me on this tour!
Profile Image for Jennifer.
496 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 25, 2026
I really enjoyed this one. Historical fiction isn't always my go-to genre, but the combination of a murder mystery, gang rivalries, and 1907 New York completely pulled me in.

Caitlin was easy to root for from the very beginning. I loved how determined she was to find out what happened to her sister, and she had just enough humor to lighten some of the darker moments. William was probably my favorite character, though. His internal struggle made him feel much more than just your typical gangster.

The setting was one of the biggest highlights for me. It was gritty, atmospheric, and really brought New York to life. I could easily picture the streets, the docks, and the different worlds these characters were navigating.

The pacing did slow down a bit in the middle, and I think the story could have been a little shorter, but I never lost interest in finding out how everything would come together. Once things started picking up again, I was fully invested.

Overall, this was an entertaining historical mystery with memorable characters, plenty of suspense, and just enough romance mixed in. I'd definitely recommend it if you enjoy historical crime fiction, murder mysteries, and character-driven stories.

Thank you to NetGalley and Knopf Books for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
63 reviews
October 22, 2026
AN IRISH GIRL LOOKING FOR HER SISTER IN NEW YORK GETS SAVED TWICE BY LOCAL GANGSTER. - The Age of Fury by John Stephens. 4⭐

Caitlin receives a letter from her sister who ran away to New York. When she gets to New York she is saved by local gangster, William Furey. He then saves her life again when she is investigating what happened to her sister.
.
Neither one can solve the mystery without the other. William has gang turf wars going on and Caitlin has a side to her personality that William doesn't understand.
.
Set in New York in 1907, this book is so many things - a mystery, a romance and best of all a hilarious tale of the catholic church's intervention in their lives. The giant nun and the pirate eyed, hand clasping priest elicit the best responses from Irish Caitlin. This is an excellent YA book that all ages will enjoy.
.
Thank you to @johnstephenswriterguy @instabooktours and @hotkeybooks for an ARC of The Age of Fury. I loved it - an easy read that I struggled to put down in parts.
83 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 10, 2026
The Age of Fury is a very good read and kept me on the edge as I wanted to find out more about the whole story, especially about Caitlin's sister.
The characters are so well described and kept me entertained and engaged in the story. 
The FMC is so well portraited and is seen as very determined and fiery to find out the real truth and nothing would stop her to do just that.
I do believe that she is a bit too naive and trust people too easily, but she is also quick in making up for her mistakes.
The MMC is so full of suspense and you never know what he's going to do next. However, he is very committed in finding out the truth.
The book is fast paced with lots of turns, twists, suspense, laughter, love and so much more.
I really like the relationship formed between FMC and MMC and the ending is just great.
A very easy book to read and if you like suspense, historical fiction, crime, mystery then this book is for you.
Profile Image for Tarnavska Oleksandra.
75 reviews2 followers
October 29, 2026
Manhattan, 1907 — glittering ballrooms and Fifth Avenue luxury on one side, blood, poverty, and gangsters on the other.

I absolutely loved the atmosphere of this book! Caitlin Quinn arrives in New York from Ireland hoping to reunite with her twin sister, Mary, only to discover that she’s been murdered. When the police fail to give her the answers she needs, Caitlin joins forces with William Furey, a feared gangster with more honour than some of the city’s most respectable people.

I really enjoyed their dynamic: Caitlin’s determination and refusal to back down, paired with William’s dangerous nature and moral complexity. The contrast between high society and the darker side of New York made the story especially compelling.

The mystery kept me engaged, and the final twist genuinely surprised me. If you enjoy atmospheric historical mysteries, morally complex characters, and a dark glimpse into Gilded Age New York, this one is worth checking out!
Profile Image for ReneeReads.
1,868 reviews156 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 27, 2026
This book is being mis-marketed as YA in my opinion and I am having a hard time continuing reading.
In Chapter One, Caitlin is writing to her sister Mary, the year is 1907. Caitlin tells her sister in the letter ""To be honest, I don't see how it's any of your fucking business.". Did people speak like this in 1907? The use of profanity in books doesn't normally bother me, but if this is meant to be written in 1907, I would assume that different language would be used especially from a lady, especially in writing. Now, we are still in Chapter one and there is mention of men taking advantage of women. In Chapter Three, one of the characters says "I don't want some dead slut in my cab." Chapter Eight - "I'll fix that slut". I'm just not vibing with this book at all.

The use of language in this book is definitely an interesting choice and it's taking me out of the story. DNF at 15%
Profile Image for Jennifer.
37 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 24, 2026
The Age of Fury by John Stephens, a historical fiction novel about a young and spirited Irish woman, Caitlin, a notorious New York gangster and enforcer, William Furey, and their search to find Caitlin’s sister’s murderer. I enjoyed the setting: New York City, 1907. The reader is immersed in the poor slums of the orphaned lost boys and the docks, then transported to lavish dinner parties with champagne and chauffeurs. The author did a great job developing the main characters and revealing the mystery of a doomed love affair full of twists and ill-fated turns. I was engaged with the story from the beginning, and recommend it to fans of historical fiction, murder mysteries, and gritty main characters. 4 stars.

(Thank you to NetGalley for providing this book in exchange for an honest review.)
Profile Image for Kirsty Fowler.
316 reviews2 followers
October 13, 2026
I really enjoyed this historical fiction set between Ireland and New York. I particularly loved the dual POV from Caitlin and William, which gave the story two very different perspectives and made it easy to become invested in both of their journeys.

Neither character is perfect — they’re flawed, complicated and vulnerable — but I think that’s what made them so compelling. I found myself really rooting for them, even when they didn’t always make the best choices!

There are also some fantastic side characters… the kind you absolutely love to hate 😂

The author does a brilliant job of bringing both Ireland and New York to life through their descriptions. I could really picture the settings as the story unfolded, which added so much to the atmosphere.

A really enjoyable historical read, and I’d absolutely pick up another book by this author!
Profile Image for Paula.
1,360 reviews13 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
June 12, 2026
Caitlyn is 17 and living in her family home alone since her twin ran off with a man she was in love with to America. Caitlyn is heartbroken and misses her sister but she receives a letter saying that Mary is in trouble. Caitlyn gets to New York only to find that Mary has been murdered. She vows to find who killed her and avenge her death.

I loved the 1907 time period as well as the story. William Furey was a great character whose struggle with his identity was a challenge for him. Caitlyn's wit and humor was refreshing and brought some relief in dark places. I look forward to reading more of Stephens' works.

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for allowing me to read and review this book.
292 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 14, 2026
HIstorical Fiction-early 1900's
Caitlin arrives from Ireland desperate to save her twin sister, Mary. Caitlin discovers that Mary has been murdered and it becomes her quest to find her killer. Mob enforcer, William Fury, is ordered by his boss to investigate Mary's murder. The gang suspects her death is tied to an ongoing dockwar with a rival gang, the Gophers. It is on the streets that Caitlin and William meet and end up working together to find Mary's killer.
Awesome book! Lots of suspicious characters that keep you guessing "who dunnit". Great character development with both Caitlin and William plus an added romance between the two. Interesting 1900 era themes of gang violence, corruption in the police departments and immigration.
Profile Image for Liz.
373 reviews
October 26, 2026
John Stephens has such a talent for creating compelling characters and gripping storylines. The tension was consistent throughout the plot, the dialogue quick and often humorous, but never in a way that sacrificed substance. The historical setting was clearly well researched. And above all, I adored Caitlin as a character. She’s fierce and devoted and has her share of flaws and I really loved following her story. For her especially, this book gets five stars.

It was wonderful to have John Stephens’ writing in my life again, and I hope he writes many more books going forward. My only real criticism of The Age of Fury is that it’s not as good as The Books of Beginning trilogy, but that’s only because that series is incredible and shaped me in so many ways, so nothing can compare.
Profile Image for mrsbookburnee Niamh Burnett.
1,318 reviews29 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 18, 2026
Oh Caitlin is my sort of character, strong, passionate and some fantastic one liners, I was completely rooting for her and fell in love with her bluntness and inner dialogue . Whilst I wasn’t that interested in their romance storyline I really liked the character development of her and Williams.

I also really enjoyed the era that the book was set in and the author kept me engaged through his descriptions of the locations and also the use of letters throughout.

I will definitely be re-reading this as it has so much going on and so many intriguing characters, that I feel that it is one of those reads where you get something different with each read.

.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 43 reviews