What do you think?
Rate this book
Rosato & DiNunzio #3
Corrupted
Bennie Rosato, the founder of the Rosato & DiNunzio law firm, hides her big heart beneath her tough-as-nails exterior and she doesn’t like to fail. Now, a case from her past shows her how differently things might have turned out. Thirteen years ago, Bennie Rosato took on Jason Lefkavick, a twelve-year-old boy who was sent to a juvenile detention center after fighting a class bully. Bennie couldn’t free Jason, and to this day it’s the case that haunts her.
Jason has grown up in and out of juvenile prison, and his adulthood hasn’t been any easier. Bennie no longer represents those accused of murder, but when Jason is indicted for killing the same bully he fought with as a kid, she sees no choice but to represent him. She doesn’t know whether or not to believe his claims of innocence, but she knows she owes him for past failures―of the law, of the juvenile justice system, and of herself. Forced to relive the darkest period of her life, Bennie will do everything in her power to get the truth and justice.
Jason has grown up in and out of juvenile prison, and his adulthood hasn’t been any easier. Bennie no longer represents those accused of murder, but when Jason is indicted for killing the same bully he fought with as a kid, she sees no choice but to represent him. She doesn’t know whether or not to believe his claims of innocence, but she knows she owes him for past failures―of the law, of the juvenile justice system, and of herself. Forced to relive the darkest period of her life, Bennie will do everything in her power to get the truth and justice.
433 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 9, 2015
1688 people are currently reading
7851 people want to read
About the author
Lisa Scottoline
137 books15.6k followersLisa Scottoline is a #1 bestselling and Edgar award-winning author of 33 novels. Her books are book-club favorites, and Lisa and her daughter Francesca Serritella have hosted an annual Big Book Club Party for over a thousand readers at her Pennsylvania farm, for the past twelve years. Lisa has served as President of Mystery Writers of America, and her reviews of fiction and non-fiction have appeared in The New York Times, The Washington Post and The Philadelphia Inquirer. She also writes a weekly column with her daughter for the Philadelphia Inquirer entitled Chick Wit, a witty take on life from a woman’s perspective, which have been collected in a bestselling series of humorous memoirs. Lisa graduated magna cum laude in three years from the University of Pennsylvania, with a B.A. in English, and cum laude from the University of Pennsylvania Law School, where she taught Justice and Fiction. Lisa has over 30 million copies of her books in print and is published in over 35 countries. She lives in the Philadelphia area with an array of disobedient pets and wouldn’t have it any other way.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,337 reviews
March 11, 2017
Legal thriller featuring Bennie Rosato, original partner of her law firm Rosato & DiNunzio. A character that hasn't always been front and center.
Bennie takes on a murder case involving a young man, Jason Leftavick. Bennie defended Jason 13 years ago, when he was a pre-teen. She never had the chance to see it through, after being yanked off the case. Now she has a second chance. Bennie felt she never got justice for the first time around. Now it’s personal.
Bennie has always been portrayed as a very tough, no nonsense lawyer. This book shows her softer more vulnerable side. A look behind the wall she built around herself.
A Great mix of courtroom action and personal character development. If you are a fan of the series then you will love this one.
A nice light read to break up my string of thrillers.
Bennie takes on a murder case involving a young man, Jason Leftavick. Bennie defended Jason 13 years ago, when he was a pre-teen. She never had the chance to see it through, after being yanked off the case. Now she has a second chance. Bennie felt she never got justice for the first time around. Now it’s personal.
Bennie has always been portrayed as a very tough, no nonsense lawyer. This book shows her softer more vulnerable side. A look behind the wall she built around herself.
A Great mix of courtroom action and personal character development. If you are a fan of the series then you will love this one.
A nice light read to break up my string of thrillers.
October 18, 2021
In this 3rd book in the 'Rosato and DiNunzio' series, lawyer Bennie Rosato defends a young man she tried to help when he was a child in juvie. The book can be read as a standalone.
*****
Philadelphia attorney Bennie Rosato first met Jason Lefkavick thirteen years ago, when he was a sweet 12-year-old boy. Jason had lashed out at a middle school bully named Richie Grusini, who was calling Jason's deceased mother names. The resulting fight landed both boys in juvenile hall, and Jason was sentenced to several months in juvie jail.
Jason's father Matthew hired Bennie to try to get Jason out sooner.
Bennie discovered that Jason and his dad were manipulated into giving up Jason's right to consult an attorney before he pled guilty. Thus Bennie entered an appeal for Jason, which appeared likely to succeed. However, it would take longer than Bennie had hoped.
In the meantime Bennie started dating the bully's uncle, a good-looking state trooper named Declan Mitchell. Bennie and Declan were soon smitten with one another, and Bennie had to give up Jason's case. As a result, Jason's appeal was aborted and - after serving his sentence - Jason emerged from juvie angry and disillusioned. In the end, Jason's entire childhood was blighted.
A subsequent exposé revealed corruption among juvenile court judges. Some of them - including Jason's - were 'on the payroll' of private detention facilities, and were sentencing kids to jail for the tiniest infractions. Unfortunately, this scandal broke too late to help young Jason.
Jump to the present and Jason, now a 25-year-old man, is accused of murdering his old enemy Richie Grusini. There's a LOT of evidence against Jason, but he claims he was framed. So Bennie, who feels like she failed Jason when he was a kid, takes the case. Bennie gets some assistance from the employees of her law firm, Rosato and DeNunuzio, especially the firm's investigator Lou.
The fact that Bennie is representing Jason upsets Richie's uncle Declan, who's now a lawyer. Declan doesn't want Bennie to use her formidable skills to get Jason off.
So - though Declan hasn't seen Bennie in over a decade - he comes to her house and implores her to drop the case. Of course Bennie refuses, despite the fact she still has feelings for Declan. (In my opinion Bennie is way too soppy about Declan and mentions his very handsome face a few too many times. 🙄)
Jason's case goes to court, and the jousting between Bennie and the prosecuting attorney is a highlight of the book. Though Jason seems reluctant to participate in his own defense, the truth eventually comes out.
In the course of the story we learn a bit about Bennie's past, and see more of her personality - which is tough, but caring and concerned. The book also points up an inherent problem of private prisons, which garner the most profit from holding the maximum number of prisoners - a factor that could put pressure on the justice system.
I think the dual timelines of the story work well, and I'd recommend the book to fans of legal mysteries.
You can follow my reviews at https://reviewsbybarbsaffer.blogspot....
October 15, 2022
“Nobody comes out of prison better than they went in”
In 2008, the breaking US story of the Kids-for-Cash scandal shocked the world. Two corrupt Pennsylvania judges had unjustly stolen the childhoods and destroyed the futures of thousands of minors by unjustly incarcerating them in a harsh juvenile prison system for their own enrichment. Lisa Scottoline has brilliantly riffed off this real-life criminal judicial travesty and ugly scandal by creating the story of Jason Lefkavick, a 12 year old boy tossed into the juvie slammer under the pretense of a zero tolerance policy for the outrageous offense of protecting himself from a bully and fighting at school.
CORRUPTED is the heartbreaking and completely gripping legal procedural tale, of Benny Rosato’s failure to obtain the release of a twelve year old Lefkavick from an unjust 60 day sentence for fighting, despite her reputation as one of Philadelphia’s top lawyers. The story morphs into an enthralling romance and courtroom drama in which Rosato is determined to defend an adult Lefkavick on the charge of first degree murder of the thug with whom he had fought in school so many years ago. It was clear that the simmering feud between the two men had never cooled and had survived into adulthood. The police were convinced that the hatred between these two men had boiled over into an argument, a barroom shove, an alley fight, and, ultimately, a murder. Rosato thought otherwise and was determined to redeem her earlier failure.
The story is brilliantly told. The pacing, while much slower than a typical thriller, is steady, convincing and compelling. Readers will find themselves invested in the characters, rooting or booing for the good guys or the bad guys. Scottoline’s story does not leave the reader the option of sitting passively on the sideline simply watching the story unfold. The romance is an integral, critical part of the overall plot and is as convincing as the reality of the legal issues. Scottoline never allows the romance to cross the line into saccharine melodrama.
Easy to recommend. Well done, Ms Scottline. I’ll definitely be looking for more novels in the Rosato and DiNunzio series.
Paul Weiss
In 2008, the breaking US story of the Kids-for-Cash scandal shocked the world. Two corrupt Pennsylvania judges had unjustly stolen the childhoods and destroyed the futures of thousands of minors by unjustly incarcerating them in a harsh juvenile prison system for their own enrichment. Lisa Scottoline has brilliantly riffed off this real-life criminal judicial travesty and ugly scandal by creating the story of Jason Lefkavick, a 12 year old boy tossed into the juvie slammer under the pretense of a zero tolerance policy for the outrageous offense of protecting himself from a bully and fighting at school.
CORRUPTED is the heartbreaking and completely gripping legal procedural tale, of Benny Rosato’s failure to obtain the release of a twelve year old Lefkavick from an unjust 60 day sentence for fighting, despite her reputation as one of Philadelphia’s top lawyers. The story morphs into an enthralling romance and courtroom drama in which Rosato is determined to defend an adult Lefkavick on the charge of first degree murder of the thug with whom he had fought in school so many years ago. It was clear that the simmering feud between the two men had never cooled and had survived into adulthood. The police were convinced that the hatred between these two men had boiled over into an argument, a barroom shove, an alley fight, and, ultimately, a murder. Rosato thought otherwise and was determined to redeem her earlier failure.
The story is brilliantly told. The pacing, while much slower than a typical thriller, is steady, convincing and compelling. Readers will find themselves invested in the characters, rooting or booing for the good guys or the bad guys. Scottoline’s story does not leave the reader the option of sitting passively on the sideline simply watching the story unfold. The romance is an integral, critical part of the overall plot and is as convincing as the reality of the legal issues. Scottoline never allows the romance to cross the line into saccharine melodrama.
Easy to recommend. Well done, Ms Scottline. I’ll definitely be looking for more novels in the Rosato and DiNunzio series.
Paul Weiss
August 16, 2016
3.5 stars. By all rights, I should be giving Corrupted a lower rating because it's full of flaws -- some of them pretty big. But it seems more fair to rate the book based on how fast it had me flipping pages than based on my intellectual analysis of its flaws. I gather Corrupted is book 3 of a mystery series featuring a law firm based in Philadelphia. It's my first read in the series, but there was no issue with jumping in at #3. Corrupted focuses on a murder trial that Bennie takes on for a client she had represented 13 years earlier when he was 12 years old and detained in a youth detention centre after a middle school fight. The book gives us the lengthy back story, and then jumps forward to the murder trial where the story becomes a full out courtroom drama. The flaws? Parts one and two don't mesh very well in terms of style and focus. There is a love interest that is central to the book but that had me rolling my eyes at its silliness. And the ending amounted to an out of the blue hard to believe resolution. So why did I keep flipping the pages? There's a background political issue that's at the centre of the first part that I found really interesting. Except for the end, Scottoline did a great job presenting the dynamics in the courtroom. And I liked Bennie and her dedication to her work and clients. On balance, I liked it enough to have me want to read the next one on the series. Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for giving me access to an advance copy -- although I ended up reading it well after publication.
November 17, 2015
Corrupted, the 3rd book in Lisa Scottoline’s Rosato & DiNuzio Series is a suspenseful and riveting story of corruption, abuse of power and how the court system can be manipulated to making innocent people suffer a lot of heartache and unfairness.
Attorney Bennie Rosato, one of the partners receives a call for help from Jason Leftavik, someone she had tried to help thirteen years before, when he was unfairly sentenced to juvenile detention. She has always felt guilty that she did not do enough when he was twelve years ago.
Jason has been charged with murdering his long time enemy…a bully who had made Jason’s life a misery all those years ago. He maintains his innocence and believes that he has been framed for the murder.
The story switches between the present and the time, thirteen years ago, when she first met Jason.
This is an emotional and sad story of a boy whose life was forever changed when he was sent to juvenile prison.
It’s also a story of a woman who has carried the guilt of not doing enough for the young boy and who is now determined to not giving up on him.
As Bernie begins looking into Jason’s life, she discovers that there’s more to the murder that he’s suppose to have done.
Her past haunts her….the man she had fallen in love with who had left her in a situation that she has never been able to overcome, is now back and not to get together again with her but in fact against everything she believes in.
What I most liked about this story was the courtroom scenes. Bennie shines!
She’s smart, quick-witted and not scared to cross the boundary line if it means it will save her client’s life. She’s also such a warm and caring person.
I found her such a fascinating and likeable character.
The secondary characters are interesting and particularly liked the camaraderie and work relationship she has with her partners and staff.
The one thing that got to me…..the fact that the man from her past, who had given Bennie up without a good enough reason is suddenly back, still giving her grieve and when the truth about Jason’s case is revealed…..he suddenly wants to be back in her life!!! Really! Grovel a bit longer!!!!
Corrupted is a moving, touching and affecting story and a look into the courtroom procedures and all its laws and procedures.
Attorney Bennie Rosato, one of the partners receives a call for help from Jason Leftavik, someone she had tried to help thirteen years before, when he was unfairly sentenced to juvenile detention. She has always felt guilty that she did not do enough when he was twelve years ago.
Jason has been charged with murdering his long time enemy…a bully who had made Jason’s life a misery all those years ago. He maintains his innocence and believes that he has been framed for the murder.
The story switches between the present and the time, thirteen years ago, when she first met Jason.
This is an emotional and sad story of a boy whose life was forever changed when he was sent to juvenile prison.
It’s also a story of a woman who has carried the guilt of not doing enough for the young boy and who is now determined to not giving up on him.
As Bernie begins looking into Jason’s life, she discovers that there’s more to the murder that he’s suppose to have done.
Her past haunts her….the man she had fallen in love with who had left her in a situation that she has never been able to overcome, is now back and not to get together again with her but in fact against everything she believes in.
What I most liked about this story was the courtroom scenes. Bennie shines!
She’s smart, quick-witted and not scared to cross the boundary line if it means it will save her client’s life. She’s also such a warm and caring person.
I found her such a fascinating and likeable character.
The secondary characters are interesting and particularly liked the camaraderie and work relationship she has with her partners and staff.
The one thing that got to me…..the fact that the man from her past, who had given Bennie up without a good enough reason is suddenly back, still giving her grieve and when the truth about Jason’s case is revealed…..he suddenly wants to be back in her life!!! Really! Grovel a bit longer!!!!
Corrupted is a moving, touching and affecting story and a look into the courtroom procedures and all its laws and procedures.
August 26, 2025
Lisa Scottoline outdid herself with Corrupted.
It is always extra special for me to read Rosato & DiNunzio books because they are based in my native city of Philadelphia. This episode was particularly nostalgic for me since I also worked many of the very same streets mentioned as an older adults in-home social worker. Side note: Everything Scottoline refers to in Philadelphia, streets, restaurants, etc... are real.
Bennie Rosato (founder of the Rosato & DiNunzio Law Firm) is terrific in this episode. I always enjoy it when the storyline revolves around her, because she is such a tough, intelligent, spunky, yet also (secretly/undercover) caring and compassionate person. Bennie is not to be outdone in the courtroom. I'd want her as a defense attorney because guilty or not, I have faith she would get me acquitted.
The courtroom scene at the end was riveting and one of the most moving I have experienced thus far in the series.
It is always extra special for me to read Rosato & DiNunzio books because they are based in my native city of Philadelphia. This episode was particularly nostalgic for me since I also worked many of the very same streets mentioned as an older adults in-home social worker. Side note: Everything Scottoline refers to in Philadelphia, streets, restaurants, etc... are real.
Bennie Rosato (founder of the Rosato & DiNunzio Law Firm) is terrific in this episode. I always enjoy it when the storyline revolves around her, because she is such a tough, intelligent, spunky, yet also (secretly/undercover) caring and compassionate person. Bennie is not to be outdone in the courtroom. I'd want her as a defense attorney because guilty or not, I have faith she would get me acquitted.
The courtroom scene at the end was riveting and one of the most moving I have experienced thus far in the series.
January 30, 2019
This review can also be found at Carole's Random Life in Books.
This was really good! I have had this book for a long time and I have to say that right now I am kicking myself for not picking it up sooner. I was totally sucked into the story and had a hard time setting it aside once I got going. I think that one of the reasons that I hesitated for so long is because it is the third book in the series and I wasn't sure that it would work out of order but it works perfectly as a stand-alone novel. I am so glad that I finally decided to give this book a try.
This book covers two different cases at different points in time that share the same cast of characters. Thirteen years ago, Bennie represented Jason who was twelve years old at the time. Jason was sent to juvenile detention over a relatively minor incident where he stood up to a bully in the school cafeteria. The punishment of 90 days in juvenile detention seemed quite harsh for such a young child and Bennie worked hard to get him released. Unfortunately, she was pulled off the case by Jason's father because of a personal relationship. The current case has Bennie defending Jason who is being charged with murdering the same bully from all those years ago.
I liked how different the two cases were in this book and thought that they were both equally interesting. I really enjoyed the fact that this book really focused on all of the legal maneuvers. I found all of the motions and appeals to be very interesting in the way it was presented. I also liked getting the chance to learn Bennie's thought process during the trial as she made decisions to object and question witnesses.
I did like the characters in this book. Bennie is incredibly competent as a lawyer and there was never a doubt in my mind that she would always do what was in her client's best interest. She does have a romantic relationship in this story and I think that seeing her in a more vulnerable situation really helped to make her feel authentic. It was interesting to see the contrast between Jason as a child to the man being tried for murder.
I thought that Kate Burton did a fantastic job with the narration of this book. She just pulled me into the story and held my attention. I think that she did a wonderful job with all of the character voices and brought a lot of emotion into the story anytime it was warranted. I believe that this is the first time that I have had the chance to listen to Kate Burton's work but I plan to look for her in the future.
I would recommend this book to others. I thought that this was a well done legal thriller that kept me guessing. This was quite the page-turner in the end and I cannot wait to read more from Lisa Scottoline very soon.
I received a digital review copy of this book from St. Martin's Press via NetGalley and borrowed a copy of the audiobook from my local library.
Initial Thoughts
I thought that this book was very well done. There are really two cases that are detailed in the book. The first case happens when Bennie's client is a middle school age child and the second case occurs about 13 years later when the same client is an adult. I liked that this book stayed pretty focused on the court proceeding and rationale behind the lawyer's moves. There is a romance that comes into play but the main focus is on the cases. The audiobook narration was easy to listen to and added to my enjoyment of the novel.
This was really good! I have had this book for a long time and I have to say that right now I am kicking myself for not picking it up sooner. I was totally sucked into the story and had a hard time setting it aside once I got going. I think that one of the reasons that I hesitated for so long is because it is the third book in the series and I wasn't sure that it would work out of order but it works perfectly as a stand-alone novel. I am so glad that I finally decided to give this book a try.
This book covers two different cases at different points in time that share the same cast of characters. Thirteen years ago, Bennie represented Jason who was twelve years old at the time. Jason was sent to juvenile detention over a relatively minor incident where he stood up to a bully in the school cafeteria. The punishment of 90 days in juvenile detention seemed quite harsh for such a young child and Bennie worked hard to get him released. Unfortunately, she was pulled off the case by Jason's father because of a personal relationship. The current case has Bennie defending Jason who is being charged with murdering the same bully from all those years ago.
I liked how different the two cases were in this book and thought that they were both equally interesting. I really enjoyed the fact that this book really focused on all of the legal maneuvers. I found all of the motions and appeals to be very interesting in the way it was presented. I also liked getting the chance to learn Bennie's thought process during the trial as she made decisions to object and question witnesses.
I did like the characters in this book. Bennie is incredibly competent as a lawyer and there was never a doubt in my mind that she would always do what was in her client's best interest. She does have a romantic relationship in this story and I think that seeing her in a more vulnerable situation really helped to make her feel authentic. It was interesting to see the contrast between Jason as a child to the man being tried for murder.
I thought that Kate Burton did a fantastic job with the narration of this book. She just pulled me into the story and held my attention. I think that she did a wonderful job with all of the character voices and brought a lot of emotion into the story anytime it was warranted. I believe that this is the first time that I have had the chance to listen to Kate Burton's work but I plan to look for her in the future.
I would recommend this book to others. I thought that this was a well done legal thriller that kept me guessing. This was quite the page-turner in the end and I cannot wait to read more from Lisa Scottoline very soon.
I received a digital review copy of this book from St. Martin's Press via NetGalley and borrowed a copy of the audiobook from my local library.
Initial Thoughts
I thought that this book was very well done. There are really two cases that are detailed in the book. The first case happens when Bennie's client is a middle school age child and the second case occurs about 13 years later when the same client is an adult. I liked that this book stayed pretty focused on the court proceeding and rationale behind the lawyer's moves. There is a romance that comes into play but the main focus is on the cases. The audiobook narration was easy to listen to and added to my enjoyment of the novel.
July 31, 2017
This captivating tale was inspired by the tragic events of the Kids-for-Cash scandal of 2008. At the heart, two corrupt Pennsylvania judges presided over juvenile hearings. Together, they conspired to adjudicate boys to a for-profit detention facility for monetary gain. Over the course of several years, literally, thousands of children were unjustly incarcerated for minor offenses. Their childhoods, their dreams - stolen. The author marvelously, delivered an action-packed, well-written narrative that held me captive to the print.
Jason Lefkavick, age twelve, was by all accounts, a timid, good-natured and friendly boy who wouldn't harm a fly. One day in the school cafeteria he pushed another student after being cruelly provoked. He'd been bullied by this young thug throughout grade school - Richie Grusuni. For his actions, Jason stood before Judge Ciavarella and was unjustly sentenced to serve ninety days in juvenile hall. His punishment had far exceeded the nature of his offense. At worst, he might have received suspension from school. Richie was also sent to juvie, though, with a lesser sentence - sixty days. Still, an exorbitant punishment. Way too long.
Jason's father contacted one of Philly's top lawyer's, Benny Rosato. No introduction was needed here. A stellar reputation preceded her. He knew his son did not deserve to be in lockup and feared for his safety. Much of the inmate population were older, bigger and had committed far worse offenses. He wanted only the best representation for his son and felt comfort knowing that his son's fate rested in the trusted hands of Ms. Rosato. So he believed.
After several futile attempts, Benny was unsuccessful in her bid to get Jason released even though she had Constitutional Law on her side. The judge refused to waiver from his decision. With Christmas just around the corner, there he was to remain with no release in sight. He was at the mercy of older kids and bullies who never gave him a moment's peace. His time there had been a living hell. It would ultimately change his life forever.
Thirteen years later Jason and Richie's paths collided once again. Their hatred for each other had not diminished over time. One fateful night they confronted each other. Push turned to shove. Regrettably, It was finally time for a showdown. The sorrowful outcome however, could not have been predicted.
Once again, Jason found himself in need of legal representation. Having learned of Jason's troubles,
Benny was quick to volunteer her services. She was doggedly determined not to let him down again. Failure was not an option.
A dramatic courtroom battle ensued. Benny was in her element, however, this time, the cards had been stacked against her, actually, the defendant. Evidence presented in court against her client had been overwhelming. She was embroiled in a losing battle with a disastrous outcome looming just ahead.
As a last ditch effort, Jason took the the stand. This was Benny's "Hail Mary". It hadn't gone well. In fact, it was a disaster. Just when it seemed his conviction was a certainty, an unpredictable, last-minute twist knocked me off my chair. I was stunned. It was an ending that shook me to the core. As you probably already surmised, I had enjoyed this read from beginning to a great end. A story well told.
Jason Lefkavick, age twelve, was by all accounts, a timid, good-natured and friendly boy who wouldn't harm a fly. One day in the school cafeteria he pushed another student after being cruelly provoked. He'd been bullied by this young thug throughout grade school - Richie Grusuni. For his actions, Jason stood before Judge Ciavarella and was unjustly sentenced to serve ninety days in juvenile hall. His punishment had far exceeded the nature of his offense. At worst, he might have received suspension from school. Richie was also sent to juvie, though, with a lesser sentence - sixty days. Still, an exorbitant punishment. Way too long.
Jason's father contacted one of Philly's top lawyer's, Benny Rosato. No introduction was needed here. A stellar reputation preceded her. He knew his son did not deserve to be in lockup and feared for his safety. Much of the inmate population were older, bigger and had committed far worse offenses. He wanted only the best representation for his son and felt comfort knowing that his son's fate rested in the trusted hands of Ms. Rosato. So he believed.
After several futile attempts, Benny was unsuccessful in her bid to get Jason released even though she had Constitutional Law on her side. The judge refused to waiver from his decision. With Christmas just around the corner, there he was to remain with no release in sight. He was at the mercy of older kids and bullies who never gave him a moment's peace. His time there had been a living hell. It would ultimately change his life forever.
Thirteen years later Jason and Richie's paths collided once again. Their hatred for each other had not diminished over time. One fateful night they confronted each other. Push turned to shove. Regrettably, It was finally time for a showdown. The sorrowful outcome however, could not have been predicted.
Once again, Jason found himself in need of legal representation. Having learned of Jason's troubles,
Benny was quick to volunteer her services. She was doggedly determined not to let him down again. Failure was not an option.
A dramatic courtroom battle ensued. Benny was in her element, however, this time, the cards had been stacked against her, actually, the defendant. Evidence presented in court against her client had been overwhelming. She was embroiled in a losing battle with a disastrous outcome looming just ahead.
As a last ditch effort, Jason took the the stand. This was Benny's "Hail Mary". It hadn't gone well. In fact, it was a disaster. Just when it seemed his conviction was a certainty, an unpredictable, last-minute twist knocked me off my chair. I was stunned. It was an ending that shook me to the core. As you probably already surmised, I had enjoyed this read from beginning to a great end. A story well told.
November 27, 2015
I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
I have listened to a number of Ms. Scottoline’s books and really most enjoyed her standalone book, “Every Fifteen Minutes”. I was looking forward to this book to see what this series was all about, I’ve read such rave reviews.
Beginning the book we are in the present time, Bennie Rosato receives a call from a former client who is now facing a murder charge. Fifteen years ago Ms. Rosato represented Jason as a 12 year old who was forced to spend time in a juvenile facility for a fight at school, mainly due to the school’s No Tolerance policy and a corrupt judge at the time. She has never forgiven herself for not being able to get him released from that detention facility.
We are sent back in time to the story of the young Bennie and the juvenile Jason. While at first I enjoyed this part of the book I found that it was very drawn out. There is a romantic element which I enjoyed as it brought out Bennie’s very warm, human side. But after so many pages of the description of back and forth etc between the lawyer and the justice system I grew tired of it. I was very happy when it switched to present time and the murder charge against Jason.
I enjoyed the second half a lot more. Jason, found in an alley with a dead man (the very bully that he was incarcerated for having a fight with at age 12), he is found with the bloody knife in his hand. Jason who swears innocence will not plead down. A very experienced proficient lawyer now, it’s great to “watch and listen” to Bennie defend her client and fight it out with the opponents. This part of the book seemed to move a lot quicker for me.
I would recommend this book to those who like courtroom drama that is well written with great characters.
I have listened to a number of Ms. Scottoline’s books and really most enjoyed her standalone book, “Every Fifteen Minutes”. I was looking forward to this book to see what this series was all about, I’ve read such rave reviews.
Beginning the book we are in the present time, Bennie Rosato receives a call from a former client who is now facing a murder charge. Fifteen years ago Ms. Rosato represented Jason as a 12 year old who was forced to spend time in a juvenile facility for a fight at school, mainly due to the school’s No Tolerance policy and a corrupt judge at the time. She has never forgiven herself for not being able to get him released from that detention facility.
We are sent back in time to the story of the young Bennie and the juvenile Jason. While at first I enjoyed this part of the book I found that it was very drawn out. There is a romantic element which I enjoyed as it brought out Bennie’s very warm, human side. But after so many pages of the description of back and forth etc between the lawyer and the justice system I grew tired of it. I was very happy when it switched to present time and the murder charge against Jason.
I enjoyed the second half a lot more. Jason, found in an alley with a dead man (the very bully that he was incarcerated for having a fight with at age 12), he is found with the bloody knife in his hand. Jason who swears innocence will not plead down. A very experienced proficient lawyer now, it’s great to “watch and listen” to Bennie defend her client and fight it out with the opponents. This part of the book seemed to move a lot quicker for me.
I would recommend this book to those who like courtroom drama that is well written with great characters.
June 7, 2023
Lisa Scottoline continues developing the spin-off Rosato and DiNunzio series, providing the reader with stunning legal thrillers that will keep everyone thinking. While the law can sometimes be straightforward, Scottoline knows how to bend things and create unique perspectives for all to enjoy. Bennie Rosato is known in the Philadelphia legal community as being a tough brawler, inside the courtroom and while defending her clients. However, a case from her past, when Bennie sought to defend a juvenile in rural Pennsylvania, impacted her a great deal, especially when justice was not able to prevail. Now, when her client, a full grown adult, has been accused of murdering his life-long enemy, Bennie is happy to return to help and hopes to bring justice to a case where no one is giving the defendant a chance. Bennie has made an impact before, but this will take more than all she has to give, as she tries to correct a wrong and prove her worth to someone who has all but given up on her. Scottoline does a stunning job with these parallel cases and keeps the reader enthralled until the final pages.
Bennie Rosato has been a successful trial attorney in Philadelphia for years, having founded Rosato & DiNunzio and watched it rise to glory. However, her rough exterior hides a softer side, particularly when outcomes to those who cannot defend themselves. A case crosses her desk that has her remembering a time thirteen years ago when she saw justice fail a young boy. Jason Leftavick was not yet a teenager when he was sent away to a juvenile detention centre for fighting the local bully. Working to forge new law in Pennsylvania, Bennie was not able to get a rural community to see the error of its way and Jason was left to suffer until his sentence ended, leaving him defeated. Bennie did, however, forge a close relationship with the bully’s uncle, believing that it was the state that had messed three both up, even though Jason’s family could not see things that same way.
Now, Jason has been arrested for killing that same bully after a barroom incident. Jason is twenty-five and yet still holds onto the animosity that he had as a youth. Bennie wants nothing more than to redeem herself and show the state that they made a horrible mistake all while ensuring her client’s pleas of self-defence do not fall on deaf ears.
Feeling guilt to represent him, Bennie cannot be sure that Jason is innocent, but she will do everything she can to ensure he gets a fair trial. When evidence clouds the truth, Bennie will have to clear her own clarity for the jury, in hopes of having them see that Jason is truly a good person who has been dealt a horrible hand. Scottoline offers up a wonderful story that touches the series fan, particularly when they learn of some secrets Bennie has been keeping for over a decade.
My discovery of Lisa Scottoline’s series led to a great binge reading experience that is ongoing. I cannot get my fill of these books, filled with great legal stories and populated with stunning characters. While the book returns to one of its core protagonists, the reader is able to take much away about Bennie Rosato and much of her untold past. The foundation of the novel remains its strong narrative, but this helps prepare the reader for two time periods and an in-depth look at Bennie’s life, her love, and how deeply she cherishes justice within the law. Plot points emerge and help the reader to discover wonderful aspects of the series not touched upon before, but it is the sentimental moments surrounding Bennie and her darkest hours that really had me pushing forward to learn even more. I cannot wait to see what is to come with the next novel, only hoping that I will be able to express it as well in my ongoing reviews.
Kudos, Madam Scottoline, for a definite thinker with this one.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
Bennie Rosato has been a successful trial attorney in Philadelphia for years, having founded Rosato & DiNunzio and watched it rise to glory. However, her rough exterior hides a softer side, particularly when outcomes to those who cannot defend themselves. A case crosses her desk that has her remembering a time thirteen years ago when she saw justice fail a young boy. Jason Leftavick was not yet a teenager when he was sent away to a juvenile detention centre for fighting the local bully. Working to forge new law in Pennsylvania, Bennie was not able to get a rural community to see the error of its way and Jason was left to suffer until his sentence ended, leaving him defeated. Bennie did, however, forge a close relationship with the bully’s uncle, believing that it was the state that had messed three both up, even though Jason’s family could not see things that same way.
Now, Jason has been arrested for killing that same bully after a barroom incident. Jason is twenty-five and yet still holds onto the animosity that he had as a youth. Bennie wants nothing more than to redeem herself and show the state that they made a horrible mistake all while ensuring her client’s pleas of self-defence do not fall on deaf ears.
Feeling guilt to represent him, Bennie cannot be sure that Jason is innocent, but she will do everything she can to ensure he gets a fair trial. When evidence clouds the truth, Bennie will have to clear her own clarity for the jury, in hopes of having them see that Jason is truly a good person who has been dealt a horrible hand. Scottoline offers up a wonderful story that touches the series fan, particularly when they learn of some secrets Bennie has been keeping for over a decade.
My discovery of Lisa Scottoline’s series led to a great binge reading experience that is ongoing. I cannot get my fill of these books, filled with great legal stories and populated with stunning characters. While the book returns to one of its core protagonists, the reader is able to take much away about Bennie Rosato and much of her untold past. The foundation of the novel remains its strong narrative, but this helps prepare the reader for two time periods and an in-depth look at Bennie’s life, her love, and how deeply she cherishes justice within the law. Plot points emerge and help the reader to discover wonderful aspects of the series not touched upon before, but it is the sentimental moments surrounding Bennie and her darkest hours that really had me pushing forward to learn even more. I cannot wait to see what is to come with the next novel, only hoping that I will be able to express it as well in my ongoing reviews.
Kudos, Madam Scottoline, for a definite thinker with this one.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
November 15, 2017
Dumb.
The 'romance' portion of the book was D.U.M.B. Spoiler?They basically fall in love over a weekend and don't seriously date anyone else for the next 15 years pining away for each other. Men as good looking as Declan allegedly is don't do that. It would have been more realistic if he had at least been married and divorced in that time due to incompatibility. The court room scenes were interesting, but again, did Scottoline have to spell out for us why Bennie said every little thing she did? If the jury was supposed to have powers of deduction, shouldn't we as readers? Also,Bennie basically never gets overruled at all and the prosecutor always gets overruled- which again, is just not realistic. She can't be THAT good. And the twist? Possible spoiler- I guessed it from a mile when Scottoline was so heavy handed with Paul Stowloski's testimony and his focus on his wife. The Lego man introduced in court? Puh-lease. Lame. But to each his/her own. I also did not find Bennie and Declan near as likeable as characters in her other books,and the ending was way too neatly and quickly wrapped up between the two of them.
The 'romance' portion of the book was D.U.M.B. Spoiler?They basically fall in love over a weekend and don't seriously date anyone else for the next 15 years pining away for each other. Men as good looking as Declan allegedly is don't do that. It would have been more realistic if he had at least been married and divorced in that time due to incompatibility. The court room scenes were interesting, but again, did Scottoline have to spell out for us why Bennie said every little thing she did? If the jury was supposed to have powers of deduction, shouldn't we as readers? Also,Bennie basically never gets overruled at all and the prosecutor always gets overruled- which again, is just not realistic. She can't be THAT good. And the twist? Possible spoiler- I guessed it from a mile when Scottoline was so heavy handed with Paul Stowloski's testimony and his focus on his wife. The Lego man introduced in court? Puh-lease. Lame. But to each his/her own. I also did not find Bennie and Declan near as likeable as characters in her other books,and the ending was way too neatly and quickly wrapped up between the two of them.
July 7, 2016
Very good storyline. Even though I listened to this at work, it kept my attention. It's a sitting on the edge of your seat until the end. I'm really enjoying this series a lot. Well worth the time if you like murder mysteries.
September 29, 2015
(Thank you Netgalley for an early reader copy)
Justice delayed is justice denied....Bennie Rosato doesn't usually defend kids, but she finds herself representing 12 year old Jason Lefkavick in a case that should never gone to trail. Jason is accused of pushing a schoolyard bully named Richie. Both boys find themselves sentenced to time in a juvenile facility, sentences that seem overly harsh in light of the circumstances. Something funny is going on in the juvenile court system, and Bennie is determined to get to the heart of it, and get her 12 year old client out of jail. And then things go wrong...
13 years later, now 25 year old Jason is on trial for murdering the very bully responsible for his spending much of his young life in jail. Bennie gets the call, and although she hasn't taken on a murder case in years, this time she is determined to get justice for Jason.
An old flame, an old secret, politics, corruption and old stories all conspire to add tension and mystery to the story as Bennie seeks to find out what really happened in that dark ally, and who really murdered Richie Grusini.
Bennie's character is a great one; a tall, good looking, strong minded, intelligent woman with a soft heart and a passion for justice. She is also bold, courageous and creative, and she never gives up. I'd want her on my side if I needed a lawyer! It's sheer delight to watch her take on lesser mortals a she defends her clients like a lioness defending her cubs. Enjoy the twists and turns as Bennie unearths new clues as to who murdered Richie Grusini. Yes, there are occasionally things that happen that would never happen in a real courtroom, but that's why it's called fiction. The book left me wanting more!
Justice delayed is justice denied....Bennie Rosato doesn't usually defend kids, but she finds herself representing 12 year old Jason Lefkavick in a case that should never gone to trail. Jason is accused of pushing a schoolyard bully named Richie. Both boys find themselves sentenced to time in a juvenile facility, sentences that seem overly harsh in light of the circumstances. Something funny is going on in the juvenile court system, and Bennie is determined to get to the heart of it, and get her 12 year old client out of jail. And then things go wrong...
13 years later, now 25 year old Jason is on trial for murdering the very bully responsible for his spending much of his young life in jail. Bennie gets the call, and although she hasn't taken on a murder case in years, this time she is determined to get justice for Jason.
An old flame, an old secret, politics, corruption and old stories all conspire to add tension and mystery to the story as Bennie seeks to find out what really happened in that dark ally, and who really murdered Richie Grusini.
Bennie's character is a great one; a tall, good looking, strong minded, intelligent woman with a soft heart and a passion for justice. She is also bold, courageous and creative, and she never gives up. I'd want her on my side if I needed a lawyer! It's sheer delight to watch her take on lesser mortals a she defends her clients like a lioness defending her cubs. Enjoy the twists and turns as Bennie unearths new clues as to who murdered Richie Grusini. Yes, there are occasionally things that happen that would never happen in a real courtroom, but that's why it's called fiction. The book left me wanting more!
November 24, 2015
I enjoyed the book, however the way Bennie reacted when seeing Declan again made me angry. She is a strong woman and this made her into every stereotypical woman who feel all the guilt for something they didn't do.
I also felt the ending was contrived and ridiculous. It was as if she didn't know how to end the book and came up with this ending.
I also felt the ending was contrived and ridiculous. It was as if she didn't know how to end the book and came up with this ending.
May 24, 2025
Thus was a re-read for me. One of my favourite legal thrillers; by one of my favourite legal thriller writers. An excellent plot, courtroom drama and unexpected endings.
Unputdownable.
Unputdownable.
April 8, 2017
4.5 stars. So glad that Lisa Scottoline has returned to Bennie Rosato as I was getting sick of Mary DiNunzio's personal life and family taking precedence over plot. This book was excellent: Bennie is called to defend a man accused of murder, found in an alley, with a knife in his hand, and his lifelong tormentor with his throat slit. The book then goes back twelve years to tell the backstory of Bennie defending the same guy when he was a middle schooler, sent to juvie for 90 days for defending his mother's reputation by shoving a kid in school, ruining his life. Note: this is based on a true story in Eastern Pennsylvania where a crooked judge, masquerading as a "no tolerance" hardliner, filled a privately-owned prison, in which he had a financial interest, with juvenile defendants. The defendant's story is weak, and Bennie does her best to create a self-defense justification, but in the eleventh hour figures out what really happened in the alley. I liked that Bennie's personal life was part of the story, but not the main plot -- a welcome change from the recent books in this long-lived series.
December 2, 2015
"First-Reads, Goodreads win"
I ordinarily would not have picked up a book like this, however I entered into a giveaway to win a free copy and I did. So, giving it a try, not my usual read, what the heck it's was free. And boy am I glad I did because this book was great. In fact, I bought the second one now I need to find the first.
I don't want to "spoil" the book for anyone because I hate it when others do that and I don't want to give a long a** review of blah, blah, blah.... Let me throw in a big word with a lot more blah, blah, blah. So let me just say, corruption, justice, resentment and life is what this book is about. It's not Little House on the Prairie but life in today's society and in our f**ked up so call justice system. Injustice system should be more like it. Working for a PD for over ten years I can tell you this reads more non-fiction then fiction. Law & Order needs to watch out for Scottoline. Corrupted is superb. I'm now a Lisa Scottoline fan.
I ordinarily would not have picked up a book like this, however I entered into a giveaway to win a free copy and I did. So, giving it a try, not my usual read, what the heck it's was free. And boy am I glad I did because this book was great. In fact, I bought the second one now I need to find the first.
I don't want to "spoil" the book for anyone because I hate it when others do that and I don't want to give a long a** review of blah, blah, blah.... Let me throw in a big word with a lot more blah, blah, blah. So let me just say, corruption, justice, resentment and life is what this book is about. It's not Little House on the Prairie but life in today's society and in our f**ked up so call justice system. Injustice system should be more like it. Working for a PD for over ten years I can tell you this reads more non-fiction then fiction. Law & Order needs to watch out for Scottoline. Corrupted is superb. I'm now a Lisa Scottoline fan.
December 5, 2019
Ugh. The only reason I'm rating this book as high as two stars is because the beginning was heartbreaking, but interesting. (Maybe because it was based on a true-life scandal.) There is not a judge in the world that would allow the crap Bennie was pulling. And the romance that was thrown in was ridiculous. (In my opinion. 😉)
August 18, 2018
Please see all of my reviews on my blog at www.robinlovesreading.blogspot.com.
4.5 Stars
Founder of the Rosato & DiNunzio law firm, Bennie Rosato, takes on the case of Jason Leflavick, accused of murdering Richie Grusini. Thirteen years previously, Jason, at the age of twelve, was sent to a juvenile detention center after fighting a class bully, the very same Richie. Bennie pulled out all of the stops, but was was unable to free Jason and has never forgiven herself. When she hears of Jason's indictment for killing Richie, she is determined not to let him down a second time. Bennie is going to work really hard for Jason because she cannot let him down again.
Bennie has always displayed a tough-as-nails exterior, especially around her co-workers, but for several chapters in this book, Jason's childhood case is recalled. These recollections are hard on Bennie as she has many dark memories of that time while trying to help young Jason. We get to see Bennie's softer, more maternal, side. Bennie fell in love with a cop, Declan, Richard Grusini's uncle, and subsequently suffered a broken heart. Now that Declan's nephew is dead, Bennie cannot help but to cross paths with him again. No doubt he stands against her defending Jason, but what is more, wants something else from Bennie.
Corrupted was a fast-paced read, marrying the past and present cases that tell us a lot about Bennie's nature and why she has always been so gruff. She suffered undeniable hurt in her life at the hands of the man who said he loved her. But her focus is now, and she seeks to redeem herself with Jason's case, and this shows just how strong a character she is. This is a thrilling, yet sensitive story, not necessarily a hard-hitting legal drama. Yet, it is chock full of secrets, a broken heart, corruption and sensitivity.
I purchased this entire series and have read Accused and Betrayed, Mary's and Judy's stories, respectively. I have Feared for review for NetGalley and as a die-hard lover of series, will also be reading Damaged and Exposed. I have also purchased several other titles by this author.
4.5 Stars
Founder of the Rosato & DiNunzio law firm, Bennie Rosato, takes on the case of Jason Leflavick, accused of murdering Richie Grusini. Thirteen years previously, Jason, at the age of twelve, was sent to a juvenile detention center after fighting a class bully, the very same Richie. Bennie pulled out all of the stops, but was was unable to free Jason and has never forgiven herself. When she hears of Jason's indictment for killing Richie, she is determined not to let him down a second time. Bennie is going to work really hard for Jason because she cannot let him down again.
Bennie has always displayed a tough-as-nails exterior, especially around her co-workers, but for several chapters in this book, Jason's childhood case is recalled. These recollections are hard on Bennie as she has many dark memories of that time while trying to help young Jason. We get to see Bennie's softer, more maternal, side. Bennie fell in love with a cop, Declan, Richard Grusini's uncle, and subsequently suffered a broken heart. Now that Declan's nephew is dead, Bennie cannot help but to cross paths with him again. No doubt he stands against her defending Jason, but what is more, wants something else from Bennie.
Corrupted was a fast-paced read, marrying the past and present cases that tell us a lot about Bennie's nature and why she has always been so gruff. She suffered undeniable hurt in her life at the hands of the man who said he loved her. But her focus is now, and she seeks to redeem herself with Jason's case, and this shows just how strong a character she is. This is a thrilling, yet sensitive story, not necessarily a hard-hitting legal drama. Yet, it is chock full of secrets, a broken heart, corruption and sensitivity.
I purchased this entire series and have read Accused and Betrayed, Mary's and Judy's stories, respectively. I have Feared for review for NetGalley and as a die-hard lover of series, will also be reading Damaged and Exposed. I have also purchased several other titles by this author.
March 3, 2019
All my reviews can be found at: http://jessicasreadingroom.com
~~~~~
This review will post on my site on March 5, 2019
~~~~~
4.5 stars rounded up to 5
~~~~~
As I have mentioned in previous reviews, I have become a big fan of Lisa Scottoline and the Rosato & Dinunzio series. I have just been reading them out of order. (Not of my own choosing, it was ignorance of not knowing the first one that I read was the fourth in the series…) Now I am all caught up and have read all of the books in this series. Corrupted focuses on the enigma that is the boss-lady herself: Ms.Bennie Rosato, and I can say I saved the best for last. I finally know about Bennie’s life!
Corrupted starts in present day with Bennie receiving a phone call from a former client who now faces a murder charge. Though she doesn’t take murder cases, she feels that she MUST take on this case because of her past failings with the client, Jason Leftavick.
Corrupted takes us back in time when Jason was a twelve year old dealing with a class bully situation that gets out of hand and Bennie takes on his case. Again, having read this series out of order I know what will happen and was enjoying knowing Bennie’s ‘future’ and wondered how this novel was going to end. There was a huge secret that Bennie has that no one knows that left me with my mouth dropped! When the ‘past’ case ends and we go back to present day I couldn’t help but root for Bennie and Jason to win their case. I had no idea how this case was going to conclude and the way it does end is shocking! It was also a bit unbelievable, but I still really enjoyed it! Due to the unbelieve-ability my rating was 4.5 stars.
The books in this series can all be treated as standalones and therefore can be read out of order and you won’t lose anything by doing that, but I would say read it in order as that is how it is meant to be read.
I have thoroughly enjoyed this series and look forward to future installments that Ms. Scottoline writes. There is an 11 book series that comes before this one called Rosato & Associates that I must read! Here’s to hoping my library system offers it on audio!
Corrupted is highly recommended!
~~~~~
This review will post on my site on March 5, 2019
~~~~~
4.5 stars rounded up to 5
~~~~~
As I have mentioned in previous reviews, I have become a big fan of Lisa Scottoline and the Rosato & Dinunzio series. I have just been reading them out of order. (Not of my own choosing, it was ignorance of not knowing the first one that I read was the fourth in the series…) Now I am all caught up and have read all of the books in this series. Corrupted focuses on the enigma that is the boss-lady herself: Ms.Bennie Rosato, and I can say I saved the best for last. I finally know about Bennie’s life!
Corrupted starts in present day with Bennie receiving a phone call from a former client who now faces a murder charge. Though she doesn’t take murder cases, she feels that she MUST take on this case because of her past failings with the client, Jason Leftavick.
Corrupted takes us back in time when Jason was a twelve year old dealing with a class bully situation that gets out of hand and Bennie takes on his case. Again, having read this series out of order I know what will happen and was enjoying knowing Bennie’s ‘future’ and wondered how this novel was going to end. There was a huge secret that Bennie has that no one knows that left me with my mouth dropped! When the ‘past’ case ends and we go back to present day I couldn’t help but root for Bennie and Jason to win their case. I had no idea how this case was going to conclude and the way it does end is shocking! It was also a bit unbelievable, but I still really enjoyed it! Due to the unbelieve-ability my rating was 4.5 stars.
The books in this series can all be treated as standalones and therefore can be read out of order and you won’t lose anything by doing that, but I would say read it in order as that is how it is meant to be read.
I have thoroughly enjoyed this series and look forward to future installments that Ms. Scottoline writes. There is an 11 book series that comes before this one called Rosato & Associates that I must read! Here’s to hoping my library system offers it on audio!
Corrupted is highly recommended!
December 18, 2015
This is the third in the author's Rosato & DiNunzio novels, I believe, but it's a first for me. And I must say that overall, it just didn't quite grab me. In fact, I waffled between 3 and 4 stars for my rating - but since that's not an option, I rounded up just because I didn't not enjoy it.
As I said, I'm not familiar with either Bennie Rosato or her law firm partner, Mary DiNunzio; and after reading this, I still don't know much about the latter, who is pretty much a DiNoShow in this one. Bennie takes front, center and side stage as she takes on as a client Jason, who's been charged with the murder of a guy he's hated since middle school. Back then, Bennie defended him when, at age 12, he was sent to a juvenile detention center after getting into a fight with the kid he's now believed to have murdered. Professionally bruised and convinced that she wronged him back then by failing to get him out, she's hell-bent on making sure she doesn't drop the ball this time around.
Complicating things is the murdered guy's uncle, Declan, with whom Bennie had a brief fling (think just one weekend) during that first case that left her madly in love. Claiming family responsibilities, though, he bailed, breaking her heart. Now that her client is charged with the murder of his nephew 13 years later, he makes it clear he's in no mood to get cozy again (unless, of course, she drops the client she believes is innocent). Somehow, she musters up the courage to tell him no (personally, I'd have told him to put his ultimatums where the sun don't shine, but maybe that's just me).
Actually, both court cases - the second one involving a murder trial - make for very interesting reading; it's the sappy romance part that pretty much turned me off. Hunky appearance notwithstanding, I just couldn't warm up to Declan - and most of me fervently hoped she wouldn't take him back in the end (of course, my lips are sealed as to whether or not that happened). All in all, this is a pretty good book, but it's nowhere near the top of my favorites list.
As I said, I'm not familiar with either Bennie Rosato or her law firm partner, Mary DiNunzio; and after reading this, I still don't know much about the latter, who is pretty much a DiNoShow in this one. Bennie takes front, center and side stage as she takes on as a client Jason, who's been charged with the murder of a guy he's hated since middle school. Back then, Bennie defended him when, at age 12, he was sent to a juvenile detention center after getting into a fight with the kid he's now believed to have murdered. Professionally bruised and convinced that she wronged him back then by failing to get him out, she's hell-bent on making sure she doesn't drop the ball this time around.
Complicating things is the murdered guy's uncle, Declan, with whom Bennie had a brief fling (think just one weekend) during that first case that left her madly in love. Claiming family responsibilities, though, he bailed, breaking her heart. Now that her client is charged with the murder of his nephew 13 years later, he makes it clear he's in no mood to get cozy again (unless, of course, she drops the client she believes is innocent). Somehow, she musters up the courage to tell him no (personally, I'd have told him to put his ultimatums where the sun don't shine, but maybe that's just me).
Actually, both court cases - the second one involving a murder trial - make for very interesting reading; it's the sappy romance part that pretty much turned me off. Hunky appearance notwithstanding, I just couldn't warm up to Declan - and most of me fervently hoped she wouldn't take him back in the end (of course, my lips are sealed as to whether or not that happened). All in all, this is a pretty good book, but it's nowhere near the top of my favorites list.
November 1, 2015
This was a high-energy, heart-pounding book, full of suspense, twist and turns, and surprises. Bennie Rosato is the head of her own law firm, a brilliant lawyer with a heart of gold. She is hired to represent Jason Leftavick, a 12-year-old who is unjustly incarcerated at a juvenile detention center for a fight at school. Fast forward 12 years later, and Jason is facing murder charges, for killing Richie, the same boy he fought with as a boy. Bennie feels like she let Jason down before, and hopes that by taking his case now she can right a terrible injustice. To complicate matters, there is Declan Mitchell, state trooper and Richie's uncle, and the man Bennie falls in love with. This book is full of courtroom drama, and Bennie's legal mind is something to behold! Bennie is brilliant, funny, and totally devoted to her client. Will she achieve in finding justice for Jason? Will it cost her Declan's love? This book is fast-paced, and will hook you right until the stunning conclusion! So many intricacies in the plot, and the author does an amazing job of putting it all together in a very exciting story. I highly recommend this book! I was lucky enough to win an advanced copy of this book from the publisher, through a Goodreads giveaway.
April 21, 2017
Corrupted is about two seven graders who are sent to juvenile detention a/k/a kids prison that will ruin their lives until the day they die (one a bully and the other a sweet kid who is a good student and who is a good kid). The kids were sent to juvenile detention because the bully said something horrific about the sweet kid’s recently dead mother and the sweet kid push him causing the bully to beat him up.
We later learn two judges were in a kids-for-cash scheme where the judges made a profit for each kid they sent to kids’ prison. We also learn the judges owned a percentage of the kids prison and both judges were sent to prison for a short period of time and not for ruining the lives of juveniles. Author Scottoline covered a lot of ground in an entertaining manner in teaching us how the penal system works only for judges and politicians who profit from sending kids to prisons thus making it hard for attorneys to navigate the system in the best interest of their clients.
I enjoyed Corrupted immensely because it was a story that will remain with me always. Kate Burton story telling made the story compelling.
We later learn two judges were in a kids-for-cash scheme where the judges made a profit for each kid they sent to kids’ prison. We also learn the judges owned a percentage of the kids prison and both judges were sent to prison for a short period of time and not for ruining the lives of juveniles. Author Scottoline covered a lot of ground in an entertaining manner in teaching us how the penal system works only for judges and politicians who profit from sending kids to prisons thus making it hard for attorneys to navigate the system in the best interest of their clients.
I enjoyed Corrupted immensely because it was a story that will remain with me always. Kate Burton story telling made the story compelling.
December 8, 2015
This story revolves heavily around two court cases concerning Bennie, the founder of Rosato & DiNunzio law firm. A past case she worked on that has implications that landed in her lap again.
I really felt for Jason and the author has developed her characters in a way that you feel like you know them intimately. As a lawyer herself, Scottoline really knows how to bring the suspense into the story with this legal case. With plenty of twists and turns, you really feel the anxiety that Bennie is feeling while trying to figure out how to save this man. Plenty of drama to keep you involved completely.
I loved the court action and listening to it on audio made all the difference! It was riveting in many places and you felt like you were right in the courtroom. The reader does a fabulous job and make the entire book come to life!
The ending felt a bit rushed but overall the author really brought a great story to the table with this installment. Scottoline does it again!
The full review is on http://amidlifewife.com
I really felt for Jason and the author has developed her characters in a way that you feel like you know them intimately. As a lawyer herself, Scottoline really knows how to bring the suspense into the story with this legal case. With plenty of twists and turns, you really feel the anxiety that Bennie is feeling while trying to figure out how to save this man. Plenty of drama to keep you involved completely.
I loved the court action and listening to it on audio made all the difference! It was riveting in many places and you felt like you were right in the courtroom. The reader does a fabulous job and make the entire book come to life!
The ending felt a bit rushed but overall the author really brought a great story to the table with this installment. Scottoline does it again!
The full review is on http://amidlifewife.com
December 9, 2015
I received a copy of Corrupted from the publisher in exchange for an honest review. Corrupted is the third book in Lisa Scottoline's Rosato & DiNunzio series. I hadn't read any of the previous books in this series, but I don't think that affected my enjoyment of this story. The story evolves around Bennie Rosato and a young man charged with the murder of his childhood nemesis. The story alternates from past to present as Bennie represented the young man when he was placed in a juvenile facility due to a run in with the same bully. The final part of the book takes us through a fast paced and twisting trial. A good read - solid 3.5!
December 6, 2017
It's been a number of years since I read the earlier books of this Rosato & DiNunzio series. But I really liked Mary DiNunzio and her family. When I received a copy of EXPOSED, No.4 in the series, I decided to postpone reading it until I'd read the two before it. It wasn't necessary, especially for this book which features Bennie Rosato the founder of the Rosato & DiNunzio law firm. We learn about Bennie’s past and a young boy whom she defended as a juvenile. Once again, Jason comes to ask her to defend her. Once again Scottoline delivers an interesting courtroom drama as well as giving us to know Bennie a bit better
March 14, 2016
I was very excited when I won this book from goodreads first reads. I'm a big fan of Lisa Scottoline, having read all of her fiction and most of her non-fiction. She is one of those authors whose new books I eagerly await and always get a hold of as soon as I can, as she never fails to disappoint. And this one definitely did not disappoint. I will admit that I do enjoy her series of novels that deal with the legal cases more than the stand alone ones. I read Everywhere That Mary Went, (the first book in the Rosato and Associates series) a thriller about a fresh out of law school lawyer named Mary DiNunzio back in 1993 when it came out, and I’ve been a loyal fan ever since.
This book has everything that I hope for in a legal thriller; a client who’s been completely screwed over by the justice system (and justice system seems like such an oxymoron most of the time to me), a gross miscarriage of justice, a brilliant defense attorney who you would definitely want to have on your side in a criminal trial, and a taut and exciting courtroom drama where the defense attorney works her magic and pulls an unbelievable defense theory seemingly out of thin air to prove her client’s innocence (my favorite part). Most of all I love trying to figure out how Bennie Rosato is ever going to win a case when all the damaging evidence seems to point to her client.
Twelve years ago Bennie defended Jason Lefkavick, a 12 year old boy who got in a fight with another boy in the lunchroom at his middle school. The boy had been bullying him for years, calling him names like “Fat Boy”, “Tank”, and “Blubber Boy”, because as Jason puts it, he’s a bit “chunky.” His mom always told him to be like a duck and let the words just roll off his back. One day though, the teasing was different. Richie started teasing him about his mom who had just died, saying she was “big as a house”, and that she died because she had a heart attack because she was a “big fat pig.” Jason couldn’t let this go and had to defend his mom, so he pushed Richie. They got into a fight and the principal called the cops. The cops came and took both boys away in handcuffs and they ended up being taken to the Juvenile Detention Center. The judge, known as the Zero Tolerance Judge, sentenced Jason to 6 months and Richie to 3 months. This is where I’m saying “WTH?” That could never happen. Why would a principal call the cops? That’s crazy! I’m a teacher, and at the schools where I’ve worked the fight would be immediately broken up and the kids sent to the principal’s office. He or she would talk to them and their parents and they would probably get suspended for anywhere from 1-5 days, depending on the offense. So this case seemed like something that could never happen in real life. Big surprise. It did. It turned out to be a huge case of corruption involving two judges who were getting big kick-backs from the juvenile detention facilities they were sentencing kids to. Huge kick-backs, like $2.6 million worth. Here’s a link to the story: http://jlc.org/luzerne-county-kids-ca....
That’s the first part of the story. The second part happens twelve years later in present day when Jason is accused of murdering Richie and Bennie again takes on his defense. It’s a definite page turner for sure. I could barely stand to put it down. If you enjoy legal thrillers, especially if the events are ripped right from the headlines, then you will want to check this one out. Highly recommended.
This book has everything that I hope for in a legal thriller; a client who’s been completely screwed over by the justice system (and justice system seems like such an oxymoron most of the time to me), a gross miscarriage of justice, a brilliant defense attorney who you would definitely want to have on your side in a criminal trial, and a taut and exciting courtroom drama where the defense attorney works her magic and pulls an unbelievable defense theory seemingly out of thin air to prove her client’s innocence (my favorite part). Most of all I love trying to figure out how Bennie Rosato is ever going to win a case when all the damaging evidence seems to point to her client.
Twelve years ago Bennie defended Jason Lefkavick, a 12 year old boy who got in a fight with another boy in the lunchroom at his middle school. The boy had been bullying him for years, calling him names like “Fat Boy”, “Tank”, and “Blubber Boy”, because as Jason puts it, he’s a bit “chunky.” His mom always told him to be like a duck and let the words just roll off his back. One day though, the teasing was different. Richie started teasing him about his mom who had just died, saying she was “big as a house”, and that she died because she had a heart attack because she was a “big fat pig.” Jason couldn’t let this go and had to defend his mom, so he pushed Richie. They got into a fight and the principal called the cops. The cops came and took both boys away in handcuffs and they ended up being taken to the Juvenile Detention Center. The judge, known as the Zero Tolerance Judge, sentenced Jason to 6 months and Richie to 3 months. This is where I’m saying “WTH?” That could never happen. Why would a principal call the cops? That’s crazy! I’m a teacher, and at the schools where I’ve worked the fight would be immediately broken up and the kids sent to the principal’s office. He or she would talk to them and their parents and they would probably get suspended for anywhere from 1-5 days, depending on the offense. So this case seemed like something that could never happen in real life. Big surprise. It did. It turned out to be a huge case of corruption involving two judges who were getting big kick-backs from the juvenile detention facilities they were sentencing kids to. Huge kick-backs, like $2.6 million worth. Here’s a link to the story: http://jlc.org/luzerne-county-kids-ca....
That’s the first part of the story. The second part happens twelve years later in present day when Jason is accused of murdering Richie and Bennie again takes on his defense. It’s a definite page turner for sure. I could barely stand to put it down. If you enjoy legal thrillers, especially if the events are ripped right from the headlines, then you will want to check this one out. Highly recommended.
November 20, 2015
For an extended review of this book and more, please visit http://fortheloveoftheread.blogspot.com
I received an advanced copy of this novel from Net Galley per my request. I'm a long-time fan of Scottoline, having read nearly all of her books, with a special love for Bennie's law firm.
Jumping back into the world of Rosato felt a little like coming home. I loved rolling around in the legalese and Bennie's intensity as a lawyer. There are times throughout the book when the focus is on the trial, and the author uses Bennie's thoughts as a way to keep the reading in the loop on the legal terms and what exactly is going on.
This book was a little different from the others because it lays out two cases, not just one. This one focuses on Jason's current murder case, while also giving the reader the information needed about the previous case that Bennie took on for Jason. The past case also allows the author to develop parts of Bennie's life to share with the reader. I enjoyed learning more about Bennie and piecing together some of her history.
The ending of the book was a bit weird to me. Scottoline always has a twist at the end that changes the case from what you think it will be, and this book was no exception. However, I felt like the twist was not readily obvious to the reader and that it was almost lazy. The author threw in a character that the reader didn't know and had that character completely upend the entire case. It wasn't one of Scottoline's best endings, but the way the case was going was compelling and kept me interested.
Overall, I do think fans of Scottline will enjoy this book, particularly if you are a fan of the Rosato & Associates novels. If you're unfamiliar with Scottline's work, this book is an easy one to jump into, requiring no prior knowledge about characters or events.
I received an advanced copy of this novel from Net Galley per my request. I'm a long-time fan of Scottoline, having read nearly all of her books, with a special love for Bennie's law firm.
Jumping back into the world of Rosato felt a little like coming home. I loved rolling around in the legalese and Bennie's intensity as a lawyer. There are times throughout the book when the focus is on the trial, and the author uses Bennie's thoughts as a way to keep the reading in the loop on the legal terms and what exactly is going on.
This book was a little different from the others because it lays out two cases, not just one. This one focuses on Jason's current murder case, while also giving the reader the information needed about the previous case that Bennie took on for Jason. The past case also allows the author to develop parts of Bennie's life to share with the reader. I enjoyed learning more about Bennie and piecing together some of her history.
The ending of the book was a bit weird to me. Scottoline always has a twist at the end that changes the case from what you think it will be, and this book was no exception. However, I felt like the twist was not readily obvious to the reader and that it was almost lazy. The author threw in a character that the reader didn't know and had that character completely upend the entire case. It wasn't one of Scottoline's best endings, but the way the case was going was compelling and kept me interested.
Overall, I do think fans of Scottline will enjoy this book, particularly if you are a fan of the Rosato & Associates novels. If you're unfamiliar with Scottline's work, this book is an easy one to jump into, requiring no prior knowledge about characters or events.
March 15, 2016
I listened to Kate Burton's excellent narration.
My friend Jenny recently told me that she enjoys romance novels better if they are wrapped in another genre such as a mystery. This book fits that description. It is a legal thriller/mystery by former trial lawyer Lisa Scottoline. Her books are a softer style than someone like John Grisham or Scott Turow but the mysteries are good and the character development pleasing. I'd call them legal beach reads.
Corrupted is from a series about the all female law firm Rosato and Associates. As Bennie Rosato says, she just hired the best lawyers she could find and they all happened to be women. So no feminist hard sell is included, which I appreciate. Scottoline doesn't just stick with one character from book to book, so that adds variety.
This one focuses on Bennie Rosato who never takes murder cases, but takes this seemingly ordinary one in order to pay a debt from her past. We get both stories, past and present, to give context and I found both engaging. Here's where the romance comes in. I was surprised but it was well blended with the story and I liked it. I also found it refreshing that these lawyers don't try to spin the truth, work the system, or bend the law any more than a real life lawyer would. It gave me an insider's look at the legal system and trying a case.
The mystery had me on the edge of my seat to see how it would come out, as well as the romance. I'd give it 3-1/2 stars but will round up due to overall enjoyment.
My friend Jenny recently told me that she enjoys romance novels better if they are wrapped in another genre such as a mystery. This book fits that description. It is a legal thriller/mystery by former trial lawyer Lisa Scottoline. Her books are a softer style than someone like John Grisham or Scott Turow but the mysteries are good and the character development pleasing. I'd call them legal beach reads.
Corrupted is from a series about the all female law firm Rosato and Associates. As Bennie Rosato says, she just hired the best lawyers she could find and they all happened to be women. So no feminist hard sell is included, which I appreciate. Scottoline doesn't just stick with one character from book to book, so that adds variety.
This one focuses on Bennie Rosato who never takes murder cases, but takes this seemingly ordinary one in order to pay a debt from her past. We get both stories, past and present, to give context and I found both engaging. Here's where the romance comes in. I was surprised but it was well blended with the story and I liked it. I also found it refreshing that these lawyers don't try to spin the truth, work the system, or bend the law any more than a real life lawyer would. It gave me an insider's look at the legal system and trying a case.
The mystery had me on the edge of my seat to see how it would come out, as well as the romance. I'd give it 3-1/2 stars but will round up due to overall enjoyment.
November 24, 2015
This may well be the best of Lisa Scottoline's series of mysteries/courtroom dramas about the all-female law firm started by Bennie Rosato (though they just acquired a new male associate). Bennie hasn't done a murder case in a long time but rushes to the rescue of Jason Lefkavick, a young man she tried to rescue from a wrongful stay in juvenile jail when he was 12 and got in a fight at school when a bully classmate Richie made fun of his recently deceased mom's weight. Unfortunately the judge in the case was rushing kids for nothing at all to a for-profit juvenile prison he was part owner of and though Bennie came close to freeing him, his dad, enraged that Bennie was sleeping with Richie's state trooper uncle, fired her and didn't hire another lawyer so the boy spent his childhood in prison.
Fast forward 14 years- Bennie gets a call from Jason this time because he is in jail accused of murdering the bully Richie now as an adult. It looks bad for Jason- all of the evidence points at his guilt- but Bennie feels guilty at letting him down years ago and is determined to clear his name. One problem- Richie's uncle dumped her years ago and he is back on the scene.
Fast forward 14 years- Bennie gets a call from Jason this time because he is in jail accused of murdering the bully Richie now as an adult. It looks bad for Jason- all of the evidence points at his guilt- but Bennie feels guilty at letting him down years ago and is determined to clear his name. One problem- Richie's uncle dumped her years ago and he is back on the scene.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,337 reviews