What do you think?
Rate this book
Bones of Kings #1
Forged in Fading
A grieving blacksmith fighting for revenge. A tortured rebel fighting for freedom. A ruthless king out to destroy them both.
Three years after the loss of her mother and sister, Alvara survives through endless hours at the forge, training with her spear, and consuming what some would consider too much sugar.
When she is tasked with delivering a sword to another kingdom, she expects the worst part of her journey to be traveling alongside the elf who broke her heart.
…not finding herself imprisoned in King Einar’s dungeon. And learning he was responsible for her sister’s death.
To avenge her family, Alvara must join the growing resistance and train with a handsome rebel leader, who isn’t at all what he seems, to control the magic she has locked away for so long.
As war looms and the fate of the five kingdoms hangs in the balance, Alvara is forced to confront her past or risk tearing herself and the rebellion apart.
Even more dangerous is her discovery that she may have found something—or someone—worth living for.
Forged in Fading is the first book in this slow-burn, Nordic-inspired, epic romantic fantasy series, Bones of Kings. Perfect for fans of the slow-burn romance and immersive world-building of Daughter of No Worlds and the heart and humor of Paladin's Grace.
Three years after the loss of her mother and sister, Alvara survives through endless hours at the forge, training with her spear, and consuming what some would consider too much sugar.
When she is tasked with delivering a sword to another kingdom, she expects the worst part of her journey to be traveling alongside the elf who broke her heart.
…not finding herself imprisoned in King Einar’s dungeon. And learning he was responsible for her sister’s death.
To avenge her family, Alvara must join the growing resistance and train with a handsome rebel leader, who isn’t at all what he seems, to control the magic she has locked away for so long.
As war looms and the fate of the five kingdoms hangs in the balance, Alvara is forced to confront her past or risk tearing herself and the rebellion apart.
Even more dangerous is her discovery that she may have found something—or someone—worth living for.
Forged in Fading is the first book in this slow-burn, Nordic-inspired, epic romantic fantasy series, Bones of Kings. Perfect for fans of the slow-burn romance and immersive world-building of Daughter of No Worlds and the heart and humor of Paladin's Grace.
466 pages, Kindle Edition
Published August 28, 2026
About the author
Madeline Haiston
1 book60 followersMadeline Haiston is a fantasy author whose love for storytelling emerged from a bad habit of reading a book a day and losing herself in fictional worlds. When she’s not putting her linguistics degree to good use by handcrafting names for her characters, she can be found baking, singing (even when her toddler tells her to stop), and exploring Colorado with her husband, two daughters, and their dogs.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 331 reviews
August 2, 2026
ARC REVIEW
This book completely stole my heart.
This is so much more than a fantasy romance. It’s a beautifully written story about loss, healing, found family, and learning that surviving isn’t the same as truly living.
From the very first chapter, Madeline creates a world that feels tangible. I could practically feel the cold winter air, picture every castle hall, every forest, every mountain. The worldbuilding is immersive without ever feeling overwhelming, and I was hooked immediately.
At the center of it all is Alvara, a heroine whose grief feels incredibly real. Watching her navigate unimaginable loss while slowly finding hope again was one of the most emotional character journeys I’ve read this year. As someone who has experienced losing a parent, so many of her thoughts and emotions resonated with me on a deeply personal level. There were chapters that genuinely had me crying.
And then there’s Boden…
Kind. Patient. Protective. Emotionally mature. The definition of “I’ll carry this burden with you.” Watching their relationship develop through quiet moments, training sessions, shared laughter, and unwavering support was everything I want from a slow-burn romance. The chemistry is undeniable, but it’s the trust they build that made me fall in love with them.
The found family absolutely shines here. Every member of the group feels distinct, bringing humor, warmth, and heart even in the darkest moments. I laughed far more than I expected, which made the emotional scenes hit even harder.
If you love:
🤍 Slow burn romance
🤍 Found family
🤍 He trains her
🤍 Emotional healing arcs
🤍 Witty banter
🤍 Cozy moments between the chaos
🤍 Expansive fantasy worlds
🤍 Animal companions
🤍 Characters who choose hope even after unimaginable loss
…please put this on your TBR.
This book broke my heart, gently stitched it back together, and reminded me that healing isn’t about forgetting the people we love—it’s about learning to carry them with us as we keep moving forward.
One of my favorite reads of the year, and I already know I’ll be thinking about Alvara and Boden for a very long time. 🩵
This book completely stole my heart.
This is so much more than a fantasy romance. It’s a beautifully written story about loss, healing, found family, and learning that surviving isn’t the same as truly living.
From the very first chapter, Madeline creates a world that feels tangible. I could practically feel the cold winter air, picture every castle hall, every forest, every mountain. The worldbuilding is immersive without ever feeling overwhelming, and I was hooked immediately.
At the center of it all is Alvara, a heroine whose grief feels incredibly real. Watching her navigate unimaginable loss while slowly finding hope again was one of the most emotional character journeys I’ve read this year. As someone who has experienced losing a parent, so many of her thoughts and emotions resonated with me on a deeply personal level. There were chapters that genuinely had me crying.
And then there’s Boden…
Kind. Patient. Protective. Emotionally mature. The definition of “I’ll carry this burden with you.” Watching their relationship develop through quiet moments, training sessions, shared laughter, and unwavering support was everything I want from a slow-burn romance. The chemistry is undeniable, but it’s the trust they build that made me fall in love with them.
The found family absolutely shines here. Every member of the group feels distinct, bringing humor, warmth, and heart even in the darkest moments. I laughed far more than I expected, which made the emotional scenes hit even harder.
If you love:
🤍 Slow burn romance
🤍 Found family
🤍 He trains her
🤍 Emotional healing arcs
🤍 Witty banter
🤍 Cozy moments between the chaos
🤍 Expansive fantasy worlds
🤍 Animal companions
🤍 Characters who choose hope even after unimaginable loss
…please put this on your TBR.
This book broke my heart, gently stitched it back together, and reminded me that healing isn’t about forgetting the people we love—it’s about learning to carry them with us as we keep moving forward.
One of my favorite reads of the year, and I already know I’ll be thinking about Alvara and Boden for a very long time. 🩵
Did Not Finish
August 19, 2026DNF 25%
When I started this book It had so many great reviews that I wanted to feel the same way about it. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case.
For me, characters are essential in a book, and in this instance, I couldn't connect with any of them. Maybe I'm reading it at the wrong time and in other situation I would love it, I don't know.
The plot involving the different kingdoms, the king, the humans, and so on was interesting, but I just couldn't stand the FMC and so I don't see myself like continuing; she seemed like a teenager most of the time, and just in case it is needed to say, she isn't one.
I also feel that some things happened so quickly, so abruptly that there wasn't time enough to connect with the characters or situations, so I couldn't enjoy them as much.
Maybe I'll try it in some future again, to see if it was just a bad moment to read it, and so I can finally enjoy it as much as the rest of people did.
Thanks to the author, Madeline Haiston, for the ARC in exchange of an honest review, and I hope the best for her book's release.
When I started this book It had so many great reviews that I wanted to feel the same way about it. Unfortunately, that wasn't the case.
For me, characters are essential in a book, and in this instance, I couldn't connect with any of them. Maybe I'm reading it at the wrong time and in other situation I would love it, I don't know.
The plot involving the different kingdoms, the king, the humans, and so on was interesting, but I just couldn't stand the FMC and so I don't see myself like continuing; she seemed like a teenager most of the time, and just in case it is needed to say, she isn't one.
I also feel that some things happened so quickly, so abruptly that there wasn't time enough to connect with the characters or situations, so I couldn't enjoy them as much.
Maybe I'll try it in some future again, to see if it was just a bad moment to read it, and so I can finally enjoy it as much as the rest of people did.
Thanks to the author, Madeline Haiston, for the ARC in exchange of an honest review, and I hope the best for her book's release.
September 3, 2026
ARC Review
YUP! I’m going to need 15 more of these!! ASAP!
I loved this story so much! The author beautifully and accurately wrote about grief and the struggles that come along with it. I loved the aspect of found family and how people that love you can do so while also holding you accountable.
I NEEEEEEEEEEEEED MORE OF ALVARA AND BODEN!
YUP! I’m going to need 15 more of these!! ASAP!
I loved this story so much! The author beautifully and accurately wrote about grief and the struggles that come along with it. I loved the aspect of found family and how people that love you can do so while also holding you accountable.
I NEEEEEEEEEEEEED MORE OF ALVARA AND BODEN!
July 12, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Such a great story with such good characters!
Such a great story with such good characters!
August 29, 2026
“You are worth every fight, every sleepless night, every bruised knee. You are and always have been utterly irreplaceable. And no one will be able to convince me otherwise, not from now until the day I fade.”
This book took me by complete surprise in the BEST way! It's everything I adore about romantasy with characters I have fallen irrevocably in love with! I adored the depiction of grief and forgiveness in this story, as well as the focus on making impossible choices for the greater good. Alvara is so easy to relate to and a lead that you cannot help but root for! For a large portion of the story, she is coming to terms with grief and trying to sort out what meaning the rest of her life could have. What I loved most about her is that I could readily put myself in her shoes and understand how she arrived at certain choices she makes... and that she is ready and willing to own up to her mistakes and do literally anything to make things right.
AND BODEN. MY GOD. I was swooning in perpetuity. You simply have to read this book to understand just how patient, steady, and downright irresistible he is. I was highlighting sections of text whenever they were on the page together, and I would read 400 pages more about them! Their black cat x golden retriever dynamic (where she's the black cat) was delicious, their banter was a treat, and I loved how protective they are of each other! This is how slow burn is done! I would also be remiss to not mention how much I loved the found family aspect as well!
If you're craving a romantasy with strong elements of found family and an addicting slowburn romance, pick this one up today!
This book took me by complete surprise in the BEST way! It's everything I adore about romantasy with characters I have fallen irrevocably in love with! I adored the depiction of grief and forgiveness in this story, as well as the focus on making impossible choices for the greater good. Alvara is so easy to relate to and a lead that you cannot help but root for! For a large portion of the story, she is coming to terms with grief and trying to sort out what meaning the rest of her life could have. What I loved most about her is that I could readily put myself in her shoes and understand how she arrived at certain choices she makes... and that she is ready and willing to own up to her mistakes and do literally anything to make things right.
AND BODEN. MY GOD. I was swooning in perpetuity. You simply have to read this book to understand just how patient, steady, and downright irresistible he is. I was highlighting sections of text whenever they were on the page together, and I would read 400 pages more about them! Their black cat x golden retriever dynamic (where she's the black cat) was delicious, their banter was a treat, and I loved how protective they are of each other! This is how slow burn is done! I would also be remiss to not mention how much I loved the found family aspect as well!
If you're craving a romantasy with strong elements of found family and an addicting slowburn romance, pick this one up today!
July 22, 2026
I want to thank Madeline Haiston for giving me the opportunity to read and review her debut novel.
A Nordic themed epic fantasy with spectacular world building, Forged in Fading, offers the reader a strong FMC whose quest for revenge catapults her into battle with the King Einar, the epitome of the evil villain. Alvara, an elven blacksmith has already lost her sister and mother as the story begins. All that Alvara knows is that her sister died in a accident and her mother tragically died from grief. However, when Alvara finds out the truth behind her sister's death, she vows to avenge her death.
Teaming up with a group of elves, Kat, Boden, Rav, and Lena, Alvara embarks on a mission to unite elves, dwarves, demi- elves, witches and humans in hopes of stopping Einar from becoming High King of the realm.
The romantic tension between Boden and Alvara is slow burning, moving gradually in a realistic way. They become friends first and as time passes they begin to realize that their feelings go way beyond friendship. Alvara is well developed, flawed and believable. Boden and Alvara's interactions are natural which creates an authentic relationship arc. The minor characters act as important contributors to the plot line and also provide sub plots that seem to point to further development as the series continues.
The pacing moves steadily for the first 2/3 of the novel, but then slows down as the upcoming battle approaches. The culmination of the major conflict comes quickly and the ending definitely does not disappoint. I particularly loved the Nordic setting- the world building was detailed and filled with sensory imagery. I can't wait for Book #2
The novel provides a fresh setting with a memorable and well developed group of characters and an engaging story.
A Nordic themed epic fantasy with spectacular world building, Forged in Fading, offers the reader a strong FMC whose quest for revenge catapults her into battle with the King Einar, the epitome of the evil villain. Alvara, an elven blacksmith has already lost her sister and mother as the story begins. All that Alvara knows is that her sister died in a accident and her mother tragically died from grief. However, when Alvara finds out the truth behind her sister's death, she vows to avenge her death.
Teaming up with a group of elves, Kat, Boden, Rav, and Lena, Alvara embarks on a mission to unite elves, dwarves, demi- elves, witches and humans in hopes of stopping Einar from becoming High King of the realm.
The romantic tension between Boden and Alvara is slow burning, moving gradually in a realistic way. They become friends first and as time passes they begin to realize that their feelings go way beyond friendship. Alvara is well developed, flawed and believable. Boden and Alvara's interactions are natural which creates an authentic relationship arc. The minor characters act as important contributors to the plot line and also provide sub plots that seem to point to further development as the series continues.
The pacing moves steadily for the first 2/3 of the novel, but then slows down as the upcoming battle approaches. The culmination of the major conflict comes quickly and the ending definitely does not disappoint. I particularly loved the Nordic setting- the world building was detailed and filled with sensory imagery. I can't wait for Book #2
The novel provides a fresh setting with a memorable and well developed group of characters and an engaging story.
August 3, 2026
I ended up enjoying this one overall, but it definitely took me a while to get into. The first 20% felt really slow, and I struggled to push through it, but once the story got going I found myself much more invested.
I really liked that this was fantasy first and foremost. The different races were interesting, the plot kept me engaged once it picked up, and I enjoyed how the romance was sprinkled throughout rather than dominating the story. It also leaned into a lot of familiar fantasy tropes, which I generally had a lot of fun with.
That said, I did have a few issues. The magic system never felt fully explained, and I was left wanting a bit more detail about how everything worked. I also felt like there was a lack of real tension at times because the plot armour was quite noticeable. On top of that, I never felt the story fully explained why certain magical devices posed such a huge threat, and I think the world-building could have been much stronger overall.
A really enjoyable epic fantasy once it found its feet, but I think with a stronger opening, deeper world-building and a more fleshed-out magic system, this could have been an even better read.
I really liked that this was fantasy first and foremost. The different races were interesting, the plot kept me engaged once it picked up, and I enjoyed how the romance was sprinkled throughout rather than dominating the story. It also leaned into a lot of familiar fantasy tropes, which I generally had a lot of fun with.
That said, I did have a few issues. The magic system never felt fully explained, and I was left wanting a bit more detail about how everything worked. I also felt like there was a lack of real tension at times because the plot armour was quite noticeable. On top of that, I never felt the story fully explained why certain magical devices posed such a huge threat, and I think the world-building could have been much stronger overall.
A really enjoyable epic fantasy once it found its feet, but I think with a stronger opening, deeper world-building and a more fleshed-out magic system, this could have been an even better read.
Review of advance copy received from Author
This Nordic-inspired slow burn romantic fantasy was *chef’s kiss*. I especially loved the amount of detail there was in the author’s writing, I felt myself being sucked into the book with the incredible story telling! If you love magic, FMC/MMC banter, and epic battle scenes - this one’s for you.
August 28, 2026
This book was not was I was expecting but I’m not mad about it.
It had a bit of a slow start but once I got hooked I couldn’t put it down. The book itself was written in third person which took some getting used to but I’m glad I stuck it out!
Reading this book truly transported you to another world. And don’t even get me started about the romance subplot. I LOVED Alvara and Boden. The banter, the friendship, the ship (iykyk), and the protectiveness. THIS IS THE BOOK IF YOU LOVE A GOOD SLOWBURN.
It had a bit of a slow start but once I got hooked I couldn’t put it down. The book itself was written in third person which took some getting used to but I’m glad I stuck it out!
Reading this book truly transported you to another world. And don’t even get me started about the romance subplot. I LOVED Alvara and Boden. The banter, the friendship, the ship (iykyk), and the protectiveness. THIS IS THE BOOK IF YOU LOVE A GOOD SLOWBURN.
August 14, 2026
° ˖✧ 𝓣𝓛;𝓓𝓡 ✧˖°
A nordic-inspired romantasy perfect for readers looking for intricate worldbuilding including languages and politics, an action-packed storyline at a fast pace, and a growing friendship that blooms with romantic chemistry.
° ˖✧ 𝓡𝓪𝓽𝓲𝓷𝓰𝓼 ✧˖°
3.5 ⭐
0 🌶️
° ˖✧ 𝓠𝓾𝓸𝓽𝓮𝓼 ✧˖°
"Focus on who you've become, Boden, not who you had to be to survive in a world that was bent on breaking you."
"You mean something to him, and that means something to me."
"What's the point of saving everyone if you aren't willing to save yourself?"
"You are and always have been utterly irreplaceable."
° ˖✧ 𝓢𝔂𝓷𝓸𝓹𝓼𝓲𝓼 𝓢𝓾𝓶𝓶𝓪𝓻𝔂 ✧˖°
When elven blacksmith Alvara is captured by the King responsible for her sister’s death, she joins the resistance to avenge her family. But with inexperienced magic, she must train with rebel leader Boden or risk the fate of the five kingdoms.
° ˖✧ 𝓣𝓻𝓸𝓹𝓮𝓼 ✧˖°
💘 Strangers to Friends to Lovers
🧲 Opposites Attract
❤️🔥 Extremely Slow Burn
🫶 Found Family
❤️🩹 Hurt/Comfort
🧐 Political Intrigue
❄️ Elemental Magic + Shifters
🐻 Reluctant Allies (multiple races)
° ˖✧ 𝓣𝓻𝓲𝓰𝓰𝓮𝓻 𝓦𝓪𝓻𝓷𝓲𝓷𝓰𝓼 ✧˖°
🩸 Violence + Torture
🪦 Death + Grief
💀 Near-Death-Experiences
🍺 Substance Abuse (ish)
° ˖✧ 𝓛𝓲𝓴𝓮𝓼 ✧˖°
+ Fun Training Sequences
+ Cool Magic System
+ Slowest of Burns
+ Sweet Romantic Chemistry
+ Rav's Hard-Earned Friendship
° ˖✧ 𝓓𝓲𝓼𝓵𝓲𝓴𝓮𝓼 ✧˖°
- Start was difficult to get into
- Lots of Info-Dumping
- Complex Worldbuilding
- Rushed Pacing
- Early Emotive Moments were Flat
- Most Side Characters were unlikeable or bland
° ˖✧ 𝓜𝔂 𝓣𝓱𝓸𝓾𝓰𝓱𝓽𝓼 ✧˖°
I was really excited for this one but it took a WHILE for me to get into, unfortunately. If it wasn't part of a buddy read, or an ARC, I probably would've DNF'd after the first few chapters. It was only around the 25-30% mark that I started to connect more with the characters and story enough to continue willingly.
The first quarter of the story is basically all setup. There's a lot of info-dumping which builds a complex political history that's very confusing to follow especially with lots of new terms that are thrown at you. Now, granted, there is a glossary at the back of the book, but I just found myself frustrated trying to read.
I also struggled to follow the pacing of this book. Especially at the start, a lot happens really quickly. It's so fast that it makes it hard for the reader to be immersed in any of it, making it feel rushed and inconsequential.
There are a lot of emotional stakes early on that also don't really land because we're told a lot rather than experiencing it for ourselves. Alvara's ex and father are prominent characters at the start but I felt almost no connection to them and when Alvara processed her relationship with those characters it felt very flat.
I wasn't the biggest fan of Boden's introduction either. Alvara and Boden are at odds initially (great, love some tension) but they didn't quite fit together in the way I wanted, almost like they were pretending to be something they weren't. It was only when the pair started to open up to one another and become friends that I really enjoyed their interactions.
I didn't realise quite how much of a slow burn this would be but I was here for it! The gentle friendship that blooms between them was so sweet to watch, especially when feelings began to follow shortly after. There were a couple of instances where I got frustrated with interruptions or the characters resisting, but overall I loved the chemistry between them!
Most of the other characters didn't do much for me, Pyry just annoyed me and Kat felt really bland. I did like Lilja (Boden's sister) though, and especially Rav! Rav had the best development of the whole book, I felt, and his friendship with Boden and Alvara felt really authentic.
I also really enjoyed the scenes where Alvara was taught magic, especially the classroom style scenes nearer the beginning! I would've loved to have seen her really win over the teacher and the younglings. The magic in general was really interesting in this world, but as with the politics it felt as though we were told a lot of unnecessary detail alongside it.
I don't know that I'd read the sequel at this point. I'd love to see more of Alvara and Boden's relationship progress, but the ending seemed pretty resolved. I'm not sure there's many unanswered questions that would pull me into the next in the series. Plus, I'm not sure I'd want to sign up for more skimming of backstory/lore again!
Thank you to Madeline Haiston for the opportunity to receive an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
A nordic-inspired romantasy perfect for readers looking for intricate worldbuilding including languages and politics, an action-packed storyline at a fast pace, and a growing friendship that blooms with romantic chemistry.
° ˖✧ 𝓡𝓪𝓽𝓲𝓷𝓰𝓼 ✧˖°
3.5 ⭐
0 🌶️
° ˖✧ 𝓠𝓾𝓸𝓽𝓮𝓼 ✧˖°
"Focus on who you've become, Boden, not who you had to be to survive in a world that was bent on breaking you."
"You mean something to him, and that means something to me."
"What's the point of saving everyone if you aren't willing to save yourself?"
"You are and always have been utterly irreplaceable."
° ˖✧ 𝓢𝔂𝓷𝓸𝓹𝓼𝓲𝓼 𝓢𝓾𝓶𝓶𝓪𝓻𝔂 ✧˖°
When elven blacksmith Alvara is captured by the King responsible for her sister’s death, she joins the resistance to avenge her family. But with inexperienced magic, she must train with rebel leader Boden or risk the fate of the five kingdoms.
° ˖✧ 𝓣𝓻𝓸𝓹𝓮𝓼 ✧˖°
💘 Strangers to Friends to Lovers
🧲 Opposites Attract
❤️🔥 Extremely Slow Burn
🫶 Found Family
❤️🩹 Hurt/Comfort
🧐 Political Intrigue
❄️ Elemental Magic + Shifters
🐻 Reluctant Allies (multiple races)
° ˖✧ 𝓣𝓻𝓲𝓰𝓰𝓮𝓻 𝓦𝓪𝓻𝓷𝓲𝓷𝓰𝓼 ✧˖°
🩸 Violence + Torture
🪦 Death + Grief
💀 Near-Death-Experiences
🍺 Substance Abuse (ish)
° ˖✧ 𝓛𝓲𝓴𝓮𝓼 ✧˖°
+ Fun Training Sequences
+ Cool Magic System
+ Slowest of Burns
+ Sweet Romantic Chemistry
+ Rav's Hard-Earned Friendship
° ˖✧ 𝓓𝓲𝓼𝓵𝓲𝓴𝓮𝓼 ✧˖°
- Start was difficult to get into
- Lots of Info-Dumping
- Complex Worldbuilding
- Rushed Pacing
- Early Emotive Moments were Flat
- Most Side Characters were unlikeable or bland
° ˖✧ 𝓜𝔂 𝓣𝓱𝓸𝓾𝓰𝓱𝓽𝓼 ✧˖°
I was really excited for this one but it took a WHILE for me to get into, unfortunately. If it wasn't part of a buddy read, or an ARC, I probably would've DNF'd after the first few chapters. It was only around the 25-30% mark that I started to connect more with the characters and story enough to continue willingly.
The first quarter of the story is basically all setup. There's a lot of info-dumping which builds a complex political history that's very confusing to follow especially with lots of new terms that are thrown at you. Now, granted, there is a glossary at the back of the book, but I just found myself frustrated trying to read.
I also struggled to follow the pacing of this book. Especially at the start, a lot happens really quickly. It's so fast that it makes it hard for the reader to be immersed in any of it, making it feel rushed and inconsequential.
There are a lot of emotional stakes early on that also don't really land because we're told a lot rather than experiencing it for ourselves. Alvara's ex and father are prominent characters at the start but I felt almost no connection to them and when Alvara processed her relationship with those characters it felt very flat.
I wasn't the biggest fan of Boden's introduction either. Alvara and Boden are at odds initially (great, love some tension) but they didn't quite fit together in the way I wanted, almost like they were pretending to be something they weren't. It was only when the pair started to open up to one another and become friends that I really enjoyed their interactions.
I didn't realise quite how much of a slow burn this would be but I was here for it! The gentle friendship that blooms between them was so sweet to watch, especially when feelings began to follow shortly after. There were a couple of instances where I got frustrated with interruptions or the characters resisting, but overall I loved the chemistry between them!
Most of the other characters didn't do much for me, Pyry just annoyed me and Kat felt really bland. I did like Lilja (Boden's sister) though, and especially Rav! Rav had the best development of the whole book, I felt, and his friendship with Boden and Alvara felt really authentic.
I also really enjoyed the scenes where Alvara was taught magic, especially the classroom style scenes nearer the beginning! I would've loved to have seen her really win over the teacher and the younglings. The magic in general was really interesting in this world, but as with the politics it felt as though we were told a lot of unnecessary detail alongside it.
I don't know that I'd read the sequel at this point. I'd love to see more of Alvara and Boden's relationship progress, but the ending seemed pretty resolved. I'm not sure there's many unanswered questions that would pull me into the next in the series. Plus, I'm not sure I'd want to sign up for more skimming of backstory/lore again!
Thank you to Madeline Haiston for the opportunity to receive an ARC in exchange for my honest review.
September 7, 2026
3,5 ⭐
Forged in Fading is truly a gripping fantasy story. Madeline manages to not only make you love every single character she introduces, but also immerse you into a vibrant icy world. The story is told from the FMC Alvara's point of view. I really enjoyed seeing her grow throughout the story and her love interest was so good. I love an actual slow burn and this was a real one. My favourite character was probably Rav and I do hope to see even more of them in the sequel. The back and forth between Alvara and Rav, as well as between Alvara and Boden were definitely some of my favourite parts. I found myself smiling from time to time at the stupid little jokes and the banter.
What I really enjoyed about this book, is that so much happens in these 440 pages and it felt like there wasn't a single boring moment. There's a perfect balance between adventure, action, character development and romance.
Read if you like:
✨ Slow burn
✨ Nordic influences
✨ Elves, humans and more
✨ Black cat x golden retriever
✨ Found family
✨ One bed
✨ Shifters
Forged in Fading is truly a gripping fantasy story. Madeline manages to not only make you love every single character she introduces, but also immerse you into a vibrant icy world. The story is told from the FMC Alvara's point of view. I really enjoyed seeing her grow throughout the story and her love interest was so good. I love an actual slow burn and this was a real one. My favourite character was probably Rav and I do hope to see even more of them in the sequel. The back and forth between Alvara and Rav, as well as between Alvara and Boden were definitely some of my favourite parts. I found myself smiling from time to time at the stupid little jokes and the banter.
What I really enjoyed about this book, is that so much happens in these 440 pages and it felt like there wasn't a single boring moment. There's a perfect balance between adventure, action, character development and romance.
Read if you like:
✨ Slow burn
✨ Nordic influences
✨ Elves, humans and more
✨ Black cat x golden retriever
✨ Found family
✨ One bed
✨ Shifters
Review of advance copy received from Author
I was lucky enough to receive an ARC of this one from the author, and wow — what a debut.
There's a specific kind of book that doesn't just tell you a story — it makes you feel like you lived inside it. This was one of those.
Madeline built an entire world so carefully that by the time I was deep into it, I wasn't working to understand it anymore, I was just in it. Chapter by chapter, it unfolds so naturally.
But it was the characters that wrecked me. By the end of this book, I didn't just root for Alvara and Boden — I felt like I knew them. Alvara spends this whole story learning how to let people in after loss, after grief, after convincing herself she doesn't deserve to be loved that way. And Boden just... keeps showing up. Keeps choosing her, even when she pushes him away.
I cried. Not because something dramatic happened, but because I recognized it. That fear of being loved fully. That instinct to push away the person who keeps coming back anyway. If you've ever felt like you had to prove you deserved love before you could accept it, this book will find you.
And the slow burn? It's SLOW. If you need your couple fully together by the last page, brace yourself — you may be waiting for book two. But that's exactly what made it worth it.
If you like...
-Slow burns that make you WAIT for it
-FMCs healing from grief while becoming who they're meant to be
-MMCs who keep showing up no matter how many times they're pushed away
-Found family that hits as hard as the romance
-Rich, easy-to-follow world-building (elves, humans, dwarves, witches — it all just works)
-Nordic-inspired epic fantasy
-Books that compare to Daughter of No Worlds and Paladin's Grace
This is a debut. A DEBUT. I'm still thinking about these characters and I am not okay. 😭📖
There's a specific kind of book that doesn't just tell you a story — it makes you feel like you lived inside it. This was one of those.
Madeline built an entire world so carefully that by the time I was deep into it, I wasn't working to understand it anymore, I was just in it. Chapter by chapter, it unfolds so naturally.
But it was the characters that wrecked me. By the end of this book, I didn't just root for Alvara and Boden — I felt like I knew them. Alvara spends this whole story learning how to let people in after loss, after grief, after convincing herself she doesn't deserve to be loved that way. And Boden just... keeps showing up. Keeps choosing her, even when she pushes him away.
I cried. Not because something dramatic happened, but because I recognized it. That fear of being loved fully. That instinct to push away the person who keeps coming back anyway. If you've ever felt like you had to prove you deserved love before you could accept it, this book will find you.
And the slow burn? It's SLOW. If you need your couple fully together by the last page, brace yourself — you may be waiting for book two. But that's exactly what made it worth it.
If you like...
-Slow burns that make you WAIT for it
-FMCs healing from grief while becoming who they're meant to be
-MMCs who keep showing up no matter how many times they're pushed away
-Found family that hits as hard as the romance
-Rich, easy-to-follow world-building (elves, humans, dwarves, witches — it all just works)
-Nordic-inspired epic fantasy
-Books that compare to Daughter of No Worlds and Paladin's Grace
This is a debut. A DEBUT. I'm still thinking about these characters and I am not okay. 😭📖
September 24, 2026
WOW! What a superb debut book!
I was instantly captivated by the fantasy world building, the magic system, the different races, and the characters. This is a realm that includes humans, elves, dwarves, magic, and more. There is a created language, customs, and different lands (also I love how cool the weapons from the dwarves are!). The dialogue is witty, snappy, and the humor is SO smartly written into the prose. The voices of the characters really shine in the author's writing.
I really loved Alvara’s journey in this. She has been through unimaginable loss with her family, and she is such a great MC taking us on the journey with her. She's not perfect, she'll make mistakes, but she is someone you will absolutely love I think.
There is also a delicious slow burn between her and Boden (who I love and I want more chapters from his POV lol). I love how his sunshine ways and chatty Cathy personality offset her stern grumpiness. I love the slow fall that these two have for each other, and that while Alvara has fears about letting someone in and losing them and losing that friendship, these two just slowly become end game for each other.
(also I legit LOL-ed when I went to the glossary to look up a certain phrase - SO clever Madeline!!)
There are so many other characters I want to know more about. I think this is a 4 book series based on the news of the audiobook rights, so I cannot wait to continue reading about this world and these characters.
No steam in this one, but the TENSIONNN and the feels and the swoony way Alvara and Boden are despite the upcoming battles, will leave you absolutely charmed and in love with them!
If you are a fan of the found family trope - this is a must read!
I received a copy for an instagram tour - my thoughts are my own.
I was instantly captivated by the fantasy world building, the magic system, the different races, and the characters. This is a realm that includes humans, elves, dwarves, magic, and more. There is a created language, customs, and different lands (also I love how cool the weapons from the dwarves are!). The dialogue is witty, snappy, and the humor is SO smartly written into the prose. The voices of the characters really shine in the author's writing.
I really loved Alvara’s journey in this. She has been through unimaginable loss with her family, and she is such a great MC taking us on the journey with her. She's not perfect, she'll make mistakes, but she is someone you will absolutely love I think.
There is also a delicious slow burn between her and Boden (who I love and I want more chapters from his POV lol). I love how his sunshine ways and chatty Cathy personality offset her stern grumpiness. I love the slow fall that these two have for each other, and that while Alvara has fears about letting someone in and losing them and losing that friendship, these two just slowly become end game for each other.
(also I legit LOL-ed when I went to the glossary to look up a certain phrase - SO clever Madeline!!)
There are so many other characters I want to know more about. I think this is a 4 book series based on the news of the audiobook rights, so I cannot wait to continue reading about this world and these characters.
No steam in this one, but the TENSIONNN and the feels and the swoony way Alvara and Boden are despite the upcoming battles, will leave you absolutely charmed and in love with them!
If you are a fan of the found family trope - this is a must read!
I received a copy for an instagram tour - my thoughts are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
What if you lost the only family you had?
Would you lose purpose?
Will to go on and fight for your people?
What if you all the people around you have loved have let you down would you be willing to let anyone inside?
Could you learn to trust again?
Alvara must avenge her family but she has to learn to work with others when she used to doing everything by herself since the loss of her mother and sister. She has to go against a King who took them away from her and work with a guy who can't just shut up. But like does he have to be good looking which causes her to stare more than she likes. As she goes on this adventure she meets characters like Kat, Rav, and Aurilena who become like her family. Join these characters on adventure where you will learn how to fall in again, find new family, trust and let others in and fight for what you believe in and protect the people who deserve to be included in protection. Madeline Haiston has truly swept me away with this story and I feel I won't emotionally recover but that is okay because I know this won't be the last story I read from her and truly she has a way of drawing you into a story with the setting, characters and words. Please support and check out her new upcoming book.
Would you lose purpose?
Will to go on and fight for your people?
What if you all the people around you have loved have let you down would you be willing to let anyone inside?
Could you learn to trust again?
Alvara must avenge her family but she has to learn to work with others when she used to doing everything by herself since the loss of her mother and sister. She has to go against a King who took them away from her and work with a guy who can't just shut up. But like does he have to be good looking which causes her to stare more than she likes. As she goes on this adventure she meets characters like Kat, Rav, and Aurilena who become like her family. Join these characters on adventure where you will learn how to fall in again, find new family, trust and let others in and fight for what you believe in and protect the people who deserve to be included in protection. Madeline Haiston has truly swept me away with this story and I feel I won't emotionally recover but that is okay because I know this won't be the last story I read from her and truly she has a way of drawing you into a story with the setting, characters and words. Please support and check out her new upcoming book.
October 9, 2026
Forged in Fading is a great story, what stood out to me most was how much the story explores family, loss, and what it really takes to move forward.
I enjoyed watching the main characters find each other and, through their connection, discover parts of themselves they hadn’t been able to see before. Their relationship isn’t just about romance, it becomes part of their journey toward healing, understanding who they are, and figuring out how to carry the things they’ve lost without letting them define their future.
It’s a story that reminded me that sometimes moving forward doesn’t mean leaving the past behind. Sometimes it means learning how to live with it and allowing yourself to become someone new.
I enjoyed watching the main characters find each other and, through their connection, discover parts of themselves they hadn’t been able to see before. Their relationship isn’t just about romance, it becomes part of their journey toward healing, understanding who they are, and figuring out how to carry the things they’ve lost without letting them define their future.
It’s a story that reminded me that sometimes moving forward doesn’t mean leaving the past behind. Sometimes it means learning how to live with it and allowing yourself to become someone new.
August 30, 2026
Arc review!
“We all bleed same,”
I really enjoyed this book. It is much more than a fantasy novel. It is a powerful story about grief and loss. It deals with a lot of heavier topics and it does so in a very eloquent way. The ways in which Alvara deal with grief feel very real. I loved seeing her go on this journey not just physically, but also mentally. I could see her change and evolve throughout the story. Boden was a great character. He is fiercely loyal and cares about those he holds close. I truly loved the story and I’m so glad that I got to read it.
“We all bleed same,”
I really enjoyed this book. It is much more than a fantasy novel. It is a powerful story about grief and loss. It deals with a lot of heavier topics and it does so in a very eloquent way. The ways in which Alvara deal with grief feel very real. I loved seeing her go on this journey not just physically, but also mentally. I could see her change and evolve throughout the story. Boden was a great character. He is fiercely loyal and cares about those he holds close. I truly loved the story and I’m so glad that I got to read it.
July 22, 2026
I want to thank Madeline Haiston for the opportunity to let me arc read her debut novel- Forged in Fading. I recieved the copy through Net galley
This Nordic inspired romantasy is truly a one of a kind novel. The world building is unique and brings a new refreshing twist to the world of fantasy. The slow burn romance kept you wanting more and I appreciated the author not dragging out any miscommunications between the MMC and the FMC which tend to overshadow the plot.
Our FMC, Alvara, is dealing with grief from loss of her mother and sister and just wants to live her life as a blacksmith and tending to her father and herself when she’s suddenly thrust into a rebellion she had no idea her now faded (passed/dead) sister helped in against a corrupt king that forces her to rethink everything she believes and ends up being an integral part in.
Boden, our MMC, or our (teddy)bear shapeshifting hottie, is living a double agent type of life, trying to help the rebellion against the king while also trying to remain who he is without loosing himself to the terrible things he has to do on a daily basis.
I loved that the main character wasn’t human and we got to see things from a different perspective. I love that she didn’t know what a dog was and that it seems to be only a human thing to have one amongst other things. I also very much loved that we get to see how weapons can have special abilities too when forged a certain way by the dwarves.
Now I did take one star off for the things I didn’t like so let’s get into it : I think the dwarves weapons they supplied to the main character could have been expanded more. There could have been more scenes showing what all the weapons could truly do in a battle. I also didn’t like how a lot of the story felt rushed. For instance, battles where very short lived or times of strong emotion from deaths or almost deaths etc fell flat because the author chose to not make the scene longer or have more description to it for the emotion to come out accurately. I did appreciate that the characters dealt with their emotions through the book but at the moment of the happen stance I felt it fell flat. I also did love that there are different races introduced into the story, example Selkie, Demi elves, dwarves, witches etc, but sometimes it felt rushed and like an afterthought. I wish we could have seen more of each race and gotten to know more of them. The ending also felt rushed and I think things resolved a little too quickly.
Overall I actually really loved this book and will be recommending it to people! I also know this is the authors first book and I can’t wait to see what else she writes and how she expands on everything! This is also the first in a series and I can’t wait to see more of each of these characters!
If you love:
Slow burn
No spice
Unique World and magic system
Nordic inspired
Enemies to lovers
Found family
Then this is the book for you!
Thank you again to Madeline for letting me arc read your book and I’m excited to see more!
Also I LOVED that the author added a glossary and a pronunciation guide at the end!
This Nordic inspired romantasy is truly a one of a kind novel. The world building is unique and brings a new refreshing twist to the world of fantasy. The slow burn romance kept you wanting more and I appreciated the author not dragging out any miscommunications between the MMC and the FMC which tend to overshadow the plot.
Our FMC, Alvara, is dealing with grief from loss of her mother and sister and just wants to live her life as a blacksmith and tending to her father and herself when she’s suddenly thrust into a rebellion she had no idea her now faded (passed/dead) sister helped in against a corrupt king that forces her to rethink everything she believes and ends up being an integral part in.
Boden, our MMC, or our (teddy)bear shapeshifting hottie, is living a double agent type of life, trying to help the rebellion against the king while also trying to remain who he is without loosing himself to the terrible things he has to do on a daily basis.
I loved that the main character wasn’t human and we got to see things from a different perspective. I love that she didn’t know what a dog was and that it seems to be only a human thing to have one amongst other things. I also very much loved that we get to see how weapons can have special abilities too when forged a certain way by the dwarves.
Now I did take one star off for the things I didn’t like so let’s get into it : I think the dwarves weapons they supplied to the main character could have been expanded more. There could have been more scenes showing what all the weapons could truly do in a battle. I also didn’t like how a lot of the story felt rushed. For instance, battles where very short lived or times of strong emotion from deaths or almost deaths etc fell flat because the author chose to not make the scene longer or have more description to it for the emotion to come out accurately. I did appreciate that the characters dealt with their emotions through the book but at the moment of the happen stance I felt it fell flat. I also did love that there are different races introduced into the story, example Selkie, Demi elves, dwarves, witches etc, but sometimes it felt rushed and like an afterthought. I wish we could have seen more of each race and gotten to know more of them. The ending also felt rushed and I think things resolved a little too quickly.
Overall I actually really loved this book and will be recommending it to people! I also know this is the authors first book and I can’t wait to see what else she writes and how she expands on everything! This is also the first in a series and I can’t wait to see more of each of these characters!
If you love:
Slow burn
No spice
Unique World and magic system
Nordic inspired
Enemies to lovers
Found family
Then this is the book for you!
Thank you again to Madeline for letting me arc read your book and I’m excited to see more!
Also I LOVED that the author added a glossary and a pronunciation guide at the end!
July 25, 2026
ARC review
Unfortunately, this one wasn’t quite for me, although I can definitely see elements that other romantasy readers may enjoy.
I loved the idea of a stubborn FMC forging weapons, the magic system being tied to emotions, and the way magical abilities are connected to where someone is born. The slow-burn romance also had some lovely moments, and I enjoyed the romantic build-up.
For me, the pacing and writing style made it difficult to fully connect with the story. The plot moved very quickly, with some transitions feeling abrupt, and I often felt that there wasn’t quite enough time for certain events, relationships, or revelations to develop before the story moved on. Some elements also felt a little far-fetched to me, while other parts were explained in a way that didn’t always leave much room for the reader to interpret things for themselves.
I also found it difficult to warm to the writing style, and the introduction of some important figures and elements of the world, including the witches, came quite late in the story. Because of this, I struggled to become emotionally invested in the characters and the world.
Overall, this felt more YA than adult romantasy to me, despite having some elements I really enjoyed. The golden retriever vs. black cat dynamic, slow-burn romance, Nordic-inspired vibes, and only one bed trope were all appealing, but unfortunately the overall execution wasn’t quite right for me.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for the opportunity to read this early review copy. All thoughts are my own and I am sure there are other readers who will love this story.
Unfortunately, this one wasn’t quite for me, although I can definitely see elements that other romantasy readers may enjoy.
I loved the idea of a stubborn FMC forging weapons, the magic system being tied to emotions, and the way magical abilities are connected to where someone is born. The slow-burn romance also had some lovely moments, and I enjoyed the romantic build-up.
For me, the pacing and writing style made it difficult to fully connect with the story. The plot moved very quickly, with some transitions feeling abrupt, and I often felt that there wasn’t quite enough time for certain events, relationships, or revelations to develop before the story moved on. Some elements also felt a little far-fetched to me, while other parts were explained in a way that didn’t always leave much room for the reader to interpret things for themselves.
I also found it difficult to warm to the writing style, and the introduction of some important figures and elements of the world, including the witches, came quite late in the story. Because of this, I struggled to become emotionally invested in the characters and the world.
Overall, this felt more YA than adult romantasy to me, despite having some elements I really enjoyed. The golden retriever vs. black cat dynamic, slow-burn romance, Nordic-inspired vibes, and only one bed trope were all appealing, but unfortunately the overall execution wasn’t quite right for me.
Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for the opportunity to read this early review copy. All thoughts are my own and I am sure there are other readers who will love this story.
July 21, 2026
⭐️ 5/5
🧠 3/5
🌶️ 1/5
✧ ─── ❄︎ ⚔︎ ❅ ⚔︎ ❄︎ ─── ✧
🪿elves
🪿witches
🪿rebel group
🪿dwarves
🪿slowburn
✧ ─── ❄︎ ⚔︎ ❅ ⚔︎ ❄︎ ─── ✧
Thank you for allowing me to be apart of the street team and arc reading this wonderful book. The characters are so thought out and I truly fell in love with them.
Boden is absolutely amazing. But daddy, I love him.
This one would be great for fans of road of bones.
✧ ─── ❄︎ ⚔︎ ❅ ⚔︎ ❄︎ ─── ✧
https://www.instagram.com/kylieinpryt...
🧠 3/5
🌶️ 1/5
✧ ─── ❄︎ ⚔︎ ❅ ⚔︎ ❄︎ ─── ✧
🪿elves
🪿witches
🪿rebel group
🪿dwarves
🪿slowburn
✧ ─── ❄︎ ⚔︎ ❅ ⚔︎ ❄︎ ─── ✧
Thank you for allowing me to be apart of the street team and arc reading this wonderful book. The characters are so thought out and I truly fell in love with them.
Boden is absolutely amazing. But daddy, I love him.
This one would be great for fans of road of bones.
✧ ─── ❄︎ ⚔︎ ❅ ⚔︎ ❄︎ ─── ✧
https://www.instagram.com/kylieinpryt...
August 30, 2026
Thank you to Madeline Haiston for giving me access to this arc
Rating : ⭐⭐⭐⭐,75/5
⋆˚౨ৎ ⋆.˚ Overall thoughts : Forged in Fading is the first book in the Bones of Kings series and the setting/world building was a favorite thing of mine while reading. I have genuinely been on a fantasy kick lately and the books have been amazing. Not gonna lie, this took me sometime to finish and it is a long book, but by the end it is SO WORTH it. This story is about elves, humans and the fuid that happened a long time ago. The King of one of the elvan kingdoms has it against humans and demi-elves. But as the story goes by, we discover new details and the stakes get bigger. I didn't know what to expect from this book but the blurb has made me want to read it and as I said, I DEVOURED it. I loved the ending and the way there was no cliffhangers. That's another point that was gained in my rating.
⋆˚౨ৎ ⋆.˚ Alvara : The loss that she went through is something I can never imagine. I enjoyed watching the character development that she went through. From being lost in her grief to helping with the cause and the war that came upon them. I think that seeing her accept her loss and getting better by focusing on important things such as being in a new community and helping others against a danger that is looming over both elves and humans at the same time was a well thought of action. Grief is hard, and she showed that even if she got better, she will never forget her family.
⋆˚౨ৎ ⋆.˚ Boden : His character was such a breath of fresh air. He might seem bubbly and talkative, but there is much more to him than his powers. The work and the courage he put on for the cause that he believed in, helping others and fighting for their freedom. He is such an underatted character. Alvara and him are very similar with the way they don't let themselves forget their mistakes. But since they are the right fit for each other, they balanced each other out and helped eo SM. They saw through the other a lot and you bet i was giggling behind my screen.
Rating : ⭐⭐⭐⭐,75/5
⋆˚౨ৎ ⋆.˚ Overall thoughts : Forged in Fading is the first book in the Bones of Kings series and the setting/world building was a favorite thing of mine while reading. I have genuinely been on a fantasy kick lately and the books have been amazing. Not gonna lie, this took me sometime to finish and it is a long book, but by the end it is SO WORTH it. This story is about elves, humans and the fuid that happened a long time ago. The King of one of the elvan kingdoms has it against humans and demi-elves. But as the story goes by, we discover new details and the stakes get bigger. I didn't know what to expect from this book but the blurb has made me want to read it and as I said, I DEVOURED it. I loved the ending and the way there was no cliffhangers. That's another point that was gained in my rating.
⋆˚౨ৎ ⋆.˚ Alvara : The loss that she went through is something I can never imagine. I enjoyed watching the character development that she went through. From being lost in her grief to helping with the cause and the war that came upon them. I think that seeing her accept her loss and getting better by focusing on important things such as being in a new community and helping others against a danger that is looming over both elves and humans at the same time was a well thought of action. Grief is hard, and she showed that even if she got better, she will never forget her family.
⋆˚౨ৎ ⋆.˚ Boden : His character was such a breath of fresh air. He might seem bubbly and talkative, but there is much more to him than his powers. The work and the courage he put on for the cause that he believed in, helping others and fighting for their freedom. He is such an underatted character. Alvara and him are very similar with the way they don't let themselves forget their mistakes. But since they are the right fit for each other, they balanced each other out and helped eo SM. They saw through the other a lot and you bet i was giggling behind my screen.
Did Not Finish
September 21, 2026**Thank you for this Advanced Reader Copy that I received from Madeline Haiston**
Unfortunately this book wasn’t for me, but I hope that many others will enjoy and love it. I chose not to rate this book because I did not finish it at the 54% mark (page 271).
I’ll start with things that I did enjoy. Although “Forged in Fading” is marketed as an epic fantasy, I felt that it was more like a cozy fantasy, which worked out for me because I was in the mood for a cozy fantasy. The world building felt very cute, and the magic system was interesting. The magic of the elves depends on their kingdom of origin, with the kingdoms being based on the five seasons of the year. Elves who are born during the season of the respective kingdoms (e.g. during dalvi for Dalvians) have stronger magic. I enjoyed the slowburn romance because it felt natural and not based entirely on physical attraction and witty banter. It also wasn’t super obvious who the romantic love interest would be.
What I personally did not enjoy about the book was Alvara’s lack of agency in the book and the choppy pacing. I understand that Alvara is struggling with grief and depression; at the same time, I feel that the storytelling was very passive because most of the plot points were essentially happening to or being forced onto her. I ultimately decided to stop reading because, as someone who enjoys reading about military strategy, I felt disappointed by the big battle. There was a lot of lead-up but the battle itself ended very quickly. If you’re not someone who is interested in military strategy, then I think that you may not find this to be a problem.
Overall I am thankful for this opportunity to review this book and hope that those who would enjoy this book will find it. If you are in the mood for a cozy fantasy, then this may be the book for you.
Unfortunately this book wasn’t for me, but I hope that many others will enjoy and love it. I chose not to rate this book because I did not finish it at the 54% mark (page 271).
I’ll start with things that I did enjoy. Although “Forged in Fading” is marketed as an epic fantasy, I felt that it was more like a cozy fantasy, which worked out for me because I was in the mood for a cozy fantasy. The world building felt very cute, and the magic system was interesting. The magic of the elves depends on their kingdom of origin, with the kingdoms being based on the five seasons of the year. Elves who are born during the season of the respective kingdoms (e.g. during dalvi for Dalvians) have stronger magic. I enjoyed the slowburn romance because it felt natural and not based entirely on physical attraction and witty banter. It also wasn’t super obvious who the romantic love interest would be.
What I personally did not enjoy about the book was Alvara’s lack of agency in the book and the choppy pacing. I understand that Alvara is struggling with grief and depression; at the same time, I feel that the storytelling was very passive because most of the plot points were essentially happening to or being forced onto her. I ultimately decided to stop reading because, as someone who enjoys reading about military strategy, I felt disappointed by the big battle. There was a lot of lead-up but the battle itself ended very quickly. If you’re not someone who is interested in military strategy, then I think that you may not find this to be a problem.
Overall I am thankful for this opportunity to review this book and hope that those who would enjoy this book will find it. If you are in the mood for a cozy fantasy, then this may be the book for you.
July 13, 2026
Thank you to author, Madeline Haiston, for this ARC. All opinions are my own.
I absolutely adored this book. Perfect for fans of ACOTAR, Throne of Glass and Fourth Wing, this Nordic-inspired story had me hooked from the first page! The author has a way of taking old tropes and making them feel so fresh! The enemies-to-lovers slow burn was delicious and I appreciated the way things like misunderstandings and miscommunications were cleared up quickly and didn’t drag on. It felt much more realistic to the way adults interact, which was great considering the FMC is in her early 30s (thank youuu!) Boden is a dream and his banter was written so, so well. I’m completely in love with him. 💖 Alvara is such a badass and one of my favorite FMCs to date.
The pacing was fantastic and no part of the book dragged or felt like a struggle. The MCs felt like they were building a true relationship instead of a “lust at first sight” situation. The friendships were great and somehow I felt like I still knew characters that had passed before the start of the book! I would have liked a little more ✨something✨ at the very end. It felt like it ended a little abruptly, but I understand this is also the first book in a planned series and I am looking forward to the next installment!!! Please note this is a true slow burn and while there is no spice, the relationship building is 👌
I absolutely adored this book. Perfect for fans of ACOTAR, Throne of Glass and Fourth Wing, this Nordic-inspired story had me hooked from the first page! The author has a way of taking old tropes and making them feel so fresh! The enemies-to-lovers slow burn was delicious and I appreciated the way things like misunderstandings and miscommunications were cleared up quickly and didn’t drag on. It felt much more realistic to the way adults interact, which was great considering the FMC is in her early 30s (thank youuu!) Boden is a dream and his banter was written so, so well. I’m completely in love with him. 💖 Alvara is such a badass and one of my favorite FMCs to date.
The pacing was fantastic and no part of the book dragged or felt like a struggle. The MCs felt like they were building a true relationship instead of a “lust at first sight” situation. The friendships were great and somehow I felt like I still knew characters that had passed before the start of the book! I would have liked a little more ✨something✨ at the very end. It felt like it ended a little abruptly, but I understand this is also the first book in a planned series and I am looking forward to the next installment!!! Please note this is a true slow burn and while there is no spice, the relationship building is 👌
July 6, 2026
I just want to start by thanking Maddy for giving me the opportunity to be on her Bones of Kings street team and an ARC reader.
This really is an epic fantasy, with incredible world building that explores grief better than any other book I’ve read. Aiding character development, that creates a sense of found family.
You have Alvara the FMC, who has been through a lot to say the least. She’s an incredibly strong woman who ends up realising she wants to continue her sister’s legacy, after a traumatic event in which she ends up imprisoned by a king.
In enters Boden, the MMC, who again has been through a hell of a lot and is kind of living a double life. He is one of the kindest souls, who wants to help Alvara reach her full potential and see her own self worth.
Boden brings Alvara to join this rebel group that he sister was a part of, at first she’s hesitant and doesn’t think that this is really for her. But with Boden’s help and some amazing friends, she realises that she could make a real difference here. A chance to bring elves and humans together. To finish what her sister started.
There are humans, elves, demi-elves, witches and dwarves. Honestly, everything you want and more in a fantasy.
There is a romance element to this story, with a slow burn that really makes you route for both Alvara and Boden.
I truly became so invested in these characters and quite frankly still am, I’ve thought about them every day since finishing this book. I cannot wait for book two!
This really is an epic fantasy, with incredible world building that explores grief better than any other book I’ve read. Aiding character development, that creates a sense of found family.
You have Alvara the FMC, who has been through a lot to say the least. She’s an incredibly strong woman who ends up realising she wants to continue her sister’s legacy, after a traumatic event in which she ends up imprisoned by a king.
In enters Boden, the MMC, who again has been through a hell of a lot and is kind of living a double life. He is one of the kindest souls, who wants to help Alvara reach her full potential and see her own self worth.
Boden brings Alvara to join this rebel group that he sister was a part of, at first she’s hesitant and doesn’t think that this is really for her. But with Boden’s help and some amazing friends, she realises that she could make a real difference here. A chance to bring elves and humans together. To finish what her sister started.
There are humans, elves, demi-elves, witches and dwarves. Honestly, everything you want and more in a fantasy.
There is a romance element to this story, with a slow burn that really makes you route for both Alvara and Boden.
I truly became so invested in these characters and quite frankly still am, I’ve thought about them every day since finishing this book. I cannot wait for book two!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 16, 2026
Thank you to the author for the advance readers copy
This book pulled so many of my hearts strings. As someone who has lost both parents I felt the pain and grief Alvara, the FMC, is experiencing. I really like the space the author gave for Alvara to experience the grief and have her self sabotage moments. I really enjoyed the character growth shown by Alvara and many of the side characters as the story progresses. The story was well written with its magical people and the magic system involved. I am now obsessed with elf’s, polar bears, and Vigi!!! We also meet Boden, the MMC, who had me swooning! He was everything Alvara needed to help her heal from her grief. Someone that protected her and gave her time and space to heal. Someone that taught her how to process her pain and yeah her what it means to truly live and be ok after so much loss. This book holds a special place in my heart.
❄️ elemental magic
❄️ black cat + golden retriever
❄️ only one bed
❄️ found family
❄️ Norse/ Nordic vibes
❄️ blacksmith FMC
❄️ slow-burn romance
❄️ Elves, Dwarves, Witches, & Selkies
This book pulled so many of my hearts strings. As someone who has lost both parents I felt the pain and grief Alvara, the FMC, is experiencing. I really like the space the author gave for Alvara to experience the grief and have her self sabotage moments. I really enjoyed the character growth shown by Alvara and many of the side characters as the story progresses. The story was well written with its magical people and the magic system involved. I am now obsessed with elf’s, polar bears, and Vigi!!! We also meet Boden, the MMC, who had me swooning! He was everything Alvara needed to help her heal from her grief. Someone that protected her and gave her time and space to heal. Someone that taught her how to process her pain and yeah her what it means to truly live and be ok after so much loss. This book holds a special place in my heart.
❄️ elemental magic
❄️ black cat + golden retriever
❄️ only one bed
❄️ found family
❄️ Norse/ Nordic vibes
❄️ blacksmith FMC
❄️ slow-burn romance
❄️ Elves, Dwarves, Witches, & Selkies
August 31, 2026
I enjoyed the world building and story telling. Although the magic system was basically elemental, it was based on which region someone was from and what season they were born within. Alvara has already lost her sister and mother and her father is slowly fading. She puts all her efforts into blacksmithing until one day she is sent to Ela to deliver a sword and her whole world changes. She is forced from her home and her city, she has to learn to use her magic again when she had closed it off for so long. She meets people who want to befriend her, but she stays closed off not wanting to lose anyone else. That is until Boden, she feels safe with him and they have a lot in common, including loss. They all are fighting against a crazy king who wants to eradicate humans and demi-elves. There is a lot of action and great banter between all of the characters. There is a love story, but it is slow moving, starts as friendship and grows from there. It's really a sweet part of the story. And eventually Alvara becomes part of the found family.
August 28, 2026
Forged in Fading is the first book in a slow-burn, Nordic-inspired epic fantasy romance series by debut author Madeline Haiston.
i had so much fun reading this book! We first meet the FMC Alvara, a grieving blacksmith, tasked with delivering a sword to another kingdom, but ends up in the dungeons instead (oops).
The writing and storytelling were amazing, and Alvara’s grief was portrayed in such a beautiful way! The trauma and grief, and the emotional growth were so inspiring, and I enjoyed every second of it.
My only bone to pick with this book, though, is that it suffered from white-room syndrome, and the pacing was a teensy bit awkward at the start. Still, Forged in Fading is an amazing debut, and I look forward to seeing more from its author!
So grateful to have received this ARC from Madeline Haiston! All thoughts and opinions are my own.
i had so much fun reading this book! We first meet the FMC Alvara, a grieving blacksmith, tasked with delivering a sword to another kingdom, but ends up in the dungeons instead (oops).
The writing and storytelling were amazing, and Alvara’s grief was portrayed in such a beautiful way! The trauma and grief, and the emotional growth were so inspiring, and I enjoyed every second of it.
My only bone to pick with this book, though, is that it suffered from white-room syndrome, and the pacing was a teensy bit awkward at the start. Still, Forged in Fading is an amazing debut, and I look forward to seeing more from its author!
So grateful to have received this ARC from Madeline Haiston! All thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 11, 2026
Forged in Fading was such an enjoyable fantasy read! I loved the rich world building, unique magic system, and the way the story balanced action, emotion, and political intrigue.
Slow burn romance ❤️🔥
Enemies to allies 🤺
Found family 🥹
Political intrigue 👑
Magic 🧙🏼
Strong FMC 🗡️
The characters were easy to connect with! I especially enjoyed watching the main character grow into her strength while navigating impossible choices. 🫣
The slow burn romance was woven into the story perfectly, adding tension without overshadowing the plot!! ☺️
By the end I was completely invested in the characters and excited to see where the series goes next!!!
⭐⭐⭐⭐/5
Release date: August 28, 2026
Thank you to the author (Madeline Haiston) & Netgalley for the ARC. All opinions are my own!
Slow burn romance ❤️🔥
Enemies to allies 🤺
Found family 🥹
Political intrigue 👑
Magic 🧙🏼
Strong FMC 🗡️
The characters were easy to connect with! I especially enjoyed watching the main character grow into her strength while navigating impossible choices. 🫣
The slow burn romance was woven into the story perfectly, adding tension without overshadowing the plot!! ☺️
By the end I was completely invested in the characters and excited to see where the series goes next!!!
⭐⭐⭐⭐/5
Release date: August 28, 2026
Thank you to the author (Madeline Haiston) & Netgalley for the ARC. All opinions are my own!
July 11, 2026
Such an incredible journey! I didn’t want it to end!
The world building is incredible and detailed but at no time does it feel dense or slows the progression of the plot. You are immediately immersed in the world and it keeps opening up more and more as the story progresses. The different realms and races of mythical creatures is a fantasy readers dream.
This is the slowest of burns and the yearning has me hooked. Alvara deserves every ounce of happiness. Boden the man/elf that you are. No notes.
There are so many Easter eggs and nods to mythology, classics, and everything that makes a nerd heart happy. I will definitely be doing a reread before the next one!!
Thank you Madeline for the opportunity to read this ARC. It was a delightful honor.
The world building is incredible and detailed but at no time does it feel dense or slows the progression of the plot. You are immediately immersed in the world and it keeps opening up more and more as the story progresses. The different realms and races of mythical creatures is a fantasy readers dream.
This is the slowest of burns and the yearning has me hooked. Alvara deserves every ounce of happiness. Boden the man/elf that you are. No notes.
There are so many Easter eggs and nods to mythology, classics, and everything that makes a nerd heart happy. I will definitely be doing a reread before the next one!!
Thank you Madeline for the opportunity to read this ARC. It was a delightful honor.
August 27, 2026
Review: Forged in Fading by Madeline Haiston
I’m rounding my rating up to 4 stars on Goodreads (a true 3.5 for me), because while I had a few pacing struggles, there’s no denying how beautifully written Forged in Fading by Forged in Fading truly is.
This story takes its time building both the world and the emotional depth of the characters. The writing itself is immersive and lyrical, and you can feel the care that Madeline Haiston put into crafting the atmosphere and foundation of the story. However, for me, the buildup felt a bit drawn out compared to how quickly the ending came together. After investing so much time in the world and its complexities, I found myself wishing the resolution had been given more space to unfold.
That said, one of the standout elements was the tension between Alvara and Boden. Their dynamic added a compelling layer to the story and kept me engaged, especially during the slower portions. Their interactions carried a weight that balanced out some of the pacing issues.
Overall, this was a thoughtfully written and emotionally rich read, even if it didn’t fully land the pacing for me. I’m very grateful to have received an ARC—thank you to Madeline for trusting me with an early read. I’m definitely interested in seeing what she writes next.
I’m rounding my rating up to 4 stars on Goodreads (a true 3.5 for me), because while I had a few pacing struggles, there’s no denying how beautifully written Forged in Fading by Forged in Fading truly is.
This story takes its time building both the world and the emotional depth of the characters. The writing itself is immersive and lyrical, and you can feel the care that Madeline Haiston put into crafting the atmosphere and foundation of the story. However, for me, the buildup felt a bit drawn out compared to how quickly the ending came together. After investing so much time in the world and its complexities, I found myself wishing the resolution had been given more space to unfold.
That said, one of the standout elements was the tension between Alvara and Boden. Their dynamic added a compelling layer to the story and kept me engaged, especially during the slower portions. Their interactions carried a weight that balanced out some of the pacing issues.
Overall, this was a thoughtfully written and emotionally rich read, even if it didn’t fully land the pacing for me. I’m very grateful to have received an ARC—thank you to Madeline for trusting me with an early read. I’m definitely interested in seeing what she writes next.
August 28, 2026
The book is so good! It feels so Nordic. It makes me want to travel and see the Nordic countries myself. The writing showing the characters emotions was well-done as well. I could feel the loss she felt. I also liked the message it sends to the readers about always worrying about the past. I know it’s something I’ve had a problem with it so it really connected to me. I feel like my only concern with the book is that it felt rushed. There were scenes I wish were longer and that some topics were explained more. I’m sure doing so would have required it to be separated into two books, but I don’t think it would have been a problem. I’d have read them. Either way I love the story and I’m excited to see what comes next.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 331 reviews