In Japan, a driving instructor and her adult student discover a dead body in the trunk of one of the training cars. Unfortunately, the police don't really have the resources to investigate it... after all, an asteroid is due to impact the Earth in a matter of months. A big enough asteroid that no one is expected to survive the impact, except perhaps those rich or connected enough to get into some kind of deep underground bunkers. Society is starting to wind down, people engaging in unfinished business... but these two women decide they're going to try and find the killer.
Disclaimer: I got a free advance copy of this book through NetGalley. I don't think it affected my review.
You know, if I had a nickel for every time I read a story involving people trying to solve a murder while an asteroid is months away from hitting Earth and killing everybody... well, I'd have two nickels, but still, it's weird that it's happened twice. The Last Policeman (and its sequels, successively closer to the impact date) have become some of my favorites, but there's nothing particularly proprietary about any individual idea, it's how you execute it that's important, and I was excited to read this particular spin on the same idea. I won't even compare them directly except to acknowledge that similarities exist.
My reaction to this book was somewhat mixed, with ups and down, although on balance I land firmly on the side of a positive feeling. Frankly, I loved the start... and I kinda loved the end too. The middle lost me a little... not in terms of what was going on in the plot, but just my enthusiasm. Unfortunately the middle is "the murder mystery" aspect. That is, once they started making revelations of what happened and why, it just didn't satisfy me as much as I was hoping. Not particularly bad, but just... I felt a little let down. Perhaps because it seemed a little too focused on 'twists' in the first place. Like, to me, a book set during society's slow collapse before a widely accepted end of the world is the perfect kind of book where you can violate norms and tropes of mysteries and police procedurals and have a killer essentially just being random, with no connection to anyone else. Heck, you can even have it being one where they don't actually solve the case and it's about just the journey, the process of trying to do the right thing and get justice when arguably, nothing matters anymore. Instead, the author throws up suspects connected to the main characters and dramatic revelations and even though the eventual resolution was reasonably good, and even some of the earlier twists made a good moment of shock that made me want to go back and rereread to look for clues, in general it just felt a little too... written. Like a murder mystery, but one where you can't just immerse into the story and forget you're reading one. And, beyond that... a few of the choices for what happened, unbeknownst to the characters, before the story really got going, felt like they were just missing what could have been more interesting story beats.
That said, I was really into just vibing with the two main characters, who I really liked following, and seeing the little glimpses of people just coping with a world that's come to the end of the line. And, I liked the particular grim optimism of the specific ending scene, even though I'm at least a month between reading and writing, it still sticks in my mind, which says something (at least, with my mind lately).
The book's not just set in Japan, it was written by a Japanese author in Japanese, and as such, this is a translation. Sometimes translations can read a bit stilted... really nobody's fault, it's just things that work in one language don't work in another, and translators often have to compromise between either rendering faithfully and feeling awkward at times in the new language, or flowing naturally to English readers but with some amount of invention to fill in the gaps. Having neither ability nor the access to read the original Japanese text, I can't actually speak to the level of faithfulness, but I'll say there were only a couple times that I felt that bit of jarring "oh right, this sentence is a bit awkward, I forgot it was a translation" sense that I get pretty often with translations, so... again, can't comment on how GOOD a translation it is, but I'll say it's at least pretty SMOOTH compared to others I've read, particularly from Japanese.
All in all, I'd probably put it at about 3.5 stars, but willing to round up to four stars, and well-worth checking out if it's the kind of premise that tickles you, as it did me.