Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Ask Me How I Know

Not yet published
Expected 2 Mar 27
Rate this book
After the sudden loss of their father, five sisters and their mother must come together to confront their fractured past and find a new understanding of family, sisterhood, and what it means to forgive in this big, rich, deeply felt debut novel.

With their father’s death, the five Carpenter sisters worry for their widowed mother. A complicated, moody woman, Evelyn struggled with raising and being close to her daughters. Believing their complex needs were better served by their father’s easy love, she retreated into her volunteer work at the church where she felt most at home, leaving the girls to fend for themselves.

Now without the guidepost of her husband, Evelyn is adrift. Her daughters fear she will withdraw entirely without their intervention, so they agree to take on the burden of her care, even though none of them is in a position to do so. Morgan’s bitter heart is broken over a doomed love affair with a married co-worker, making her a cliché she’s tried desperately to avoid becoming. Caroline’s perfectly coiffed life is upended when she makes a shocking discovery about her son and realizes that in her need for control, she’s sacrificed others’ trust. Shy Beth is thrown into a harsh spotlight when her beloved-by-all husband runs for mayor. Jillian is about to marry her childhood sweetheart, a man who has become to feel more like a brother than a fiancé—a truth she can’t admit, especially to herself. And Ashlyn, the youngest, has endured a lifetime of shame because of a terrible secret she never meant to reveal. On the verge of becoming a mother herself, she’s ready to confront the family about the truth of what happened all those years ago.

As the sisters grieve their father and shoulder the care of their mother, they must make a choice: band together or fall utterly, spectacularly apart. A sweeping story of family and shared history, Ask Me How I Know is an intimate and heartbreakingly warm portrait of a family and the decisions they make—a story of what it means to be a sister, a mother, and a woman.

272 pages, Hardcover

Expected publication March 16, 2027

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Mary Grace Colangelo

1 book17 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
16 (80%)
4 stars
4 (20%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews
Profile Image for Lysandra.
358 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 21, 2026
Thanks to John Murray Press (John Murray) and NetGalley for the opportunity of reading this ARC! The review is personal and unaltered by external factors.

5/5

“Ask Me How I Know” by Mary Grace Colangelo is a social fresco following the lives of five sisters — Caroline, Beth, Morgan, Jillian and Ashlyn — and their mother, Evelyn, following the death of their father. Offering a vast palette of ages, the novel allows the reader to experience womanhood at various stages and in different situations, Colangelo having an undeniable talent of eviscerating the very nucleus of a woman’s heart, regardless of her experiences. It is worth mentioning that this is a particularly strong debut novel, and experiencing this book as a piece of art has made Colangelo an artist, an author for me to follow from now on.

At a rather surrealistic level, the novel described itself within by having a side-character describe the relationship between the siblings and their mother through an entertained yet objective lens — « It’s like “Little Women” meets “Real Housewives”. » Consequently, the plot is character-driven, the relationship between the women depicted being the main focus, along with their healing journey both together and separately, in their private lives.

The characters are all fleshed out extremely well, depicting different stages of a woman’s life and the issues which arise with it.

Caroline, the eldest sister who has always been the one to keep everyone organised and together, finds herself placed in an unexpected situation by something related to her twelve-year-old son, thus making her feel that she is helpless, unable to regain control and, first and foremost, protect her child. Nothing can prepare a mother for such an experience, and Caroline shines through having the best intentions and still respecting her son as his own person. I enjoyed her relationship with her husband, Greg, too, them being a very lovely couple as well as parents.

Beth, a housewife and mother of five, finds herself disconnected from her own person. She is always doing something for someone else and barely has time to think of herself, to the extent that she even has complexes regarding her body. Her journey of healing and not only reconnecting with herself but also accepting whom she is and further working on improving herself is delicately and tenderly portrayed, yet with a raw and poignant directness. As a reader, one can’t help but cheer for the sweet Beth, wanting only the very best for her. Her relationship with her husband and children is also delightful, filled with love at all times.

Morgan, and my personal favourite out of all sisters, is a successful career woman who finds herself dealing with the ghosts of her past, trying her best to overcome a trauma. Her life spirals out of control as she is yet again given a poor deal, but Morgan perseveres; her healing journey is deeply connected to both Evelyn and Ashlyn, the three of them being especially intertwined. Morgan’s selflessness with regards to her family is a beauty in itself; despite her own issues, she loves wholly, without holding back, and is there, always, in times of need. A true sister.

Jillian, my other favourite, has a different challenge; she finds herself in the middle of her wedding planning, dealing with both grief and doubt, when she receives a promotion, a possibility to achieve success beyond her age due to her excellent work performance and etiquette, a change for the better. Her inner turmoil regarding her life is representative of many women’s, when one has to pick between herself and others, when one considers asking the question of whether or not she should prioritise her own person in her own life. Her (semi-)open end was exhilarating.

Ashlyn, the youngest, is heavily pregnant and in a happy relationship with her husband, but the regrets of her past catch up to her upon the imminent change to becoming a mother. Her storyline was, again, intertwined with Morgan’s, and her own acceptance regarding the feelings she’s held towards her older sister was beautiful. Sometimes we do painful things to the people we love, even if they are acts of protection and done with the best intentions. Ashlyn’s story is very telling.

Last, but definitely not least, Evelyn, the mother and the recurring leitmotif of the novel, as each sister is a different image of their mother, cue “Ask Me How I Know”. Evelyn’s character is quite polarising, but it is so tenderly and delicately handled by the author, thus making her a complex figure with her own grief and healing to deal with it. It is only when the mother heals that the others follow.

The prose is third-person narration and reveals the perspectives of all women; I have particularly enjoyed the very subtle differences in vocabulary, cadence and overall voice in each of the chapters. One could very well tell that these women are all so very different but yet somehow similar, apart yet together, related, sisters. Very beautiful reflection of their relationship in the prose at a structural level, a work of art in itself.

As far as recommendations go, I feel everyone who enjoys an accurate portrayal of the bond of sisterhood, with both the good and the bad, will regard this book very fondly. Fans of “Little Women” by Louisa May Alcott, “Pride and Prejudice” by Jane Austen and even “Book Lovers” by Emily Henry will surely love the Carpenter sisters.
1 review
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 17, 2026
To me, it’s Little Women for a contemporary audience—five sisters navigating the loss of their father while caring for their difficult mother. Each chapter drops you inside a different family member’s head: shy Beth, naive Ashlyn, ambitious Jillian, black sheep Morgan, eldest daughter Caroline grappling with questions about her son’s identity, and even their socially awkward but perceptive mother, Evelyn.

I found myself relating to every character, even when their circumstances were nothing like mine. The chapters are short and propulsive. I breezed through it. A warm, uplifting story about resilience and forgiveness.
Profile Image for Farah G.
2,680 reviews30 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 18, 2026
The five Carpenter sisters are dealing with a lot. Not just the burden of handling their mother, which is a challenge in and of itself, but also the grief they are struggling with over the death of their father.

And as if that were not bad enough, each of the sisters feels as if she is at a personal crossroads of her own - whether related to a sense of grievance over family dynamics, or a challenge that relates to their phase of life, or the problems they face due to their individual circumstances.

This is an interesting insight into family dynamics - particularly as they relate to sisterhood. As someone who has not experienced this personally, I perhaps relate less than others might - but the story is entertaining, regardless. It gets 3.5 stars.

I received a free copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review
693 reviews31 followers
August 3, 2026
I’m a sucker for stories about sisters. If you like Mary Beth Kean and Claire Lombardo, this book is for you.
Profile Image for Josie Taylor.
82 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 19, 2026
I got the opportunity to read this book early, and I adored it! I think many of my goodreads will love this one :)
Profile Image for Ellen Ross.
726 reviews97 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 11, 2026
Absolutely loved this book about a family and all their drama and chaos. Every sibling is going through something different while they and their mom navigate the recent death of their dad. The issues are so so relatable and how they handle things is so realistic and relevant. I read this in one sitting because I just couldn’t step away from this family. They have their flaws but that’s what makes me like them even more. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for Jackie.
185 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 30, 2026
I have been in a reading funk and this was just the book to get me reading again. Liked the characters, appreciated the family dynamics, and enjoyed seeing the characters grow and learn. My only complaint would be the end- it felt abrupt yet also felt finished so cannot pinpoint what felt off to me.

Thanks to NetGalley for an advanced reader copy of this book.
Profile Image for Debi Canterbury.
11 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 17, 2026
This family journey is one I still replay in my mind. I love the sister dynamics that read hilarious, heart-warming, heartbreaking, and authentic. I appreciate how propulsive the book reads while the nuanced layers remain with you. Cannot wait to recommend to my book club!
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews