This novel comprises two storylines that are primarily related by the fact that they take place on the Toronto Islands. Living in Toronto, I'm sentimental about the islands and the setting contributed to my enjoyment of the novel. The author does a great job of evoking time and place, sights and sounds, in both the historical storyline in the 1900s where Hanlan's Point was an amusement park, and the contemporary storyline. Her prose is also insightful and evocative in describing the overwhelming feelings of falling in love experienced by Bette and Freddy and the sense of grief and loss experienced by Joss. The main characters are all believable and empathetic. However, I didn't like the intertwining of the two storylines. Since the chapters about Joss were so short, I found it jarring and distracting when they were inserted into the historical storyline. I kept wondering what the contemporary storyline had to do with the historical one; lesbians on the Toronto Islands didn't seem to be a strong enough link for me. The historical storyline was far more enjoyable than the contemporary one but that may have been because it was fleshed out more. There seemed to be some untapped potential in the contemporary storyline. I also didn't like how either of the storylines ended. The historical storyline ending was melodramatic and a little too Romeo-and-Juliet for me. And I simply didn't get the contemporary storyline ending. I think it would've been better if the author wrote two separate stories and delved deeper into each one. Overall, a short easy read that was good but had the potential to be great.