I came home looking for redemption, not a second chance with the man my heart never forgot...
Noelle Running away a month before my wedding was the hardest choice I ever made. But crawling back thirteen years later with my life in shambles might be worse.
I’m jobless and homeless with a laundry list of apologies to make. But as an eldest daughter, my motto is “I’m fine.”
Only it’s not fine, and I’m tired of pretending.
I have a place to live, thanks to my conniving little sister, but my landlord is NOT supposed to be my ex-fiancé, hockey captain, Cal Satterfield. He’s not supposed to be my new boss either. But his daughter needs a nanny, and I’ve always been a sucker for those blue eyes.
I have plenty of bridges to mend, and Cal wants to break down the walls between us. Like a second chance is possible.
If only I were brave enough to believe it.
Cal
Thirteen years, two months, and seventeen days.
That’s how long I’ve waited for the girl who got away.
And finally, Noelle Shepherd is back.
Logically, I shouldn’t find her this enchanting. And I definitely shouldn’t hire her as my daughter’s nanny. However, logic has never been my strong suit.
It might be the worst decision I’ve ever made, or the second chance I’ve always prayed for. Because despite the history between us, Noelle is still the one I want to come home to.
I’ll do everything I can to prove to her I’ve changed.
This time, I’m playing for keeps.
Falling Back to You is a hockey rom-com featuring a second chance between a single dad and the nanny, plenty of heartfelt healing, everyday faith, swoony banter, and laugh aloud small town shenanigans—all without the spice.
Morgan Taylor Giesbrecht fell in love with fictional realms at a young age and quickly began writing tales of her own--full of hope, brave living in a dark world, and unexpected love stories for the crusty romantics (like herself). She’s a hobbit at heart (but not in height) with deep roots in the past, who loves the occasional adventure, accidentally talks in a British accent on occasion, and has the dry humour to match. When she isn’t writing or reading a book on her never ending to-be-read list, she can be found drinking copious amounts of tea, rewatching comfort shows for the umpteenth time, hanging out with family and friends, reorganising her bookshelves, or playing Christmas music year-round. British Columbia, Canada is the place she calls home, nestled in the foothills.
Hey, friend! 🧡 Welcome to Serenity Springs, Idaho!
If you’re new here, hi! And if you’re a returning visitor, I’m so happy you’re back!
Cal Satterfield stole readers’ hearts (& mine) all the way back in Terms and Traditions, and it was only fair to give him his time in the spotlight.
This story of forgiveness and redemption is for the ones who’ve held it together with a smile and never let anyone see their frayed edges. It’s for the ones who finally broke and the ones who are still healing. Who are learning it’s okay to accept help and that their worth isn’t tied to their accomplishments.
From one eldest daughter to another, I see you. You are worthy of love just for being you; you don’t have to earn it. And for the chronically ill girlies, I see you, too. You’re braver than you know. 🫶🏻
I hope you enjoy this fall adventure into the world of second chances, small town shenanigans, tender moments, and a group of hockey players who might steal your heart (& take over the group chat)! 🤭
This was so stinking cute!!! It is also, from my understanding as I haven’t read many, a unique approach to a second chance romance where the main characters aren’t at all bitter and snarly at each other and didn’t fall apart for stupid reasons, as many of these types of romances appear to be (it’s actually very similar to my other favorite second chance romance story, Second Chance Superhero by H. L. Burke) and I really like how Morgan approached it.
My heart broke for Noelle as I’ve felt many of the same family and friend issues she’s dealt with, and I’m so happy she eventually found hope and healing from it all and reconnected with Cal’s family. Cal was wonderful and funny (I especially loved his belief in twin telepathy with Greyson while Greyson was just like please stop, lol) and his interactions with Khia melted my heart, those were honestly some of my favorite parts of the whole story, they are so sweet together.
The romance was the sweetest, built on a foundation of friendship and determination on Cal’s end to not give it up for anything, and I loved the progression of them falling back/further in love then they were before. And as always for this series, the friendship, family, and found family bonds were just as strong as the romance and also so necessary to their relationship as a whole, which I really love to see and think Morgan writes so well and uniquely to the romance genre, which usually just hyper focuses on the couple and no one else.
The fall and small town vibes were also immaculate and the continued presence of Jerry the devil cat is nothing short of hilarious, lol.
Violence: in the past a character was in a car accident (not shown); injuries and blood (not detailed); two guys beat each other up in hockey (not detailed); a guy punched another’s nose (not detailed)
Sexual: married women in two separate families cheated on their husbands (not either of the MCs); kissing (not detailed); mild suggestive hints
Alcohol/Drugs: a woman died of drug overdose (only mentioned)
Other: a character’s mom died of cancer; grief over lost loved ones; a neglectful family
****Note: I received a free copy of the book from the author/publisher. All thoughts and opinions are most assuredly my own and I wasn’t required to write a positive review. If I was I wouldn’t have read it. 😜****
Another beautiful romance from Morgan! Cal and Noelle’s second chance story was so sweet! I love the way Cal took care of Noelle. He was so thoughtful and caring. And he was the sweetest dad to Khia. Noelle was a great fmc. She was sweet and kind. She loved taking care of people, and while she did that, nobody really took time to take care of her. But I love that Cal showed up and took care of her, and showed her that she doesn’t have to do everything on her own. As the eldest daughter, I could relate to Noelle’s struggles in many ways. And I appreciate the faith themes that were in the book. It was truly a beautiful story about redemption, forgiveness, and grace, it made me tear up multiple times. 🥹 There was something so beautiful and refreshing about the Satterfields big family. I love the way they always showed up for each other and how deeply they cared about each other. The teasing between the siblings was great! I found myself laughing at their banter many times. Cal and Grayson’s bond was especially remarkable, since they’re twins. I loved their brotherly bond so much. I definitely recommend this whole series!
tropes: 💛childhood best friends 💛second chance 💛fall romance 💛single dad x nanny 💛faith themes 💛small town 💛forced proximity 💛hockey player mmc 💛chronic illness rep 💛he takes care of her 💛found family 💛dual pov
Did I like the style? Yes! Was I super excited to read a book about someone going back to deal with the hurt they caused yes! Am I possibly going to try to read this book again in the future? I think so. As it was, I just was having trouble with the fact that EVERYONE is just welcoming Noelle back and doesn't seem that hurt about her just walking out of their life. I did love seeing forgiveness being extended and grace given, but I felt it was totally unrealistic that all these people would just let her fit back into their lives like she hadn't hurt them. I was 15% in, so maybe there is some of that coming but... I just wasn't feeling like finishing.
Falling Back to You by Morgan Giesbrecht ⭐️My rating: 5/5 📚Book #3 of “The Reluctant Romantics” ❤️🔥Spice level: closed-door 🤬Language: none ⚠️CW: infertility, chronic illness, dysfunctional family dynamics; mentions of PPD and drug overdose (off-page)
I’m convinced this book is for the eldest daughters - the ones who feel like love has to be earned, the “glue” kids that had to hold everything together and be perfect…that felt they didn’t deserve grace or forgiveness when they messed up…
so in other words, this one really resonated with me❤️🩹 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Second chance romances can be hit or miss for me, but Cal and Noelle’s story was PERFECTLY done! They are the epitome of “right person, wrong time”. I love how they both had growth to do and the reader can see the contrast through the past and present chapters. I also adored how much grace was a part of this story. I loved seeing Noelle put in the work to mend bridges and how she learned to accept grace🥲❤️🩹
“I know a thing or two about atonement. But I also know about grace. Guilt is a prison; grace is a key. Make amends but move forward.”
My most favorite thing though was watching a stubborn, perfectionist eldest daughter be loved by a man who cherishes her. Cal made her see that his love for her was never earned by anything she did, but just by being herself - and the way they tied it all back to our true value ultimately coming from our Creator? ✋🏻🥲❤️ it had my heart all fuzzy
“My love doesn’t have conditions, Elle.” ^^^like c’mon…be still my heart😭🫶🏻🫠
Things I loved about this book: -an actual realistic and believable second chance romance💕 -the most wholesome found family vibes🥹 -faith interwoven through the whole story with a heavy emphasis on what it means to heal and be forgiven🕊️ -healthy female friendships -a do-it-myself eldest daughter falling for the golden retriever who loves her like it’s breathing and takes care of her🥲 -the nicknames😍 -the texting group chats🤣 -Macy’s spontaneous prayers🙏🏻 -“I’ll handle it” and “Let me take care of you” 🫠 -how he actually prayed for a second chance with her😭
Obsessed with the Satterfield found family and cannot wait for the next love story!! Make sure you read Nash & Stephanie’s and Greyson & Paisley’s stories first!! It really strengthens the story to have their background🫶🏻
I always get jealous when people say they find so many characters to read about that they relate to. I don’t usually relate to most of the characters I read about.
Enter Noelle, the FMC in this story. First of all her name is Noelle and my middle name is Noelle. She’s a tall girl, I’m a tall girl. She has chronic pain that changed her life overnight, I have chronic pain that changed my life overnight. She had to quit her job in healthcare that she loved because of her health, I had to quit my job in healthcare that I loved because of my health. I could go on, but all of that to say my favorite part of this book was being able to relate so closely with a character and see parts of myself in her story.
I always love Morgan’s writing. This is my third book by her and she’s such a trusted romance author for me. The way she weaves faith into her stories is so beautiful and real without ever feeling preachy or cheesy.
Morgan, if you see this, don’t keep reading!🙈 Listen this is still a four star book. I really enjoyed it and highly recommend it but I wish I would’ve seen more chemistry between Noelle and Cal. And Cal is described as such a fun, golden retriever energy type guy and I feel like his character was a bit one-dimensional and I wanted him to pop so much more.
I’m an absolute goner for a good hockey romance, and Falling Back to You was everything I wanted. After reading In Every Chapter, I could not wait for Cal’s story. The author has an amazing way of writing characters who feel real and pull you in.
Cal and Noelle’s meeting after thirteen years was perfect. Reading about them navigating forgiveness, things that changed over the years, and figuring out what they wanted was the best.
Oh, and the text threads. I don’t know why but I love a good conversation through text in a book. Macy and Noelle’s friendship shined through each bubble notification. The family group chat and team thread had me laughing too. I’m smiling just thinking about them. The LOTR jokes were still plentiful and welcome.
This was a wonderful story about second chances and how the Lord can take some of our biggest mistakes and turn them into something beautiful. If you’re looking for a book that’ll make you want spiced hot chocolate, light your favorite Fall scented candle, and leave you wanting to be real-life friends with the characters, then you’ll love Falling Back to You.
I was given a complimentary copy of Falling Back to You. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I really enjoyed this third installment of The Reluctant Romantics series!!! I loved getting to know Cal and Noelle - seeing them come together as much more matured and healed versions of themselves was a beautiful thing. ❤️ I loved the eldest daughter and chronic illness rep as well! Noelle’s struggles and experiences with both were so real and relatable. Cal’s relationship with his daughter is so adorable! Absolutely loved oved the small town + fall vibes! 🍁
“We couldn't rewrite our story. We were two different people-shaped by the past and embracing the present. But we could start a new chapter, one built on forgiveness and trust, crafting the future into something beautiful. One page at a time.”
Wow this book is THE CUTEST!! I am in love with this swoony fall romcom and I loved reading it!! Morgan is a new author for me and her writing is stunning!!!
So excited for this books release TOMORROW!! Definitely a must read! 🎉🎉
NOELLE came home to find redemption. Thirteen years later and struggling, she just wants to find relief. She’s tired of pretending and exhausted. What she doesn’t expect is her sister to make housing arrangements that land her on her ex-fiancés property.
CAL needs a nanny for his daughter. Seeing Noelle shocks me but suddenly he desires more again, and maybe she’s just the one for the job. A second chance may be in the cards for them but can they both fight for their future; a future with his daughter?
I feel like this series gets better and better with every new release, and it has quickly become one of my favorite romance collections!
This story presents characters whose pasts are heavy with heartbreak, but it also shines a spotlight on finding hope and second chances (especially in relation to the clean - kisses only - romance). I loved the message that, even though it's difficult and takes courage, sometimes it's best to face mistakes so we can move forward into a brighter future.
I loved the comedy too! Cal's banter with siblings and teammates is so good, and Noelle's sarcastic sense of humor lightened even some of the heavier moments. And Cal's daughter, Khia, brightened her scenes with an adorable personality! Her close relationship with single-dad Cal is so sweet!
The small town's autumn atmosphere is really good (yes, I'm now in the mood for all the cozy fall things!!), but I'd definitely also recommend this to older teen/adult romance fans throughout the rest of the year as well!
*Content to note* .....May contain minor spoilers..... Memories/discussions of dysfunctional family situations in past teen years (including discovering mom in relationship with another man). Brief mentions of postpartum depression and cancer (both past/side characters); discussions of passed loved ones (including spouse lost to overdose - not shown on page). Character with fibromyalgia symptoms (chronic pain, etc.) and gluten allergy. Mentions of pregnancy before marriage; brief mentions of side characters' inability to have kids.
**Thank you to the author for providing a complimentary e-ARC. All thoughts expressed are my own.**
I absolutely loved this book! 🍁🤎 First of all, it’s set in a small town during fall, and the cozy vibes were everything. It can sometimes take a few chapters for me to get into a book. But I was hooked from the very first chapter and immediately fell in love with the world the author created!
I’m always a fan of a second-chance romance, but the couple’s growth throughout the story really stood out to me. Their character arcs felt so genuine and beautifully written. As an eldest daughter, this story definitely hits a little different 🥹 I really connected with that part of the story, and it made the characters’ journey toward grace, forgiveness, and learning to let go feel even more meaningful.
This story has such amazing faith themes woven throughout the book. The themes of grace, forgiveness, trust, and surrender were so beautifully portrayed, and I loved seeing how they were reflected in the characters’ journeys. It added such a meaningful depth to the story and made the message of forgiveness and second chances all the more memorable.
This book contains: 🌶️ Kisses only 🫢 No explicit language ‼️ Directly from the authors own content warning: “Mentions of infertility, chronic illness, dysfunctional family dynamics, losing loved one to cancer (off-screen, past), parent having a marital affair (side character, past), and mentions of postpartum depression/death of drug overdose (off screen, past).”
Ugh, Morgan, you've done it again 😭 While Greyson & Paisley are still my favourites in In Every Chapter, Cal & Noelle's story resonates so close to home for me in many ways. Reading Falling Back To You was unexpectedly healing & I laughed & cried a bit & just felt so seen & wrapped in a massive, warm hug. Like I've said before, thanks muchly for taking a genre I usually don't enjoy (& some of the tropes I equally don't like: like the single-parent romance) & turning it into something beautiful. It's Hallmark but without the silly drama & with maturity instead 🖤
Man, this second chance romance is for the eldest daughters 😮💨
This story felt so realistic and relatable. Cal & Noelle's story was so raw & full of hurt but also hope & forgiveness & beautiful things sprinkled in, as well.
The text threads were SO fun & there were so many, lol. I looked forward to the chats.
The family dynamics were heartbreaking & relatable (for Noelle and me) & heartwarming & also relatable (for Cal & my husband's family who adopted me in as one of their own & have loved me for more than half my life at this point through easy & hard times). I saw a lot of myself in Noelle & a lot of my husband in Cal (including the not listening well in the beginning of our relationship 🤪).
I felt that Morgan handled Noelle's chronic illness/pain with care, as well as the difficult family dynamics and building those bridges. I'm so excited for the next book in this series
📖: 1st person, dual POV, 3rd in The Reluctant Romantics series 🌶️: kisses only 🤬: no foul language ⚠️: From the author — infertility, chronic illness, dysfunctional family dynamics, losing loved one to cancer (off-screen, past), parent having a marital affair (side character, past), and mentions of postpartum depression/death of drug overdose (off screen, past).
Thank you to Morgan for the advanced reader copy of Falling Back to You 🫶🏼
The tension between Noelle and Cal was SO good! I loved watching their relationship unfold and seeing how they both came to understand that they needed God at the center of their relationship. The themes of forgiveness, grace, and God’s love were beautifully woven throughout the story.
And yes… I finished this book in 24 hours! That should tell you everything you need to know.
This series has definitely become one I can recommend. If you haven’t started it yet, I recommend beginning with Terms and Traditions (even though it takes place during the Christmas season ) so you can fully appreciate the series and the connections between the characters.
BUTTTT… you can absolutely start with Falling Back to You if you want to see whether this series is for you first!
Get ready for swoony moments, laughter, heartfelt conversations, dad jokes , and beautiful reminders of God’s amazing love, mercy, and forgiveness.
I’m so glad I picked this one up, and I’m already looking forward to more from this series!
I received an early copy from the author and was not required to leave a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I was so excited to read about Cal after reading Grey and Paisley’s story and it was even better than I expected!
It was really refreshing to read about a single dad who is head over heels in love with his daughter. There was something about seeing their love that really warmed me.
There was so many layers of healing that needed to be done with these characters and I appreciated how Morgan always pointed the characters back to Jesus. Her books are just the most inspiring & faith uplifting stories of how good God is, how much He loves us & how He never leaves us or forsakes us, even when we make mistakes.
I loved this second chance romance and I really think you will too!
And dare I say, we saw a soft side of Jerry for a split second?! 👀
Super grateful to have had the chance to read this story!❤️
I really liked this book. The characters were real and made me want to go to their small town and meet them in person. The more I read about them, the more I love them! Just a sweet, easy read with some good truths in it. I want another one now.
Sometimes a first love never leaves and forgiveness is right there, if only you ask.
I really enjoyed Cal's story. Cal is a sweetheart. All the green flags. He loves his little girl, tries to be a good friend and sibling, and forgives Noelle after she hurts him so badly. Honestly, he forgives wayyy easier than I would have. I actually was expecting Capt. Wentworth but got a Mr. Bingley, ready to love and forgive everyone.
Noelle was much harder for me to like, at first. As an oldest daughter, I can't imagine leaving my siblings at 19 to fend for themselves. Okay, maybe I did leave home at 19 to go halfway around the world (Thailand) while my 5 other siblings still lived at home. But! I didn't cut off communication or pretend like I wasn't part of the family for years on end. I also spent every evening worrying about how they'd get on without me (which is silly, but big sister worries aren't very logical). I think because Noelle had much in common with me, I had a hard time forgiving her for cutting ties so permanently (or, at least, semi-permanently). She does become more likable as time goes on, and I found myself rooting for them both by the end. The romance is super, super sweet. Like I said, Cal is an absolute sweetheart. You can't help but love him. If you like sweet, second Chance romances, then try out this book!
Ok this was cute. Yea, I started with the third book but hey, it’s fall and I wanted something seasonal!
Noelle’s struggle with chronic illness has suddenly taken the life she built and forced her to face the past she ran away from. Years after she left, she finds herself returning home, unsure of what her future holds. Cal never got over his fiancé leaving weeks before their wedding. He’s tried to forget it and move on, but 13 years later, she’s back in town, bringing all the past with her. Now a widowed, single father, he has so much more to lose if things go south again.
what I enjoyed
🍂 second-chance romance 🍂 Christian themes 🍂 lots of humorous lines 🍂 the group chat 🍂the stranger session 🫢(my favorite scene in the book) 🍂big family/community vibes
I enjoyed this. It was cute, funny, and has that extended/big family vibe that I love. It did feel a tad longer than necessary and I found myself pushing through some parts because I was ready to wrap things up. If you’re looking for a cute, CHRISTIAN, romcom/contemporary romance, this is a fun option. I’m really looking forward to reading the others in the series!
CW: nothing major that I recall—there are some brief mentions of cheating, divorce, family drama.
Cuando Noelle quiso hablar con Cal de sus problemas él no le ponía atención y solo decía que todos se solucionaría.
La verdad, no me encanta cómo se maneja la serie, porque en cada libro se presentan varios personajes y hay indicios de sus propias historias. Se da un poco de información, pero siempre es muy superficial y al final nunca llegamos a conocer realmente la verdad. Cada libro tiene protagonistas diferentes y las historias no están conectadas directamente; pueden ser conocidos, amigos o incluso el amigo de un amigo..
After more than a decade away, Noelle Shepherd returned to Serenity Springs seeking redemption from her past, not an opportunity to reconnect with her lost love. Professional hockey player Cal Satterfield built a quiet life with his young daughter, never expecting his former fiancée to be a part of it. But when Cal needs a nanny and Noelle needs a job, the two find their lives becoming entwined in a way that could prove to be the second chance they never thought they’d have.
Cal and Noelle absolutely stole my heart with their story of forgiveness, redemption and restoration of what’s been broken. Noelle is the eldest daughter who took on a burden that wasn’t hers to carry and when the weight becomes too heavy, she ran away from her family and her fiancé for a fresh start. After years of regret, she returns to her hometown to take accountability for her actions and make amends to the people she hurt. Cal Satterfield, the man she left behind, regrets that he didn’t always listen closely enough to understand why she left. Cal and Noelle recognize the hurt they’ve caused each other and find forgiveness and the redemption they both sought. Faith played a large role in both of their stories – with Cal trusting the Lord with his decisions and Noelle understanding that grace is freely given and not something we earn.
Second chance romances are one of my favorite types of stories and this one absolutely delivered. I loved how sweet Cal and Noelle are together; from the sweet nicknames they had for each other, their mutual encouragement and all the times they showed up to be what the other needed. Though they never stopped loving each other, it was beautiful to see that love mature and become something deeper than they ever thought possible. I especially enjoyed seeing how Noelle found her place in Cal’s family, how deeply she began to care for his little girl and how much Khia loved Noelle.
I always appreciate a story told through dual POV. Experiencing Cal and Noelle’s perspectives helped me better understand their emotions and motivations. There are also flashback chapters in between the main timeline that showcase their past together and ultimately what led Noelle to flee Serenity Springs. The text threads between players on Cal’s hockey team and the Satterfield family, along with the texts between the main characters and their family and friends were absolutely delightful. Their exchanges added a layer of heart and humor, and made you wish you lived in their small yet special hometown.
If you love stories about second chances at love, this book belongs on your shelf. Cal and Noelle's story is a beautiful reminder that love is worth the fight—and that what rises from the ashes can be more beautiful than before.
Oh, this was just so good! I knew that I was going to love Cal’s story and it did not disappoint me. The perfect blend of redemption, forgiveness, and second chances. Falling Back to You is the third book in Morgan Taylor Giesbrecht’s The Reluctant Romantics series. Cal was just trying to take care of his daughter. He was trying to be the best father that he could be but he was also longing for a partner. Noelle was just trying to find her place and make amends for past mistakes. She was at the end of herself and just trying to find her home. I loved both Cal and Noelle! They had both been through so much and were honestly just trying to trust God in their rollercoaster of a life. I really felt for both of them. Cal had to learn to trust God and figure out if he was willing to let Noelle back into this life. He had never stopped loving her but he was scared of getting hurt. Noelle had to learn to let go of the past and see that forgiveness and redemption were possible. I loved seeing the growth of both of these characters as they wrestled with their feelings and hopes. The romance was sweet. It was a bit of slow burn, a bit of instant love. They had been in love before but time had gotten away from them so they had to get to know each other again. I loved the way that they tried to support each other even as they worked through their feelings. I loved the side characters!! Khia was a sweetheart. She had Cal wrapped around her finger and I love reading about her interactions with Noelle. The whole Satterfield family is amazing and I loved the family themes. It was also fun to see some of the old characters too! I am so excited for the next books to come. This was a wonderful book and I would totally recommend it! Falling Back to You is a closed door contemporary romance with inspirational themes.
What I loved Cal and his relationship with his daughter The Satterfield family Mr. Pickles, the cat The text messages Redemption Disability representation The small town vibes
The way I swooned and smiled while reading this book needs to be studied 😍😍. Such a sweet couple, a beautiful family, and wonderfully crafted characters truly the perfect recipe for a story that wraps itself around your heart.
This is the first book in the series I’ve picked up, and I’m officially obsessed. I will be reading the other two. What’s funny is I’d seen the first book floating around social media for ages. I even added it to my TBR, then removed it, and somehow still ended up diving straight into book three. And honestly? It was too beautiful for words.
Second‑chance romance is my all‑time favourite trope, so reading about Cap and Elle gave me every single feeling I adore. My favourite part was how they didn’t even kiss until much later in the book, yet the chemistry and sweetness were absolutely overflowing. They gave me that wholesome, heart‑warming feeling that makes you wish you were giving and receiving that kind of love with your own person. Add Khia into the mix and I was completely lost in swoon world.
I loved how forgiveness and grace were portrayed. Forgiving someone who’s hurt you is hard, but the book captured the truth so well, forgiveness isn’t pretending the pain didn’t happen; it’s acknowledging it and still choosing to extend mercy. I adore love that withstands time, hardship, loss, and healing. That’s exactly the kind of love Cap and Elle share. Watching them blossom and thrive in the same space was genuinely beautiful. I just love them so much 🥹🤗.
The side characters were a 10/10. They made me so happy, and I found myself smiling through entire chapters. No last‑minute miscommunication, great character growth, and such a well‑rounded story. I had an amazing time reading this book, and I’m so glad I finally picked it up. I’m going to need many more books set in this town with these wonderful characters.
Special thanks to the author for writing such a beautiful story ❤️❤️.
I adored every second of this sweet, second chance romance🥰
The themes of forgiveness, grace, and redemption in this novel are anchored in Jesus and His finished work on the cross, which makes this story even sweeter because it’s a tangible reminder of the gospel. Like 1 John 4:19 says “we love because He first loved us.” I love how the cast of characters, not just the MC’s, modeled Christ-like love and extended forgiveness to Noelle, even the ones unsure and hesitant at first.
CAL & NOELLE!!!!! The character growth between these two throughout the course of the book was equal parts inspiring and challenging. Challenging because their story confronts our pre-conceived human notions about love and choosing to forgive those who have hurt us. We’d rather not deal with conflict, shove it under the rug, not talk about the hard things, not ask for forgiveness. This book shows us the beauty that rises from keeping Christ the center in our relationships with others (not just romantic) instead of holding a grudge or letting pride rule in our hearts and minds keeping us from loving others well. The humility woven throughout, even in the side character’s lives is simply refreshing and brought so much joy to my heart.
Cal and Noelle are inspiring because their story shows us God does in fact create beauty from ashes and He can redeem even the most seemingly devastating and heartbreaking circumstances of our lives and use them for our good and sanctification and His glory.
📖: 1st person, dual POV 💋: kisses only 🤐: no foul language ⚠️: directly from author’s content warning in the book: “Mentions of infertility, chronic illness, dysfunctional family dynamics, losing a loved one to cancer (off-screen, past), parent having a marital affair (side character, past), and mentions of postpartum depression/death of drug overdose (off-screen, past).”
This third installment in the Reluctant Romantics series by Morgan Taylor Giesbrecht had me both laughing and crying!
Cal is basically the epitome of a green flag guy. He's a single dad who loves his little girl, works hard, has a great relationship with his family, and easily forgives. Noelle takes care of others and has a hard time moving on from her past mistakes. They were high school sweethearts and engaged until Noelle abruptly skipped town to get away from the pressure she was feeling. When she returns years later to make amends with her family and friends for cutting them off, it's not an easy task. Especially when it turns out her landlord is Cal, and she ends up accepting the position of nanny for his daughter!
All the characters feel real and deal with realistic issues in their lives and relationships, especially forgiveness and moving on from past hurt. Reading this book is a great way to get a glimpse into how other people's minds work and how different everyone is. Not every single person Noelle encounters responds to her with immediate forgiveness and openness, just as you would expect to happen in real life.
I personally had a hard time relating to past Noelle who chose to leave everyone behind, letting her younger siblings fend for themselves without their big sister and abandoning her fiancé. But I could much more easily relate to present-day Noelle who is doing what she can to set things right. Seeing her relationship with her family, especially her father, being restored brings me hope for real-life relationship restoration.
Morgan has woven another sweet tale of love, and it was wonderful to see Cal get his happy ending I've been wanting him to have! If you enjoy second chance romance with an absolutely green flag MMC and characters who are imperfect people, check out this book!
What a perfect fall read! It had so many of the things we love about fall—corn mazes, campfires, sweaters, hot cocoa, all the yummy foods, and more! It felt like an early 2000’s romcom or Gilmore Girls and we are here for it. If you want to start getting in the mood for fall, this book is the one for you!
Can we just talk about Cal for a minute?! First of all, we are suckers for a single dad situation. Seeing how Cal adores Khia and how she has him wrapped around her little finger. It melted us into a puddle seeing the sweet bond between father and daughter! We also just love Cal’s fun-loving and exuberant personality. His dad jokes…lol! And then how Cal welcomes Noelle home and forgives her so quickly. He doesn’t shy away from the pain of the past but faces it in order to reach reconciliation.
And Noelle, what a brave woman! To go back after so many years to make things right and ask for forgiveness from so many people. That’s not easy to do. And gosh, she just pulls at the heart strings because she just serves everyone and puts herself last every time. She is so strong through her chronic illness. But then family and friends step up and come alongside her, letting her know she doesn’t have to do it all alone. She learns to lean on her people.
We also loved how the friend group and Cal’s family welcomed Noelle back, some took a little longer than others... But it was so sweet watching Noelle humbly ask for forgiveness and try to make amends.
We love all of the different text threads between Cal and his siblings, Cal and the hockey players, as well as Noelle and Macy.
We were so honored to get an advanced reader copy of this book and really feel like it is a must read book!
I love these books so much 🥰 They're a great blend of funny, wholesome romance that Stull knows how to be serious and meaningful.
*Spoiler Warning! If you don't want spoilers, don't read past the content warning!*
*Content Warning!* Language - None!
Spice - None!
Violence - None, really. PG.
Other - Themes of infertility, grief, postpartum depression, and overdose (off page, in the past) ************************************************
This book was so good!
I loved how the second chance romance was done. It wasn't just Noelle's falt that her and Cal broke up. Both were young and made mistakes. And both grew up to be so much more mature than they were.
I got attached to both characters and I loved following their story. I love how Noelle grew to accept grace from others and to let go of self blame. And I love how she slowly learned to let others take care of her. And Cal's growth was just as good. He learned to become a responsible man and father and he learned from his past mistakes and listened to Noelle rather than brushing off her problems.
The themes of faith in this book were so good. Both Cal and Noelle recieved great talks from side characters and both of them prayed and relied on God most over everything else. There were a lot of good points about grace and trust in this book!
And Khia! She was so adorable 🥹 I absolutely loved the father-daughter relationship with her and Cal. And I loved how she and Noelle bonded!
And, as always, I love when authors thank their readers! Thank you, Morgan Taylor Giesbrecht, for writing these wonderful books!
Overall, this book was just as good, if not better, than In Every Chapter (which is the first book of hers I read) and I can't wait to read more!
Redemption and second chances in an autumn hockey romance...need I say anything more? There's something about the way Morgan Taylor Giesbrecht tells a story that has a warmth and feeling of coming home and family, which I have really loved about the previous books in this series, and with its fall vibes and Noelle's actual homecoming, that is certainly true for this story as well. Seriously, I just adored Cal and Noelle's story so much. Second chance romance are some of my very favorites... I love the history that it offers, I love the healing, and I love that reminder that sometimes it's not the wrong person, but the wrong time... all of the things that this story displayed so beautifully. The connection between Cal and Noelle was undeniable, and while they certainly had some past hurts to work through, I love how natural their reconnection felt. Their story was tender and heartfelt, with so many great moments of both faith and laughter mixed in (many of those laughs courtesy of team chats and the adorably sweet Khia), and I absolutely couldn't get enough. As someone who struggles with chronic pain/illness, I also found myself relating to Noelle in that way and appreciated seeing that represented so well. I have loved every single visit to Serenity Springs, but this one just might be my new favorite... so far.
Falling Back to You is a faith-filled romance with kisses only and no language. It is the third book in The Reluctant Romantics series, but I do believe it could be enjoyed as a standalone as well.
**ARC received for consideration. All opinions are my own.
This one is my favorite of the series so far! I received a copy of this delightful story from the author. All thoughts are very much my own. And boy do I have thoughts! 😁
🍁 First-person, Dual-POV, past tense 🍁 Second-chance romance 🍁 Pro hockey player / single dad MMC 🍁 Former-nurse, now nanny FMC 🍁 Fibromyalgia, and GF representation 🍁Small town 🍁 Christian characters and faith themes 🍁 Large, tight knit family 🍁 Family dysfunction 🍁 Green flag MMC 🍁 He fights for her AND lets her stand up for herself
Where to begin... I just loved this story. I wasn't a fan of second-chance romances before this, but the way that Morgan gave both characters room for growth and redemption without stifling consequences or disregarding their past has changed my mind! *chef's kiss* 🤌 Beautifully and believably done. I especially loved how the flashbacks were woven into the present narrative.
Cal is so endearing and hilarious. I loved him from page one. And Khia is adorable! Cal is a great dad and I loved that aspect of the story. Cal's extended family were just so wholesome and kind as well and warmed my heart every time they were on page. Noelle is genuine and kind despite everything she's gone through. And as a former nurse myself, I thought she was pretty cool 😎 it was so rewarding seeing her make amends and build bridges throughout the book, especially with her dad.
I looked forward to every opportunity I got to spend time with these characters. It had me literally squealing and kicking my feet, laughing out loud, and even feeling misty-eyed at certain points. I highly recommend it for your fall TBR, or any time you need a warm hug in the form of a book. 🍁📖🤗
What a time I had reading Falling Back To You by Morgan Taylor Giesbrecht! For my first book by the author and my first fall read of 2026, Morgan delivered with humor, a second-chance romance with community redemption, a chronic illness rep, childlike joy, the joy of animals, and, of course, all the fall feels.
My overall thoughts are that the backstory was neatly woven into the story and was well done, and though this story contains many characters, it was easy to enjoy and follow. Everyone’s character role in the story had meaning. I greatly appreciate how Morgan included the chronic illness trope into one of the main characters. I felt seen and could totally relate. The love between someone with a chronic illness and someone who may present as stronger but is fully invested was well written and evident. Morgan also creatively illustrated how second chances can be not only in love, but also with family and friends. She displayed how powerful forgiveness is!
Now, for what I loved the most…
Definitely has to be a remorseful Noelle, single dad Cal, and his super adorable daughter, Khaia. Noelle wants to make amends, Cal has been praying for a second chance, and 4-year-old Khaia, well, she wants a mommy and a dog of her own!
Favorite Quotes: “I had value as a person. Not because of what I could or couldn’t do. But because God said I matter.” - Noelle
“You, me, and Jesus — sounds like the adventure of a lifetime.” - Cal
I highly recommend Falling Back To You for your Fall 2026 TBR.
I received an ARC e-copy of Falling Back To You from the author, Morgan Taylor Giesbrecht. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.