Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Songstealer

Not yet published
Expected 7 Jan 27
Rate this book
The gods and goddesses residing Above the Five Kingdoms are mysterious, powerful and bored. And what better way to cure immortal boredom than to pick a mortal love story to bet your odds upon? Starting with the star-crossed tale of a mermaid princess and ruthless pirate captain...

Lyra Northsea, princess of the opulent Mermaid Court, has only ever loved one her human childhood friend, who disappeared without a trace ten years ago. Now, prompted by a mysterious dream, Lyra sets out in search of him, only to stumble upon a dreadful truth. Her childhood friend is now the deadly Pirate King... and he doesn't even remember her.

Heartbroken, Lyra wants nothing but to go home. But the gods have already placed bets on Lyra’s story, and their meddling costs her something precious—her tail. Her only hope to get it back is to hire the Pirate King's crew to take her to Warden's Cove, where she might find a mythical jewel that will grant her any wish.

To Lyra's surprise, she fits in just fine with the motley crew—except their grumpy captain, who is far from thrilled with the spoiled little princess on his ship. But there's a masked villain on their tail, determined to turn the game of gods even deadlier… and as Lyra and the Pirate King race to unveil the game of immortals that's been manipulating their entire lives, the friction between them soon turns hotter and darker.

Can they reclaim the love that once bound them before the gods rip it from their hands?

The Princess Bride meets Sinbad in SONGSTEALER, a swashbuckling, seafaring adventure with messy deities, scrappy mermaids, found family, and a love story worth living for.

485 pages, Kindle Edition

Expected publication January 7, 2027

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Heda Woods

2 books10 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
24 (80%)
4 stars
6 (20%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
Profile Image for Amanie ✮⋆˙.
104 reviews180 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 6, 2026
"ɪ ᴡᴏᴜʟᴅ ʀᴀᴛʜᴇʀ ᴅɪᴇ ᴀ ᴛʜᴏᴜꜱᴀɴᴅ ᴅᴇᴀᴛʜꜱ ᴛʜᴀɴ ʜᴀᴠᴇ ɴᴇᴠᴇʀ ꜱᴇᴛ ᴇʏᴇꜱ ᴏɴ ʏᴏᴜ."

If The Princess Bride, The Little Mermaid, and Sinbad had a love child, put it on a pirate ship, sprinkled in some meddling Gods and Cheshire Cat levels of chaos, and then made everyone yearn like their lives depended on it, you'd get Songstealer.

And I ate up…EVERY. SECOND.

Heda Woods has this way of writing that makes you forget you're reading. I could practically feel the wind against my skin, hear the waves crashing around the ship, and see the magic unfolding right in front of me. There is something so special about a story that makes you feel like you've stepped inside another world, and Heda does exactly that. But what makes Songstealer so enchanting isn't just the magic or the adventure. It's the heart beating underneath it all.

Enter Lyra: a mermaid princess who has lost her tail, is suddenly navigating a world she barely understands, and is searching for the childhood best friend and long-lost love she's never forgotten. She's curious, tender, and discovering so much about the world around her, but PLEASE do not mistake her sweetness for a lack of pettiness. That girl has her moments, and I adore her for it.

And then there's Cillian.

THE. PIRATE. KING.

Dark, broody, mysterious, and seemingly committed to acting like he has never cared about a single thing in his life. Naturally, I wanted to climb aboard his ship immediately.

The dynamic between these two??? The tension. The banter. The enemies-to-lovers energy. The yearning that makes you want to grab both of them by the shoulders and tell them to GET IT TOGETHER. Lyra and Cillian had me in a chokehold, and I need everyone to understand that I was not reading this book in a normal or dignified manner.

And Cillian's way with rope? Let's just say my highlights in this book are between me, my Kindle, and God.

But beyond the romance, one of my favorite things about Songstealer is the found family. There's something about a crew of misfits, each carrying their own history and their own reasons for being where they are, slowly becoming something more than a collection of people sharing a ship. The banter, the trust, the little moments that make these characters feel like they belong to one another. GIVE ME FOUND FAMILY OR GIVE ME NOTHING.

Add in the magic, the mystery, the meddling gods who apparently have never heard of minding their business, a little "touch her and die," and one bed, and I was GONE.

Songstealer felt like a fairytale without ever losing sight of the people at its center. It's whimsical and adventurous, romantic and chaotic, but it also understands the ache of loving someone, the pull of the people who become your home, and the way some stories feel bigger than the adventure they're taking you on.

Heda, you have such a gift for making readers fall headfirst into the worlds you create. This book swept me away, made me laugh, made me yearn, and reminded me why I love getting lost in a book in the first place.

Five stars for the magic, the mayhem, the misfits, and a certain grumpy Pirate King who has absolutely NO business being this compelling.

Whatever world you decide to throw me into next, consider me already aboard. I don't even need to know the destination. Just hand me a ticket and let me meet the next fictional man who's about to ruin my life <3

(Please give me a moment to recover from Cillian first.)
Profile Image for ameowzingbooks.
40 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 11, 2026
5⭐/5 - Thank you to the author for the ARC!

I absolutely loved this book! It was SO. MUCH. FUN. Truly, I am sitting here trying to form words for what a great time I had reading this. I never go into books looking for something to be wrong, but I absolutely notice when everything feels right. Every part of the plot felt fully fleshed out, and the only loose ends were the intentional ones that leave room for future stories. Every side character felt rich and whole, and I genuinely felt like Lyra developed a real relationship with each one. I always try to take notes as I read ARCs, but I was so engrossed in this story that my notes actually feel sparse compared to how much I want to say.

There were moments from the very start that I loved, beginning with Lyra and her family, which introduced us to the Mermaid Court and the world she lives in. Then we meet Cillian and his crew and learn more about him as the dreaded Pirate King. The character introductions and the way everyone interacted with one another had me absolutely delighted. There's so much banter throughout, and as we learn more about their backstories, we also get to see the beginnings of a found family as Lyra meets the crew and joins them on their journey to get her tail back. I was immediately invested in how everything would unfold, and I loved the little side adventures they went on along the way. Meeting someone from each of the other kingdoms gave us just enough insight to leave us wanting more, while gradually expanding the world. Even the city of Metamorphity was so interesting to me right away. It felt like a real, lived-in place rather than just a quick pit stop to move the plot along.

The romance between Lyra and Cillian also never felt rushed. Yes, she knows he's her childhood sweetheart, but he initially saw her as a blank canvas. His feelings developed as he got to know who she really was, her values, and the person beneath her beauty. On Lyra's side, she had to overcome her own ideas of who her childhood friend was and who Cillian had grown up to be as the Pirate King. Also, the intimacy felt earned and not just there for the sake of spice. It was delicious and sexy, and I think we need more ropes in the next book.

Lastly, the ending wrapped things up in a way that was incredibly satisfying while still leaving so much open for what's to come. I'm now going to be following the author, Heda, into every future work. This book NEEDS to be traditionally published, and we need special editions, ASAP.

This book would be perfect for anyone who love mermaids, pirates, found family, childhood sweethearts, banter-filled adventures, multiple kingdoms to discover, and a healthy dose of romance and spice.
Profile Image for moon.
312 reviews80 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 2, 2026
“Charming,” he said, raising his eyebrows. “A young woman who behaves like a common urchin.”
“Better than a thieving pirate.”
He clutched at his heart mockingly. “You wound my heart, Buttercup.”
“What a liar. You don’t possess a heart.”
“Careful, it’s beginning to sound a lot like you’re flirting with me.”
She picked up a golden telescope from the floor and pointed it at him. “With absolutely full offense, I would rather die. Weren’t you leaving?”


Eternity is a long time. Especially for gods that are bored. So why not bet on the love story of a mermaid and a pirate ?

𐙚 Mermaid x Pirate
𐙚 Childhood friends
𐙚 Forced proximity
𐙚 Found family
𐙚 Memory loss
𐙚 Treasure quest
𐙚 Gods

It was so easy to fall in love with this book.

It had everything I needed for me to connect with it. A beautiful storyline, characters that have depth, are funny and really attaching.

There's always something so enchanting about mermaids and pirates. Something that incites us to envy, to dream. Whether it's about the beauty of a mermaid or the freedom of a pirate.

And it's even more special when a book portrays it so well.

This book did it for me.

I felt that feeling of want and dream. I wanted more to read about, I wanted to be both the beautiful mermaid and the ruthless pirate. I felt the fierce love of both and it made me want it to be mine.

I'm almost sad while writing this review. Or rather, specifically this part, because I haven't finished the book and I’m careful about the sadness I could end up feeling depending on how it'll end.

But yes, sad. This book matters to me and I don't want it to end. I don’t want to finish it. Because if I finish it, it means that Lyra and Cillian's story is just a story that has an end. And it surely doesn't feel like it when I'm reading it.

It feels like I'm part of the crew. Butterfly mate.
Even the fact that I had the opportunity to choose a crew name makes it all more special.

I'm on an adventure. One I really, really don't want to see end.

And I was so deep in that adventure, that I didn't write anything more after that. I just needed to read, more and more,so this part is written now that I finished this book. And I still feel that pang of sadness, but how relieved and happy I am.
Happy that it's a HEA and happy that we'll probably get more of this world I dived into.

I fell in love with this book and its characters. That's all that I have to say.
It's one of those books you just love, cherish and can't wait to re-read.

The storyline, the world building, the writing. It was perfect to me. Of course I wouldn't have said no to more of everything, but that's just greed talking.

Because in the end, this book is perfect as it is and I'm so happy I had the chance to read it.

Thank you Heda <3
Profile Image for Anastasia A.
282 reviews14 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 1, 2026
♾️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️ medium spice

- HOLY YEARNING BATMAN
- PIRATES AND MERMAIDS
- and boy was I tired of pirates and mermaids but then THIS CAME INTO MY LIFE
- AMNESIA
- MEDDLESOME GODS
- SIDE CHARACTERS THAT MAKE THE BOOK SO FAB
- pretty prose and emotional storytelling
- LUUUSSHHHH WORLD
- did I mention FAB side characters????
- insanely good spice
- a dangerous pirate lord with no memory of her
- a beautiful mermaid with powers and a search for her long lost love
- The Little Mermaid meets Sinbad meets HOT PIRATES
- TWWIISSTTSS
- YEARNOMETER OFF THE CHARTS
- great pacing

Heda has a MASTERS in yearnalism, a DOCTORATE in character building and is absolutely creative AF. I adored this story, what do you mean the pirate lord bad boy stays a bad boy and she loves him for it? What do you mean she’s searching for her long lost love and he’s RIGHT IN FRONT OF HER. What do you MEAN that he’s named his ship after her and DOESNT KNOW WHY.

I loved this book. I need to read it again. I need it. It’s gonna be huge guys.
Profile Image for Michi Moony.
12 reviews
November 12, 2026
Review of Advanced Reader Copy provided by the author! .✦ ݁˖

oh my goodness.
this might have been one of the best books i've read in the last couple of years.
first of all, thank you so much to Heda and the team behind Songstealer for this wonderful chance, it was my first ARC and i honestly couldn't be more grateful and amazed.
Songstealer conveys some of my favorite tropes and settings in a beautiful, god-written novel: mermaids, pirates, childhood friends, found family, quests, pettiness, star-crossed lovers, sort of enemies to lovers, memory loss... well, yes, everything in it is absolutely to my liking, but that wouldn't have been enough to make me like it.
i essentially devoured it. i couldn't put it down for the life of me!

i instantly fell in love with Heda's writing since the early pages, as soon as i started it: it is like seeing threads gently being tangled to one another (much like i pictured The Seamstress in action!) to create a magic carpet that will take you into fantasy realms from which you'd never want to come back. she perfectly expresses herself though still keeping the scenes clear and flowing, it keeps you hooked until you realise that you've finished the book (much to my disappointment... i need MORE!).
i love how she wrote the ending, having the quest of the main characters come to its conclusion - and thus leaving you satisfied with the story - but still leaving the story open enough to let it continue: i truly cannot wait for the second installment of this series.

the characters were so well-written i forgot they weren't real. the chemistry between Lyra and Cillian felt so authentic i loved every single interaction they had, even as we went on in the story and, well... it happens what it happens!
Lyra is a very good and complex FMC: se is soft, genuine, kind and caring while still having a though side in her. i love that she doesn't let the world change her, keeping her soft heart even through difficulties, where she learns she needed to be strong and make bold choices. she stays true to herself until the end, and i think that's a lesson many of us should learn from her.
Cillian was absolutely swoon-worthy, the perfect mix of sarcastic, morally gray and warm male character. he was a dream since the very beginning (and yes, pun intended, sorry lyra), and to see his development directly in the chapters from his point of view really left me quite pleased with the way he's been written. i cannot wait to find out more of him and Lyra in future books as well!
but i have to say, basically every character had its focus, their writing was coherent and i loved how we got a good characterisation for all of them, even though they were not the main characters. this was probably the best "found family" i've ever read, i need to be honest - i grew attached to all the characters, and their dynamic was exquisite.

i also pretty much liked and am very curious about Aera and the (light spoiler!) new member of the crew... hehe!

the scenes of the gods were very interesting!

i don't have much left to say (well, i do, but this would become a truly endless review) if not THANK YOU HEDA FOR THIS AMAZING STORY!!!! i cannot wait to read more from you!
Profile Image for OM.
795 reviews12 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 15, 2026
Thank you to Heda Woods for the ARC!

I LOVE Sinbad, I LOVE the Princess Bride and I LOVE THIS BOOK!

This book was an adventure that perfectly balances humor, tension, longing, mystery, adventure, found family, and romance.

I LOVE Lyra and Cillian they’re perfect 🥹 The structure immediately grabs your interest and keeps you hooked. The writing is fantastic.

All the characters were so complex and interesting and I could read tales of them forever.

Sometimes I can get overwhelmed with descriptions but this was just the right amount to show you what's happening but not confusing. The descriptions only enhanced the story.

The ending was wild, and chaotic but in that adventure fun and fast rollercoaster way.

This book I wanted to consume and savor at the same time.

DID I SHARE HOW MUCH I LOVE THIS BOOK?!?!?
Profile Image for Lauren.
8 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 12, 2026
Everyone needs to read this book! Disney nostalgia but make it adult themed
Profile Image for valls.
28 reviews
October 29, 2026
Review of Advanced copy received from Author

🖤Ahoy! What an absolute banger!
I have to say, I haven't read many pirate books in my life, this is possibly one of the first time I set sail to the adventures of the sea, and what a heartfelt adventure it was!!

THE PLOT:
This book was genuinely addicting, sometimes I would have to stop whatever I was doing to read "just one more chapter", and even when I wasn't reading I was constantly thinking about the plot and what would happen next. The plot was a mixture of my favourite movies and tropes, described and narrated so thoroughly that it made me feel part of the story too, I was completely immersed in this beautiful and cruel world. At first I thought that it would have too many sub plots to explore, but the author had the capability to make (almost) everything fit perfectly without loosing sight of the main plot. However, I thought that towards the end everything started to feel a bit rushed, for example Cillian's loss of his childhood memories felt a bit overlooked towards the end, and I wish we'd have more insight on Cillian's feelings regarding this matter. I did like how every pieces of the puzzle slowly started to fit perfectly into one beautiful masterpiece.

THE CHARACTERS:
I don't have to say much about the characters except that I LOVE THEM with my whole being! Every single crew member had their depth, they weren't just side characters put there to fill some empty space, which is not a given! I loved Lyra's dynamic with the whole crew, how they became to love her as she became to love them. I also love how the "villains" were portrayed, they were so original and so well written that I'm still not sure who should I consider a villain or not!
(bonus points to Aera, I actually really liked her as a character, she had this aura of mysteriousness that made her so interesting, despite being disliked by most of the crew)
Lyra and Cillian, these two have my heart. I have to say I did feel that their love story was the part of the plot that felt rushed and overlooked, I felt like so many things were happening all the time that their story, which is ironically the centre of the "quest" was a bit forgotten. Not that I minded, because this story was so interesting in its entirety that I didn't need that much romance to swoop in and save it from its collapse. I didn't think think Cillian would be so morally grey honestly (not that I minded 😉), but he's a pirate so it makes sense.

Overall, I'm not giving this five stars simply because of these little things that I did not quite enjoy, but this remains one of the best debut novels I've ever read. Heda Woods is truly an amazing writer and I genuinely cannot wait to devour everything she writes from now on!
Profile Image for M.
96 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 19, 2026
This book delivers on everything that was promised, and more!

Things to expect:
⚓️ Pirate King x Mermaid Princess
🐚 Childhood friends to Strangers
⚓️ Hate to Love
🐚 Found family
⚓️ Meddling gods
🐚 Touch her and die

The writing and the world felt very immersive, and the reading experience was just like watching a movie (and I think this would be a fantastic animated movie, or even a video game). If you loved Sinbad and The Little Mermaid, you will love this book!

I absolutely adored all the characters in this story, both main and side. Lyra, is a princess through and through, with a touch of bratty attitude that big bad grumpy pirate Cillian loves to "hate". The tension and the banter are so well done, I totally felt like I was a part of the crew that just can't wait to finally see them kiss.

This book was just overall such a great time, filled with adventure, fun, and of course - romance.

Thank you to the author for the eARC, my review is entirely voluntary and my own.
Profile Image for Fable  of Fatigue.
34 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 17, 2026
I did not want this book to end at all. I loved this book with a passion. The characters, the plot, the tension and suspense. *chef's kiss* Delectable. Lyra and Cillian's relationship was beautiful and spicy and raw (wink wink) and played so well into the plot. The dynamic of the two of them fitting into the surroundings of the story was hilarious to me. Add in the crew mates and their characteristics, and I was dead! You could not have written better side characters! The familiar relationship that they created with each other was great! I loved the bonds that were formed and the suspense that still managed to keep me on my toes. The whole thing was just so well played it's crazy. Very satisfied with this read!
Profile Image for Lorelai.
23 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 5, 2026
AH THIS BOOK WAS SO GOOD!!!

I will not lie, I’ve been on an ARC reading trend of not so great books. Books with such interesting plots that fell through or didn’t hit on the things they should of or the romance was too rushed and not compelling enough, the reasons go on and on. And I was really worried that I would be cursed with mid ARCs forever.

I cannot tell you how thrilled I am to be wrong. Because Songstealer was EVERYTHING. Definitely my favorite read of the year and quite honestly one of the highest reads on my list. I love, love, LOVED Lyra and Cillian. I loved the crew too, which is something I was pleasantly surprised about. I find in stories like these often I am bored with the side characters, they feel like needless filler diverting the story away from the main couple. But nope, not this book. Every single character was developed, was purposeful, was given the time both in their conceptualization AND on the page.

I need book 2 yesterday. Heda is too good of a writer, too good of an artist, for me not to have more of her work in my hands. I beg you, do not sleep on this author or this book. It is everything it promised and more, and I cannot tell you how delighted and excited I was reading this book. It didn’t just pull me out of a slump, it set me up on a grand adventure high that I fear I will not be able to replicate until I read her next book.
Profile Image for Angie.
72 reviews3 followers
November 8, 2026
Oh, captain, MY captain!

This was surprisingly refreshing!

The Princess Bride is one of my favorite movies, and this was giving all of that as well as The Little Mermaid and some Pirates of the Caribbean.

The found family and the dynamics between all the characters. The plot. The banter! I had a ridiculously good time. While nostalgic, there were a lot of moments that truly shocked me and I was both eager to see how everything unraveled as well as not wanting it to end.

The cast is purely perfection From Cillian, who is rumored to be this unremorseful Pirate King but fiercely loyal to his crew and honorable. Lyra, the sheltered mermaid princess who wins over literally everyone she crosses paths, but with a fiery mouth. Dog, the youngin who stole the hearts of everyone on board. Wolf, Falcon, and Cat. Love love LOVE. This found family will forever live in my heart.
Profile Image for tliareads.
299 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 16, 2026
4.5 ⭐️| 2 🌶️

Review coming soon 🧜‍♀️🏴‍☠️
Profile Image for Naz- bookhusbandcollector.
95 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 30, 2026
Thank you so much to Heda Woods for the arc of Songstealer!

This was such a fun time! I love when a book gets me rooting for two people to get together and that's what I was doing the whole time for the MCs. We have an intriguing story where a mermaid princess makes friends with a human boy and then he disappears. Years later she is off to look for him and discovers he isn't quite who he used to be and has no memory of her :(

Our Mermaid Princess Lyra joins the pirate king's crew to search for some items to help her and all the while she and the Captain have a lot of time together. Their banter and flirting is really funny and their chemistry is very much alive and well. The Gods are playing games with them though and my heart aches for them both this whole time! Lyra is headstrong and doesn't bend so easily for the captain, all while winning the crew over.

One of the other great parts of this book besides pirates adventuring is the crew! I have discovered that one of my favorite things in a book is found family and you get an entire pirate crew with this book. You learn their stories and dammit, I felt like I was part of the crew ! They all have animal names and I found myself inserting myself on the crew as penguin (my fav animal) lol

Even though the crew are "side" characters you still get to see so much of their personalities and lots of hints about their emotions, motivations and struggles. It also seems like this story will continue with some of the other characters at the forefront in the next installment and I can't wait!
Profile Image for Lena.
9 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 8, 2026
ARC Reader Review
Well, first things first the arts of this book are *MUAW CHEF KISS* which as what first draw me into it.
Now I'm a sucker for Mermaid x Pirate plots add to it the fact that they are childhood friends and in an adventure and count me in.
This book was such a good journey and i enjoyed each part of it.
Reading their day by day on ship with the whole crew was definitely my fav part (Found family yayy!!!!).
Can't wait for more books in this universe 👀
Profile Image for Kayleigh.
8 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 29, 2026
Short and sweet review for now:

This book is a beautiful story about childhood friends turned strangers. I absolutely loved this book for so many reasons. The journey the characters are on is captivating and so incredibly interesting. Lyra and Cillian are one of my new favorite pairings and I love them. I can't wait for the next book! I neeed to know what else happens with The Crew.
Profile Image for Téa.
46 reviews1 follower
October 27, 2026
This story made my heart so happy!

I loved getting to know the Cillian and Lyra watching their journey unfold and how everything turned out! The story of the side characters has me wanting and needing each of their stories!

This book had me kicking my feet giggling and blushing loving every little moment. I grew to CARE for the characters which made me love it more.

I binged this book, couldn’t put it down!!
2 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
October 30, 2026
This book has just about everything you could want from a romantasy book. Mermaids, magic, and a pirate king that I think I could convince to like me. 10/10.
Profile Image for Linah Soliman.
98 reviews7 followers
September 4, 2026
This was an absolute blast! I always enjoy a pirates book, but this was way more than just pirates. Songstealer was different species, adventures, kingdoms and way much more.

The magic system was very unique. The concept that every person has their own song and aura around them that represents their soul and feelings was beautifully poetic.

The concept that humans are so incredibly talented with their arts and crafts and no other species holds a candle to their talent, because their lifespan is so short and fleeting and they try to compensate for it by creating, is wondrous.

The crew might be one of my favourites in all the pirate books I ever read. Every member carries their own in term of individuality and storyline. They compliment and complete each other and they are so fun to be around.

The entire story was fun and humorous with high stakes that kept me on the edge of my seat and earned spice that curl the toes.

Lyra & Cillian were beautifully woven together from the start. Their road was bumpy all the way up till the end. A balanced true enemies to lovers, and they remind me why I love reading star-crossed stories.

I enjoyed the book on so many levels. I laughed with them. Cried. Giggled. And the amount of times I straightened my back when the plots hit their mark was diabolical.

It’s the kind of story I would reread every once in a while and still enjoy it as if it’s brand new. Dare I say a new comfort read.

Even though it’s a complete standalone, i can see the book sets up nicely for other standalones. I hope I can find out more about the rest of the crew in following books and see more of Lyra & Cillian my babies!🥹❤️
Profile Image for Mimo.
59 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 2, 2026
ARC review
This is my first time ever as an advanced reader and I was honoured to read this book
First of all, I have followed this story from the beginning when the author told us about it in bits and snippets and me and other readers had so much fun giving theories on what it could possibly be and so I have been excited about it for as long as I've known of it's existence
I have always loved mermaids stories and it was one of my top 5 fairytales, and as a child I had a mermaid obsession phase so basically this book was my tea
Now onto the real stuff, first I'm going to lay what I didn't like about the book and then the good things so balance things up
The reason this book wasn't a 5 star read for me was the writing style; up until the 80% mark, the writing was juvenile at times and it felt more like I was reading a wattpad book, but not always just sometimes and that's why I took off half a star from my rating
Now onto the good stuff;
It was a very well told story from the beginning, and although it was taking its sweet time the first 10 chapters (around 30%) to give space to world-building and character introduction, I enjoyed it
The premise of the story unfolded after that and it went better than I expected honestly
I enjoyed the found family of it all and all those sweet moments, the relationships between all of the characters
Cillian and Lyra my sweets, they did go through a lot and they deserved a happy ending
The story, however, leaves more to come because I believe the author isn't planning on leaving us hanging like that
Long story short, it's a good book especially if you're into mermaids and pirates and found family
Profile Image for Gwen Brophy.
374 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 15, 2026
PLOT: When mermaid princess Lyra goes looking for her lost childhood love, she loses her mermaid tail and winds up sailing with Cillian Rogues, the notorious pirate king, who looks an awful lot like that childhood love, but who doesn't remember her. With meddling gods interfering at every turn and a mysterious man continually trying to steal Lyra's power chasing them, they search for the Devil's Tear, a magical item that will grant wishes.

TROPES: Grumpy/Sunshine, Forced Proximity, One Bed, Little Mermaid Retelling, Pirates, Found Family

SPICE: 3/5

CLIFFHANGER: 8/10 (technically a standalone, but part of an overarching series. You could stop here, but...why?)

This was amazing. I couldn't put it down once I started it, and I devoured it in a single day. The world-building is top notch, with varied types of magical peoples living side by side. This is a fantastic found family story, with Lyra never fitting in at the mermaid court, but finding her place almost immediately among Cillian's crew.

I loved Cillian and Lyra's relationship. Secrets abound, some remembered, some intentionally withheld and some forgotten. I feel like the pace of the story was absolutely on-point, with those secrets coming to light at the right time, rather than being dragged out or coming out too soon.

Cillian, or Pirate Rope Daddy, as he should be called forever, is an appropriately grumpy, brooding, scarred and tormented MMC. Lyra is a sunshine mermaid, but she's got darkness of her own.

You get all of the fun pirate/mermaid stories that you want: a nasty storm, a sea battle when the authorities try to capture the notorious pirate king, sirens, krakens and rum. I LOVED this book!
Profile Image for Angie.
51 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 17, 2026
I DON'T EVEN HAVE THE WORDS. This book was SO well written. Heda, you did an AMAZING job! The plot, the tropes, the characters… EVERYTHING. 😍

First of all… THE GAME OF THE GODS?! Of course the gods would get bored and decide to interfere in mortal affairs. What could possibly go wrong? 😂

Let's talk about Lyra…

I absolutely loved her. She was strong, powerful and incredibly resilient throughout the entire book. No matter what was thrown her way, she refused to give up. I loved watching her stand her ground and fight for herself.

And then there's Cillian Rogues…

Oh, my heart. 😭🖤

Your typical guarded, grumpy MMC, but there's SO much more to him than meets the eye. As the story progresses, we get to see more of who he really is and what he's feeling.

And from the very beginning, he was DIFFERENT with Lyra. The crew could see it, and honestly, so could I. 🤭

Speaking of THE CREW… I ADORED EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM. I loved how they welcomed Lyra and became her found family. Their dynamic was everything!

And Cillian and Lyra's banter? ABSOLUTE PERFECTION. The chemistry, the tension, the little moments… I was eating it all up. 😏

AND THE FACT THAT THEY'RE CHILDHOOD FRIENDS BUT HE DOESN'T REMEMBER?! HELLO?! THE YEARNING. THE ANGST. I WAS NOT OKAY. 😭

If you love grumpy x sunshine, only one bed 👀, hate to love, childhood friends, yearning, witty banter, touch her and die, found family and a whole lot of romantic tension, then Songstealer needs to be on your TBR!

Heda Woods, you have officially stolen my heart with this one. 🖤🎶
Profile Image for Courtney Bodeen.
6 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 17, 2026
Thank you to Heda Woods and her PA Amanie for the advanced reader copy!!

This book brought me back to my childhood and my love for The Goonies and the Emily Windsnap series. Adventure and pirates and mermaids hold such a dear spot in my heart and this filled all of those holes from the very start, with the high stakes and beautiful whimsical writing.

Lyra and Cillian!!!!! I love them so much. Cillian, the rope daddy captain that you are 😮‍💨 Ropes are very versatile. And he really knows his way around them 😏 And Lyra. My sweet mischievous mermaid princess. I love her so much. I love that with Cillian and the rest of the crew she was able to truly speak her mind and unlearn years of royal mannerisms and prejudices.

This book felt like a log flume, we hit the water running in all the best ways and all the twists and turns kept me surprised and on the edge of my seat.

The writing was lyrical and whimsical, just like Lyra’s song. It was easy to tune into and fall in love with, and the tethers between Lyra and Cillian were always present, no matter the knots thrown in their way by the gods.


“You were always my world, Buttercup. Even when I forgot you, the whispers of you remained in my life. Your traces haunted my dreams, your apparition forever a ghost over my shoulder. You completed me without even knowing I was broken. I love you.”
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Hannah Zachary.
7 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 12, 2026
I was part of the amazing ARC team for this book! I was so excited to read it because of the yearning and mystery surrounding the main characters’ past. This book hooked me really quickly and I was very engrossed in the world-building and the unique characters. The story had some interesting twists that I didn’t see coming, which I really feel is hard to find in books these days. I can’t wait for book two and would definitely recommend this to fans of pirate romances and grumpy MMCs!!
Profile Image for Subhangi Majumdar.
10 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 17, 2026
Cillian and Lyra's story is so deep, emotional and heartbreakingly beautiful, it really melted my heart..❤️ The story is full of adventures, dangers and the deadly trials that made my skin crawl in anticipation and not to mention, the plot twists??! Hello??🫣. Even as the meddling gods infuriated me to no end, there's also the sweet sweet sweet payoff that made the end of this breathtaking adventure so satisfying...because love? It's a sneaky little thing...100% recommended read!!
🥹❤️‍🩹
Profile Image for CurlyMomReads.
16 reviews
November 19, 2026
Oh, this was good…& meddling gods is an understatement!! I enjoyed every minute of this book. Hilarious banter & tension-filled romance that had me shaking my Kindle in frustration! With enough action & adventure to keep the pages turning while also pulling at your heartstrings at times! I adore the whole crew & all the unique personalities. I’m team Cat 🐈‍⬛ all day!! I’ve always loved stories with mermaids & pirates & Songstealer did not disappoint!
Profile Image for Neemo.
4 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 15, 2026
This was such a fun read. I didn’t want it to end! Thank you so much to the author & team for such a cool opportunity to read early.

If you like adventures, friends to enemies to lovers and found family this is for YOU

Out January 7!!
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews