There are two types of those who want to forget and those who would do anything to remember.
Jamie Kessler wants to remember. After a car accident wipes away most of her memories, she's left with fragments of a life she no longer recognizes. Confused and overwhelmed, Jamie undergoes an experimental procedure to recapture lost memories. With each recollection, she pieces together a feeling that something—or someone—is clinging to her heart and won't let go. One name keeps coming up and is impossible to forget, Mallory Ziegler. The woman she met in an AOL chatroom when she was nineteen, the woman she fell madly in love with, and the woman she somehow lost.
The more she digs, the deeper she falls for Mallory and embraces the love that memory never erased. But some memories were buried for a reason, and the pain and betrayal she discovers could completely change the direction of her life.
Morgan Lee Miller started writing at the age of 5 in the suburbs of Cleveland, Ohio. Since there is absolutely nothing to do there, she entertained herself by writing her first few novels by hand.
She currently resides in Washington, D.C. with her two feline children, Milo and Elsa. She has a serious problem with oversharing pictures of her cats on Instagram and promises never to apologize for it.
READ THIS! Ok so I just loved this book, a lot. I don’t know if its one of the best books I have read this year, or if it was just the right thing at the right time for me in particular, but I LOVED it. This was a page turner that I couldn’t put down and NEEDED to know what was going to happen next. It’s a simple book ultimately, but maybe that’s what makes it so effective.
The structure of the novel was creative and original, and I like the way the author used it to carry us through the story; new favorite dual-timeline book? idk that’s a tough contest but its up there.
I loved the flashbacks. I don’t think I have read anything that captured the 90’s and early 2000’s as well as this book did and I enjoyed the nostalgia. I loved the BIG emotions and they definitely got me. This was just satisfying, plainly and simply. All the stars.
This novel had messy characters. Actual messy, realistic, real characters though, not the “we have messy characters” that people sometimes say when they want to write something toxic or that doesn’t make sense. Real life hurts sometimes, and I think it’s the very realistic nature of this story that allowed it to leave an impact on me.
After reading this I was wondering when the last time I read something I liked this much was….so I looked (yay GoodReads)! And I think the last book I read that I liked this much was about 60-70 books ago; I think that speaks for itself.
This wasn’t perfect, I'm not promising that. There are a few parts where I wish the story had slowed down and spent a little more time, and the ending was one of them. There are a handful of little things I would change if I could. The overall package though, was just a chefs kiss.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing a free ARC. This honest review was left voluntarily.
Her stare carries sympathy, and that gravitational pull of hers catches my spiraling thoughts and anchors me to the now. I let myself get lost in her eyes until my pulse slows. As I relax, she nods subtly, like I’m doing something right by looking at her and only her, like nothing else exists. (pg. 228).
I cannot separate my own lived experience from this story. There are simply too many emotions. No, I did not have TBI. No, I did not have amnesia. But, “you’re an ache that never healed,” (pg. 152) something along those lines. I must be going on 18 years now; a similar time span in which Jamie and Mallory find each other, while attending college at opposite sides of the country, through AOL chat – yes, 90’s nostalgia is front and center. A love story erased by a car accident that goes back 20 years. Jamie undergoes an experiment to reclaim her memories. The esteemed Dr. Wilson leads the treatment. Beautiful, quiet, sharp around the edges, with controlled emotions. Blink and you’ll miss her nonverbal thoughts. Jamie seems to catch them. Miller takes you through a creative balance between past and present where both main characters develop an array of relationships [with each other and beyond] through their late teens, young adult life and well into adulthood.
Imagine reliving your memories for the first time. Every kiss, every touch, every emotion. There is so much wrapped up in the chemistry, between these two it’s intoxicating. But the heartbreak will tangle you up. You are pulled and your chest will ache. From Jamie’s point of view, it is clear – Mallory is her person. But then, mistakes are made. They aren’t flushed out and as the reader this may frustrate you. Time is also lost and Jamie takes you into her grief because “moving on” seems impossible. Will lessons be learned? What happens when a second chance, scratch that, a third chance is presented in the most peculiar way. “Answers rise from what has been, but hope blooms in what could be” (pg. 190) Jamie, what will you do with hope?
Wow! Morgan Lee Miller take a bow! The Rewind Effect is so good! I was utterly spellbound by a narrative structure that is as inventive as it is poignant. The story utilizes a clever and effective framing device involving an experimental medical procedure designed to help Jamie Kessler retrieve memories lost after a devastating car accident. This memory retrieval process serves as a brilliant framing mechanism, allowing the narrative to seamlessly weave back and forth through time while neatly embedding important cultural touchstones (like connecting in early AOL chatrooms, the tragedy of 9/11, for example) that ground the characters’ formative years in an authentic, nostalgic era.
Beyond the inventive premise, what captured my heart was the breathtaking emotional pull of the relationship between Jamie and Mallory. Their connection feels profoundly visceral, raw, and entirely consuming. As Jamie slowly pieces together the fragments of her past, the longing, vulnerability, and enduring love she feels for Mallory anchor the entire novel. The author captures the ache of second-chance romance with stunning precision, making every revelation feel earned and moving. I experienced Jamie’s desperation to reclaim her lost history right alongside her, feeling every shred of her heartache, hope, and eventual healing.
The chemistry between them leaps off the page, charged with a tender intensity. This is a masterclass in romance storytelling—romantic and sexy in precisely the right ways, yet grounded by genuine emotional depth and the terrifying reality of what it means to lose and rediscover love. Morgan Lee Miller has crafted a treasure-filled read. This is right up there with the very best deeply felt, beautifully written LGBTQ+ romance.
I was lucky enough to grab both the text and the audio version of this, and the novel works just well either way. Quin Riley captures the essence of Jamie superbly and narrates with verve and bounce. She’s also one of the very best when it comes to physical scenes.
Thank you to the author and publisher the amazing Bold Strokes Books, and to NetGalley for the opportunity of going back in time and sharing Jamie’s life-shaping years.
Every emotion I own has been thoroughly played with, hammered, plucked and petted like my favorite song. I hit play on this audiobook and Morgan Lee Miller and Quinn Riley whispers in my ears a fantastic story of memory and a love that never truly ends. I love the concept of using music to help regain memories lost in a traumatic car accident. Dipping back and forth in time with Jamie and Mallory is a rollercoaster ride that thrills and breaks your heart. I highly recommend this wonderful book and if possible get the audiobook. Of course I'm giving this 5 Radiohead stars
This has been an interesting story featuring a woman with amnesia following an accident—a seemingly recurring theme in recent lesbian novels. What makes this one innovative is the method by which the protagonist regains her lost memories; since it forces her to relive them, the story becomes one about her adolescence rather than her adulthood, as she relives her entire youth over the course of a single week.
Beyond the amnesia, the story focuses on Jamie, beginning with an online relationship she started in the late 90s—the era when chat rooms for meeting people first emerged. She was 19 when she met Mallory, a girl living on the other side of the country; what began as an online connection eventually evolved into an in-person relationship. In her quest to regain her memory, Jamie relives every moment of that relationship, alongside the early days of her professional career.
The story is original, though it has shades of *Forrest Gump*—I’m exaggerating a bit. But there are historical moments that give you goosebumps when you relive them.
I enjoyed this book, it was a different style, with flashbacks used as a diagnostic medical method to restore Jamies's memory. It was also very much a YA story since the majority of the book is told through the flashbacks going back 25 years when Jamie and Mallory met on an AOL chat room.
Jamie's insecurity was a big problem in her relationships, she could never fully trust any of her partners. Mallory was also a bit troubled because, she didn't like the long distance relationship that she had with Jamie and settled for other women to fill her romantic needs.
Thanks to Net Galley for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I absolutely love this book! It brought me back to AOL and the music of the times! Jamie needs this procedure to get her memories back after a devestating accident. This book is heart warming and heart wrenching. It is a beautiful book! A FAVORITE!!! Worth more than 5 stars!
💟 Second Chance 💟 Childhood Sweethearts 💟 Exes to Lovers 💟 Past & Present Timeline
Ahh my heart 🥹 this book had me soo happy, then sad, then happy again. It was beyond beautiful.
It’s a love story erased by a car accident that goes back 20 years. Jamie undergoes an experiment to reclaim her memories. The story was so unique and I was completely immersed in their story. The pacing was perfect. The past and present were equally enjoyable, and normally I tend to favor one over the other.
Imagine reliving your memories again for the first time. Every emotion, every heartbreak, first kiss, first love, just everything. There is sooo much chemistry between Jamie and Mallory, my heart was bursting. I was so wrapped up in their story. Their love was beautiful, even down to their heartbreak, which broke my heart. 🥹
I loved the creative balance between the past and present and all the nostalgia throughout. I found myself missing my childhood and using AOL to chat with strangers! 😂 good times!
Romance isn’t my favorite genre but I’ve been working on reading more and finding a lot of great queer romance books that I have really enjoyed and I thought the idea of music and memory to be really intriguing.
However i just can’t escape the struggle I feel when toxic relationships are glorified because of “love”.
The story follows Jamie in her mid forties trying to remember her past through a breakout technology that uses light patterns and music. Starting in the early AOL days of chat rooms and mix tapes we see a relationship traverse the decades with Mallory.
The relationship parts in the beginning I really liked. The nostalgia mixed with the queer identity of the 90s and time in early adulthood just really solid. It was after 2001 where I think the story falters significantly and it just becomes such a toxic mess.
I didn’t mind all the ups and downs of their relationship and the stages they go through and a lot of it does make sense but it does bother me when there was no growth, no effort them to work on being better and the sex scenes felt displaced as a result. It feels so much like infatuation and lust and I don’t think it was intended to and the disjointed moments really stand out.
Other huge problems I have (while keeping spoiler free).
- how the hell does a huge music lover working in the music industry in NYC during 2001 not mention The Blueprint by Jay-Z. Sure the MC loves grunge but she likes shitty pop music by all the references she makes to them (I mean a 23 year old being more excited for N*sync instead of Jay-z???). The Blueprint will forever be tied to NYC because of the songs but the day it came out and how it propelled people into moments of pride and love for a damaged city. To ignore this album - arguably one of Jay-z’s best albums and overall greatest rap albums of all time - is such a shame.
- the music choices are all radio hits and singles. That was really disappointing too. Liking the song Meet Virginia is also a -⭐️ the self proclaimed music snob being in love with American idol or whatever show it was and talking pop music is just another show of hypocrisy. Jamie has a mini rant about thinking Nirvana is overrated (which I totally agree with but I don’t listen to them stil) and yet all the Seattle hot spots are references to Nirvana 😭
- If she lost all her memories after the age of 19 how come the 25ish years she’s trying to remember she doesn’t have a single chapter or song about anyone else other than Mallory. This one really bothered me. A chapter about some family situation or related to her job in a meaningful way not the little tidbits of her work barely mentioned. Nothing for any of her other friends? At least one chapter could have been without Mallory and would have given Jamie much needed depth.
- if the memory technology actually worked its terrifying how it would make people feel. It doesn’t talk about the tech in any meaningful way but seeing how it affects Jamie makes me think of how people could fall in love with abusive exs or get really conflicted feeling over major life events. Or any historical event having to relive. This bothered me how insistent the procedure was and how dangerous was without being clear with safe conversations. A procedure like this needs other medical specialists like counseling services and its glaring omission made my stomach churn.
- I just didn’t like Mallory and Jamie together. Maybe because their romantic relationship parts are solely sex focused and doesn’t feel like either of them are as good as they were as friends. I didn’t want to root for them and I didn’t care about their story around the 70% mark. It’s so surface level if feels like it lacks complexity and depth that existed in the early chapters then of course there thes mad dash to rush through years. I don’t understand how Jamie learned all her memories time jumping.
- any type of plot reveal was obvious well in advance.
I can keep on complaining about this one but at the end of the day I didn’t like it and I don’t recommend it.
I thought the breathy audiobook narration by Quinn Riley works for the story so that is my positive. I’d definitely listen to more of her. It’s also quite spicy and these scenes were well done. I hate when romance books use corny euphemisms and this one doesn’t.
I am gratefully for receiving an advanced copy of the audiobook from NetGalley and Tantor media. I hope others do enjoy this sapphic romance 💘
Wow! What a ride and interesting concept! Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher for an advance review copy for free. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I loved the premise and the execution was well done. I felt the story was well paced and filled with emotion, first love, heartbreak, second chances and cool medical breakthroughs (fictional of course). But what I really enjoyed was the nostalgia I felt in just about every chapter. From the dawn of the internet and AOL cartoons to twenty-five years of living, learning, making mistakes and reaching maturity where change is viable.
Read Jamie’s story. Live through the rewind and be immersed in the nostalgia as well as the connections and experiences that shaped not only Jamie and Mallory, but many of us as well.
This sapphic romance is so emotionally rich and meaningful. Jamie’s memory was effectively wiped after a car accident, and she has no recollection of the past 20 years of her life, and how she ended up in California. This book unravels as Jamie goes through a breakthrough treatment at a neurology facility to recover her memories. Each treatment bridging the gap from college to present day memory by memory. All the while something feels as though it’s weighing on her heart. Jamie is confronted with memories of her first love, a girl she met in an AOL chatroom in the 90s, Mallory, and starts reliving their love story as she recovers her memory. SWOON. Memories/amnesia and nonlinear timelines are some of my most favorite plot devices. This sets you up for a fast paced read that makes you unable to put this story down. The characters are thoughtfully developed and layered making you super invested in them through the story. As they navigate difficult times the timeline and relationships feel real and beautiful. As we walk down memory lane we see some significant moments in history, like 911, and the legalization of gay marriage, through the lens of our characters as well. The entire book brings in nostalgic feelings and makes it easy for all readers to connect. The romance is sweet and emotionally rich while also having plenty of steamy spicy scenes to balance the emotional depth. I cried no less than 7 times reading this book and that to mean says it all. I LOVED the epilogue <3 Audio notes: a beautiful performance by Quinn Riley. I loved the range of emotions portrayed through the performance and the distinction between the characters tone and inflictions that felt wholly “Them”
What an excellent ride this was. It was so interesting following Jamie in the present day as she’s undergoing an experimental procedure to recover her lost memories. The detail of using songs to connect her to the past was a nice touch. I loved seeing her recover her memories of the 90s and 2000s and Mallory, the woman she fell in love with. I was so invested in uncovering the path of their romance and why they weren’t together anymore. This was the type of second chance romance that I can really get behind. Because you get to see the initial romance instead of just being plopped into the story later on and only hearing tiny bits of information of what happened before.
I loved seeing all the details in the past, like Jamie and Mallory meeting in an AOL chatroom and bonding over their love of Claire Danes, Jamie’s obsession with the drink Fruitopia, listening to Melissa Etheridge while sitting on the roof, counting down to the year 2000. It was so great seeing how Jamie and Mallory’s friendship and romance grew and changed over the years. Their conflicts made sense and never felt like they were just thrown in so that there could be drama for the sake of the narrative’s arc.
I definitely recommend this book for people looking for a compelling lesbian romance that spans decades. It’s full of love, sex, music, friendship, tragedy, and reconciliation. I listened to this on audio and the narrator Quinn Riley did an excellent job at bringing the characters to life. I was annoyed whenever I had to pause the book to do something else. I was always dying to get back to the characters so I could discover their romance as Jamie was recovering her memories.
Thank you to the publisher for providing an advance copy via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
When I picked up this romance, I expected more than what I got. To read two people stuck in a situationship only to keep breaking up and getting back together was exhausting. I despised the main character and there was never any good conclusion to her insecurities because the moment the external factor causing them was removed, things returned to "normal" until it happened again.
I cringed reading through Jamie's POV with how immature she acts (sounding nearly the same at 19 and 45). I also wasn't convinced by their chemistry because it kept reading like infatuation and limerence first before any genuine romance.
There's also some doctor-patient relationship ethical concerns towards the end when Jamie finds out more about herself, and it broke my immersion with it being spun as a way to bolster the romance's tragedy. The real tragedy was in these two people being unable to let go of each other to an obsessive degree.
It wasn't for me, as much as I wanted to be. While I normally like messier romances, there wasn't enough strength in the relationship that made me want to root for them. It kept harping on how electric it was but mainly described scenes with physical intimacy or huge explosive conflicts. I couldn't get a grip on what they were like together aside from this "picturesque" couple Jamie kept describing them as. By the end, I felt frustrated and disillusioned with the couple.
I felt all of it: falling in love, the heartbreak, and everything in between that comes with loving and losing your one true love. Spoiler alert: it has a happy ending. So all is well. Getting there is tumultuous and painful at times, and I enjoyed every minute of it. Oh, and it's sexy too! In that passionate romantic way.
These two are so made for each other. And OMG, the first part, where they fall in love, was literally me and my first love. We met on MSN Messenger, and for 5 years lived on opposite sides of the Atlantic, listened to Ani DiFranco, and (I kid you not) thought of each other every time the clock hit 11:11pm. That was our thing. Turns out it was Mallory and Jamie's thing too. I had to double-check the author's name to make sure my first ever girlfriend hadn't written this book (she didn't).
Nostalgia aside, I'm impressed by this story. If you can get past the pseudoscience behind the procedure, it's an incredible way to give romance fans like us a love story that spans 30 years. Second chance, soulmates, jealousy, heartbreak: it's all in there, carried by two beautiful MCs who make your heart ache. It's a long, emotional ride, and it kept me hooked for a few days of full-on addiction.
Mallory frustrated me a few times. She hurt my heart. That's mostly because we don't get her POV, and by the end it's clear she had her reasons for her choices.
Going straight onto my favourites shelf. Now I need a light, low-angst, feel-good romance to recover from this whirlwind.
would like to thank netgalley and the publisher for letting me read this thought provoking book
this book is so much more than what the blurb says... its intense, interesting and boy is it thought provoking....
jamie has no memories left after her accident... that she was in an accident is all gone from her mind but with the help of a doctor she undergoes a new treatment that can bring her memories back.....
its a painful road for jamie and what those memories stir up....
have to say i was hooked right from the beginning and i couldnt wait to see how it would all pan out....
its a great read and will keep you up for hours just reading it to find out what happens next
I received an ALC of The Rewind Effect through NetGalley, and the second I saw Quinn Riley was narrating, I snatched this one up. She is a fantastic narrator, and she brought Jamie’s story to life in exactly the way it needed. The emotion, nostalgia, and different stages of Jamie’s life all came through beautifully.
This was my first book by Morgan Lee Miller, and I really enjoyed it.
After a car accident leaves Jamie without most of her memories, she begins using an experimental treatment to try to recover pieces of her past. Music becomes a huge part of that journey, taking her back through different moments of her life, beginning when she was nineteen.
As someone in my 40s, the nostalgia in this book hit so well. The AOL days, the music, the way people connected before social media became what it is today…it felt like getting little snapshots of an entirely different era. I especially loved how music was woven into the story as a way of unlocking Jamie’s memories. The song choices and the moments attached to them were such a fun part of the listening experience.
At the center of those memories is Mallory, Jamie’s first love.
We get to experience their relationship almost alongside Jamie as she remembers meeting Mallory, falling in love, and everything that followed. Their story spans decades and explores first love, long-distance relationships, jealousy, mistakes, heartbreak, forgiveness, second chances, and how complicated loving someone can become when you are both still figuring out who you are.
I also really enjoyed that this wasn’t a perfectly polished love story. Jamie and Mallory make mistakes. They hurt each other. They grow. Life takes them in different directions, and Jamie has to confront both the beautiful memories and the painful ones.
Overall, The Rewind Effect was an emotional, nostalgic, quick listen that kept me entertained from beginning to end. Quinn Riley’s narration made the experience even better, and I’ll absolutely be checking out more from Morgan Lee Miller.
I actually finished this book a few days ago but I needed a moment to collect all my thoughts. First, I really enjoyed how immersive this was. This was such a nostalgia trip for me because I’m the same age as Jaimie and our “growing up” matched so perfectly it was almost eerie. The music, the drinks, the food and even the mention of the aol messenger door sound had me floating back in time. Bias for sure but this felt written for me. This is a tale of firsts with a HEA ending. That said, my biggest knit was the last 20% felt rushed compared to the care that was taken of unfolding this love story in the first 2/3rds. TBH, even though it was a little long for a romance, I would have enjoyed an extra 50 pages to flesh out the ending so it didn’t appear so abruptly.
I like Morgan Lee Miller’s writing, but this book was a bit difficult for me. Not because of the writing, but the story didn’t resonate with me and I found it to be too much. I understand this is some sort of a second chance romance, but this isn’t the way I like it to be told. However ingenious it might be.
The narration by Quinn Riley is pretty good. I think maybe the distinction between characters could be a bit more pronounced, sometimes I didn’t know who was talking. Even though everything is in first person POV of just 1 character.
In general I think it’s a fine audiobook, but I expected a little more. Could have done with less flashbacks/ reliving/ remembering the past for example.
Genuinely didn’t know how I would feel going into this book. Thought oh I’ll pick up a cute little book about someone getting their memories back. Instead I was taken on a trip to a nostalgic time with though song and memory. The way Jamie’s life comes back to her is so beautiful, I felt like I was right there experiencing it all. This was written in such an immersive way I was watching it all through Jamie’s eyes. I felt her excitement, her heartbreak, the anxiety after her sessions. As a 33 year old this story took me back, the second aim chatrooms and Delilah radio got mentioned I was squealing. The emotions in this are so raw and so relatable to everyone. I think what also really tore at my heart was how Jamie got the opportunity to watch her life back with new eyes. The first time she experienced it she was young, and didn’t see her worth. Seeing it again through adult eyes changed it all and showed her just how loved she was free of that youthful insecurity. I don’t want to give too much away because I think like Jamie you need to experience it all for yourself. I was lucky enough to get to listen to this on netgalley and I think the audiobook really elevated this experience. Morgan Lee Miller wrote a unique story with some beautiful characters and Quinn Riley does a phenomenal job of breathing life into them. I could feel everything these characters were going through and hearing it through Quinn’s narration was on another level. The raw emotion and vulnerability really comes through. I love this book so much already, prepare to cry from all kinds of emotions.
3/5 Like always, thank you , NetGalley and the publishing house, for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Overall , it's a great romance ; it's very original , and the concept is quite simple to understand . I just started to get a bit bored around the 30-40% mark of the book. I feel like I was reading the same thing over and over, as Mallory and Jamie had the same issues-like, please, girls, just break up at this point! I'm not a big fan of second-chance romance; that's maybe why I'm a hater, but hear me out...
The characters are great ; I'm kind of sad that the book is only from Jamie's POV because we don't get to know Mallory, only through Jamie's mind and eyes. By the way, Jamie is my favorite character ; she's funny and honestly quite relatable (# loser lesbian assemble). I feel like Mallory was pretty much the love interest, but also the villain, and that's due to the fact that everything happens from Jamie's POV. The setting is so cool! I'm too young to know anything about this era, so a lot of references didn't land with me, but I'm a big music fan, so I knew pretty much all the songs and artists mentioned . On this note, I loved the idea of having a song per memory; it's a very good concept and makes the book even better!
To end this review, it's a really interesting book ; the romance is quite complex and evolves around the characters, but also with time itself!
The Rewind Effect follows Jamie, who loses years of her memories after a tragic car accident. Through an experimental music based therapy, she’s able to slowly recover them, with every memory leading her back to the girl she met on AOL in the late 90s.
I requested this book thinking it would be a cute, funny sapphic rom com. I couldn’t have been more wrong and I’m so glad I was. This is one of the most beautiful, intimate and realistic portrayals of a relationship I’ve ever read. The story follows Jamie from her college years, through moving to the city and starting her career, all the way to her forties. At the heart of it all is her relationship with Mallory, the girl she met on AOL at the dawn of the internet. This book captures so perfectly what it feels like to meet the love of your life when you’re so young and everything that comes with that, the joy, the heartbreak, the uncertainty, the longing and all the ways your lives grow together and apart over the years. It’s such a tender story, full of yearning and so much emotion. I had to put this book down multiple times because I was crying so much. I loved experiencing everything through Jamie’s perspective, her love, her mistakes, her grief, her anger and her happiness. It genuinely felt like growing up alongside her, finding the people who become your family and never quite being able to let go of the girl who changed your life all those years ago.
The nostalgia was another thing I absolutely loved. The late 90s and early 2000s felt so vivid and the music woven throughout the story made it even more special. The ending had me crying and smiling at the same time and I don’t think I’ll be forgetting this story anytime soon. I don’t want to say much more because I truly think this is a story that’s best experienced going in almost completely blind. This is easily one of the best books I’ve read all year and I immediately wanted to pick up everything Morgan Lee Miller has ever written.
An easy 5 stars. A perfect read.
This book comes out on 08/11/26.
Thank you so much netgalley and Bold Strokes Books for the Arc!
I loved discovering Jamie’s life alongside her as she slowly recovers her memories and reflects on the person she used to be.
This is the second book featuring amnesia that I’ve read this summer (after Back to Square One by Georgia Beers), and while it may not be the most believable plot device, I really love what it allows here. Giving both main characters a fresh start brings so much emotional depth to their relationship, and I found it incredibly moving.
The nostalgia woven throughout The Rewind Effect was the icing on the cake for me. I absolutely loved it.
The Heart Remembers. Unfortunately, So Does Everything Else. Morgan Lee Miller’s “The Rewind Effect” gives first love a neurological encore – complete with old songs, old jealousy, and the bill for old mistakes By Demetris Papadimitropoulos | August 7th, 2026
Disaster leaves Jamie Kessler with a forty-five-year-old life and only nineteen years of usable testimony. After a car accident erases nearly all of her adult autobiographical memory, she wakes knowing facts without experience: she works in music, comes from Virginia, has an older sister, remembers adolescence and the first tremors of queer desire. Most of what followed is blank. Amnesia initially grants her the procedural innocence of someone who cannot remember what she did. Morgan Lee Miller’s “The Rewind Effect” spends its best pages taking that innocence away. Jamie must recover the woman she loved, certainly, but also the woman she was while loving her – including the choices that helped ruin what she most wanted to keep.
Experimental medicine is how Miller makes the missing decades speak. At a neurological institute in Malibu, Jamie undergoes OAST, a fictional treatment pairing light stimulation with personally meaningful music. Songs become trapdoors. Oasis returns a teenage Ford Fiesta, Big Red gum and Jamie’s first sexual experience with a woman; Radiohead leads her toward college; later tracks recover apartments, bodies, arguments, careers and grief. The medicine need not survive peer review to do its fictional job, and music is less decoration here than method. Miller is better with the odd sequence of recollection itself: taste before chronology, a guitar figure before the room around it, bodily recognition before biography catches up.
Memory first returns Jamie to 1998 and an AOL lesbian chatroom, where ItsJamie97 meets MalRooE80. Their courtship begins when intimacy can still be assembled from typed jokes, a screen name and the nerve required to send a private message. They trade Claire Danes references and music opinions; 11:11 becomes ritual; a telephone call can feel nearly ceremonial. Fruitopia, Walkmans and Lilith Fair date the scene, but the retro pleasure is not finally about remembering discontinued beverages. For a closeted nineteen-year-old in Virginia, an F4F room is proof that lesbian life exists elsewhere in ordinary, funny, flirtatious numbers. The internet does not merely introduce Mallory. It enlarges the imaginable world.
Eventually the women meet, and distance acquires a smell. Mallory gives Jamie a sweatshirt carrying her scent. Seattle becomes both grunge pilgrimage and courtship; New Year’s Eve 1999 turns friendship into sex and love. Miller understands the humble residues of long-distance intimacy: detergent, perfume, borrowed clothing, the peculiar intimacy of a voice known before a face. The sweatshirt is especially good because it does not need to symbolize much to matter. Sometimes longing is simply sleeping in somebody else’s clothes because the country is inconveniently large.
The treatment room changes meaning when Jamie surfaces from one of these memories, looks at the reserved Dr. Wilson beside her and realizes she is looking at Mallory. Not a resemblance, not a relative – Mallory herself, twenty-five years older and carrying another surname. From then on, every session has a double exposure. Jamie inhabits the young Mallory while the older woman sits a few feet away, already knowing the ending Jamie has not reached. The beloved being reconstructed is also supervising the reconstruction. A high-concept hook acquires a discomfort the book cannot entirely charm away.
Reunion, once Jamie reaches it in the recovered past, does not stay suspended in youthful longing. She and Mallory build a shared life: apartments, intertwined families, careers, ordinary habits. Mallory’s father, Alan, develops early-onset dementia, eventually turning her toward neurology and giving her research its private motive. Jamie moves from music journalism into A&R. Domesticity is where the book stops being merely about the glow of first love. Once the women share a household, losing Mallory no longer means losing an ideal. It means losing routines, family obligations, bad workdays, the person who knows which silence means leave me alone and which means please stay. Alan’s decline also keeps OAST from floating free as handy plot science: Mallory’s fascination with recall grows from watching music briefly return recognizable pieces of her father.
In Jamie, Miller has a narrator so insistently present that even amnesia cannot quiet her. She is profane, horny, funny, sentimental, impatient and musically judgmental. Biography has vanished; temperament has not. Taste, appetite, humor and attraction survive where chronology does not. Jamie’s immediate interest in Dr. Wilson before recognizing her is both gag and instinct. The mind has misplaced twenty-five years; the eye, apparently, kept better records.
Plenty of Jamie is the point; occasionally, it is also the problem. Miller favors quick declaratives, fragments, bantering dialogue and longer rushes when memory floods her. The prose moves quickly, but Jamie often supplies the sensation, the joke about it, the metaphor for it and then the explanation of what it meant. A scene lands, and the narration occasionally sends a forwarding address. The same surplus affects the period texture: several references create atmosphere; a dozen begin to resemble inventory. Miller controls Jamie’s voice firmly. She is less disciplined about when that voice should leave some air in the room.
As the sessions continue, OAST controls what Jamie remembers and when the novel is allowed to know it. Paige and Mallory cannot simply fill in the missing decades without risking contamination of Jamie’s recollections, so disclosure arrives at the speed of memory rather than at the convenience of exposition. This turns backstory into suspense: Why is Mallory now Dr. Wilson? What happened between them? Why was Jamie in California before the crash? The procedure can settle into a visible rhythm – song, memory, clinic, next song – but it also makes Jamie’s musical life formally necessary. Liane Moriarty’s “What Alice Forgot” likewise estranges a woman from the life she made; Miller adds the peculiar severity of making Jamie watch the decisive scenes from inside the person who made the mistakes.
Past Jamie becomes hardest to defend when Kelly enters the story. Mallory once ended their long-distance relationship to pursue Candice, a nearby woman, and the fear of replacement survives the couple’s later reconciliation. Years afterward, when Mallory grows close to fellow neurologist Kelly, Jamie treats proximity itself as evidence. Mallory says Kelly’s feelings are not reciprocated. Jamie cannot accept the reassurance. Mallory repeats herself; Jamie distrusts repetition; Mallory withdraws; Jamie reads withdrawal as proof. When both women receive fellowships in California, Jamie sees betrayal inside a professional triumph Mallory wants her to share. Love has become an interrogation in which reassurance is inadmissible.
Amnesia earns its place in the novel when present Jamie has to endure the 2010 breakup without the privilege of intervention. She understands why the younger woman is frightened, but explanation is not acquittal. OAST restores what happened to Jamie and, more painfully, Jamie’s authorship of what happened next. She discovers that she was capable of loving Mallory intensely while using that love to justify behavior that made intimacy harder. Amnesia has spared her the memory of guilt, not its authorship.
During the fourteen years after the breakup, the novel grows wider and thinner. Jamie builds a successful A&R career, her family expands, and she loves other women. Mallory eventually marries Kelly. Jamie spends three years with Amanda, a relationship the book treats as real rather than filler. Neither woman waits in amber. Yet Jamie and Mallory receive scenes while much of these alternative lives arrives in synopsis. Amanda matters, but we experience comparatively little of the relationship that proves Jamie can love after Mallory. That asymmetry matters because the novel later invokes those intervening loves as evidence of maturity while giving us less chance to inhabit them. The ending is partly decided by where Miller spends her pages.
In 2024, when Jamie learns that Mallory is divorcing Kelly, Miller has to decide how much reality to grant the marriage that came after Jamie. Mallory describes it as loving but eventually insufficient, a partnership that became “good enough” beside the charge she once knew with Jamie. Jamie recognizes the same ranking in her own life. The path back to first love is now conveniently clear. A more difficult version could have let Mallory love Kelly enormously and Jamie love Amanda enormously without making either attachment a lesser draft of the right one. Then reunion would be a choice among lives that all counted, not proof that first love had been quietly winning for twenty-five years.
More troubling is how quickly the novel abandons its own warning that memory can be contaminated. Jamie is told that photographs, stories and outside information may alter recollection, briefly raising the possibility that remembering is reconstruction rather than retrieval. Yet her recovered past is astonishingly obedient – chronological, sensorially rich, conversationally complete. Rooms return; sex returns; arguments return with their meanings attached. No consequential recollection later proves substantially wrong. Miller opens the door to a less trustworthy past, then elects not to walk through it. The romance becomes easier to settle; the premise becomes a little less strange.
In the last recovered memory, past and present finally meet. Jamie and Mallory reunite in 2024 after fourteen years apart. Mallory reveals the impending divorce; Kelly’s name reactivates Jamie’s resentment; the women reenact the emotional logic of 2010. Jamie leaves furious. Then she realizes, almost at once, that she has performed the old mistake with astonishing fidelity. This time recognition arrives before years of silence can follow. She turns the car around to go back and apologize. Headlights appear. The crash that erased Jamie’s memories occurred because she had finally decided not to repeat herself.
That U-turn is almost offensively neat as symbolism, but neatness occasionally earns its keep. The novel has spent hundreds of pages rewinding, and Jamie’s final remembered act is literally to reverse direction. More important, the accident is no longer arbitrary misfortune. It interrupts a change Jamie had already begun making before OAST restored the reasons for it. Seconds before her old life vanished, she chose repair over departure. The satisfying part is not that plot, title and character align. It is that the book makes a metaphor out of an action Jamie actually has to take.
Responsibility is not left entirely on Jamie’s side. Mallory admits that she, too, became cold and punitive, and later reveals that she underwent OAST during Jamie’s treatment because she did not want to care for Jamie while trapped inside anger from a fight Jamie could no longer remember. Mallory’s treatment keeps Jamie from being the only one sentenced to meet her former self. It also gives their history a second witness, which matters because Jamie’s recovered account would otherwise dominate the moral record. Her resentment is not disproved; it is placed beside the tenderness, fear and bad decisions that produced it. Neither woman gets to keep the version of the past in which only the other one failed.
One awkward fact refuses to disappear into romance: Mallory is Jamie’s former lover, the object of her returning desire and one of the physicians overseeing the procedure through which that desire is being restored. Miller recognizes the doctor-ex-lover problem, building in Dr. Singh, supervision and informed consent, and she postpones overt reunion until treatment ends. Those safeguards matter without making the situation neutral. The arrangement can feel thrillingly charged or clinically dubious; either way, an ethics committee seems to hover just beyond the exam-room door. That discomfort keeps the premise from becoming entirely wish fulfillment.
Paired across a quarter century, AOL and OAST make the book’s neatest rhyme. At nineteen, Jamie uses one technology to discover that queer life extends beyond the limits of her immediate world. At forty-five, another restores the history that first connection produced. One lets her find Mallory; the other lets her find the self who loved Mallory. The social distance between those moments is considerable: an anonymous F4F chatroom at one end, two middle-aged women able to make their private promise legally ordinary at the other. Miller leaves that history in the background, where it registers through what Jamie can first only type anonymously and what, decades later, she can say in public without asking permission.
On the page, “The Rewind Effect” is often more pleasurable than its final romantic certainty is convincing. I’d place it at 79/100, or 3/5 stars. Its structure is more disciplined than its prose, and it understands jealousy, shame and repair more deeply than it understands the plurality of adult love. The book’s best move is to make Jamie recover authorship of the damage she once helped cause. Its compromise is to let that difficult knowledge complicate her innocence while allowing it, finally, to simplify whom she was meant to love.
Under the epilogue’s courthouse wedding, another image keeps moving. Jamie is in the car, minutes before the accident, realizing she has reached the old mistake again and turning back. That is where the title does its finest work. A rewind can return the song, the argument, the smell of a sweatshirt, even the person one used to be. Revision begins only when the familiar road reappears and someone, at last, takes the turn differently.
I’m starting with I do NOT think they should’ve ended up together…call me a monster but if you leave me TWICE then marry the woman you tell me not to worry about we are never ever getting back together or whatever Taylor Swift said in that song. I was really rooting for Jamie’s character in the beginning I even wanted them to get back together. It was maybe 50-60% in that I’m like oh hey Mallory actually kind of sucks and constantly hurt Jamie with actions and words. Jamie was not perfect, but her insecurities and jealousy were directly caused by Mallory’s actions! Mallory was not even necessarily a good person…When she moved to Harvard for med school Jamie was dating another woman. Yet she kept flirting and hint dropping her feelings towards Jamie. Also her friends and family definitely should not have encouraged them reuniting the first time after college. Let alone 14 years later after once again Mallory finds herself single. It just felt like Mallory was taking advantage of the feelings she knew Jamie had for her. It came off as Mallory wanting her when she wasn’t available and wanting her because she was lonely.
~The 9/11 scene was written the most beautifully out of all the memories told. This one was the most vivid and heartbreaking.
~Also the only memories she could bring back were Mallory. Cool I guess forget her friends, family, and any other accomplishments she may have had while building her career. This is getting 2 stars because I absolutely love the cover although it does portray this would be a YA title.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.