Sin Sackey is driven by the same hardwired need as every eldest first-generation daughter--to make her family proud. And she built her career and chose her partners with that single goal as her north star.
Everyone said she had it all. And for more than twenty years, Sin let herself believe they were right. Until a near-death experience makes the truth impossible to deny. Her relationship is on life support. Her journalism career is in freefall. And the city she thought she'd conquer has chewed her up and spit her out.
With everything to prove--and everything to lose--Sin moves back home to Washington, DC. But on the eve of the first day of the rest of her new life, the saying about old habits proves painfully accurate.
A new lead falls into her lap, and Sin dives back into the story that nearly cost her everything. Then, when a man who is all the things she's sworn to avoid invites her to dinner, she says yes. But this story could resurrect her career--and take down an entire black-market empire. She's closer than ever to catching its elusive leader, and she can't let go now.
And this man could be the one. So, she lowers her walls just enough for him to climb over.
But just when it seems her gamble might pay off, her lead starts to feel more like a trap. And the man she's let herself love appears to be the one who set it.
Thank you to NetGalley, Dylan Allen, Blue Box Press, and Tantor Media for the opportunity to listen to an advanced audio copy of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review. **audiobook release date Aug 18, 2026**
I’d seen “To Catch a Sinner” around for a while and was really intrigued by the premise, especially after other ARC readers were talking about it. And let me say, with this being Dylan Allen debut novel, she starts the story off really strong.
The chemistry and banter between Sin and Kwame immediately worked for me. There was spice early on, their attraction felt natural, and their personalities played well against each other. Sin is a little all over the place, but comes with the territory of her career. She is honest, relentless, and navigating her own life while also being an investigative journalist determined to uncover the truth. Kwame, whose cultural background is Ghanaian; he is a criminal prosecutor dealing with grief and a complicated family history, has plenty of his own baggage.
Once we got beyond Kwame reading his mother’s will, the pacing slowed down considerably. There was a lot of dialogue, character development, family history, grief, cultural expectations, and backstory. I enjoyed learning those things, but there was not enough action moving alongside that development.
What initially feels coincidental slowly starts feeling like fate, particularly when Sin realizes her family’s home has a connection to the property Kwame’s mother left him in her will. Add Sin’s investigation into stolen Ghanaian cultural artifacts and a black-market operation that may connect directly to Kwame’s family, and that’s a lot to manage with all the other connections being added.
It felt like the story introduced all of these intriguing notions at the beginning, then asked me to hold onto them for a very long time before something happened again. By the time the suspense really began picking back up, I felt like I was around 65% into the story. That’s a long time to wait when the opening promises something much faster.
Unfortunately, that’s also where the book started losing me. For a romantic suspense, I needed more depth in suspense.
I don’t think the plot itself was boring. I actually think the premise is really good. For me, this was more of a structural and pacing issue. I wanted some of that character development broken up by smaller reveals, danger, investigative discoveries, or moments of tension that kept reminding me there was a larger mystery unfolding.
I also struggled at times with the number of characters being introduced. With a dual-POV story that already has two developed protagonists, introducing a large supporting cast requires really clear transitions and placement. There were moments when I had to replay chapters because I wasn’t completely sure who someone was or how they connected to everything else.
One thing I did appreciate was the cultural layer of the story. Sin and Kwame both are adults who are still navigating parental expectations and family obligations. They’re grown-grown, but that doesn’t automatically remove the influence of family or culture from their decisions. I thought there was something interesting in watching both characters navigate family dynamics.
And then…that cliffhanger. 😩 Now I understand why everyone was talking about it.
Overall, it had strong beginning, an interesting cultural foundation, complicated family dynamics, and a premise with a lot of potential. I just needed the suspense woven more consistently throughout to keep me fully engaged.
I would potentially lean in and read book 2 due to the cliffhanger, but it won’t be an immediate read.
This is a mystery romance that puts the hot yet decidedly slow burning developing love between two first-generation children of African immigrants at the heart of an art heist. Even though the art heist is a central event in this book, the book is really focused on the two MCs, their love story, and their individual journeys exploring their intersecting identities, family ties, and wrestling with careers that turn out to be disappointing & disheartening.
The author does a really good job of developing our MCs. They both are likable, but clearly flawed and nuanced individuals. Towards the end of the books, I started to dislike the MMC more than the FMC. The MMC has been astronomically rich his entire life. The conflicts he navigates are rooted in his distaste of his own wealth and wealth privilege, that he simultaneously uses throughout the book. He presents as a person who strongly holds a personal moral code. His wealth makes it easy for his to hold these values because he's never had to risk or compromise anything to achieve a goal. I enjoyed how the FMC is plain spoken about her conflicts. She is presented as person who more directly takes on challenges, even if her approach is not subtle or nuanced or lawful. This was refreshing for me.
As the book progressed, I became frustrated with how the MCs were so effusive about their feelings for one another but so secretive about many other aspects of their lives. But this fits with their personalities. The MMC hiding the FMC away from his wealthy family and friends fits with the shame he carries about his wealth. The FMC desire to hide her relationship from her family fits with her obsessing over how she is perceived by her family given her first daughter status.
It took me a minute to get used to the chosen voice actors for this story. Knowing that the MCs were both Black Ghanaian, the FMC's voice actor didn't initially feel like the right choice to me. After the first few chapters, I didn't mind and she did an excellent job with her MMC voice and the colonial English accents of several of the supporting characters. The MMC's voice actor did a great job conveying the MMC's aloofness and rich-boy swag, but to me, he sounded older than the MMC is supposed to be. I accept that these are my own personal tastes.
The book ends on a cliffhanger so I'm excited to see where the story goes from here. I hope the art heist is resolved by the end of the next book. For it being a recurring theme in the book, we don't spend much time on this part of the drama in this book. This is the first book I've read by this author and this book makes me excited to read more of her work.
ALC Review 📚 Book Title: To Catch a Sinner ✍️🏽Author: Dylan Allen Writing As Lucy Wilson-Tagoe 🎙️ Narrator(s): Mirron Willis & Soneela Nankani 📕 Format: 🎧 ⭐️ Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 🕑 Quick Take: Arsinoé “Sin” Sackey is the eldest first-generation daughter of Ghanaian American parents. She was an investigative journalist on the verge of publishing a major story about the return of cultural artifacts to their west African roots he'd story is scooped and she decides to resign from The Times. Meanwhile, a new lead emerges about a artifact heist during transportation to an exhibit and an illegal dealer, but she's struggling to pitch this story to her new media outlet because she's shifting to the Lifestyle section as an advice columnist. Her career transition is complicated further by her fragile relationship.
Kwame Palmer has come back to DC for his mother's will reading but is eager to return to his job as an attorney in LA. Because of his strained relationship with his father, whom he considers a villain, he tries to distance himself from his father's name and influence.
The two meet by chance at Dogon, a Ghanaian restaurant inside The Salamander Hotel. With limited reservations, they choose to dine together, and sparks fly, and what was supposed to be just one night turns into something more. Months later, their paths cross once again, and many connections began to unfold. ✨ Themes - One Night Stand - Friends to Lovers - He Falls First - Billlionaire - Romantic Suspsnce
🎭 Narration: Mirron Willis and Soneela Nankani delivered an excellent narration of this novel, especially in voicing different characters. They effectively kept a tense atmosphere throughout. Moreover, some sections needed distinctive accents for the minor characters, which they executed with great skill.
💭Final Thoughts: I enjoyed To Catch a Sinner because I really enjoy romantic suspense! The narrative included both historical and cultural references about Ghana and gave insight into the familial and social pressures and expectations faced by first-generation children of immigrant parents amid the promise of the American Dream. There was definitely a sense of looming suspense. At times, I found both Sin and Kwame to be too trusting or naive to be investigative journalists and prosecutors in their late thirties. Nevertheless, this was a great novel, and I can't wait for Book 2 in the Blurred Lines Duet!
Thanks, Tantor Media, for this advanced listener copy.
was basically a fever dream. It was surreal, chaotic, unexpectedly romantic, and somehow still had a great storyline underneath all of it. I have complicated feelings about Sin and Kwame because the beginning of their life together was anything but conventional. At times, it felt like they became dependent on each other more than they actually developed a healthy relationship, and the situation with Paloma definitely made me look at Kwame differently. But the chemistry between these two? UNDENIABLE. The romance went crazy from beginning to end, and the spice level was a 9/10. They were not wasting any time.
I was actually surprised by how much romance there was because I initially thought we would get more of Sin’s career and professional life, but the storyline kept me invested regardless. And then there were Oz and Paloma, who were both absolutely unhinged. Like, what is Y’ALL deal? And Violet?! Who is Violet and why does she keep popping up?! I need answers immediately. The story explored family dynamics, second chances, identity, and self-worth in ways that gave the romance more depth than I expected.
My only real complaint is that IT DIDN’T END. How am I supposed to feel satisfied when I clearly need the next book immediately? Overall, this book was everything you want from a romance when you want to escape real life for a little while: complicated love, undeniable chemistry, plenty of spice, drama, and a storyline that keeps you turning the pages. It felt like a fever dream filled with the kind of romance you want in real life, wrapped up in a story that kept me entertained the entire time.
Thank you to NetGalley and Tantor Media for the advanced listening copy of this book. I was a lucky paperback winner and hadn’t started it yet, so I was excited to listen too! This was my first Dylan Allen/Lucy Wilson-Tagoe read. The cover caught my eye right away. The Blurred Lines Duet is a must read; I’m ready for book 2!
"If the mountain won't come to me, I will go to her.” ❤️
The narrators, Mirron Willis and Soneela Nankani, are seasoned and exceptional. Both narrators are engaging and warm. I love the grounded tone of both of them as eldest siblings. Both were capable of witty banter but also emotional depth. Soneela was very expressive and great at balancing both Sin and Kwame. Mirron was so smooth, velvety, and soulful. He had a way of brining an intense quietness at just the right time for just the right amount of time.
Began this one for the suspense and high stakes investigation, stayed for the cultural identity and romance. The “will they won’t they” beyond their first encounter was sooo good! Kwame and Sin had such great chemistry. Their attraction felt genuine and unrushed. Their conversations were my favorite part! Besides their romance, the suspense kept me on my toes - I was living for every secret. My only complaint is leaving us on a cliffhanger!
I really enjoyed the mix of romance and mystery in To Catch a Sinner! At its core, this story is about identity, family, and choosing your own path. If you know what it’s like to feel the pressure of your parents when it comes to the choices you make, this one will definitely hit.
Kwame and Sin come from completely different backgrounds, but they’re both carrying similar pressures and expectations from their families. I really enjoyed their romance and watching that connection grow. Sin was easily my favorite. I loved her character, her independence, and the passion she had for her work.
The hunt Sin is on slowly starts unraveling so much, and I loved seeing how everything was intertwined. The mystery wasn’t quite as prominent as the romance, but I was here for it. It added that extra layer to the story and kept me wanting to figure out how everything connected.
The audio was also really well done. The accents were perfect and added so much to the characters and story.
I was lucky to receive the ARC last year in another format, which I believe was from an earlier draft. I wasn’t expecting a cliffhanger, but I was completely drawn into how the pieces came together for Kwame and Sin—their complicated family, the DMV shoutouts, their career goals, the art theft mystery, the morally gray choices, their relationship. However, the audio version didn’t work for me. The female narrator didn’t capture Sin’s vibe or that of her family. She’s clearly talented, but I couldn’t feel the connection between her performance and the characters. The male narrator didn’t come across as a cool, virile man; instead, he felt more like an elder statesman who occasionally says something shocking. I’d recommend reading another format, and if cliffhangers aren’t your thing, maybe wait until the second book is out.
Ehh... it was okay. I only had the audiobook to work with, and I feel the narrators weren't the best choice. They aren't terrible, but when it came to the spicy scenes, they sounded too professional. And it sounded awkward, like listening to virgins trying dirty talk for the first time.
Now onto the actual story. The characters seemed like they didn't even have chemistry at first. On their first meet up, seemed like they were arguing and trying to humble each other. Then somehow, then ended up falling for each other? Something about their romance just wasn't believable.
Then, I felt like too much time was spent on talking about Kwame and Sin and not enough about Sin investigating the Black Market and stolen art. Which brings me to point three...
This book DID NOT need to be 13+ hours. 10 hours TOPS was all that was needed.
Thanks to the author and NetGalley for early access to this ALC.
I enjoyed this book for the storyline. It kept me invested and waiting for what’s next. My draw back was the narration at times. I enjoyed the accents but sometimes the normal characters’ voice came off whiny especially the female narrator.
I would purchase this book but would most likely skip on purchasing the audiobook. But one thing I need to know when the next book is dropping cause that ending 🤯
I really wanted to like this novel, but it was seriously all over the place. It felt like two separate stories being forced together with literally zero resolution. I understand a cliffhanger to captivate your audience to read the next book, but this was so sloppy and poorly done. I will say the audio was stunning. The narrators’ voices were beautiful. I feel like this story had so much potential, but the execution leaves a lot to be desired.
This book had potential but it had so much happening that it didn’t come together. Also too much back story, it could have been told in a different way and we could still get the point it was trying to make. Especially about her parents and her job.
If the whole book was more like the end I would have enjoyed it more.
It just felt like every idea the author had was put into the book and it wasn’t necessary.
The book wasn’t bad, I was just left wanting more. It does end in a cliffhanger and while I don’t mind cliffhanger’s at all, this one fell flat for me. The relationship between the MCs was instalove and I didn’t see enough building of their relationship to warrant them as a connected couple.
The narrators to the audiobook did an amazing job! The accent was done perfectly and they brought life to the characters.
I didn't know this was a part of a series. So, I was confused when I was getting to the end of the story and I was left on a cliffhanger. I need book two immediately. I enjoyed the romance and the mystery. This was a good time.
Enjoyable. Not sure Kwame and Sin would make it as a couple, assuming Sin makes it. Was disappointed in the ending but I suppose that sets you up for a sequel.