1.5 Stars
This review may contain spoilers. I try to avoid them when reviewing at all costs, but since I have rated this book so low I feel it's only fair to properly point out my issues with this book. I have not given away what I consider to be major plot points, but if you like to go into a book totally blind then I would advise you not to continue reading.
This is such a tough review to write, I had many issues with this book; the characters, the story, the editing, even sadly the writing. But apart from all these issues I think I just found that it didn't hold my interest. I picked it up and put it down several times before I was able to finish, and I'm normally one for finishing a book in one sitting, or at least not starting other books while I've still got one half read. Ordinarily I am a person who rarely won't finish a book, no matter how much I struggle with it, I think there has been only two occasions where I haven't been able to finish a book. Since this was an ARC received through our blog I had to power through with it, but honestly if it was a book I had purchased to read of my own accord I don't believe I would have gotten past the first 10%.
So, the first problem I had with this book was the relationship between the two main characters. They are brother and sister, twins in fact, and even considering the problems they faced from such a young age which of course would make them close, I found their relationship just to be...weird. To me, it's strange that a brother and sister in their 20's would share a bed, and I found Brian's feelings over his sister Blaine's having a boyfriend odd to say the least. Of course an over-protective brother may dislike the fact his sister is dating, but Brian's issue seemed to be more the fact that she "didn't need him anymore" and she was replacing him. Well, that's just odd! It was almost as if he was jealous, and that just weirded me out.
Secondly I found Brian, the main character whose POV this book is mostly written in, an unconvincing male. To clarify, I could clearly tell his first person POV was written by a woman, and of course it was but that shouldn't be so glaringly obvious. The whole idea of writing is that you can create convincing characters, and Brian just was not a convincing character. There were many mannerisms and speech from him that I cringed at, I couldn't help but think, "A guy just wouldn't say that", or, "A guy just wouldn't do that!" Either that or he was a very girly guy, he even said "Puh-lease!" at one point!
Now to the love story, which I guess should be considered a plot point, but it's really not so much. Brian experiences a huge dose of insta-love with Madeline. From the moment he meets her he's confessing his love for her. And even though she expresses zero interest at first and has a boyfriend he still pursues her. He borders on the creepy on some occasions. Yes, I get he's been in prison from the age of 11 and has no idea how to be around girls, I get that, but this is unbelievable even considering that. Oh, and while I'm on topic of him being inside since he was 11 and being socially awkward, yes, that's totally believable and he would indeed be that way. But Brian seems to have a thing where he cannot tell when people are lying to him, and he doesn't understand subtleties, he needs everything spelled out because he struggles to read people. This is made out to be because he's been in prison so long. Come on, he'd been inside with rapists and murderers for 11 years, he'd be an expert at smelling out a lie. Do we think he wouldn't have come into contact with professional liars in the whole time he was in there? Back on topic of him and Maddie, I just couldn't not believe the scene where Brian threatens her boyfriend and tells him never to show his face in Maddie's restaurant again. And that's the first time he spoke to him. What gives him the right to say that? I had to put my kindle down at that point because I was so frustrated, real people just don't act that way surely. It just seemed so far-fetched. I guess the writing just wasn't that great.
Lastly I'm guessing since this is an ARC that final edits had not been completed, now I'm no stranger to this, I'm used to ignoring the odd typo or grammatical error, but this book had quite a lot. Some of them were so obvious too, like the word 'then' consistently being misused for 'than'. Simple errors like that that are consistently misused throughout tend not to be so much the odd missed error, but more likely due to the author or editor having missed it because they consider it to be correct.
I'm sorry to say that I really did not enjoy this book, I really struggled to finish it. It's a shame because the blurb really piqued my interest but when it came down to it the book just did not deliver.