This book begs the why should an album make you feel good?
In 1989, The Cure's Robert Smith was going to turn thirty years old. His fears and anxieties of age-having not yet written his pinnacle album-caused Smith to embark on the band's undoing with Disintegration. The result was an LP drenched in melancholy sublime, a beautiful decree of breaking down to build anew. From the fame and notoriety of The Cure after their hit, “Just Like Heaven,” to the departure of the only other consistent band member, Lol Tolhurst, it's clear that the grisly spiral into the depths of pain is stamped throughout Disintegration.
This book explores the depths of Smith's masterpiece by way of the French Modernist Charles Baudelaire and his poem, “Spleen.” Much like Smith, Baudelaire took his temperament and softened the edges of sorrow, transforming it into a mass of supercharged a tenuous concoction of sin and sex, lust and monstrosity, self-hatred and fear… all cauterized by the malaise (and acceptance) of eternal melancholy.
And through Disintegration lies Robert Smith's corpus-his spleen. It's here that The Cure's upheaval and Smith's heroic martyrdom became the catalyst for his masterpiece.
The Cure's Disintegration? It's one of the greatest albums of all time. Heap all the praise upon it.
Andi Harriman's book about the album? Probably not the worst book I've ever read, but definitely one of the worst I've read in the past ten years.
When one picks up a book about a specific album, one expects the author to, you know, talk about the album. Here the first fifteen percent is spent predominately waffling on about Baudelaire, with little ink dedicated to the band, let alone the album the book is named for.
Things do not improve as the book continues. Imagine reading over a hundred pages written by an unbearable grad student convinced of their own genius—or the gate-keeping hipster in the music store—and you'll have some idea what it's like to read this book.
I'm going to go put the album on at maximum volume and hope that it can blast this book from my brain.
Rare enough that a 33 1/3 even takes on the album I'd have chosen by a given act, but this is one of the still smaller number to pick an all-time Top 10 greatest album ever. Yeah, you'd think at 200+ entries (not counting subsidiary ranges) they should have had that covered by now, but they will persist in working from misguided notions of 'the canon' or 'the preferences of individual contributors' rather than asking me for a checklist, so these things happen.
Of course, maybe that's for the best, because if I'm reading about an album that interests me but which I don't know back to front, like John Prine or Madvillainy, I'm probably an easier crowd than I am for thoughts on a record where I already have so many of my own. Still, I don't think you'd need to be a hardcore Cure fan – and it's not as if I'm one of the most hardcore ones I know, not by a long shot – to pick up on some of the problems here. I'm not even talking about the endemic 33 1/3 misstep of saying it's about one album, but then giving a fairly detailed account of the act's career up to that point and even to some extent after. Normally it irks me, but in this instance, yeah, I'm not sure you can properly talk about Disintegration without a full picture of what exactly was disintegrating, and that needs enough backstory about the band and the soured friendship between Robert Smith and Lol Tolhurst for the climax to land with the appropriate emotional weight. No, I'm more bothered by things like the overemphasis on Baudelaire. Who, yes, was very good, and had definite aesthetic shared ground with the Cure, and did even supply the lyrics to one of their songs (albeit not one on Disintegration). But at times Harriman seems to be trying to write almost a Parallel Lives when the material just won't sustain that degree of connection – and, having invoked the poor bastard to shine a light on the (yes, very Disintegration) yoking of beauty to sadness, she never even deploys his best line on exactly that topic, which ever since I read it, I've thought comes as close as anyone does or could to explaining the phenomenon: that humans cry when we see or hear something beautiful for the same reason an exile cries when reminded of home.
The issue goes way beyond that, though. It could seem odd to complain about pretentiousness when discussing a borderline concept album where half the tracks run past the six minute mark, but that's only because 'pretentious' gets thrown around so readily by idiots and philistines who assume that anything more complex than a grunt must be fake. Every lush soundscape and enigmatic lyric on Disintegration means something, was created with knowledge and purpose, works. Whereas this book, at least in the Netgalley ARC, is a mess of sentences that sound high-flown but are assembled in ways that aren't quite right: "If the tightrope between the spectrum of pleasantries and the abyss started with The Head on the Door, it was perfected with 1987's Kiss Me, Kiss Me, Kiss Me album. The double LP had been an oscillating diatribe of the previous Cure as an overall pop ride with tinges of sadness in all the right places – even with a slight return to the dismality of the albums Seventeen Seconds, Faith, and Pornography." I get what that's trying to say, but it reads like it said it much better before an overenthusiastic eleven-year-old ran it through the thesaurus backwards. Elsewhere, though, it's genuinely mystifying. Of Robert Smith and the goth look in general: "In its most basic form, his aesthetic tapped into mainstream semiotic consciousness with feminine touches of makeup, a pale posterior, and a tangle of black hair" – am I simply forgetting all the times he showed his arse, or was 'posterior' not the word wanted? When A Forest is described as "The Cure's first justifiable single", is that merely a terrible take, or is Harriman trying to say something else entirely? And those are very much not isolated examples. There is some good stuff here, if only from the assembly of earlier material (my favourite line was from producer Dave 'not that one' Allen, quite correctly saying of the album that "It's massive, you can go for a swim in it"), and it's always fascinating/horrifying to be reminded that this was a record made by a man terrified he was getting old and hadn't achieved anything, when he was not yet 30 and had already put out seven mostly very good albums. But what frustrates me is that I think with some combination of dialling down the prose and sympathetic editing, Harriman may well have been able to offer further insights, which as it stands are drowning in twisted English and tenuous Baudelaire references.
Veel dank aan Netgalley en Bloomsbury Academic voor het recensie-exemplaar. The Cure’s Disintegration is vanaf 15 oktober te koop.
The Cure is één van die bands die ontzettend belangrijk geweest is voor de ontwikkeling van mijn muzikale smaak. Ik luister inmiddels alweer zo’n twintig jaar naar de band en het bijzondere van hun diverse discografie is dat ze een album lijken te hebben voor iedere fase in mijn leven. Zo zijn Faith, Pornography, The Head on the Door allemaal ergens in mijn leven mijn favoriete Cure-album geweest. Momenteel is dat Disintegration, op de voet gevolgd door Seventeen Seconds. Over mijn favoriete Cure-album van het moment is nu een nieuw boekje in de 33 1/3-reeks verschenen, maar liefhebbers kunnen dat wat mij betreft prima overslaan.
Auteur Andi Harriman karakteriseert Disintegration als een melancholisch album en melancholie is volgens haar een emotie waarbij het zure en het zoete hand in hand gaan. Met die karakterisering van het album en de definitie van melancholie ben ik het helemaal eens. Disintegration is een wonderschoon album vol magnifieke nummers dat probeert om te gaan met fenomenen als vergankelijkheid en eindigheid. De manier waarop The Cure deze thema’s door prachtig georkestreerde composities heen weeft, zorgt ervoor dat je je als luisteraar op een heerlijke manier kunt wentelen in alle droefheid die Robert Smith en kornuiten tentoonspreiden.
Stortvloed Maar daar houdt mijn waardering voor dit nieuwe boekje in de 33 1/3 reeks ook wel op. Het zijn dunne boekjes dus je hebt als auteur eigenlijk weinig ruimte om alles wat er over een boeiend album als Disintegration te schrijven is, kwijt te kunnen. Toch besteedt Harriman zo’n vijftig pagina’s aan alle Cure-albums die voor Disintegration komen. Wat het nut daarvan is? Werkelijk waar geen idee.
Als het Harriman te doen is om te focussen op de vriendschap tussen Smith en Lol Tolhurst – die lang heel innig was, maar tijdens de opnames voor Disintegration op instorten stond, had je dit boek op een heel andere manier kunnen en moeten opbouwen. Nu voelen die eerste vijftig pagina’s aan als een stortvloed van totaal overbodige en nutteloze informatie. Informatie bovendien die mij al wel bekend was en ik ben echt geen hardcore Cure-fan die alles leest wat los en vast zit over de band.
Baudelaire Bovendien ziet Harriman overeenkomsten tussen de melancholie die spreekt uit de gedichten van Charles Baudelaire en de melancholie die te horen is op Disintegration. Het gevolg is dat het vooral in de eerste helft van het boek vooral heel veel over Baudelaire gaat en dat ze telkens heel geforceerd de connectie tussen die twee zoekt; totaal oninteressant en ook bijzonder ergerlijk.
Wanneer het dan eindelijk over Disintegration gaat, blijft de boel akelig oppervlakkig en daar kunnen wat verwijzingen naar Baudelaire niks aan redden. De goede boeken in deze reeks – en die zijn er gelukkig genoeg – veranderen je blik op een bepaald album door in te zoomen op de tijdsgeest, onderzoeken de levenshouding van de betrokken muzikant(en) en brengen verdieping door interessante dwarsverbanden te leggen. Naast die goede boeken uit de reeks steekt dit werkje heel bleekjes af.
In de handen van een goede schrijver had dit iets heel moois en boeiends kunnen worden, maar in de handen van Harriman is het vooral een zootje geworden. Een geniaal album als Disintegration verdient zoveel beter. Het album nadert de perfecte score, maar aan dit boekje kan ik geen voldoende kwijt.
This is only my second 33 1/3 book, and somehow, both referenced philosophical theories by Kristeva—what are the chances of two different authors choosing to go down such an unlikely and pretentious route for two very different artists and records?
I suppose this series is like a box of chocolates—in theory, you never know what you’re going to get, but in practice, I’ve now gotten two very scholarly treatises that drew parallels to things I have little to no interest in: In Harriman’s case, French poet Charles Baudelaire. To be fair, Robert Smith directly lifted lyrics from a Baudelaire poem, so the connection isn’t completely tenuous... except that Harriman doesn’t bring that detail up, and that particular song is not featured on Disintegration—the record we’re allegedly here to talk about. You’re forgiven if that’s slipped your mind, because we don't get to it until almost halfway through this slim volume.
"The beautiful is sad. To rendezvous with beauty is to run, bravely, into the arms of melancholy.”
Harriman characterizes Disintegration as a melancholic album, where the bitter and the sweet goes hand in hand. I don’t think any fan of the Cure would disagree with that assessment, but the way she repeatedly seeks to draw a parallel between the record and Baudelaire felt very contrived. As a relatively new fan of the Cure who is mostly unfamiliar with the band lore, a straight-forward band history without any esoteric tangents is what I would’ve preferred, but I think that if your proposal hinges on such a non-traditional take, you shouldn’t pull your punch. If Harriman had taken a big swing with the Baudelaire stuff throughout the entire volume… I’m not saying that I would’ve liked it any better, but if she’d interwoven the Baudelaire angle throughout, I would at the very least have respected the attempt more. As it is, it felt like she remembered that she ought to tie it back to the opening chapter at the end of what had turned into your standard band biography.
For a long-time, die-hard fan, I imagine that the information given is rather superficial: Even I, starting from a familiarity with the album and not much more, wished for a deeper dive into the writing and recording of it—more about the music, less about the concept of melancholy. At least the reading of the book and writing of this review gave me a good excuse to listen to a great record on repeat.
—————
Note: I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Big thanks to Bloomsbury Academic and NetGalley for sharing one of the latest in their 33 1/3 series of great albums. This one is on one of my favorite albums, which was also one of the albums that was instrumental in shaping my later musical tastes, The Cure’s Disintegration by Andi Harriman. I’m so glad that there is a 33 1/3 book about The Cure, and especially about what many believe to be their best album, 1989’s Disintegration. Herriman’s approach to documenting the album is excellent as she explores the band’s prior discography and how their sounds was influenced both by the changing nature of punk and post-punk in late 70s and early 80s Britain, as well as pressure to record pop singles while also maintaining a sense of artistic integrity and individual voice in their music. Herriman frames Disintegration as the pinnacle of The Cure’s oppositional battle between these forces that ended up confounding reviewers and record execs at first, but has, over time, resulted in what many consider to be the band’s most lauded album. However, what also sets this book apart from other 33 1/3 entries is Harriman’s analysis of The Cure’s work with 19th century French poet Charles Baudelaire. Harriman cites examples of Baudelaire’s poetry and life to explore similarities to The Cure’s music and lyrical content, as well as how the author of Fleur du Mal’s dark and decadent life mirrored some of the gothic intonations of Disintegration. I really appreciated the way this book is structured, as Harriman provides a useful analysis of The Cure’s work up to Disintegration, which helped me to understand how the same band that wrote poppy punk songs like “Boys Don’t Cry” and “Jumping Someone Else’s Train” followed them up with albums like Faith, Seventeen Seconds, and Pornography. She also takes a close look at some of the poppier albums that followed, including The Head on the Door and Kiss Me, Kiss Me, Kiss Me. It was interesting to see how such an iconic band were constantly evolving their sound and the various sources (and substances) that influenced their changing sounds. The Cure is not only known for their unique sound but also their unique look which many attribute to the Goth style. Harriman also explores some of the genesis of Robert Smith and band members’ style, which at times seems to result from comfort as well as a kind of insecurity of being on stage and singing. Harriman also explores the origins and influences of some of The Cure’s songs, which again was interesting to learn more about. However, I loved reading Harriman’s connections between Baudelaire’s work and aspects of The Cure’s songs and style. Baudelaire is such an interesting writer, influenced by Poe, but also uniquely French, he wrote poems and short vignettes that straddled the era of Romanticism and Modernism, yet managed to also create a kind of decadent style that celebrated the fleeting feelings of passion and emotion while also acknowledging the impending decay and rot that frequently follows these pleasures. It’s been a while since I last read Fleur du Mal, so I appreciated Harriman’s inclusion of some of the texts, particularly the poems titled “Spleen”. Harriman not only examines the earlier beliefs in humors, and how the spleen was thought to hold some of the darker humors that influenced feelings like melancholy, but also how Baudelaire’s work shifted the notion of the grotesque and ugliness from evil to something beautiful and sublime. She includes the opening lines, translated by Edna St. Vincent Millay, as “if I lived a thousand years I could not be more crammed with dubious souvenirs. There’s no old chest of drawers bulging with deeds and bills, Love-letters, locks of hair, novels, bad verses, wills, That hides so many secrets as my wretched head;- It’s like a mausoleum, like a pyramid, Holding more heaped unpleasant bones than a Potter’s Field;”. These lines resonate so much with me, as well as the title that is sometimes applied to this “Spleen” poem, “The Sphinx.” Even before delving into the analysis of Disintegration, I could see the relevance of Baudelaire’s lines to songs like “Lullaby” and “Pictures of You”, which are both haunting and romantic in their own dark way. Additionally, noting “The Sphinx” title adds to the mysterious and ominous nature of the music and lyrics of The Cure, where the ambiguity points to both love and loss, remembrance and fading, pleasure and pain. Harriman includes other references to Baudelaire’s work throughout her book, but it’s the last two chapters (before the outro) that detail the creation of Disintegration, which is fascinating to learn more about as well. As the band gradually shifted from original member Lol Tollhurst due to his waning influence, alcoholism, and inability to learn new synthesizer technology, Smith brought in other musicians, who added to and helped shape the evolving sound of the band, bringing it back to darker more melancholic sounds found on earlier albums. Yet, there is something different to the sound of Disintegration, possibly shaped by Smith’s turning 30 and his marriage that filled the album with a sense of fleeting pleasure and the darker side of romanticism. As Harriman notes with Baudelaire, his poetry “rejected the empty gestures of romanticism without losing the heroic energy.” The Cure’s sound feels similar to this notion in that there’s such emotion and feeling in their music, but it doesn’t traffic in the traditional romantic tropes. The pain is not just loss, but the kind of ennui that longs for a time passed that will never return. Even analyzing the cover, which features a faded, almost underwater looking image of Robert Smith surrounded by flowers and other obscured images, suggests something uncanny, familiar, yet distant and fantom-like, observable, but out of reach. Harriman examines how songs like “Pictures of You”, “Love Song”, and Lullaby”- some of the singles from the album, represent this kind of fleeting feeling. Furthermore, she notes how videos helped the band add to the goth imagery of love and loss. I loved reading about the “Lullaby” song and video, since that was always one of my favorites, despite being haunted and frightened by the video when I was younger. It was interesting to learn that Smith’s own childhood and his fascination with mouths added to the creation of this song. I also found it interesting that the band thought that “Fascination Street” was the one song that didn’t quite fit on the album and presented as the US single. I think “Fascination Street” might have been my first exposure to The Cure, and I loved the bass line and guitar feedback and reverb in that song. Beyond the analysis of the album’s contents, Harriman also details how the album was created, with the band moving into a rented old home in the British countryside, and how a fire nearly destroyed the lyrics for the album. I really enjoyed learning more about the creative process, and how the band all ended up bringing demos and ideas for each other to listen to and vote on for inclusion on the album. It was fascinating to learn more about the creative process that was involved in developing and producing this amazing album. I absolutely loved this book, not just because Disintegration is one of the formative albums of my youth that I still listen to today, but also because of Harriman’s fresh approach to analyzing music and literature, noting the similarities between Baudelaire’s own trailblazing style that pushed past the “hollow frills of Romanticism in order to inject its emptiness with the bulbous, uncomfortable tragedies of his damned existence” noting hos “His words are struggles between the virtuous and the immoral, a bouquet of calamitous cavorts with the devil himself.” She goes on to note the oppositions at play in Disintegration, and how “anxiety and pleasure converge in heaps within an immense fortress of sound. A love, an obsession, for the grotesque and the horrible.” It’s a beautiful synthesis that helps to unlock some of the bulging drawers filled with haunting “Memories, nightmares. Messy, shattered dreams.” Both this book and Disintegration the album are a trip down a melancholy lane, reveling in the oddities and sadness we feel along the way. Highly recommended!
My thanks to NetGalley and Bloomsbury Academic for an advance copy of a book that looks at the creation, the inspirations, the toils and tribulations of an album that spoke to many, about the darkness they felt, the loneliness of their lives, pictures of lives, but with even at their sadness, a hope to go on a beauty that one had to live to fully understand.
I was not a fan of high school. Nor was it a fan of me. I had books, comics, computer games, no school spirt, no interest in things that interested the kids around me, and a shyness that many read as distain, teacher and students. Maybe the distain was real. Our school loved arena rock, the stuff played by day on MTV, before if discovered black music, both pop and later rap. I loved the music they played late at night. The darker songs. With weird videos that spoke to my love of movies, but with so many jump cuts, that it was hard to take in. Repeat viewing was important. I remember watching something with the Cure. A slash of red on a dark stage, lipstick so smeared I thought the singer had been punched. Reading this book, its possible he might have been. Robert Smith seemed above it all, a reader, a man with sadness, but a man with a mission. That mission was self-implosion, as the book also shows. Yet from great disasters great art, like the album discussed here, is created. The Cure's Disintegration is another book in the popular 33 1/3 series, written by Andi Harriman and is a look at an album made in a maelstrom of chaos, of addiction, of loss, of fighting, an album that still speaks today, a snapshot of sadness, but also a soundscape that stuns.
The book begins with an overview not of music but of prose and poetry, from the French modernist movement, especially the work of poet Charles Baudelaire, and his work Spasm. Harriman also looks at melancholy, and its consulation to many, its use in art, and as a basis of creativity. From there we come to a band already at the end of their rope, in some cases a hangman's noose. The Cure were a band decaying. Members were being shed, Robert Smith, the singer and architect of sound and in many cases their fury, wanted the band over. So much so that he was becoming a guitarist for hire for other bands. In addition addiction was taking its toll, LSD and alcohol especially. The band was reduced to two Lol Tolhurst a long time friend of Smith, and Smith. Music though was hard to escape, and even in a world slowly collapsing, music was a life preserver. Songs were approached differently, Synthesizers were added, problems written about. The abyss looked into and written about. Creating an album that captures moments for listeners, both good and bad.
And odd book with a intro that might make people move on quickly, or one that will educate in different ways. There is a not long section, but in a book less than 200 pages, fills up quite a bit, about melancholy, French poetry and sadness. We really don't meet the Cure, just joing them in media res just as things are going bad. There is a lot of information, why Smith liked lipstick, different musical and studio tricks used to make the songs sound unique. And of course the numerous problems the band had dealing with each other, fame, addictions and music. Much more than I knew.
I wish there was more about the music, but still I found this to be an interesting primer into the Cure, an album I really enjoy, even a look at their influences. Fans might want more, or already be aware of much that is written here. For listeners who are not as devoted, this is a good start, and one I still found very engaging.
I usually pick up any 33 1/3 series book I see if it's a record or artist that even mildly interests me. You never really know what you are going to get - whether it's a scholarly treatise that reads like a term paper, a fiction story inspired by the record or more straightforward music journalism. Andi Harriman's edition about The Cure's Disintegration is a combination. Harriman frames the Cure's story with a comparison of the French poet Charles Baudelaire, making the case that Baudelaire's poetry and the Cure's music are connected through their effectiveness at conveying melancholy. It's a interesting conceit, but once the idea is introduced it is rarely brought up the rest of the book as the focus turns towards a more traditional history of the Cure. Ultimately, I think the author should have focused on a less traditional narrative, and interweaved Baudelaire's story to a greater degree or instead, just focused on the band.
Harriman's history of the Cure and the focus on the creation of Disintegration along with the following tour and aftermath was thorough, including a variety of quotes and first hand accounts from all the players involved, with Robert Smith getting the most attention. As a non-diehard Cure fan, this was an entertaining read - I appreciated the focus on the songcraft and production of the album especially. I always like to listen to the album I am reading about, especially when the author goes song by song. This was no exception and made for a great way to reintroduce myself to Disintegration in a new way.
Highly recommend this one to longtime or casual Cure fans - if the introduction with Baudelaire doesn't interest you - stick through it and you will enjoy the rest of the books more straightforward history of the Cure.
The Cure's Disintegration by Andi Harriman, part of the 33 1/3 series, is an excellent mix of what makes so many books in the series enjoyable. It is largely how the writer interacts with the album, which helps make each volume a little different. Turns out Harriman places the album not simply within her own lifetime and cultural period but also within the larger literary tradition of similar melancholic works.
I found the bigger picture to be a fun way to remember both the album and the ways it made me feel when I first heard it and the multiple times since. I think it even gave me some new insight into some of my friends who practically worshiped Smith.
Admittedly some people simply enjoy whining about books not being what they wanted. Which is fine even if it is vacuous. If you're an engaged reader who is able and willing to take a book for what it intended to be you will find a lot here to enjoy. This might not be what you anticipated when you picked it up, but you will likely, if you're capable, find new ways to think about the album, about Smith, and about yourself. If you happen to enjoy placing relatively contemporary art alongside the classics, or at least the classic writers, there will be even more that will interest you. If not, pose and pretend to be special looking over a book.
Reviewed from a copy made available by the publisher via NetGalley.
As a longtime, casual fan of The Cure's music, this was a very easy pick-up for me. While subjective tastes may vary, Disintegration is considered the band's finest album for very good reason.
Here, Harriman offers a well-researched, blow-by-blow account of one of the more turbulent times in the group's history, ironically birthing a creative masterpiece during that period.
I found the book very informative; the author's obvious enthusiasm for The Cure came across clearly and made everything much more engaging to take in.
As well as the short introduction to the band and the run-up to the creation of Disintegration, Harriman takes a look at Smith's lyrics by way of Baudelaire's famous poem "Spleen," which was a fascinating and interesting approach to take, as well as a highly appreciated one.
Highly recommended for all casual or more hardcore lovers of the godfathers of goth.
**ARC provided by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review**
As someone who love the band, The Cure, I jumped at the chance to review this book. I've listened to Disintegration for years, it was a formative part of my musical journey when I was in middle and high school. And while the book does take a deep dive into the album, and dips into the history of the band leading up to its release, the over reliance on the Baudelaire comparisons made it hard to really love this book.
The concept of "melancholy" is heavily explored in this book, as the author feels it is the basis of Disintegration and The Cure as a band. While some of this exploration was interesting, it went on far too long for such a short book. I would have preferred a bit more about the band and less about a poet and the meaning of melancholy.
Overall, I really enjoyed the book, but in my mind, it should have been more about the music and less about the esoteric Baudelaire references.
this was fine I guess, but don't go into this expecting much history or breakdown of the recording and musical content of disintegration. a lot of this book is spent positing an allegorical relationship between robert smith and french poet baudelaire, which starts off interesting but feels increasingly forced as the book goes on. this analogy does tie in to disintegration vaguely well thematically, which I appreciated, but it almost feels like this books disintegration title is hedged on that coincidence alone. a few pages are spent on the recording of the album, and another few on the accompanying tour; both segments enjoyable, while the bulk of the book is general cure history from inception to the release of wish - or discussing baudelaire. still a really entertaining read despite feeling more like a comparative critical essay assessment than a book about disintegration.
A long time ago, down in my parents' basement, listening to the radio late at night, the first stark chords of Boys Don't Cry came over WNEW. Back then I used to wait for moments like that, hanging on to Vinny Scelsa, wondering what he'd play next. We used to tape songs off the radio so we could hear them again. Soon after that, some late-night comedy program did a skit about the Robert Smith Helpline, where basically you called Robert Smith and he told you how sad he was to make you feel better. Hard to believe that that band would go on to sell out enormous stadiums.
The first chapter of the book is a HUGE turnoff. The author unwelcomely projects their love of the French poet Baudelaire and attempts to link that to Robert Smith's melancholy. I came to hear about Disintegration, not a Baudelairean perspective. Mercifully this dies down until the "outro."
The rest of the book is a quite good collection of quotes from Smith and stories about intraband difficulties and recording of albums, lineup changes, touring, etc. And holy smokes, the album Disintegration still carries that heft of darkness all these years later. Skip Chapter 1 and turn up the volume on "Fascination Street" or the exquisite self-titled track as you read.
This book is odd. It starts by comparing Robert Smith with the French poet Baudledere. Why? because they are both melancholic? It's hard to understand the comparisons, especially in this context, where the book purports to be about not just one band, but one specific album. At one point Harriman describes it as having two protagonists, but the comparisons feel forced, artificial and unnecessary. I found this volume heavy going, and drifted off without finishing it. Maybe i should go investigate Baudledere and then return to it.
thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the e-arc in exchange for an honest review.
An album as brilliant and emotionally complex as Disintegration deserved a much better examination than this. My criticism is not that Harriman doesn't lack interesting ideas, but her overly elaborate, pretentious writing frequently obscures whatever insights she might have to offer. The book talks more about Baudelaire than Disintegration. Which, if I had bought a book about Baudelaire, would have been great. There is some historical background about Robert and Lol's falling out, a little bit about Robert's state of mind and fear of aging when recording it, some excerpts from previously published interviews and articles, and that's it. And it is in dire need of a good editor. Big disappointment
So the first section wasn't as interesting to me because it was so philosophical, and that was what the author thought was important, but what I liked was the rest, where it talked about the band and how they made their music and interacted with each other. This was my college music so I did love learning more about these interesting people. I don't know why I was surprised there was so much drama lol. Thanks to NetGalley for letting me read this
Disintegration saw The Cure falling to pieces, and the book sort of echoes that. Harriman executes an extended metaphor/comparison of Baudelaire and Smith and then spends a large portion of the end of the book discussing the accompanying tour. I wanted more focus on the album and its recording, which we are teased with but never fully drawn into.
A very deep dive not the birth, recording and release and review of Disintegration by the cure. Deffo one for the fans and don’t make any attempt to read t if you haven’t heard the album recently. Also talks about Baudelaire a lot.
Full Disclosure: I received an Advanced Reader's Copy of The Cure's Disintegration by Andi Harriman from Bloomsbury Academic via NetGalley. This book will be published around October 15, 2026.
The Cure's Disintegration by Andi Harriman is part of the 33 1/3 series. It focuses on one album and its place in music history. In this case, Harriman chose to look at Disintegration through the lens of Charles Baudelaire's "Spleen." I hadn't read Baudelaire, but I understand the sentiment. I think of Disintegration like upbeat melancholy if you can have such a thing. You might be sad, but you still want to dance around the room. Fans of The Cure will understand what I mean. I find learning more about the behind-the-scenes of the album gives me an even greater appreciation of the music. If you are a fan, you will want to read this when it comes out. And then listen to Disintegration on repeat.