In this witty and heartwarming fantasy adventure, a thief with a sensitive soul and his romance-obsessed raven sidekick form a series of unlikely alliances as they scheme against the city's power-hungry mages to protect a girl they accidentally rescued.
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC and the opportunity to read Crow & Shadow!
Unfortunately, I had a hard time getting into this one. My biggest issue was the writing, which often felt lacking in subtext and left the story feeling a bit shallow.
As for the characters, I did enjoy Shadow, but I struggled with his dialogue and felt there was little character growth. I love me some witty banter, but it just didn’t quite work for me with Shadow and Crow. There seemed to be a constant need for a clever remark, which ultimately bogged down the plot and made the dialogue feel unnatural.
That said, I can definitely see the appeal! If you enjoy fun, quirky adventures with a talking bird companion, this might be right up your alley. For me, though, I just wish the execution had been stronger, because there’s definitely potential here!
Lotsa thanks to NetGalley and Del Rey for the ARC! 🫶🏻
Crow & Shadow has all the bones of a classic action fantasy, and the main story was pretty good. It just felt a little too familiar for me at times, and I didn’t find much that really made it stand out. The worldbuilding felt fairly light, very much on the YA side.
The writing also was pretty straightforward, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but I did find myself noticing some repetition. Especially “I lost it.” 😭 The MMC is constantly saying “I lost it” or “before I lost it,” and then even Crow gets in on it with “I lost it.” Bro. I get it. Shush now. 🫢😂
I usually LOVE a talking pet, so I really wanted Crow to be a favourite, but unfortunately not for me. The snarky, sarcastic back and forth between Crow and the MMC was funny at first, but after a while it started getting weary.
The pacing was probably my biggest struggle. There’s quite a bit of step by step narration by the MMC travelling, arriving places, and going through conversations, which made the story feel slower than I would’ve liked. I don’t mind detailed writing when the prose is really lush and atmospheric, but here I sometimes found myself thinking, okayyy, can we please get to the point now? 😭
Overall, I think there’s a solid story here, and I can see why it would work for readers who enjoy straightforward action fantasy, lots of banter, and a lighter YA feel. It just didn’t fully click for me, and by the end I was mostly reading to see how everything would end.
I love a good fantasy adventure, and I think this is a solid start of a new series! I love both Shadow (Silas) and Crow (who is actually a raven), and how the story develops from him contracting to steal a crown and ending up rescuing and then protecting a young woman who had been caged by the Grey Wizard.
The banter between Shadow & Crow is great, and I really liked that the story didn't handwave away Shadow's deep trauma of being enslaved in the mines and losing his entire family. He struggles to trust, he blacks out, he makes too-impulsive decisions when he feels like someone is being unjustly imprisoned or targeted. He deals with his nightmares by reading to Crow from their favorite books. I also really appreciated that his love interest wasn't the girl (Willow) he rescued - it was a women he already knew (Orya), who was strong and smart and competent in her own right.
I thought the world was interesting, but I also think we're necessarily limited by having everything solely be from Shadow's point of view. He's telling the present day story, while tossing in pieces of his own history and information about the world at the reader, and while it mostly works, I think sometimes we could have used a bit more. A lot happens in a really short period of time!
Overall, a good start in a new fantasy adventure series, and I'm looking forward to seeing what happens to our crew in future books!
A bit slower of a story than I am used to, the details fill in as you go. I would almost call this an unreliable narrator, not because Shadow tells you only his side, but because he's reluctant to tell any part of his side because it means even the reader gets closer to him. And Shadow is very clear on one thing from the beginning: no one gets close to him. Very fun narrative tool if you ask me. It follows a pretty simple hero's journey, with the foil of his current struggles being the past he is trying to hide from himself and others. Sometimes the simplicity of a plot allows us to explore the themes more vividly. I think the main theme of this book is that men in power want us to work alone, its much harder to win when you are alone.
I really loved this book. I think i want to re-listen to this book when it comes out i loved the first half of this book and felt that last half also gave me d&d vibes, I think i really want to listen to the last half. I loved the first half and was loving the slower start and the character moments. This book was unepected suprise!!
Thank you to NetGalley and Del Rey for the advance copy!
This book follows Shadow, a man living in secret after escaping slavery and working as a treasure hunter, and his bonded raven named Crow. They are familiar with taking on dangerous situations in the name of fulfilling a contract but are quickly faced with dilemmas far more perilous than they're used to, each seemingly more impossible than the next.
There were many things I really enjoyed about this book, particularly the cast of quirky characters and their relationships. I loved that Shadow was a man in touch with his emotions and the love that he and Crow shared for story telling and romance, which I thought was a great plot line throughout the book. The deep set morals that many of the people in this fantasy world are bound by was another interesting aspect which most of the time was embedded well amongst the fighting and violence. I found the different species really creative, especially the shape shifters who could take the form of an animal and the underground people who are literally hive minded. Despite a slower start, I thought the plot picked up the pace and packed in a great deal of action by the halfway point, throwing back to back obstacles in the way for the characters to navigate.
However, a few things about this book were lacking for me. From the start, I found a lot of the dialogue, especially the inner thoughts between Shadow and Crow, a little immature and basic. I also felt there could have been far more world building descriptors as I really couldn't picture much of the scenery or get a feel for what the city that most of the book took place in was like. This was the biggest drawback for me as I really liked the basis of the society, the plot points, and the powers each group of people were gifted with but there wasn't enough to get a really detailed picture of it all. Finally, I felt that the author leaned heavily on repeated tropes to get the characters out of certain situations, especially the solid morals I mentioned earlier, in the form of contracts and agreements that the characters rely on solely through trust. While I thought the overall plot was well thought out and there were lots of relevant but diverting side quests along the way, this aspect of introducing a literally impossible situation and then having basically just luck guide the characters out of it started to fall flat.
I really wanted to enjoy this one. It started promisingly, with an interesting premise and the makings of a fun fantasy adventure. Unfortunately, the further I got into it, the more I felt like I was waiting for the story to actually go somewhere.
There’s nothing inherently wrong with familiar fantasy tropes, but I need an author to do something interesting with them. The jumping between bodies is an interesting concept as well. But, here, the worldbuilding felt relatively shallow, the characters never quite grabbed me, and the story didn’t offer much to distinguish itself from countless other fantasy adventures.
My biggest issue was the pacing. There was a lot of traveling, talking, and moving from one situation to the next without enough meaningful development to make those stretches worthwhile. I don’t mind a slow burn, but I need something to be burning. Character growth, political intrigue, escalating stakes, something. Instead, I kept waiting for the narrative to find another gear.
And then there’s Crow, who is actually a raven. Which I suppose is meant to be funny.
I usually love a sarcastic animal companion. Unfortunately, the banter between the bird and the protagonist wore thin fairly quickly. What started as an entertaining dynamic eventually became repetitive rather than charming. There’s only so much snark that can substitute for actual character development.
Ultimately, this wasn’t a terrible book as evidenced by the rating. There is still a decent adventure here, and I can see it appealing to readers who enjoy lighter, more straightforward fantasy with plenty of banter. But for me, the characters lacked depth, the world never felt particularly immersive, and the pacing made an otherwise promising premise feel considerably longer than it needed to.
By the end, I wasn’t reading because I was invested. I was reading because I’d already come this far and wanted to see how it finished.
Thank you to NetGalley and Del Rey for providing an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you NetGalley, Del Ray, Random House Worlds and Inklore for the digital ARC
Crow and Shadow is a fun tale about a brute and his bird companion on a quest to save a damsel in distress from a wizard syndicate.
This story has a good foundation to be an epic fantastical tale but it fell short in a few areas for me. There are a few moments in the book where Shadow talks directly to the reader, which made this feel like a campfire story. Fun in theory, however it pulled me out of the narrative each time and made him feel a bit like an unreliable narrator (“look how cool I am, I defeated the big bad single handedly and the fish I caught was THIIIIIISS BIIG”)but he does confess to being a liar so maybe this is on purpose. I did love the connections that were made between the story that we were being told and the stories Shadow read to Crow but because of the POV made this feel more like a tall tale.
There were also a few times where the world lore was repeated when discussing things like the honour/beliefs of certain groups of people or how the metals are involved in the world’s magic system, and yet sometimes the lore felt very surface level (“this place is scary and dangerous” but doesn’t really explain why). Minor characters felt a bit more like plot devices than people but maybe that is a symptom of the POV.
Overall I think this book could have benefitted from being a little more fast paced with a couple less chapters, or a few chapters longer with some more in-depth character and world building. I would love to have read Shadow and Crow’s origin story, following their meeting and journey through the mines (still Shadow’s point of view but maybe present tense instead of past).
Crow & Shadow by Hemant Nayak is a fun, fast-paced adventure that blends imaginative worldbuilding with witty, irreverent humor.
The absolute highlight of this book is the dynamic between Silas (Shadow) and his feathered companion, Crow. Crow is easily one of the most memorable sidekicks I’ve read in fantasy recently—a sassy, romance-novel-obsessed corvid who completely steals every scene he's in. The banter between Silas and Crow keeps the tone lighthearted even when the stakes get high. Nayak’s worldbuilding is rich and layered, cleverly weaving underlying themes of colonialism into a high-stakes techno-fantasy quest.
Where the book stumbled a bit for me was in the pacing and plot structure. While the action kicks off quickly, certain mid-book sequences felt slightly episodic, slowing down the overall momentum. A few of the secondary characters and subplots also felt like they could have used a bit more room to breathe and develop fully.
That said, if you enjoy cheeky banter, unique fantasy worlds, and a genuinely delightful duo navigating desperate schemes, this is a very enjoyable read!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advanced reader copy (ARC) in exchange for an honest review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Silas Tuck is a fine tracker, a miserably poor thief, and the most unsteady narrator I’ve enjoyed in a long time. His punchy, patchy telling felt exactly like a man haunted by his years in the mines, someone who knows he can black out into rage and still clings to a moral code that kept him light in a dark life. Crow, his snarky raven, makes every tense moment funnier, even when the banter runs a little long. When the Syndicate wizards burned his house and Crow’s beloved romance books, I couldn’t wait to see how annoyed that raven could get. The pace barely lets up as they run from the city protecting the girl everyone wants dead. The world feels thin in places and I wanted more depth, but I’m already curious where book two takes them.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC.
I received an advanced copy of this book and tore through it in one weekend. I'm a sucker for a lone wolf and cub story, but when the lone wolf has a talking raven companion...chef's kiss!
Crow and Shadow is a delightful romp through a world filled with dangerous magic, unexpected shapeshifting, and heroic quests, peppered with witty repartee and driven by the fierce desire for justice. It's an engrossing read that left me wanting more!
I really thought I would like this book. There was something off about the writing. It didn't flow well for me to stay engaged in the story. The story was jumping around. I was lost about what was going on even at 10%. I read some high fantasy books, so I know that it's not the complexity.
Thank you to NetGalley, Hemant Nayak, and Del Rey for the e-arc in exchange for an honest review.
thanks to NetGalley and Del Rey for the ARC! 🫶🏻 Honestly, I found it too "classic," I thought the writing style was too "childish" and also too "modern." It annoys me when I don't like a bow that I asked for, then I feel really bad because I feel like I'm not entitled to ask for another one.
I had high hopes for this book, but ultimately it didn't work for me and I DNF'd at 45%. Overall tone seemed oddly juvenile, world building was lackluster, and I couldn't stop picturing the main character as Wreck-It Ralph.
Not a terrible story, I felt like it couldn’t decide if it wanted to be funny or serious at points. The banter between the main two characters was fun, but I felt like some of the magic system was jus reloaded over. I’ll read the next one to see if it improves.