Everyone loves Poppy. She’s pure sunshine vibes with an infectious snort-laugh, and nobody is immune to her outrageous flirting. Nobody, that is, apart from her much older brother’s best friend, former Scottish rugby star and grumpy fun sponge, Rory Wallace.
The last thing Rory wants is a woman who represents everything he avoids: cameras, chaos and constant attention. The irony is that although Lady Poppy Sterling flirts with the world, the man she’s had a crush on since childhood can’t stand her. At least that’s what he tells himself…
It’s only when Rory's betrayal leaves Poppy vulnerable to both paparazzi and predators that he realises too late what he stands to lose. Her celebrity lifestyle might be his dealbreaker, but his failure to protect her? That's hers.
DEAL BREAKER is an enemies-to-lovers, brother’s best friend, age-gap, grumpy/sunshine contemporary romance featuring family secrets, red carpet drama, and a grumpy hero who'll move heaven and earth to protect his sunshine girl—once he realises she's been his all along.
Content warning: discussions of drink spiking and predatory behaviour.
Susie is a USA Today and #1 Amazon bestselling author who writes addictive, feel-good contemporary romance with heroes who may make you a little ragey, but who always redeem themselves in the end! She’s been a doctor in the NHS for over twenty years and lives in beautiful Dorset with her wonderful husband, three gorgeous boys and an even more wonderful dog.
Admittedly, reading Law Maker (the first book in this series) was a very nice surprise, and it was only inevitable that I would immediately read Deal Breaker. Suffice it to say, I was not disappointed.
This time around involves Rafe’s sister Poppy, who has a contentious history with his best friend, rugby player Rory. She’s light personified, effervescent in her charm and likability, and her status of not only being of noble blood but a popular social media influencer, makes her the best person to help Rory and his charity goals. He doesn’t want her help but unfortunately, desperately needs it for his cause.
When these two are forced to work together, past hurts and misunderstandings come to the fore as well as their still amorous feelings.
So yes, beware 5 years of separation, minimal communication, and plenty of wrong assumptions - things that would normally frustrate many a reader. Rory too, just like Rafe, is kinda an asshole, and he puts his foot in it over and over again. Thankfully, he’s also a man absolutely obsessed with Poppy, and once he gets another taste, he won’t make the mistake of letting her go again.
Obviously for me, there’s just something about Tate’s writing that makes her books unputdownable, and just like the first book, I read this in a short two days. Her MMC’s are imperfect and often infuriating, but they are also top tier dominant and protective. It doesn’t hurt that Rory does some much needed groveling when he finally realizes he’s in the wrong, making up for his ignorant thoughts/behavior in swoony ways.
Overall, amidst some cheeky fun and spice, this layers in several serious topics to up the dramatic and emotional impact to this love story. I impatiently look forward to the next installment as March can’t come soon enough!
Thank you to the author and GP Putnam’s Sons via NetGalley for a copy to review honestly
Poppy Sterling is one of those people that everyone seems to love. She's outgoing, flirty, funny and generally just a bit of sunshine. Everyone loves her, apart from Rory Wallace, apparently.
Rory is a former Scottish rugby player, Poppy's much older brother's best friend and the man she's had a crush on for pretty much her entire life. Unfortunately, Rory isn't particularly fond of the attention that comes with Poppy's lifestyle, and he makes that pretty clear. However, when his own actions leave Poppy vulnerable to the paparazzi and some rather unpleasant people, he starts to realise that he might have made a massive mistake.
So, after reading *Law Maker*, I was really excited to read Poppy and Rory's story. You could sense throughout that book that there was going to be more to their tale than met the eye. However, this was one of those times where the reality didn't quite meet expectations.
I usually love Susie Tate. Her writing style, characters and the relationships and stories she creates always hit for me, so I was quite disappointed that this one didn't.
Poppy is basically a fictional Amelia Dimoldenberg, and I loved that. I genuinely couldn't pick a thing wrong with her, except perhaps her taste in men.
On the surface, I loved the sound of Rory. A grumpy former rugby player? Absolutely. A grumpy athlete is a definite yes for me in an MMC. The thing is... he was horrible.
He reminded me of the dickhead ex that all FMCs seem to have. You know, the one who puts her down, belittles her and basically dims her shine. Except in this case, he's supposed to be the man we're rooting for. And the problem is that he stayed that way for MOST of the book.
Yes, we had the grovelling, the realisation that he'd made mistakes and all the usual stuff, but by that point, I was just thinking that Poppy should have thrown the whole man away.
I also can't overlook the fact that there's a ten-year age gap. OK, not too bad in the grand scheme of romance books, and ordinarily I wouldn't have an issue with it. However, the fact that Rory started seeing Poppy as someone he wanted sexually and romantically when she was 17 and he was 27 is just gross to me.
Which also brings me to the fact that Poppy is 27 during the story. Rory, mate, that makes you 37. Can you please grow up?
Don't get me wrong, I'll read Susie Tate again and again because I generally love her books, but this one was a flop for me. I'd love to sugarcoat it, but I think my overall takeaway from this book is pretty simple.
Poppy deserved better.
Tropes: - Enemies to lovers - Brother's best friend - Age gap
*Age gap *Brother's best friend *Enemies to lovers *Grumpy/sunshine *Sports *Grovel *Second chance
Once again Susie Tate made her little miracle and gave us this amazing story. Of course it was added in my all time favourite books that I re-read so often. I loved Poppy and her endless positivity though she wanted some shaking in order to get over her insecurities. And Rory...he might have been a pain in the butt and in general a butt towards Poppy, he redeemed himself. Let's be honest, he was unnecessarily cruel and mean towards Poppy that even his hurtful past didn't excuse his attitude. Thank God for those fictional toxic boyfriends that they can redeem themselves so we can love them even more.
To phrase this metaphorically, We all think we love and appreciate the sun - but only when it’s shining on our terms, isn’t it? Once it gets too hot, too bright, doesn’t set fast enough, we forget how much we owe the sun, or how much it burns itself to keep us warm, don’t we?
Well, considering that, Rory and the Sterlings weren’t careless or mean, they were just ignorant, as we all sometimes are.
This book brought the spring to my soul ❤️
Poppy, the little sunshine heroine was the breath of light and fresh air I didn’t even knew I needed. Her empaty, optimism, kindness and care for everyone around her really undid me. It was so heart wrenching to watch her set herself on fire to keep everyone else happy and at ease. And even more so, to witness her being rebuffed and belittled time and time again for her care.
I truly believe Rory’s intentions, that her family dotted on her, but this was a perfect example of how loving someone, but not loving them right, might have devastating consequences. One can only speak up if they feel heard and taken seriously.
Rory really pulled a 180 in this book and maned up through the chapters. His grumpy with-a-feet-in-his-mouth personality really brought a lot of drama and fun to the story. As bad as I felt for Poppy sometimes, I could totally relate why she was into him, cause boooy so am I 😆❤️
I inhaled the whole story in one go, like literally, I couldn’t even leave my kindle behind to get myself some cake, so obsessed I was.
The plot, the twists, the gut punches, everything was perfect. I wouldn’t change a thing. This was absolutely marvelous.
This book is covering a very serious disease, but is much lighter and bubblier than the last one. If you are a fan of a grumpy sunshine romance with good grovel, growth and depth and a few gut punches, you’re gonna love this ❤️ I certainly did.
Thanks to the universe that this book is already written and Susie for trusting me to be part of her arc team.
Did I went over myself and posted my first review here based solely on the short preview in Law Maker, before actually reading the book? Yes I did!
Was I wrong? - Hell no! 🔥❤️
—————-————————
“I think it was ‘mad prostitute with a penchant for glitter’.”
Sooooo excited for this!! Just finished Law Maker today and the first two chapters of this masterpiece and I am definitely hooked! Soo sad that it first comes in November 😔
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC.
This is one of those books that makes me irrationally angry. Why would you give me a sweet pixie happy FMC and pair her with a man that treats her like that?
This man still thinks the worst of her, doubts her and never questioned the words of a random mean spirited man over his knowledge of her character. Let’s hope that my men believed me and not one of his bros…oh wait they weren’t even friends, so he believed a RANDOM MAN HE DISLIKED!
I could have believed his grovel if he didn’t still doubt her at every turn. And why wouldn’t he mention his reasoning for ghosting her? He had so many chances, but after being with her again, he still somehow believed she’d betrayed him five years ago. He never once considered the guy had lied. Rory was a fucking dumbass, an asshole and he didn’t redeem himself at all; he just knew how to fuck and he wasn’t even charming.
Before anyone says “he was insecure and that’s why he did what he did”…he still had a relationship with her brother, never once questioned why Rafe would be his friend so that’s not reasoning enough for me.
Oh and why are we not thinking of safe sex at the big 2026? I understand it’s a book so “suspend rational belief” but fingering someone and fucking someone while covered in mud is not hot. All I could think was how poor Poppy would get a mammoth of a UTI.
Her family was also a disgrace. They put her and her accomplishments down, made her out to being flaky and a dummy. Her brother believed she was a drunk and barely knew she never drank, putting her life at risk…just why? There are enough shitty people in real life, why write a romance book where everyone is shitty towards the FMC? Poppy couldn’t catch a break.
I have more things to say but I’ll leave it right here.
A little sunshine, a lot of stubbornness and one very overdue apology made this romance such an interesting read.
Poppy was such a sweetheart, and I really liked how much of herself she put into helping others. She was always looking out for everyone, bringing a bit of happiness wherever she went, even when she wasn't feeling particularly great herself. I did feel for her, especially when the people closest to her constantly underestimated her. There was so much more to her than they gave her credit for!
Rory certainly tested my patience with his stubbornness and his talent for saying the wrong thing at exactly the wrong time. Thankfully, he had some serious grovelling to do, and I was quite happy to watch him work for it! Their history, all those unresolved feelings and the chemistry between them made their relationship really enjoyable to follow. I also liked seeing Rory work through his own insecurities and finally realise that Poppy deserved someone who would actually listen to her and appreciate her for who she was.
I also appreciated the MND storyline and how much care went into portraying such a difficult condition. It added some genuinely emotional moments without taking away from the humour and romance. Between the entertaining family dynamics, the banter and all the swoony moments, I flew through this one.
I thoroughly enjoyed spending time with these characters and getting another glimpse into this wonderful series.
~~~~
ALC Review (Audiobook) 🎧
Shane East and Zara Hampton Brown were such a good pairing for this audiobook! I really enjoyed listening to them bring the characters to life, particularly the contrast between Rory's gruff personality and Poppy's much brighter, bubbly nature. Their delivery made the banter fun to listen to, and I thought they did a lovely job with the more romantic moments too. The emotional scenes were another highlight, especially the way they handled the heavier moments without making them feel overdone. I also found the narration easy to settle into, and both voices suited their characters so well. It was one of those audiobooks where I was happy to keep listening just to spend a little more time with the characters. A really enjoyable experience from both narrators!
~~~~
I was so excited to experience this one in both formats. Having the ARC and ALC meant I could fully sink into the story, and honestly, it made the experience that much better.
~~~~
A sincere thank you to Susie Tate and Good Girls PR for the ARC! 🥰📚
I’m so grateful for the early read. As always, all thoughts and opinions are completely my own. ✨
This was an absolute 5⭐️ read that almost matched my love for Law Maker! Still so thrilled I scored an ARC for this one. While Rafe and Clara still hold a special place in my heart, Poppy and Rory came remarkably close with a top-tier grumpy x sunshine, age-gap dynamic. Rory definitely starts off as an egocentric, prideful, and ignorant **** in a sea of equally ****ish (please insert chosen expletive at the *) men, but his character development and shift in dynamics as he eventually shows up for Poppy was so satisfying. Poppy might start off quiet, but she doesn't half pack a punch and knows her worth, endlessly trying to support others and bring happiness wherever she can. What truly elevated this book, though, was the portrayal of ALS and chronic illness—it was written from such an insightful, thoughtful angle, showing how impairments can be accommodated and how people navigate difficult, deteriorating diagnoses while still trying their absolute best despite feeling betrayed by their own bodies. Emotional, empowering, and executed brilliantly!
Susie Tate has destroyed me multiple times and rebuilt me after. A lot of her books have great groveling and/or character arcs, which is the only way I ever except dumbass decisions by MMCs, and her FMCs are routinely looked down upon or dismissed, before they're shown to be their truly stunning selves. I'm clearly a big fan of her work, and yet i wasn't aware she released a book in 2026 or had another one coming.
This story starts with the tried and true Tate miscommunication-preconceived notions problem. Rory seems to have forgetten everything he knew about Poppy, and decides to just believe the gossip form the media and the persona she portrays online. Poppy has avoided Rory for years because she has no clue why he ghosted her.
The way they speak is a bit off putting. I know it's called the Aristocrats of London, but I did not enjoy the "accent" and vocabulary associated with it. Especially calling her v*gina her "foofoo". That would have been a hard out for me, and I would have DNF'd the book if this wasn't an ARC.
Susie Tate’s FMCs are treated unfairly and looked down upon, at least the ones I've read from her are, until others inevitably realise who the FMC actually is. Poppy is no different; while her family knows she runs the foundation, takes care of the grandma and has a thriving career, they still see her as a teenager: Clumsy, dumb, struggling with dyslexia, prone to drinking and flights of fancy. Her family loves her, but not in the way she needs and they don't /see/ her. Which is incredibly relatable. For whatever reason, Poppy is very prone to “retching” and I’ve never read a book that had so much bile and throwing up as reactions in it. Everything involves retching for some reason. It was weird and I saw no point in it.
Rory, Rory, Rory. Such a mess and not an MMC im a fan of TBH. Who he was as a teen seemed very sweet, and I totally understood why Poppy fell for him then. However, it was all downhill from there. He was a dick for so long which made it difficult to really engage with. He believes all the media BS, despite knowing how wrong they can be, and then realises he was wrong. And that was cute and fun. But the level of which he was rude to her, even at the start before we knew anything put me off of him and I didn't understand why Poppy wanted him back. Then I'd learn about their past and he'd make a small apology, and I'd warm up to him slightly, just for him to fuck up again. Rory let his insecurities get the better of him repeatedly and suffers from a horrible case of saying things that hit right where it hurts the most when he's upset. And that happens all the time.
I do not understand why Poppy kept going back to adult Rory. Her abysmal sense of self and people pleasing ways, doesn’t explain why she keeps going for him when he’s this bad! He does not support her, he got violent and he calls her names he knows will hurt her! He has no introspection or emotional control. It’s really just hard to see the appeal for a big chunk of this story. He does change though, eventually, sort of, but it doesn't feel healthy after everything.
His apologies came but only ever seemed to be for that one moment, not the history of ghosting and poor behaviour, which made each apology somehow annoy me even more. All of this until their big final confrontation. His final grovelling showed how much he cared and knew about Poppy, setting him apart from her family too, while also putting him outside his normal comfort zone and showing how he was willing to change. But I still think it needed to be longer than two weeks and with a heaping buttload of therapy for him.
Overall, I think Rory was written simply too cruel. The fights could have the same effect but with different words, toned down a little, to not continuously present him this horribly. He is, to me, unintentionally emotionally abusive and he even threw a phone near her. While he is partially redeemed elsewhere, his behaviour when angry or hurt is never addressed, never developed, and is still a weird background danger. But I do understand what I might consider a deal breaker here is personal and other might be totally comfortable reading about MMCs like that.
There are many things that made me frustrated and wanting to stop reading or throw my phone (it’s okay when I do it because nobody is around!) and yet I still needed to see what happened and did enjoy the book at times. Most of that is a pretty typical Susie Tate reading experience for me and I keep coming back for more, but I usually feel a little more positive about it all, than I do this time.
Thank-you NetGalley and X. All opinionsnare my own.
I wanted to love this but unfortunately Rory never quite left his teenage years behind and even though he's pushing 40 he's still whinging like a 15 year old. He got on my wick.
"Poppy decided she was too good for a red-flag asshole like Rory. So, she dumped his ass, chose herself and lived happily ever after."
There. I fixed the ending of this disaster of a book that has the audacity to parade a relationship between a toxic man like Rory and a beautiful, kind soul like Poppy as some sort of grand romance.
Please.
The book starts with Rory absolutely hating Poppy. He makes disparaging comments about her to practically anyone who will listen, including insulting her reading disability by calling her dumb, despite knowing the truth. He dismisses her job as a joke, reduces her to a rich party girl with a ridiculous career, and calls her an attention seeker, sometimes even implying she's an actual attention whore because, as a talk-show host, she mildly flirts with celebrities.
And why does he behave this way? Well, obviously, because he can't have her, so he has to be an asshole about it.
Rory believes he's too good for Poppy (the only thing I agree with him on), because he's supposedly "ugly" and comes from a "lower class". In his mind, someone like Poppy could never genuinely want him and must have been using him to get an interview five years ago. A misunderstanding that could have been resolved with a simple conversation and, perhaps, a rewatch of that interview. Instead, he finally gets around to doing that five years later, after they've already rekindled their relationship and Poppy has given him a second chance he absolutely did not deserve.
And that's not even the worst of it. He actually believes some creep over the woman he supposedly loves when the creep claims Poppy cheated on him with him. All because poor little Rory is insecure about his looks and wealth and was bullied as a child. I understand having insecurities, but at what point does that become an excuse to repeatedly hurt someone who has done nothing but love you?
Now, after completely breaking Poppy's heart five years ago and using her as a punching bag ever since, he gets another chance. Apparently, he "couldn't breathe without her" and couldn't stay away from her anymore. How he managed to do both for all those years is anyone's guess.
Does he use this opportunity to redeem himself? No, no, he does not.
He continues to act like a possessive asshole. He's toxic, doesn't trust her, leaves her alone when she needs him, and constantly makes her feel like being with her is just too much because *she* is too much. And then, one day, he explodes and says all of it to her face, even going so far as to criticise the way she laughs, calling it attention-seeking.
And that genuinely broke my heart. He stole her joy.
Poppy is a woman who puts everyone ahead of herself. She lives a largely selfless life and goes out of her way to spread happiness wherever she goes. Yet, somewhere along the way, she starts dimming her own light to make room for Rory's insecurities. And what does he offer in return? A couple of meaningless gestures, like defending her when her own family makes fun of her and bringing her things when she's on her period. As if those little acts are supposed to make everything else okay?
I was genuinely proud of Poppy whenever she pushed Rory away and demanded better for herself. She deserved so much more than the scraps of affection and occasional apologies he offered her.
And that's another thing that drove me up the wall. Rory has a habit of behaving like a toxic ass, blurting out the most hateful things he can think of, and then, once he's calmed down, calling himself a bastard and apologising. Rinse and repeat. I don't see a man like that changing simply because he feels bad after the damage is done.
It's a travesty that Poppy forgives him in the end. He doesn't deserve it.
Poppy deserved someone who basked in her joy from the very beginning. Someone who loved her laugh, celebrated her personality and never made her feel like she needed to be less of herself to be loved. Not someone who spent so much time destroying that joy, only to realise what he'd lost after months of watching her suppress herself to keep him happy.
Poppy deserved better. And honestly, so did this ending.
DNF 23% I'd not made it a quarter of the way through the book and they had already flip flopped back and forth between hating and wanting each other twice for reasons that are so incredibly juvenile, it's hard to believe they're in their 20's and 30's and a PAINFUL miscommunication that barely even qualifies as a miscommunication since it's more like the MMC loses his mind for 5 years and just get it back out of nowhere after 5 years.
He'd literally known her since she was 8 years old, was 10 years older, was best friends with her older brother and their entire family! To think for even a second that she was somehow this manipulative femme fatale when he's known her most of her life is ridiculous, but to refuse to have even a basic conversation with her and hold a massive grudge against her for 5 years because of one conversation and one embarrassing interview is beyond the pale. If he believes the first bit of bad gossip he heard about her in 8 years of knowing her and seeing her grow up without even having a direct conversation with her, he would always be swayed by any bad thing that comes along.
My other gripe that some others might like but grinds my gears is that fact when they first almost started a relationship 5 years ago, she was a virgin and he was so enamored by that. She even promised him she'd wait for him. Then she's no longer a virgin 5 years later when they actually get together. 🙄 Listen, I know I'm one of the last hold-outs of an old age that enjoys reading about virgin heroines and people get violently angry if a girl is a virgin these days and I can respect that preference. However, why even mention her virginity at ALL or act like it's some prize only to yank it away? Just don't mention the virgin thing at all then! I'm fine with that! But to tease it and then say "nevermind, she didn't wait!' adds all kinds of baggage that is completely unnecessary and unfair to the heroine and the overall story.
Overall, it just was a lot of cliche drama fluff and no real substance, much like Rory accuses Poppy of near the beginning.
Thank you to NetGalley and Susie Tate for the ARC of Deal Breaker in the Aristocrats of London series.
After the first book, I was genuinely excited for Rory and Poppy’s story. Their little glimpse at the end left me wanting more, especially after such a fantastic first installment. Unfortunately, this one didn't quite deliver.
My biggest struggle was with the characterization and the overall story. The characters felt more like actors playing roles in a television drama than fully developed people. I could see who they were supposed to be, but I struggled to feel the depth behind them. The plot itself also left me wanting more. Whether it lacked the depth I needed or simply didn't connect with me, something just never quite clicked. And the MMC calling the FMC "wee lass" at times meant to be spicy...? Let's just say it was not doing it for me.
I did appreciate the attention brought to ALS (MND in the book) and the opportunity to shine a light on something so important.
I'll still be picking up the next book because I'm invested in this series, but this installment felt like a step backward. Not a deal breaker for the series, but definitely not my favorite.
3 🌟🌟🌟 2 🌶🌶
Enemies to Lovers | Sports Romance | Class Gap | Grumpy x Sunshine | Brother's Best Friend | Age Gap
dude lol I need to switch genres or just stop reading this author because the last two books have been so bad. I read these books because I love a good grovel story…but 75% of the way in and it’s just repetitive bullshit. The mmc is an asshole who repeatedly assumes the worst of the fmc and keeps fucking up and it’s like, you’re sorry only to do it again. He loves having sex with her but still his inner monologue is the most negative shit about her and stuff he assumes is true about her even though there’s no proof of what he’s been told. He just believes everybody else over this girl that he has known basically his entire life. Then the “big” conflict happens and after nearly 80% of the book of him being an asshole…? once again so repetitive because he has done it so many fucking times..and you’re going to resolve it in the next 30 to 50 pages? No
So cringe and her family sucked too because she gets drugged randomly at like 85% and of course her brother assumes that she’s just drunk. “Oh I thought she changed too but it’s typical for her!!!” and then a quick apology later and she’s like, oh, it’s all good!!! So stupid.
Rory (mmc) was just a insecure loser. 🗑 He needed to grow the fuck up. Which I believe explains why I've rated this book so low. And even this is generous. 🙄
Not for me. This one just felt very juvenile, from the constant silly name calling to the over emphasis on size and age difference. It was just over done. For example small appears 125 times and tiny 78 times. Just gives the whole impression of teenagers instead of adults.
Poppy is portrayed as a small tiny glittering fluff ball; her friend even nicknamed her Powerpuff 😒
While the Rory is referred to as a big grumpy git, even by himself and uses the same line that he can’t be with Poppy because her brother will not be happy.
That said, the MC’s met when Poppy was 8 and Rory 18. He’s a family friend who was at their house regularly. While he never looked at her in any inappropriate way until she was 17; he would have been 27. That is quite uncomfortable. It was another 3 years before a kiss but even then 20 & 30 is a big age gap when she’s so young.
Outside of above issues, Rory was consistently tearing Poppy down and berating her. While we could see as readers that it came from concern, obviously Poppy couldn’t. And yet she just kept accepting his behaviour. It felt toxic especially with him being older.
I like the idea of this book. Grumpy x sunshine is such a great trope, as is brother's best friend, and sports romances are always so much fun - I've never read a rugby romance before! But I can't get behind a main character with such glaringly unhinged red flags, where they start to dip into emotional abuse territory. This "relationship" is not healthy. Rory berates Poppy and tears her down, only to beg and plead for forgiveness, love bomb, and just doing and saying whatever he needs to for Poppy to forgive him. AND SHE DOES?! Time and time again she forgives him. I don't get it. She is confident and strong and smart, but her brain goes out the window the second Rory enters the picture, and I hate that for her. She deserves so much better than him. I liked the storyline with Connor, with everyone coming together to raise money, and found that the friend group was a charming bunch. Overall though, I can't say I enjoyed the romance. Thanks Netgalley for the e-ARC!
So far I’m not enjoying this series. I’ve read enough Susie Tate books to know the style, FMC is usally either put down or misunderstood by the MMC and others and in the end he ends up grovelling to win her affection. This is the same, brother’s best friend, big grumpy Scottish Rugby player. He’s known her for years and loved her as many… so if this is the case how can he get her personality completely wrong and actually know nothing about her?? He was falling in love but he thought she was a cheater and a liar, and didn’t like her life style in public eye? So what did he love about her exactly? This was just too unbelievable. He had at least 3 ppl telling him to accept all of her or leave her be, and then he continued to berated her saying it was the poppy show ect but still wanted to be with her.
He Constantly hurt her said sorry but doesn’t change anything! Walking red flag of emotional abuse and love bombing, I didn’t not like this MMC at all.
I did like the FMC and think after the last time he put her down she should have walked away. She deserved so much more in a MMC and also from her family, they were always putting her down too. Rafe being her brother, should have kicked his ass for being so mean to her. Another issue I have is he had sexual feelings for her when she was 17 and he was 28! I can’t get on board with that, I don’t mind age gap but she’s far too young. Also he said she was 20 when he left for the World Cup so he must have been 30/31 and that’s when he ghosted her…. Like come on grown up, just ask her did u have a relationship with another guy! Also her brother saying she did, but clearly never asked any questions on her relationship in 5yrs is ridiculous he just assumed they were together but never asked how it was going?? It’s all so stupid it made me angry reading it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Ok I NEED to go back and read book 1 now! This was such a cute read! The ALC was amazing and put me more in their world with their unique accents and how they say different things.
Always a sucker for brothers best friend but add age gap to that and I am all in! Poppy Sterling was the cutest sweet bit of sunshine. She leads a celebrity lifestyle which leads to red carpet drama. Rory is a grumpy brooding giant rugby player who hates the spotlight. Poppy has loved him since childhood but he always pushed her away for fear he wouldn’t be enough for her.
The way this man finally gives into how he feels and wants to protect his little ray of sunshine was so sweet and pulled at my heart strings. They were THE cutest example of opposites attract! I can’t wait for the next book in the series. My first London high society read and will not be my last!
Lady Poppy Sterling is the sister of a Duke and she is such a delight. She’s not academic, but she’s sunshiney and so very big hearted. She’ll stay in the limelight to further her charitable interests, and make fun of herself for a good cause. The trouble is that her family believe her façade and don’t look deeper for the real Poppy.
Rory Wallace has been around the family since they were kids. He’s a professional rugby player, brutish and hiding a bunch of insecurities about the media and being enough. As a brawly rugby player, he has a lot of hangups about his value compared to his aristocratic friends – and Poppy. He’s always had a thing for Poppy, but he’s buried it nice and deep.
Deal Breaker is breezy and fast paced as Poppy does her thing and Rory plays catch up as he underestimates and undervalues her at every opportunity. Unfortunately for Poppy, who has been crushing on Rory forever, he is pretty thoughtless. He is dismissive of her as a form of self-defence and self-protection and while his grovel is lovely – and protracted – I like the recognition that sometimes men do and say stupid things to the women they love. I’m clapping for this snippet of real behaviour inside a lovely ‘Beauty and the Beast’ coded fairytale.
Deal Breaker has banter that’s frantic and it's full of British-isms and insults. The character growth is mostly on Rory as he needs to work through his issues, and his own self-worth. There’s a villain in plain sight who is threatening Poppy, and this shows Rory how much he has misjudged her, even as it tears them apart.
A sub plot involves a fundraising touch rugby game aiming to set a world record for Motor Neurone Disease research and this works well to draw attention to this incurable and debilitating disease.
A perfect read if you enjoy British romcoms, with a gorgeous and vulnerable heroine, and an excellent grovel. For fans of Catherine Walsh and Kristen Bailey.
Thank you so much Susie Tate for the ARC. Opinions are my own.
Overall, I'd give the story 3.5 stars. The story itself was fine, but ugh, why is Rory such a mess and why does Poppy put up with him? I really enjoyed Poppy's character; she was sweet and authentic and unapologetically herself. Rory on the other hand, was a fine character but a terrible partner. Goodness, I would never put up with the way he talked to Poppy, lashing out because he can't deal with his own feelings? What a toddler.
*Grumpy/Sunshine *Second chance *Brother's best friend/Best friend's sister *Age gap *Rugby player/Celebrity
Format: ebook
Thank you NetGalley, Susie Tate, and Putnam for the ARC!
Thank you to Susie and NetGalley for this arc. This is my honest review.
What a story! I was feeling all the things.
Lady Poppy Sterling has been in love with Rory Wallace (former Scottish professional rugby player) for years. Him being her brother’s friend, they have spent a lot of time together. She attracts a lot of attention, he prefers to be in the background away from people. He can’t stand her, for reasons revealed in the book, but also can’t stay away. Will he realize too late she’s worth the risk, or lose her?
Susie Tate is notorious for a groveling mmc and boy does Rory need to grovel. We love to see it. He does a number on Poppy’s heart and honestly doesn’t deserve her. However, he’s willing to put in the work and I hope he continues for the rest of his life or I will have some words 😂 He did redeem himself, but so many times I wanted to scream at him to think before speaking and think from all angles. Many times he was very narrow minded. I’m glad he learned his lesson.
Poppy is literally perfect, no notes. She is the kindest, strongest, and most caring woman and everyone should feel so lucky to be in her presence. She has some insecurity and puts herself down because she’s used to others doing it. It breaks my heart. Luckily Rory (eventually) starts putting a stop to that from herself but also other people. He plays the protector role very nicely. These two are really great together, once they truly communicate and are honest with themselves.
I also loved this book because of a subplot surrounding ALS (MND) One of the side characters has it and it becomes a big part of the book. It was very moving to read about and watch the characters throughout stepping up and trying to help. I definitely cried. It was very beautiful and I cried even harder when I learned that Susie Tate’s husband is diagnosed with it. She did the portrayal such justice and I feel like this must be a truly special book for her and her family. It has also become a very special book for me too! Highly recommend!
Tropes: 🗡️ Enemies to Lovers 😏 Brother’s best friend 😮 Age gap ☀️ Grumpy x sunshine 📸 Famous MCs
This was such a good audiobook!! I loved Poppy soooo much! She has such good intentions and stays doing the most! I loved that Rory realized he needed to do some groveling and I absolutely loved them together! If you love grumpy sunshine, some age gap, a protective MMC that’s also a rugby player you need to check this one out!
duet narration by Shane East and Zara Hampton Brown. Produced by East House Productions 💕
Tropes: 📸 Brother’s best friend 📸 Grumpy / sunshine 📸 enemies to lovers 📸 she falls first but he falls harder 📸 hero grovels 📸 secret crush 📸 age gap 📸 protective hero
3.75 ⭐️ While the heaviness of Clara’s storyline kept me from enjoying Law Maker, the first in Susie Tate’s new Aristocrats of London series, I *did* love the character of Lady Poppy Sterling, sister to Lord Rafe Sterling, and was eager to learn her and Rory’s story (Tate’s storylines often overlap with the previous book, so we had already witnessed a pivotal scene from Clara’s point of view, while in this book, it was told from Rory’s). I’m a sucker for groveling, and this book was full of it- mostly because Rory could never seem to grasp the fact that he was the almost always the one at fault. We learn pretty quickly that he and Poppy once dated in secret, only to have him ghost her and subsequently hate her for the next five years, but don’t address the reasons *why* for most of the book- until there’s really no other path for this book to take. I’m not a fan of keeping key plot points under wraps for so long, but Tate loves to employ it in her writing. She also never shies away from abuse, particularly abuse towards women, and attempted SA happens not once, but twice in this book, at the hands of a man who should have faced justice long ago, but didn’t, as Poppy never wanted to cause a stir (not victim-blaming here, just pointing out the very real problem of women putting everyone else’s needs before their own, when they should never have been conditioned to think that way). If I had one grievance with Poppy (who, despite being perilously close to a “Manic Pixie Dream Girl,” blessedly came across as a less-crazy version of Kira from Anything But Easy), it’s that she doesn’t advocate for herself. She will stand up for everyone and every cause around her (such as raising money to help with research for MND, a subject that hit particularly close to home, as I have a family member who has been in a losing battle with ALS for seven years now), but will take hit after hit after hit from the people who supposedly love her the most. Her own family basically treats her like she’s Special Needs, despite her being fully capable in her social and work life for years, all because of her diagnosed-too-late dyslexia and her wild behavior as a teenager- a TEENAGER. Even her own brother, who is fiercely protective of her, thinks the worst of her at a critical moment, believing she would eschew her duties at a fundraiser by getting “shit-faced” and “embarrassing herself,” instead of showing concern that she was doing something so out of character for her (when in fact, she’d been roofied). I felt very protective of Poppy by the end (as I have with Tate’s previous FMCs, Vicky and Millie), and in all honesty, I was battling with myself through most of the book as to whether I really wanted her to take Rory back at all. He’d mess up, then apologize, then mess up even more egregiously, and then apologize and try to show he’d changed, and by the last blowout, after Tate’s predictable miscommunication trope pops up to cause its more predictable third-act breakup, I was ready to wash my hands of Rory Wallace. But in the end, he came through for her in a way that even her own family didn’t (along with facing his demons about the press), so find myself cautiously optimistic about their future. And to be fair, he *did* get her to laugh again- a proper Poppy laugh (IYKYK).
I received an advanced copy through the author via Book Funnel.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I was really excited going into this story from the brief glimpse we got of the dynamic between Poppy and Rory in book 1!
“There’s no colour in my life without you. Everything’s black, white and grey.”
I absolutely adored Poppy, from start to finish. She has so much self doubt and it’s from people constantly thinking the worst of her or undermining her abilities. Inside she’s such a warm and loving person. She uses her platform to help all kinds of charities and causes.
“I’d live my life in the limelight if that’s where she was. Because if I was with Poppy, everything else was just noise.”
I wanted to love Rory, I really did but it seemed like the author went too hard on his constant doubt and negativity towards Poppy. Even when they were dating he still spoke to her like she was garbage. 🥲 His treatment towards Poppy for literally 75% of the book crossed the line into true emotional abuse and manipulation. I don’t feel like he truly ever redeemed himself.
There are sweet moments at the end that I just loved. I wish he didn’t spend so much of the book as a complete jerk. 😕
I will continue to read the series because I love all of the side characters and where the series is going, but I just think Poppy deserved better than who Rory was for most of this book.
Tropes: ☀️ Grumpy x Sunshine 💃🏻 Rugby Player x Aristocratic Socialite 🤭 Brother’s Best Friend 🍷 Age Gap (10 yrs) ❤️🩹 He Takes Care of Her When She’s Sick 🫶🏼 Found Family
I am a HARDCORE Susie Tate fan, and it genuinely pains me to say this, but this MMC truly SUCKED.
Look, I get Susie Tate's formula. She normally writes MMCs who start off acting like complete a**holes, spend most of the book spectacularly messing things up, and eventually have some grand epiphany that makes them realize what absolute idiots they've been.
And you know what? I EAT THAT UP.
But this guy? He wasn't *acting* like an a**hole. **He WAS one.** With absolutely ZERO redeeming qualities.
Why, you ask? Oh, I'm SO glad you asked.
**1. THE "BUTS."**
"I love her, BUT she's so loud."
"I love her, BUT her laugh is obnoxious."
"I love her, BUT she's an attention seeker."
"I love her, BUT she loves the spotlight."
"I love her, BUT she's too bubbly."
"I love her, BUT she dresses ridiculously."
AND THE LIST GOES ON.
DUDE. WHAT EXACTLY DO YOU LOVE ABOUT POPPY?!
Because from where I'm standing, you seem to dislike every single thing that makes her who she is. At this point, just date someone else! Preferably someone who doesn't laugh, talk, dress up, or have a personality.
**2. THE PAPARAZZI INCIDENT.**
OH. MY. GOD.
So they're FINALLY together, and this huge, broody rugby player decides to leave her ALONE in a crowd of paparazzi to "fend for herself" because, apparently, she's used to it?
EXCUSE ME?!
And it's not like he wasn't there! HE WAS RIGHT THERE! They were walking TOGETHER!
This man makes a beeline for his vehicle and LEAVES HER BEHIND.
She then has to fight her way through the crowd, gets hit in the ribs, and falls on her a**.
And when he later SEES THE BRUISES ON HER RIBS, he just accepts her ridiculous explanation that the kids accidentally hit her during practice.
SIR. YOU ARE A PROFESSIONAL ATHLETE. SURELY YOU HAVE ENOUGH FUNCTIONING BRAIN CELLS TO PUT TWO AND TWO TOGETHER.
Which brings me to...
**3. POPPY. OH, MY SWEET CHILD. *SIGH*.**
Girl. You are a LADY.
LITERALLY.
**LADY POPPY STERLING.**
ACT LIKE IT!
You're a beautiful, wealthy, internet-famous socialite, surrounded by celebrities, gorgeous people, and a world full of light, laughter, and opportunities.
GIRL, YOU HAD EVERYTHING GOING FOR YOU!
I understand having insecurities. I understand struggling with self-worth. But ma'am, hire a therapist, book yourself a fabulous vacation, and MOVE ON.
You did NOT need to spend YEARS allowing this giant rugby player to treat you like an inconvenience he occasionally wanted to sleep with.
Have some self-respect, PLEASE. I'm begging you.
**4. THE MISCOMMUNICATION TROPE ON STEROIDS.**
And THIS is where the book completely lost me.
He believes she cheated on him.
Does he confront her? NO.
Does he ask for an explanation? NO.
Does he give the woman he supposedly loves the benefit of the doubt? ABSOLUTELY NOT.
Instead, he believes some RANDOM MAN who claims he slept with her.
No questions. No investigation. No conversation.
Just YEARS of resentment and treating her like garbage over something he couldn't even be bothered to verify.
And POPPY?!
GIRL!
You eventually find out that this man believed every nasty rumor about you, thought the absolute worst of your character, and apparently trusted a random stranger more than the woman he claimed to love...
AND YOU STILL WANT HIM?!
WHY?!
At some point, this stops being a second-chance romance and becomes a case study in why communication and self-respect should be taught in schools.
I LOVE a good second-chance romance. Give me the heartbreak, the angst, the groveling, the emotional devastation, and the redemption.
But the key word here is **REDEMPTION**.
I need to understand WHY this man deserves another chance. I need to see genuine growth. I need him to WORK for it.
And this man? He needed a personality transplant, several years of therapy, and a restraining order from Poppy.
**Final thoughts:**
Susie Tate, I love you. I really, really do. Your British humor, your emotionally messy characters, your ability to make me laugh while simultaneously breaking my heart? Usually, PERFECTION.
But this one?
NAH.
This wasn't a misunderstood, emotionally unavailable hero who needed to learn how to love.
This was a man who didn't even seem to LIKE the woman he supposedly loved.
And no amount of brooding, rugby muscles, or last-minute revelations was going to convince me otherwise.
This author is an auto-buy for me - she always delivers on the feels and the drama. I have had this one on my radar for months! Loved seeing Poppy in the previous book and was excited for her to get her moment.
Tropes include - grumpy - sunshine, opposites attract and brothers best friend.
Poppy is such a ray of sunshine, but she’s also a bit broken on the inside. A people pleaser who just wants to be loved as the hot mess express that she is. I was rooting for her happily ever after the whole time. Rory is a little harder to love, grumpy and quick to lash out. But with a good heart under it all. There was a lot of miscommunication and repetition in their arguments and issues - which made me want to yell at Rory to grow up. But overall, the drama and the grovel was on point.
Poppy has been in love with Rory for years, her brother’s best friend (who is also 10 years older than her). But the brooding rugby star had his chance and broke her heart five years ago. Now he acts like he can’t stand her. But with a charity event for Rory’s friend pulling them together, they quickly realize that neither got over the other. But with Poppy’s life being in the spotlight and Rory wanting nothing to do with that life, could they ever have a real shot at being together, or will the past just repeat into their future.
I really hate to put 3 stars because Susie Tate is one of my favorite authors. Unfortunately I couldn’t get into Rory and Poppy. 😩 I loved Law Maker and was so excited about this but it just did not deliver.
I’m going to try and keep this spoiler-free. As far as storyline goes I loved it. Especially knowing what the author is struggling with right now, due to her husband’s condition. 🥺
At first I enjoyed the grumpy rugby player Rory, and bubbly sunshine Poppy. It sounded like a fun time. As I started to read the book, I realized their relationship was pretty toxic. I mean I could get over the one or two times a miscommunication happens in the relationship but every time that man snapped, he was so cruel to her. Reminded me of an ex than the main character energy.
I know at the end he somewhat groveled but I just felt like it was toxic the entire time they were together. 😬😩
I will still continue to support this author because I truly love her books. However, this one wasn’t my cup of tea.
I’m really excited to read Lily’s book. Hopefully will make a comeback. 😆💖
tropes:
age gap rugby player grumpy/sunshine with a lil bit of enemies, but only from him. lol celebrity status she falls first, he falls harder he grovels (a lot) 😬
📕Book Review📕 This was my first book by Susie Tate and I enjoyed it. I have not yet read a book with a clear accent written into dialogue and I dinnae know if I read it in my head correctly or not but I had a fun time (see what I did there?). Poppy and Rory had a more bumpy road to their HEA, but a satisfying one. The spice was spicing, the groveling and yearning delicious. There was an epic caretaking scene I really enjoyed. I was rooting for these two.
Therapist 👋 Take: Learning more about someone and that they aren’t who you thought they were takes time (and communication, and in this case epic groveling and yearning). From a therapist lens, the journey to the HEA was realistic given the circumstances and I slow clapped several times for how the FMC handled herself, set clear boundaries, advocated for her needs to be met and also radically accepted that to have the life she wanted she would need to navigate some unfortunate, but likely necessary, drama. I enjoyed the up and down, the longing and the emotional intimacy building.
Thank you to Susie Tate ( @susietateauthor ) and Good Girls PR ( @good.girls.pr ) for the eARC and beautiful gifted copy and goodies too 🫶🏻