When disaster strikes, the headlines focus on death tolls, destruction, and chaos. But behind every catastrophe is a deeper story—one of failed leadership, ignored warnings, poor planning, and systems that collapsed long before the first lives were lost.
In After Lessons from the Worst Disasters in History, 1SG Daryl S. Roddy, USA (Ret.) examines some of history's most devastating disasters through the lens of leadership, logistics, crisis management, and human decision making. From ancient fires and deadly plagues to industrial catastrophes and modern emergency failures, Roddy breaks down what happened, why it happened, and what leaders today still refuse to learn.
Drawing from more than 27 years of military service, including combat deployments and years of experience in logistics and emergency management, Roddy delivers a direct and unapologetic analysis of the moments where preparation failed, communication broke down, and ordinary people paid the price.
This is not just a history book. It is an after-action review of humanity at its worst-and the hard lessons we cannot afford to ignore.
"Disasters don't kill systems—systems fail first, and then people die."
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary author's copy of this book in exchange for an honest review
"Walking through the streets, there are markers, memorials, and museums that tell the story of 1900. It's not hidden. It's acknowledged. That matters. Remembering a disaster is part of preventing the next one. When a city chooses to preserve that memory, it's making a statement about learning from the past."
As an emergency management professional, and someone who thrives on learning the lessons that others had to learn the hard way, I was excited to read Daryl S. Roddy's book that explores historical disasters through the lens of an after-action review. I thoroughly enjoyed my read-through of this book, and it will join the list of books that I recommend to those entering emergency management. Roddy's accessible style of writing and narration made this a very easy read, though I took my time to really consider the lessons identified in each chapter.
I enjoyed the common framework for each chapter that ensured we understood not only the historical events but also how they related to contemporary issues in emergency management. Each of the lessons identified is one that we continue to wrestle with today, and placing that in the context of history is helpful because it allows us to draw connections that we might not otherwise find. It is sometimes easier to learn lessons when it is Nero fiddling while Rome burns instead of something more recent where the lessons may involve people we currently work or learn alongside.
There were two things that left this a little short of a 5-star review though. First was the lack of historical context and nuance. We have a brief overview of the circumstances surrounding a disaster, but the events are assessed against a 2026 framework, not a historically accurate framework. The lessons we learned and the structures we have built in emergency management have all been at the cost of the lives lost in those historical disasters. We cannot fault ancient Rome for not having a functioning emergency management office when the entire industry of emergency management is built on the ashes of that ancient city.
The second is that these chapters were entirely too short for my liking. I found myself craving more detailed information and deeper analysis of the events surrounding these disasters and how they relate to contemporary emergency management. There is likely enough information here to make each of these chapters into a separate book on their own, especially if they are appropriately contextualized and assessed in their historical contexts instead of contemporary expectations.
Overall, this is an excellent book that could use some more nuance and detail but provides some key lessons from history that will help emergency managers better understand and contextualize contemporary actions and lessons identified.