Pru Merriweather’s life has become a waking nightmare. Still reeling from the devastating attack on Stormlash manor, Pru has one choice: convince Hetty Jones, leader of the fearsome Ladies of Leora, to join her in the fight against zealot general, Maximus Hale, who threatens the existence of every woman in her beloved country—and the sanity of her lover, Puck Reed.
Meanwhile, as Puck agonizes over the capture of his daughter Beatrice, he must also confront his transformation into a Zeraph, a monstrous avenging angel whose will is directly tied to Hale’s greater mission of conquering Leora. Tortured by nightly visions of his daughter, Puck battles the urge to rescue her on his own, knowing Hale will seize the opportunity to twist him into a loyal soldier.
Together, Pru and Puck enlist the Ladies in a rescue plan aimed not just at getting Beatrice back, but freeing the entire country from Hale’s ever-increasing influence. But after Hetty sends Pru on a scouting mission, Puck loses the one tether keeping him from answering Hale’s persistent call. And when Pru discovers a growing Zeraphel army determined to burn all women who voice dissent, Hetty reacts in a way Pru doesn’t expect: she plans to take the coven and abandon Leora in favor of a country that celebrates rather than condemns women’s power.
With her lover gone, Pru must discover how to both defeat the seemingly all-powerful Zeraphel and rally the Ladies to save a country destined to destroy itself. And Puck, chosen by Hale to bring the city of Talonsbury to heel in exchange for his daughter’s freedom, must hold to his own inner strength—and his love for Pru and Beatrice—or else become one of the general’s monsters.
Taylor Hartley graduated from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill with a Bachelor’s degree in English Literature and a minor in Creative Writing. Inspired largely by Tamora Pierce and Madeline L’Engle, they started writing stories when they were nine years old and never looked back.
When they’re not reading or writing, Taylor can be found watching TV favorites such as Peaky Blinders, Wayne, or Succession, working out their rage on the rowing machine, or drinking coffee while staring into space. They love weekly Sunday night dinners with their father, crisp fall afternoons, and long runs, but only on scenic greenways. An eternal lover of the em dash and the Oxford comma, Taylor lives in Charlotte, North Carolina with their partner Aaron and two spoiled familiars masquerading as housecats.
Taylor is represented by Danielle Burby at Mad Woman Literary Agency.
This book was the perfect follow up to Song of the Hell Witch. I was lucky enough to receive an ARC for Dance of the Dark Mother. The amount of times I cried, gasped, and raged in this book is insane! I loved the female rage it evoked, the LGBTQ+ representation, the conflicts, all of it. There was no good place to put this book down. Specifically, I loved how open Pru was about how she wasn’t good with kids, but she still ran into the fire to save Bea. I spent the whole book wondering if Puck would hold strong or give in to Hale. From a logical stand point I wanted Pru to save Bea and let Puck go because he was too far gone. Emotionally though, I was like SAVE THAT MAN! It nearly took me out when Shea signed with Arcadie translating to Pru “Don’t drown trying to save what’s already dead.” Needless to say, this book had me on the edge of my seat the entire time I was reading it. Both this book and the first book are 5 stars!
CINEMATIC. That is the best way I can think to describe this book. Absolutely cinematic. Taylor Hartley writes in such a phenomenal way. The characters in this novel don’t just come alive, they walk out of the pages, into the world and straight to my heart where they stand with a vice like grip.
This is SUCH a strong sequel. I really appreciated the recap at the beginning of the story, it was written in such a way that I was quickly caught up and back into the action, like I pressed unpause on a film I was just watching and not like I was reading the sequel to a book I read 10 months ago. It also wasn’t overbearing, so if you are reading them back to back (lucky!!!) you won’t feel bogged down by it.
I’ve spoken before how I think Taylor Hartley writes in a phenomenal way but the writing moved me to tears at point. How the story moved from action to deeply moving at the flip of the switch but never felt jarring. Fast paced without losing any depth.
I love Pru. I love her. She is my sister. She is complex and brave and bright and I adore her. She is the heroine we need in 2026.
Pucks arc was one I found deeply interesting. He isn’t the boring male romantic lead we see so often. hHe is a complex character of his own. He is inherently such a good person yet he still makes mistakes. I found this particularly interesting as he is such an ally to these women, but his actions cause harm to women all the same - I thought it acted as a strong reminder that people in positions of privilege (whether that’s a sex, race, financial privilege) are continually benefitting from this system and often causing harm they would never mean to. It worked as a stark reminder to me not to just be a supporter and ally but you have to work every day to be anti the system you benefit from.
This story is truly a song that I will take with me for the rest of my life.
I got an ARC copy of this book, and it was the perfect second and final installment to Pru, Puck and the Spectabra Daughters Story.
The world continues to grow, and the characters gain more color and more depth in a heartbreaking and beautiful way. Taylor does a great job of high stakes storytelling in the world of Leora. I laughed, I cried, I stress clenched my toes. It ruined me and gave me hope. Song of the Hell Witch and the Dance of the Dark Mother is a duology I will sing praises for loud and often.
This was a gut wrenching conclusion for the Leora duet. You can viscerslly feel the agony that Puck experiences, and the gravity Pru experiences of doing whats right despite it being a difficult choice. I really enjoyed one of the opening scenes with Puck and Pru together. Taylor masterfully crafted their romance and respect for each other beautifully and intentionally rather than forcing it to fit within a plot.
Thank you to Taylor Hartley, the author, for the ARC! I was honored to be a reader.
This sequel was a very solid conclusion to the world of Pru and Puck! Admittedly, I was hoping to see more from Arcadie and Mari, two characters I really enjoyed from the first novel, Song of the Hell-Witch. I appreciated their representation in the story.
I love the concept of the hell-witches and the wide variety of "monsters" they reflect. I liked the battle-cry of women for women... Hartley's stories are a beautiful reminder of how powerful women are when we hold each other not only in great esteem but also accountable. Women truly run the world, just as they prove in Talonsbury and Stormlash!
I thought the inclusion of Brother Kay as a sort of foil for Puck was interesting. It was nice to see another Zeraphel who attempted to challenge Hale's ideals.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book. I know this duology was a true labor of love! Congratulations to Taylor on this great series debut... looking forward to what they continue to write!
As someone who really enjoyed Song of the Hell Witch, it breaks my heart to say that Dance of the Dark Mother was a disappointing conclusion.
We pick up right after SOTHW ended: Pru has to convince the leader of the Ladies of Leora, Hetty Jones, to join forces in taking down Hale and rescue Bea, Puck’s daughter. Meanwhile, Puck deals with the aftermath of his transformation into a Zeraph.
During the first half of the book, I strongly believed this was going to be a five-star read. The conflict between Pru and Hetty was by far my favorite part. It added complexity that elevated the stakes of the story and good commentary about feminism which applies to what’s currently happening in the real world. I also really liked Puck’s internal struggle, and I found myself worried about what his fate would be in the end. The worldbuilding expanded in this book and it was explained in a better way than SOTHW was: more seamless, less info-dumpy. The pacing was well-balanced and I flew through this section!
But then I hit the second half and that’s where my enjoyment fell. I was more invested in Pru’s chapters than Puck’s, and that is largely because I failed to see how Puck’s mission tied to the overarching theme of the story. Even when explained, I was scratching my head a lot.
The more I read, the more I noticed how a lot of the side characters that had huge roles in SOTHW were sidelined in this installment, to the point where they were barely on-page. It was strange considering some of them left SOTHW with their arcs unfinished and this book didn’t conclude them. The side characters that were focused on this book had their arcs rushed and I didn’t connect with them as much as I should’ve to care. I also found myself wishing for more Pru and Puck moments.
Harltey excels in writing cinematic fight scenes and after the ending of SOTHW, I was very excited to see how the action would play out in this book. Unfortunately these scenes were way more toned down, which didn’t quite fit with the spectacle the finale was setting up to be. Speaking of the finale, the ending was very rushed and it didn’t have a huge impact on me. It felt like there was more left to tell.
My expectations were high and that might have affected my enjoyment. That being said, this duology was a solid debut for Hartley and I’m really looking forward to reading their future work!
Thank you to the author for the advanced copy. All opinions are my own.
I was lucky enough to get an early copy of DotDM, which was great since I was eagerly awaiting finding out how Puck and Pru's story ends. I think one of the beautiful things about Hartley's writing is that...well, there are many beautiful things...but I'm able to find myself in a story that has so many real world parallels. I think sometimes (most of the time) we can get lost in the new cycle and all of the horrors that persist each day. Picking up a book is an escape and a way for us to make more sense of the world, even if it isn't OUR world.
Leora is a place where women struggle, just like ours. And while we've come much further than our Ladies, there's still a huge fight ahead of us. Pru taught me that we can't do it alone. Puck taught me how men can be allies. The story taught me how to hope.
Some favorite quotes: "I know who you are, Duchess Talonsbury...You're the Hell Witch who murdered her husband. The most wanted woman in all of Leora, and hard proof that we are the Dark Mother's wicked daughters, bent on destroying good men."
"It was true, what people said. A father really would sacrifice everything for his child. Even his soul."
"Is that how you're going to sleep at night, then? When you hear the news coming out of Leora, will you tell yourself 'I saved a woman once, so I don't need to do anything else."
"But what are our songs and our medicines if not rebellion? We have been standing with you, in our own way. I believe you may have forgotten what it is like, vampiress. To actually be powerless in a fight."
And once again, yes, I will be reviewing my own novel...though not in the way people might think.
It was my goal in writing DANCE OF THE DARK MOTHER to really wrestle with the struggles that feminism faces and the various ways in which our refusal to acknowledge intersectionality harms us as a whole. For example, Hetty's reaction to Pru is not one born out of selfishness, but rather a direct response to those women who refuse to appreciate her sacrifices and work to help HER in the fight she's waged alone for so long. Moreover, Puck symbolizes those allies that women need as we fight for our own equality...and the dangers toxic masculinity poses not only to women, but to men as well. I only hope that people walk away from the reading experience feeling both empowered and enraged...so many have fought for our freedoms, but we must continue that fight, and we cannot do it alone.
It's my hope that Pru and Puck's journey concludes in a way that is both satisfying and inspiring. These characters have been with me for the better part of ten years, and I am so glad they've finally found their readers. I hope you enjoy their story as much as I enjoyed creating it.