Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Fight to the Death: Human Stories from the Assisted Dying Debate

Rate this book
Every story in this audiobook begins with a life shaped by love.

Assisted dying is a question that reaches into the deepest parts of us, sitting at the intersection of medicine, morality and personal liberty. For decades, debates around legalisation have played out across the world, even as people on both sides have suffered, struggling with impossibly complex choices.

In Fight to the Death, award-winning journalist Paul Brand explores the lives unfolding behind the headlines, collecting true stories from those who stand on both sides of assisted people living with unrelenting pain who long for autonomy in their final days, and those who have lost someone they love to a decision they could not accept.

These narratives are not arguments on either side of a political debate, but lives unfolding – a mother facing the slow erosion of her body, a son believing he made a merciful choice. Brand takes us inside the rooms where those decisions are confronted - in the hospitals, kitchens, courtrooms and quiet late-night conversations.

Honest and unflinching, Fight to the Death invites listeners to witness, not judge. This is an audiobook about the limits of the human body, the strength of family, and the emotional landscapes no law can ever capture.

Paul Brand is the UK Editor for ITV News and presenter of ITV’s flagship Tonight programme. He appears nightly on the Evening News and News at Ten, and regularly on Good Morning Britain, as well as a host on LBC radio. Paul is a six-time Royal Television Society award-winner and in 2022 was awarded Broadcaster of the Year at the London Press Club Awards. He has a social media following of 250,000 across Twitter and Bluesky.

2026 Paul Brand (P) 2026 DK Audio

Audible Audio

Published October 1, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Paul Brand

1 book3 followers
Paul Brand is a multi-award winning journalist and broadcaster. He is currently UK Editor and Presenter for ITV News and Good Morning Britain, as well as Presenter on LBC radio. He anchors the UK's most-watched current affairs programme, Tonight. His reputation for breaking exclusives including the partygate scandal, alongside his empathetic style of reporting, has won him six Royal Television Society awards, including two for his work on assisted dying.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
5 (31%)
4 stars
9 (56%)
3 stars
2 (12%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews
18 reviews
September 27, 2026
Rigorously researched and compassionately handled - you may not feel convinced of either side of the argument by the end but you will have been encouraged to consider every aspect of the debate.
Profile Image for Katheryn Haskell.
417 reviews21 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
September 19, 2026
Objectively, this is a very well written book, a great, objective piece of journalism. It keeps everything neutral and factual, while delivering multiple sides and beliefs without making one or another feel like the "right" one. Just information that the reader can decide what they think, and that is fantastic journalism.

And I think it's cool to hear about MAID laws in other countries, and of how the laws came to be (or not be). I like that the content has range, covering laws, personal stories, different countries, all kinds of topics, and it really doesn't sway from talking about MAID (even in some circumstances where there's a lot of influence from other things, like religion for example).

Personally, this book made me rage multiple times, as a very liberal minded individual. But it was also good to see other people's opinions, even if they contrast with mine.
117 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 29, 2026
I received an advance reader copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.

Premise
A personal investigation into the controversial topic of assisted dying

Liked
* A mix of policy, history, and anecdotal narratives on the contentious subject of assisted dying
* Broad in scope yet filled with deeply personal accounts of families and professionals touched by the subject
* Fair and deep reporting covering both the camps for and against the legalization and expansion of assisted dying, with plenty of well-explored ambivalence in between
* Does not draw a definitive conclusion but left the readers well-informed to make up their own minds
* Reminds me of Far from the Tree by Andrew Solomon

Not for Me
* Some parts on the legislative process a bit dry (though ultimately necessary)

Closing Comment
This is a tremendously reported book on an extremely delicate subject. I came with my own biases and my mind was changed repeatedly during the course of reading the book. I must applaud the author for writing a fair-minded and touching entry to the subject. An essential read for anyone interested in the subject of life, death, and personal autonomy.
Profile Image for Saarah Niña.
559 reviews24 followers
October 19, 2026
A Human Story Before a Political Debate

Fight to the Death explores the debate surrounding assisted dying, assisted suicide and euthanasia. Paul Brand examines the issue from multiple perspectives, presenting a comprehensive and nuanced discussion. While the religious arguments are covered less extensively than some other viewpoints, Brand explains his fair reasoning for this and remains transparent about the book's focus.

From the very first page, Brand grounds the debate in a real person's experience. We meet Jessica, a woman who knows exactly when she will die. She has carefully prepared for her chosen date, even timing her television binge-watching so she can finish her favourite series beforehand. Living with a debilitating autoimmune condition, she has decided that an assisted death will provide her with the control, dignity and freedom from suffering that a natural death may not. For Jessica, dignity is tied to avoiding future suffering.

Beginning the book with Jessica's story immediately reminds readers that this debate is not simply legal or political, but profoundly personal. Jessica's story remained one of the most memorable parts of the book for me. Beyond the legal and ethical questions, Brand captures the grief experienced by those left behind. The conversations between Jessica and her lifelong friend Wendy are particularly moving, with both women confronting the reality that Jessica will not live to experience future milestones and shared memories. Their friendship serves as a reminder that assisted dying is never solely an individual decision; its effects ripple through families, friendships and communities. [pp. 2-3]

My heart was deeply engaged throughout this discussion, particularly by the stories of the people at the centre of it. Brand weaves personal experiences into the wider conversation, highlighting individuals seeking what they believe is a dignified and safe death while also wanting to protect their loved ones from legal consequences for helping them achieve it. In some cases, that journey is heartbreakingly lonely. People choose not to tell their families of their plans because they do not want to incriminate them. Instead, relatives learn only after the fact that a loved one has travelled abroad, often to Switzerland, and died there. Oftentimes these are individuals who chose this route because it is about having a death that is planned, medically supervised and controlled, reducing uncertainty and the potential trauma that a suicide might bring for loved ones.

Changing Attitudes Towards Assisted Dying
Brand notes: "Across the Western world, people have become increasingly relaxed about the idea of assisted dying. Opponents object to the use of polling to capture attitudes towards such a morally complex question, but the trends over time are clear to see." [p. 7] I appreciated this acknowledgement because it reflects Brand's willingness to recognise changing public attitudes without suggesting that popularity alone determines morality.

Choice, Control and Health Consumerism
Brand also explores how broader cultural changes have influenced the assisted dying debate. He discusses the rise of health consumerism, where patients increasingly expect to be active participants in decisions about their care rather than passive recipients of medical advice. This is particularly evident among the baby boomer generation, many of whom have grown to value and expect autonomy, personal choice and control over major life decisions, including those surrounding death. For supporters of assisted dying, the ability to determine the circumstances of one's death is viewed as an extension of the same principles that underpin informed consent and patient-centred care.

The Slippery Slope Argument
Opponents, however, worry that legalising assisted dying could create a slippery slope. Some fear eligibility criteria may gradually expand beyond their original limits, leading to what critics describe as "designer deaths" or a culture in which assisted dying becomes increasingly normalised. Others express concerns that vulnerable individuals may be influenced by societal attitudes or begin to view assisted death as an expected response to illness, disability or old age.

Brand addresses these anxieties by examining evidence from countries where assisted dying has been legal for many years. While he acknowledges that safeguards and oversight remain crucial, he argues that some of the fears expressed by opponents have not emerged to the extent critics predicted. This willingness to test claims against evidence rather than rely on rhetoric was one of the aspects of the book I found most persuasive.

Disability Rights and Safeguarding the Vulnerable
The book also examines the legal and political challenges involved in recognising assisted dying as a non-criminal act. Campaigners often frame the issue as one of compassion and autonomy, while opponents raise concerns about coercion and the devaluation of vulnerable lives.
Disability rights campaigners, in particular, warn that legalisation could reinforce the damaging idea that disabled lives are somehow less valuable. Someone who has spent a lifetime absorbing messages that they are a burden may be especially vulnerable to making decisions based on those beliefs. Brand explores these concerns alongside the extensive assessments, interviews and safeguards used in jurisdictions where assisted dying is legal.
Brand also includes the perspective of doctors such as Dr Clarke, whose concerns extend beyond legal safeguards and into the realities of end-of-life care. Drawing on years of experience in palliative care, she argues that some suffering experienced by dying patients is avoidable and stems not from the illness itself but from inadequate medical, social and palliative support. She worries that legalising assisted dying in a system where many people already struggle to access the care they need could result in vulnerable individuals choosing death when better support might have alleviated their suffering. [p. 57]

I found this one of the stronger arguments presented against assisted dying because it shifts the discussion away from individual choice and towards society's responsibilities. Rather than asking whether someone should have the right to die, Dr Clarke asks whether society has done enough to help them live with dignity first. [p. 57] As a nurse in England, I believe our society is failing in these duties of care towards end of life and terminal patients.

The Physician's Dilemma
Another area I found particularly interesting was the role of the physician. Opponents often express concern about doctors becoming directly involved in ending a patient's life, arguing that this could erode trust in the medical profession.
Brand discusses doctors who have personally wrestled with this responsibility. For some, participation in assisted dying appears fundamentally at odds with the identity they have developed throughout their careers and with the Hippocratic Oath and tradition that shaped their understanding of medicine. Having dedicated their lives to preserving life and relieving suffering, some struggle with the idea that their role might also involve helping a patient to die.

At the same time, Brand examines jurisdictions where physician involvement forms part of the process. In parts of Australia, for example, some patients may choose a physician-administered death through intravenous medication rather than self-administering prescribed drugs. Brand notes that in jurisdictions where both physician-administered and self-administered deaths are available, the overwhelming choice is for physician administration. [p. 175] While critics view this as a troubling extension of medical power, Brand discusses how some patients value this option because it removes uncertainty about whether the medication will work as intended. For them, physician involvement can provide reassurance, safety and compassion at what is often the most vulnerable moment of their lives.

Mental Illness, Capacity and the Limits of Autonomy
One of the strongest chapters in the book for me was Chapter 7, in which Brand explores some of the most controversial applications of assisted dying: cases involving mental illness rather than terminal physical disease. These are individuals whose suffering may be considered unbearable or intolerable by them, despite the absence of a terminal diagnosis. [p. 174]

Brand writes that only a minority of countries currently permit assisted dying on the basis of mental illness, including the Netherlands, Belgium, Colombia, Luxembourg and Switzerland. He also notes the inconsistency of international approaches, observing that in some places, "the diagnosis of a mental disorder is actually a barrier to accessing an assisted death." [p. 178]

Reading this chapter raised difficult questions. If a person's suffering is rooted in mental illness, how can clinicians determine whether their bleak outlook is a reflection of reality or a symptom of the condition itself? How can anyone know with certainty that recovery is impossible, that treatment will never work, or that circumstances will not improve? Brand does not offer easy answers, but he does an excellent job of illustrating why this remains one of the most ethically contested areas of the debate.

The chapter also explores age as a potential barrier. Brand discusses cases in which minors have accessed assisted dying and notes that even some supporters of the practice have expressed unease about such cases. Concerns range from neurological development and decision-making capacity to the possibility that younger patients have not yet exhausted future treatment options or benefited from emerging therapies. [p. 186]

Brand further examines concerns about a potential contagion or copycat effect, whereby euthanasia becomes increasingly normalised or even idealised within society. His discussion of duo-euthanasia, in which two people, most commonly romantic partners, choose to die together, was particularly interesting. While advocates may view such cases as an expression of autonomy and companionship, critics argue that they risk reinforcing an idealised vision of death in which grief, separation and loss can somehow be avoided and that these conditions are terminal and cannot be overcome. [p. 186]

Control, Choice and Peace of Mind
One of the arguments I didn't expect to encounter in the book comes from Dr Philip Nitschke. Nitschke argues that access to assisted dying can sometimes extend life rather than shorten it. He suggests that when people know the option is available, they may feel less anxious about future suffering and less pressured to act prematurely. The reassurance of remaining in control can allow some individuals to continue living with greater peace of mind.
Brand presents this argument without necessarily endorsing it, but I found it particularly striking because it challenges the assumption that access to assisted dying inevitably leads people to choose death sooner. Instead, for some individuals, simply having the option available may provide comfort and a sense of security, even if they never use it. [p. 27]

Religion and the Limits of Persuasion
As someone whose own position on assisted dying is shaped by my religion, I would have liked a more extensive discussion of the faith-based arguments against it.
That said, I found Brand's explanation for limiting this section a fair one. He points out that the major faith traditions are already relatively clear and united in their opposition, and that people's acceptance or rejection of these arguments often depends on whether they share the underlying religious beliefs. Rather than revisiting well-established positions at length, Brand chooses to focus on the legal, ethical and practical questions surrounding assisted dying. Even if I would have welcomed a deeper exploration of the religious perspective, I can understand why he made that editorial choice.

Final Thoughts
One aspect I particularly appreciated was Brand's willingness to reveal his own position at the end of the book which is rare in my experience of reading non fiction literature like this one. Rather than presenting himself as a detached observer with no personal stake in the debate, he acknowledges the complexity of the issue and the impact that years of reporting on assisted dying have had on him. He writes that assisted dying is "a debate that cannot be settled by dogma" and describes autonomy, vulnerability, compassion and faith as competing values at the heart of the discussion. [p. 210]

In many respects, Brand's final reflections came surprisingly close to my own. Like him, I found myself deeply moved by the stories of people experiencing profound suffering and by the compassion that motivates many supporters of assisted dying. Where our views ultimately diverge is on the role of faith. My own position remains shaped by my religious beliefs, and my nursing career, but I appreciated that Brand treated faith as one of the competing values within the debate rather than dismissing it outright. [p. 210] Personally, I would never judge someone who chose this route, nor would I wish to deny access to someone who met the legal criteria. While my faith leads me to oppose assisted dying for myself, I do not believe it should necessarily be illegal. I understand I do not and should not have the right to make such a deeply personal decision on behalf of another person.

Brand does not tell readers what to think or push you towards a side. Instead, he humanises a deeply polarising issue and encourages thoughtful engagement with one of the most difficult ethical questions of our time. I found the pro-assisted death arguments far more compelling and thought-provoking than I had anticipated. Ultimately, this is what impressed me most -not that the book changed my position, but that it challenged me to understand the perspectives more deeply.


Overall, this is a thoughtful and compassionate exploration of assisted dying that prioritises people over ideology. Brand succeeds in presenting the ethical, legal and personal complexities of the debate in an accessible and engaging way.

Reflecting on my rating, I think the difference between 4 and 5 stars comes down largely to the book's structure. I found the individual stories compelling and the legal and ethical discussions equally engaging, but I did not always feel they were woven together seamlessly. There were times when I wanted to stay with a particular person's story for longer before moving into politics and legislation. The material itself was consistently thought-provoking, but the organisation occasionally made the reading experience feel less cohesive than it might have been.

I received this book for review consideration from Lovereading UK. All opinions are my own and completely honest.
Profile Image for Zoe Lipman.
2,235 reviews40 followers
October 12, 2026
4.25/5

This book is a conversation on medically assisted dying. And I didn't know a whole lot about that, so I was curious and wanted to learn.

This goes through how it works and it viewed (in different countries), the laws and requirements around it, and features stories about those experiencing the process.

This is a VERY heavy read, especially as someone who is chronically ill. So be warned that this may be too heavy for you to read at certain points if you (or someone you know) is going through something similar. But I did learn a lot from this book.

And it's only about 200 pages.

And I definitely have thoughts about the using this for anorexia. That's for sure.

Thanks to NetGalley for the e-ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review!
Profile Image for betsy.
185 reviews10 followers
November 8, 2026
i went into Fight to the Death pretty well-versed in the politics and legislation surrounding medically assisted dying but always interested in learning more. i found the book to be deeply humanizing and thought it never lost sight of the real people living inside the policy debates.

it was informative without being dry, presenting the arguments on both sides are clearly and fairly, and the whole thing is so well organized that it was easy to follow even when the personal stories got heavy.

if you want to understand the medically assisted dying debate beyond the clickbaity headlines, pick this up.

thanks to the author and publisher for the advanced copy.
Profile Image for Whitney Hofstetter.
89 reviews2 followers
August 2, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and DK for an advanced copy of the book.

Disclaimer: I am a palliative care/hospice nurse practitioner and deal with this issue often.

4/5 stars

Plot: Non-fiction about the legalization and implementation of assisted dying. Several stories of individuals are shared.

Impression: This book is hard for me to rate but it is such an important topic. The stories of individuals are handled with dignity and respect. I detected minimal to no bias from the author but that does make this a more “dry” book. However, some of the stories are horrifying- finding out your loved one chose to end their life after the fact is unacceptable. I have conflicted feelings on this issue but came away with reinforcement that access to better palliative and mental healthcare is essential.

Trigger Warning: this book deals intimately with death/suicide

Star System: 5 star reads are books I can’t put down and/or make me cry. This is a book that will stick with me for either the topic, writing style, or emotional impact.
4 star books are unique or interesting and perhaps teach me something new. A feel good read is usually 4 stars.
3 star reads are good, solid books. I’m not necessarily learning or feeling anything new.
2 star books have some plot holes or timeline issues. These are the books that just aren’t believable.
1 star books are typically offensive
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews