Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Only Angels Have Blue Eyes

Rate this book
Things are looking up for Maylin Cole and her 4-year-old daughter, Margo. Fleeing an abusive relationship, the private clinic Heaven’s Hope offers shelter and the promise of a new life. Led by the charismatic and beguiling Seraph Nakir, they learn a surprising truth: they’re actually angels who have lost their way.

Everyone has an angel name and is being prepared to ‘ascend’ when the time is right. Their angelic identities will play a significant role in aiding humanity when the world ends.

As the weeks pass, Maylin becomes accustomed to the peculiar confrontational therapy. The black curtains and bars on the windows no longer trouble her. The lack of privacy, mystifying theology, and strange rules become commonplace. She sees Margo less frequently since the children are kept in the basement.

The death of another patient awakens Maylin to dark secrets within the walls, and soon the horrifying truth about Nakir and Heaven’s Hope is revealed. Maylin must confront her insecurities, rediscover her individuality, and use her wits and resources if she hopes to save Margo and the other children.

Inspired by a true crime case, this slow-burn thriller roars to a pulse-pounding climax, reminding the reader to think independently, ask questions, and be careful who you trust.

Warning: This story contains descriptions of domestic abuse, indoctrination, and child abuse.

287 pages, ebook

Published August 3, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

J. Todd Kingrea

18 books46 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
34 (77%)
4 stars
10 (22%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
Profile Image for Tina A..
214 reviews11 followers
August 7, 2026
5 Stars Isn’t Enough for This Eye-conic Cult Thriller!

I’ve read a ton of psychological thrillers, but this is just... WOW! From the very first page, I was pulled in so completely that I felt like I was there the entire time. J. Todd Kingrea has fearlessly executed a sinister story that went so far beyond my expectations.

Inspired by a true cult-crime case, the narrative captures the chilling isolation hidden right in the middle of ordinary suburban sprawl. Inside, the disturbing dynamics of a compound ruled by strict guidelines and absolute consequences kept me on edge.

Seeing how enraptured the characters were by the leader's charisma and ideals was both frustrating and sad—there were times I literally wanted to smack them back to reality!

It delivers an addictive, relentless pace that promises to be an unforgettable read, even if you’ve never picked up a cult crime thriller before. It is absolutely movie-worthy and forever etched in my brain!
Profile Image for Tara Magana.
59 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 4, 2026
Maylin and her four year old, Margo, are desperate. The duo has exhausted their time at a local shelter and are hiding from a violent, drug dealing ex-boyfriend. Their fear is all-encompassing and Maylin has no viable options or a realistic path to move forward. Seemingly answered prayers arrive in perfect time with the charismatic Seraph Nakir and his rehabilitation home, Heaven’s Hope. The residence has concerning, almost extreme rules such as no outdoor access and stringent dietary guidelines. There are unconventional therapy sessions and time with a resident’s children is doled out in small measures.

Numerous warning signs alert Maylin that Seraph Nakir may not be who he seems as the gap between promise and reality slowly widen. She begins to recognize others share her unease, adding another layer of tension and the building sense of dread. Dire in her circumstances, Maylin’s mind fractures into cognitive dissonance with Seraph Nakir’s teachings and reassurance of a stable, safe life for herself and Margo. His belief of “ascending” as angels to those that dutifully adhere to his doctrines is fanatical. A shocking event shatters her fragile illusions and strips her of denial. Heaven’s Hope is not a safe refuge and she, along with the other residents and children are in a danger far greater than she ever imagined.

The novel’s final quarter is packed with intense revelations, ratcheting tighter with every chapter. In my opinion, the stories power is in its intricate exploration of the reasons that contribute to someone’s unwitting access to a cult. Kingrea presents psychological distress and internal conflict well, illustrating Maylin’s mental health journey. At times I found myself in disbelief and admonishing the protagonist choices. The author allows you to feel the weight of the emotional despair of the characters. Knowing that the story draws from true events made it more horrific. I found myself giving thought to the characters and the storyline long after I finished the last chapter.
Profile Image for Harold Cloninger.
Author 10 books7 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 6, 2026
First, a couple of warnings. There is sex (although light and not overly descriptive), strong language and religious themes. If you're easily offended about religious views, you may not want to read this book.

With that said, this is a good book. I really enjoyed how the antagonist took familiar ideas/teachings and twisted them just enough to use them to his benefit. It explores how certain people can identify vulnerabilities in others and exploit them for their own benefit. You can wonder how people would ever fall for a cult, and this book does a great job of walking through the brainwashing and how the leaders use desperation as a tool to demand obedience. Another thing I really enjoyed was how the different members of the cult each had their own needs and reasons for being in the cult. This would be where one of my minor gripes comes in. I wish a few of the characters and their reasons for being members in the cult were fleshed out a bit more. Most of the characters were sufficiently explained, but a couple characters were just there for story purposes.

Another thing I appreciated was the explanation of narcissists. They don't see what they do as evil. In their minds, whatever they do is right and justified. They really have no concept of the harm they cause others. This book shows that even after all the horrible things they've done, they still felt like they were in the right. It's hard to fathom how people can be evil, but this story shows how oblivious certain people are to their actions, which in itself is terrifying.
Profile Image for Chapters_with_VDKeck.
804 reviews94 followers
August 3, 2026
Y’all, Only Angels Have Blue Eyes starts with hope and ends in a nightmare. After escaping an abusive relationship, Maylin Cole and her young daughter find refuge at Heaven’s Hope—until the clinic’s unsettling rules, twisted beliefs, and missing children reveal something far more sinister.

J. Todd Kingre crafts a slow-burn psychological thriller that builds tension one unsettling page at a time. Maylin’s determination to save Margo makes her impossible not to root for, and the atmospheric writing wraps around you like a tightening noose. Inspired by a true crime case, this is a chilling reminder that the most dangerous monsters often hide behind the friendliest smiles.
Profile Image for Allison.
21 reviews
July 3, 2026
Malin and her daughter are out of options. Chased by an angry ex, they flee to Heaven's Hope, a house full of people who welcome them with open arms. Could Malin have finally found a safe place to heal and begin again?
This story will likely appeal to religious cult story fans as well as those who enjoy psychological suspense and grief horror.
I'm not usually a cult story fan, and I admit I got annoyed with the MC many times for seeming to ignore so many red flags. Still, the character development in this book is excellent and I enjoyed getting to know Malin and her housemates. Each have a unique backstory and personality that keep you guessing about who to trust and who has secrets you've yet to discover. The ending is action-packed and is well worth the slow burn leading up to it.
⚠️ CW for child abuse
***
I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Bookaholic__Reviews.
1,535 reviews186 followers
August 3, 2026
I absolutely loved this story. Cults are so fascinating to me so I ate this story up! The fact that this story drew inspiration from real life events, makes it that much more impactful. To be real.... indoctrination is one of the scariest things that exists. This story played up the danger of it beautifully. Reading about the children though was heartbreaking.

I received a copy in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Robin Ginther-Venneri.
1,222 reviews100 followers
October 22, 2026
💀 ROBIN’S REVIEW: THE AUTOPSY OF ONLY ANGELS HAVE BLUE EYES

Only Angels Have Blue Eyes by J. Todd Kingrea

Star Rating: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Skull Dread Rating: 💀💀

🪦 THE BODY

Well, Mr. Kingrea.

I would like to congratulate you on creating a place I would rather be dragged through a zombie apocalypse than visit.

And considering my love of zombies, that is saying something.

Imagine finding what appears to be the answer to your problems, only to discover you have traded one nightmare for another.

Enter Maylin, a mother desperately trying to give herself and her little girl something resembling a decent life.

Unfortunately, the universe apparently looked at her circumstances and decided she had not suffered enough.

And then we meet Seraph Nakir.

Oh, this man.

I disliked him almost immediately.

Which, naturally, meant I needed to keep reading.

🔪 FIRST INCISION

What makes this story so disturbing is how quietly everything begins to feel wrong.

There is no giant flashing sign announcing that everyone should immediately run for the nearest exit.

Instead, little things start adding up.

An uncomfortable conversation.

An expectation that seems slightly unreasonable.

A rule that makes absolutely no sense.

And somehow, what would normally send someone running becomes just another part of daily life.

That is the terrifying part.

Not how strange everything becomes.

But how easily people can be convinced that strange is perfectly acceptable.

Personally, the moment somebody starts explaining why I need permission to make ordinary decisions, I am leaving.

Preferably through the nearest window.

🩸 THE AUTOPSY

Mr. Kingrea understands something important about psychological horror.

You do not need supernatural creatures to make readers uncomfortable.

Sometimes all you need is a convincing liar, a vulnerable person, and an environment where questioning anything becomes dangerous.

The gradual manipulation is what makes this story effective.

Watching someone surrender small pieces of independence without immediately recognizing what is happening is deeply unsettling.

And the worst part?

You can understand how it happens.

That bothered me far more than any fictional monster could.

There were moments when I wanted to grab Maylin by the shoulders and shake some sense into her.

Then I had to remind myself that readers have the luxury of seeing warning signs without being trapped inside the situation.

Well played, Mr. Kingrea.

I came here to judge fictional people's decisions.

You made me examine my own assumptions instead.

Rude.

🫀 STILL HAD A PULSE

Maylin is the emotional center of this story.

She is not perfect.

She makes choices that frustrated me.

There were moments when I wanted to yell, "Woman, PLEASE!"

But that is also what made her believable.

Fear, exhaustion, and the desperate need for stability can change how people interpret the world around them.

And when a child is involved, every decision carries additional weight.

Margo made the situation particularly difficult to read because there is something especially upsetting about children being caught in circumstances they cannot possibly understand or control.

As for Seraph?

Sir.

I have encountered some spectacularly unpleasant fictional characters.

You have earned yourself a very respectable position on that list.

Congratulations.

Your prize is absolutely nothing.

🦴 WHAT BROKE

My patience.

My blood pressure.

And whatever tiny amount of faith I had left in people who appoint themselves humanity's spiritual authority.

The pacing takes its time in places, and some of the longer chapters could have benefited from a little trimming.

But I also understand why the author allows certain situations to develop gradually.

The discomfort comes from watching the atmosphere change while the characters struggle to recognize just how much their circumstances have deteriorated.

I wanted things to move faster because I wanted Maylin to realize what was happening.

Which, I suspect, was exactly the point.

☠️ CAUSE OF DEATH

Only Angels Have Blue Eyes is the kind of psychological horror that makes you uncomfortable for reasons that have absolutely nothing to do with ghosts, demons, or things hiding under your bed.

The frightening part is how believable the manipulation becomes.

Mr. Kingrea has written a story about vulnerability, misplaced trust, and the terrifying consequences of allowing someone else to decide what is best for you.

And knowing the novel draws inspiration from actual criminal cases makes the experience considerably more disturbing.

Because somewhere along the way, you realize the most unbelievable parts of a horror story are not always the ones that require imagination.

Five stars for a book that had me suspicious, frustrated, furious, and desperately hoping certain characters would discover the wonderful benefits of independent thought.

Mr. Kingrea, I would like to make one thing perfectly clear.

If a man ever approaches me claiming to possess exclusive knowledge about my divine destiny, I will be asking for identification, references, and a thorough background check.

And if he tells me questioning him is forbidden?

Congratulations.

That is my cue to leave.

Preferably before the complimentary refreshments.

Reviewed by Robin for Robin’s Review
Profile Image for Kerry.
201 reviews
August 4, 2026
My Review
Only Angels Have Blue Eyes written by J.Todd Kingrea is a psychological horror story, it comes with a blend of cult fiction, suspense and emotional drama. It is inspired by a true story and the story lingers even after the final page. The story follows Maylin Cole, who with daughter Margo, is fleeing from an abusive relationship. She seeks sanctuary at the secluded Heavens Hope clinic but as the story progresses she realises all is not as it seems and something sinister is going on.

Kingrea excels at creating an atmosphere of impending dread and doom. Rather than relying on shocks galore, he gradually builds up tension when Maylin begins to question the clinics strange beliefs, authoritarian rules and the clinics leader, Seraph Nakir. As the story explores the theme of coercive control, trauma, manipulation of vulnerable people following abuse - it may be wise to take heed of the trigger warnings.

Throughout the story we watch Maylins character grow from fear and self doubt to sheer determination with her need to protect Margo, this gives the story an emotional element. The side characters add layers of ambiguity as you don't know who to trust.

For those looking for none stop action, you will find the pacing steady in the first half but this is deliberate as the second half really ramps up offering intense and a fast climax which delivers both suspense and emotional elements.

Overall, WOW! This book is certainly up there with one of my favourite reads so far this year. It will appear to readers of cult based horror, domestic suspense and character driven stories. The exploration of manipulation and resilience throughout is thought provoking and chilling. It will certainly stay with me for a while. Would love to see a screen adaptation of this story.
35 reviews1 follower
November 5, 2026
Only Angels Have Blue Eyes by J. Todd Kingrea is a chilling, atmospheric psychological thriller that explores the terrifying speed at which desperation can be weaponized against the vulnerable. Inspired by true crime, the narrative pulls readers into a suffocating web of indoctrination, control, and survival.
The story follows Maylin Cole and her four year old daughter, Margo, who are fleeing a dangerous, abusive ex boyfriend. With nowhere left to turn, Maylin seeks shelter at "Heaven’s Hope," a private clinic led by the magnetic and beguiling Seraph Nakir. What initially promises sanctuary and healing quickly devolves into an eerie nightmare defined by strict rules, isolating therapy, and dark theological manipulation.
Kingrea’s greatest strength lies in his masterclass pacing and character psychology. Rather than portraying cult indoctrination as an immediate trap, he reveals the subtle, insidious ways autonomy is stripped away piece by piece. Maylin's fierce maternal instinct to protect Margo forms the emotional core of the novel, making her struggle deeply empathetic and intensely suspenseful.
Dark, thought provoking, and relentlessly tense, Only Angels Have Blue Eyes is a standout read for fans of domestic thrillers, cult fiction, and slow-burn psychological horror. Highly recommended!
17 reviews2 followers
October 10, 2026
Only Angels Have Blue Eyes is a masterfully crafted slow-burn thriller that kept me hooked from the very first page. The story follows Maylin Cole and her young daughter, Margo, as they flee an abusive relationship and seek refuge at a private clinic called Heaven's Hope. What starts as a promise for a new life quickly spirals into a chilling nightmare under the charismatic and beguiling leadership of Seraph Nakir.
The author does a phenomenal job building a sense of dread as Maylin becomes normalized to the clinic’s bizarre confrontational therapy, black curtains, and barred windows. The tension reaches a boiling point when the children are separated and kept in the basement, forcing Maylin to confront the horrifying dark secrets of the clinic to save her daughter. Inspired by a true crime case, this book delivers a powerful, pulse-pounding climax that forces you to think independently and question who you trust. It is intense, thought-provoking, and completely unforgettable. Highly recommended for thriller fans!
Profile Image for The Book Ssirren.
7,709 reviews191 followers
August 4, 2026
This was an absolutely amazing read. Maylin, running from an abusive ex with her daughter Margo, find themselves finding refuge at Heavens Hope. A place that offers shelter and helps keep the privacy of their residents. The way Maylin brushed off the rules, even though they were very strange, had me already screaming at her to grab her daughter and go. But she was in desperate need, and that desperation kept her there. The way the children were kept in the basement? Screaming red flag right there. But again, she brushed it off. It was more than apparent she’d gotten herself wrapped you in a cult. The conditioning was subtle at times, but at others it was clear as day.
This story had me so invested, I was literally gripping my iPad. It’s amazing the things people will allow themselves to fall into. And so many do it unknowingly. This was very intense and absolutely thrilling. The suspense, the mystery, it was so captivating. This was a truly amazing read.
Profile Image for Josette Thomas.
1,423 reviews1 follower
August 19, 2026
Domestic violence can lead people out of the frying pan and into the fire. From the moment I began reading this book until the last pages; I had so much compassion for Maylin. She was trying to better her and her daughter’s life and she managed to step into a worse place than she was before. Rather quickly she figures out this guru is not being honest with the people in the program. When she decides she wants out; things become downright dangerous. The worst part was finding out that there was a a group that actively looked for women with addiction issues. The guy was a really good at pretending to care until someone questioned his tactics. Even though this was fiction so many real life stories come out about issues like this. No wonder some people feel the human race is doomed.
17 reviews1 follower
Read
October 11, 2026
As a long-time fan of dark psychological thrillers, I found this book to be an absolute roller coaster. I was drawn in from the moment Maylin Cole and her four-year-old daughter, Margo, arrive at Heaven’s Hope looking for safety from an abusive ex. Kingrea creates an intensely claustrophobic atmosphere as Seraph Nakir’s disturbing cult rules gradually close in around Maylin.
I found myself holding my breath as Maylin struggled to protect her daughter behind locked doors, security sensors, and blacked-out windows. The graphic depictions of psychological manipulation and dark cult rituals were emotionally intense enough that I needed a few breaks while reading, but the suspense kept pulling me back and had me turning pages late into the night. Its haunting atmosphere and relentless tension made it an unforgettable read.
Profile Image for E. Lawrence.
Author 8 books4 followers
November 1, 2026
A widow running from an abuser walks her daughter into a free private “clinic” with blacked-out windows and almost no doors, and Kingrea never lets you out of her head. That is the book’s real achievement. The horror isn’t what happens in the house, which you figure out early. It’s watching a reasonable woman notice something wrong and talk herself back out of it, again and again, while the place is built to keep her mind fogged. The rulebook, the homemade scripture, the “moment of decision”: the cult runs like a machine, and the eye-colour detail is planted beautifully.

The dialect is heavy, a few similes land at the wrong moment, and the ending is reported more than staged. But this is one of the most honest pictures of coercive control I’ve read from an indie author this year. Check the content warnings first. Four stars.
Profile Image for Carli Harvey.
45 reviews2 followers
August 21, 2026
Wow!! This book was just WOOW!! It’s so good! I 1000% recommend this book. It brings so many emotions from thrill, to anger, to sadness to everything in between. It follows Maylin and her 4 year old daughter Margo, trying desperately to escape an abusive relationship she gets welcomed into a “shelter” (Heavens Hope) for women and men needing help finding their inner self’s/ angels self. What you think is a savings grace for Maylin and Margo soon turns to hell. With lots of horrors and thrills you find out just how desperate this mother is to get her and her daughter to safety FINALLY.

AMAZING READ!
16 reviews1 follower
October 20, 2026
I recieved a free copy of this book and I can honestly say I immediately loved it. It has an intriguing storyline right away! My one complaint as I was reading is that the chapters are super long! Totally worth the read still and there are some small markers to help break them up a bit. Overall intense and interesting storyline, I love the descriptions and word usage, the ideas all feel very new and unique to me! This story is inspired by true crime cult cases but it is a work of fiction (thank goodness). I love this book and honestly plan to refer it to others I know that will enjoy it too! It is TO good, definitely fitting for a psychological horror and thriller!
Profile Image for Leighah.
405 reviews9 followers
August 9, 2026
I wasn't sure if I was going to enjoy this one as it is not my usual genre and I don't know a great deal about cults. I actually ended up really getting into this story.
I have to admit when I started it I thought the main character was silly to fall for such a scheme. But because of how it was written by halfway through I could understand how the manipulation could wear a person down to the degree that they believe everything they are told. I also enjoyed how the legal side of things were covered at the end. Definitely worth your time.
34 reviews1 follower
November 7, 2026
This is a dark thriller that tackles heavy, intense themes. Without giving away spoilers, prospective readers should be mindful of the trigger warnings: domestic abuse, severe cult indoctrination, psychological abuse, and graphic violence. It is not for the faint of heart, but for thriller fans who like their fiction gritty and high-stakes, it delivers in spades. Only Angels Have Blue Eyes is a gripping, deeply unsettling exploration of vulnerability, manipulation, and the fierce primal instinct of a mother protecting her child. If you love dark cult-survival thrillers that make your heart race and your skin crawl, grab a copy of this one immediately just make sure you don't start it right before bed!
24 reviews1 follower
August 7, 2026
This book had me screaming at my screen with frustration, in a good way! The whole way through i was willing Maylin to see the truth but her judgement was clouded by sheer desperation after fleeing domestic violence. Maylin's endeavour to keep herself and her daughter Margo safe only ended in more horror and i was devastated for them. I actually ended up skimming pages towards the end because I just NEEEDED to know what came next.
46 reviews1 follower
October 10, 2026
This book is a powerful and thought provoking exploration of fear, manipulation, and the difficult journey toward freedom. The author handles its darker themes with intensity, creating an unsettling atmosphere that keeps readers invested in the story. Maylin’s experiences bring emotional weight to the narrative, while the challenges she faces reveal the lasting impact of control and the importance of inner strength. I enjoyed how the story encourages readers to question harmful beliefs and recognize the courage it takes to break free from oppressive situations.
26 reviews1 follower
November 9, 2026
This is a powerful thriller with a dark subject and a story that makes you think. I liked how the author built tension through the unusual teachings of the Florilegium and the growing doubts among the people living at Heaven’s Hope. Maylin’s journey from trusting the people who promised to help her to finding the strength to escape was one of the strongest parts for me. The book also does a good job showing how manipulation, fear, and control can affect people in different ways.
Profile Image for Shellyann Paape.
254 reviews8 followers
September 21, 2026
Blue Eyes

To run from one monster for another.

Same may say, she ran into the arms of an even worse monster.

She drank the kool-aid in the beginning, but she realized that it was ALL wrong. A race against time to save herself, her children. And all of the others.

If only Angels have blue eyes? What happened to everyone else?
51 reviews1 follower
October 10, 2026
This book is a gripping psychological thriller that explores the dangers of blind faith, manipulation, and the search for freedom. The author builds suspense through an unsettling atmosphere where appearances can be deceiving and trust becomes increasingly difficult. Maylin’s determination to protect her daughter adds emotional depth, making her struggles feel personal and compelling. I appreciated how the story highlights the courage needed to question authority and recognize harmful situations.
Profile Image for Brennan LaFaro.
Author 29 books218 followers
Read
July 22, 2026
Only Angels Have Blue Eyes moves at runaway-train speed, mixing familiar elements of true crime with the author’s original, and horrifying, machinations. Kingrea reminds us at every bend that the worst monster is the kind that knows how to put on a mask. Brimming with paranoia, tension, but never skimping on the empathy, this is a read that will keep you up at night.
1,413 reviews68 followers
August 6, 2026
Maylin is running from a bad situation she thinks she has found a safe place. Then she notices little things that seem odd. Maybe the place she is hiding is more dangerous than she thought. Psychology horror thriller full of emotion and heart. Can love help her escape?
Profile Image for Chelle .
41 reviews3 followers
August 15, 2026
I enjoyed this book, well written and a great story.
Profile Image for Jessica Lewis.
30 reviews1 follower
September 9, 2026
Wow! This book was absolutely amazing. The storyline was so unique to anything I’ve ever read. Definitely some trigger warnings in there but really excellent writing overall!
14 reviews2 followers
Read
September 23, 2026
Maylin and her four year old, Margo, are desperate. The duo has exhausted their time at a local shelter and are hiding from a violent, drug dealing ex-boyfriend. Their fear is all-encompassing and Maylin has no viable options or a realistic path to move forward. Seemingly answered prayers arrive in perfect time with the charismatic Seraph Nakir and his rehabilitation home, Heaven’s Hope. The residence has concerning, almost extreme rules such as no outdoor access and stringent dietary guidelines. There are unconventional therapy sessions and time with a resident’s children is doled out in small measures.

Numerous warning signs alert Maylin that Seraph Nakir may not be who he seems as the gap between promise and reality slowly widen. She begins to recognize others share her unease, adding another layer of tension and the building sense of dread. Dire in her circumstances, Maylin’s mind fractures into cognitive dissonance with Seraph Nakir’s teachings and reassurance of a stable, safe life for herself and Margo. His belief of “ascending” as angels to those that dutifully adhere to his doctrines is fanatical. A shocking event shatters her fragile illusions and strips her of denial. Heaven’s Hope is not a safe refuge and she, along with the other residents and children are in a danger far greater than she ever imagined.

The novel’s final quarter is packed with intense revelations, ratcheting tighter with every chapter. In my opinion, the stories power is in its intricate exploration of the reasons that contribute to someone’s unwitting access to a cult. Kingrea presents psychological distress and internal conflict well, illustrating Maylin’s mental health journey. At times I found myself in disbelief and admonishing the protagonist choices. The author allows you to feel the weight of the emotional despair of the characters. Knowing that the story draws from true events made it more horrific. I found myself giving thought to the characters and the storyline long after I finished the last chapter.
Profile Image for Nikki B..
1,282 reviews32 followers
August 4, 2026
This story made me so thankful I did not have blue eyes, nor am I an angel. Thank goodness for my dark brown eyes.
Maylin is escaping an abusive relationship with her daughter Margo. She's just looking for a place for them to be able to rest and heal and that's when she comes across Heaven's Hope. At first, she feels like it's to good to be true. A place to rest, food, a room, a bed, people to help care for her daughter. All she has to do is follow the rules. She's introduced to the leader, Seraph Nakir. He explains to her how only angles have blue eyes and that there is an angel within them. With his help, he will help them ascend when the time comes. The people within this "refuge" are cut off from outside contact. Maylin is limited to how much time she can spend with her daughter or even how often she can see her. She's told this is all part of preparations for ascending. She's smitten with Serpah Nakir. But when another one of the patients dies and Maylin begins to pay attention to what's really going on, the truth about what Heaven's Hope is revealed to her. She notices the children, locked away in the basement. She notices they all look deformed, gaunt, like they're starving. She notices the ways in which they are disciplined. She notices everything is a lie. But when Serpah Nakir becomes aware of her realizations, it puts not just her life, but the life of her daughter in jeopardy as well.
At first, I kept thinking... there's no way she just sat there and fell for that. There's no way she believed all the things he was saying. It can't be that easy to pull someone into a cult. But then I realized, it is. It happens everyday and most of the time, it's out of desperation. Maylin, once realizing what was happening, was such a strong character. I like to put myself in the characters shoes and envision myself as that character to fully experience a story. Don't do that here!! I was not ready for what was coming. The anxiety and panic, I felt at certain parts of the story, literally had my stomach in knots!!
This was a fantastic thriller. It was gut wrenching at moments and had my heart pounding! The horror of what was going on is something I don't think I will be able to stop thinking about for a while. I have horrible memory and usually forget a book immediately upon finishing it, so when the story can linger in my ming like this and make me not forget it, it means it was amazing! If you like, dark, heart stoping, pulse pounding, nail biting, suspenseful thrillers with cult like themes, I highly recommend you read this one!!
Profile Image for Alexandra  Bollella.
129 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 16, 2026
Thank you J. Todd Kingrea for giving me the opportunity to read the ARC copy of your book.

Omunuois, unforseeable, Twisted

Maylin and her 4 year old daughter Margo are trying to flee an abusive relationship. Maylin ex-boyfriend was charming in the beginning and evolved into a controlling and aggressive monster. Maylin wants her and Margo to have a better life, not having to constantly look over her shoulder not knowing if they're safe. In the midst of fleeing, Laylah takes in Maylin and Margo to Heavens Hope providing them a new chapter of life, safety and a roof over their head.

Heaven's Hope, has many regimented rules, treatment to re-build and being prepared to" Ascend." The other catch is everyone who lives there, has Angel names and play major role in the community gearing towards for when the world ends. Adults live upstairs and kids live in the basement, secluded from each other. Strange right? Seraph Nakir, who leads Heavens Hope, has high expectations for each of his Angels and his consequences are no joke.

"They've got to be weaned from the world, just like us."

As the weeks progress, Maylin becomes skeptical of how Heaven's Hope operates and is becoming uneasy. The unexpected death of an Angel, makes her question it all and the truth starts to show. Each Angel has their story and Maylin is sucked into the unimaginable, feeling there is no way out, starting to spiral. Will Maylin and Margo get out of this Labyrinth? As they're exiled from the outside world.

"They had come to him with hope of healing but all they found was more trauma."

This book was eye opening, shocking and uneasy. It brought a greater perspective on how mind bending and grisly cults are. The story unfolded into unexplainable fear and strain that impact all the Angels and livelyhood. The tensions rising at Heaven's Hope really brought a pivotal point on how colossal and macabre Seraph Nakir really was. This book was very well done, well paced and really painted a bigger picture of what these characters endured as if you were right there with them.

Only Angel's Have Blue Eyes will be released August 3rd!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews