Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Brady Family #2

Case Study: An Opposites Attract Romance

Rate this book
Meet the Brady family. They're brilliant, brooding and barreling into relationships whether they like it or not.

Liam Brady has no chill. He’s a guy who irons his underwear and checks people’s math for a living. When his family business hires a creative writer for a marketing project, he is not prepared to spend time with a woman who keeps candy in her pockets and always asks people uncomfortable questions.

Maddie Parker is barely holding it together. Laid off from her long-term newspaper job, she’s desperate to finance her health insurance. Insulin’s expensive, and when Maddie’s friend Nicole lands her a job writing about a group of grouchy engineers, Maddie signs on the dotted line.

While Liam shows her the ropes, Maddie pushes all his buttons. Actually, she starts to fantasize about unbuttoning Liam’s top button. Meanwhile, he can’t stop thinking about her red lips...even if she gets cracker crumbs in his car. A summer storm finally washes away their resistance to one another, but their night of passion has unexpected consequences.

Can Liam learn the difference between overbearing and caring? Can Maddie overcome her own fears about her diabetes to see herself through Liam’s eyes?

238 pages, Paperback

Published June 27, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Lainey Davis

86 books418 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
180 (31%)
4 stars
224 (38%)
3 stars
141 (24%)
2 stars
28 (4%)
1 star
2 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
Profile Image for Lynn_G.
1,238 reviews28 followers
January 4, 2024
Not my favorite of the series. Maddie was OTT exasperating, particularly after Liam freaked out on her - although he did so following a pretty disgusting incident for which he’d obvi not been prepared, nor could he have been. Also, despite him immediately apologizing and attempting to remedy the situation, Maddie dug her heels in and froze him out for weeks. She also refused to cut him any slack when he reacted in a very Liam way to additional news/incidents, and therein lies my greatest issue with Maddie: she’s supposedly a talented writer and insightful interviewer but she’s wicked slow to the party in putting together the puzzle that is Liam’s approach to life.
Finally, I didn’t really feel the connection between them from the start. And for fuck’s sake, the Major Plot Point Which Shall Not Be Named Because Here Be Spoilers - it’s the “surprise” trope I hate a lot - it was better handled in Orla’s book, but just barely!
Shaky starts are NOT made better in RL by the addition of… ugh. Can’t give it away here.
I’m glad I read these books out of order, or I would’ve given up on the series entirely. Kellen’s book & Mick’s story were the first I’d read and they are light years ahead of this one both in terms of style and substance.
Profile Image for Rellim.
1,676 reviews45 followers
March 8, 2023
3/7/2023: Davis has a Kickstarter featuring the Brady series (books, audiobooks, book swag & more)

3/4/2023: Note: Books 1-3 have been combined into a box set.

This is book 2 in the Brady Family series by Lainey Davis. While you can enjoy this on its own, I think it’s best enjoyed after book 1, Foundation. (This series is a spin-off from Davis’ Stag Brothers series & I also think it would be nice, but not necessary, to have listened to Fragile Illusion as well.)

I absolutely loved this book. I know much of it is that I’m married to a Type 1 diabetic and I could relate to both Maddie and Liam. This book so accurately captured what it’s like to be diagnosed young, how that impacts the way you relate to your family, how & when you share your diabetes with others, pump & CGM details… and what it’s like to be the partner to a diabetic.

Maddie is best friends with Liam’s brother’s girlfriend. When Maddie works on a short term project at Beltane Engineering, Liam is assigned to help her with meeting their clients. Sparks fly and it’s not long that these two give in. Unfortunately Liam’s fastidiousness and inquisitive nature combined with poor word choices collide with Maddie’s need to be in control of her own life.

There’s some bumps in the road and a big surprise as these two learn to communicate effectively. While I don’t normally like dragged out angst/arguments between the MCs – it worked well for me here. This relationship was very new when “the big thing” happened and they needed time and progress so I could feel their HEA.

There’s also lots of laughs, great sex scenes both steamy and including the very real annoyance of a blood sugar crash, and fun interaction with all the secondary characters. I loved the epilogue and can’t wait for Kellen’s story, Inspection.

Narration:
I love Tom Taylorson & Carly Robins and I love them paired together even more. Their styles really compliment each other. They’re both great at all the emotions that Davis’s writing throws at them. It was the perfect listen.
Profile Image for Nikki.
75 reviews
July 1, 2024
4⭐️ (Audiobook)
Some parts were dragged out and the communication was off but I still thought it was pretty cute and liked most of it.
Profile Image for Gen Tuffy.
8 reviews
May 26, 2025
Not my favorite book of this series but it was moreso because of the characters not being enjoyable to me. And as someone well versed in type one diabetes, this book was the most accurately written (that I’ve read so far) with a T1D main character. However, there were still some inaccuracies but very minor. Thanks for the T1D representation. Another thing I have noticed about literally all of the Lainey Davis books I have read so far, is the fact that the female characters almost all have strained relationships with their parents? There are some traits in these characters that just make be believe that the author is projecting and doing a self insert into each of her FMCs.
238 reviews14 followers
November 1, 2022
I loved reading Suspension by Lainey Davis, an extremely short book/novella about an accidental pregnancy. Hero Liam Brady an engineer with control issues meets the heroine Maddie Parker, a type 1 diabetic with control issues of her own when h is contracted to write a book about the Brady family's engineering company. Much compromising happens before these two opposites reach their HEA.
14 reviews
August 18, 2020
Ok, this one i was looking foward to dive in, the blurb was promising and for a few chapters it really held it all together, until the character devel started to get alarmingly, underwhelmingly non existent, mosty from the hero.
I get that he was new to all this dating/relationship thing, but all of his arguments with the h ended up in him being a jerk to her, and to be honest she was the most vulnerable part here (not only dealing with her health issues, but also carrying a pregnancy with al the scary alternatives it implies for her and the baby, not having a home, being unemployed), and on top of that she has to deal with his bullshit.
But what really shut down his character develop for me is that he NEVER EVER WORKED HIS SHIT OUT, NEVER ONCE HE LOOKED FOR SOLUTIONS, NEVER, HE JUST TALKED TO OTHERS AND EXPECTED OTHER PEOPLE TO COME UP WITH THE ANSWER TO HIS ISSUE. He calls the h a "freak", he does nothing and eventually talks to his siblings who tell the what to do to fix things. They fight over her meal consumption and he makes petty remarks at her (A PREGNANT LADY STUGGLING WITH HER ILLNES) and literally gives up at having a relationship with her, even thinks of how to settle the child support and it isnt until he gets a RANDOM CALL FROM A COLLEAGUE saying she is a good person and struggles with a lot that he actually thinks in fixing their shit. HOW LAME IS THAT????? He literally ALWAYS waits for others to give him solutions to a relationship he never even thinks of repairing, is this how he'll act every time there's an issue between them? We all have shit to deal with internally, but she was the one with the desease and the growing human being inside, and i honestly think she deserved much better than this mock of a partner.

In the other hand, i found her flawed and insecure but real, the writing was pretty good and engaging, hence the 3 stars, but the way the story moved foward with the H made me pull my hair more than once.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Lainey Davis.
Author 86 books418 followers
Want to Read
May 26, 2023
Readers are saying the Brady family series is "like This is Us...but they do it!"

Fall in love with the Brady fam today.

Also available via audio, narrated by Tom Taylorson and Carly Robins

Direct from me: https://payhip.com/b/IsTbS
Hoopla: https://www.hoopladigital.com/title/1...
Kobo/Kobo Plus: https://www.kobo.com/us/en/audiobook/...
Apple: https://books.apple.com/us/audiobook/...
B&N: https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/susp...
Chirp: https://www.chirpbooks.com/audiobooks...
Google Play: https://play.google.com/store/audiobo...
Audible: https://www.audible.com/pd/Suspension...
119 reviews
August 16, 2020
Solid romance

This was an incredibly interesting romance for me. I wanted an unplanned pregnancy romance and this was definitely above what I was expecting. (SPOILERS)

Maddie is diabetic and is hired by Liam's company to write up the company history. Liam is an engineer in his father's company- generally up tight and has difficulty expressing emotions. Liam is captivated by Maddie and their attraction heats up as they work together. At about the right spot in the story, they of course come together. Of course Liam screws up afterwards in a really big way. Then he slowly figures out how to work it out and they have a rocky start but get to a loving and happy place when the baby is born in the epilogue.
I liked the following: the author really did her homework on engineering and even tho I doubt a small firm would be involved in quite so varied of projects, it was very interesting to learn about the engineering work; also we are up close and personal to the daily struggles of a type one diabetic, and it is an incredibly instructive story into the disease (you can also see where getting a low on your own could easily lead to a diabetic coma or death); I liked that while we learned about this disease, Liam doesn't fall for her or fall more for her due to a potentially debilitating illness/injury. I liked also that Liam's big error that caused the most damage was something that I could easily see happening and hurting Maddie as much as it did, without making Liam unredeemable; also neither characters were orphans or something equally improbable but would cause emotional stinginess, in their backstory; finally the sex was good. Some good scenes with appropriate and equal foreplay but I could have had more to be honest. (I did read this over two days instead of in one sitting so I could be forgetting- it was not due to the novel, but life interference, that caused me to drag it into two days). I also really appreciate how we learned what sex would really be like w the tubes being connected to Maddie but how they work around and can still be super passionate. Sex-o-meter score 7.6/10 (based on quantity and eroticism - so a 10/10 would have higher quantity but also much more kinky sex, which wouldn't match this story).

What I wasn't crazy about - I know I'm a bad person for this, but I kinda prefer the H to do something that justifies the h not telling him about the surprise pregnancy for a few months and then he finds out. Here, she was very up front about the pregnancy immediately upon finding out. Also, the main, or at least stronger, hurt/separation climax comes right after they get together, kind of in the middle of the story. This makes sense a lot in the story, bc that would be when he could be fully exposed to her reality, I just prefer the couple to get sexually and emotionally closer first so that that climax really guts you as the reader and you get the whole gamut of emotions. Also, with any office romance, I'd love a hot office sex scene. The scenes were hot and good, but I just think in that setting or a semi public setting, it adds a frisson of ... Je ne se pas... that adds a lot of stimulation to the scene.

This was my first novel of this author and I look forward to this or future work. I can see Emma would be in the first novel in the series but I hope I get to see Zach and Nicole's story too. Thank you, Ms. Davis, for such well-researched work.
Profile Image for Slick.
1,414 reviews42 followers
March 11, 2024
Eh…this one just didn’t have enough for me; not enough character development (doing the hard work to improve), not enough chemistry, not enough communication, and not enough of a plot. Liam is anal retentive and possibly a bit OCD and even though he’s got personal issues and can afford it hasn’t seen fit to get therapy. Maddie is a type 1 diabetic and to be honest I found the way she managed her diabetes strange, but I also know people do what works for them so I’ll give that a pass. Anyway, these two started off full of heat and then for me it just became mundane. Liam feeling out of control and Maddie digging in because she doesn’t like being managed and I found none of it fun to read and honestly I didn’t really care for either character which makes it really hard to love a book. If it wasn’t for the Brady family, this book wouldn’t have gotten 3 stars; they are the ones that kept this book afloat.
Profile Image for Tally Vivarais.
Author 2 books16 followers
August 18, 2023
There's no way this is the entire book.

Okay, was this book exactly what I needed when I needed it? Yes. Is it a good book? Also actually yes but it's about 50% of a good book. WHAY too fast paced to the point where you feel like you're just reading the highlights of their lives rather than a story.

Plus, oh god those tropes. So many interesting tropes. I did also notice that she literally never forgave him for calling her a freak and I love her for that. And yes, I loved the diabetic representation in this book. As my sister is diabetic and currently pregnant, reading about someone in a similar circumstance and being absolutely bad ass about it is greatly appreciated. Honestly, I wish it was longer and I wish the MMC was more caring toward her in a way that wasn't aggressively controlling but OTHER THAN THAT.
Profile Image for Sandra.
329 reviews4 followers
August 14, 2020
This authors characters are rather unique, a little bit left of centre but it does make them interesting. This time you have Liam, a very uptight, neurotic & perhaps slightly OCD H & Maddie a rather strong willed h with some health issues. It makes for a very unusual pairing.

There's also instant attraction & slow build up of tension between them but just as things start to look good for this couple Liam says something to hurt Maddie & she gives him the cold shoulder. There is of course something that brings them together which adds to Liam's neuroses.

If you like a story that a bit different with quirky characters you'll enjoy this tale.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
944 reviews3 followers
August 13, 2020
The story line flows smoothly. Maddie and Liam meet at work and are smitten with each other, but never seem to be on the same page with their emotions and feelings. The growth of the characters throughout the book learning to compromise and deal wit their fears and quirks was well written and the reader experiences the feelings and emotional turmoil of the characters especially when they overreact or overstep their bounds. It was easy to relate to the characters and I enjoyed the book and the well deserved HEA .

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Jordan.
310 reviews8 followers
January 18, 2022
3.5 I LOVED the first 50% of this book and overall it was very fun, it also hit on a number of my favorite tropes (helloooooo boy obsessed Mr. Liam Brady). BUT by the second half the heroine got very annoying in her choices. Her reasoning made sense but I didn’t feel like her character arc ever ended up anywhere. We didn’t get to see her confront what was causing her character flaws or get to see her grow as a person and believe in herself. Which was very dissatisfying. Same went for the hero. He didn’t ever CONFRONT the baggage that was causing him to be a controlling jerk for half the story.
Profile Image for CJ.
400 reviews
March 11, 2024
I did enjoy reading this book and I was really looking forward to it after the sneak peek on Foundation (book 1), but it could have been so much more. The health condition of the FMC and chaos experienced by the couple was enlightening, but I think with a little more discussion between them this could have been so much better. I could’ve done without the forward by the author though, considering not that it was her personal view, but that it set the book off on the wrong note. I think it would’ve been best to add that at the end. It was like saying this book is going to be ok, but what you’re about to read is not what I wanted to give you, the reader.
Profile Image for Lauren.
111 reviews4 followers
July 29, 2026
💜 Case Study by Lainey Davis 💜

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 4/5

💜 Grumpy × Sunshine
💜 Opposites Attract
💜 Workplace Romance
💜 Type 1 Diabetes Representation

Case Study was a cute grumpy x sunshine, opposites attract romance. I always love seeing more Type 1 Diabetes representation in books, and I really appreciated that the author didn't shy away from the reality of living with T1D.

Liam was so sweet and was always making sure Maddie was safe and had snacks if she needed them. Those little moments were some of my favorites. I did wish there were a few more romance scenes since I felt another storyline took up a lot of the book, but I still really enjoyed it overall.

I also appreciated how the story highlighted the realities of living with Type 1 Diabetes. It was a good reminder that insulin is lifesaving medication, and no one should have to struggle to afford something they need to survive.
6,577 reviews35 followers
August 24, 2020
An enjoyable and exciting book two in the Brady Family series! The story line is engaging, emotionally deep, witty, heart-tugging, with phenomenal character growth, and is guaranteed to pull you in from the first page. The characters are real and have a number of obstacles to overcome, but you will love and root for them; the chemistry between them is off the charts. Definitely recommended!

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
185 reviews
August 15, 2020
I absolutely LOVED IT!!! It was amazing, sweet, romantic and not to mention STEAMY. I loved the characters and the plot development. The emotional portrayl was amazing!!! I loved learning about another brother from the Brady bunch and can not for the next one. Lainey Davis, well done on anothe amazing book.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Guada.
794 reviews3 followers
November 12, 2023
Unexpected pregnancy/grumpy x sunshine ish
1.5/5🌶️

Does anyone in this family know the benefits of ADD and ADHD medication?
Liam is neurotic and uptight, understandable with hiss upbringing, but he could use some professional help, Maddie could use a psychologist as well. Maddie is so set on very specific ways that is hard for her to see Liam has good intentions on what he is doing.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Mrs Moa.
600 reviews36 followers
November 28, 2023
I absolutely adore Lainey’s Brady Family Series.

Liam and Maddie’s story has:

💜grumpy sunshine
💜opposites attract
💜chronic illness rep
💜forced proximity
💜spice
💜unplanned pregnancy
💜strong FMC
💜HEA

I listened to Suspension as an audio book and can’t recommend it enough. The narrators, Carly Robins and Tom Taylorson are a perfect match for this romcom.
Profile Image for Fos.
1,444 reviews2 followers
May 18, 2025
Audiobook

Narration is Good
Liam and Maddie
She is a Type 1 DM
He seems to be On The Spectrum? A fixer type person. Nervous, tidy. A Protector Archetype? He needs to ask lots of questions because answers make him comfortable.
That Engineer type brain.
Maddie is Independent but a bit insecure about having a insulin pump on her body on a relationship but manages it very well. Her Fanny pack chic is quirky and fun.
They really work hard to overcome their own issues and each other's issues.
Both are likable characters and very well written, fully fleshed out.

I think this Author is very under-rated.

This is my favorite of the series.
7,813 reviews65 followers
August 13, 2020
I enjoyed how well these characters took on a life if there own. . The smoothness of this well developed storyline was great.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
6,341 reviews30 followers
August 14, 2020
Numbers don’t lie.

Hers what I liked:
Liam. He’s all starchy and uptight. He’s a numbers guy. Of course he’s gonna need someone (besides his brother) to bring in chaos into his life. That’s Maddie, a hot mess and then some.
Recommend.
Profile Image for Jeanne Kotsios.
2,422 reviews11 followers
August 17, 2020
This book hooked me from the get go I just couldn’t put it down I fell in love with these characters and omg what a story just a perfect read.

I received a free copy of this book via booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review
Profile Image for Deb.
7,796 reviews36 followers
August 23, 2020
A good story that had characters with issues which gave the story a realism to it. I wasn’t a fan of reading the multiple disagreements between them which were also realistic. I did like the story though.
Profile Image for Claudia, Cmarie927.
2,304 reviews48 followers
March 23, 2021
Just Wow!

This (2nd book of the series) is full of so much!

I enjoyed Madison and her ownership of her situation...a tough one for anyone.
Liam is a great character and I enjoyed his evolution.

Please read this series in order to get the most from this story.
262 reviews
June 30, 2021
Good read

Another great book from this author. Good characters and storyline that grabs you from the start and keeps you interested until the end. Looking forward to more from this series and author.
Profile Image for Gretchen.
789 reviews25 followers
September 13, 2022
Liam (Yum) and Maddie are a fun read. He is very stodgy, and Maddie is much more by the seat of her pants kind of gal. I love the supporting characters/ world that Lainey Davis has created in these books. I enjoy that the Engineering is legit.
Profile Image for Céline NARICADOU.
449 reviews23 followers
March 6, 2026
3,5/5
J'aime beaucoup les personnages, mais je trouve l'élément dramatique de séparation très simple et sans vrai enjeux. Comme pour le tome 1, c'est une petite dispute de couple, mais rien de renversant.
1,335 reviews8 followers
Read
August 19, 2020
DNF@50%
Irritating main characters
1,085 reviews11 followers
August 27, 2020
This is Maddie and Liam story

When Maddie mets Liam he knows she is the woman for him but he has along way to go to win her over
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews