NEVER HAVE I EVER meets BETTER THAN THE MOVIES in this paperback original romance full of academic rivalry, senior year shenanigans, and springtime magic.
Mira and Colin have been academic rivals for all four years of high school. So when they find out their GPAs are exactly tied, they refuse to share the valedictorian title, instead concocting an elaborate competition to determine the true head of the class.
As the whole school tunes into their increasingly desperate attempts to outdo each other, Mira and Colin realize that their rivalry might have been masking something else all along...
Smart characters = great banter: Rivals-to-lovers hits harder when they’re both whip-smart and incredibly witty!
The most wonderful time of year: Despite what you may have heard, it’s not Christmas. It’s the last few weeks of school, when the sun is out and anything is possible—even falling in love with the last person you expected.
Opposites attract: Overachieving is just about the only thing Mira and Colin have in common... or so they think.
age rating: 13+ (toxic home life) spice: none language: 1/5
a quick and easy little romance!! i feel like these are harder and harder to find nowadays, but this was truly a YA book. there were no sexual innuendos, the language usage was fairly infrequent, and the characters actually behaved like teenagers. i will note that the writing style itself was more middle grade than i’d like.
academic rivals to lovers is probably my all time favorite trope, but as cute as this book was, colin and mira’s rivalry for valedictorian just didn’t do it for me in that aspect. it might’ve worked better if we had first person pov rather than third. it’s explained that colin’s toxic home life is what pushes him to fight for the title, but then there’s mira who admits herself that she doesn’t know WHY she wants to be named valedictorian so badly. (other than to beat him).
there was one tiny moment in the last 25% that gave me the ick so so bad—i’m not sure why the author thought it’d be a good move for the sake of conflict, but it genuinely left such a bad taste in my mouth. i get that both mc’s are meant to be eighteen but…it was weird. 😭😭
despite the times i cringed—i cannot handle performance or singing scenes, i’m sorryyy—this was a cutie read overall !!
thank you to harpercollins and netgalley for inviting me to view the e-arc 🫶🏼
Thank you so much to Harper Collins Publishers and NetGalley for the opportunity to read this ARC! All thoughts and opinions are my own. 💕
Better Than You by Emma Harrison—⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🎦 Movie rating equivalent: PG (PG-13 only because of some language) 📖 Format: ARC ebook 🗓️ Release Date: Mar 30, 2027 📚 Would I reread? Yes 💭 Short reaction: A ridiculously sweet slow burn that had me kicking my feet and giggling. 😭💕 💕 Tropes ♡ Academic rivals to lovers ♡ First love ♡ First kisses ♡ Slow burn ✨You’ll probably love this if you enjoy: ♡ YA romance ♡ Academic rivals ♡ Totally clean wholesome romance ⚠️ Content ꕤ 🌶️ Spice: ★☆☆☆☆ (YA, no spice, squeaky clean) ꕤ 💋 Kisses: A few sweet kisses, no description. ꕤ 🤬 Language: Mild ꕤ LGBTQ+: None. ꕤ 😭 Emotional Damage: 1.5/5 ꕤ 🌿Cozy Vibes: 5/5
Sometimes a five-star read isn’t about a completely mind-blowing plot twist, massive character transformation, or a story that changes your entire perspective on life. Sometimes it’s simply about how much fun you had reading it and how a book made you feel.
And that is exactly what this book was for me. 💕
I had such a genuinely good time reading this. There was character development, and I thought it was done really well, but what ultimately made this a five-star read was the overall feeling. The chemistry, the slow burn, the anticipation, the little moments, and just how much I enjoyed being in this story.
Speaking of the slow burn… THE SLOW BURN IS REAL. 😭
Every time I thought we were finally going to get some kind of development, something would get in the way, and I would just sit there like, ARE YOU KIDDING ME?! 😂 It was simultaneously frustrating and SO entertaining because it kept me wanting more. The payoff was absolutely worth it, though. When things finally came together, I was kicking my feet and quietly giggling in bed because everyone else was already asleep. 🫣💕
If I had more free time, I genuinely think I could have finished this in a day or two. It’s a relatively quick and easy read, but more importantly, it’s the kind of book that makes you want to fly through it. I read it over about three to four days simply because I didn’t have as much reading time as I would have liked, but if I’d had the time, I probably would have devoured it.
I also want to mention the writing style because it took me a little while to get used to. It’s a very particular style that feels different from what I usually see in modern contemporary romance. The story is told through two POVs in third person, which isn’t necessarily what I would have expected for this type of book, but the author really made it work. Once I settled into the writing style, I actually really enjoyed it.
And the payoff? AMAZING. 🤌🏻 The ending was satisfying to me and it made me so happy while also not wanting it to end. It was exactly the kind of payoff that makes all the waiting and frustration worth it. The book had me going through all the emotions, and I loved that.
One of my favorite things about their relationship was how naturally it developed. This wasn’t love-at-first-sight, and it wasn’t a case of two people spending years absolutely hating each other before suddenly falling in love. They were academic rivals, but they were still able to be civil with each other and actually get along.
Their relationship developed gradually, and it felt surprisingly real-world and believable for a romance novel. Obviously, there are still fictional-romance moments where you have to suspend disbelief a little 😂, but their actual progression from one stage of the relationship to another felt natural rather than forced. I really appreciated that.
And I especially liked that the academic rivalry didn’t turn into an extreme enemies-to-lovers dynamic. They had their competition, but there was still a level of respect and familiarity between them, which made the eventual romantic development feel much more organic.
🌷 Content / Romance
This is where this book REALLY stood out to me.
There is absolutely no spice. And I mean actually no spice.
There were no suggestive comments, no sexual innuendo, and no scenes that made me feel like I had to brace myself for where the book was going. 🙌🏻
There is kissing, but even those moments were not descriptive. The kisses were sweet without going into unnecessary physical detail.
As someone who prefers romance that is genuinely wholesome, this was SO refreshing. Sometimes a book can technically be labeled “no spice,” but still have enough suggestive comments or innuendo that I find myself thinking, Okay… do I need to skip this? 😭 And honestly, having to constantly overlook little comments like that can get tiring.
That was not an issue here.
The romance stayed sweet, and I never felt like I had to mentally prepare myself for an unexpected suggestive scene. I could just enjoy the relationship and the story, which made the reading experience so much better for me.
There is some language throughout the book, but it isn’t particularly frequent compared to many other contemporary romances. The stronger profanity was even less common, and there was no F-word.
⚠️ Other Content
There are some family issues and an emotionally difficult, intense home environment,, primarily on the boy’s side. His parents are extremely strict and place very high expectations on him, and their lack of affection contributes to some of the difficulties he experiences throughout the story.
He does describe his parents negatively at several points because of this, and honestly, the book doesn’t really give you much of a “well, maybe they have another side to them” perspective. Their relationship with him is simply not loving.
That said, this isn’t an especially deep or heavy family-issues storyline. It’s more of an emotional element that helps explain some of his struggles and motivations.
Otherwise, I didn’t come across LGBTQ+ representation, bullying, violence, alcohol, or drug use.
And something I actually found really refreshing for a contemporary romance: there was no underage drinking or any drug mentions. In fact, there were moments where the characters explicitly chose things like juice or sparkling drinks instead of alcohol, and it was treated completely normally. There wasn’t even that “ugh, why did we get this?” attitude about it. It was just… what they were drinking. 😂
That tiny detail genuinely made me happy because it felt so refreshing to see in a contemporary setting.
💭 Final Thoughts
This was such a fun read.
It wasn’t necessarily a five-star book because it had the most complicated plot I’ve ever read or because every character experienced some enormous transformation.
It was a five-star read because I loved reading it.
I loved the characters. I loved the natural progression of their relationship. I loved the slow burn. I loved the anticipation. I loved the payoff. I loved how much it made me smile.
𐙚 And sometimes that’s more than enough to earn five stars. 𐙚
The characters in this narrative are crafted with a level of interest and realism that makes them engaging and relatable to a wide audience. They exhibit a blend of humor and emotional depth that resonates throughout the story, showcasing a diverse range of personalities and backgrounds. Most characters undergo significant development as the plot unfolds, allowing readers to witness their growth and transformation.
However, one character, in particular, stands out for her lack of depth—Mira. While she is undoubtedly interesting, dedicated, hardworking, talented, and smart, her character development feels somewhat stunted in this book. This missed opportunity leaves her character feeling less fleshed out and less connected to readers on a deeper level.
Mira's journey is marked by her desire to explore various interests, from participating in the band to engaging in academic decathlons. Her passion for music, particularly her impressive guitar playing and singing skills, is sure to resonate with band kids and music enthusiasts alike. However, despite her relatable aspirations, Mira's motivations can sometimes be perplexing. For instance, her intense desire to achieve valedictorian status raises questions, especially since she has already been accepted into her college of choice. It often appears that her ambition is driven more by external validation than by a genuine passion for learning or excellence.
Moreover, Mira's perspective tends to be quite narrow, which makes it challenging for readers to fully connect with her. In her interactions with Colin, particularly during their competitive exchanges, she labels him as selfish, stuck-up, and arrogant without pausing to consider his viewpoint or the pressures he might be facing. This lack of empathy not only hinders her character development but also diminishes the potential for a deeper understanding between her and Colin. If Mira had taken the time to reflect on her own behavior and engage more meaningfully with Colin's motivations for wanting to be valedictorian, it could have enriched her character arc and enhanced the overall narrative, especially in terms of the romantic subplot between the two.
In contrast, Colin emerges as a wonderfully multifaceted character. He embodies qualities such as intelligence, dedication, hard work, open-mindedness, and kindness, making him relatable to readers who may share similar struggles with familial and academic pressures. His ability to juggle multiple clubs and activities while maintaining good grades is nothing short of impressive, and readers might find themselves in awe of his time management skills and commitment to his passions. Colin's character adds a layer of depth to the story, as he grapples with the expectations placed upon him by his family and the school environment.
The settings throughout the book, including the school, local bakery, and diner, contribute significantly to the story's authenticity, creating a vibrant sense of community that enhances the narrative. These locations serve not only as backdrops but also as integral parts of the characters' lives, reinforcing the importance of connection and belonging. The writing style is infused with humor and emotional nuance, effectively capturing the diverse perspectives on home life, family dynamics, friendships, and the school experience.
While the plot is entertaining, realistic, and at times, emotionally charged, it does experience moments of sluggishness, where the pacing feels uneven. There is a particular plot point introduced as a source of conflict that feels somewhat disjointed and lacks significance in the overarching narrative. This element seems to serve merely as a minor obstacle between Mira and Colin rather than contributing meaningfully to their development or the story's progression.
The romance between Mira and Colin is intriguing, yet it faces challenges in terms of believability. Readers can easily perceive Colin's interest in Mira, but Mira's attraction to Colin appears to hinge primarily on physical appeal. This dynamic complicates their chemistry and makes it difficult for readers to fully invest in their relationship, despite the sweet and well-executed conclusion.
Ultimately, the book imparts valuable lessons about kindness, empathy, and understanding different perspectives. It highlights the importance of hard work and the sense of belonging that can be fostered through school clubs and community engagement. The narrative suggests that competitions can lead to unexpected connections and friendships that may not have been anticipated.
"Better Than You" by Emma Harrison is an engaging and entertaining young adult novel that offers readers—both teens and older audiences—a delightful exploration of banter, work ethics, humor, friendship, and community through the lives of Mira and Colin. The story invites readers to reflect on their own experiences and relationships, making it a worthwhile read for those looking to connect with relatable characters and situations.
Mira and Colin are high school seniors who have been battling it out for class valedictorian throughout high school. Now in spring semester with graduation right around the corner, they discover that once again, they are tied for the top honor, and they need to come up with a way to break the tie. With the help of their friends, Mira and Colin agree to a five part competition of sorts to determine who will walk away with the honor of being this year’s valedictorian. As they become immersed in the battle, they soon discover they might actually have more in common than they originally thought. Who will take the top spot, and will their tentative friendship continue to build and survive the competition?
I thought that, overall, the plot was nicely done and had some good twists, however, the characters came off a big younger than their eighteen years. Also, I felt like Mira didn’t really grow all that much as a character. The competition was meant to challenge them as people and make them a bit more well-rounded, but really it felt like the one who was continually stepping out of their comfort zone was Colin. On top of that, it felt like Colin was the much more empathetic character, and he learned to stand up for himself more by the end of the story. Whereas Mira was quickly ready to give up claim to the title towards the beginning of the book, and she never really grew much from there. Even when Mira was presented with the opportunity to show her empathy towards Colin, she makes a quick comment about it to her mom, but then the opportunity to do more with it quickly fades without her actually following through. The romance was sweet, but it felt more real and deep coming from Colin, as his affection was based on a deeper understanding of her as a person, and her affection was based more on his looks. I did have one cringe worthy moment, when Colin declared that he was eighteen, and, therefore, could do whatever he wanted, despite living with his parents. On the other hand, I did appreciate that there was no spice in this book. There were only a few kisses and even those only received a brief mention. I also really appreciated that this was the first book I’ve read in a long time that didn’t mention or involve underage drinking or drugs. In addition, the compromise solution at the end was cute.
3 Stars 12 + Mild profanity
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for providing me with an ARC. As always, all thoughts and opinions are entirely my own.
I ended up liking Better Than You quite a bit, although I wasn't completely sold at first.
The writing initially felt a little on the easy side, and the characters sometimes seemed younger than I expected for high school seniors. But the upside of that writing style is that this is a very easy, accessible read. More importantly, the story surprised me a couple of times. Just when I thought I knew exactly where things were going, the book took a turn I wasn't expecting. That's always a plus for me.
There is one thing in the book that I have to push back on as a high school librarian: the idea that underclassmen automatically defer to seniors. Nope. 😂 I work in a high school, and I can assure you that freshmen do not automatically defer to anything. Obviously, you should never generalize about an entire group of teenagers, but I'm going to make an exception for freshmen here.
Honestly, this would have been an almost perfect book for our Summer Reading program. It is accessible, has characters and situations that I think our students would enjoy, and has enough surprises to keep readers engaged.
Unfortunately, I keep running into the same problem with these books: language. There are a few minor curse words in Better Than You, which our program can accommodate. But there is one use of "GD," and that is enough to disqualify the book from our Summer Reading program.
That's a shame, because I really think our students would have enjoyed this book and might have chosen it as one of their summer reading favorites. A shame, because it would have been a great fit.
Emma Harrison is BACK!!!!! My teenaged heart is so happy!
This was a cute, old school YA Romance, where the romance kind of takes a side seat to teens being teens. It was so refreshing and sweet.
It heavily focuses on the two main characters fighting to be Valedictorian. Rather than it be up to the GPA, the guidances counselors tell them to solve it themselves. So they create a hairbrained competition with the help of their friends. It's cheesy and over the top and utterly silly, and it felt very teen.
I will admit that when Mira realized pretty early on that she wasn't sure why she wanted Valedictorian other than she *did*, I was a little turned off by her character becaussssse it had been firmly established why Colin wanted it, even if Mira didn't know yet. The downside to the dual POV, I guess.
On that note, in breaking with it's Teen Lit vibes of the early aughts (which is a compliment), it's dual POV and 3rd person, which I thought was just a really interesting choice for a book being published YA in 2027, and I'm sorry, but the publisher comping Better Than The Movies is crazy to me. Nothing about this is Lynn Painter, and I absolutely do not mean that as an insult to either author.
Better Than You by Emma Harrison was the high school romance rivalry I needed. As I read this book, I felt like I was back in high school and it brought back so many great memories.
First off, the main characters, Mira and Colin were so relatable coming from someone who also wanted to strive to be the best in her class at school. You can clearly feel how both characters want to be the best due to their personal reasons whether it be proving your self-worth or doing it because its a family expectation/tradition. Second, I truly loved how the characters were able to learn so much about themselves as they compete to prove who is the MORE worthy valedictorian. In addition, it was nice to see how their character development has changed due to realizing their flaws or what they want to achieve personally. And lastly, I do love how the story was at first striving to be the best and earn the title of valedictorian, however, along the way you could just feel the playful banter/flirting and the longing romance. Overall, I truly loved reading this academic rivalry, romance, and self-discovery journey along the way. Thank you Netgalley, Emma Harrison, and HarperCollins Children's Books for the ARC copy and this is my honest review!
What a cute YA Book! Definitely fits the fans who enjoy Never Have I ever comparison. Mira and Colin are tied for valedictorian and have to determine (on their own) who is going to win the title through a series of competitions. While had I been one of those characters, I couldn't imagine doing that, but the idea was a fresh take on a rivals to lovers.
Two characters who have always been aware of one another are slowly learning that they don't hate each other and end up spending time together and find that they enjoy each other's company. I think the author does a good job of writing the teens being teens. I felt like the characters, even their friends, really added to the story.
Aside from the one small over the top moment that I wish would've been slightly different at the end (no spoilers!), I think this was an excellent YA book.
These are the kind of YA romances that I love to read.
Thank you for Netgalley for my advanced copy. I'm happy to write this positive review.
I'm not much of a binge reader but this totally got me binging. It was so easy and fun to read and I was really invested in the storyline from the start!
The writing felt modern but in a good way, the characters were likeable, the narrative was strong, and the ending was amazing. ❤️
This was an amazing enemies to lovers and I really, really enjoyed following Colin and Mira.
It was also really funny sometimes and I was so thoroughly entertained the whole time that putting it down was sad.
Especially because I really liked the community that was built in the book. Both of their friend groups were fleshed out and not just flat characters, and the school felt real. Also, the competition aspect was SO fun!
An absolutely amazing read and has me so excited to read Falling Into You!
I'm not much of a binge reader but this totally got me binging. It was so easy and fun to read and I was really invested in the storyline from the start!
The writing felt modern but in a good way, the characters were likeable, the narrative was strong, and the ending was amazing. ❤️
This was an amazing enemies to lovers and I really, really enjoyed following Colin and Mira.
It was also really funny sometimes and I was so thoroughly entertained the whole time that putting it down was sad.
Especially because I really liked the community that was built in the book. Both of their friend groups were fleshed out and not just flat characters, and the school felt real. Also, the competition aspect was SO fun!
An absolutely amazing read and has me so excited to read Falling Into You!
This was such a cute read! I really enjoyed the academic rivals setup and watching Mira and Colin go from constantly competing with each other to slowly realizing they actually liked each other.
I think my favorite part was seeing them learn more about each other outside of school. Colin had so much pressure on him from his family, and I liked getting to see that softer side of him. Mira was also such a fun character because she had so many different interests and talents, and she kept surprising him.
It was a little predictable at times, but I honestly did not mind because it was still really enjoyable. I also appreciated that once they finally got together, there was not a big unnecessary breakup just for drama.
Overall, this was a fun, sweet academic rivals-to-lovers romance with competition, banter, cute moments, and a satisfying ending. I had a really good time reading
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you HarperCollins Teen for the early access ARC.
Overall just cute and fluffy. This dual POV from Mira and Colin follow the academic rivals to friends to lovers trope. Their group of friends along the way help boost the story and uplift the mood, so I'm glad their presence was continually included.
I wouldn't necessarily call the writing unsurprised, but even with other YA in the genre I have read romances with a little more depth. This felt low pressure with a lack of depth in the plot and character storylines. Which isn't necessarily a bad thing, sometimes you just want an easy and mindless read.
This was a quick and easy read! Colin and Mira are both great characters and easy to love. I love rivals-to-lovers, and this was no exception. It felt like I actually knew the characters. I also loved how Mira was wearing cute outfits throughout the book. I feel like a lot of authors have their characters wear the ugliest outfits.
Thank you, NetGalley, for letting me read this book early! I really enjoyed reading Better Than You.
Thank you to HarperCollins Children's Books for the ARC!
This was a cute and pleasant read, but compared to similar recent YA releases that I've read, it fell a bit short for me. The rivalry was entertaining and the side characters and all the sweet friendship moments were great, but the main romance lacked spark for me. Because I feel YA romance mostly relies so heavily on slow-burn tension, sweet moments and emotional buildup to create those "butterfly" feelings, the lack of connection between the two made it feel a little off for me. Perhaps I felt like they didn't have enough "screen time" together with just the two of them? Overall, a fun story, but a solid 3 stars for me.
I was recommended this because I enjoyed The Romance Rivalry and they weren't wrong. Not quite as mature but had the same vibes. I enjoyed the contests and battle of wits and talents. Mira and Colin are both over achievers and refused to share the title for valedictorian, but things got interesting when fighting for that title in creative ways. Grades, clubs, volunteering weren't enough. It was interesting to see how Mira responded to a challenge with the support and love of her family vs Colin who felt more pressure from his family. That is what really what pushes their choices. Colin did rub me the wrong way in a moment where Mira was being vulnerable and open but....typical boy haha He had the biggest character growth towards the end though with help from friends and I found it all so cute and sweet. Also, loved that these nerdy kids take their MC moment without being treated like "geeky losers". These kids were popular, fun, taken seriously, talented, well rounded and respected. Loved that and related to it because I was a well rounded nerd in HS that was friends with people of all circles in school 🥰