“Narrative, celebratory history at its purest” (Publishers Weekly)—the real story of how the Bill of Rights came to a vivid account of political strategy, big egos, and the partisan interests that set the terms of the ongoing contest between the federal government and the states.Those who argue that the Bill of Rights reflects the founding fathers’ “original intent” are wrong. The Bill of Rights was actually a brilliant political act executed by James Madison to preserve the Constitution, the federal government, and the latter’s authority over the states. In the skilled hands of award-winning historian Carol Berkin, the story of the founders’ fight over the Bill of Rights comes alive in a drama full of partisanship, clashing egos, and cunning manipulation. In 1789, the nation faced a great divide around a question still unanswered should broad power and authority reside in the federal government or should it reside in state governments? The Bill of Rights, from protecting religious freedom to the people’s right to bear arms, was a political ploy first and a matter of principle second. The truth of how and why Madison came to devise this plan, the debates it caused in the Congress, and its ultimate success is more engrossing than any of the myths that shroud our national beginnings. The debate over the Bill of Rights still continues through many Supreme Court decisions. By pulling back the curtain on the short-sighted and self-interested intentions of the founding fathers, Berkin reveals the anxiety many felt that the new federal government might not survive—and shows that the true “original intent” of the Bill of Rights was simply to oppose the Antifederalists who hoped to diminish the government’s powers. This book is “a highly readable American history lesson that provides a deeper understanding of the Bill of Rights, the fears that generated it, and the miracle of the amendments” (Kirkus Reviews).
The author offers her version of the purpose and historical development of the Bill of Rights [the first ten amendments to the U.S. Constitution]. She works on the premise that they were established to counter the anti-federalaist who wanted a weak central government. I feel that she should have spent more time examining the Ninth and Tenth Amendments. Short biographical sketches are included for the members of the first congress.
Carol Berkin's concise summation of the debate over the Bill of Rights is a masterful, clear discussion of the real world context, politics, and strategies of James Madison and the Federalists as they battle Anti federalists over the adoption of the Bill of Rights. Berkin's main thesis is that Madison astutely perceived states-rites' advocates real motives in opposing the Constitution and Bill of Rights -- their desire for a Second Constitutional Convention in order to rewrite the Constitution more along the lines of the earlier, ineffective Articles of Confederation. Berkin argues that the real difference between the Federalists and Anti federalists is that Federalists wanted a stronger national government, while Anti federalists wanted stronger local governance. It also contains brief and interesting biographies of both the senate members and house members of the newly formed Congress. The complicated and often contradictory positions of the various leading players in the debate are vivid. Interesting things I learned: Roger Sherman of Connecticut is the only patriot to sign the Declaration of Independence, The Constitution, and the Bill of Rights; Massachusetts, Georgia, and Connecticut did not formally ratify the Bill of Rights until 1939!; and James Madison, leading Federalist and author of the Bill of Rights, later penned the Virginia Resolutions advocating states' rights in reaction to the Sedition Acts! Fascinating read!
“The men who created the Declaration did so to justify a revolution, and the men who passed the Bill of Rights acted to secure the loyalty of citizens wary of their new federal government”. I had no idea some didn’t want the Bill of Rights and didn’t think they should waste time creating a redundant article and pick and choose why liberties are protected, including limiting other liberties. I was surprised to learn that the nations first newspaper was published in English and Cherokee. I never knew what an important role James Madison played in the creation of the Bill of the Rights. Overall a good book detailing the creation of the Bill of Rights.
Four stars for the writing and a bonus star for the importance of this book.
(small rant)
It is a rare school system in the second decade of the 21st Century that puts any significant emphasis on civics. Thus, our high school graduates know little if anything about our system of government or their privileges and responsibilities as citizens.
(rant concluded)
Given that we all can benefit from reviewing how our country was founded and what made it advisable for the newly ratified Constitution to be so quickly amended, Berkin does excellent work in describing the initial philosophical split between the Federalists and the Anti-Federalists.
She then takes us through the strategy formulated by James Madison to present a limited number of ammendments; the debate in the House and the Senate; the rejection of over 100 other amendments; and, the immediate consequences of those actions.
Berkin concludes by demonstrating why it took about three quarters of a century for The Bill of Rights to be recognized as primarily a protector of individual freedoms. She does this economically and with sufficient style to make the journey both interesting and worthwhile. This will have a permanent place on my bookshelf.
I heard Carol Berkin speak about our "Founding Fathers" at a One Day University session this September. She is a feisty, dynamic speaker so I placed a hold on one of her books. While this is a bit academic -- lots of quotes and notes in the back of the book -- it is fascinating to learn about how the Bill of Rights actually got included. In school I remember (accurately or not) being told that the Congress immediately went to work adding the amendments because the ratifying states has asked for them. RI and North Carolina didn't ratify supposedly because the rights were in the original document. In reality, once Congress got started they were mainly concerned about setting up the judiciary, figuring out how to deal with taxing and money, and how much they should get paid. The discussion on the rights, which ones to include, how to phrase them and what was their purpose became quite testy. The new congressmen, so lately divided into Anti-Federalists and Federalists, slung insults and made long verbose speeches just like we've heard about prior to the Civil War. I was pleasantly surprised to learn that Madison proposed to get the BoR included because he worried that the majority would shut out the minority. He even wanted the rights to pertain to the states. This, of course, didn't happen until the Civil War. Fascinating part of history. I didn't read the biographies of the congressmen at the end of the book.
I have an appreciation for things that can be written succinctly. This book isn't written as an opportunity for Berkin to express her historical genius. Instead, the focus is, as it should be, on the struggled to pass a Bill of Rights. You get all the information you need in a clear and concise way. I also really like the mini-biography she gave on all of the senators and house members that were serving during the passage of the Bill of Rights.
I picked this up to fill in some gaps in the James Madison biography I was reading. For someone who isn’t reading the Madison biography, this would be a great book for learning about the political maneuvering that went into the creation of our Bill of Rights. Since I’d already read most of this in the biography I had hoped to get a little more context of why each right was included, and that was mostly lacking.
A very well written, easy to read important study on how and why the Bill of Rights came about and those men who fought for and against its progress through the first Congress.
Interesting account of the first 10 amendments to the US constitution and how the battle between the Federalists and Anti-federalists developed into the formulation of the constitution and the subsequent session that added the bill of rights.
American's have a almost mystical reverence for the constitution and that is understandable, but I also hear an enormous amount of nonsense spoken about its formulation and how the founding fathers had some form of unique insight into how things were going to pan out over the next several hundred years. That clearly wasn't the case (as insightful as they undoubtedly were) and there was a high degree of expediency in putting both the original constitution and the bill of rights together. This doesn't diminish their importance or significance but it should be acknowledged.
Understanding the context makes it more significant and important in the history of the US as far as I'm concerned but also lends the lie to so many who claim that they have some inside track into what the founders were thinking. Clearly we need to look at the facts, as inconvenient as they may be to ones argument.
The book is good, relatively short and covers a defined sense of time and well illustrates the state first attitude versus the establishment of a federal government. It has enough depth to be interesting but not overly detailed so that it becomes hard to follow. As a Brit, I'm not schooled in this, so it was interesting for me to learn about it at this level.
A nice survey of the Bill of Rights and how it came into existence, my one quibble with this book would be that some sections got into too much legislative detail while other sections felt too much like summaries.
Overall, though, this volume is worth a read. Some of the arguments seem remarkably similar to those that continue today, but I was impressed by how, with rare exception, those early American politicians seemed dedicated to working together for the good of the country (and not just for their own personal benefit). Perhaps that’s simply Dr. Berkin’s view of the time period, but it gave me a deeper appreciation for how the United States managed to find its footing.
The book also includes an appendix featuring brief biographies of all of the senators and congressmen of the First Congress. It’s a lot of information and details but worth a read.
Finally, it might be worth sending a copy of this book to the current Congress to remind them of what their job is supposed to be. I finished this book feeling a bit depressed that our current Congress seems less able to govern or even understand what that entails compared to men two hundred years before. Recommended.
A thorough account of the formation of the Bill of Rights in the late 1780's and early 1790's.
James Madison, the future president, was the key driving force behind the Bill of Rights. When he first proposed it many of the country's leaders thought the idea was premature what with the constitution only just finished. But Madison kept at it, taking several years to bring it to fruition.
I had always believed the the founding fathers of our country while engaged in serious debate about one aspect or another of the constitution or of the proposed Bill of Rights had mostly avoided the rancorous arguing that we experience today in the 21st century. But this book dispelled that mistaken belief of mine. Author Berkin delves into every debate, opinion and the mindset of the members of our first congress revealing how they were just as contentious as we observe our elected leaders to be today. That was a real eye opener for me.
Worth reading for those interested in our Bill of Rights and the early years of the US Congress.
Berkin tells the legislative history behind the passage of the Bill of Rights in a way that mirrors the polarization of America's contemporary political atmosphere. The historical characters and personas come to life in this narrative. James Madison is portrayed as a clever and calculating strategist who pushed for a federal bill of rights as a way to split the leadership of the Antifederalists and secure a moderate version of nationalism.
This is good read for those who are interested in the early functions of Congress or the secrets behind the treasures Bill of Rights.
Berkin for the masses. I enjoyed reading this book. I really love the concept of focusing on an event that is often glossed over - the addition of the Bill of Rights to the Constitution. She did a great job of highlighting all of Madison's contributions, as well as those of his contemporaries, such as Elbridge Gerry. I was interested to read why and how Madison fathered the Bill of Rights. Learned a lot!
"We see the men who began our national history not as bronze statues in our parks and surely not as visionaries confidently shaping the world for generations yet to com, but as imperfect actors in an unpredictable drama." - Carole Berkin
insight into right to bear arms from founders perspective. Madison wanted it to get guns into hands of citizens (as militia) for defense of the nation. Also used Swift's tale of a tub about whalers and other ships throwing out a tub to distract a whale from attacking their ship.