Little Witch: A Dark Faster Burn MFM Paranormal Romance

by Tierney Storer

Good girls shouldn't go into the darkness.

Amber Halloway has spent years trying to ignore its call.

But in Autumn's Hollow, the darkness has always known her name.

The Whispering Pines still sing to her. Nightmares bleed into waking life. And waiting at the heart of it all are the demon twins who were never meant to become her stepbrothers a couple of years ago.

One never left town, standing watch over the old Halloway house and the deadly secrets buried beneath it. The other vanished without a trace, only to return with hell in his eyes and desires as dangerous as the magic coursing through his veins.

Together, they're temptation wrapped in sin—and Amber has never been good at walking away.

When her dormant magic awakens, an ancient evil rises with it, determined to claim the power hidden in her blood. Hunted by monsters, haunted by prophecy, and torn between two demons who would burn the world to keep her, Amber must decide just how far into the darkness she's willing to fall.

Because in Autumn's Hollow, the darkness doesn't just find you.

It never lets you leave.


Little Witch is book one in the Seasons of Sin series—a collection of interconnected dark paranormal romance standalones set in the cursed town of Autumn's Hollow, where monsters walk among humans, ancient magic lurks beneath the Whispering Pines, and every season brings new sins to uncover.

This book features a dark MFM romance between a sunsine heroine and her demon stepbrothers. Expect grumpy/sunshine, forbidden attraction, possessive demon heroes, family secrets, ancient magic, touch her and die, why choose, forced proximity, morally grey characters, and a guaranteed happily ever after.

While each book follows a different FMC and her love interest/s and can be enjoyed as a standalone with a complete ending, the mysteries of Autumn's Hollow continue throughout the series. You can read the books in any order, but publication order is recommended for the best experience.

For a full list of content warnings and additional information, please visit my website by searching Tierney Storer Author.

Genres: Paranormal

199 pages, Kindle Edition

Published August 26, 2026

Reviews

[Kassi Ward · Rating 4 out of 5]

Okay, Little Witch was a solid 4 stars for me.

First, the vibes? Absolutely there. Dark, weird, uncomfortable in the best ways and just enough “what the actual eff am I reading” to keep me interested 😂 I went into this one expecting it to be dark, obviously, but there were definitely a few moments where I was like ohhhh okay so THAT’S what we’re doing. Got it.

I really liked how messy everything felt. Nobody felt perfectly good or perfectly bad and I personally love when a book lets its characters be a little messed up without trying to constantly explain or validate them. Give me questionable decisions. Give me people I probably shouldn’t be rooting for but somehow I am anyways. I love questioning myself by the end of a good book.

The reason it didn’t hit 5 stars for me is there were a few places where I wanted MORE. More development, more time with certain parts of the story, just more of that emotional punch that makes me finish a book and stare at the wall for a little while. I enjoyed it, I was invested, but it didn’t completely consume me and apparently that is the ridiculous standard I’ve set for 5 stars 😂

But overall? Dark, twisted, entertaining and definitely worth the read. I had a good time and would absolutely recommend it to someone who likes their books a little unhinged.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Rachel · Rating 5 out of 5]

If you're looking for a peak autumnal experience with a touch of the supernatural, then you have to read Tierney Storer's Little Witch. The romance between Amber and her demonic twin best friends, Orias and Rowan, was surprisingly sweet. Orias is playful and has been by Amber's side, while broody Rowan has just strolled back into town after a few years. LW was my first stepbrother romance. Since they grew up best friends and were older when their parents married, I didn't have a problem with it. Actually, I felt for them a little because feelings were always there. Then their parents went and made it uncomfortable. Later, no one really knew how to cross that line, so they danced around it a bit before things came out in the open, but the guys always protected her in their own way.


The town of Autumn's Hollow is perpetually in autumn and has all the warm, cozy goodness that comes with that. It would be my dream place to live, except I'm pretty sure they're living on top of a hellmouth. Something sinister was lurking at the edges of the story. Haunted forest, missing people, and let's not forget the whispers. The twist totally caught me off guard, but in the best way, and the story ended well, so I was happy. Little Witch was such a cozy and quick read, and it's just in time for fall.

[Mrs C · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was a fun book especially good now that Autumn is back upon us.

Amber is our main female character in this book. She runs her family’s bakery along with her Step-brother Orias. Amber hears whispers pulling her into the woods surrounding the village.

Set in Autumn’s Hollow, dark magic is in play, trying to take Amber into its clutches, with only Orias and his recently returned twin brother Rowan to stop it.

I loved the relationship between Amber and the twins, a protective bond formed since childhood that has developed into a forever.

This isn’t the usual type of book I read with demon blood in the twins, magic, full moon, spells and witchcraft, but it was a nice change from the norm.

A why choose tale with step-sibling love. Spice but not too much to kill the story behind it. There is mention of female-female relationships and there is fighting, black magic and loss woven through the story.

If like me this isn’t what you would usually choose, give it a try, especially this Halloween.

5 stars for this fun book. Very different from books I have already read by this author but highly recommended.

[Shanaé · Rating 3 out of 5]

⭐⭐⭐ 3/5
🔥1/5

Little Witch was an okay read for me, but it ultimately didn’t leave a strong impression.

I liked that the relationships already had an established history, so the story focused more on developing those existing connections. The chemistry between the characters was there, but I personally wanted a little more depth from both the FMC and MMCs to feel fully invested in them.

The plot had some interesting ideas, but I found myself wanting more from the overall story. The pacing also felt a little uneven in places, and some of the spicy moments didn’t always feel naturally woven into the rest of the book.

Overall, this was one of those reads where I enjoyed certain elements, but I kept feeling like I needed just a little more to fully connect with the story.

Read if you enjoy:
* Paranormal Romance
* Why Choose
* Taboo Romance - Step-Siblings
* Magical Settings
* Demons & Witches.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Jamie Beth · Rating 3 out of 5]

I was excited to try a book from this author, as I've had a few on my TBR.
That being said, I'm not sure this was the right book to start with.
It feels like you got dumped into a world and just have to figure it out as you go. It's lacking world-building and feels rushed. It would have benefited from being longer, so that more details/explanation could be included. I'm not 100% sure of the dynamics between the twins and Amber. We know *why* Rowan left, but it feels like little more than an excuse. Osias doesn't really have any personality to me; he's just the one who stayed.
I know this comes off as harsh, and it's possible that I'm wanting more from a book that isn't supposed to be that much, and I apologize if that's the case.

[Heidi Lauper · Rating 4 out of 5]

I enjoyed this MFM paranormal romance.
Amber is haunted by whispers from the forest and by disappearances from her past.

She, Rowan and Orias set out to solve the mysteries of the whispered voices, what they want and what has happened to those who disappeared. The spice is hot as they give in to the temptation of each other. Thank you for the ARC booksprouts, all thoughts are my own.

[Brittany Palmer · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was a great read. It had the perfect mix of magic and spice. If you're looking for a book that has a cozy fall feel to it with magic swirling around, and spells being cast to defend the town. Then this book is perfect for you!.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.

[Nikki Clark · Rating 3 out of 5]

I got this book as ARC. I have loved some of the previous books I have read of this author’s. I didn’t like this one as much. It had a good storyline and great characters but everything kept jumping around and I feel like some things got lost.

I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.