*3.5 stars, in actuality
SPOILER-FREE REVIEW: Mooncussers is an entertaining sequal to Brown's Oddity. The pace is slow to start, but by the halfway mark things pick up dramatically. The character development is not as deep as I would have preferred, but it's still a fine follow up and continuation of Clover's story.
This time around, they're setting out to hunt and destroy the vermin who scattered across the continent following the battle at Harper's Ridge. Clover must once again face her fears and learn to trust people on the way to achieving their goal, all while staying out of the crosshairs of Senator-turned-President Auburn. When a new enemy makes itself known, it changes their path and takes them through a battle they didn't have any clue they'd be up against.
SPOILERS AHEAD **************
Mooncussers was a little bit of a letdown for me following Oddity, but it was still a fine book. I'm sure middle graders would have very few gripes with it, though. I don't have any major complaints about the writing - I think I was just missing some of the character depth from the first book. I feel like I barely know anything about Hazel for how crucial a role she plays in the story. There are so many blanks about her that we're left to imagine and fill in for ourselves. Same for Miss Yamada. Given her knowledge of Clover's mom, I expected there to be more conversations about her.
We know that Clover still feels connected to her mother because she calls out for her help in a moment of desperation. That connection, however, isn't very evident in the rest of the book.
There's a shift from a hero's journey to something very much more a team effort. Clover is still the central protagonist, but the story doesn't feel like it's hers in the way the first book did. This story seems to be more about the factions of good vs. evil in general and is less concerned with the actual development of each character.
To that end, the characters are not as well developed in Mooncussers as they were in Oddity. The first half of the book was a bit of a slog for me, to be honest, but the second half really came in and redeemed the whole. The pace picked up dramatically and I sure did end the book with a smile. If he ends up writing a third, I'd totally pick it up, and I still recommend this duology very highly!
Thank you to Edelweiss and Walker Books US for the advanced copy of this book.