What do you think?
Rate this book
House of Secrets #2
Битката на зверовете
Продължението на бестселъра на „Ню Йорк Таймс“ Къщата на тайните, наречен от Дж. К. Роулинг главоломно приключение, е пълно с още по-експлозивни обрати. След последното приключение на Брендан, Кордилия и Елинор Уокър, животът им в тайнствената къща на Кристоф значително се е подобрил. Семейството е забогатяло, а Ветрената Вещица е заточена надалеч. Но никой член на семейство Уокър няма да бъде в безопасност, докато тя не бъде открита. Когато вещицата е призована в Сан Франциско, това отпраща тримата Уокър на опасно и заплетено пътешествие през коварните книги на Денвър Кристоф. Брендан, Кордилия и Елинор пътуват от Древен Рим през Втората световна война, чак до Тибет – изпитание като никое друго преди. Ветрената Вещица и Денвър Кристоф ги дебнат на всеки ъгъл, а напрежението помежду им им играе неприятни шеги.
384 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2014
170 people are currently reading
3083 people want to read
About the author
Chris Columbus
16 books222 followersChris Joseph Columbus is an American film director, producer and screenwriter. Columbus is known for such movies as Gremlins, The Goonies, Mrs. Doubtfire, and Home Alone, the last receiving a British Comedy Award for Best Comedy Film.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 236 reviews
April 19, 2017
كم مرة شعرت أن الهروب لمغامرة بداخل رواية أمرا أجمل من واقعنا الرتيب ومتاعبه؟
لكن بالنسبة للثلاث أشقاء ووكر هذا يعتبر لعنة، فهم سجناء في عالم خيالي مزيج من 3 روايات رهيبة كابوسية
ولكن هل هذا فعلا أسوأ من الواقع؟ألم يصير الجميع هاربا بالفعل؟
هذه هي التيمة الأساسية بالجزء الثاني..هذه المرة يتلاعب بيت الأسرار بهم ليقنعهم أن العالم الخيالي هو أفضل من عالمهم الواقعي..المحطم،البائس
هذا العيب الرهيب بعالمنا.. كل منا في عالمه في هاتفه...والذي تحدثت عليه من قبل في مقالات أخترنا لك هي ما لعبت روح المؤلف الكابوسي كريستوف التي تطاردهم من خلال رواياته التي يعيشون أهوالها
فهم يعيشون في بيته بسان فرانسيسكو، لم يعلموا أن كتب مكتبته بها لعنة تحبسهم بداخل مغامراته المهولة
في الجزء الثاني تستمر المغامرات، تستمر اللعنة والتي بالرغم من انها تبدأ بشكل مختلف هذه المرة الا انها ليست بالقوة التي بدأت بها أحداث الجزء السابق
تبدأ بأن الأشقاء الثلاث يقابلهم مشاكل سواء عائلية أو في الدراسة.. وبسبب حدث ما في النادي البوهيمي بسان فرانسسكو بعودة كريستوف له
أنفسهم مرة اخري ينتقلون بمنزلهم، منزل الأسرار ، لثلاث عوالم خيالية مختلفة من روايات كريستوف الجهنمية
رواية في أجواء الرومان وصراعات المصارعين الوحشية مع وحوش رهيبة، والتي يشرف عليها امبراطور روماني سادي مجنون
وآخري في اجواء الحرب العالمية الثانية ، ولكن هنا يقوم النازيون بإستخدام جنود من الروبوت، وحشية مصفحة ضد الموت
وقصة ثالثة في اجواء التبت الجليدية القارصة، ومعبد للرهبان البوذيين يواجهه وحوشا خرافية
ليجد أصدقائنا الثلاثة ، براندون و اليانور وكورديلا ، وينضم لهم ويل مرة اخري في عوالم كابوسية سجناء بها والخروج منها صار اصعب
خاصا عندما يشعرون ان ذلك العالم الخيالي قد يكون افضل من الواقع...ولكن العالم الخيالي سيتحول لكابوسا بحق عندما تبدأ صراعات الوحوش
~~~~~~~~~~~
للأسف لم يتم استخدام جزء النادي البوهيمي بشكل جيد كما كان متوقعا ان يكون اكبر، فهو بالجزء الاول شعرت أنه سيربط الأحداث التاريخية بالفانتازيا بالأخص تم البناء لفكرة هامة به منذ الجزء الأول -ربما ايضا توقعت ان يكون هناك دورا للماسونية ربما ولكن يبدو أنها تم تأجيلها ربما من المؤلفان لكتاب قادم لا نعلم مصيره بعد-
التطور في الشخصيات كان ممتازا واكثر واقعية ونضجا ، وأن كان غريب بالنسبة للتغير في حياة والدهم.. أيضا من الأسئلة المفتوحة حتي الجزء القادم
أعجبني جدا بالربع الأول الشعور بروح وحياة الأخوات، المشاكل اليومية التي تواجههم في البيت او المدرسة، الأثارة لشراء طلب من عن طريق الأنترنت ، سخرية زملاء المدرسة من أمور تافهة ، وغيرها الكثير
وبالرغم من أن الأنتقال للعوالم الثلاثة لم يكن جديدا ولكن الأحداث به هي التي كانت جديدة ومختلفة عن الجزء الأول
عالم الرومان وحلبات الصراع الوحشي
عالم الحرب العالمية الثانية -بعد الحرب العالمية الأولي بالجزء الأول- والنازيين الآليين
ثم عالم التبت ووحوش الجليد والرهبان البوذيين
وظل التشويق والاثارة بها ممتدا حتي النهاية.. فكما قالت جي كي رولينج عن الجزء الاول انه كالارجوحة الافعوانية ترفعك وتهبط بك بسرعة في احداث متلاحقة لاهثة مثيرة
ستظل هكذا حتي النهاية، وهل سيخرج عائلة ووكر من تلك العوالم الكابوسية أم لا، وهل ستنتهي تلك اللعنة اخيرا؟
لعنة بيت الأسرار
~~~~~~~~~
حسنا لكل رواية قيمة ما
وأعتقد أنك ستدرك مغزاها بالنهاية
حتي وأن كانت كنهايات الأفلام الهوليوودية التقليدية ,ألا أنك ستخرج من أحداث الرواية بشعور جيد
ان تقبل الواقع بتحدياته
وتواجه تلك التحديات ، اعتبرها وحوشك وواجهها واهزمها ولا تهرب منها
ايا كانت تلك الوحوش
جليدية، مفترسة، آلية، امبراطور او قائد عسكري فاسد مستبد
كلها تحديات
ولكن لا مانع من أضافة بعض السحر والخيال من حين لأخر
كانت أخر قراءة ب2014 لأبطال عشقت مغامراتهم من اخر قراءة معهم في العام الماضي
وسأفتقد سحر مغامراتهم لحين معرفة هل سيصدر جزء جديد من بيت الأسرار أم لا
Dedicated to Ned Vizzini 1981 - 2013
محمد العربي
من 18 ديسمبر 2014
إلي 25 ديسمبر 2014
--------------
ومن سحر الخيال , للعمل بنصيحة الرواية وقراءة التاريخ والواقع وعدم الهروب منه
إلي رحلة لا أعلم بعد عقباها إلي الحرب العالمية الأولي
بدون وحوش
وأن كنت أري أن بعض البشر وقتها كانوا وحوشا بما فيه الكفاية
أولي قراءتي التاريخية وكين فوليت ..ًصراع العمالقة
لكن بالنسبة للثلاث أشقاء ووكر هذا يعتبر لعنة، فهم سجناء في عالم خيالي مزيج من 3 روايات رهيبة كابوسية
ولكن هل هذا فعلا أسوأ من الواقع؟ألم يصير الجميع هاربا بالفعل؟
هذه هي التيمة الأساسية بالجزء الثاني..هذه المرة يتلاعب بيت الأسرار بهم ليقنعهم أن العالم الخيالي هو أفضل من عالمهم الواقعي..المحطم،البائس
"ما الذي تتحدث عنه؟"
قالتها كورديلا التي شعرت فجأه أنها تدافع عن حياتها بأكملها
"سان فرانسيسكو مبهرة"
"حقا؟ حيث كل الناس دائما يحدقون في تليفوناتهم، ويضغطون بأصابعهم؟ أنا أراهم من نوافذ المقاهي..ينقرون بأصابعهم كأنهم مصابين بمرض ما"
"أنت تبالغ بشدــ"
"وماذا عن هذه الأماكن التي تسمونها مركز اللياقة؟ كل هؤلاء الناس مرتبطون بأجهزة,يجرون في أماكنهم كفأر تجارب؟ ما المغزي؟"
"ليبقوا في لياقة وشكل مناسب"
"إذن لم لا يجتمع بعض الاصدقاء لدورة كرة قدم؟ النقطة هنا هي أن الناس في عالمك يفضلون البقاء وحدهم عن البقاء مع شخص أخر. ولكن هناـ"
نزل ويل بالطائرة ورفعها مرة اخري ,فأطلقت كورديلا صرخة رعب
"ـ"هنا نحن في مغامرة
هذا العيب الرهيب بعالمنا.. كل منا في عالمه في هاتفه...والذي تحدثت عليه من قبل في مقالات أخترنا لك هي ما لعبت روح المؤلف الكابوسي كريستوف التي تطاردهم من خلال رواياته التي يعيشون أهوالها
فهم يعيشون في بيته بسان فرانسيسكو، لم يعلموا أن كتب مكتبته بها لعنة تحبسهم بداخل مغامراته المهولة
في الجزء الثاني تستمر المغامرات، تستمر اللعنة والتي بالرغم من انها تبدأ بشكل مختلف هذه المرة الا انها ليست بالقوة التي بدأت بها أحداث الجزء السابق
تبدأ بأن الأشقاء الثلاث يقابلهم مشاكل سواء عائلية أو في الدراسة.. وبسبب حدث ما في النادي البوهيمي بسان فرانسسكو بعودة كريستوف له
أنفسهم مرة اخري ينتقلون بمنزلهم، منزل الأسرار ، لثلاث عوالم خيالية مختلفة من روايات كريستوف الجهنمية
رواية في أجواء الرومان وصراعات المصارعين الوحشية مع وحوش رهيبة، والتي يشرف عليها امبراطور روماني سادي مجنون
وآخري في اجواء الحرب العالمية الثانية ، ولكن هنا يقوم النازيون بإستخدام جنود من الروبوت، وحشية مصفحة ضد الموت
وقصة ثالثة في اجواء التبت الجليدية القارصة، ومعبد للرهبان البوذيين يواجهه وحوشا خرافية
ليجد أصدقائنا الثلاثة ، براندون و اليانور وكورديلا ، وينضم لهم ويل مرة اخري في عوالم كابوسية سجناء بها والخروج منها صار اصعب
خاصا عندما يشعرون ان ذلك العالم الخيالي قد يكون افضل من الواقع...ولكن العالم الخيالي سيتحول لكابوسا بحق عندما تبدأ صراعات الوحوش
~~~~~~~~~~~
للأسف لم يتم استخدام جزء النادي البوهيمي بشكل جيد كما كان متوقعا ان يكون اكبر، فهو بالجزء الاول شعرت أنه سيربط الأحداث التاريخية بالفانتازيا بالأخص تم البناء لفكرة هامة به منذ الجزء الأول -ربما ايضا توقعت ان يكون هناك دورا للماسونية ربما ولكن يبدو أنها تم تأجيلها ربما من المؤلفان لكتاب قادم لا نعلم مصيره بعد-
التطور في الشخصيات كان ممتازا واكثر واقعية ونضجا ، وأن كان غريب بالنسبة للتغير في حياة والدهم.. أيضا من الأسئلة المفتوحة حتي الجزء القادم
أعجبني جدا بالربع الأول الشعور بروح وحياة الأخوات، المشاكل اليومية التي تواجههم في البيت او المدرسة، الأثارة لشراء طلب من عن طريق الأنترنت ، سخرية زملاء المدرسة من أمور تافهة ، وغيرها الكثير
وبالرغم من أن الأنتقال للعوالم الثلاثة لم يكن جديدا ولكن الأحداث به هي التي كانت جديدة ومختلفة عن الجزء الأول
عالم الرومان وحلبات الصراع الوحشي
عالم الحرب العالمية الثانية -بعد الحرب العالمية الأولي بالجزء الأول- والنازيين الآليين
ثم عالم التبت ووحوش الجليد والرهبان البوذيين
وظل التشويق والاثارة بها ممتدا حتي النهاية.. فكما قالت جي كي رولينج عن الجزء الاول انه كالارجوحة الافعوانية ترفعك وتهبط بك بسرعة في احداث متلاحقة لاهثة مثيرة
ستظل هكذا حتي النهاية، وهل سيخرج عائلة ووكر من تلك العوالم الكابوسية أم لا، وهل ستنتهي تلك اللعنة اخيرا؟
لعنة بيت الأسرار
~~~~~~~~~
حسنا لكل رواية قيمة ما
وأعتقد أنك ستدرك مغزاها بالنهاية
حتي وأن كانت كنهايات الأفلام الهوليوودية التقليدية ,ألا أنك ستخرج من أحداث الرواية بشعور جيد
ان تقبل الواقع بتحدياته
وتواجه تلك التحديات ، اعتبرها وحوشك وواجهها واهزمها ولا تهرب منها
ايا كانت تلك الوحوش
جليدية، مفترسة، آلية، امبراطور او قائد عسكري فاسد مستبد
كلها تحديات
ولكن لا مانع من أضافة بعض السحر والخيال من حين لأخر
كانت أخر قراءة ب2014 لأبطال عشقت مغامراتهم من اخر قراءة معهم في العام الماضي
وسأفتقد سحر مغامراتهم لحين معرفة هل سيصدر جزء جديد من بيت الأسرار أم لا
Dedicated to Ned Vizzini 1981 - 2013
محمد العربي
من 18 ديسمبر 2014
إلي 25 ديسمبر 2014
--------------
ومن سحر الخيال , للعمل بنصيحة الرواية وقراءة التاريخ والواقع وعدم الهروب منه
إلي رحلة لا أعلم بعد عقباها إلي الحرب العالمية الأولي
بدون وحوش
وأن كنت أري أن بعض البشر وقتها كانوا وحوشا بما فيه الكفاية
أولي قراءتي التاريخية وكين فوليت ..ًصراع العمالقة
January 12, 2025
I have read quite a few children's and young adult novels that seem to have as their main purpose landing a fat movie contract. This is the first that has the feel of being a novelization of a cartoon. Some of the action sequences are so stylized it is difficult to visualize them even making it to CGI: the Nazi cyborgs being detonated into mangled wrecks of dismembered mechanical parts; the explosive capabilities of semi-digested Buddhist monks in the stomachs of giant yeti-like frost beasts; or young Brendan's improbable confrontation with two hungry Roman lions. They are only the star turns. There are many other episodes, and they turn the action from exciting battles into Tom and Jerry chases and scraps.
It is a pity, since the relationships between Cordelia, Eleanor and Brendan are quite lively and well drawn, if a little over sentimental at times, and there is a dose of reality with their father's gambling compulsion, following the family's newly found wealth gained during the first book in the series House of Secrets. Their mother has to fight to keep a home together with a fool for a husband. It could have all been so much better if the scope of the fantasy had been reined back from the anything goes, anything is possible, magic without rules attitude. However, that may be an end product of having to fill in 500-plus pages of plot in a story that could have been told in 300.
It is an undemanding read for kids who are reluctant to be stretched and don't mind a good smear of comedy blood and gore.
It is a pity, since the relationships between Cordelia, Eleanor and Brendan are quite lively and well drawn, if a little over sentimental at times, and there is a dose of reality with their father's gambling compulsion, following the family's newly found wealth gained during the first book in the series House of Secrets. Their mother has to fight to keep a home together with a fool for a husband. It could have all been so much better if the scope of the fantasy had been reined back from the anything goes, anything is possible, magic without rules attitude. However, that may be an end product of having to fill in 500-plus pages of plot in a story that could have been told in 300.
It is an undemanding read for kids who are reluctant to be stretched and don't mind a good smear of comedy blood and gore.
April 28, 2021
It was amazing! I loved the plot and it is one of my favourite books.
February 19, 2014
I loved the book. So much emotion and thrilling adventure. Some books aren't as good without some loss but it is fabulous.
March 14, 2014
Firstly and as usual I received this book for free in exchange for a review. Despite that kind consideration I give my scrupulously honest opinions below.
To begin, this is a children's book so I judge by different criteria than I would an adult novel. The first point of judgment, and one that has been known to blow a book out of the water by itself, is the presence of inappropriate content for children. I have absolutely no tolerance for sex, drugs and other such topics in kid's books. This book is safe on that account though it does have quite a bit of violence. It's nothing profoundly graphic but it will get young readers attention and might arouse a question or two.
The second criterion is basically an answer to the question of whether the reader will learn anything or gain anything positive from the book. In this case, the book scores pretty highly. This is a rather broad romp through history and the author isn't afraid to throw out solid historical terms from Roman times through the P-51 mustang. These factoids are woven very skillfully through the narrative in such a way that the little ones might not actually be aware they're learning much of anything. So in this case the book is likely to cause more than a few questions and Wikipedia searches. I'm forty years old and I ended up doing some searches of my own throughout the course of the book so kids will get plenty of new tidbits.
Lastly, I ponder whether kids will enjoy the book. Here's where I think the book may have problems. It is a wild and unpredictable ride to be sure but at times it's just utterly preposterous and openly defiant of logic. In general I'm OK with some of that, especially for a book aimed at very young children, but the reading level of this feels like it's more in the 10-13 range and that's the age where children start to question plausibility, when those exclamations of "cool!" started turning into "what?!" instead. To put is simply, I think the kids who can read it won't buy into it and the kids who are young enough to buy into it can't read it.
In summary, this is a solid "maybe" in my book. It's great on many points but the last third of the book just wobbles too violently and I think readers will get lost in it. You'll need to be the judge of just how much your kids will tolerate wacky madcap zaniness in their magical adventure novels and make your decision from there.
To begin, this is a children's book so I judge by different criteria than I would an adult novel. The first point of judgment, and one that has been known to blow a book out of the water by itself, is the presence of inappropriate content for children. I have absolutely no tolerance for sex, drugs and other such topics in kid's books. This book is safe on that account though it does have quite a bit of violence. It's nothing profoundly graphic but it will get young readers attention and might arouse a question or two.
The second criterion is basically an answer to the question of whether the reader will learn anything or gain anything positive from the book. In this case, the book scores pretty highly. This is a rather broad romp through history and the author isn't afraid to throw out solid historical terms from Roman times through the P-51 mustang. These factoids are woven very skillfully through the narrative in such a way that the little ones might not actually be aware they're learning much of anything. So in this case the book is likely to cause more than a few questions and Wikipedia searches. I'm forty years old and I ended up doing some searches of my own throughout the course of the book so kids will get plenty of new tidbits.
Lastly, I ponder whether kids will enjoy the book. Here's where I think the book may have problems. It is a wild and unpredictable ride to be sure but at times it's just utterly preposterous and openly defiant of logic. In general I'm OK with some of that, especially for a book aimed at very young children, but the reading level of this feels like it's more in the 10-13 range and that's the age where children start to question plausibility, when those exclamations of "cool!" started turning into "what?!" instead. To put is simply, I think the kids who can read it won't buy into it and the kids who are young enough to buy into it can't read it.
In summary, this is a solid "maybe" in my book. It's great on many points but the last third of the book just wobbles too violently and I think readers will get lost in it. You'll need to be the judge of just how much your kids will tolerate wacky madcap zaniness in their magical adventure novels and make your decision from there.
May 19, 2017
If you've been following my reviews for a few years, you know that I absolutely hated the first House of Secrets book. There were very few redeeming qualities in it. At first, I was very iffy about whether I wanted to continue the series or not. When I got a chance to read the second book on Edelweiss, I figured that I didn't have much else to read, so I would give it a try. I'm so glad I did.
Battle of the Beasts was a welcome change from the first House of Secrets book. The character's seemed like they had a lot of character development that the reader didn't get to see between the first and second books. They were more mature, which made reading the book a lot more enjoyable. I didn't want to pull my hair out at some of the things that they did. I also loved that the author brought back some of the minor characters. I wasn't expecting that at all, and it was a pleasant surprise.
The plot was action packed. There was never a dull moment. At times, it was so tense that I wanted to jump up and down and tell at the characters that they could survive this, and that's a feeling that I've only ever gotten a few times while reading. It comes with the feeling that you know you're reading a really good book. My favorite scene was the one with the pirates. It was action packed and kept me on the edge of my seat. I had no idea what was going to happen.
Battle of the Beasts ends on a surprising cliffhanger. I was not expecting it at all. It should be interesting to see where the story goes from here. I will definitely be reading the final book in the trilogy as soon as it is released. Even though I was hesitant in the beginning, I'm so glad I continued on with this trilogy.
Battle of the Beasts was a welcome change from the first House of Secrets book. The character's seemed like they had a lot of character development that the reader didn't get to see between the first and second books. They were more mature, which made reading the book a lot more enjoyable. I didn't want to pull my hair out at some of the things that they did. I also loved that the author brought back some of the minor characters. I wasn't expecting that at all, and it was a pleasant surprise.
The plot was action packed. There was never a dull moment. At times, it was so tense that I wanted to jump up and down and tell at the characters that they could survive this, and that's a feeling that I've only ever gotten a few times while reading. It comes with the feeling that you know you're reading a really good book. My favorite scene was the one with the pirates. It was action packed and kept me on the edge of my seat. I had no idea what was going to happen.
Battle of the Beasts ends on a surprising cliffhanger. I was not expecting it at all. It should be interesting to see where the story goes from here. I will definitely be reading the final book in the trilogy as soon as it is released. Even though I was hesitant in the beginning, I'm so glad I continued on with this trilogy.
August 5, 2015
This sequel follows the crazy, fast-paced, twist-filled plot of the first book...only a little more. The Walker siblings survived being stuck in Denver Kristoff's novels once, but now they're going to have to do it again. And this time, there's more at stake then just getting home - they're going to have to try and stick together as well, which is harder than it seems.
I loved this book just as much as I loved the first. Again, it is written in an omnipotent voice that bounces between characters pretty frequently, but it at least it isn't confusing. You always know whose head you're in. And as far as the writing, as fresh and action-packed as always.
As far as the characters, they're still awesome: Brendan with his snappy wisecracks, Eleanor with her honesty and courage no matter what is happening, Cordelia with her book-knowledge and wits, and Will with his British charm, derring-do attitude, and humor. But there are also a few new characters thrown in: the monks from any part of the world who battle frost creatures, Nazi cyborgs (yes, you heard that right), a crazy Roman emperor, and Felix, the Greek gladiator who kinda ended up getting married to Cordelia (spoiler, whoops).
I read this book in little under three hours. I laughed quite a few times, was surprised at some points, and then shouted "Whaaat??? no!!!!" at several parts as well. Let's just say that I'm hoping there will be a third book soon, because there needs to be. Please. This series can't end like this!
I loved this book just as much as I loved the first. Again, it is written in an omnipotent voice that bounces between characters pretty frequently, but it at least it isn't confusing. You always know whose head you're in. And as far as the writing, as fresh and action-packed as always.
As far as the characters, they're still awesome: Brendan with his snappy wisecracks, Eleanor with her honesty and courage no matter what is happening, Cordelia with her book-knowledge and wits, and Will with his British charm, derring-do attitude, and humor. But there are also a few new characters thrown in: the monks from any part of the world who battle frost creatures, Nazi cyborgs (yes, you heard that right), a crazy Roman emperor, and Felix, the Greek gladiator who kinda ended up getting married to Cordelia (spoiler, whoops).
I read this book in little under three hours. I laughed quite a few times, was surprised at some points, and then shouted "Whaaat??? no!!!!" at several parts as well. Let's just say that I'm hoping there will be a third book soon, because there needs to be. Please. This series can't end like this!
September 25, 2016
След като вече прочетохме с голям интерес и отразихме първата книга от трилогията, идва ред и на „Къщата на тайните: Битката на зверовете”! Режисьорът и сценарист Крис Кълъмбъс в ново амплоа, този път се изявява като писател на детско фентъзи, а компания му прави неговият съавтор Нед Везини. След като в предния том от трилогията сестрите Кордилия и Елинор Уокър и брат им Брендан се оказаха хванати в капана на смъртоносното въображение на окултния писател Денвър Кристоф, сега тяхното шеметно пътешествие през света на книгите продължава с пълна пара. Прочетете ревюто на "Книжни Криле":
https://knijnikrile.wordpress.com/201...
https://knijnikrile.wordpress.com/201...
February 23, 2017
Read as part of the PopSugar Reading Challenge 2017, to fill 15) A book with a subtitle.
This series might be fun and adventurous for kids, but it's really going downhill for me. There are just way too many plot holes and coincidences for it to even be slightly believable.
The only mildly likeable character is Eleanor, and even she gets on my nerves sometimes. The relationship between Cordelia and Will is ridiculous; the whole first book she was swooning over him and he had no interest, in this book the roles are completely reversed for no apparent reason other than Will's jealousy.
Also I'm pretty sure the Nazi storyline is horrendously offensive.
I'm reading the third book, but only because I already own it.
This series might be fun and adventurous for kids, but it's really going downhill for me. There are just way too many plot holes and coincidences for it to even be slightly believable.
The only mildly likeable character is Eleanor, and even she gets on my nerves sometimes. The relationship between Cordelia and Will is ridiculous; the whole first book she was swooning over him and he had no interest, in this book the roles are completely reversed for no apparent reason other than Will's jealousy.
Also I'm pretty sure the Nazi storyline is horrendously offensive.
I'm reading the third book, but only because I already own it.
January 27, 2021
I first found this book in a second hand bookstore years ago and only recently found it on my bookshelf.
I haven't read the first book, so there were at times where I was bit lost at what was happening but conversations between the Walker kids, Wind Witch, Storm King and Will I quickly picked up the gist of it.
The target audience for this series is for younger readers and feel that they will enjoy this series for kids. Perhaps I would've enjoyed and appreciated the story more as a kid.
I haven't read the first book, so there were at times where I was bit lost at what was happening but conversations between the Walker kids, Wind Witch, Storm King and Will I quickly picked up the gist of it.
The target audience for this series is for younger readers and feel that they will enjoy this series for kids. Perhaps I would've enjoyed and appreciated the story more as a kid.
June 9, 2014
This is yet again another brilliant sequel, I loved this book it is even btter then the first one almost certainly, there is so much more to it then you realise. I would really reccomend this to anyone!!!!!!!!
July 31, 2023
Mogłaby być o połowe krótsza ale i tak bawiłam się dobrze. Czekam na kontynuacje o ile będzie.Zakończenie zmiotło mnie z planszy, bo w ogóle nie spodziewałam się że to zakończenie może iść w tą stronę.
January 16, 2019
I really liked this book although personally I think that it was not as good as the first. I still enjoyed reading it even though it was slightly less enjoyable than the first book.
December 6, 2020
A great sequel to this amazing trilogy.
February 26, 2022
Lepsze od 1 części trochr
June 16, 2020
This was definitely not the best sequel I've ever read. In fact, I actually had pretty high expectations for it, and I was let down. Overall, the storyline felt pretty unfocused to me. A lot of things happened without a clear purpose. In fact, a lot of the novel contained content that seemed to just fill space between the first book and the conclusion. I did still enjoy the characters, and I didn't hate reading the book by any means. I just never felt all that invested while reading it.
That said, the target audience for this series is younger readers, and I do think this is a great set of books for children. I think it is something I would've enjoyed more as a kid.
That said, the target audience for this series is younger readers, and I do think this is a great set of books for children. I think it is something I would've enjoyed more as a kid.
June 14, 2017
Følger NØYAKTIG samme oppskrift som forgjengeren; her er det action, og kun action, som driver handlingen framover, og ikke ett eneste kapittel vies til noe annet enn det. Voksenpersonen i meg savnet litt mer substans, litt mer karakterskildringer, men den 12-årige versjonen av meg ville elsket denne like mye som den første, da det var action som måtte til for at jeg skulle lese bøker den gang.
Greit tidsfordriv, lettlest, og langt ifra kjedelig. Jeg bare håper andre unge liker den like godt som jeg ville gjort som barn.
Greit tidsfordriv, lettlest, og langt ifra kjedelig. Jeg bare håper andre unge liker den like godt som jeg ville gjort som barn.
September 11, 2024
DNF masakra. Wszystko jest takie mdłe i bez sensu, że nie dam rady. Dialogi aż się proszą o poprawę.
December 5, 2025
Roman Empire and Third Reich crossover-nice.
March 25, 2014
Review first appeared on my blog: Book Addict 24-7
I received a copy via Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review
Battle of the Beasts is the sequel to the middle grade novel, House of Secrets, written by Chris Columbus and the late Ned Vizzini. Though I entered this book with a few doubts, I ended up liking it a lot more than its predecessor. The action was more fluid and the characters were more realistic (with a few exceptions). I also felt like the pacing was a lot better, making it a much faster read--and if you look at the print edition of this book, it's not a little book. More addicting, more exciting, and more gruesome, Battle of the Beasts serves up an awesome adventure.
One of the main issues I had with the previous installment in this series was how immature the narrating felt. I'm one of those readers that reads whatever age group of fiction that I want to, but reading House of Secrets was tough because it felt so young (despite the content). Imagine my surprise when I began reading Battle of the Beasts and seeing a much more mature narrator. I know that some time passed since the last adventure the Walker kids had, but it had only been a few weeks, so I attribute it to a better writing style. I felt like the narrating in this one was more welcoming for an older audience.
I also liked the Walkers a lot more this time around. The character growth was a lot greater in this one for the two older children, Cordelia and Bren. I love the idea of this book teaching kids how some of their selfish choices can not only affect the people around them, but also the children themselves.
The one character that was slightly disappointing was Eleanor. Other than the fact that the name Eleanor is old-fashioned and often alludes to a person full of wisdom, this character is only eight years-old. A reviewer of the first book stated that it seemed a bit unrealistic that a child with dyslexia could nearly read a full adult novel on her own, and I have to agree. In the short time between the first book and the second book, Eleanor has become a much better reader and though this is a fantastic boost of self-esteem for other children in similar situations when it comes to reading, it's also unrealistic. Plus, there were instances where she acted like a mini adult in Battle of the Beasts, but then regressed to acting like a child again. This discontinuity made Eleanor a bit intolerable at times.
If it weren’t for the gore and slightly disturbing cinematic moments, this could almost be read as a hallmark movie book adaptation. Especially when the children share their love and teach each other life lessons through mistakes and dangerous situations.
I would recommend this one to kids who are on the cusp of teenage-hood. The descriptions and situations in this installment are a lot darker than the first novel, making it a bit too old for the 9-12 age group. If you like adventure, quirky characters, and a story that doesn't revolve around romance, then you'll enjoy this one!
I received a copy via Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review
Battle of the Beasts is the sequel to the middle grade novel, House of Secrets, written by Chris Columbus and the late Ned Vizzini. Though I entered this book with a few doubts, I ended up liking it a lot more than its predecessor. The action was more fluid and the characters were more realistic (with a few exceptions). I also felt like the pacing was a lot better, making it a much faster read--and if you look at the print edition of this book, it's not a little book. More addicting, more exciting, and more gruesome, Battle of the Beasts serves up an awesome adventure.
One of the main issues I had with the previous installment in this series was how immature the narrating felt. I'm one of those readers that reads whatever age group of fiction that I want to, but reading House of Secrets was tough because it felt so young (despite the content). Imagine my surprise when I began reading Battle of the Beasts and seeing a much more mature narrator. I know that some time passed since the last adventure the Walker kids had, but it had only been a few weeks, so I attribute it to a better writing style. I felt like the narrating in this one was more welcoming for an older audience.
I also liked the Walkers a lot more this time around. The character growth was a lot greater in this one for the two older children, Cordelia and Bren. I love the idea of this book teaching kids how some of their selfish choices can not only affect the people around them, but also the children themselves.
The one character that was slightly disappointing was Eleanor. Other than the fact that the name Eleanor is old-fashioned and often alludes to a person full of wisdom, this character is only eight years-old. A reviewer of the first book stated that it seemed a bit unrealistic that a child with dyslexia could nearly read a full adult novel on her own, and I have to agree. In the short time between the first book and the second book, Eleanor has become a much better reader and though this is a fantastic boost of self-esteem for other children in similar situations when it comes to reading, it's also unrealistic. Plus, there were instances where she acted like a mini adult in Battle of the Beasts, but then regressed to acting like a child again. This discontinuity made Eleanor a bit intolerable at times.
If it weren’t for the gore and slightly disturbing cinematic moments, this could almost be read as a hallmark movie book adaptation. Especially when the children share their love and teach each other life lessons through mistakes and dangerous situations.
I would recommend this one to kids who are on the cusp of teenage-hood. The descriptions and situations in this installment are a lot darker than the first novel, making it a bit too old for the 9-12 age group. If you like adventure, quirky characters, and a story that doesn't revolve around romance, then you'll enjoy this one!
April 6, 2014
Disclaimer - I won this book before it was published!
This book was better than the first! The adventures in this book were more adventurous and seemed to mesh very well together. I'm glad at the outcome but I'm curious to see how Fat Jagger gets out of this new sticky situation he has gotten himself in - can the Walkers save him? Also I wonder if Felix and Will, will return in the 3rd book because I think Will plays a major role in the Walker life but I'm not sure if Felix should return but I'm sure he will have to because of what happened between Cordelia and him - plus we have to know what happens to him!
I also hope that the next book covers more of how this book ended. It didnt really explain what happened and why. I guess I will just have to wait!
This book was better than the first! The adventures in this book were more adventurous and seemed to mesh very well together. I'm glad at the outcome but I'm curious to see how Fat Jagger gets out of this new sticky situation he has gotten himself in - can the Walkers save him? Also I wonder if Felix and Will, will return in the 3rd book because I think Will plays a major role in the Walker life but I'm not sure if Felix should return but I'm sure he will have to because of what happened between Cordelia and him - plus we have to know what happens to him!
I also hope that the next book covers more of how this book ended. It didnt really explain what happened and why. I guess I will just have to wait!
October 9, 2014
I didn't read book one, so I was a little lost at times, but not so much as to distract from the story line. The a Walker children are running from the Wind Witch and find themselves transported to another of Denver Kristoff's books, landing in the middle of the roman Collesium. After defeating the lions by magic, the Emperor thinks Bren is the highest warrior.
Adventures also include a trip to a cold mountain top where the kids battle the frost beasts.
The adventures divide them, but in the end, they realize that family binds them together.
Adventures also include a trip to a cold mountain top where the kids battle the frost beasts.
The adventures divide them, but in the end, they realize that family binds them together.
July 20, 2015
http://trulyrudiono.blogspot.com/2015...
Bagian favorit saya:
Sebuah rak buku.
Benda itu mirip rak kayu apung yang mereka lihat di petualangan terdahulu. Rak itu benar-benar berada di bawah permukaan air kolam. Dan di setiap raknya, terlihat jelas meski berada dalam air, berjejer lusinan manuskrip.
Sebuah rak penuh buku berada di bawah air tanpa merusak buku! OK saya mau pesan satu zat atau mantera apalah yang bisa membuat koleksi saya menjadi seperti itu. Lumayan, menghemat tempat penyimpanan.
Bagian favorit saya:
Sebuah rak buku.
Benda itu mirip rak kayu apung yang mereka lihat di petualangan terdahulu. Rak itu benar-benar berada di bawah permukaan air kolam. Dan di setiap raknya, terlihat jelas meski berada dalam air, berjejer lusinan manuskrip.
Sebuah rak penuh buku berada di bawah air tanpa merusak buku! OK saya mau pesan satu zat atau mantera apalah yang bisa membuat koleksi saya menjadi seperti itu. Lumayan, menghemat tempat penyimpanan.
July 12, 2020
I'm beyond shocked to see the average review for this book. The characters have regressed since the last book. Any problem that emerges is not resolved by them but a magical solution they just happened upon. The only character I partially liked was Eleanor.
I would not recommend this book to anyone especially not young readers. There are many other stories out there for a young audience that has better lessons and a richer story.
I would not recommend this book to anyone especially not young readers. There are many other stories out there for a young audience that has better lessons and a richer story.
April 8, 2014
Most definitely part of a kids series - as the Walker family children have adventures taken from the pages of the books of a man named Denver Kristoff's library. How else could an entire house time travel and land in the Roman coliseum only to find themselves by Nazis from yet another book. A fun adventure for kids who are able to suspend all logic and just take things as they come.
October 12, 2025
Damn. This was my least favourite of the series as a kid, but now, this was a HUGE letdown!!! Sooo many things happen, but the characters are flat and don’t interact in meaningful ways. And also there were thing no a here that just. We’re not great.
This was written by white men, and it’s so painfully obvious. 🤨
This was written by white men, and it’s so painfully obvious. 🤨
May 25, 2014
Awesome!!
February 4, 2021
A bit out there. Got frustrated when too many things inhibited the books progress.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 236 reviews