What do you think?
Rate this book
War on the Basepaths: The Definitive Biography of Ty Cobb
During his twenty-four-year career, Ty Cobb was an MVP, Triple Crown-winner, twelve-time batting champion, and was elected in the inaugural ballot for the National Baseball Hall of Fame (along with Honus Wagner, Babe Ruth, Christy Mathewson, and Walter Johnson). As someone who retired from the game over eighty-five years ago, he is still the leader for career batting average, second in runs, hits, and triples, and a mainstay in dozens of other categories.However, when most people think of “The Georgia Peach,” they’re reminded of his reputation as a “dirty” player. It was said that got so many of his steals because he would sharpen his metal cleats and “spike” the second basemen if they would try to tag him out. It’s also said that he was rude, nasty, a racist, and hated by peers and the press alike.As author Tim Hornbaker did for Charles Comiskey in Turning the Black Sox White, War on the Basepaths is an unbiased biography of one of the greatest players to ever grace a baseball diamond. Based on detailed research and analysis, Tim Hornbaker offers the full story of Cobb’s life and career; some of which has been altered for almost a century. While he retired in 1928 and passed away in 1961, War on the Basepaths will show how Ty Cobb really was and place readers in the box seats of his incredible life.Skyhorse Publishing, as well as our Sports Publishing imprint, are proud to publish a broad range of books for readers interested in sports-books about baseball, pro football, college football, pro and college basketball, hockey, or soccer, we have a book about your sport or your team.Whether you are a New York Yankees fan or hail from Red Sox nation; whether you are a die-hard Green Bay Packers or Dallas Cowboys fan; whether you root for the Kentucky Wildcats, Louisville Cardinals, UCLA Bruins, or Kansas Jayhawks; whether you route for the Boston Bruins, Toronto Maple Leafs, Montreal Canadiens, or Los Angeles Kings; we have a book for you. While not every title we publish becomes a New York Times bestseller or a national bestseller, we are committed to publishing books on subjects that are sometimes overlooked by other publishers and to authors whose work might not otherwise find a home.
394 pages, Kindle Edition
First published April 7, 2015
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews
June 29, 2015
This is an outstanding biography of one of baseball's most driven players--Ty Cobb. He had demons, and these affected his play and his life. But many treatments of Cobb emphasize this element in his life and do not take a more nuanced view. This book explores his life in detail--warts and the good alike.
A key part of his life was his father. He was attached to him greatly. When his father came around to accepting (and even approving) Ty's desire to play baseball, it was a key moment for him. But when his mother (under not completely clear circumstances) killed his father, it affected him considerably. So, too, bullying that he experienced. He developed a fire to succeed.
The book provides a chronological history of his life and times. His childhood, his early years in baseball (at the outset, playing against boys older than him, and sometimes taking abuse as a result), the outset of his professional career. His minor league career soon settled into excellent play. This landed him a contract with the Detroit Tigers. His first year (only a part of a season) was not outstanding, but he showed enough to get a contract to continue. And how he continued!
The story of his baseball exploits is well told. The hitting, the fielding, and the baserunning. He studied the game closely; he also used primitive psychology to advantage, trying to get under other players' skins. With baserunning, he studies pitchers and their tendencies. He would often take what seemed like crazy chances, such as stealing home, going from first to home on a single, and so on. His stolen base tally remained # 1 until many decades later.
His hitting? With his left handed split grip, he bunted, sprayed the baseball around, and could hit with power for the era. Many RBIs. He won batting championship after batting championship. Hi was on pennant winning teams a hgandful of times, but could never experience being World Series champs.
On the human side, the book shows the ups and downs of his relationship with other players--including his own teammates. Sometimes, a number of his teammates saw him as only pursuing personal goals (batting championships). He had feuds with other teammates--as well as players on other teams. He had a reputation in some quarters as dirty, using his spikes to hurt other players as he ran the bases. One of the positive aspects of this book is the author's analysis of such charges--suggesting that most times he was simply running rh bases hard (although there were probably some times when he went across a boundary). His relations with teammates and other playes was sometimes rocky. And yet he got on well with many players.
The book describes his time as manager of Detroit--with both strengths and weaknesses outlined. It deals with his fights with fans, employees, and others. The text notes some rough encounters with African-Americans, to some extent (apparently), because of his southern views of them. Not an especially pretty picture. His relations with his family are well depicted--the ups and downs. The allegations that he and Tris Speaker were involved in betting on games. The final picture is not completely clear here.
Finally, his life in retirement. Cobb was generous in many respects, with some philanthropic enterprises that were beneficial to the larger community. He did seem to mellow in retirement, although there were outbursts and his family life remained somewhat turbulent. His entrance into baseball's Hall of Fame is a part of this post-baseball life.
All in all, a very nice biography of an enigmatic person.
A key part of his life was his father. He was attached to him greatly. When his father came around to accepting (and even approving) Ty's desire to play baseball, it was a key moment for him. But when his mother (under not completely clear circumstances) killed his father, it affected him considerably. So, too, bullying that he experienced. He developed a fire to succeed.
The book provides a chronological history of his life and times. His childhood, his early years in baseball (at the outset, playing against boys older than him, and sometimes taking abuse as a result), the outset of his professional career. His minor league career soon settled into excellent play. This landed him a contract with the Detroit Tigers. His first year (only a part of a season) was not outstanding, but he showed enough to get a contract to continue. And how he continued!
The story of his baseball exploits is well told. The hitting, the fielding, and the baserunning. He studied the game closely; he also used primitive psychology to advantage, trying to get under other players' skins. With baserunning, he studies pitchers and their tendencies. He would often take what seemed like crazy chances, such as stealing home, going from first to home on a single, and so on. His stolen base tally remained # 1 until many decades later.
His hitting? With his left handed split grip, he bunted, sprayed the baseball around, and could hit with power for the era. Many RBIs. He won batting championship after batting championship. Hi was on pennant winning teams a hgandful of times, but could never experience being World Series champs.
On the human side, the book shows the ups and downs of his relationship with other players--including his own teammates. Sometimes, a number of his teammates saw him as only pursuing personal goals (batting championships). He had feuds with other teammates--as well as players on other teams. He had a reputation in some quarters as dirty, using his spikes to hurt other players as he ran the bases. One of the positive aspects of this book is the author's analysis of such charges--suggesting that most times he was simply running rh bases hard (although there were probably some times when he went across a boundary). His relations with teammates and other playes was sometimes rocky. And yet he got on well with many players.
The book describes his time as manager of Detroit--with both strengths and weaknesses outlined. It deals with his fights with fans, employees, and others. The text notes some rough encounters with African-Americans, to some extent (apparently), because of his southern views of them. Not an especially pretty picture. His relations with his family are well depicted--the ups and downs. The allegations that he and Tris Speaker were involved in betting on games. The final picture is not completely clear here.
Finally, his life in retirement. Cobb was generous in many respects, with some philanthropic enterprises that were beneficial to the larger community. He did seem to mellow in retirement, although there were outbursts and his family life remained somewhat turbulent. His entrance into baseball's Hall of Fame is a part of this post-baseball life.
All in all, a very nice biography of an enigmatic person.
November 13, 2022
One of two “definitive biographies” recently published of Ty Cobb, this one reads a little more like a play by play book but is just as amply supported by research — something Ty Cobb’s first autobiographical ghost writer Al Stump couldn’t be bothered to do.
There are a couple of tiny typos (the one in the notes section on p. 334 reads “[replace with en dash]” which is a copy editing oversight). However this book is well written in general, and a welcome addition to a baseball fan’s library. I especially appreciated the great photos of the legend and his contemporaries, most of which I had never seen before.
There are a couple of tiny typos (the one in the notes section on p. 334 reads “[replace with en dash]” which is a copy editing oversight). However this book is well written in general, and a welcome addition to a baseball fan’s library. I especially appreciated the great photos of the legend and his contemporaries, most of which I had never seen before.
May 9, 2021
For those who fell into the routine of perpetuating what Al Stump published about Cobb in the early 1960s (even the 1994 Hollywood movie Cobb, starring Tommy Lee Jones, was based on Stump’s writings), this book is a suitable antidote. Cobb was no angel, but after years of misleading anecdotes damaging his reputation, Cobb's life deserves closer scrutiny and better evaluation.
July 11, 2024
Ty Cobb is one of the most revered and yet polarizing figures in American sports history. Undeniably one of if not the greatest hitter of all time, an early pioneer and face of Major League baseball, and one of the Immortals, the first class to ever be inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame. He was also born and raised in the south during the turn of the century, with the expected attitudes toward African-Americans combined with a reputation for a short fuse culminating in accusations of spiking and several physical altercations. In digging into this figure’s life, Tim Hornbaker works to create a balanced and nuanced view of this revered figure, understanding him through the lens of his day and time as opposed to a modern lens that can be colored by the passing of time and changing of values.
The end result is a relatively standard biography that follows a typical path of the life of Cobb, while nonetheless doing some work to counter the common conceptions of Cobb as a fighting ruffian with a racist edge. The book struggles with this somewhat, however, as it will defend Cobb against claims of violence while readily acknowledging the fights and altercations he would get into with his sharp temper. The book does a good job of dissecting the racial views of the icon, reflecting the reality of his time and his views without simplifying him with a modern eye. All in all, this is a worthwhile read following the life and career of the significant figure and icon which I will encourage fans to read. It is not perfect as it certainly treats Cobb with significant reverence, but it remains a satisfying read, especially for those with little knowledge of the man and his accomplishments.
The end result is a relatively standard biography that follows a typical path of the life of Cobb, while nonetheless doing some work to counter the common conceptions of Cobb as a fighting ruffian with a racist edge. The book struggles with this somewhat, however, as it will defend Cobb against claims of violence while readily acknowledging the fights and altercations he would get into with his sharp temper. The book does a good job of dissecting the racial views of the icon, reflecting the reality of his time and his views without simplifying him with a modern eye. All in all, this is a worthwhile read following the life and career of the significant figure and icon which I will encourage fans to read. It is not perfect as it certainly treats Cobb with significant reverence, but it remains a satisfying read, especially for those with little knowledge of the man and his accomplishments.
November 17, 2025
The “definitive” life story of one of major league baseball’s most recognized players, both for his dazzling stats on the field and his argumentative (to put it kindly) tendencies away from it. Actually, that’s not entirely true. His bad attitude was visible in both venues. The whole premise of this telling seems to be “Ty really wasn’t such a bad guy; the tabloids and agenda-obsessed editors exaggerated his misdeeds for publicity,” but I don’t buy it. Babe Ruth hated him and once he KO'd Lou Gehrig in a locker room. Two wives filed for divorce and his eldest son wanted nothing to do with him. The introduction even explores the sins of Cobb’s hand-picked ghost writer, who penned late life memoirs for the celebrity athlete, then wrote a scathing tell-all about the experience after his death. Funny how literally everyone had the same wrong opinion of this guy.
And it’s not like the author can tell his story without acknowledging the transgressions. Without well-worn stories about spiking opposing fielders, refusing to socialize with teammates and inciting fisticuffs on an almost monthly basis, there wouldn’t be much to talk about. A proud southerner, Cobb picks countless fights with black men (and women), usually for some sort of loosely defined disrespect. One victim dared to occupy a phone booth while Ty was waiting. Another cleaned his hotel room. Yet another told a nearby pedestrian that the crosswalk was closed. The book’s sheepish admission of these facts is so constant, it almost becomes a punchline. Tell me, what color was his opponent’s skin this time? Oh, really? Again? You don’t say! Repeated reminders that the star hitter grew up in the deep south, that he was raised with a dash of bigot in his blood, might have held water early in his career. By the time of his retirement, he’d been playing home games in Detroit and/or Philadelphia for nearly a quarter century. Maybe he was just an asshole. An asshole who could hit, slide and run like hell.
Turn of the century MLB was a wild place to play ball, with murky rules and varied techniques. Cobb helped change the game, not just through his passion and longevity (though these were both world-class), but by using his brain to scout and exploit his opponents’ weaknesses. Ty was an incredibly efficient batter and tremendously fast on the basepaths, but physical gifts weren’t the only tools of his trade. A pity his considerable brainpower didn’t also include any traces of humility.
And it’s not like the author can tell his story without acknowledging the transgressions. Without well-worn stories about spiking opposing fielders, refusing to socialize with teammates and inciting fisticuffs on an almost monthly basis, there wouldn’t be much to talk about. A proud southerner, Cobb picks countless fights with black men (and women), usually for some sort of loosely defined disrespect. One victim dared to occupy a phone booth while Ty was waiting. Another cleaned his hotel room. Yet another told a nearby pedestrian that the crosswalk was closed. The book’s sheepish admission of these facts is so constant, it almost becomes a punchline. Tell me, what color was his opponent’s skin this time? Oh, really? Again? You don’t say! Repeated reminders that the star hitter grew up in the deep south, that he was raised with a dash of bigot in his blood, might have held water early in his career. By the time of his retirement, he’d been playing home games in Detroit and/or Philadelphia for nearly a quarter century. Maybe he was just an asshole. An asshole who could hit, slide and run like hell.
Turn of the century MLB was a wild place to play ball, with murky rules and varied techniques. Cobb helped change the game, not just through his passion and longevity (though these were both world-class), but by using his brain to scout and exploit his opponents’ weaknesses. Ty was an incredibly efficient batter and tremendously fast on the basepaths, but physical gifts weren’t the only tools of his trade. A pity his considerable brainpower didn’t also include any traces of humility.
September 3, 2024
I really enjoyed this book, as I love reading about the early, wild and wooly days of our national sports leagues. Who knew there was so much fighting and excitement in baseball? Ty Cobb is definitely a fascinating figure in not only sports history but American history in general. Just like most people the legends don't quite tell his story and the reality is (arguably) more interesting than the legends. Having said that, the glossing over of his horrific racism and unprovoked attacks on black people (including a woman) left me with a bad taste in my mouth. For the writer to just blame the area of the country Ty Cobb grew up in for his unprovoked assaults and beatings of black people is glib at best. Plenty of white people who grew up in late 19th-early 20th century Georgia did not beat up black people just for talking to them without the deference Ty Cobb demanded for being a white man. This did not dampen my enjoyment of the book and it's main character but it does stick in my craw.
April 20, 2021
There has been so much written about Cobb. This book, like all of the others, strives to set the record straight, offering a more balanced portrait of the combustible Georgia Peach. It's a fine baseball biography that offers facts, but not a lot of insight - some, and it's valuable, but not much. A solid biography among many about Tyrus Raymond Cobb. I recommend it.
May 4, 2015
The last 15 years or so, coinciding with the meteoric rise in internet access and usage, have seen an explosion in books and other coverage of the early history of baseball. From Ken Burns's dynamic PBS miniseries to the incredible work from the folks at SABR, our knowledge of those long-gone days continues to grow every day. As a result, we have gotten fantastic, definitive biographies on many of baseball's greatest early stars - Walter Johnson, Babe Ruth, Christy Mathewson, Nap Lajoie and many others with one major exception.
Ty Cobb.
Over the last 50 years, Cobb has been the subject of two biographies and his own autobiography. Unfortunately, Ty's co-author on his autobiography (Al Stump), also the author of one of the two biographies, has been proven a fraud whose writings are highly suspect at best. The other biography, by historian Charles Alexander, is now 30 years old and suffers from factual inaccuracies and a reliance on the work of Stump. Thus we are left with a dearth of credible, in-depth coverage of Cobb.
Into that void has stepped Tim Hornbaker. Hornbaker first came to prominence as the author of a serious, scholarly tome on the history of pro
wrestling's National Wrestling Alliance. The depth and quality of his research for that title elevated pro wrestling writing to a level rarely reached in the realm of sports non-fiction. Unfortunately, while highly detailed, "National Wrestling Alliance: The Untold Story of the Monopoly That Strangled Pro Wrestling" suffered from being over-long, out of order chronologically, and a habit of using real names in places where performance names were better suited.
Thankfully, Hornbaker's newest work, "War on the Basepaths: The Definitive Biography of Ty Cobb" suffers from none of those faults. Hornbaker seeks to peel back the layers of Cobb mythology and reveal the true facts of his career and personality, a goal which he largely reaches. The Cobb of Hornbaker's telling is a nuanced, complicated man prone to wild fits of anger coupled with deep sensitivity to teasing and a difficulty in socializing at a young age. The sum is a more complete portrait of Cobb than ever seen before, one setting aside some of the fairy tales we have heard so often, while offering supporting information for other not-so-flattering stories, including seemingly dozens of fights, brawls, and near-altercations. Strong evidence is provided that Cobb was, indeed as he's been accused so many times, a racist, albeit not a hateful one a la the KKK. These revelations are balanced against tales of Cobb struggling with fitting in with his teammates who teased and hazed frequently as a young player, even sawing his bats in half.
Obviously, no biography of Ty Cobb would be complete without many, many stories of Cobb's feats on the diamond and "War on the Basepaths" certainly delivers in that respect. We are regaled with stories of Cobb scoring from first on singles, stealing home, making great catches, hitting five home runs over the course of two days, and more. These stories of Cobb are set in the larger context of early 20th century baseball, a place where many, many things are different than what we see today. A player choosing to stay in the field rather than walk past abusive fans while team bats? Players sitting in the opposing team's dugout? Fans on the field? They are all here.
For all its positives, "War on the Basepaths" is not perfect. There are a few places where an incorrect word is used ("viral" where "virile" is clearly intended, "weary" instead of "wary", "council" instead of "counsel", etc). Further, Hornbaker occasionally falls into a pattern seen in the works of so many other authors covering baseball's dead ball era - the use of dated wording reminiscent of writings of the early 20th century. For example, on occasion Hornbaker refers to Cobb as a "batsman" rather than the modern "hitter" that would be more appropriate. In addition, Hornbaker largely accepts Cobb's explanation of not seeking to injure opposing players on the basepaths (with two exceptions). This acceptance ignores a very famous photo of Cobb that features him leaping him into a catcher at home plate with what looks to be a flying kick to a very tender place for the unfortunate recipient of Cobb's "slide". There are also occasional statistical oddities (at various points in the book, Ty's career games played number is given as 3033, 3034, and 3035).
Still, these are (obviously) incredibly minor niggles in what is a fabulous work of baseball history. "War on the Basepaths" is a highly entertaining, very detailed yet eminently readable biography of the man once considered baseball's greatest-ever star (receiving more Hall of Fame votes than even Babe Ruth). Over its roughly 290 pages (supplemented by some 60 pages of footnotes), "War on the Basepaths" reaches the highest echelons of baseball biography previously reached by titles such as "The Big Bam", "Ted Williams: The Biography of an American Hero" and a handful of others.
With "War on the Basepaths", Tim Hornbaker sought to produce the definitive biography of Ty Cobb. With his voluminous research and entertaining writing, Tim Hornbaker has achieved exactly that. Well done, Mr. Hornbaker.
Ty Cobb.
Over the last 50 years, Cobb has been the subject of two biographies and his own autobiography. Unfortunately, Ty's co-author on his autobiography (Al Stump), also the author of one of the two biographies, has been proven a fraud whose writings are highly suspect at best. The other biography, by historian Charles Alexander, is now 30 years old and suffers from factual inaccuracies and a reliance on the work of Stump. Thus we are left with a dearth of credible, in-depth coverage of Cobb.
Into that void has stepped Tim Hornbaker. Hornbaker first came to prominence as the author of a serious, scholarly tome on the history of pro
wrestling's National Wrestling Alliance. The depth and quality of his research for that title elevated pro wrestling writing to a level rarely reached in the realm of sports non-fiction. Unfortunately, while highly detailed, "National Wrestling Alliance: The Untold Story of the Monopoly That Strangled Pro Wrestling" suffered from being over-long, out of order chronologically, and a habit of using real names in places where performance names were better suited.
Thankfully, Hornbaker's newest work, "War on the Basepaths: The Definitive Biography of Ty Cobb" suffers from none of those faults. Hornbaker seeks to peel back the layers of Cobb mythology and reveal the true facts of his career and personality, a goal which he largely reaches. The Cobb of Hornbaker's telling is a nuanced, complicated man prone to wild fits of anger coupled with deep sensitivity to teasing and a difficulty in socializing at a young age. The sum is a more complete portrait of Cobb than ever seen before, one setting aside some of the fairy tales we have heard so often, while offering supporting information for other not-so-flattering stories, including seemingly dozens of fights, brawls, and near-altercations. Strong evidence is provided that Cobb was, indeed as he's been accused so many times, a racist, albeit not a hateful one a la the KKK. These revelations are balanced against tales of Cobb struggling with fitting in with his teammates who teased and hazed frequently as a young player, even sawing his bats in half.
Obviously, no biography of Ty Cobb would be complete without many, many stories of Cobb's feats on the diamond and "War on the Basepaths" certainly delivers in that respect. We are regaled with stories of Cobb scoring from first on singles, stealing home, making great catches, hitting five home runs over the course of two days, and more. These stories of Cobb are set in the larger context of early 20th century baseball, a place where many, many things are different than what we see today. A player choosing to stay in the field rather than walk past abusive fans while team bats? Players sitting in the opposing team's dugout? Fans on the field? They are all here.
For all its positives, "War on the Basepaths" is not perfect. There are a few places where an incorrect word is used ("viral" where "virile" is clearly intended, "weary" instead of "wary", "council" instead of "counsel", etc). Further, Hornbaker occasionally falls into a pattern seen in the works of so many other authors covering baseball's dead ball era - the use of dated wording reminiscent of writings of the early 20th century. For example, on occasion Hornbaker refers to Cobb as a "batsman" rather than the modern "hitter" that would be more appropriate. In addition, Hornbaker largely accepts Cobb's explanation of not seeking to injure opposing players on the basepaths (with two exceptions). This acceptance ignores a very famous photo of Cobb that features him leaping him into a catcher at home plate with what looks to be a flying kick to a very tender place for the unfortunate recipient of Cobb's "slide". There are also occasional statistical oddities (at various points in the book, Ty's career games played number is given as 3033, 3034, and 3035).
Still, these are (obviously) incredibly minor niggles in what is a fabulous work of baseball history. "War on the Basepaths" is a highly entertaining, very detailed yet eminently readable biography of the man once considered baseball's greatest-ever star (receiving more Hall of Fame votes than even Babe Ruth). Over its roughly 290 pages (supplemented by some 60 pages of footnotes), "War on the Basepaths" reaches the highest echelons of baseball biography previously reached by titles such as "The Big Bam", "Ted Williams: The Biography of an American Hero" and a handful of others.
With "War on the Basepaths", Tim Hornbaker sought to produce the definitive biography of Ty Cobb. With his voluminous research and entertaining writing, Tim Hornbaker has achieved exactly that. Well done, Mr. Hornbaker.
December 9, 2022
An excellent well balanced biography of Cobb including his best and worst points. Presents a well documented picture of the baseball player who has had several false stories presented about him.
Want to Read
April 8, 2023to-read
June 2, 2024
4.5 stars
The author does an admirable job of rehabilitating Cobb's reputation.
The author does an admirable job of rehabilitating Cobb's reputation.
November 26, 2025
As a biography it is very good because Cobb was always in some dramatic shenanigans or worse. The author tires to make an excuse for Cobb's perception. I still am not convinced, he wasn't his own worst enemy. There are many quotes from Cobb who never seemed to take blame and denies his responsibility constantly. The author blames the newspaper reporters for his perception which makes sense because they did have an extreme amount of power over the public's opinions. The hecklers were also probably awful back then as well. But there were actions which cannot be defended or explained away. He seemed to never learn how to master his anger while he was still playing. In his defense, it seems for every on the field controversy, the player who should have been upset always said Cobb was not malicious. His gambling controversy is still cloudy for me. He was very lucky not to be kicked out of baseball.
June 17, 2016
Take a better look at Ty Cobb. He is more complicated than you think.
Baseball's all-time greatest hitter.
Baseball's all-time greatest hitter.
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews