A romantasy reader accidentally enters a fantasy world, only to realize that some tropes are better in fiction, in this satirical, hijinks-filled meta-romantasy.
Everything in Eve Lockwood’s life is grey—and not in a fun, morally ambiguous kind of way. No matter how much soggy takeout she orders or how many Friends re-runs she binges, the only place she can truly escape is between the pages of her beloved romantasy novels. So, when an advertisement for a romantasy-lovers retreat crosses her path, Eve jumps at the chance to immerse herself in her favorite genre—until she unknowingly stumbles through a portal during a retreat activity and finds herself thrust into a real-life fantasy world.
Just like her beloved books, everyone she encounters is otherworldly attractive, from the brooding prince to his regal aunt, and even the mysterious spirit haunting her dreams. Unfortunately, the fantasy ends there. Despite being spectacularly unqualified for the position, Eve has been declared The Chosen OneTM, and is promptly saddled with a life-and-death mission to save the kingdom from a centuries-old curse. Apparently, this job comes with zero training and excellent odds of death.
Eve quickly realizes that reading countless fantasy novels is no match for living one, not when she can barely swing a sword to save her life. What’s worse, her fae prince love interest seems perfectly content staying in the enemies stage of their relationship arc. It’ll take everything in her to navigate court politics and battle ancient forces to return home, but everything will work out. After all, main characters can’t die… right?
Romantasyland is a funny, steamy, and wickedly self-aware romp for anyone who knows exactly how the story goes—and loves to fall for it anyway.
Emma MacDonald currently resides outside of Washington, DC, living out her dreams as a witch in the woods.
When she’s not writing, she can be found gardening, brewing potions, or chasing after her small menagerie of pets. Emma loves to write fantasy with a big splash of magic and romance.
Her debut Adult Fantasy dark academia novel, WHISPERS MOST FOUL, was published by Penguin Michael Joseph in October 2024, with its sequel WHISPERS MOST DEADLY soon to follow in Fall of 2025.
Unfortunately this did not work for me. I love portal fantasy and the cover definitely drew me in, but I felt let down by the rough writing. The ideas were interesting but the characters felt flat, and the FMC behaved like a hormonal teenager. Overall it's a 2.5. It can be entertaining under the right circumstances, but I expected better.
Emma MacDonald definitely did a good job poking fun at all the most typical and tiresome tropes, I found myself chuckling or giggling every now and then
I think Romantasyland is misunderstood, perhaps taken too literally and/or too seriously, but I have to agree with those who said they couldn’t connect with the characters (even though Eve was funny) and that the pacing dragged. To be fair, the author explicitly states right at the beginning of the book: […Satire with Feelings… Plot What Plot?]. and don’t get me wrong, I love a good bit of mockery, and I was really keen on the idea of a fantasy satire—but it’s not unreasonable to expect a book to actually have a plot, you know? 😭
This was alright; I didn’t love it, but I didn’t hate it either. i love myself a quirky fantasy book but this one just wasn’t my cup of tea, i fear
First, thank you to the publisher and to NetGalley for providing this ARC.
Unfortunately, I DNF at 44%. I think the premise of this book is great, and the cover, title and the premise is what hooked me. However, the execution was not great.
This was marketed as a satire, but it clearly wasn’t. Self-awareness isn’t the same thing as satire, and the FMC being self-aware of every single trope got really old really fast. Also, any sort of romance between her and the MMC wasn’t believable for me, because she was literally calling everybody hot and attractive and lusting over them. I get it’s trying to be a mockery, but it felt more like items were being checked off a list than anything else.
The characters were flat and none of them were interesting to me. I couldn’t even picture the world in my head, and I wish there was more showing instead of telling.
This had the potential to be a great read, but it was lackluster and it couldn’t keep my interest.
Unlike other books, the heroine has — gasp — brown hair! And she’s bi! And she had loving parents … before they died. And she’s totally not snarky, she’s just bad at being sarcastic. She even has a thought about choosing a bear, so you know she’s topical. He’s not just a fae with wings, he’s got antlers, too. (I wonder if they fall off in winter?) This book wants very badly to be seen as witty and cutting edge. It’s trying so hard that I found myself feeling bad for it.
The writing is … adequate. The characters are a collection of tropes so self aware that they barely need me to roll my eyes, because they’re doing it themselves. After all, I can’t call it bad if it’s already calling itself bad, right?
This isn’t a story; it’s a collection of boxes being ticked with the idea that they’re deconstructing the tropes, only whatever wrote this isn’t clever enough or smart enough to understand deconstruction and just goes for being just like every other romantasy book out there that thinks it’s better than its genre. Pass. Solid pass.
Thank you to Net Galley and the publisher for the ARC.
Listen, I love a Isekai/portal fantasy novel. One of my favorite reads from this year was Ilona Andrews’s This Kingdom Will Not Kill Me. So I went into this book with high hopes and was really rather disappointed by Romantasyland.
The biggest issue with this book is that it is really shallow. The concept was really strong, but the author seemed to bank on the premise for much of her storytelling. Additionally, Eve is a really weak (and also shallow) main character, so the character work doesn’t really shore up the glaring underwriting of the entire novel.
Because this book, unlike TKWNKM, is a completely new world not based on a specific book with our main character loved, there needed to be much stronger world building. Instead, it felt like a lot of hand waving, especially through the narration of Eve. There’s a lot of this “well this looks straight out of every fantasy book/movie” or this looks like “The Lord of the Rings” without taking any further effort to build the world. Anything that can’t be explained to Eve (and to the readers) is kind of just scooted around as part of the chaos magic. Maybe it’s not fair to compare Romantasyland to TKWNKM, but I think the difference is stark and highlights some deeper issues with the narrative. Ilona Andrews has been writing in the fantasy genre for decades now, and it shows in their construction of both characters and fans. Maggie in their novel has a deep reverence for fantasy, for how it functions in our world, and her experience in the novel shows how jarring it is when our fantasy comes into conflict with our reality. In comparison, it kind of feels like Eve doesn’t even really like fantasy or romantasy books. She spends so much of her time calling the places, people, or situations she encounters cliches that it gives the impression that she has a disdain for this genre. I can’t and won’t make assumptions of Emma MacDonald’s reading tastes, but the impression I got from this particular novel is that this is an “easy” genre to write in because so much of it is the same across the board. The pointing out of the tropes-oh this is miscommunication, this is the racially ambiguous MMC (which kind of shocked me to see included at all because like ?), here’s the stereotypical evil king- it was all very strange because it didn’t go further than that. There was no commentary, no deconstructing what a person from our reality would make of it besides “this sucks in real life”, no real relevance to the plot at all. In Sarah Rees Brendan’s Long Live Evil, the FMC uses these tropes to better navigate her way through the world and manipulate the situation to her benefit. For Eve, it felt like she was on a safari pointing out all the animals she’s seeing. It doesn’t feel like MacDonals’s a fan of the genre, it didn’t feel like Eve is a fan, so it made it kind of uncomfortable to read. Maybe it is a lack of experience reading in or writing in the fantasy genre, or not having a firm grasp of it. But it was honestly gave the impression of lazy writing.
Now Eve did not making things easy to get into the narrative. Her first impression of everyone is “wow they’re hot I’d smash.” She’s so horny all the time. Which is a character type that I personally hate, so if I knew that I probably wouldn’t have picked up this book. With that being said, this could be charming with a different character’s personality but it really didn’t fit with her meekness. MacDonald could’ve leaned into the chaotic freewheeling bisexual a lot more but didn’t want to commit. Eve’s inner monologue was tough to listen to and the choices she makes are strange. It’s too bad because her background is kind of the perfect one to have for a portal fantasy FMC and she had the right motivations to really step up to being a Chosen One. But she’s just so shallow. As a result, the relationships she has also lack depth or any real connection. Which is further exacerbated by Eve constantly blaming it on tropes. Rowan’s being difficult because he is the “grumpy prince” or because the “miscommunication trope” is in full swing. It undercut Rowan’s actual thoughts and actions in a very frustrating way.
In the TLDR, this relied heavily on concept and reader’s previous experience with the genre which left us with an underdeveloped and shallow story.
Romantasyland promises a clever send-up of romantasy, but its self-aware premise never develops into sharp satire or a satisfying fantasy story. I picked it up for the cover, but once Eve enters the fantasy world, the story loses focus amid familiar elements: royal politics, dangerous quests, forced proximity, hot princes, and a chosen-one narrative. The premise could have allowed the novel to indulge in and critique the genre’s conventions. Instead, it mostly reproduces them with a knowing wink. Self-awareness is not the same as satire: familiar tropes need to be exaggerated, complicated, or recontextualized to reveal what they assume and how they function.
Here, the novel repeatedly points out its own conventions without asking what makes them appealing, limiting, or absurd. Royal politics could have exposed the shallow wish fulfillment of fantasy courts, but they remain decorative intrigue. The dangerous quest could have challenged the idea that trauma and peril automatically produce character growth, yet it mainly moves Eve toward the next expected revelation. The hot-prince romance could have interrogated the genre’s tendency to treat possessiveness, power imbalances, and instant attraction as proof of destiny, but it largely accepts those dynamics as romantic shorthand. Even the chosen-one plot, which might have questioned why fantasy heroines are granted importance only after being singled out by prophecy, ultimately reinforces that hierarchy.
Because these opportunities are missed, the tropes do not become objects of critique; they simply become the story’s machinery. Eve feels less like a fully realized person than a collection of recognizable protagonist quirks, including manufactured bookishness and “not like other girls” energy. Her transformation from ordinary reader to central figure also lacks the emotional development needed to make the fantasy of being chosen feel either convincing or meaningfully examined. The plot moves predictably from one expected beat to the next, and the romance is similarly underdeveloped. Forced proximity creates tension, but intimacy arrives as a required step rather than the payoff to meaningful connection.
The ending feels especially checklist-like: Eve returns through a portal, the story jumps forward, and phone calls lead to a cozy cottage happily-ever-after. These details might have been charming if they meaningfully reshaped the genre’s conventions; instead, they feel like familiar rewards disconnected from the preceding conflict. With thin characterization, predictable plotting, an underdeveloped romance, and satire that never substantially interrogates its tropes, Romantasyland is neither the sharp critique nor the satisfying fantasy it promises. I skimmed the final stretch after losing interest in the prose, pacing, and protagonist. Readers who enjoy chaotic, trope-heavy meta-romantasy may still enjoy it, but for me it was less a clever send-up than a trope checklist. 2 stars for the cover and the map.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. This is my honest and voluntary review.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
I read this ARC for NetGalley. The concept is fun and honestly the cover art is what drew me to this book originally. I love the look of the book and one of the stars is just for the cover art.
I don’t think the writing and plot are for me, sadly. This reminds me of that book turned to movie - Austenland. Except it’s for fantasy lovers. Or that’s what Eve thinks when she is dropped into the world. It has every cliche trope you can think of and is kind of sarcastically written in that way. But dialog is so wooden that it doesn’t even have funny sarcastic banter. I could not care or get hooked into the story. It felt like I was reading a book that I didn’t want to stay in. It was like a terrible movie you keep on in the background but wish you could turn off.
I love transmigration – it’s my guilty pleasure trope. This is the first American take on the trope that I’ve read (though I don't know if it counts as quite transmigration) and I must admit that I’m disappointed. I have very specific preferences on the transmigration trope, and unless the main character is transmigrating into a side character, villain, or otherwise “secret” characters, I really struggle with it. I think it’s much more fun that way. One thing Romantasyland has taught me about myself is that I am NOT a Chosen One fan when the Chosen One is the main character. It’s too easy for the author to fall into the over-reactive, exposition-heavy dialogue trap when it’s the main character who has to question every single thing about the new world they’ve fallen into. Never heard of “insert forest name here”? Eve is going to ask about it. Never heard of this type of monster? Eve is going to ask about it. Don’t know how long the standard life span is for these fantasy folks? Eve is going to ask about it. Would we all probably do the same thing in her shoes? Sure, but it’s not fun to trudge through the dialogue when it happens every other page.
That aside, the humor wasn’t hitting the right beats for me, and I had a hard time caring about any of the characters. I skimmed the last third of the book, read through the epilogue, and while I liked that Rowan ends the novel as more a “side character” (again, my transmigration preference rears its head), I just can’t justify liking it enough to give it a 3. This book may be worth a chance for anyone who hasn’t read transmigration as a trope before, but if you’re versed in it and have your own specific preferences about the trope, this may miss the mark.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Thank you to Netgalley and Ballantine | Dell for the ARC copy of this book!
I was drawn to this book by the title and cover alone. "Romantasyland" what a fun play on many people's favored genre of books. After reading the description, I immediately knew I wanted to read the book, I mean who doesn't want to escape the mundane everyday life and teleport into a magical fantasy realm? I know I wouldn't pass up the opportunity.
The book was light-hearted and satirical. If you take this book at face-value, and enjoy silly and unserious reads, then you may enjoy this book.
However, I found myself bored and at times annoyed with the overuse of tropes. I understand that is the premise of this book, but I feel like it could have been executed differently. The FMC also would not stop talking about how attractive everyone else was. It got boring after awhile. In the end, I just could not relate to the protagonist, which led to me being uninvested in the story as a whole.
2.75 ⭐️ The idea behind this book is actually very creative; the execution, not so much.
I mean, who doesn’t want to be teleported to their favourite fantasy world and live happily ever after? What this story attempts is to show the non idealised reality of a fantasy world- and for me that kind of fell flat. I couldn’t connect with the main character Eve at all. In the beginning I thought she was a bit relatable, but once she gets to the Fantasy world, any and all character is put behind how horny she is, and how fuckable every other character is. I also couldn’t quite get behind the romance; it just seemed to me like she fell in love with the prince because that’s what happens in romantasy books, no actual romance needed.
The satirical commentary was there, just not particularly well done in my opinion. It simply isn’t enough to have a self aware main character pointing out all of the cliché tropes. (how often does that word appear in the book? Way too many). If you don’t take it too seriously, I think you might enjoy this book, it just wasn’t for me.
When I saw a book about a girl basically going into a book, I knew this would be something that I would really enjoy. A lot of it was fun? But then a lot of it missed the mark for me. It did kind of drag on in many places. Was it fun? sure. but do I recommend it? I couldn’t really tell you for sure.
Thank you NetGalley and publisher for the opportunity to read this for my honest review.
the idea of this book is really fun - a romantasy lover who is stuck in a mundane day-to-day life without much adventure or joy finds herself in a foreign land, with all the makings of a romantasy surrounding her.
now, beyond that is where things started to miss for me. she lands in this foreign land and immediately… wants to sleep with EVERYONE she sees. I get it, mythical beings are gorgeous, but her repetitive inner thoughts about everyone’s beauty and how much she wanted to hop into bed was super overpowering to any of the plot or character building. every character is hot, and I don’t really know much else about them! also, how am I to believe that our main character falls so deeply in love when one page ago she was fantasizing about someone else? the love story isn’t believable, and that’s a big miss for me.
this story is super chaotic. I think it was done intentionally to try and emphasize that the main character was a romantasy reader/fan, but we really don’t need EVERY trope, with another one popping up every few minutes. this could’ve been fun with the way that the author breaks the third wall in these moments, but it was way too overdone.
the fantasy world in this doesn’t seem fully fleshed out to me. we learn the names of the species and some of their powers (with random tidbits thrown out here and there) but I really don’t know much about the world. not to mention that everyone in that world is talking about the curse and the prophecy, but it’s never actually fully described to our main character. the world building here was lacking, but you can see that there are some promising ideas (most notably- the giant dogs in the form of ithil, various different monsters that they have to face, some of the gods in this realm).
I think that this story could’ve been much better if there was less focus on the main character’s lust for EVERYONE and more focus on world building, character development, and refinement of the tropes/challenges that they face. this was a romantasy with a barely outlined fantasy world and a lackluster love story.
thank you to netgalley and the publishers for the arc!
Thank you to Ballantine and NetGalley for the ARC!
2.25/5 Stars
I was hoping this would be a fun read that pokes fun at the Romantasy genre and is in on the joke. The premise of an accidental portal fantasy while at a book retreat and a burnt out bisexual main character with depraved reading taste? Sign me up! However, what I got was a bit of a mess. Even with the expectations of a more silly, goofy, fun time, I was disappointed. It felt like someone tried to write fanfiction (not a bad thing!) but instead of exploring tropes or giving any satirical takes, everything was surface level and just thrown in a blender.
What could have been a tongue in cheek love letter to the genre instead felt like a shallow echo chamber of every buzzword and popular trope shoved together to try and appeal to someone. Unfortunately, there is neither enough depth to our main character or chemistry with the love interests to make any of it charming. In chapter one we begin with seeing how terrible our main character's job is, how the woman she has a crush on is ~surprise!~ seeing someone else and happy. And not only has our main character not healed from the loss of her cat, it also happens to be the anniversary of the death of her perfect, loving, smart, philanthropist parents. All of it just thrown in to cover the stereotypical bases without even one of them feeling real enough to actually matter.
I wanted to love this one SO badly but as someone who reads a lot of romantasy, including some pretty atrociously trope heavy reads, this felt more like being mocked by someone pretending to like the genre than being in on the joke or having any actual commentary.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Unfortunately, this one was a miss for me. I went into it excited by the premise, especially as someone who loves portal fantasy, and the gorgeous cover certainly didn’t hurt. In fact, the cover art earned one of those two stars all on its own!
The concept had so much potential, but the execution just wasn’t there for me. I struggled with the writing, found the dialogue awkward, and never felt particularly connected to the characters. Our FMC’s constant attraction to practically every person she encountered quickly became repetitive, leaving very little room for meaningful character development or a romance I could actually believe in.
The story also felt like it was trying to squeeze in every romantasy trope imaginable. What could have been a clever, tongue-in-cheek take on the genre instead became chaotic and overdone. I wanted more depth in the fantasy world, more substance behind the characters, and a plot that gave me something to invest in.
There were some genuinely fun ideas tucked inside this story, but I never felt fully immersed in them. I wanted to love this one, but between the writing, underdeveloped world, and lack of romantic chemistry, it simply wasn’t my kind of romantasy.
Thank you to Random House and Net Galley for a digital ARC. I read this book in exchange for an honest review.
Romantasyland is a US debut by author Emma MacDonald. In it, our protagonist Eve finds herself facing a lot of dead ends in her life: she’s lost her parents and her cat, she’s in a soul-sucking job, and she can’t even muster the courage to tell her attractive coworker that she likes her. Sigh.
So it totally tracks that going to a romantasy lovers weekend should add some spark to her otherwise humdrum life, right? Too bad she gets spirited away to another world and must now navigate a spate of familiar tropes. Turns out living them out is a lot less fun than reading about them…
For those who love the romantasy genre, this book will no doubt be a lot of fun. Emma MacDonald writes with a constant, self-deprecating wink to her audience about the reasons readers lose themselves in the genre, which includes an ongoing meta-narrative about the greater anxieties and difficulties of modern life that necessitate such mental/emotional escape. It’s clear she’s writing especially for those who fall outside of society ‘norms’ (ADHD, mental health, and LGBTQ+ identities are all represented throughout the book) and I commend her for knowing and writing for her audience well.
However, where I personally struggled with the book was wanting it to commit more tonally. I love a good satirical story, especially when it’s written with such love of the niche it’s critiquing. But I feel like the consistent self-awareness of the tropes that our protagonist was living out kept distancing me from what was actually happening to our heroine. Before the actual emotion of the moment could hit Eve (our protagonist), she would fire off yet another snappy quip or scathing commentary about how much-more-awesome this sort of thing is if you read it rather than live it. This had the effect of making it hard for me to care when Eve was trying not to care either.
The ‘I care now’ shift *did* come for me eventually—but it was nearly at the midpoint of the story… which is very, very late if you’re wanting to capture a reader. This is likely because I’m not the bullseye for the ideal reader. Someone who struggles with the same things Eve does (mental health, ADHD, etc.) might self-identify more so that they feel swept into her story. As it was, I found Eve’s constant self-deflection distancing rather than winsome.
However, once EVE HERSELF invested in what was happening around her—once she started to care about the stakes—that’s when I could finally invest alongside her.
And perhaps that is also the point—perhaps the author is showing us how deeply disengaged we are from the world we’re *actually* in… and if we can claw our way up out of our coping mechanisms, numbness, and disengagement, we, too, can find that there’s a beautiful, broken world around us filled with beautiful, broken people that we are called not to save, but to show up for in our own small, beautiful, broken ways.
Thank you so much to NetGalley and Dell for the ARC!!!
6 stars out of five. 100 out of ten. The way I DEVOURED this book. I always thought when ARCs came out I MAY get the paperback, you know, support the author still. No baby I’m buying this. Deluxe edition. Whatever is available. This book was SO fucking good. Not only was it absolutely well written it was downright hilarious. I cackled out loud several times, much to my cat’s annoyance. This book was so self aware without hitting you over the head with it. I loved Silas SO much. Loved Eve. Loved the banter. Loved how Eve was not with the bullshit. It was all amazing. Emma Macdonald it seems I have grown quite fond of you.
Sadly I dnf @11%, granted I knew it was going to have cliches. But it felt just off, even the beginning pacing of the book had me struggling to get invested. The humor was not really for me. Eve going from crushing on her work buddy, almost crying cause of them being with someone. To then blushing and admiring the potential new love interest 8% in — I just couldn’t get into it. The satire felt overly done, to the point it felt forced so many times.
thank you netgalley and ballantine for the arc in exchange for an honest review.
i was almost about to dnf this at 20% but i stuck through.
what intrigued me the most and led me to request and start the book was its beautiful cover and the blurb. the story follows eve who gets isekai'ed into a fantasy world filled with people with wings and horns, a chaotic magic system, a curse to break, and gets stuck in a love triangle. it does sound fun right? it did to me, and well, it was not fun, unfortunately.
the things that i appreciated— eve being very self aware of every trope that she was thrust upon, the whole making fun of all the usual stuff that happens in all fantasy books in a satirical way— got old really fast. there were too many tropes and it felt like the plot was just filled with tropes and nothing else, and even though she was really self aware, and even though it was implied that it was a dumbass x grumpy trope, she never picked up on hints that should have been obvious to a girl who reads lots of fantasy books. also i mean i understand that she was surrounded by hot people and i would have admired all of them too, but why was she lusting after ALL of them? it came to a point that i just stopped caring about the whole romance aspect of this romantasy, even the smut was confusing to me.
in terms of plot, the idea was really interesting, but the execution lacked structure. the plot was too chaotic — i think trying to add every trope or element into it made it too much and too confusing. the worldbuilding was also lacking; the start had structure and a clear goal, but by 50% there were plot twists revealed (which were quite unexpected, i feel) and confusion began. i didn't know where everything was going. one second she was with this other dude, and now she's sleeping with another? ig that's where the love triangle comes into play, but it got too confusing for me to care about them anymore. I did like the co-relation of real life stuff like ADHD and autism to people kissed by annorath and ceanrath respectively in the fantasy world.
i think if the plot got more structure, lost a few unnecessary tropes used as plot devices, and the worldbuilding became stronger, the book would be much more interesting.
Things I liked: the main fantasy plot was an interesting idea - the fight between order and chaos in this fantasy world. A woman dropped in from our world, but she is a huge fantasy reader and super self-aware, as she navigates why she is there and what she needs to do. I thought is was a fun idea to use the aspect of tropes, that our FMC is fully aware of, to build the world. I did like the FMC; she was fun and not a complete dummy; I liked that she was bisexual. Rowan was a good MMC and I would've like to learn more about him.
With that being said, I think the story has a lot of issues. As a whole, it's supposed to be a satire, but doesn't really subvert the genre enough to make any kind of commentary on it. The only thing it does is have a lot of tropes and a self aware FMC. It just reads as a poorly done romantasy, without any real romance. The characters are very underdeveloped and a bit shallow; they never have any real, deep, or meaningful conversations or development. I didn't believe any of the romance. The world is also underdeveloped, which makes the concept of the main plot not feel as meaningful. The writing is very repetitive - several times there are full sentences and phrasing that are repeated, and it doesn't feel intentional. I wish more had been done with the FMC's bisexuality and maybe would've made the story more interesting if she was gay or not sexually/romantically attracted to the MMC.
This story was easy to read and fairly fast paced, but I still struggled to get through it. I would like to check out other stories by Emma MacDonald, though, because the idea was so fun.
2.5/5 stars. Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine for this eARC.
I have to be completely honest: this was a disaster. The concept was cute and appealing, but it totally missed the mark. The author leaned way too hard into the satirical aspect. So much so that everything else fell completely flat. The characters were unrelatable, the plot was unoriginal, and the writing was atrocious. The push to be new adult was unnecessary and forced. It read like a YA novel but with an excessive amount of expletives and a little bit of boring smut thrown in. I’ve read more compelling fanfics. This book needs a lot of polishing prior to publish, though I’m not sure even heavy editing could save it.
Romantasyland by Emma MacDonald is an action-packed, hilarious adventure filled with literally every writing trope in literary canon. If you are a fantasy lover, a romantic comedy enthusiast, and love writing and plot structures similar to your Wattpad favorites - this book is for you!
Thank you, NetGalley, Balantine | Dell, and Emma MacDonald for sending me this advanced review copy for free. I am leaving this review voluntarily and with joy in my heart!
Romantasyland tells the story of Eve Lockwood, a normal woman by any shake of the imagination. Clumsy, snack-loving, ADHD riddled, and firmly glued to romantasy books, she finds herself in a bit of a grief-fueled rut. When the opportunity arises to attend a fantasy bookish retreat with like-minded readers, she signs up in a beat of positivity. Like any introvert signing up for any social event literally ever, Eve later regrets her decision and attempts to negotiate herself out of attending. Nevertheless, she ends up at the event and tries to make the best of it.
At this point in the story, Eve and the fantasy reader group take a hike into the wilderness. Of course, the isekai mechanic firmly kicks in, and Eve is transported into a fantasy world. Facing a world unlike our own, Eve quickly learns that the men inhabiting the lands are extremely attractive and embody all of your favorite romantasy fantasy mechanics - wings, horns, shadows, oh my!
The first thing that struck me in these beginning chapters was the sheer volume of references, direct and modest, to other works in the romance, fantasy, and romantasy genres. I commend the author for not being too shy to fully commit to a wink-wink-nudge-nudge toward everyone’s favorite literary giants. However, I quickly felt that these references were less modest acknowledgements and more like a punch in the face. I lost count and appreciation after approximately ten tropes and did not enjoy this mechanic.
In reflection, I think that the author was attempting to incorporate a large number of tropes in order to poke fun at these literary mechanics and provide commentary therein. Likely, I think the message was supposed to land somewhere near making fun of romance, fantasy, and romantasy authors for selling and marketing their books purely off of tropes and clickable quotes. However, I do not think that the writing was successful in carrying this message. I felt extremely uninspired by the writing and overall scheme of mechanics.
It felt, to me, as if the plot structure fell victim to the next trope to be incorporated - almost as if the author was playing a creative writing game with a wheel to decide the next scene. The overall storytelling was hogtied by the reappearance of tropes, and could have been aided by way of a stronger editorial voice.
In addition, I think the overall plot shape needs sharp editing. As the story begins, there is a very clear direction of the story. There is a clear beginning and end for the quest Eve is sent on. However, that story is very quickly expanded and then consistently thrown into different directions. The overall discontinuity and shifts may read as exciting to some readers, but it reads as disjointed and uncomfortable to me. I felt that the story was just throwing the reader into a new direction without fully fleshing out previous ideas.
I would have really liked to luxuriate in this fantasy world. There were so many aspects, like the magic system, that I felt needed much more development to feel fully realized. I understand the limitations of working within a story about the potential end of the world, but the story could have benefited from a few beats of slice-of-life. Those quiet moments are where readers fall in love with the characters forever after, and that was missing here.
This being said, I genuinely feel that there is a good story here. The bones of this story are present! Further, I think that people will genuinely gravitate toward the cast of characters and the fantasy setting.
The characters are genuinely funny, and the dialogue feels natural and flows easily. I found myself laughing at Eve consistently. Her reactions to the events in the story were genuinely funny and quite entertaining. I won’t give any spoilers for the male love interest, but any person who loves enemies-to-lovers, morally grey men, dark humor, shadowy figures, and court intrigue will be fully satisfied.
Note: this is an open-door adult romance. There are scenes of an adult nature not appropriate for all audiences.
This book will work for any long-time fan of Kindle Unlimited, and bite-sized books similar to what we all read on Wattpad as girls. This book is similar in that the plot unfurls extremely quickly and works within traditional character archetypes without being bogged down with too many details. If you are someone who enjoys moving quickly through a book with a brisk succession of events one after another, you will really enjoy diving into this book!
I really wanted to love this one because the premise had so much potential. A bisexual woman with ADHD who loves romantasy gets dropped into a world that seems to be built around all the tropes she knows and loves? I was immediately intrigued, and I really appreciated the bisexual representation throughout the book.
Unfortunately, the execution just didn’t quite work for me.
The biggest issue was the pacing. Everything moved so quickly that I rarely had time to settle into a scene, the world, or a relationship before we were off to the next thing. At the same time, the overall story somehow started to feel slow and a little dull. There were a lot of interesting reveals and ideas, but they often weren’t given enough time to really land. Even toward the end, things happened so quickly that I didn’t always have time to settle into the emotional moments before we were moving on.
I also struggled with the romance. I actually really liked the development between Eve and Rowan when we finally got some banter, vulnerability, and forced proximity. Those were some of my favorite parts of the book because I could actually feel their relationship developing. Unfortunately, that relationship kept getting pushed aside, and other romantic/sexual storylines started taking up space without ever feeling like a clear why-choose direction. One of the spice scenes was genuinely very good, but I still found myself wondering why that relationship needed to exist in the first place when I was more invested in the relationship the story had already started building with Rowan. (Though it would have been a fun dream scene to remove the emotional impact but have fun!)
The constant trope callouts were another struggle for me. I understand that Eve is intentionally self-aware because she knows romantasy tropes, and I think that could have been a really fun part of her character. I just wish that self-awareness had been handled more subtly. A small nod showing that she recognizes a familiar trope while still naturally playing into it could have been funny without feeling cheesy or overly obvious. Instead, the repeated direct callouts often pulled me out of the story.
As someone with ADHD myself, I also had mixed feelings about Eve’s ADHD representation. There were definitely moments where I recognized the way her brain worked, but by the end, some of her internal distractions during emotional scenes pulled me out rather than making me feel seen. There is a difference between recognizing a thought pattern and wanting to read that thought pattern interrupt an important emotional moment over and over. In particular, there were moments when Rowan was being vulnerable and Eve’s thoughts kept turning toward sex, which felt distracting rather than adding to the emotional impact of the scene.
That said, there were definitely things I enjoyed. The bisexual representation was a big positive for me, there were some fun worldbuilding elements, and I genuinely enjoyed several individual scenes and character interactions. The mysterious shadow figure was especially intriguing for a while, and I liked getting to see Eve and Rowan actually connect when the story slowed down enough to let them.
My biggest frustration is that I kept seeing glimpses of the book I wanted this to be. There are good ideas here, and I think with more room for the relationships and worldbuilding to breathe, some tightening of the pacing, and less reliance on directly calling out the tropes, this could become a much stronger story.
As an ARC, I’m also keeping in mind that there is still time before publication for editing and polishing. Overall, I didn’t hate it, but I found myself wanting it to be over for quite a while before I actually reached the end.
Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine for the opportunity to read and review this ARC. My review will be posted on Goodreads and NetGalley, and will also be available on Barnes & Noble once the book is published.
The chosen one and a broody prince walk into a bar.... Okay, where do I start on this one? I had a lot of feelings. I was immediately interested in this book on the title alone, and was definitely drawn in even more with the blurb/description. I was very excited to read this one. And then I looked through some of the reviews. And then I started it and immediately was nervous because I kind of hated the FMC. Seriously, my notes literally say "girl stop whining its only been 2 chapters." But once I got a few chapters in, it was easy to really get into the story. The premise of this book is amazing. A mortal girl living a mundane life in modern times accidentally finds herself in a fantasy world in the middle of a battle between gods? I always like it when fantasy, like fae/magic/dragons fantasy, intersects with the modern world. I think it was even better that Eve was a reader who was literally at a fantasy retreat when the books she read became real. Its like me getting tossed into ACOTAR or Fourth Wing while at Books, Gowns, and Crowns or Apollycon. I think this is ultimately a story about getting out of your comfort zone, and what can happen when you do. Sure, we will probably won't have something as dramatic as falling through a portal to a different realm and end up falling in love with the hot fae prince, but definitely good things on a more realistic scale. I think Eve, while I found her a little whiny at first, ended up being really relatable. I know we all would like to think if we got dropped into our favorite fantasy novel we would jump in without hesitation and just be a total bad ass, but realistically, I think we (or at least me) would be very much like Eve--confused, a little overwhelmed, and questioning if I could actually do this. Oh, and scared, definitely scared. Overall, I think that Eve's inner monologue as the story progressed helped me like her more as a character. Not to say she wasn't annoying, (girl, we get it, your horny. Can you please stop thinking about sleeping with literally every character we meet?), but she's also funny. There was a plethora of your typical fantasy tropes in this one, and I loved Eve calling them out. She grows on you (even if one of my notes as I was reading was "saying you have grown does not count as character growth." Don't worry, the growth comes). I appreciated the nods (some a little in your face, some in the vaguest sense possible) to other popular fantasy series and fairytales. I loved the one liners-- "what in the greek mythology??". The characters were fleshed out, and had their own distinct personalities. The villain was unexpected. I never really knew where the story was going (aside from a vague idea), which I really enjoyed. You don't know who the villain is, who the love interest is, or really if the hero will make it out alive or if the realm will be doomed. The scenery and setting was interesting and detailed, even if it was a little confusing at first. There were some things I would've liked developed a little more (the relationship, the initial quest), and I think it could've benefitted from being a little longer, but overall I really enjoyed Romantasyland. Thank you to Random House and Netgalley for this ARC. I am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
2.5⭐️ Unfortunately, this one was more of a miss than a hit for me.
The concept is actually pretty interesting, but I just couldn’t connect with the characters. And honestly, for most of the book, I didn’t really care what happened to any of them.
One thing I will give it credit for is how naturally it works a bunch of popular tropes into the story. It’s not quite a deconstruction of the genre, but it’s not a parody either. It kind of sits somewhere in the middle, and I actually liked that part.
The characters, though, were a different story. The FMC is trying to collect every possible character trait like she’s filling out a checklist. She’s queer, she has ADHD (which gets brought up multiple times, although I can’t really say the book does much with it beyond telling us that she has it), she’s grieving her parents, she’s lonely, etc.
As for the MMC, well... he hates the FMC (except he actually doesn’t), because apparently we needed another popular trope checked off the list. In reality, he’s probably the biggest green flag in the entire book. He’s so ridiculously understanding that he’s even perfectly fine with the FMC hooking up with someone else. Sir, do you have any self-respect?
And as for that someone else... I genuinely don’t even know what to say. He actually could’ve made for a much more interesting main character, but alas, here we are. We got what we got.
And then there’s the romance.
At the beginning, the FMC has a little crush on her coworker. Then she gets yeeted into the magical world and suddenly every other character she meets inspires a horny thought or two. Girl, please!
But the biggest issue for me was the love triangle. I already have a complicated relationship with this trope, so for me to enjoy it, it really needs to be done well. And... yeah, this wasn’t it.
The FMC basically speedruns her way through both love interests over the course of two days, literally going from one bed to the other. She does acknowledge that this is weird, and I’ll give her that, but self-awareness doesn’t automatically make the behavior make sense. I’m sorry, but watching her bounce between two people like that felt less like romantasy and more like I’d accidentally picked up a contemporary melodrama.
Maybe I’m being overly picky, but the whole thing just didn’t work for me.
I finished this yesterday, and after having some time to think about it, I can kind of see how the FMC’s chaotic relationship choices might be explained by the whole chaos magic thing. So... okay, I guess? But that is simply not my jam.
I don’t think this is necessarily a bad book. It has a fun concept, some interesting ideas, and I can absolutely see why it works for other readers. I just don’t think I’m the audience for this particular flavor of chaos.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.
In this epic portal fantasy, we meet Eve who is admittedly living a dull, grey life. She takes a leap of faith and attends a reading retreat where happens upon a portal to a fae realm. The story follows Eve as color slowly comes back to her world, alongside an ancient curse and a budding romance. Great choice for readers who enjoy books that sound like their best friend telling them a story. Readers with ADHD looking for representation of how their brain works will also appreciate this.
My impression is that this book is meant to poke fun and common romantasy tropes, which had potential to be hilarious. I was also hoping for a fresh take on familiar tropes rather than reading the same ingredients rearranged. However, the frequent callouts about the cliche nature of the world felt repetitive and on the nose. It would have been more affective and enjoyable to have little nods and winks here and there rather than overt and consistent call out. Similarly, Eve spends so much time commenting on the tropes that she comes across as unserious. So much so that it actually makes it feel like the book should not be taken seriously, like one big joke (and not in a good way), undercutting the excitement and thrill of the high stakes situations-resulting in loss of interest.
The writing style lost me. There’s lots of telling and not a lot of showing. It’s in the third person from the perspective of Eve but the tone almost feels like a diary or a long text to a friend with very informal language. I would imagine this is intentional to reflect the stream of consciousness of someone with ADHD, but it did not land for me. Her character feels one dimensional and her sense of humor cliche. As a result, the pace feels slow, even though the actual pace of plot events is not.
The slow burn tension is the highlight of the book. It’s truly criminally slow and all together visceral by the midpoint. Without giving too much away, the secondary romance also kept my interest, but the way that ends it’s a little confusing and disappointing. The world building is light-there is brief scenic descriptions and imagine features but not in depth enough to be immersive. The first and second halves also feel like different books. As much as the tension between Eve and Rowan was captivating, the first half felt more like set up they had been drawn out and could have been much shorter. The plot is much more interesting in the second half, containing a huge plot twist and glimpses of a more sophisticated writing style.
There is a small thread about how grief drives people woven through the character development, as well as a dichotomy between chaos and order. I would have loved to see this dichotomy explored more instead of the emphasis on tropes.
The book ends on a cliffhanger so I imagine there’s a book 2 coming! Thank you to Ballantine and Emma MacDonald for the free advanced copy.
Thank you to Netgalley, the publisher, and the author for the opportunity to read 'Romantasyland' before its publication. This review is of my own opinion, and I encourage you to still check out this book if you're into satire, comedy, a self-loathing FMC with chaotic energy, and MMCs so hot, they'll distract you from the plot.
Please note that this review has potential spoilers!
This story follows Eve Lockwood - a down on her luck kind of gal who enjoys all things romantasy.
While having a pity party and moping about her crush Jess who already has a girlfriend, she agrees to go with Jess and Jess's girlfriend to a retreat for fantasy lovers.
While on said retreat, things get chaotic and Eve finds herself in an entirely different world. Hypocritical of her surroundings, she can't believe she fell into a world like the ones so loves to read about.
I enjoyed how humorous this story was and I enjoyed the chaotic ADHD energy that was here for the entirety of the story. (Yay for ADHD rep!!) I enjoyed how self aware Eve was of how ridiculous a lot of the tropes she encountered were, and I especially loved that she was basically like, "Yikes... this is better left in books and not real life."
I did struggle for a hot moment at the end of the book for what seemed like a last minute possible love triangle, and I was not for it.
The chemistry between her and the prince also seemed very lackluster and almost forced. At times, she has better chemistry with the alleged villain than she did with the prince and I won't lie; this is one of those times when I wished this WAS a why-choose because I couldn't picture the FMC with who she ended up with.
*possible spoilers ahead*
The ending as well seemed very rushed. One moment we were in a battle of gods that seemed like there was a lot of promise, to her then being transported home. It does get tied up SLIGHTLY, but it was such an abrupt ending that I wasn't expecting it to happen that way.
Aside from that, this story has satirical comedy, an extremely horny bisexual FMC, and lowkey an annoyingly handsome prince and a lip smacking "villain".
I didn't love this book, but I did definitely have a good time reading its ridiculousness and I think this can easily be a great palette cleanser for those wanting something silly before diving into something deeper.
2.5/5 stars! 3 stars for the sake of netgalley and goodreads.
*3.75 stars Overall, I enjoyed reading this book, but there were moments when I didn't have the desire to pick it up. It has pros and cons, and I think they balance out. There does need to be a heavy edit before it is released, however.
Pros: *The idea behind the plot is fun. Normal girl falls into a fantasy world and has to navigate a bunch of tropes (chosen one, only one bed, etc). *There is a snarky "side" character that has some great entrances and exits, as well as some funny one-liners. *There are a few stand out secondary characters, such as Tallis, that I enjoyed reading about. *There is a giant, horned dog/pet that is absolutely adorable (despite the slobbery kisses). *The world that Eve, the main character, falls into is interesting. I wish it had been built out some more, but I could still picture it reasonably well. *The chapters aren't too long. It was an easy, quick-ish read.
Cons: *The mention of all of the tropes gets a bit irritating deeper into the story. *The phrase, "Which, like, fair/yeah/duh" is way overused. By the end of the book, I was rolling my eyes every time I read it. *Eve's thoughts are annoying at times. She will think, oh this is a bad idea, but I'm going to do it anyway. That got old quick. *For being a lover of fantasy and recognizing all of the tropes, Eve still makes that classic heroine in a new world dumb mistakes. She never asks questions and when things get revealed she will think, "I should have asked about that," or "I guess that was pretty obvious, how could I miss that?" *I didn't quite believe the romance. The enemies-to-lovers transition was abrupt and clunky. *The pacing was a bit weird. The action scenes wrapped up quickly, but the exposition seemed to drag a bit. Hopefully this gets finessed in the final edit.
Editing: *This definitely needs a couple more edits. There were several missing words, as well as missing punctuation. *The main character's thoughts/speech pattern was a bit too colloquial for my liking. She says "like" way too much. *There were also a couple of misused words. For example, appreciably was used when it should have been appreciatively.
I would be interested to see how the final version of this book turns out, since it has a lot of potential. If it gets a really good edit and streamlines that pacing a bit more, I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Romantasyland.