Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Mystery of Insch Brae House

Rate this book
“A middle-grade tale with a classic feel…I definitely recommend this novel.”
Claire McFall, author of the Ferryman Trilogy.

Eight-year-old Muriel’s life has suddenly turned upside down. With her family in turmoil and her father missing, Muriel is whisked away to Insch Brae House (pronounced "Inch Bray") on the windswept coast of Scotland under the watchful eye of her less-than-friendly minder, Miss Floss.

At first, Moreland and Insch Brae seem to offer nothing but grey skies and dusty corners. But everything changes when Muriel meets a local boy who shares her suspicion that something about the town, and the run-down great house, just doesn’t make sense. Together, they discover that Insch Brae hides secrets in every shadow, and that even the icy Miss Floss may not be who she seems.

Perfect for fans of The Bletchley Riddle, Lemony Snicket, and The Mysterious Benedict Society, The Mystery of Insch Brae House is a captivating middle-grade mystery filled with creepy investigations, surprising twists, and puzzling secrets.

Advance Praise:

“Excellent read, a real page turner”
Eli (aged 10), Emily (8) and mummy

“A mystery with a great twist near the end, good reading. I can't wait to read it to my grandchildren”
S. Stark

“Gripping story with a great twist…’
C. Grant

“A lovely entertaining read.”
Frances

“A spooky Scottish Mystery”
H MacDonald

“Great story.”
Ruth Montgomery

“Captivating and exciting read my kids loved.”
Miss C Begg

“Mystery is a wonderful thing.”
English Teacher, London, UK

101 pages, Paperback

First published April 21, 2020

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Susan Fiddes

2 books4 followers
Welcome to my author page, great to see you here! This is where you can find out more about what I am up to.

I am a Scottish writer, originally from Aberdeen city, currently living in Washington DC, USA with my husband and two children. My love of writing stretches back to childhood, when I used to devour books at night by torchlight and write little stories in my notebooks. Today, my love of reading and writing is as passionate as ever and I hope that you enjoy all that I release. It is fair to say that I have eclectic tastes in the words I both read and write - from stories for children - to dark tales of adulthood, thrillers and espionage.

My first release, THE MYSTERY OF INSCH BRAE HOUSE (now into its second edition), covers a few of these bases: it is a mystery written for children set in a fictional Scottish seaside town, which sees my characters become amateur sleuths in the search for the truth about spooky Inch Brae House. My little reviewers tell me it is a fantastic read for both boys and girls, and especially if you are aged 5-9 and enjoy reading yourself, or being read chapter books at night by a grown-up.

Much of my inspiration for this book comes from my own childhood and summers spent running wild at the Scottish seaside.

If this sounds interesting, please click on my "follow" button and keep up to date with my latest news and releases.

You can also connect with me on Facebook: @susanfiddesauthor

I love hearing what my readers think and encourage/welcome your online reviews and direct messages to me via my platforms.

Thank you and happy reading!

Susan

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
4 (18%)
4 stars
8 (36%)
3 stars
8 (36%)
2 stars
2 (9%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews
Profile Image for escaping through novels .
652 reviews97 followers
Read
September 1, 2026
When Muriel is sent away from her family to a mysterious old school full of secrets, she is determined to find answers as to who else may be in the building with her and her guardian.

This book ended up being very cute! The writing style felt a bit unusual and almost historical at times, rather than taking place just a decade ago, but once I got used to the writing, it was easy to get swept into the adventure of the story. I loved the setting, the backstory, and Muriel’s desire to get answers. It was a fun read, and also sad at times!

Thanks so much to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. All thoughts are my own.
Profile Image for Stormi (StormReads).
1,977 reviews222 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 2, 2026
There was not much mystery to the Mystery of Insch Brae House. I thought it was easy to figure out, but maybe not for a younger middle grader; I think older middle graders could probably see where the story was headed. I liked the characters fine, but was just kind of bored.
Profile Image for Marsha.
256 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 26, 2026
Simple and easy to read and follow. Starts out with promise, interesting style of writing, and interesting main character. I'm not sure on the target age group, but I would put this a little younger than middle grade.
However, all other characters fell flat. Plot and dialog felt very improbable. I do wish they had leaned a bit more into the spooky angle.
Received an Advanced Reader Copy from Netgalley
Profile Image for Maria.
3,560 reviews103 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 18, 2026
This book had me turning the pages to see what would happen next but not in the way that I had expected. I was thrilled with the spooky setting of the old school, but more could have been done with this setting and ultimately, this didn’t cash in on the spookiness. The mystery element and additional characters are not even introduced until over halfway through the book, leaving the first half for Muriel to constantly wonder why she is with this woman and why her mother left her. Finally, the story gets to the mystery, but it wasn’t much of one and is resolved almost immediately and with little tension. This would be good for anxious readers who need light suspense and a happy ending.

Thank you to NetGalley and TigerLovesBooks for the review copy.

869 reviews23 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 4, 2026
Muriel is sent on a train journey with Miss Foss, her Mum saw her off at the station in Edinburgh, the train is going to Moreland. Muriel has no idea who Miss Foss is or why she has to go with her, she does know that her Mum spent loads of time in Moreland when she was a girl. But that was summer and this is winter and it’s snowing and Muriel hasn’t got her boots on.
This is a gothic tale for children, which I’m sure they will love, it has everything, courage, friendship and overcoming difficulties. An excellent book which my grandchildren will love.
My thanks to NetGalley and the publishers for the arc
Profile Image for Tonja Drecker.
Author 3 books252 followers
October 11, 2026
With the atmosphere of past times and a hint of mystery, this is a quick read with a character to enjoy.

Muriel has no idea why she's been sent with a strange woman to a house in Scotland by her mother. Everyone has been saying that Mum needs a break, but Muriel isn't sure why. Her and her mum both miss her father, who is in India to help the people there after an earthquake, but everything else seems to be normal. While Muriel wonders what is going on, she also has to deal with a very grumpy Miss Floss, who only complains about Muriel. When they, finally, get to the house in Scotland, it's clear that Miss Floss wants Muriel to stay in the nursery or library and be as little seen as possible. But Muriel doesn't really enjoy be shut away, especially since someone or something seems to be in the house with them. At least, food appears in front of Muriel's bedroom door and things are knocked over without anyone around. It's a mystery Muriel has to solve.

This is an enjoyable, short tale which keeps the reader engaged from beginning to end...but not in the way I thought it would. While there is a little mystery, it's more about Muriel's search for the truth behind her trip with Miss Floss, which leads her to discover a bit about her mum's own time in the town as a child. There's a bit of tension and danger here and there to keep the tale grabbing, but this is by no means an action story or even spooky...although Miss Floss' unpleasant personality does leave Muriel, understandably, scared to run in to her. Instead, the tale takes on almost an historical note as Muriel learns a little bit about the past and the people her mum once knew. Mix that with a few unexpected situations, and it's an interesting and enjoyable read.

The author keeps everything about this read short and directed. The chapters are often only two or so pages, if even that. There isn't a long, intricate plot, but rather, Muriel's tale is straightforward and fitting for the middle grade audience.
1,660 reviews25 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 14, 2026
What worked:
The author describes a mysterious, depressing setting for Muriel, as she’s sent to stay with a guardian she’s never met. Miss Floss demeans her at every opportunity to the point where Muriel is afraid to move about the house. The house itself is drab and dusty, with most of the rooms standing empty. However, food surprisingly appears outside her bedroom door, but it seems Miss Floss doesn’t know anything about it. Strange sounds and Muriel’s curiosity lead her to begin investigating the house.
The author uses short chapters, which should appeal to young readers. The conflict focuses on the history of Insch Brae House, since Muriel doesn’t understand why it’s in such poor condition now. She deduces that it may have been a school where Miss Floss once worked, but Muriel wants to know why she’s now so sad and bitter. A young boy from town joins Muriel halfway into the story, and together, they follow clues to uncover what happened to the house and Miss Floss. The truth involves bullying and a tragic love story and builds to a surprising climax.
What didn’t work as well:
The prologue and an early chapter describe Muriel’s father in India. He’s injured during an earthquake, and her mother travels there to be with him. However, her parents aren’t a major part of the story, and readers may be disappointed or surprised by that. Perhaps the parents will be more present in the book’s sequel.
The final verdict:
The plot isn’t a suspenseful mystery, but it features unique characters and a heart-warming ending. I suggest you give it a shot.
Profile Image for Patricia  N..
394 reviews3 followers
October 24, 2026
The Mystery of Insch Brae House
by Susan Fiddes

Rated: 4 star rating

I just finished reading The Mystery of Insch Brae House by Susan Fiddes, and it was a really good story. It is about an eight year old girl named Muriel whose dad goes missing. Because things are crazy at home, she gets sent away to a cold, dreary seaside town to live in this creepy old mansion called Insch Brae House.

The house used to be a busy school, but now it is just empty and dusty. Muriel has to live with a mean lady named Miss Floss who totally hates kids and makes Muriel super scared to even leave her room.

The mystery gets going when plates of food start randomly showing up right outside Muriel's bedroom door. She ends up making friends with a local boy named Christopher, and they start exploring the creepy secret tunnels under the house to find clues.

Together, they try to figure out what Miss Floss is hiding and why the whole town is so sad. The chapters are really short, so it goes by fast, and it is never too scary. It actually has a sweet ending about friendship and forgiveness. It is an easy read for kids or anyone who likes a good old-school mystery. I definitely recommend this book.

Thank you, NetGalley, Sibylline Press, and Claire R. McDougall, author, for this ebook review consideration. All review opinions are my own.

#NetGalley
#SibyllinePress
#ClaireRMcDougall author
#SongoftheSelkie

http://goodreads.com/patriciasreading...

http://www.patriciasreadingroom.blogs...
Profile Image for Rachel.
1,062 reviews19 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 12, 2026
*I received a free ARC from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review*

This was not quite what I was expecting (I thought it would be more of a supernatural tale) but still a very enjoyable book. I liked Muriel and her ability to go with whatever was going on around her and not falling into a sulk because her situation was not great. I do not quite understand why her mother would put her in the care of a woman she had not talked to in years and to send her to a house she had not seen in years - did she really have no other options? I also wondered how hard people looked for the missing caretaker considering these two kids found him within a few days. Ultimately, this book is about forgiving ourselves and each other for past hurts and to recognize that although you cannot take back something you have done, you can make amends to others and do better in the future. I was actually kind of sad how much time was lost between Miss Floss and Robert all because of one incident. I really hope there will be more books that partner up Muriel and Christopher as mystery solvers, they were a great team.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Sarah.
103 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 23, 2026
The Mystery of Insch Brae House was a fun read that I would have liked to delve a bit deeper too. I enjoyed the world that Susan Fiddes created and Muriel, our main character, was quite entertaining. Muriel is living her everyday life when all of a sudden, she is sent away with the cranky Miss Floss to stay at Insch Brae while her mother is busy with who knows what (the reader finds out early on) and her father is away. Muriel quickly discovers that Insch Brae is NOT what it looks like (nor what her mother remembers) and with her new friend, Christopher, they start to unravel and explore the mysteries of the house.

There were several points in the book where I wanted to know MORE to deepen my understanding of what was happening in the book. I felt there were a few parts that were rushed through, leaving me wanting more. Overall though, the story was charming and fun - I can see the appeal for younger readers who would appreciate the shorter chapters and faster pace, while still getting the world building that has been carefully put into the story.
Profile Image for Priyanka (ReadwithBanner ).
202 reviews36 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
September 22, 2026
Received an Advanced Reader Copy from Netgalley!!

Narrator is Muriel, 8-year old girl away from parents, friends and not sure why she landed in Insch Brae House in the first place, which was cold and dilapted with Miss Floss who was not keen to have Muriel around. She found herself surrounded by mysteries: who served her tomato soup, who is Robert Forsyth, who keeps coughing in the corridor, who left the keys in Library. In her journey of unraveling the truth, she met Christopher and together they solve the oldest mystery of Moreland - disapperance of Robert Forsyth.

I was getting a creepy, crawly feeling on my skin at the begining of the story and with Muriel's daydreaming sequences I found my smile back. It's unusal for a mystery, usually it's tragic, sad and horrifying. With the build up, I thought it will be supernatural, however I was proven wrong.

If you are looking for a mystery which is short and sweet, pick this one.
Profile Image for Aliceson.
171 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
July 24, 2026
This is an interesting introductory mystery. Muriel’s father is off in another country working. Her mom suddenly sends her to stay at Insch Bray house with the terrible Miss Floss. Muriel tries to figure out the mystery of Insch Bray and why Miss Floss is so mean to her. This book is just mysterious enough to hold your interest. Packed with a creepy old house and maybe a ghost? I thought the reason her mother sent her away with a stranger was a little flimsy. The friendship Muriel develops with a local boy seems genuine. Parts of the ending feel unrealistic. The story wraps up neatly in a little package.

Recommended for grades 2-4 for mystery fans.
Profile Image for Toya Taylor.
319 reviews6 followers
November 1, 2026
Took me a bit with the beginning, but once I started reading I loved this book.
This book is about Muriel who is sent to stay at Insch Brae House just like her mother. Upon arrival Muriel is greeted by the frosty Miss Floss and taken to a very dark and abandoned looking Insch Brae House. Instantly think start to happen that lead Muriel to believe the house is haunted. Upon further inspection she finds out about the history of the house and solved the mystery of Insch Brae House. Wonderful book!!!!!
Profile Image for MaggieDay.
117 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 9, 2026
Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for an edition of this book to read. Muriel is sent to stay in mysterious Insch Brae House in Moreland, Scotland. There are secrets within the seemingly abandoned building with only Miss Floss, a woman who seems to hate Muriel. It's up to Muriel to find out what the building has to hide.

I believe the target audience for this book would be 9-11 year olds. The plot is easy to follow and has scary sections suitable for a younger audience.
Profile Image for Beth.
264 reviews3 followers
November 8, 2026
This is definitely more of a children's mystery than the middle grade mystery it showed up for me as, and that's where I'm a little stuck in terms of rating. It was good, I would recommend it, but it's ultimately not what I was hoping for. I think the intended audience will enjoy this, especially if read by / with a parent.

Thank you to the author for allowing me to read this eARC via NetGalley.
Profile Image for Christine.
114 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 29, 2026
This reminds me of the little princess a bit. A simple story and a simple mystery that young readers will relish.
Displaying 1 - 17 of 17 reviews