"This is what they will not tell you about loving a god."
Raised among Spartan soldiers, Hyacinthus survives on discipline and silence, clinging to fleeting moments of warmth. But when fate severs his first bond of love, grief hollows him into something unrecognizable. Years later, Apollo enters his life―radiant, distant, and enticing. Drawn towards the god's light, Hyacinthus dares to imagine a future not wholly defined by blood and absence. But divine desire casts long shadows, and some gazes are not meant to linger.
"Dear Hyacinthus" follows a star-crossed prince long before the poets remember him―through grief, kinship, and the slow rebuilding of a scarred heart learning what it means to love. By the time Apollo turns his gaze toward him, Hyacinthus is prepared to give up everything.
now playing…ᯓ♪ ▶︎•၊၊||၊|။|||||။၊|။•lover, please stay - nothing but thieves
ONE BILLION STARS ☆ ⋆˚꩜。 🪻
overall thoughts ⋆⭒˚.⋆ 🌊
oh my GODDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 when i tell you this is THE BEST greek myth retelling i’ve ever read and NO this is not biased just cause the author is my best friend, this book is everything to me. everything was absolutely perfect. the pacing, the character development, the metaphors, the WRITING??????? sophia genuinely your writing style is one of the best i’ve ever had the pleasure of devouring, you describe everything so beautifully. i’d never heard of this myth before my bestest friend started planning this novel all those years ago (it originally started as a short story fun fact) and now it’s become one of my favorites. the last 50 pages or so had me so filled with dread i was actually terrified 😭🙏 only read this if you’re prepared to be emotionally destroyed, my friend PHYSICALLY cannot write happy endings (love you so so much) but oh my goodness i am so honored that i get to call this incredible author my best friend, it seems it was only yesterday when we were writing our first joint fanfic together at our 7th grade lunch table and now you’re a published author. this is truly a triumph, i adore you so so much dearest 💗 i’m getting choked up kill me
characters ⋆⭒˚.⋆ ☀️
hyacinthus - yeah just kill me now HES EVERYTHING TO ME ☹️☹️☹️☹️ i LOVED watching him grow up but also it was the end of me he’s just everything
apollo - SWEET BOY ☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️ he’s also everything to me
tws/cws ⋆⭒˚.⋆ ‼️
death, gore, slavery, (mentions of) sexual assault (sorry if i missed any!! 💗)
⋆✴︎˚。⋆ “i think that you are my roots. wherever you take me, that is home.” ⋆✴︎˚。⋆
this book has destroyed me in so many ways, and not just because of the ending itself but because we have hyacinthus throughout the book showing us his world views on everything, his grief, his own helplessness in life and how he sees the universe, we have his views on the essence of mortality and what it means to be human and temporary that i just…. CRIED, i feel like crying just writing this because of how deeply i resonated with him.
i saw myself in him so much, i feel that this book found me at the right time, i needed to read about how temporary and beautiful life can be even when you’re lost and don’t know what is the purpose to be alive but that you can still find happiness wether it be on a person or in something like music (in his case both lol). this is a tragic book, yes. but not for the initial reason you might think, its a retelling of a greek myth so ofc you know what’s going to happen if you’re into myths but the fact that THE thing only actually happened in the last few pages shows you that the saddest part of this book wasn’t actually death because “Maybe, after all, dying was not the Dog’s throw it was named to be, but the unavoidable toss that gracefully ended the game. Gods were granted no such clean severance.”
as much as i wished this book was even longer, i’m glad it ended this way, id have no emotional capacity to read Apollo grieving even more than what we saw of him by the ending. this book was amazing, i can’t even put into words how much i loved it. all my attempts of writing this review can’t do it justice, PLEASE just read it, you will not regret it. but also sophia…. can’t believe you didn’t let him see the sea >:| that was CRUEL!!!!!! “Today, I thought. There would be no more waiting, day after day; no more endless tomorrows, blotting themselves like ink stains on my life.” anyway i’d give it more stars if there was the option!
(tried to keep this as spoiler free as possible but oh well)
also minor editing, just forgot to comment on how PHENOMENAL the writing was, honestly amazing. this is definitely one of the best books i’ve ever read, i agree with the comment that said every phrase felt like it was poetry, every metaphor so beautiful and well written. i want to inject this book in my veins for how beautifully it was written !!!!!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
For someone who took forever to finish the book, I am utterly heartbroken and destroyed by a book I knew the ending to because I knew the myth (pjo came in clutch). Each sentence really is a bind that keeps you from looking away, beautifully written (by the beautiful author🥹) and beautifully heartbreaking.
i havent felt this BAD since i read TSOA wich is GREAT!! the whole story is just a piece of art i literally devoured it in a week (wich is AMAZING as a slow reader). I LOVED APOLLO?? i usually dont like him in books but this time he was very cutesy. the whole books i cozy AND traumatic so its absolutely worth every moment with it
Such a beautiful and tasteful retelling of Hyacinthus and Apollo. Every line read like poetry. Leokles mentioning discus in the beginning was gut wrenching 5 stars. I’m so happy i found this book. Absolutely masterful down to every reference
This is the best book I think I've ever read. It takes me a bit to find a book that I'm fully into, but this book caught my attention fast. I finished this in class today and started crying. MID CLASS. I genuinely love the writing style, and now that I've finished it, I don't know what to do. I feel empty knowing it's done. I'm not one to reread books -- I've never done it before -- but this book might just be an exception that I'll make. I'm unable to put into words the raw emotions I felt while reading it. I started crying when LEOKLES died. Just imagine how it was when the same happened to Hyacinthus. The descriptions made me feel as though I was there, being told the story from Hyacinthus himself. To the author, If you see this, please write more books. it pains me knowing that this is the only one you've written.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Absolutely loved this! Greek mythology retellings are so special when the author manages to make the story feel much more intimate and alive, and this author really captured that.
This book was truly a beautiful read; I can only hope that it receives all the attention it deserves. The author not only had such a descriptive and lovely writing style, but everything about this book had me completely immersed and I’m glad to say I was unable to put it down. The emotional depth in this writing, as well as the complexity of Hyacinthus was regarded with such wonderful detail as well. As someone who loves books and has read around 20 this year, I had to make an account just to leave a positive review on this book—it is entirely deserving of all the good reviews it receives and so much more! I am excited to see what else this author has in store and I will certainly be buying her other books as well.
there is no possible way that i can even begin to describe the rush of emotions this book filled me with. the joy, the love, and the utterly devastating truth that it would end, that these tragedies really do remain the same.
so for starters, i was playing sufjan stevens and the lines ‘my black shroud’ kept repeating and it was already making me tear up, but then as i came to the last chapter, fourth of july started playing in my headphones, with the opening lines:
‘the evil it spread like a fever ahead / it was night when you died, my firefly / what could i have said to raise you from the dead? / oh, could i be the sky on the fourth of july?’
you can already imagine the dread this filled me with. it was like a confirmation for me, a finality. that, like all things, this must end too. my heart was too heavy yet so empty and i grieved. i grieved because this boy i had come to see myself in, this love and this life—which felt as much as mine as his—was gone.
the most beautiful thing about this book was it's prose. the author has such a beautiful, loving way of describing things, people, and situations that makes them seem so much more tender. i couldn't say they struck me as beautiful, it's more that her words wrapped around me, encasing me whole. every line felt like a work of poetry, and as a somewhat writer myself, i was so awfully jealous. this book rekindled my love for greek mythology, reminding me why i loved it in the first place.
i saw myself so much in hyacinthus, and i grew to love him so, so much because of it. his pure innocence as a child, his solidarity and silence, everything about him made me feel like i was looking through a mirror. hyacinthus' complete detachment from his family and the way he describes them...too much for me. these lines especially made me want to tattoo them into my heart and scream until my throat hurt,
“but i wanted more. that was a thing about me—my entire life, i always wanted more than i had, and i searched for it until i drove myself and everything around me into the ground.”
“i dreamed. i dreamed for the first time since i was fifteen, filled with wonder and hope that something might still bloom for me.”
“the things you love, you love with all of your heart, all of the time. if you are not an ocean, then you are nothing.”
and the abruptness with which hyacinthus died, it makes you read the lines over and over again, and think ‘what could've changed? what could have been? what could anyone have done?’ it is written in such a devastatingly tragic way that you cannot help but grieve for him, for the both of them.
i fear anything i say will still not be enough to explain simply how much i adored this book. i couldn't bring myself to read more than a chapter a day because of how sad it made me. i felt everything in it so deeply, and i have so much respect for the author, because there is just no way this is a debut novel. this is one book that i think will continue to stay with me throughout my whole life. sophia g. ammari, i will gladly read everything you continue to write for literally forever. i love you 🙁
So usually whenever a book makes me upset I say “AUTHOR WHEN I CATCH YOU😡” except the author of this book is one of my bestfriends so I will literally catch you.. watch out Sophia
Anyways THIS BOOK WAS PHENOMENAL. I quite literally can’t put it into words. The absolute talent this wonderful author has is absurd. The writing style was so beautiful, from the very first sentence you get enthralled. I could barely put the book down because I NEEDED to find out what happened next. Our main character Hyacinthus is so dear to me, getting to read about how he was raised and how his story progressed made me feel ALL the emotions😭 This was my first time reading about this myth and if you don’t know it already GO IN BLIND!! The plot twists hit so hard I felt like I was actually getting punched.
My absolute favorite part of this book were the hidden metaphors. The second I finished the book I had to sit and think about everything because it all wraps up perfectlyyyy. You can definitely tell there was a lot of thought put into the themes in this book and all the small details you initially glance over all come rushing back after the ending. I could not think of a single thing I would critique about this book, Ms. Sophia Ammari is actually a genius. The pacing was excellent, there wasn’t a single time I was bored and everything written was valuable to either the plot or the background of these amazing characters.
If you haven’t bought this book yet… what are you doing!! This masterpiece is worth all the money and time, I will be thinking about this story for a long time. I am so grateful to be among the first readers and getting to experience her writing this. She makes me so proud 🙈
INFINITY STARS OBVIOUSLYYY
🪻“Hyacinthus, she called him. It was a name of the people, and ancestral in every way.” 🪻
I had mixed feelings about this book. The author spent so much time on the chemistry between Hyacinthus and Leokles that I became more attached to their bond than to the one between Apollo and Hyacinthus. Leokles is introduced in the early chapters and given plenty of page time, only for the author to kill him off abruptly, almost absurdly. One moment he is surviving, and the next he dies of blood loss in the middle of telling Hyacinthus his story. After so much buildup, the death felt more jarring than tragic.
That said, Hyacinthus himself is a very well-written character. I empathized with his story, and the writing put me in his place and his point of view. The river he goes to in order to relieve his stress and isolate himself from the world is a beautifully written moment. It lets the reader feel his emotions without making the pressure on a teenager seem overwhelming.
His first meeting with Apollo is an interesting introduction and good character development. Apollo starts out cold and gradually becomes clingy and soft toward Hyacinthus, which is heartwarming. But beyond Apollo offering immortality, what else really happens between them? The timeline skips a lot, and scenes that could have been shown on the page are explained in detail instead. As a result, the story reads like a dragged-out essay. I felt like I was reading an answer to an essay question rather than living inside the story.
Still, Hyacinthus’s death is beautifully executed. I can’t find another word for it. It captures the reality that mortals, in the end, must die.
The best Greek mythology retelling story that I’ve ever read! The author has such a great talent to take you to Sparta and make you live the story, and feel every little feeling that Hyacinthus experiences. I also loved the book cover, knowing that the author designed it, what a great talent! I enjoyed reading this book a lot and I recommend that you also read it and enjoy it!
AWEE so cuteeee da babies are so in loveee aww look at them playyy AWEE yes Brain: you know what’s coming Noo I dontttt— heheh so cuteeee da babies aww they play together and laughing together aw look-