New Orleans in the spring of 1976 smells like mildew, sin, and sea spray.
A relentless rainy season has filled the city with bad omens, but Keningale Perks ignores them all. All he wants is a chance to prove himself as an antiques appraiser. Meek, ambitious, and hopelessly underestimated, Keningale’s life changes the moment he lays eyes on the Throbbing Idol, an artifact so elusive that most experts believe it exists only in legend. According to legend, the idol grants immortality to whoever possesses it.
The legend is true. It just leaves out the horror. The idol creates blood-feeding immortals with fiery eyes and living shadows at their heels.
Told through three converging perspectives, the novel follows Keningale, his closest friend Pearl, and the ancient immortals whose history binds them both.
When Keningale refuses to feed, starvation drives his shadow to the surface. As it begins to take control, Keningale undergoes a horrific transformation that threatens his humanity and the very awareness that makes him who he is.
Paul Glyph writes stories where myth and memory meet under strange skies in his spare time. Rooted in New Orleans, he draws from real life, folklore, history, cussing saints, and praying sinners. His work blends dark humor, emotional depth, and the spirit of the American imagination.
He wrote Fantastical Nature, a family fantasy novella for his son, Michael, whose wonder never fails to remind him that creativity is the truest kind of magic. His Weird Western, The God in the Dirt, explores the haunted borderlands of mythic horror, surreal fantasy, and gunslinger theater. The Echo of It All is his supernatural horror novel set in 1976 New Orleans that explores immortality, identity, and what remains after everything else has become an echo.
After reading the first few chapters, I was unsure whether I would continue because it seemed to be more comical and juvenile than expected. Although I needed a more lighthearted novel after my last read, I wasn’t sure if it was the time for me to read this specific book. Ultimately, I decided to read the first ten chapters in order to make a decision on the matter.
I had a hard time believing the identity of the protagonist. Therefore, when his character traits abruptly changed, it was unconvincing.
The story unraveled fairly quickly, leaving little room for suspense or further explanations. And sad to say, the holes in the plot began early on. The characters miraculously develop opinions and acquire information about other characters, out of what seems to be thin air; this is baffling. The book was not just fast-paced, it was difficult to follow.
This book was underdevelopment and the storyline was inconsistent, causing me to lose interest. “The Echo of it All” by Paul Glyph is a 1 out of 5.
I have to admit that I’m not usually good at reading horror books, but this one—and especially this author—has completely changed my mind.
What impressed me most is the way the author approaches the horror genre and builds the entire story around 1976 New Orleans, weaving American folklore into the narrative while still respecting the traditions of literary horror. And then come the unexpected twists, which kept me guessing.
When you first start reading, you might think, “What? Another popcorn vampire story?” But once you invest a few chapters and keep going, you will be rewarded.
Keningale’s transformation, the conflict between good and evil, and a story that isn’t often told in quite this way are all handled remarkably well. The author somehow manages to make every character feel vivid, strange, and perfectly fitted into the larger story. I was genuinely impressed.
And there is something even older lurking beneath it all—something that feels older than New Orleans itself.
A must-read for supernatural horror fans, especially for anyone looking for something beyond the usual horror story.
"The Echo of It All" is a really atmospheric story, it just wasn't fully my thing. It was definitely a well-written book and I’m glad I finished it. The premise sounded amazing from the start, and the atmosphere was easily my favorite part. I love stories set in New Orleans and the author really captured that heavy, rainy season mood. The writing flows really well, and the characters are interesting and well written. There is a lot happening in the plot, and by the end, the story kinda lost me. If you love highly atmospheric, supernatural horror stories rooted in New Orleans folklore, you should definitely give this one a read. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Living in New Orleans, I’m already interested when a horror story is set here. Putting it in the 1970s makes it even more appealing. What really interests me, though, is the fear of becoming someone you don’t recognize. That gets under my skin much more than a monster on its own. The questions about identity and desire give the supernatural premise something personal. I love a horror idea that makes you wonder what you would do—and whether you’d actually have as much control as you think.