Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Bad Beginnings #2

Beneath Us, Solid Ground

Rate this book
Almost dying wasn’t how Max Dion had planned to start this day. In fact, a car accident leaving him stranded in a new city, friendless, and down part of a leg wasn’t how Max Dion planned to start any day. But, well, here he was.

The only silver lining was that a paramedic who happened to be passing by the accident seemed to be making it his mission to help Max out.

Lucas Gustafsson hadn’t been able to shake the mental image of the man he helped save after a gruesome accident. Checking on him in the hospital seemed harmless, but before Lucas knew it, he was offering his spare room and his medical expertise to help get Max back on his feet.

Neither man had really considered the realities of recuperating from a traumatic amputation, and they find themselves thrown together both emotionally and physically.

Romance wasn’t meant to be part of the agreement. Is their situationship merely a convenience that will end when Max is ready to live on his own…or is this forever?

Beneath Us, Solid Ground is an open-door MM romance centered around hurt/comfort and forced proximity. It features a surprisingly nerdy ex-stripper coming to terms with limb loss and a do-gooder paramedic who would do anything for him.

254 pages, Kindle Edition

Published August 31, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Opal Andrews

3 books12 followers
OPAL ANDREWS is a 40-something professional living in the eastern United States. She’s always been a storyteller - many, many NaNoWriMos and fanfics have been written in the past - and has finally decided to pursue publishing her work. She’s passionate about LGBTQIA+ rights and stories. She’s also a total homebody, and when she’s not writing you can usually find her curled up with a cup of tea, reading, crocheting, and/or snuggling with her cats.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
21 (38%)
4 stars
21 (38%)
3 stars
11 (20%)
2 stars
1 (1%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
Profile Image for Joyfully Jay.
9,650 reviews539 followers
September 8, 2026
A Joyfully Jay review.

4 stars


Beneath Us, Solid Ground is the second story in Opal Andrews’ Bad Beginnings series, though this absolutely works as a standalone. It’s set in modern-day San Francisco and tackles some big themes, including traumatic injury, power imbalance (and/or the perception thereof), and failure to communicate. Narration is shared between Max and Lucas in first person and, while at times a bit repetitive, helps establish both characters’ pattern of not talking about significant interpersonal issues for fear of rejection.

I found it surprisingly easy to suspend my disbelief at Lucas taking in Max, a complete stranger with no job or any support system to speak of. Even when it seemed like Lucas is only acting on tremendous sympathy for Max’s situation, getting to read exactly how screwed Max is from Max’s own perspective really primed me to accept that moving in with a stranger was the best bet. At the same time, Lucas was very aware of how not-ideal it was for Max to live with him.

Read Camille’s review in its entirety here.
2,028 reviews11 followers
September 29, 2026
4.5 stars
I enjoyed Lucas and Max’s story, the characters drew me in right away and had me invested in their developing relationship. What drew me to the book originally was the fact that Max was an amputee. My cousin was a single amputee for years and recently had to have his other leg removed, and that connection made me want to see how the author handled the traumatic amputation with Max, the things he was feeling, and the physical changes and accommodations he had to make as he adjusted to his new circumstances. Although I wasn’t around my cousin much, the reports I got from family pretty much validated many feelings expressed by Max, his altered sense of self, the frustration with his body not functioning as he was used to, the way other people looked at him (or at least how he perceived that), and the gradual adjustment he made to his new reality. Lucas’s support was so essential to those first few months when Max couldn’t do as much for himself as he expected, the understandable frustration and anger that grew out of that, and the way Lucas could calm Max down with a touch or a quiet word spoke to the love and care Lucas had for this man who had been a stranger at the beginning. I could identify with Max’s frustration over simple things like then height of kitchen and bathroom counters, fixture placements in bathrooms, even trying to take a shower was an adventure. I could remember my cousin talking about these things and about remodels that could make the life of an amputee more accessible and useful for everyday tasks, things the average person would seldom give a thought to.

I liked the interaction between Max and Lucas most of the times, but the amount of miscommunication and “in- head talking” they each did frustrated me at times. I wanted to yell at them “sit down and talk about it, don’t project your thoughts on the other person!!” The two men could be so articulate at times about what they wanted, but sharing what they wanted for a relationship just got bogged down in their doubts. I really wanted to shake them and tell them to wake up and really talk to each other. Predictably, the finally did.

I think the author did a good job with the feelings Max went through after he woke up post-surgery, through the frustrations of his body not functioning as he was used to, and the additional limitations due to the other broken leg which delayed his overall recovery with PT and OT until his “good” leg could be weight-bearing. The group therapy offered him a way to process his thoughts and feelings with a group which understood him and his frustrations, and they were able to help Max and ease the way in some areas. The place Max and Lucas were in at the conclusion had a satisfied smile on my face as they looked forward to their HEA. The book is one which I think raised some good points about the limitations in life for an amputee, but it also stressed seeking out others like you in a support group to help process the whole experience, and the importance of being true to yourself and who you are and not let the perceptions of others drag you down.

260 reviews1 follower
September 11, 2026
Beneath Us, Solid Ground presents a contemporary MM romance built around trauma, recovery, emotional vulnerability, and the unexpected development of love. Max Dion's life changes dramatically after a serious accident leaves him dealing with limb loss while stranded in a new city. His difficult circumstances create an emotionally grounded starting point for a story about rebuilding both independence and trust.

Lucas Gustafsson brings another important dimension to the story. As the paramedic who helps Max after the accident, his concern gradually develops into a deeper connection. His decision to offer Max a place to stay creates the forced proximity that brings both men together while also raising complicated questions about dependence, boundaries, kindness, and emotional responsibility.

The hurt and comfort elements give the romance considerable emotional depth. Max must navigate the realities of adjusting to his changed circumstances, while Lucas tries to support him without making Max feel indebted or incapable of standing on his own. Their attraction develops alongside humor, uncertainty, miscommunication, and the gradual realization that their connection may be more meaningful than either initially expected.

The novel also offers strong appeal for readers who enjoy contemporary MM romance with emotional recovery at its center. Its focus on limb loss, vulnerability, friendship, forced proximity, banter, emotional healing, and a developing relationship creates several points of connection for romance readers. The dual perspectives also provide insight into the fears and hopes shaping both characters.

With a Goodreads rating of 4.07 from 43 ratings and 37 reviews, Beneath Us, Solid Ground has already established an encouraging early reader presence shortly after its August 2026 release. The positive response from romance reviewers further highlights its appeal among readers interested in heartfelt MM romance, hurt and comfort stories, disability representation, and emotionally focused contemporary relationships.
Profile Image for Tara Baja.
Author 2 books4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
August 29, 2026
Beneath Us, Solid Ground is the first book I've read of Opal Andrews, and the second in her Bad Beginnings series. She thoughtfully provided trigger warnings beforehand and with that list, I was prepared for a super emotional story. The book starts out with a terrifyingly life changing accident! One of our MMC, Max Dion, has moved from New Hampshire to San Francisco to start a new job, and as he's on his way to his first day, while checking his phone, he gets hits by a drunk driver.

Fortunately, the nicest, sweetest, and hottest EMT, our second MMC, Lucas Gustafsson, arrives on the scene. Yet, unfortunately, the accident was very severe and Max wakes up in the hospital in absolute pain and minus half a leg. As well as a home. And a job. With no real support in a new city, he's ambivalently surprised when the EMT who helped save his life, becomes a frequent visitor at his hospital bedside. With the help of the hospital social worker, and despite being relative strangers, an arrangement is made for Max to move in with Lucas, while he rehabilitates.

You guys, there so much that happens throughout the book, especially with two attractive and attracted gay men in close proximity. Both good and bad, there's bound to be major miscommunication between strangers to roommates et.al., however, it still doesn't take away from how these two really feel about each other. I might have cried once and got misty eyed twice, so Opal gives us the right amount of emotion alongside some spicy spice! I'm thankful she and the Gay Romance Review provided an advanced reading copy in reciprocity of my honest review. Now I need to read the first book, and wait in anticipation for a potential 3rd! 5⭐
Profile Image for Bere Peltier .
216 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy
July 28, 2026
This was hands down the best MM romance I've read this month and that's saying something because I've already read 18 books! I can't recommend it enough.

I went into this completely blind without even reading the blurb, so I had no idea what was coming, and I'm so glad I did. Every chapter had me eager to keep reading, and the story kept surprising me in the best possible way.

The vulnerability between these two characters was absolutely beautiful. The way they allowed themselves to be seen by each other made my heart ache in the best way. The miscommunication hurt so much, but honestly, it felt incredibly realistic. As a therapist who occasionally works with couples, I see relationships like this all the time, and that made their struggles feel even more authentic.

While I don't think everything developed organically right at the beginning, the emotional journey was so genuine that I'd happily reread this book over and over again. The longing and pining? Absolutely perfect.

There were a few moments that gave me a little secondhand embarrassment because the sweetness overload was real and I'm a cold, smut loving sl*t but that didn't stop me from completely falling in love with this couple.

Watching them support each other through the medical challenges was incredibly moving. Seeing the MMC attend therapy, slowly heal, and learn that his worth hadn't changed despite everything he had gone through was one of the most beautiful parts of the book. His journey felt honest, hopeful, and deeply emotional.

This book completely stole my heart. I can't recommend it enough, and I'm already looking forward to rereading it in a few months.
Profile Image for Ashley Carrillo.
422 reviews1 follower
September 3, 2026
Max never for one second thought his life would end up this way. An ex stripper with a past he walked away from and now he's in an accident in a new city with no friends, support or somewhere to go that can care for him while he's recovering from an amputation because of his accident. He doesn't know what to do but when Lucas, a paramedic who happened to be at the right place at the right time finds Max and gets him help. Now he finds himself wanting to do more for him besides visiting him in the hospital and keeping him company. He shouldn't but he finds himself not able to walk away from Max and offers to let him stay wirh him at his house. This is all so new and different for both of them especially Max as his whole world is now altered and he has to get used to a new reality where he has to heal physically and mentally from the trauma. And to make matters even more complicated both men seem to have developed a complicated attraction to the other as well as feelings. Now together they must navigate so many big and hard emotions while going through a whole lige change. Neither man is the best at communicating or talking things out and instead find themselves wanting and pining and wishing from a far. But that can't go on forever especially if they want to keep what they've found in each other. This is my first book by this author and I'm looking foward to reading more.
Profile Image for Rochelle Murray.
1,398 reviews146 followers
Review of advance copy
August 27, 2026
There's the miscommunication trope, and then there's whatever these two dummies are doing. Tropes include idiots in love, hurt/comfort, mutual pining, forced (chosen?) proximity, IKEA furniture fights...

I appreciate the author's note at the beginning about the disability rep and how everyone's journey is different and that the timeline in this book represents what's really a best case/no complications scenario. I felt like it showed the author did their research on the topic, and Max's struggle to come to terms with his disability, recovery, and what it means for his self-worth (which was already pretty low) really touched me.

I loved both Max (even though he's a bit of a grumpapotamous) and Lucas, even though I wanted to bonk their heads together SEV-ER-AL times and be like "OMG just TALK to each other already, dangit!" and even by the end I don't think they've really gotten any better at communicating at all... Please give these two some anxiety meds and enroll them in a Crucial Conversations class!

This is the second book in the Bad Beginnings series, and can be read as a standalone. I looked up book 1 and I don't think the MCs in that one are even in this one, as far as I could tell.
96 reviews
August 31, 2026
A sweet story about coming to terms with losing a part of yourself and being the person that helps someone through that.

Max has a life altering accident after moving across the country leaving him in a predicament. Unable to start his new job and no with to where to live while adjusting to life post amputation? Not what he had planned for his life.

Lucas is an EMT and after helping a man hit by a car on the street he feels invested. He did expect to get a new roommate out of the situation and he probably isn't co pletely prepared for helping someone through this type of thing. All he can do it his best and be there for Max.

Somewhere between physical therapy and support group meetings, quite dinners, trivia pursuit and Natural Detective they grow from being acquaintances to friends to maybe something more. When Max decides its time for him to step out on his own will the rug be pulled from underneath them or will they find themselves on solid ground?

This book was sweet. There were obvious hardships and lots of poor communication, but things rarely go smoothly when recovering from trauma. Max and Lucas gave me some laughs and a couple tears, but it is a book I would gladly pick up again.

Happy reading
Profile Image for Shawna.
2,409 reviews33 followers
Review of advance copy
August 12, 2026
I am a sucker for a book with caretaking and forced proximity. While I recognize the miscommunication (non-communication, sometimes) went on a bit, and it is many people's least favorite thing in romance, I felt that the circumstances warranted it. The situation was unexpected and precarious, and Max really did have to rely on Lucas a lot out of nowhere, after taking care of himself for a long time. So, I can understand the hesitance on both their parts to make declarative statements after such a short time in a fraught situation.

Overall, I thought this was a sensitive depiction of this scenario; the author clearly did research, and I was rooting for them to figure it out.

I only wish we'd gotten a scene with Max blow drying Lucas's hair; I really thought it was going to happen, but alas. Even so, I'd recommend this heartily. Thanks to GRR for the review copy!
Profile Image for Ann-Marie.
186 reviews1 follower
September 1, 2026
4.5 ⭐️

❤️‍🩹 MM Romance
❤️‍🩹 Forced Proximity
❤️‍🩹 Hurt/Comfort
❤️‍🩹 Miscommunication

You should do yourself a favor and read this if you love forced proximity, hurt/comfort, and, of course, the good old miscommunication trope.

I wasn’t sure what to expect going into this book, but once I started reading, I found myself not wanting to put it down. This is a really good hurt/comfort story about Max, who was in an accident that resulted in him losing one of his legs, and Lucas, who was the first person on the scene.
There were definitely times when I just wanted to yell at them to TALK to each other so they could finally realize how they both felt about each other. None the less I did in enjoy watching them get their HEA ❤️

Definitely one I would recommend if you enjoy forced proximity, hurt/comfort, and a little bit of miscommunication angst.

Happy reading! 📚💛
Profile Image for Deb Kel.
3,309 reviews16 followers
September 3, 2026
This was such a heartfelt hurt/comfort romance. Max goes through an absolutely devastating life change, and I really appreciated how his recovery was allowed to be messy, frustrating and emotional rather than something he simply moved past.

Lucas was impossible not to like, and I loved the way his initial instinct to help Max gradually became something much deeper. Having them share a home gave their relationship plenty of opportunity to develop, with all the awkwardness, attraction and misunderstandings that came with it. Their connection felt especially sweet because there was so much genuine care underneath everything.

There were definitely moments that had me reaching for the tissues, but the story also had plenty of warmth and spice to balance the heavier parts. Max and Lucas completely won me over.
3,443 reviews23 followers
September 3, 2026
Things do not start out well for Max. Mostly. He was in an accident that was serious and resulted in him losing part of a limb changing his life in ways that would never go away. But Lucas came to help as a paramedic and then hung around and visited Max in the hospital, eventually offering Max a place to stay and assistance as he is adjusting to his new normal. A friendship develops and more between these two over time. What they didn't get right from the beginning was communication which meant they pined a bit more than they needed to had they talked to one another. But this is a sticky situation and the meaning of feelings could have been confusing as assistance turned to more, as accepting help turned to wanting something else. I gave them credit for getting there in a complex situation.
I received an ARC from GRR and am voluntarily leaving a review.
124 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 29, 2026
Maybe it’s just impossible to imagine what it’s like to be in Max’s shoes, but as we read, he gives us so much insight without actually saying it outright that you can feel his pain between the lines—and eventually right in your own chest. I’m glad he met Lucas—the guy is just a total softie through and through. No one else could have caught him. No one else could have given him what he so desperately needs, and in the end, that’s what provides a solid foundation for them.
An emotional but not saccharine story. I was honestly pleasantly surprised that, while it admittedly assumes an ideal healing process, it was nevertheless described so authentically that you couldn’t help but empathize.
Well worth reading, without any contrived drama and with plenty of heart.
988 reviews7 followers
September 2, 2026
A great Second book in the series that I actually liked more than the first one and I liked it. This book about Max, the ex stripper and Lucas, the dogooder paramedic had me from the first. I love how well written Max and the disability he had was written and portrayed. You don’t often see that. Be prepared this book is driven by not outside forces, but driven by the fact, the two men simply can’t communicate despite their chemistry and feelings for one another. If that is a problem for you, you might not like it, but I loved it. It’s a feel good romance about how we can overcome trauma and hurt and comfort to find love. And I will say Lucas is the kind of person we all would love to have in our life.
5,210 reviews19 followers
September 12, 2026
Intense! Max is involved in car accident that ends with an amputation, a long recovery and stranded in a new unfamiliar town, knowing absolutely no one. A lot to work through. Lucas, a paramedic passing by, stops saves him, visits him in the hospital and offers temporary lodging while Max recovers. Great story of recovery and the struggle to get to accepting a new physical, emotional and mental reality. Lucas, is drawn and compelled to help and we grow to realize these two men are exactly who they need at the right time. This story really pulls at your heart and brings you along the journey of these tow men creating a new comfort zone. Well done, good cover art, great flow, handled with sensitivity and understanding. I received an ARC and am voluntarily leaving a review.
Profile Image for Michelle N..
298 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy
August 29, 2026
Beneath Us Solid Ground is the second book in Opal Andrews’ Bad Beginnings Series and it delivers. This is such a well written and unique story. When Max is hit by a car, he finds himself in a new city, without any support, without a place to go, and without much hope. Until paramedic, Lucas, offers to step in and help him out. Lucas was on the scene of the accident and has checked in on Max during his hospital stay. As a friendship grows between Max and Lucas, feelings develop as well. This is a great hurt/comfort story with some difficult parts to read for poor Max. Andrews writes Max’s injury with care and dignity in a beautiful story.
I received an ARC for my honest review.
Profile Image for Kate.
307 reviews29 followers
Review of advance copy
August 29, 2026
Two men thrown into proximity after an accident that results in a leg amputation for one. Interesting premise. One is a carer, the other is a grump.

The plotting is what threw me. Many of the chapters were blow by blow minutiae that I think were intended to mark both the challenges and progress that Max was making living with his new disability. Occasionally we got bumped weeks forward, which felt fortunate.

But also the books seemed light on tension. There definitely were communication issues. But for a book with such a meaty subject and complex characters, that didn't feel like enough to me to be invested near the end.
Profile Image for Mir Jak.
624 reviews1 follower
September 4, 2026
Okay, so opening chapter is kinda graphic but it's not overly bloody & gorey in detail, rather something very very bad happened... then MC wakes up in hospital with life-changing results. And yes, he's rather angry and a grumpy git. I can't even imagine how to deal with that and everything else. Author has given a quite realistic picture and does make you think. As for the story, it's at times funny and awkward and frustrating - all at the same time. And miscommunications, man-oh-man, there's plenty but it does end with a HEA. Very good story - also, I haven't read book 1 but can safely say you can read this as standalone.
Profile Image for Amanda D.
802 reviews
September 13, 2026
Heavy, tender, one of the series' best entries.

Book two of Bad Beginnings, and it's a hurt/comfort, forced-proximity story that opens with Max Dion almost dying — the review tags mention amputation as part of his journey, so this is heavier trauma-recovery territory than a typical fluffy sequel. Reviewers are calling it a near-5-star standout in the series, for what that's worth.

This is one where I'd actually recommend starting with book one if you haven't, since a lot of the emotional weight is clearly building on established relationships. Not one to pick up if you're in a delicate headspace about medical trauma, but a strong entry if that's within your wheelhouse.
346 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy
July 31, 2026
Very solid hurt/comfort insta-romance, where Max, who's lost part of a leg after a car accident, moves in with Lucas, a paramedic, as he adjusts to a new way of living.

A lot of the minutiae is glossed over, with some time jumps, and I'm apparently not as big a fan of that genre as I thought. More, I really don't care for stories where all the conflict/drama comes about because the two lead characters just won't talk to each other. Still, I wanted the best for them, and I'm glad they got their happy ending, even if it seemed a little rushed.
Profile Image for Saskia Veldhuis .
2,496 reviews26 followers
September 1, 2026
An unusual reason for forced proximity, and clearly one where the author has really excelled in the research. While miscommunication isn't a favourite storyline for me, it actually made a lot of sense here - Max had been forced to be independent from a young age and was suddenly stuck with a life changing injury that kept him quite dependent on Lucas in multiple ways. I can't agree with the Ikea furniture though, I love putting it together. The road to healing was well portrayed, although even by the end I wasn't convinced the two MCs had really learnt to communicate.
Profile Image for Emeli Webb.
303 reviews62 followers
September 3, 2026

This was a good story, but these two suffer from one of my biggest pet peeves. They need to actually talk to each other!!! Good grief guys. Come on! Because of that fact, this is more of a three and a half star read. Pining and wishing while being in the same place and they almost screw it up. But it was a good story overall. Lucas becomes quickly attached to Max after offering him a place to stay and to help with his recovery. Max has some serious adjustments to learn after his accident but this story is more about them adjusting to each other than Max’s recovery
Profile Image for Fay MMBookworm.
3,282 reviews75 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 19, 2026
This is a beautifully written book by the author. It features Max who losses his leg in an accident with all his emotions included. This was a first read from the author and wont be the last.
My Full Blog Reviews Link
I received an GRR advance reader copy and this is my honest thoughts of the book.
3,724 reviews40 followers
August 31, 2026
I loved this book by Opal.
I received an ARC from her and GRR.
An accident led Max to meeting Lucas…and their ‘chance encounter’ led to them being roommates.

Max had just moved to San Francisco where he was about to start a job in IT.
Lucas was a paramedic who was an all around great guy.

Their living arrangements led them to share more than just a space…but their pasts and a foundation for a wonderful future.

I recommend this story to anyone who loves romance and HEA’s.
Profile Image for Traci S.
2,393 reviews15 followers
September 4, 2026
Thank you for the book, here is my honest opinion:
3.5⭐️I liked the characters and the the opening was a great start to Mac and Luc’s story. They are good together, a bit opposite attitude and a touch of grump sunshine, with a side of hurt comfort. I will say the main tension in the relationship being a lack of communication is a bit frustrating and there are stretches were you get a lots kind of boring details - like the furniture shopping. Nice HEA though, really liked these two together.
Profile Image for Dee Layton.
1,610 reviews30 followers
September 5, 2026
This was an absolutely amazing book. This is book two in The bad beginning series. This is the first time I've ever read anything but before Andrews and honestly it was something I'm so glad I did read.
This MM Romance was just a book that was absolutely amazing.
I did go back and read book one in the series first and let me tell you it's just as amazing as this one.
Overall I can't wait to see how this series continues
Profile Image for SJ.
1,619 reviews23 followers
September 5, 2026
This was equally parts sweet and steamy. This MM romance was fast-paced and an easy/quick heartwarming read. Max and Lucas were easy to get invested in. I really enjoyed how their grumpy + sunshine dynamic worked as well as the delicious forced proximity. I really enjoyed how their relationship developed. It's definitely a low angst feel-good hurt/comfort read.

Thank you, GRR and Opal Andrews, for the opportunity to read this book.
1,800 reviews11 followers
September 7, 2026
This story is well written and the characters are great! Imagine starting a new life in a new city, new job and all, just to have it swept away in an instant. Matt was so excited, until his world crashed and he was super lucky that Lucas was there and continued to be there. These guys needed to stop second guessing each other and communicate. Every time they did that the went forward in huge steps. I loved it!!! I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
593 reviews9 followers
Review of advance copy
July 26, 2026
This book had an interesting setup and promising characters, but there wasn't any meat to it. The two characters fell together (literally by accident), moved in together, bristled at each other unnecessarily for a while, and then ILYed at each other. Bottom line: not the author for me.

My thanks to Gay Romance Reviews for an advance copy of this book.
Profile Image for Amanda Reeves.
4,583 reviews47 followers
September 3, 2026
Beneath Us, Solid Ground is the second book in the Bad Beginnings series and can be read as a standalone. This is a close proximity, hurt/comfort, low angst read about Max and Lucas. This was an interesting storyline and was an original one for me, two men meet due to a horrible accident and they get a great partnership from it. I am really loving this series.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews