Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Frosty Pines Collection

Holly's Wish List

Not yet published
Expected 1 Dec 26
Rate this book
Every snowflake needs a place to land, and every icy cowboy deserves a love to warm his heart.

Christmas obsessed Holly Lockhart lives a seemingly perfect life in Tampa, yet she wishes for a Lockhart-style love that feels like home. To find it, she must swallow her pride and return to Frosty Pines—the gossipy holiday-themed small town she fled at eighteen. When Holly is forced out of her childhood room by a family of raccoons, the Lockhart Ranch and Tree Farm manager comes to the rescue armed with a cozy guest room, a spotted, treat obsessed diva of a companion, and a grumpy attitude she can’t resist.

Dante Finch has secretly loved Holly since her family took him in over a decade ago, but his troubled upbringing leaves him feeling unworthy of her sparkle. Between holiday chaos on the reindeer ranch and his silent acts of kindness, Holly realizes that the teenage boy she once knew has grown into a hunky cowboy who checks every box on her wish list. Together,

the stubborn-as-a-mule graphic designer and stoic rancher must let go of their pasts and insecurities to finally take what they deserve from Holly’s Wish List.

Holly’s Wish List is a grumpy cowboy x snowflake princess reverse-age gap holiday romance with daddy vibes, tons of spice, and a happily ever after.

165 pages, Kindle Edition

Expected publication December 1, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Lyra Asher

6 books65 followers
Lyra Asher is an indie author with a love for all things romance, fantasy and happily ever afters. When she’s not creating compelling worlds filled with smut and obsessive MCs, she spends her days with her fur-baby, sipping tea or coffee while reading through her never ending ‘to be read’ pile. She has thousands of ideas for stories running through her head that she attempts to write out as quickly as humanly possible.

You can find out more about Lyra, her upcoming novels and exquisite fanart on her socials.

Instagram- @author.lyra.asher

TikTok- @author.lyra.asher

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
12 (36%)
4 stars
18 (54%)
3 stars
3 (9%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews
Profile Image for Scarlet.
361 reviews16 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 15, 2026
I've never had a Christmas book or movie make me cry happy tears but this little novella managed to do so with no regrets. Dante's past truly struck my heart strings and he added so much emotional depth within the read. Holly is what everyone expects from a christmas novella lots of cheer and christmas spirit for everyone around her but the thing I didnt expect was the level of compassion this woman held and how no matter how little Dante thought of himself wouldn't take it for an answer. I truly enjoyed this read from beginning to end and will be checking out more of Lyra Asher's work in the nearby future. If you've ever had a wish for a cowboy to spoil you with acts of love and wanted to ride cowboy for Christmas then this is the read for you. Highly Recommend! I got this arc via the author and this is my voluntary review.
Profile Image for Minnie.
1,359 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 12, 2026
ARC review

4⭐|3🌶️|23%🌶️frequency

Operation: Ride a cowboy for Christmas 😎

This is one book of the "Frosty Pines Collection". They can be read in any order.

Oh, Dante... 🥺 He's a broken cowboy. He has such a huge heart, but he didn't have a good childhood. He's the kind of man every woman wishes for, and still he thinks nobody wants him 😭

The fact that Holly isn't "just" his best friend's sister; she's also his boss' daughter makes things a bit complicated 🙈

I loved all the tiny things like him having a mini pig. Or his general connection with animals like Delilah, an albino reindeer 🥰

This was the first book I've read by this author. But I'll definitely check her other books.

I'm going to read another book in this series, because I already love this small town and I'm curious who will appear again 😎

As always, I wrote this review instantly after reading the book, and that's already a little while ago. So everything I was saying in present tense is now past tense 😉

Thanks to the author for providing me with an ARC 🩷


Follow me on IG for more
https://www.instagram.com/minnie.love...
Profile Image for Monzerrad.
250 reviews3 followers
November 15, 2026
𝗥𝗲𝘃𝗶𝗲𝘄 𝗼𝗳 𝗮𝗱𝘃𝗮𝗻𝗰𝗲𝗱 𝗰𝗼𝗽𝘆 𝗯𝘆 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗮𝘂𝘁𝗵𝗼𝗿

I had such a fun time reading this one! Holly’s Wish List was such an entertaining, sweet, and spicy holiday romance. I really enjoyed following Holly and Dante’s story, and these two kept me entertained from beginning to end. Their personalities, the banter, and the chemistry between them made it so easy to keep turning the pages.

I especially loved Dante. There’s just something about a big, grumpy cowboy with a soft spot for the people he loves that gets me every time. And Holly brought so much personality to the story. I enjoyed their interactions, their little moments together, and watching their relationship develop. They made me smile, laugh, and definitely blush along the way!

I also loved the Christmas atmosphere throughout the story. It gave me all those cozy holiday romance vibes, with a little extra spice to make things even better. This was such a fun read, and I definitely enjoyed my time with these characters.
Profile Image for Breony Cradock.
69 reviews
November 16, 2026
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Holly’s Wish List by Lyra Asher

A grumpy cowboy, a Christmas-loving heroine and a small town full of holiday chaos? Honestly, what’s not to love? 😂🎄

I had such a soft spot for Holly and Dante. Holly returning to Frosty Pines and finding herself back around the people and memories she left behind made for such a lovely setup.

And Dante! A man who’s secretly loved Holly for years but struggles to believe he’s good enough for her. I loved that quieter, softer side to him, especially when it came through in the little things he did for her.

Their story has that lovely mix of Christmas magic, teasing, romance and emotional moments. I also couldn’t help smiling at the reindeer ranch chaos and the raccoon situation!

I really enjoyed the combination of a grumpy cowboy and a Christmas-loving snowflake princess. It was sweet, steamy and full of the festive romance I love.

Definitely a five-star Christmas romance for me. ❤️🎄
Profile Image for Briana Scott.
657 reviews21 followers
Review of advance copy
November 13, 2026
ARC Review
First I would like to say a big thank you to Lyra for letting me be a part of this ARC Team!
Rate: 5/5⭐️
Spice: 2.5/5🌶️

What to expect when reading;
-Novella
-Ranch Manager x Owners Daughter
-Reverse Age Gap
-Forced Proximity
-Snowflake Princess x Burly Cowboy

This book is part of the Frosty Pine Novella Collection. In this book you get to follow Holly and Dante! Holly is coming home for the holidays and she only has one thing on her Christmas list this year and it’s a hunky cowboy! Let me tell you all of the Christmas slang/ innuendos were seriously the best! This slow burn had a high payoff because wow these two were oh so hot! I loved how Holly teased this man, they were such fun characters, with such great chemistry. This definitely put me in the Christmas spirit lol Great holiday novella, definitely a must read 🙌

Side notes;
-Christmas in the Country by Thomas Rhett
-Marsha🤭

Fav Quotes;
-“Getting rid of you is not on my agenda”
-“He just stands with you”
Profile Image for Jolliejjbooks.
58 reviews
November 18, 2026
Thank you very much to Ashtyn Kiana to select me for the ARCs the Frosty Pines series.

I started off enjoying this book a lot. It had lots of humor. It very much gave me Yellowstone Vibes, and Dante was almost like Rip Wheeler, and since he’s my favorite character I didn’t mind at all. Spice was suggested early on, and when it finally happened….It was a little repetitive to me. It didn’t feel realistic to me at all, and since it wasn’t a fantasy it made me scrunch my nose a bit instead of enjoying it. Besides I’m not one to Yuck somebody’s Yum but ‘Daddy’ just isn’t for me. And after that everything moved suddenly rollercoaster fast. Almost like you’ve stood in line for an hour but the ride is over in under a minute.
Don’t get me wrong. I enjoyed it, it was a fun read but it did lose some points for me.
Profile Image for Natacha Tremblay.
19 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 12, 2026
I got this ARC as part of the Frosty Pines ARC Collection and it’s been a fun collection to read.

The novellas are all adorable and fun and festive.

This one specifically wasn’t fully my cup of tea, but I still had a fun time reading it. I struggled with the writing style, and some of the more cheesy holiday puns. I also wasn’t a huge fan of the pacing. - but still. It’s romance at Christmas, so even stuff that isn’t fully your cup of tea is still adorable and enjoyable.
Profile Image for Amy Low.
229 reviews3 followers
November 20, 2026
This was a cute cowboy romance with the grumpy/sunshine trope.
Holly came back to Frosty Pines for the Holidays to her parents’ Christmas farm. She missed the small-town Montana town with all the Christmas spirit and excitement of the town’s magic. 🎄

Dante works on Holly’s family’s reindeer farm. He has always been in love with Holly. When she came back home and her parents told him she is staying with him, he couldn’t believe his luck but he never told anyone about his love for Holly. He didn’t think he deserved her. 🩷❤️

This story was so cute, a little chaos with the family but a whole lot of Christmas shenanigans! 🤶🎅

This is a novella and there are 12 books in the Frosty Pines series. This book releases on Dec. 1
Profile Image for Hannah.
83 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 15, 2026
Holly's Wish List is a cute, spicy little christmas Novella that does everything it says on the tin. With Holly returning home for the festive break and no room at the inn because of those pesky trash pandas she has no choice but to stay with Dante, who has spent years crushing on her but never believed himself worthy of the princess.

Expect lots of flirting, a house pig, a fluffy pink robe that on a big burly man is anything but decent and plenty of light hearted festive fun sprinkled with a satisfying HEA.

A delightfully quick read that will leave you warm and cosy and mire than a little satisfied.
Profile Image for Wachi BookClub.
15 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 15, 2026
ARC received in exchange for an honest review.

Holly's Wish List was a Christmas blast! It's a fast-paced love story with all my favorite things: found family, age gap, winter wonderlands, and pet shenanigans. Oh! And let's not forget the hot stuff. 🔥

Since it's a novella, you might think everything happens pretty quickly, but let me tell you, this was a slow burn through and through. You're going to be just as hot and bothered as the main characters thanks to the super descriptive writing that makes you feel like you're actually right there in Frosty Pines.

All in all, a great start to the 12-book Frosty Pines Collection. I can't wait to read more! ✨
Profile Image for Colleen Hurley Jozwiak.
695 reviews2 followers
November 17, 2026
I want to thank the authors for this cute, fun, holiday romance collection! This was a cute holiday romance. Dante has harbored a crush on Holly, his bosses daughter! Holly has only been coming to town for the holidays and this year she’s staying with him thanks to her meddling parents and some cute raccoons!

Their chemistry and desire is everything we want in a passionate romance. His love and desire for her is kept hidden because he doesn’t think he deserves her but boy does he want her! Holly realizes he’s not a boy but a man and a whole lot of a man at that! This was a cute winter novella!
60 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 20, 2026
A quick, sweet, and feel-good romance!

This was such a fun and light read!

I liked was how Holly never seemed bothered by Dante's past. She didn't judge him or make him feel like he had to be someone else to deserve her love. Instead, she showed him genuine affection, care, and acceptance. There was something lovely about seeing someone love another person without constantly holding their past against them.

I also loved that Dante was already practically part of the family. Their marriage felt less like two people starting a life together and more like making something that was already there official. It was a sweet little detail that made their relationship even more enjoyable.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 20, 2026
Holy Jingle Bells! This was such a fun read with total Grinch vs. Elf vibes!

Holly is a fiery Christmas freak who misses her Colorado ranch, and her letter to Santa has just one request: BRING ME A COWBOY!

Enter Dante, a ranch hand who grew up neglected and abandoned but has secretly carried a crush on Holly for a decade. When her parents play matchmakers and convince her to stay in his new cabin (because her room has been invaded by raccoons), things get interesting!

Holly brings all the whimsy, teasing, and cozy, homey energy that Dante never realized he was missing. Their opposites-attract dynamic is so much fun, and the Christmas chaos makes this one an absolute holiday treat!
Profile Image for Zonia H.
179 reviews6 followers
November 15, 2026

Thank you to the author for the advance reader copy

This novella was fast-paced, which made it an easy read. I liked the Christmas ranch atmosphere to it. I wanted that coming home for Christmas feeling and this one definitely delivered. Dante had a troubled upbringing and found a family that truly cared for him when the Lockharts took him in.
Really liked Holly’s attitude in regard to knowing who she wanted and going for it. I think my favorite line of the book is the response Holly gives her dad when he finds out Holly and Dante got secretly married.
Profile Image for Nadia Railao.
34 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 18, 2026
Can anyone be more Christmassy than Holly Lockhart?

I received this book as an ARC reader, and I had so much fun reading it! Even though the story touches on some deeper topics, like feeling abandoned or being ashamed of not meeting other people's expectations, it never loses its fun Christmas spirit.
Beyond the spice and a few naughty conversations, this book made me laugh a lot with all its clever Christmas puns. They were so witty! Even as a non-native English speaker, I could understand and enjoy them.

This book has everything: Christmas, love, spice, and a reminder that you deserve to be loved for who you are.
Profile Image for Julie.
211 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 20, 2026
ARC review
Anecdotal thoughts while reading
Frosty Pines Collection
I love me a map! I just wish I could print it out to reference.
Reindeer ranch and tree farm ... fun!
"I was an independent, fiercely strong woman with an impressive résumé and an even more impressive heart." These are goals for any age!
"Material items were against the elf code; our wishes for Santa had to come from the heart’s truest desire." ... and that's how it should be
Seriously, raccoons?!?
🐖
Oh no, Delilah 😬
Such a cute story!
Profile Image for Balancedbookworm.
3 reviews
Read
November 15, 2026
ARC review. Holly decides it’s time to return home for the holidays at her parent’s reindeer farm in Montana. Holly is wishing for something different. Turns out the life she been hustling for has her home sick for all that home has to offer. Before she leaves, Holly returns to her childhood practise of wiring her wish list to Santa. It is the most magical time of year … have a read to see what happens in this fun holiday novella!
Profile Image for Nina.
9 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 17, 2026
Lucky enough to be an Arc reader for this book. I loved it, it’s cute, cozy, fun and contains a sexy cowboy. What more would you want from a Christmas story.
I devoured this in one go, such an easy read perfect if you’re looking for a great quick read.
Definitely will look for more from the author, the writing style sucked me in and made me want more.
You won’t go wrong with this, I would read this again.
83 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 11, 2026
ARC Review:

This was a great, quick holiday read. I love the confidence of Holly. However she shows some vulnerability with decisions regarding her coming home. I absolutely love Dante. He is such a behind the scenes giver and finally learns he is deserving. There is spice. There is also a cute little guard pig! Love the banter. Great book!
Profile Image for Naomi kimbrell.
93 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy
November 19, 2026
I thoroughly enjoyed this Christmas Romance novella, because it wonderfully festive, spicy and romancy.  The main charactets had a lot of depth to them and I loved the meddling family.  I wouldn't have minded more to this story, but I understand that it is meant as a novella.  If you need some extra Christmas spirit this is definitely a great book to read!
Profile Image for Jenna Miller.
541 reviews
November 12, 2026
I really liked Dante and Holly’s story! I loved Marshmallow the mini pig too. It was a sweet Christmas novella with some spice and a lot of build up. At times I thought the Christmas puns and jokes were a bit much but overall I really enjoyed it.
Profile Image for Steff.
103 reviews1 follower
November 18, 2026
Holly makes a list to Santa of all the things she wants in a man. She didn’t think she’d find it in her little brother’s best friend, Dante.

Cute, spicy, and cozy!

Found family ✔️
He fell first ✔️
Close proximity ✔️
Profile Image for Kristine Falla.
24 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
November 11, 2026
A perfect little holiday read 🎄❤️
Profile Image for Marina Torre.
159 reviews
November 13, 2026
This novel started magically, and was wonderful. About 67% of the way through, the story hit warp speed and I just had a hard time keeping up with the rapid progression of the story.
Profile Image for Beth Tate.
65 reviews9 followers
November 17, 2026
ARC Review

This book was so cute! It had the perfect amount of pages and the progression of events was perfect! I feel like I need me a Dante now!
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews