What do you think?
Rate this book
Tales from Foster High #7
A Way Back To Then
Snarky yet good-hearted Robbie DeCaro made his first appearance in the pages of Tales from Foster High: End of the Innocence, years after the loss of his first and only love. A New York transplant, Robbie now decides that his work is done in the town of Foster, and the time has come for him to leave Texas.
Returning to his childhood home on Long Island, Robbie reunites with his family members. Each using their own unique methods, they try in vain to help Robbie reset to a life he knew before he left it all for the fairy-tale love he found, then tragically lost.
As he remembers some of the darkest moments from his past, Robbie wonders if he’ll ever find the “after” in “happily ever after.”
Returning to his childhood home on Long Island, Robbie reunites with his family members. Each using their own unique methods, they try in vain to help Robbie reset to a life he knew before he left it all for the fairy-tale love he found, then tragically lost.
As he remembers some of the darkest moments from his past, Robbie wonders if he’ll ever find the “after” in “happily ever after.”
200 pages, Paperback
First published June 5, 2015
1 person is currently reading
254 people want to read
About the author
Robert Halliwell
2 books44 followersRobert Halliwell hails from the mysterious land of Ronkonkoma in the Island of Long and grew up dreaming of the day the dark, handsome Mediterranean prince of his dreams would whisk him away from the boring life he was accustomed to and to a land far, far away… from his mother. A magical place full of roller skates and rainbows called Xanadu. Unfortunately, that never happened, but he was instead whisked away to the dark kingdom of Florida and the “prince” turned out to be a very pale country bumpkin from Schenectady. Yes, it’s a real place. When he’s not spending the day writing, Robert can be found at home taking care of his two-legged daughter and four-legged furry children whilst viewing unhealthy amounts of QVC, much to the dismay of his husband, Kevin.
Robert is still waiting for Lynda Carter to sign the adoption papers he sent her in 1998.
Robert is still waiting for Lynda Carter to sign the adoption papers he sent her in 1998.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
August 7, 2016
Quite a pleasant surprise!
This book, the seventh in the Tales of Foster High series, breaks away from the two main characters, Kyle and Brad, and tells the story of Robbie DeCaro's return home to New York. If you recall from book six, 151 Days, Robbie is the second-hand store owner that befriends Kyle and Brad. When they move off to college he sell his store and returns to New York.
I had never really related to Robbie as a character in any off the Tales from Foster High and when I started this book I really didn't expect to enjoy it all that much. I didn't love it but I did enjoy reading it. There were plenty of laughs. Some drama but it never took it's self too seriously. It's not a long book but worth the quick read.
February 26, 2024
✰ 3.5 stars ✰
“No, not just marriage—love, period, is about sharing. You don’t keep the bad things away from the one you love; you show it to them in all its terrible glory.
But being in love, real love, isn’t a contest. It’s not about who has the least amount of problems. There are no winners or losers. You both should get to the finish line at the same time.”
If you've been a part of the Tales' verse, then Robbie DeCaro really needs no introduction. But, just because he doesn't need an intro, does not mean he doesn't deserve to have his story told in his own words - the past, the present, the future - all that made him into the person he was and what led him to become the person that he is.
Leaving behind the life of Foster and moving back to his home in Long Island, New York was probably the best break for Robbie - a chance to sit back and reflect on what he's lost over the years and the personality that he's shed since moving away. It's also this very step that gives him a chance and a choice to open up his heart again - even if it never starts off on the right foot or with the right person, either. 😟 How he was once this 'shy, quiet, somewhat cute twink back when I started my big gay adventure, but not the one anyone ever paid attention to' who eventually became this snarky and confident person, one who simply wants the world to leave him alone so that he can wallow in the grief of a broken heart that he can't seem to get over the pain it left behind. 💔💔
“There’s a piece of my heart that still cries every day.” I looked up at the faded coffered ceiling.
“I can’t be shattered again.” I turned my head to hide my tears.”
I like Robbie - I always have. I never minded how blatantly open he was with Tyler and Brad, I didn't mind that he never forgave those who hurt him, I never cringed at his brutally honest outlook at life, and I never saw him as a reclusive outcast who ran a clothing store - someone who's seen it all and lived to tell it. I lived for his sassy sarcasm, his snark, his twisted sense of humor - everything that made him such a pleasantly vindictive part of everyone's lives. 😥 'I was so bitter and bruised that it took a team of gay men, former alcoholics, and teenage boys to get me out of the depression I had been in for so long.' But by returning home, we get to see him shed that skin and see that vulnerable side of him - one that hid away those deep insecurities and uncertainties and those irrational fears that ate away at him while growing up. So, to see him finally accept both parts of himself - to accept that he can be sarcastic and still be human - still be soft-hearted, and still be angry - it was a healing process that he had shut himself off from for too long. ❤️🩹❤️🩹
Most of all, I saw him as someone who's been so deeply hurt that he won't ever allow himself to be happy again - even when he's someone who deserved a happy ending of his own. Someone who's seen so many fairy tales happily ever afters and all he wanted was one for himself. Well, we all know how that turned out. 😢 But, for someone who fought so fiercely to deny himself ever having a second chance at love again, it's only fair that we do get to see him finally have his moment in the rain and a prince charming to sweep him off his feet - or well, literally hit him where it hurts. Someone who finally melted Robbie's cold and closed-off heart. Someone who looked beyond that bitter resentment and hateful anger towards everyone and life and reminded him that he is not alone in being afraid of giving up his heart to someone else again. 🥺🥺
“I can’t explain it, but it just works.
Sebastian is exactly what I need.”
From the way they met, to the way he argued his way into his heart, to the very moments he reminded Robbie that he was here to stay - that he shouldn't be afraid to ever lose someone close because he knows how that feels - tha toughness that was both endearing and understanding, if not forgiving - one very hunky and adorable L.A model, Sebastian, earned his place in Robbie's heart and soul. 🤍🤍 Heart-warming and so very tender, these two had their fair share of scathing hurt first, but the way he proved himself - fought for his place - it was all so heart-warming and painstakingly sweet. I swear, I had the stupidest grin on my face when they first fought, which sounds a bit silly, but so worth it! 'A big teddy bear with a body like a guardian of the galaxy', he lit up his dark and gloomy soul - countered his dreary vibes and was so warmly affectionate to him that it was near impossible to resist him. ☺️
Sebastian was that balm to his soul that he didn't realize he needed - someone who was not Riley, but someone who still fit perfectly into his heart - without ever making him feel like he ever wanted to replace the beautiful memories he shared with him - 'He’s Sebastian and he’s different. He isn’t here to impress anyone and that’s what makes him so impressive.' He was so very thoughtful , so very patient with Robbie - never hesitated to point out just how wrong he was in his way of thinking and never one to shy away from showing him just how much he wanted him. 🥹 As insta-sudden as their first stumble with each other was, their relationship still developed so very naturally and believably to me. Where their love language isn't heartwarming words of kindness, but poking fun at each other with insults and barbs that fits their dynamic perfectly. It just made sense and I think that's why it worked out for them. 💓💓
“He grabbed the back of my neck and pulled me into a deep kiss.
I pulled away after a minute or five.
“Later,” I panted. “I promise.”
“Fuck, yeah,” he said and put me down gently.
I smiled. I smiled at him and I smiled at myself.
I can do this, I thought. I finally can do this.”
A big shout-out to Robbie's mom and uncle who paved the way for him to realize that he couldn't live a solitary life - whether or not they supported him or fought against his fast dive back into the arms of another - everything came from a place of love. 💌 'Relationships, real ones, shouldn’t be so fragile that the other one bolts at the first sign of trouble.' And he really needed to know that - he had forgotten how so very deserving he was of love, that when he was finally on the receiving end - it really took awhile for him to realize it that it was okay to love again.
You wouldn't know that this wasn't written by John Goode, himself, because it doesn't show - in the slightest. Robert Halliwell captured all the emotional nuances and personal touches that made this series sparkle; with a perfect balance of humor and all that biting comments that are as if speaking directly to you, A Way Back to Then made Robbie not only lovable, but feel loved again - that, in fact, he could finally have his happily ever after. 🏰
“No, not just marriage—love, period, is about sharing. You don’t keep the bad things away from the one you love; you show it to them in all its terrible glory.
But being in love, real love, isn’t a contest. It’s not about who has the least amount of problems. There are no winners or losers. You both should get to the finish line at the same time.”
If you've been a part of the Tales' verse, then Robbie DeCaro really needs no introduction. But, just because he doesn't need an intro, does not mean he doesn't deserve to have his story told in his own words - the past, the present, the future - all that made him into the person he was and what led him to become the person that he is.
Leaving behind the life of Foster and moving back to his home in Long Island, New York was probably the best break for Robbie - a chance to sit back and reflect on what he's lost over the years and the personality that he's shed since moving away. It's also this very step that gives him a chance and a choice to open up his heart again - even if it never starts off on the right foot or with the right person, either. 😟 How he was once this 'shy, quiet, somewhat cute twink back when I started my big gay adventure, but not the one anyone ever paid attention to' who eventually became this snarky and confident person, one who simply wants the world to leave him alone so that he can wallow in the grief of a broken heart that he can't seem to get over the pain it left behind. 💔💔
“There’s a piece of my heart that still cries every day.” I looked up at the faded coffered ceiling.
“I can’t be shattered again.” I turned my head to hide my tears.”
I like Robbie - I always have. I never minded how blatantly open he was with Tyler and Brad, I didn't mind that he never forgave those who hurt him, I never cringed at his brutally honest outlook at life, and I never saw him as a reclusive outcast who ran a clothing store - someone who's seen it all and lived to tell it. I lived for his sassy sarcasm, his snark, his twisted sense of humor - everything that made him such a pleasantly vindictive part of everyone's lives. 😥 'I was so bitter and bruised that it took a team of gay men, former alcoholics, and teenage boys to get me out of the depression I had been in for so long.' But by returning home, we get to see him shed that skin and see that vulnerable side of him - one that hid away those deep insecurities and uncertainties and those irrational fears that ate away at him while growing up. So, to see him finally accept both parts of himself - to accept that he can be sarcastic and still be human - still be soft-hearted, and still be angry - it was a healing process that he had shut himself off from for too long. ❤️🩹❤️🩹
Most of all, I saw him as someone who's been so deeply hurt that he won't ever allow himself to be happy again - even when he's someone who deserved a happy ending of his own. Someone who's seen so many fairy tales happily ever afters and all he wanted was one for himself. Well, we all know how that turned out. 😢 But, for someone who fought so fiercely to deny himself ever having a second chance at love again, it's only fair that we do get to see him finally have his moment in the rain and a prince charming to sweep him off his feet - or well, literally hit him where it hurts. Someone who finally melted Robbie's cold and closed-off heart. Someone who looked beyond that bitter resentment and hateful anger towards everyone and life and reminded him that he is not alone in being afraid of giving up his heart to someone else again. 🥺🥺
“I can’t explain it, but it just works.
Sebastian is exactly what I need.”
From the way they met, to the way he argued his way into his heart, to the very moments he reminded Robbie that he was here to stay - that he shouldn't be afraid to ever lose someone close because he knows how that feels - tha toughness that was both endearing and understanding, if not forgiving - one very hunky and adorable L.A model, Sebastian, earned his place in Robbie's heart and soul. 🤍🤍 Heart-warming and so very tender, these two had their fair share of scathing hurt first, but the way he proved himself - fought for his place - it was all so heart-warming and painstakingly sweet. I swear, I had the stupidest grin on my face when they first fought, which sounds a bit silly, but so worth it! 'A big teddy bear with a body like a guardian of the galaxy', he lit up his dark and gloomy soul - countered his dreary vibes and was so warmly affectionate to him that it was near impossible to resist him. ☺️
Sebastian was that balm to his soul that he didn't realize he needed - someone who was not Riley, but someone who still fit perfectly into his heart - without ever making him feel like he ever wanted to replace the beautiful memories he shared with him - 'He’s Sebastian and he’s different. He isn’t here to impress anyone and that’s what makes him so impressive.' He was so very thoughtful , so very patient with Robbie - never hesitated to point out just how wrong he was in his way of thinking and never one to shy away from showing him just how much he wanted him. 🥹 As insta-sudden as their first stumble with each other was, their relationship still developed so very naturally and believably to me. Where their love language isn't heartwarming words of kindness, but poking fun at each other with insults and barbs that fits their dynamic perfectly. It just made sense and I think that's why it worked out for them. 💓💓
“He grabbed the back of my neck and pulled me into a deep kiss.
I pulled away after a minute or five.
“Later,” I panted. “I promise.”
“Fuck, yeah,” he said and put me down gently.
I smiled. I smiled at him and I smiled at myself.
I can do this, I thought. I finally can do this.”
A big shout-out to Robbie's mom and uncle who paved the way for him to realize that he couldn't live a solitary life - whether or not they supported him or fought against his fast dive back into the arms of another - everything came from a place of love. 💌 'Relationships, real ones, shouldn’t be so fragile that the other one bolts at the first sign of trouble.' And he really needed to know that - he had forgotten how so very deserving he was of love, that when he was finally on the receiving end - it really took awhile for him to realize it that it was okay to love again.
You wouldn't know that this wasn't written by John Goode, himself, because it doesn't show - in the slightest. Robert Halliwell captured all the emotional nuances and personal touches that made this series sparkle; with a perfect balance of humor and all that biting comments that are as if speaking directly to you, A Way Back to Then made Robbie not only lovable, but feel loved again - that, in fact, he could finally have his happily ever after. 🏰
January 23, 2020
Still impressive to read that this installment isn't written by John Goode. Loved how Robert Halliwell voiced Robbie. I'm a big fan of Robbie. Loved that he was finally able to move on with Sebastian.
**********************************************
BR, June 5th (release-day) with Paul, Sonia, Julie and Momo
4,25 stars
First of all, I want to compliment the author Robert Halliwell for doing such a good job in portraiting the voice of Robbie. The Robbie, John Goode introduced and made us love in the Tales of Foster High series.
Robbie was just as I imagined him to be and I loved reading more about him..
I hurt for him for losing Riley the way he did. How do you come back from experiencing something like that..
So, in the last installment of Foster High, Robbie returns home to Long Island/New York. With the help of his family he tries to make something of his future again..
I absolutely adored Robbie’s family. His mom, sister and his uncle were such loving people and were determined to help Robbie get on his feet again!!
And then he met Sebastian… Sebastian which I thought was a perfect match for Robbie. Sebastian was very different than Riley but Robbie had changed also, so it made sense for me that Sebastian was “the guy” for Robbie.
Robbie
Sebastian
My favorite quote that teared me up also!!
"Riley was the prince on the white horse whom I needed to get me out of the life I was in years ago. While Foster wasn’t a shiny castle, I didn’t want anything else. We rarely argued and he gave me anything I wanted, whether material or not. There wasn’t much I wanted, but I was happy to know the offer was always there.
Then he left me.
I had nothing.
The castle was empty and the glass slipper had shattered into a thousand pieces.
After some time, I tidied up the castle and fixed that damn shoe all by myself. Except I never put it back on, but instead locked it in the highest tower to prevent it from being broken ever again.
When I moved back here to the provincial town I grew up in, I didn’t want anything to do with anyone except my family, and I certainly didn’t want to find love.
Especially with the guy who looked like he should be delivering ice to the local royalty.
Sebastian is exactly what I need.
He’s a big teddy bear with a body like a guardian of the galaxy. He has never disrespected me and has never taken any of my bullshit either.
Sebastian has never been jealous or uncomfortable if my sister or mother mention Riley during a conversation.
He knows I had a life before him, and he knows what Riley meant to us all.
He has never made any attempt to make us think that he’s better than Riley or that he’s here to fill the holes in our hearts.
He’s Sebastian and he’s different. He isn’t here to impress anyone and that’s what makes him so impressive.
Robbie deserved his Happily Ever After and I’m happy he will get it!! I do hope though to see more of Robbie and Sebastian in the following installments!!
May 31, 2015
~
"Bitch mode unlocked." That's my favorite line from this entire book. : )
The line is not only telling as far as the type of dialogue delivered by Robbie, the quirky, bitter and devastated Foster transplant, but also of the general tone of book 7 of the "Tales of Foster High" series.
Robbie is a bit of a self-proclaimed cunt. But it's always best to know and embrace yourself, right? Well, he does and he isn't very good sugar coating anything, so he really doesn't try to. Ever.
Book 7, "The Way Back to Then", is Robbie's tale and chronicles a lot of back story from Robbie growing up, attending college, meeting Riley and all that follows.
If you enjoy books that help fill in why characters in a series behave the way that they have in previous books, then this is definitely a book for you.
When Kyle and Brad leave Foster for college in California, Robbie decides that his work in Foster is 'D.O.N.E.' and he needs to get the hell out of Dodge, finally able to leave without feeling like Foster has beaten him.
So he packs his bags and moves back to Long Island with his family. But Robbie's mind is still firmly planted in the past, with Riley, so he isn't really moving forward with his life.
That doesn't last long, though, as he runs into an old 'friend', then is set up on a disastrous blind date by his sister. From that point on, Robbie begins to actually heal and entertain thoughts of moving on with his life.
The book is very bitter and jaded, which I normally *hate* with a passion hotter than three suns, but the story is tinged with a ton of humor, so the book did still work for me and I highly recommend this entertaining read about moving on and finding your way back to yourself and happiness.
The book was well-written and well-paced, plus the almost instant connection between Robbie and Sebastian actually felt real, which I truly enjoyed.
Ex LA model, Sebastian. Hot, huh?
Considering how smokin' Sebastian was, I was slightly peeved that *all* of the sex was off-page. That would/could/should have been steamy, but alas... *sigh*
One thing that still perplexes me about book 7 of the series is exactly why it was penned by Robert Halliwell, instead of John Goode, so if anyone has an answer to that question, please let me know.
Also, the story ends with an emergency back in Texas, where Robbie is poised to hop on the next plane back, which started to piss me off, due to the wait for book 8.
However, I checked and book 8 is to be released only a few weeks after this book comes out, so *whew* on that count. I'm not a big fan of 'the wait.' : )
This read was a solid 4.25 *tagged-squarely-in-the-junk* stars for me, so read it now, if you're all caught up on the previous books.
--------------------------
** My ARC copy of the book was provided by the publisher in exchange for a fair, unbiased review.
"Bitch mode unlocked." That's my favorite line from this entire book. : )
The line is not only telling as far as the type of dialogue delivered by Robbie, the quirky, bitter and devastated Foster transplant, but also of the general tone of book 7 of the "Tales of Foster High" series.
Robbie is a bit of a self-proclaimed cunt. But it's always best to know and embrace yourself, right? Well, he does and he isn't very good sugar coating anything, so he really doesn't try to. Ever.
Book 7, "The Way Back to Then", is Robbie's tale and chronicles a lot of back story from Robbie growing up, attending college, meeting Riley and all that follows.
If you enjoy books that help fill in why characters in a series behave the way that they have in previous books, then this is definitely a book for you.
When Kyle and Brad leave Foster for college in California, Robbie decides that his work in Foster is 'D.O.N.E.' and he needs to get the hell out of Dodge, finally able to leave without feeling like Foster has beaten him.
So he packs his bags and moves back to Long Island with his family. But Robbie's mind is still firmly planted in the past, with Riley, so he isn't really moving forward with his life.
That doesn't last long, though, as he runs into an old 'friend', then is set up on a disastrous blind date by his sister. From that point on, Robbie begins to actually heal and entertain thoughts of moving on with his life.
The book is very bitter and jaded, which I normally *hate* with a passion hotter than three suns, but the story is tinged with a ton of humor, so the book did still work for me and I highly recommend this entertaining read about moving on and finding your way back to yourself and happiness.
The book was well-written and well-paced, plus the almost instant connection between Robbie and Sebastian actually felt real, which I truly enjoyed.
Ex LA model, Sebastian. Hot, huh?
Considering how smokin' Sebastian was, I was slightly peeved that *all* of the sex was off-page. That would/could/should have been steamy, but alas... *sigh*
One thing that still perplexes me about book 7 of the series is exactly why it was penned by Robert Halliwell, instead of John Goode, so if anyone has an answer to that question, please let me know.
Also, the story ends with an emergency back in Texas, where Robbie is poised to hop on the next plane back, which started to piss me off, due to the wait for book 8.
However, I checked and book 8 is to be released only a few weeks after this book comes out, so *whew* on that count. I'm not a big fan of 'the wait.' : )
This read was a solid 4.25 *tagged-squarely-in-the-junk* stars for me, so read it now, if you're all caught up on the previous books.
--------------------------
** My ARC copy of the book was provided by the publisher in exchange for a fair, unbiased review.
September 19, 2016
Este libro pertenece al mundo de Tales from Foster High, pero no está escrito por John Goode (el autor) y no aparecen nuestros chicos, Kyle y Brad. En esta ocasión el protagonista es Robbie, al que hemos conocido a lo largo de los seis libros anteriores, que ha tenido un papel importante en la evolución de Kyle como persona, que nos ha divertido, y que nos ha emocionado cuando hemos sabido cómo perdió a su pareja a manos de un grupo de muchachos homófobos. En A Way Back To Then no encontramos una historia de amor al uso como las que solemos leer en este mundo del MM, más que un libro romántico es un libro sobre Robbie, sobre cómo intenta superar su dolor, sobre cómo intenta dar un paso hacia delante y seguir con su vida a pesar de perder a su compañero. Y en ese viaje de vuelta a la vida cuenta con una familia loca y divertida como el y con Sebastian, al que conocerá y resultará ser nada como el imaginó y todo lo que el necesitaba.
El libro no ha puesto mi mundo patas arriba como ha ocurrido con otros de la misma serie, pero me ha gustado, ha habido momentos que me han emocionado y momentos en los que me he reído a carcajadas. Creo que es imprescindible para todo aquel que como yo ama la serie de Tales from Foster High.
El libro no ha puesto mi mundo patas arriba como ha ocurrido con otros de la misma serie, pero me ha gustado, ha habido momentos que me han emocionado y momentos en los que me he reído a carcajadas. Creo que es imprescindible para todo aquel que como yo ama la serie de Tales from Foster High.
September 27, 2016
4 Stars
So good! Another great addition to the Tales from Foster High series.
As a huge fan of Robbie DeCaro, I was chomping at the bit to get my hands on this baby! Since his first appearance in the series, I’ve always had a major soft spot for Robbie’s character. It didn’t matter whether he was being a grade A bitch, if he was making me laugh hysterically with his snark, or whether he was breaking my heart with his devastating tears--every on page moment Robbie had, his character stole the show. So no surprises that I was eager to read his very own story, and thankfully, I was not disappointed!
I really enjoyed the fact that this story was set away from Foster. I’ve always considered the town of Foster to be its very own, majorly imposing character within this series. A character that has left me emotionally drained over my recent 6 book marathon (yes, I was slow on the uptake, but I quickly learnt the error of my ways). So, yeah, it was great getting a reprieve from all the Foster madness for a while. That’s not to say this story was without emotion, because there were plenty of tears from my end—I seriously think John and Robert are two genius bastards who just love making us ugly cry, and weirdly I’m okay with that.
I liked a lot of aspects of this story. I loved Robbie’s family, I LOVED all the pop culture references
Plus, those chapter title mash-ups where the fricken bomb .
Robbie and Sebastian's romance was fantastic; I appreciated how not-perfect all of Robbie’s initial interactions with Sebastian were (reality, bitches!). And, most importantly, I adored getting to know Robbie’s character even more. He truly is a book character favourite of mine.
Before I fade away into the GR mist, I have to give praise to Robert Halliwell for writing this story for us (and John). I’d imagine jumping in to write a story within an already well established series would be scary as fuck, especially when said story is about you (or based on you, to a degree), but damned if Robert didn’t smash it out of the park!
So good! Another great addition to the Tales from Foster High series.
As a huge fan of Robbie DeCaro, I was chomping at the bit to get my hands on this baby! Since his first appearance in the series, I’ve always had a major soft spot for Robbie’s character. It didn’t matter whether he was being a grade A bitch, if he was making me laugh hysterically with his snark, or whether he was breaking my heart with his devastating tears--every on page moment Robbie had, his character stole the show. So no surprises that I was eager to read his very own story, and thankfully, I was not disappointed!
I really enjoyed the fact that this story was set away from Foster. I’ve always considered the town of Foster to be its very own, majorly imposing character within this series. A character that has left me emotionally drained over my recent 6 book marathon (yes, I was slow on the uptake, but I quickly learnt the error of my ways). So, yeah, it was great getting a reprieve from all the Foster madness for a while. That’s not to say this story was without emotion, because there were plenty of tears from my end—I seriously think John and Robert are two genius bastards who just love making us ugly cry, and weirdly I’m okay with that.
I liked a lot of aspects of this story. I loved Robbie’s family, I LOVED all the pop culture references
Plus, those chapter title mash-ups where the fricken bomb .
Robbie and Sebastian's romance was fantastic; I appreciated how not-perfect all of Robbie’s initial interactions with Sebastian were (reality, bitches!). And, most importantly, I adored getting to know Robbie’s character even more. He truly is a book character favourite of mine.
Before I fade away into the GR mist, I have to give praise to Robert Halliwell for writing this story for us (and John). I’d imagine jumping in to write a story within an already well established series would be scary as fuck, especially when said story is about you (or based on you, to a degree), but damned if Robert didn’t smash it out of the park!
June 14, 2017
Robbie DeCaro has been through so much, and he definitely hides behind a false bravado and a severely dangerous, sharp wit. This was his story about healing, about acknowledging one's fears, and despite them, finding the strength to return to the land of the living. My emotions were constantly being tossed around to extreme highs and touching lows. It was comedy central meets depressing gravity. I loved Robbie's brilliant inner, judgmental bitch, Sebastian's astounding tolerance and patience, and of course the DeCaro clan who was so over the top hilarious in showing their love.
Still just as poignant, just as affecting as all the other characters' stories, Halliwell seamlessly bridges this book with Goode's wonderful Tales of Foster High series. Though overflowing with snark, sass, and humor, there was no shirking of the emotional fallout that is standard in every story I've read thus far. A fabulous segue from the usual levity. Bravo.
Thanks to Meags for keeping me on track, or else this would have been another victim floating aimlessly in my never ending TBR pile!
Still just as poignant, just as affecting as all the other characters' stories, Halliwell seamlessly bridges this book with Goode's wonderful Tales of Foster High series. Though overflowing with snark, sass, and humor, there was no shirking of the emotional fallout that is standard in every story I've read thus far. A fabulous segue from the usual levity. Bravo.
Thanks to Meags for keeping me on track, or else this would have been another victim floating aimlessly in my never ending TBR pile!
June 8, 2015
4.5 stars
*spoilerish, so be warned* - AWESOME BR with Paul, Momo,Elsbeth, Julie and Nathan :D
I would like to start my review by expressing my admiration for real life Robbie (Halliwell).
Why you ask? Well, we all know writing is not easy (you will be able to see how not easy it is by reading my review *snickers*). So, to not only write a truly wonderful book, but to write a book about a character introduced by another awesome author - John Goode (of which you are a huge fan. Really, Robbie, that took a lot of courage and dedication!!) and be able to do that character justice? Well... Let me tell you... That's A HUGE FREAKING DEAL!
And Robbie Halliwell did all these things! And he did them splendidly! I enjoyed "A way back to then" so, so much!
It's not secret I adored Robbie when we first met him, even when he was a massive bitch (or maybe especially then)! So although I was really excited to read more about him, at the same time I was nervous that maybe Robbie written by Robbie will not be who we met and I would be disappointed...
Needless to say that didn't happen. Instead I fell more in love with him! Robbie was exactly how I remember him to be, but more. He was hilarious, snarky, clever and a big meany at times, but boy oh boy do I adore him! He was also fragile, a broken man trying to pick up the pieces of a once fairytale life.
God! It killed me to read Robbie and Riley's ending in the previous Foster High books, and I honestly considered skipping that part here, but then I thought if Robbie (and John for that matter) were able to write it then I better get my ass in gear and read it! (I'm honestly crying even now, just thinking about it). It was a terrible ending to an other wise beautiful love story, it was such a pleasure to read about how they met *happy sigh*
So altough I knew it was hopeless, I was so in love with the idea of Robbie and Riley, that I couldn't imagine what could top that. And you know what? Robbie Halliwell is one clever man! Because if he would have created some epic love story for Robbie, with a larger than life new man that outshines all the Riley was and represented I would have been so pissed! So it was genius to bring in Sebastian! Oh, I disliked him big time at first, because we saw him through Robbie judging eyes; so stuff that appeared to be one way (like Sebastian checking himself out in the window of a restaurant *yuck!* was him actually adjusting his contacts) were in fact misinterpretations made by our pig-headed MC :P And that was also genius! I see what you did there, Robbie Halliwell! But Sebastian charmed me, he was refreshing and I liked that he called Robbie on his bulshit. His reaction when hearing about Riley was beautiful and the way he pursues Robbie and makes him take a chance on them was awesome!!
So I believe Sebastian was exactly what Robbie needed to move on with his life.
So, I am more than pleased with how this all turned out. Thank you for making that happen, Robbie! *giggles* it's so amusing trying to differentiate between Robbie and RL Robbie.
We also meet Robbie's mom and uncle, who are freaking crazy!!! But so funny and lovable. Trust me, just go read the book, you'll pee your pants laughing so hard.
There's also Sean, who we don't like! I said we don't lie Sean! Remember that, it's important! Ughh!! Wish I could have put my boot through his face :D
The only thing that that bothered me a bit (since I am not a fan of the insta-love or love at-first-sight *yuck!* tropes) was how fast Robbie and Sebastian got together, but that was so beautifully explained that I got over it really fast :D
So I hope my review makes some kind of sense, but if it doesn't just remember this: I loved the book and you should go read it! Now! Go! Stop looking at me!
Bye!
*spoilerish, so be warned* - AWESOME BR with Paul, Momo,Elsbeth, Julie and Nathan :D
I would like to start my review by expressing my admiration for real life Robbie (Halliwell).
Why you ask? Well, we all know writing is not easy (you will be able to see how not easy it is by reading my review *snickers*). So, to not only write a truly wonderful book, but to write a book about a character introduced by another awesome author - John Goode (of which you are a huge fan. Really, Robbie, that took a lot of courage and dedication!!) and be able to do that character justice? Well... Let me tell you... That's A HUGE FREAKING DEAL!
And Robbie Halliwell did all these things! And he did them splendidly! I enjoyed "A way back to then" so, so much!
It's not secret I adored Robbie when we first met him, even when he was a massive bitch (or maybe especially then)! So although I was really excited to read more about him, at the same time I was nervous that maybe Robbie written by Robbie will not be who we met and I would be disappointed...
Needless to say that didn't happen. Instead I fell more in love with him! Robbie was exactly how I remember him to be, but more. He was hilarious, snarky, clever and a big meany at times, but boy oh boy do I adore him! He was also fragile, a broken man trying to pick up the pieces of a once fairytale life.
"Riley was the prince on the white horse whom I needed to get me out of the life I was in years ago. While Foster wasn’t a shiny castle, I didn’t want anything else."[..]Then he left me. I had nothing. The castle was empty and the glass slipper had shattered into a thousand pieces.
God! It killed me to read Robbie and Riley's ending in the previous Foster High books, and I honestly considered skipping that part here, but then I thought if Robbie (and John for that matter) were able to write it then I better get my ass in gear and read it! (I'm honestly crying even now, just thinking about it). It was a terrible ending to an other wise beautiful love story, it was such a pleasure to read about how they met *happy sigh*
"The nerd in question asked about Orion’s Belt. Bam! I awoke instantly. Not that I gave a shit about Orion’s Belt, shoes, or any other accessory, but I was interested by the deep, sexy drawl I’d just heard come out of my classmate’s mouth. [..]“’Scuse me,” he said. “Mind if I sit here?” I counted to three and raised my head slowly to make sure I wasn’t dreaming. I turned to look up at the boy with the Property of Foster High Athletic Department sweatshirt on and shook my head. [..]“Name’s Riley,” I heard in a muffled tone. "
So altough I knew it was hopeless, I was so in love with the idea of Robbie and Riley, that I couldn't imagine what could top that. And you know what? Robbie Halliwell is one clever man! Because if he would have created some epic love story for Robbie, with a larger than life new man that outshines all the Riley was and represented I would have been so pissed! So it was genius to bring in Sebastian! Oh, I disliked him big time at first, because we saw him through Robbie judging eyes; so stuff that appeared to be one way (like Sebastian checking himself out in the window of a restaurant *yuck!* was him actually adjusting his contacts) were in fact misinterpretations made by our pig-headed MC :P And that was also genius! I see what you did there, Robbie Halliwell! But Sebastian charmed me, he was refreshing and I liked that he called Robbie on his bulshit. His reaction when hearing about Riley was beautiful and the way he pursues Robbie and makes him take a chance on them was awesome!!
“What do you want me to tell you, Rob?” he asked, taking half a step away from me. “Do you want me to tell you that I’ve been going nuts thinking about the past week and not talking to you? Is that it? Do you want me to tell you that your sister got so sick of me asking about you that she finally relented and told me where you were going to be?”
So I believe Sebastian was exactly what Robbie needed to move on with his life.
“"Sebastian is exactly what I need. He’s a big teddy bear with a body like a guardian of the galaxy. He has never disrespected me and has never taken any of my bullshit either. He never judges my little OCD moments, but he has helped me overcome some of them. "
So, I am more than pleased with how this all turned out. Thank you for making that happen, Robbie! *giggles* it's so amusing trying to differentiate between Robbie and RL Robbie.
We also meet Robbie's mom and uncle, who are freaking crazy!!! But so funny and lovable. Trust me, just go read the book, you'll pee your pants laughing so hard.
"From my bedroom I could see the front door perfectly. It opened and my mother and uncle stood just outside. One of them was holding a golf club and the other a salami. I’ll let you guess who held what."
There's also Sean, who we don't like! I said we don't lie Sean! Remember that, it's important! Ughh!! Wish I could have put my boot through his face :D
The only thing that that bothered me a bit (since I am not a fan of the insta-love or love at-first-sight *yuck!* tropes) was how fast Robbie and Sebastian got together, but that was so beautifully explained that I got over it really fast :D
" No, I don’t have a warped reality of love at first sight or some bullshit like that. I really do love Sebastian and for some stupid reason he loves me back. I mean, he’s big and doofy and sexy as hell while I’m just… me. But I guess that does it for him. You’re not supposed to know how love works, because if we did, there wouldn’t be so many cat ladies in the world. "
So I hope my review makes some kind of sense, but if it doesn't just remember this: I loved the book and you should go read it! Now! Go! Stop looking at me!
Bye!
June 12, 2015
Dear Robbie (Halliwell),
I have to be honest with you. I had high expectations of this book, because I adored Robbie in 'Tales from Foster High', and I was really excited about reading more of his story. Now, I know expectations are dangerous, because sometimes you get disappointed as a reader with a book that doesn't meet them. But I can honestly say that you, m'dear, have exceeded my expectations by far! You are a fantastic writer, and I truly hope you publish more books in the future! Please tell me there's more in store for Robbie, too... Also, I don't know what kind of magic you worked, but 'A Way Back To Then' does not feel detached from the rest of the series. It fits like a missing piece of the puzzle. And by that, I mean that you portrayed the character of Robbie perfectly. Seriously, thank you so much for writing this! In-fucking-credible job!
Yours truly,
Cristina T.
Warning: Spoilery and chaotic review!
First of all, let me introduce the MCs, who are perfect, and chosen by Robbie (Halliwell) himself... ;-)
Robbie is back in Long Island, because he needs to try to pierce his life back together and he's sick of Texas. Gone is the flamboyant man, his theatrics are turned down to a minimum, the façade left behind. He later explains his Foster behavior to Sebastian...
You know what shattered my heart like the proverbial glass slipper Robbie talks about? His past with Riley, and how unfair it was for him to lose him like that and to have to deal with the trauma after. I just felt the need to wrap Robbie in a blanket and cuddle him forever.
Then Sebastian swoops in, and he helps Robbie cradle that shoe like it's the most precious thing in the world. He cherishes Robbie, and he puts his cards on the table, letting Robbie know how he feels.
See, I thought Riley was the perfect match for Robbie, and after what happened to him–to them–I didn't think anyone would break past the thorns in front of Robbie's castle again... But then I came to accept that Riley wouldn't come back, and I started to warm up to Seb. I mean, seeing Sebastian through Robbie's eyes, I judged him at first, too. But that all stopped when I saw his heart of gold and how smart he really was. He was exactly what Robbie needed at that point in his life, someone to help him move on and heal.
Anyway. I could ramble on and on about how awesome this book is, but I feel like this review is getting too long–if you've read this far, congrats and thanks, haha. I just want to say two more things...
#1 – I loved Robbie's family!!! They're all cray-cray, hilarious and very supportive. Mama Rose was great, and I liked James a lot–save for that one time where he was a raging bitch and I wanted to slap some sense into him!
#2 – Sean is the most annoying and awful human being ever! I hated him with a passion, but was very pleased when Robbie called him a fungus! *snickers*
I am happy Robbie got his happy ending, after all, despite his trek through hell.
P.S. Shout-out to John Goode, who created the incredible Foster High world, and who had the brilliant idea to ask Robbie to write this book! Thank you, John!!! :)
I have to be honest with you. I had high expectations of this book, because I adored Robbie in 'Tales from Foster High', and I was really excited about reading more of his story. Now, I know expectations are dangerous, because sometimes you get disappointed as a reader with a book that doesn't meet them. But I can honestly say that you, m'dear, have exceeded my expectations by far! You are a fantastic writer, and I truly hope you publish more books in the future! Please tell me there's more in store for Robbie, too... Also, I don't know what kind of magic you worked, but 'A Way Back To Then' does not feel detached from the rest of the series. It fits like a missing piece of the puzzle. And by that, I mean that you portrayed the character of Robbie perfectly. Seriously, thank you so much for writing this! In-fucking-credible job!
Yours truly,
Cristina T.
Warning: Spoilery and chaotic review!
First of all, let me introduce the MCs, who are perfect, and chosen by Robbie (Halliwell) himself... ;-)
Robbie is back in Long Island, because he needs to try to pierce his life back together and he's sick of Texas. Gone is the flamboyant man, his theatrics are turned down to a minimum, the façade left behind. He later explains his Foster behavior to Sebastian...
"I was the token gay character on the CW's Tales from Foster. The shop became my stage and I put on a Tony-award-winning performance every chance I got. I wasn't the butchest fag on the block to begin with, but when I had a new audience to impress, I turned it up three degrees gayer."
You know what shattered my heart like the proverbial glass slipper Robbie talks about? His past with Riley, and how unfair it was for him to lose him like that and to have to deal with the trauma after. I just felt the need to wrap Robbie in a blanket and cuddle him forever.
Riley was the prince on the white horse whom I needed to get me out of the life I was in years ago. While Foster wasn't a shiny castle, I didn't want anything else. We rarely argued and he gave me anything I wanted, whether material or not. There wasn't much I wanted, but I was happy to know the offer was always there.
Then he left me.
I had nothing.
The castle was empty and the glass slipper had shattered into a thousand pieces.
After some time, I tidied up the castle and fixed that damn shoe all by myself. Except I never put it back on, but instead locked it in the highest tower to prevent it from being broken ever again.
Then Sebastian swoops in, and he helps Robbie cradle that shoe like it's the most precious thing in the world. He cherishes Robbie, and he puts his cards on the table, letting Robbie know how he feels.
"I'm too old to play chicken with someone I like anymore. I'm tired of those kind of games. I like you, I want you to know it, so fuck it. And how many other times will I be able to tell people a first date began with dinner and someone punching me in the 'nads?" he added.
See, I thought Riley was the perfect match for Robbie, and after what happened to him–to them–I didn't think anyone would break past the thorns in front of Robbie's castle again... But then I came to accept that Riley wouldn't come back, and I started to warm up to Seb. I mean, seeing Sebastian through Robbie's eyes, I judged him at first, too. But that all stopped when I saw his heart of gold and how smart he really was. He was exactly what Robbie needed at that point in his life, someone to help him move on and heal.
Sebastian is exactly what I need. He's a big teddy bear with a body like a guardian of the galaxy. He has never disrespected me and has never taken any of my bullshit either.
Anyway. I could ramble on and on about how awesome this book is, but I feel like this review is getting too long–if you've read this far, congrats and thanks, haha. I just want to say two more things...
#1 – I loved Robbie's family!!! They're all cray-cray, hilarious and very supportive. Mama Rose was great, and I liked James a lot–save for that one time where he was a raging bitch and I wanted to slap some sense into him!
#2 – Sean is the most annoying and awful human being ever! I hated him with a passion, but was very pleased when Robbie called him a fungus! *snickers*
I am happy Robbie got his happy ending, after all, despite his trek through hell.
P.S. Shout-out to John Goode, who created the incredible Foster High world, and who had the brilliant idea to ask Robbie to write this book! Thank you, John!!! :)
January 2, 2016
4.5 Stars
Wow. Just...Wow. Brilliantly done. Robert Halliwell takes the story of Robbie which John Goode started, and continues it in a similar snarky, sarcastic, witty way, but also in a way that absolutely blew. me. away.
As a HUGE fan of the series I was a bit worried that someone else was writing one of the books. I'm so happy to say I wasn't disappointed with this installment. I was actually over the moon happy with the final product.
Robbie has long been my least favorite character...truthfully? His bitchiness and personality has been one that grated on me at every turn. But that opinion's undergone a complete 180 with this story.
Bravo, sir. Brilliant.
RECOMMENDED!
This review has been cross-posted at Reviews by Jessewave.
Wow. Just...Wow. Brilliantly done. Robert Halliwell takes the story of Robbie which John Goode started, and continues it in a similar snarky, sarcastic, witty way, but also in a way that absolutely blew. me. away.
As a HUGE fan of the series I was a bit worried that someone else was writing one of the books. I'm so happy to say I wasn't disappointed with this installment. I was actually over the moon happy with the final product.
Robbie has long been my least favorite character...truthfully? His bitchiness and personality has been one that grated on me at every turn. But that opinion's undergone a complete 180 with this story.
Bravo, sir. Brilliant.
RECOMMENDED!
This review has been cross-posted at Reviews by Jessewave.
November 9, 2022
4.5 Stars ~ I remember thinking when I first saw this book on the coming soon shelves of Dreamspinner Press, "What the hell?" I mean, 'Tales from Foster High' is a much loved series of mine, and I'm mad, crazy about its author, John Goode. So, who was this interloper, Robert Halliwell, and why was he writing Robbie's story? I'd loved Robbie from the first moment I met him, how was this author going to understand him? Well, trust me my friends, Mr. Halliwell did a phenomenal job, and I owe him an apology for not believing in him right from the start.
"Whether it’s four decades or two years, you never feel like it was ever enough.”
I sat on the arm of the sofa next to him. “There’s a piece of my heart that still cries every day.” I looked up at the faded coffered ceiling. “I can’t be shattered again.” I turned my head to hide my tears."
Please find my full review at Rainbow Book Reviews
"Whether it’s four decades or two years, you never feel like it was ever enough.”
I sat on the arm of the sofa next to him. “There’s a piece of my heart that still cries every day.” I looked up at the faded coffered ceiling. “I can’t be shattered again.” I turned my head to hide my tears."
Please find my full review at Rainbow Book Reviews
August 17, 2016
I was so looking forward to Robbies story, and it lived up to all my hopes.
From the last book I knew Robbie was going to surprise me and he did. He is nothing like I thought him to be from previous books. He is much deeper.
While I certainly needed my tissues in certain parts, this was not the tear fest I was expecting. Instead I got a sweet story of 2 guys coming together despite a rocky start. There was plenty of humour to equal out the sadder parts.
Robbies family added a little extra kick, especially his uncle. I hope one day he can tell his own story.
Even though this is told by a different author, it fits in the same mold as the rest of the stories.
As for that ending, all I can say is I'm glad I have the next books lined up ready.
ETA
Can't add anything more. Tears and laughter. Not sure why I only gave it 4 stars the first time but it deserves the full 5
From the last book I knew Robbie was going to surprise me and he did. He is nothing like I thought him to be from previous books. He is much deeper.
While I certainly needed my tissues in certain parts, this was not the tear fest I was expecting. Instead I got a sweet story of 2 guys coming together despite a rocky start. There was plenty of humour to equal out the sadder parts.
Robbies family added a little extra kick, especially his uncle. I hope one day he can tell his own story.
Even though this is told by a different author, it fits in the same mold as the rest of the stories.
As for that ending, all I can say is I'm glad I have the next books lined up ready.
ETA
Can't add anything more. Tears and laughter. Not sure why I only gave it 4 stars the first time but it deserves the full 5
August 12, 2016
I read this out of order, but it didn't matter. After book #6, when everything seemed to be going well for everyone else, I was desperate for Robbie to get his HEA. I totally missed this book because of the different author(?), so went straight to When I Grow Up. One of the best parts of that one was meeting Sebastian and so I was very excited to read the story of how he and Robbie met (once I figured out which book it was). And ... it was so worth -- I adored Sebastian and I really adored Sebastian and Robbie together. I loved how they met and all the ups and downs of their first date. This was sweet and funny with a little tenderness.
October 9, 2015
****4.5 STARS****
Robbie has finally decided it was time to leave Foster and move back home to Long Island with his family. And if you lived Robbie you'll love his mom, sister, and uncle just as much. Moving back home didn't magically or instantly make things better. But the families support sets him on the path that will give him the happily ever after he so deserves.
Emotional, funny, and so good! If Mr. Halliwell decides to give this writing thing another go, consider it already on my kindle.
Robbie has finally decided it was time to leave Foster and move back home to Long Island with his family. And if you lived Robbie you'll love his mom, sister, and uncle just as much. Moving back home didn't magically or instantly make things better. But the families support sets him on the path that will give him the happily ever after he so deserves.
Emotional, funny, and so good! If Mr. Halliwell decides to give this writing thing another go, consider it already on my kindle.
July 27, 2015
I loved this. Robbie was an angry, bitchy drama queen type of character in the Foster High Series, who was misunderstood by everyone but Kyle and Jennifer and really manned up when Kyle and Brad needed people around them and money to live their dream. He had plenty to be angry about at Foster, small Texan town...after all, they did jack s**t when his boyfriend was run down and killed in a hate crime all those years ago. 5 stars from me.
The author has given me a new and very welcome perspective on Robbie, what he had to endure when Riley was murdered, how he went to pieces and came close to committing suicide himself...and probably would have done but for the support of his mum, his sister and Uncle James, and latterly the young gay kids of Foster Kyle and Brad....so when, with the help of the money Robbie received from Riley's death, Brad and Kyle move to California to continue Kyle's amazing education, Robbie moves back home to Long Island. He tries to live like a hermit, but his mum and sister Nicole have other ideas...they know that Robbie has lots of love to give to the right person, he just needs a reason to see himself that way. Into the story walks Sebastian, who has secrets of his own. For those fans of the Foster High series, enjoy!!
December 23, 2018
I finished the whole series many months ago during a crazy busy time for me, but I was holding off on writing a review because I wanted to do the books justice and hopefully bring more attention to them. Well, I should have known better because the more I stall, the more unable I am to write a proper review. So I'm just going to say that this series is definitely worth picking up. I'm so very happy I decided to finally give it a go.
I don't know who Robert Halliwell is, but Robbie's story was everything I was hoping for and much, much more.
5 stars!!!
I don't know who Robert Halliwell is, but Robbie's story was everything I was hoping for and much, much more.
5 stars!!!
September 5, 2016
Oh Robbie.
Read
June 12, 2016My favourite character from Tales From Foster High after Kyle is probably Robbie. I think I really even like him better than Brad. Maybe. Ah well, I don't have to decide, do I?
I'm assuming you've read the last books in the series, so I won't make a spoiler out of former events.
My life ended up becoming one big fractured fairy tale. I'd just recently picked up the last piece in oder to start Krazy Gluing it all back together.
Disney never makes movies about those kinda stories.
Over the last books Robbie stole my heart. This broken guy who lived through the worst that life can throw at you, the death of your other half, and under the worst circumstances, too. To read about him and Riley in the last books was the hardest for me.
On the note that '151 Days' ended, though, I thought for the first time that I would be able to handle to read Robbie's story, because who he and Riley were is precious. I decided to want to know more about them, although my heart was already broken.
I wanted to see a happy ending for Robbie so very bad. I wanted so bad for him to move on, to still love Riley, but to open his heart again for someone else. I needed him to be whole again.
Moving on to 'A Way Back to Then', I found the balance between scenes from the past and the present to be perfect. It was just the right amount of former events and feelings to understand the misery and struggle that Robbie was going through, without living only in the past and mourning Riley.
It's understandingly hard for Robbie to come out of his hiding hole again. He wants to, but he really has no idea how. So, it's kinda good he has some meddling family members who nudge him into the right direction :D
So, I really loved the first half of the book. The pacing was wonderful and Robbie's snark is just plain out hilarious:
"Nice?" I said. "That translates to 'scary troll who eats kitty litter' in my book, Nicki."
She sighed. "He's not scary, nor does he like pussy of any variety."
I liked the book, but I didn't love it. There are things that didn't work for me so well.
1.) Robbie in the past and Robbie in the now
I have difficulties merging those two into one person. It's weird because they should be one, but somehow aren't. It's actually addressed in the book that the Robbie we saw in Foster was living an act, and I find the reason given plausible and satisfying. But that's the Robbie I got to know, the Robbie I first met.
It's a bit hard to really put my finger on it, it's more of a feeling, but to give some examples, Robbie in the present isn't fashionable at all, and his whole persona is less out there. In Foster—he says it himself—he was acting gayer. He can still be a bitch, but I think he's less diva, he's less everything.
Again, it's explained, but he's just different and... yeah.
2.) Robbie and Sebastian
(Sorry, this'll be full of spoilers)
What an awful first date. Both Robbie and Sebastian behave like judgemental bitches and self-righteous pricks. Okay, that's fine. That can happen.
What I have so much difficulties wrapping my head around is how things evolve from there. And I think this is just because I am totally different than they are. I don't think this couldn't happen, it's just that I am living on a different planet or something.
They fight, first verbally and then Robbie even punches Sebastian in the nuts, and what happens next is just so alien to me, I can't even. Sebastian kisses Robbie, they have sex and Sebastian spends the night.
What astonishes me just as much is that the next morning, when Sebastian finds a picture of Robbie and Riley, Robbie tells him everything. He gets it all out, the worst moment of his life, telling it to this stranger he just met. I mean, he spent so much time locking this part of him away, that I can't believe he would tell Sebastian everything after, well... nothing. A one-night stand.
Don't get the assumption, I'm somehow on Robbie's uncle's side. Far from it. I just can't see it, I can't believe it.
I'm very happy that Robbie found a way to move on. It's just not the way I'd pictured it. Why the rush? All in all, we are only shown one week, two meetings. That wasn't enough for me.
Although I'm not a fan of these two things, I still liked reading the book. It was funny, emotional, and easy to read. It just flowed and I was always surprised at my fast progress.
I'm very much looking forward to the next books that are coming out very soon. And I'm quite curious about what we'll see about Robbie and Sebastian in the future, too.
I'm assuming you've read the last books in the series, so I won't make a spoiler out of former events.
My life ended up becoming one big fractured fairy tale. I'd just recently picked up the last piece in oder to start Krazy Gluing it all back together.
Disney never makes movies about those kinda stories.
Over the last books Robbie stole my heart. This broken guy who lived through the worst that life can throw at you, the death of your other half, and under the worst circumstances, too. To read about him and Riley in the last books was the hardest for me.
On the note that '151 Days' ended, though, I thought for the first time that I would be able to handle to read Robbie's story, because who he and Riley were is precious. I decided to want to know more about them, although my heart was already broken.
I wanted to see a happy ending for Robbie so very bad. I wanted so bad for him to move on, to still love Riley, but to open his heart again for someone else. I needed him to be whole again.
Moving on to 'A Way Back to Then', I found the balance between scenes from the past and the present to be perfect. It was just the right amount of former events and feelings to understand the misery and struggle that Robbie was going through, without living only in the past and mourning Riley.
It's understandingly hard for Robbie to come out of his hiding hole again. He wants to, but he really has no idea how. So, it's kinda good he has some meddling family members who nudge him into the right direction :D
So, I really loved the first half of the book. The pacing was wonderful and Robbie's snark is just plain out hilarious:
"Nice?" I said. "That translates to 'scary troll who eats kitty litter' in my book, Nicki."
She sighed. "He's not scary, nor does he like pussy of any variety."
I liked the book, but I didn't love it. There are things that didn't work for me so well.
1.) Robbie in the past and Robbie in the now
I have difficulties merging those two into one person. It's weird because they should be one, but somehow aren't. It's actually addressed in the book that the Robbie we saw in Foster was living an act, and I find the reason given plausible and satisfying. But that's the Robbie I got to know, the Robbie I first met.
It's a bit hard to really put my finger on it, it's more of a feeling, but to give some examples, Robbie in the present isn't fashionable at all, and his whole persona is less out there. In Foster—he says it himself—he was acting gayer. He can still be a bitch, but I think he's less diva, he's less everything.
Again, it's explained, but he's just different and... yeah.
2.) Robbie and Sebastian
(Sorry, this'll be full of spoilers)
What an awful first date. Both Robbie and Sebastian behave like judgemental bitches and self-righteous pricks. Okay, that's fine. That can happen.
What I have so much difficulties wrapping my head around is how things evolve from there. And I think this is just because I am totally different than they are. I don't think this couldn't happen, it's just that I am living on a different planet or something.
They fight, first verbally and then Robbie even punches Sebastian in the nuts, and what happens next is just so alien to me, I can't even. Sebastian kisses Robbie, they have sex and Sebastian spends the night.
What astonishes me just as much is that the next morning, when Sebastian finds a picture of Robbie and Riley, Robbie tells him everything. He gets it all out, the worst moment of his life, telling it to this stranger he just met. I mean, he spent so much time locking this part of him away, that I can't believe he would tell Sebastian everything after, well... nothing. A one-night stand.
Don't get the assumption, I'm somehow on Robbie's uncle's side. Far from it. I just can't see it, I can't believe it.
I'm very happy that Robbie found a way to move on. It's just not the way I'd pictured it. Why the rush? All in all, we are only shown one week, two meetings. That wasn't enough for me.
Although I'm not a fan of these two things, I still liked reading the book. It was funny, emotional, and easy to read. It just flowed and I was always surprised at my fast progress.
I'm very much looking forward to the next books that are coming out very soon. And I'm quite curious about what we'll see about Robbie and Sebastian in the future, too.
September 11, 2016
Before I begin my review I want to speak to something very important when it comes to new authors such as Robert Halliwell. It’s not often that an author establishes such a solid “voice” in his first novel. Just so we are on the same page the author’s voice as it is described on Writeability is as follows: "Voice is the author's style, the quality that makes his or her writing unique, and which conveys the author's attitude, personality, and character."
That is a very powerful statement and sometimes it takes authors several stories before they find their way. In this case where the novel in question, A Way Back To Then, is actually a spinoff featuring a character from a highly popular and established series, Tales From Foster High, it was pretty imperative that Mr. Halliwell establish his own voice so as not to merely imitate John Goode, the author of the aforementioned Foster High Series. I am so excited and delighted to report that Mr. Halliwell not only made this story his own but presented to his readers an exciting, witty, smart and deliciously snarky voice that could never be mistaken for anything other than genuine and fresh!
What an incredible first novel this author wrote for us. Jumping right from the Foster High series, A Way Back To Then seamlessly picks up on the life of Robbie DeCaro, the Long Island transplant who’d moved to Foster with his boyfriend, Riley a few years previous. When Riley is killed during a hit and run hate crime, Robbie begins on a self-destructive path embracing and unleashing his “inner Diva” and erecting a wall so high and thick around his heart that it is doubtful he will ever love again.
Plagued by panic attacks and a pain that runs so deep, he is finally able to come to terms with a friend who watched the accident but did nothing to help as Riley lay dying in his arms. Prior to his packing up and heading home to his mother’s home in Long Island, Robbie finds a restless peace with the town of Foster and leaves the dregs of his bitterness over their quiet bigotry behind. Once home, he feels so lost and while he tries to reconnect with former friends (and I use that term loosely) he finds that he can’t bring himself to do the cruising bar scene again. It takes his sister, Nicole and her crafty blind date set up to finally bring Robbie back into the dating scene, with near disastrous results. The real question becomes can Robbie ever find the strength and bravery to let that wall he is so safe behind crumble and let someone in? Could this blind date, Sebastian, be the one who can finally break through?
I could give you paragraphs about the supporting cast, the main characters, the wit and humor of the rapier sharp dialogue and the incredible journey that Robbie finally gets to begin once he allows himself the luxury of being happy and learning to trust that emotion again. I could remark on Robbie’s family and their love/fighting/bitchery that makes them some of the most interesting and hilarious secondary characters ever to grace a novel. I could tell you that while this novel draws its origins in the Foster High Series it is a completely different animal and could indeed be the anchor for a new series by author Robert Halliwell should he choose to continue Robbie and Sebastian’s story. (By the way, I vote a BIG YES on that idea.) Finally I could tell you that this new author, this amazing new “voice” is never run of the mill, over done or trite but dynamic, humorous, heartbreaking and incredibly well written.
Instead I will say just this: buy this book. Don’t miss out on what I believe could be one of the freshest new voices in the m/m genre. This story will make you feel a gamut of emotions and each time leave you breathless and hungry for just a little more of this marvelous story.
That is a very powerful statement and sometimes it takes authors several stories before they find their way. In this case where the novel in question, A Way Back To Then, is actually a spinoff featuring a character from a highly popular and established series, Tales From Foster High, it was pretty imperative that Mr. Halliwell establish his own voice so as not to merely imitate John Goode, the author of the aforementioned Foster High Series. I am so excited and delighted to report that Mr. Halliwell not only made this story his own but presented to his readers an exciting, witty, smart and deliciously snarky voice that could never be mistaken for anything other than genuine and fresh!
What an incredible first novel this author wrote for us. Jumping right from the Foster High series, A Way Back To Then seamlessly picks up on the life of Robbie DeCaro, the Long Island transplant who’d moved to Foster with his boyfriend, Riley a few years previous. When Riley is killed during a hit and run hate crime, Robbie begins on a self-destructive path embracing and unleashing his “inner Diva” and erecting a wall so high and thick around his heart that it is doubtful he will ever love again.
Plagued by panic attacks and a pain that runs so deep, he is finally able to come to terms with a friend who watched the accident but did nothing to help as Riley lay dying in his arms. Prior to his packing up and heading home to his mother’s home in Long Island, Robbie finds a restless peace with the town of Foster and leaves the dregs of his bitterness over their quiet bigotry behind. Once home, he feels so lost and while he tries to reconnect with former friends (and I use that term loosely) he finds that he can’t bring himself to do the cruising bar scene again. It takes his sister, Nicole and her crafty blind date set up to finally bring Robbie back into the dating scene, with near disastrous results. The real question becomes can Robbie ever find the strength and bravery to let that wall he is so safe behind crumble and let someone in? Could this blind date, Sebastian, be the one who can finally break through?
I could give you paragraphs about the supporting cast, the main characters, the wit and humor of the rapier sharp dialogue and the incredible journey that Robbie finally gets to begin once he allows himself the luxury of being happy and learning to trust that emotion again. I could remark on Robbie’s family and their love/fighting/bitchery that makes them some of the most interesting and hilarious secondary characters ever to grace a novel. I could tell you that while this novel draws its origins in the Foster High Series it is a completely different animal and could indeed be the anchor for a new series by author Robert Halliwell should he choose to continue Robbie and Sebastian’s story. (By the way, I vote a BIG YES on that idea.) Finally I could tell you that this new author, this amazing new “voice” is never run of the mill, over done or trite but dynamic, humorous, heartbreaking and incredibly well written.
Instead I will say just this: buy this book. Don’t miss out on what I believe could be one of the freshest new voices in the m/m genre. This story will make you feel a gamut of emotions and each time leave you breathless and hungry for just a little more of this marvelous story.
August 18, 2015
To say that I was looking forward to Robbie’s story was an understatement. I know that sounds cliché, but it’s the best way I can describe the need I felt at the end of 151 Days when we found out that the snarky and in-your-face Robbie in the Tales of Foster High books was basically a reaction, a defense mechanism, to Riley’s death and the treatment Robbie had to suffer in the town. After he “fades off into the sunset” towards the end of that book, I just had to know that Robbie could have another HEA.
We finally get that here.
Robbie returns to Long Island, finally ready to brush the dust from Foster off his feet and learn to get his life back. He returns to his mother’s home, where his wonderful family is there to help him. And such great secondary characters we have with Rose, Robbie’s mom, Nicole, Robbie’s sister, and James, his uncle. I couldn’t help but realize where Robbie got his snark from. Robbie's here with all his sarcastic wit and tongue-lashings, but we also get to see that vulnerable Robbie that we saw in 151 Days, and I have to say it just made me love him more.
Robbie goes out on a blind date with Sebastian, a co-worker of his sister. And even though Sebastian is runway-model gorgeous, he’s not the sharpest tool in the tool box. But he has a heart of gold in him, and the two hit it off in ways that surprise both Robbie and his family. Some a little more than others.
I loved the memories of Riley that we got in this one, the happy and the sad ones. He was such a knight-in-shining armor, like Robbie says, such an incredible person, but Sebastian is exactly what Robbie needs right now. From their auspicious first meeting to their first date, oh boy, was I laughing until I was crying. (The Disney movie references alone are hilarious and worth the price of admission.)
It’s not a wild and crazy ride for Robbie, but it’s an honest and open one where Robbie finally lets himself have want he wants and needs, all with some wonderful advice from some of the family. It truly showed me the real Robbie, and I’m so glad that I got to meet him.
We finally get that here.
Robbie returns to Long Island, finally ready to brush the dust from Foster off his feet and learn to get his life back. He returns to his mother’s home, where his wonderful family is there to help him. And such great secondary characters we have with Rose, Robbie’s mom, Nicole, Robbie’s sister, and James, his uncle. I couldn’t help but realize where Robbie got his snark from. Robbie's here with all his sarcastic wit and tongue-lashings, but we also get to see that vulnerable Robbie that we saw in 151 Days, and I have to say it just made me love him more.
Robbie goes out on a blind date with Sebastian, a co-worker of his sister. And even though Sebastian is runway-model gorgeous, he’s not the sharpest tool in the tool box. But he has a heart of gold in him, and the two hit it off in ways that surprise both Robbie and his family. Some a little more than others.
I loved the memories of Riley that we got in this one, the happy and the sad ones. He was such a knight-in-shining armor, like Robbie says, such an incredible person, but Sebastian is exactly what Robbie needs right now. From their auspicious first meeting to their first date, oh boy, was I laughing until I was crying. (The Disney movie references alone are hilarious and worth the price of admission.)
It’s not a wild and crazy ride for Robbie, but it’s an honest and open one where Robbie finally lets himself have want he wants and needs, all with some wonderful advice from some of the family. It truly showed me the real Robbie, and I’m so glad that I got to meet him.
July 13, 2015
3.75 stars rounded up
Robbie DeCaro made his impression on me during his appearance on John Goode's Tales of Foster High series. Basically becoming a father figure to Kyle, snarky queen Robbie stole every scenes he was ever in, even before I knew his sad story regarding his first love, Riley. So I was pretty excited when I knew that he would have his own book. ALTHOUGH, at the beginning I was pretty confused since the author's name was not John Goode. I thought Robert Halliwell was a pen name of John, until John said that Robert was the guy that John based Robbie from.
All right then.
Well, all I could say that this was indeed Robbie's book. Yes, there were other secondary characters: his colorful family (Mom, Uncle, Sister), and a new love interest (Sebastian) ... but this was mainly Robbie's story. No one else. And it was captivating all the same.
It was good to see things from Robbie's perspective. Yes, he could still be snarky and bitchy, but by having Robbie in the driver's seat, we also learned about his vulnerabilities, his anxiety issues, his fears, and his dreams. In a sense, this book makes Robbie more well-rounded as a character.
I thought the 'new' love relationship with Sebastian was pretty unique, if not refreshing. It would be easy to make Sebastian the 'perfect' guy, who would be so patient handling Robbie, who would be so charming ... who would be, well, the second Riley.
But Sebastian wasn't...
The flaws that started Robbie and Sebastian's relationship, the arguments, the fact that they both stumbled and fall, that it wasn't perfect, was what made this book wonderful it its own way. I just wish I read more of them before that EVIL epilogue.
Halliwell's writing was easy, and fits the tone of the whole series nicely. The steamy level was very low -- sex scenes happened off page. I didn't mind it, but I am sure some readers will find it a problem :).
And yes, that ending is evil. At least I already get the next book.
Robbie DeCaro made his impression on me during his appearance on John Goode's Tales of Foster High series. Basically becoming a father figure to Kyle, snarky queen Robbie stole every scenes he was ever in, even before I knew his sad story regarding his first love, Riley. So I was pretty excited when I knew that he would have his own book. ALTHOUGH, at the beginning I was pretty confused since the author's name was not John Goode. I thought Robert Halliwell was a pen name of John, until John said that Robert was the guy that John based Robbie from.
All right then.
Well, all I could say that this was indeed Robbie's book. Yes, there were other secondary characters: his colorful family (Mom, Uncle, Sister), and a new love interest (Sebastian) ... but this was mainly Robbie's story. No one else. And it was captivating all the same.
It was good to see things from Robbie's perspective. Yes, he could still be snarky and bitchy, but by having Robbie in the driver's seat, we also learned about his vulnerabilities, his anxiety issues, his fears, and his dreams. In a sense, this book makes Robbie more well-rounded as a character.
I thought the 'new' love relationship with Sebastian was pretty unique, if not refreshing. It would be easy to make Sebastian the 'perfect' guy, who would be so patient handling Robbie, who would be so charming ... who would be, well, the second Riley.
But Sebastian wasn't...
The flaws that started Robbie and Sebastian's relationship, the arguments, the fact that they both stumbled and fall, that it wasn't perfect, was what made this book wonderful it its own way. I just wish I read more of them before that EVIL epilogue.
Halliwell's writing was easy, and fits the tone of the whole series nicely. The steamy level was very low -- sex scenes happened off page. I didn't mind it, but I am sure some readers will find it a problem :).
And yes, that ending is evil. At least I already get the next book.
June 9, 2015
Snap, snark, and barbs - bitchiness elevated to an art form. Robbie is back!!!
Robbie has shaken off the dust of Texas and settled once again with his family in Long Island. He still uses sarcasm and razor sharp barbs to hide his vulnerabilities and protect his heart but, he is ready to take baby steps and start living again.
Riley was Robbie’s first love. Riley worshiped, loved and adored Robbie and would have given him the moon. Death put an end to the fairy tale and, Robbie is lost and has to make a life without him. Robbie’s sister sets him up with Sebastian a co-worker. Seb is a former model and like Robbie has returned home disillusioned and a little wiser.
Robbie falls in love with Seb and it is so very different from what he had with Riley. Seb is a large teddy bear but not always the brightest Crayola in the box when it comes to matching wits with Robbie but, he sees the real Robbie. He knows about Robbie’s insecurities, panic attacks and irrational fears. He accepts it as being a part of Robbie and loves him all the more. These two have such a great chemistry and when they bicker and trade insults it is priceless.
Robbie’s family is NUTS and I loved them. The book ends on cliffhanger. Robbie got a call from Tyler and is heading to Texas. Someone in Foster is in trouble and, they are circling the wagons.
Robbie has shaken off the dust of Texas and settled once again with his family in Long Island. He still uses sarcasm and razor sharp barbs to hide his vulnerabilities and protect his heart but, he is ready to take baby steps and start living again.
Riley was Robbie’s first love. Riley worshiped, loved and adored Robbie and would have given him the moon. Death put an end to the fairy tale and, Robbie is lost and has to make a life without him. Robbie’s sister sets him up with Sebastian a co-worker. Seb is a former model and like Robbie has returned home disillusioned and a little wiser.
Robbie falls in love with Seb and it is so very different from what he had with Riley. Seb is a large teddy bear but not always the brightest Crayola in the box when it comes to matching wits with Robbie but, he sees the real Robbie. He knows about Robbie’s insecurities, panic attacks and irrational fears. He accepts it as being a part of Robbie and loves him all the more. These two have such a great chemistry and when they bicker and trade insults it is priceless.
Robbie’s family is NUTS and I loved them. The book ends on cliffhanger. Robbie got a call from Tyler and is heading to Texas. Someone in Foster is in trouble and, they are circling the wagons.
December 28, 2016
I'm sorry, Riley :-(!! Not only was this not for me, I actively disliked it :-/. I didn't like Robbie, or his ridiculous snarkiness, or his unreliable narration, or, well, his vibe. I didn't feel ANY connection/chemistry between him and Sebastian, and this most definitely wasn't what I expected. Even all the recounts on Riley felt clinical and failed to draw me in :-/. I have a feeling it was less about "content" and more about presentation ... it was just all over the place, and Robbie ... he was just abrasive, prickly, and offputting; so much so, he put me off this book entirely :-/. I'm bummed, because I expected MUCH more from a book that is remotely a part of the 'Tales From Foster High' series, and was sorely disappointed!! I recognize I'm probably in the minority and sincerely don't mean to make the author feel bad, but this was just my take on my experience with this book. This was a bust :-/.
It would have been awesome if this were on KU, for obvious reasons :-/.
I'm finally ready to read this *takes deep breath* ... here we go ...
Note: Riley's letter to Robbie (in John Goode's '151 Days') absolutely gutted me (which is INCREDIBLY difficult to do and so, so, SO rare) :-/, which is why I've been hesitant to read Robbie's story. But I do want to read it, I do, and I will, now! I'm ready :-)!!
It would have been awesome if this were on KU, for obvious reasons :-/.
Note: Riley's letter to Robbie (in John Goode's '151 Days') absolutely gutted me (which is INCREDIBLY difficult to do and so, so, SO rare) :-/, which is why I've been hesitant to read Robbie's story. But I do want to read it, I do, and I will, now! I'm ready :-)!!
November 19, 2015
I am not going to write a long review as others have written such great ones (see Elsbeth and Sonia for example).
Yes Robert Halliwell took on a dangerous assignment for an author, i.e. taking a character by a different author and writing that character's story. He did a wonderful job of telling Robbie's story. Robbie has grown and changed since the love of his life, Riley. He reviews his life with more mature eyes and therefore more understanding of his love of Riley. Sebastian can be the love of a more mature Robbie if Robbie will allow it.
Good story.
Yes Robert Halliwell took on a dangerous assignment for an author, i.e. taking a character by a different author and writing that character's story. He did a wonderful job of telling Robbie's story. Robbie has grown and changed since the love of his life, Riley. He reviews his life with more mature eyes and therefore more understanding of his love of Riley. Sebastian can be the love of a more mature Robbie if Robbie will allow it.
Good story.
July 6, 2015
It was great reading Robbie getting back on his feet. And meeting someone!
There were times though that I was wondering who am I reading about because of Robbie's new voice.
Still a good read though. :) Foster High fans should read this.
3.5 STARS!
There were times though that I was wondering who am I reading about because of Robbie's new voice.
Still a good read though. :) Foster High fans should read this.
3.5 STARS!
June 21, 2016
4.5 Stars
Bravo gentlemen, Bravo!
This really was beyond what I expected. We got very little of Robbie’s “voice” in 151 Days…but there was never a time when I read this that I looked down at my book and thought…Is this Robbie?? This was beautifully portrayed, witty and heartbreaking, and ultimately so in keeping with the character we have grown to love.
Now onto the book...
Well…I cried on the first page…
I cried on the second page…
I grabbed another box of Kleenex…
I met the family, pee’d in my pants but continued on…
I cried again…
I virtually punched Sean in the face…
I went on a fabulous first date which I long to re-read again and again… (I mean…really…this could not have been more fabulous and while FATE can be a bitch…FATE handed Robbie the perfect guy to tear down his emotional walls, quite literally…everything about this date from start to finish was perfection)…
I wanted to kiss Sebastian...
I wanted to hug Robbie...
I belted out laughter on the street…
I belted out laughter on the street…
I belted out laughter on the street… (yes, this happened…numerous times and honestly this is one of the funniest damn books I have ever read)…
I wanted to hit Tyler… (yeah I know. I shouldn’t feel this way anymore, but that’s a hard one to let go of, even with as much as I know now and as much as I love this character)...
I wanted to eat at Robbie’s Mom's house…
I want to hang out with the old bitter (but crass and awesome) Uncle James…
I wanted to watch every Broadway Musical and Disney movie referenced in this book…
I wanted to text with Kyle...
And ultimately I wanted more…this was way too short…I only hope that there will be another book in Robbie’s far from Neverland world. Especially now that his heart has melted.
So I land at 4.5…while I loved every minute of this…I do wish we had gotten more of Riley. While we got some and we know the love that Robbie felt for him, we did not get enough of them…of the love they shared, of what made Riley special. I would have liked their first date. Seeing maybe more differences between these two amazing men that have developed an affection for this wonderful character.
I eagerly await the next in the Foster High Universe as yes…there’s a cliffy…WTF was that all about??? Hmmmm Guess I’ll have to wait and see.
A fabulous BR with Sonia, Elsbeth, Momo, Nathan and Paul.
Status Updates:
1%
Yeah...I had to go for Kleenex on the first goddamn page.
4%
Elphaba ❤️❤️❤️
7%
A weak smile appeared on my face and tears filled my eyes as I looked at the bed. The mattress and bed set I had in Foster were the last things I threw out before I left. The bed was the first thing Riley and I had bought together when we moved into the house. No one had and no one would ever sleep in that bed except us.
The bed in front of me would be only mine.
8%
If you don’t think people are born gay, I have news for you: we most certainly are. I would dream that my house was covered in thorns and my family and I were eagerly waiting for the handsome prince to come save us.
Excuse me while I fill the feed with updates...I can't help myself. ❤️
June 6 2015 1:53 PM
view status update 15% done with A Way Back to Then: I made eye contact with the sandy-haired, green-eyed boy wearing cowboy boots.
***
Fate, quite literally, had bumped me on the head and handed me my sweet prince.
The same prince Fate would one day rip from the world.
And my soul.
Riley
25%
“How can I ‘get,’ pray tell?”
"Well,” he started slowly, “you can come off a little strong, and that’s not a bad thing, but Tyler is very quiet, and he’s still trying to figure everything out.”
I stared at the side of Riley’s face and cocked an eyebrow. “In other words he’s a newbie and you’re afraid I might barf a rainbow all over his face.” In Riley’s defense, I suppose I did come across like a one-man Broadway show sometimes.
31%
I really should have had my Xanax prescription renewed.
T-Shirt anyone??
35%
“I’m just saying. It’s been forever since someone’s been up there. I hope you don’t have any bats hibernating in your ass.” He took a sip of his tea while trying to hide his satanic smile.
“Uck! Do not get me started on what is stuck in where, old man, or I’ll tell them where Jimmy Hoffa is buried.”
38%
When I knew I was done, I turned the clippers off, put it on the counter, and pulled the plug out of the wall. I looked at my reflection and cursed myself for not going all Anne Hathaway by singing “I Dreamed a Dream” while I was cutting.
*grabs another box of kleenex*
41%
Enter Sebastian...yep I approve. *eyes pop out of head with Robbie*
53%
57%
“You do know I can kick your ass, like, fifteen different ways, right?” he said, grinning.
"Oh, bitch, please. You think you’re so tough? Try surviving clearance day at Valentina’s when she marks down the good wigs. You got nothing on New York drag queens.”
74%
So how does get one get invited to the "Moose" gathering??? ;)
Brad…
Matt...
Sebastian...
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
97%
Where to begin? I guess first, I want to express my absolute amazement at the wonders of both Robert and John. While maybe this kind of hand off writing has been done before, I have never before seen it or experienced it as a reader. This took courage on both sides and so much trust. Trust from John to be able to hand over a character in this way…that Robbie (yeah I can’t do Robert or Rob...it’s stuck already) will not fuck this up…that he will write with a similar love and affection for his characters that we have seen thus far in the Foster High Series. And gosh…the courage it must have taken Robbie to embark in such a writing adventure as this. So how did it go from my standpoint???
Bravo gentlemen, Bravo!
This really was beyond what I expected. We got very little of Robbie’s “voice” in 151 Days…but there was never a time when I read this that I looked down at my book and thought…Is this Robbie?? This was beautifully portrayed, witty and heartbreaking, and ultimately so in keeping with the character we have grown to love.
Now onto the book...
Well…I cried on the first page…
I cried on the second page…
I grabbed another box of Kleenex…
I met the family, pee’d in my pants but continued on…
I cried again…
I virtually punched Sean in the face…
I went on a fabulous first date which I long to re-read again and again… (I mean…really…this could not have been more fabulous and while FATE can be a bitch…FATE handed Robbie the perfect guy to tear down his emotional walls, quite literally…everything about this date from start to finish was perfection)…
I wanted to kiss Sebastian...
I wanted to hug Robbie...
I belted out laughter on the street…
I belted out laughter on the street…
I belted out laughter on the street… (yes, this happened…numerous times and honestly this is one of the funniest damn books I have ever read)…
I wanted to hit Tyler… (yeah I know. I shouldn’t feel this way anymore, but that’s a hard one to let go of, even with as much as I know now and as much as I love this character)...
I wanted to eat at Robbie’s Mom's house…
I want to hang out with the old bitter (but crass and awesome) Uncle James…
I wanted to watch every Broadway Musical and Disney movie referenced in this book…
I wanted to text with Kyle...
And ultimately I wanted more…this was way too short…I only hope that there will be another book in Robbie’s far from Neverland world. Especially now that his heart has melted.
So I land at 4.5…while I loved every minute of this…I do wish we had gotten more of Riley. While we got some and we know the love that Robbie felt for him, we did not get enough of them…of the love they shared, of what made Riley special. I would have liked their first date. Seeing maybe more differences between these two amazing men that have developed an affection for this wonderful character.
I eagerly await the next in the Foster High Universe as yes…there’s a cliffy…WTF was that all about??? Hmmmm Guess I’ll have to wait and see.
A fabulous BR with Sonia, Elsbeth, Momo, Nathan and Paul.
Status Updates:
1%
Yeah...I had to go for Kleenex on the first goddamn page.
4%
Elphaba ❤️❤️❤️
7%
A weak smile appeared on my face and tears filled my eyes as I looked at the bed. The mattress and bed set I had in Foster were the last things I threw out before I left. The bed was the first thing Riley and I had bought together when we moved into the house. No one had and no one would ever sleep in that bed except us.
The bed in front of me would be only mine.
8%
If you don’t think people are born gay, I have news for you: we most certainly are. I would dream that my house was covered in thorns and my family and I were eagerly waiting for the handsome prince to come save us.
Excuse me while I fill the feed with updates...I can't help myself. ❤️
June 6 2015 1:53 PM
view status update 15% done with A Way Back to Then: I made eye contact with the sandy-haired, green-eyed boy wearing cowboy boots.
***
Fate, quite literally, had bumped me on the head and handed me my sweet prince.
The same prince Fate would one day rip from the world.
And my soul.
Riley
25%
“How can I ‘get,’ pray tell?”
"Well,” he started slowly, “you can come off a little strong, and that’s not a bad thing, but Tyler is very quiet, and he’s still trying to figure everything out.”
I stared at the side of Riley’s face and cocked an eyebrow. “In other words he’s a newbie and you’re afraid I might barf a rainbow all over his face.” In Riley’s defense, I suppose I did come across like a one-man Broadway show sometimes.
31%
I really should have had my Xanax prescription renewed.
T-Shirt anyone??
35%
“I’m just saying. It’s been forever since someone’s been up there. I hope you don’t have any bats hibernating in your ass.” He took a sip of his tea while trying to hide his satanic smile.
“Uck! Do not get me started on what is stuck in where, old man, or I’ll tell them where Jimmy Hoffa is buried.”
38%
When I knew I was done, I turned the clippers off, put it on the counter, and pulled the plug out of the wall. I looked at my reflection and cursed myself for not going all Anne Hathaway by singing “I Dreamed a Dream” while I was cutting.
*grabs another box of kleenex*
41%
Enter Sebastian...yep I approve. *eyes pop out of head with Robbie*
53%
57%
“You do know I can kick your ass, like, fifteen different ways, right?” he said, grinning.
"Oh, bitch, please. You think you’re so tough? Try surviving clearance day at Valentina’s when she marks down the good wigs. You got nothing on New York drag queens.”
74%
So how does get one get invited to the "Moose" gathering??? ;)
Brad…
Matt...
Sebastian...
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
97%
July 23, 2017
Another spin Off of the Foster high Series. I have to admit I wasn't a big fan of Robbie's but after this one I like him hehe . It's a nice story about Robbie realizing that you can love again in life even after tragedy bruised your heart
August 21, 2015
3.5 stars
I was curious when this book first appeared on my periphery and asked John Goode, author of Tales from Foster High series about it (after six books plus in the series, there's a different author writing it?). He twitted me that this book was written by the guy the character Robbie was based on, one Robert Halliwell to be exact. :) In fact, this book sounded exactly like Robbie DeCaro on the series I had read so far. Probably, especially, as the story told from first person's POV.
The opening scene overlapped with what happened on 151 Days, specifically Robbie's last days in Foster, Texas. And moving forward from there. Although the story threw back a few times to the when he first met Riley, moved to Foster, and the couple got close to then-still-in-the-closet Tyler. We got to see the happy times as well as the gut-wrenching tragedy in detail. Those, were not news.
What's news, to me at least, was the secret Robbie kept all this time. Even from his beloved Riley. Behind the snarky, smart mouth was a rather vulnerable personalities. And of course, like any rom com movie drama, he was that close to jeopardising a potential happiness with the above mentioned secret and stubbornness.
But worry not, this book was not total gloom doom. Far from it. I mean, you had met Robbie in previous books right? Here we also met his very unusual family, a bunch of Italian New Yorker with attitude. They (mother, son, sister, uncle) bickered, teased and butt in each other's noses.
So, it's good to know more about past, present and future Robbie after we saw him as Kyle's sort of "adopted father" all this time. Speaking of, THAT ENDING!!!!
I'm sure the author conspired with John Goode on THAT ENDING. *giving both author the stink eye*
But I've plan on reading When I Grow Up anyway. So there.
I was curious when this book first appeared on my periphery and asked John Goode, author of Tales from Foster High series about it (after six books plus in the series, there's a different author writing it?). He twitted me that this book was written by the guy the character Robbie was based on, one Robert Halliwell to be exact. :) In fact, this book sounded exactly like Robbie DeCaro on the series I had read so far. Probably, especially, as the story told from first person's POV.
The opening scene overlapped with what happened on 151 Days, specifically Robbie's last days in Foster, Texas. And moving forward from there. Although the story threw back a few times to the when he first met Riley, moved to Foster, and the couple got close to then-still-in-the-closet Tyler. We got to see the happy times as well as the gut-wrenching tragedy in detail. Those, were not news.
What's news, to me at least, was the secret Robbie kept all this time. Even from his beloved Riley. Behind the snarky, smart mouth was a rather vulnerable personalities. And of course, like any rom com movie drama, he was that close to jeopardising a potential happiness with the above mentioned secret and stubbornness.
But worry not, this book was not total gloom doom. Far from it. I mean, you had met Robbie in previous books right? Here we also met his very unusual family, a bunch of Italian New Yorker with attitude. They (mother, son, sister, uncle) bickered, teased and butt in each other's noses.
So, it's good to know more about past, present and future Robbie after we saw him as Kyle's sort of "adopted father" all this time. Speaking of, THAT ENDING!!!!
I'm sure the author conspired with John Goode on THAT ENDING. *giving both author the stink eye*
But I've plan on reading When I Grow Up anyway. So there.
June 30, 2015
A Joyfully Jay review.
4.75 stars
Robbie was a favorite character of mine in the original series. I loved his wit and personality from the first time we met him in Tales From Foster High, and I was pleased and surprised that his story was being introduced at this time. I say pleased because to me, Robbie was an integral character, and surprised because the story was written by an author other than John Goode. Would Halliwell do the story justice, that was the question…
Written as a retrospective, the present and past come together, giving us a firm idea of who Robbie DeCaro was as a partner, son, brother, and nephew. I found the parallel between Robbie and his Uncle James, both of whom lost their loves and had great difficulty dealing with the pain, was effective and I also that Halliwell masterfully addressed the other secondary characters, like Sebastien, Nicole, and Robbie’s mother, giving them life and letting their personalities shine without taking away from the main focus of the book.
As much as I enjoyed the story, there were a few things that caught my eye and pulled me out of the book, such as when Robbie thought to himself that Sebastien worked in IT department when we had already been told he worked in the mailroom. Now it took a while, but I eventually figured out it was intentional, a flub on the part of Robbie, and not of the writing. I also had some difficulty wrapping my mind around the quick progression of Robbie and Sebastien’s relationship, although here too, some additional context was provided that smoothed it out, but wow, it sure was quick.
Read Jason’s review in its entirety here.
4.75 stars
Robbie was a favorite character of mine in the original series. I loved his wit and personality from the first time we met him in Tales From Foster High, and I was pleased and surprised that his story was being introduced at this time. I say pleased because to me, Robbie was an integral character, and surprised because the story was written by an author other than John Goode. Would Halliwell do the story justice, that was the question…
Written as a retrospective, the present and past come together, giving us a firm idea of who Robbie DeCaro was as a partner, son, brother, and nephew. I found the parallel between Robbie and his Uncle James, both of whom lost their loves and had great difficulty dealing with the pain, was effective and I also that Halliwell masterfully addressed the other secondary characters, like Sebastien, Nicole, and Robbie’s mother, giving them life and letting their personalities shine without taking away from the main focus of the book.
As much as I enjoyed the story, there were a few things that caught my eye and pulled me out of the book, such as when Robbie thought to himself that Sebastien worked in IT department when we had already been told he worked in the mailroom. Now it took a while, but I eventually figured out it was intentional, a flub on the part of Robbie, and not of the writing. I also had some difficulty wrapping my mind around the quick progression of Robbie and Sebastien’s relationship, although here too, some additional context was provided that smoothed it out, but wow, it sure was quick.
Read Jason’s review in its entirety here.
January 27, 2016
I've been following Tales from Foster High from the moment Brad kissed Kyle. However, through the triumphs and heartbreaks one character remains a mystery.
A Way Back to Then is a perfect marriage of the tales from Robbie's past, his present, and future. Riley's death has been a significant part of the series, but one character seem too afraid to tell his story. In this book, Robbie finally opened the floodgates to the past and in turn, let his future in.
I was hooked by the story of Riley's death from the eyes of his husband, but I can't believe I'd be entertained by this book as well. The perfect blend of sass, snark, self-awareness, and fear is what makes Robbie who he is. However, Robert Halliwell was able to differentiate the Robbie of the past and the Robbie of the present in very subtle ways. It was refreshing to meet the colorful characters in his life as well.
Books dealing with very depressing stories can be a chore to read sometimes. The words are too heavy and the emotions do not let up even for a few pages. However, Robert Halliwell took John Goode's Robbie and added a few more shade to his already dynamic character. As with the other characters of the series, it was as if I was talking to Robbie on my couch, listening to his tales over a glass of wine.
A Way Back to Then is a perfect marriage of the tales from Robbie's past, his present, and future. Riley's death has been a significant part of the series, but one character seem too afraid to tell his story. In this book, Robbie finally opened the floodgates to the past and in turn, let his future in.
I was hooked by the story of Riley's death from the eyes of his husband, but I can't believe I'd be entertained by this book as well. The perfect blend of sass, snark, self-awareness, and fear is what makes Robbie who he is. However, Robert Halliwell was able to differentiate the Robbie of the past and the Robbie of the present in very subtle ways. It was refreshing to meet the colorful characters in his life as well.
Books dealing with very depressing stories can be a chore to read sometimes. The words are too heavy and the emotions do not let up even for a few pages. However, Robert Halliwell took John Goode's Robbie and added a few more shade to his already dynamic character. As with the other characters of the series, it was as if I was talking to Robbie on my couch, listening to his tales over a glass of wine.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews