What do you think?
The Wednesday Box: A Dark Fable
Some stories begin with "Once Upon a Time..."
This one begins with loneliness.
From the bestselling author of WistWood comes THE WEDNESDAY BOX, an illustrated supernatural horror novel for readers who love the haunting edge of stories like Coraline, The Thief of Always, The Graveyard Book, Neverwhere, and The Nest.
"Thoughtful, tense, and hauntingly beautiful, this is a story whose rich atmosphere and emotional intensity will linger with you long after the final page is turned. You'll feel for May, just as I did. It's quietly devastating in all the right ways."
"Beneath all the strange events, this is also a story about exhaustion, poverty, protection, and the terrible compromises people make when they’re trying to survive. That emotional foundation makes the darker turns of the story hit much harder."
"Jonathan Kieran's novel THE WEDNESDAY BOX compellingly showcases the devious actions of evil, the perception of young minds, and the perseverance of a brave, imaginative girl who will do everything she can to escape the evil surrounding her." - INDIEREADER
May is eleven years old, and she has already learned how to survive in a world of shrieking subway rails, soot-stained skies, and apartment hallways where silence, caution, and never asking for too much are simply facts of life.
But when a grotesque, bloated man in a raincoat the color of broken promises begins to haunt her steps—on the train, in the tunnels, at her own door—May realizes two terrifying truths...
Only she can see him.
And keeping quiet will no longer keep her safe.
Wednesday is the only day May cannot be alone.
The only night.
When she finally shares her fear with her exhausted single mother, help arrives in the form of a new caretaker who seems to fit the kind, grandmotherly bill. But in May’s world, kindness can wear a mask, safety can be a trap, and the forgotten are often the easiest to prey upon.
Soon, May discovers that the tempting contents of an ancient box hold dangers far worse than anything she has ever feared.
The greatest danger, however, is not what hunts her, but the impossible choice before her…
Tell the truth and risk losing the one person she cannot live without.
Or keep silent and face the darkness alone.
Because below the city, something older than existence is hunting.
And it knows her name.
"Kieran weaves a starkly beautiful tapestry of gothic atmosphere and fairy-tale danger, prioritizing emotional realism over easy genre tropes. It is a sharp, unsettling, and lyrical read that will deeply resonate with anyone drawn to high-stakes psychological tension and evocative, atmospheric storytelling."
START READING.
This one begins with loneliness.
From the bestselling author of WistWood comes THE WEDNESDAY BOX, an illustrated supernatural horror novel for readers who love the haunting edge of stories like Coraline, The Thief of Always, The Graveyard Book, Neverwhere, and The Nest.
"Thoughtful, tense, and hauntingly beautiful, this is a story whose rich atmosphere and emotional intensity will linger with you long after the final page is turned. You'll feel for May, just as I did. It's quietly devastating in all the right ways."
"Beneath all the strange events, this is also a story about exhaustion, poverty, protection, and the terrible compromises people make when they’re trying to survive. That emotional foundation makes the darker turns of the story hit much harder."
"Jonathan Kieran's novel THE WEDNESDAY BOX compellingly showcases the devious actions of evil, the perception of young minds, and the perseverance of a brave, imaginative girl who will do everything she can to escape the evil surrounding her." - INDIEREADER
May is eleven years old, and she has already learned how to survive in a world of shrieking subway rails, soot-stained skies, and apartment hallways where silence, caution, and never asking for too much are simply facts of life.
But when a grotesque, bloated man in a raincoat the color of broken promises begins to haunt her steps—on the train, in the tunnels, at her own door—May realizes two terrifying truths...
Only she can see him.
And keeping quiet will no longer keep her safe.
Wednesday is the only day May cannot be alone.
The only night.
When she finally shares her fear with her exhausted single mother, help arrives in the form of a new caretaker who seems to fit the kind, grandmotherly bill. But in May’s world, kindness can wear a mask, safety can be a trap, and the forgotten are often the easiest to prey upon.
Soon, May discovers that the tempting contents of an ancient box hold dangers far worse than anything she has ever feared.
The greatest danger, however, is not what hunts her, but the impossible choice before her…
Tell the truth and risk losing the one person she cannot live without.
Or keep silent and face the darkness alone.
Because below the city, something older than existence is hunting.
And it knows her name.
"Kieran weaves a starkly beautiful tapestry of gothic atmosphere and fairy-tale danger, prioritizing emotional realism over easy genre tropes. It is a sharp, unsettling, and lyrical read that will deeply resonate with anyone drawn to high-stakes psychological tension and evocative, atmospheric storytelling."
START READING.
- GenresHorror
About the author
Jonathan Kieran
11 books56 followersKirkus-acclaimed author Jonathan Kieran is a writer and illustrator with a passion for world travel and ancient history—and an occasionally bewildered grasp of the present. He lives in a rustic house in the woodlands not far from Big Sur, California, where he awaits the future confidently with plenty of firewood, a new cat named Beezley, mercurial internet access, a magical footbridge (troll-infested and everything), and a reasonable supply of Cabernet Sauvignon. There also appears to be a significant Pinot Noir backup; viticultural shortages are not to be countenanced.
Jonathan’s interests are eclectic. He is as likely to regale you with an account of his latest misadventures in the Midi-Pyrénées as he is to ask if you happen to have any spare cookies about the house—and if so, whether you might part with five of them. Nothing piques his interest like a good old-fashioned discussion about cryptozoology, Tuscan cuisine, classical English literature, the perils of pop culture, or the harrowing details of great white shark attacks.
In addition to running up and down various mountainsides to burn off calories accrued from the wanton consumption of baked goods, Jonathan enjoys a good party with people unafraid to laugh, and he veritably lives for bedtime.
He is the author and illustrator of The Wednesday Box, WistWood and the Enchanted Heritage Chronicles, with more adventures to come.
Jonathan’s interests are eclectic. He is as likely to regale you with an account of his latest misadventures in the Midi-Pyrénées as he is to ask if you happen to have any spare cookies about the house—and if so, whether you might part with five of them. Nothing piques his interest like a good old-fashioned discussion about cryptozoology, Tuscan cuisine, classical English literature, the perils of pop culture, or the harrowing details of great white shark attacks.
In addition to running up and down various mountainsides to burn off calories accrued from the wanton consumption of baked goods, Jonathan enjoys a good party with people unafraid to laugh, and he veritably lives for bedtime.
He is the author and illustrator of The Wednesday Box, WistWood and the Enchanted Heritage Chronicles, with more adventures to come.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews
August 27, 2026
Jonathan Kieran is a versatile author and artist known for blending dark fantasy and folklore with gothic melodrama, and The Wednesday Box showcases that signature old-world flair.
It has the same tender, spooky energy as Coraline, The Graveyard Book and The Thief of Always, with illustrations that add another layer to the mood.
The Wednesday Box centers on a strange, enigmatic wooden box that disrupts the lives of those who encounter it. As uncanny events unfold, the narrative delves into secrets, temptation, and the quiet consequences of curiosity. May is the 11 year old girl who chances upon the box while being looked after one evening. What follows is an eerie tumble into another existence altogether. May and the other characters in the book are drawn more as figures navigating a fable, than grounded, modern personalities. (I was taken back to my childhood days reading Mother Goose. The stories are geared toward children, but the true subject matters can be difficult for children to navigate.)
Ultimately, it was a good read! Kieran’s illustrations throughout added a wonderful visual depth to the story, and logophiles will particularly enjoy the author’s word usage skills, as his vocabulary is dense, expressive, and crafted with obvious care. However, for a story built on eerie, dark folklore, I was left looking for something a little more haunting. This could easily be given as a gift to anyone age 12 or older.
Thank you to Brightbourne Books and Media, NetGalley, and Jonathan Kieran for the opportunity to read this book.
(3.5⭐️ rounded up) I received a copy of this book for free. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
It has the same tender, spooky energy as Coraline, The Graveyard Book and The Thief of Always, with illustrations that add another layer to the mood.
The Wednesday Box centers on a strange, enigmatic wooden box that disrupts the lives of those who encounter it. As uncanny events unfold, the narrative delves into secrets, temptation, and the quiet consequences of curiosity. May is the 11 year old girl who chances upon the box while being looked after one evening. What follows is an eerie tumble into another existence altogether. May and the other characters in the book are drawn more as figures navigating a fable, than grounded, modern personalities. (I was taken back to my childhood days reading Mother Goose. The stories are geared toward children, but the true subject matters can be difficult for children to navigate.)
Ultimately, it was a good read! Kieran’s illustrations throughout added a wonderful visual depth to the story, and logophiles will particularly enjoy the author’s word usage skills, as his vocabulary is dense, expressive, and crafted with obvious care. However, for a story built on eerie, dark folklore, I was left looking for something a little more haunting. This could easily be given as a gift to anyone age 12 or older.
Thank you to Brightbourne Books and Media, NetGalley, and Jonathan Kieran for the opportunity to read this book.
(3.5⭐️ rounded up) I received a copy of this book for free. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 23, 2026
I LOVED this! The illustrations are incredible and I loved the pacing and writing style. The world building in this is masterfully done and draws you in. This is an awesome story that I would HIGHLY recommend! Special Thank You to Jonathan Kieran, Xpresso Books and Netgalley for allowing me to read a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.
July 31, 2026
This was so creepy and good! I loved it! My only gripe was it could have been shorter as the descriptions went on for far too long! Great writing and soooo scary. Loved it.
July 21, 2026
This book is plugged as perfect for lovers of Coraline, and as that’s a favourite of mine, I was excited to read it. Was I disappointed? No. It’s a really good story with engaging characters and a mood of menace and darkness all the way through. But I did struggle to stay engaged in the beginning. Not the very beginning that gives us our understanding of May and the difficult life her and her mother lead, or when we meet the first of a wide range of monstrous “bad guys.” That bit had might right away. But at the first point of May’s crossover, I seemed to be plodding through it, which is a shame. However, it did pick right back up and I flew to the end, not able to put it down until I was done. So it’s four stars from me but definitely worth a place on your TBR.
June 28, 2026
A Creepy Little Ride Into the Dark
Dark, eerie and wonderfully atmospheric, ‘The Wednesday Box’ immediately creates an unsettling feeling. The gloomy city, creepy tunnels and mysterious figure following May give the story a haunting edge, while the illustrations add another layer to the overall experience.
May is an easy character to root for. Being the only one who can see the strange man following her makes her situation increasingly frightening, especially when keeping quiet is no longer enough to keep her safe. The mystery surrounding the Wednesday Box adds another intriguing element, and the story does a good job of creating that feeling that something much darker is hiding beneath the surface.
The writing is smooth and straightforward, which makes this an easy and quick read. There are some genuinely creepy moments, and the supernatural elements keep the story moving. The atmosphere is definitely one of its strongest points.
For this reader, the main reason for the three-star rating is that the book feels much more like YA horror than adult horror. The characters and writing style fit a younger audience well, but as an adult reader, both felt a little too simple at times. The premise has plenty of potential for something darker and more disturbing, but the story did not quite reach that level.
That said, readers who enjoy atmospheric YA horror will probably find plenty to appreciate here. The combination of a young protagonist, supernatural danger, a mysterious box and an eerie setting makes for an engaging and creepy story.
A haunting and atmospheric read with a lot of potential, but one that ultimately felt a little too young for this adult horror reader.
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC. This review reflects my honest opinion.
YA Horror | Supernatural Horror | Eleven-Year-Old Protagonist | Creepy Creature | Dark Atmosphere | Mystery Box | Eerie Setting | Emotional Themes
Dark, eerie and wonderfully atmospheric, ‘The Wednesday Box’ immediately creates an unsettling feeling. The gloomy city, creepy tunnels and mysterious figure following May give the story a haunting edge, while the illustrations add another layer to the overall experience.
May is an easy character to root for. Being the only one who can see the strange man following her makes her situation increasingly frightening, especially when keeping quiet is no longer enough to keep her safe. The mystery surrounding the Wednesday Box adds another intriguing element, and the story does a good job of creating that feeling that something much darker is hiding beneath the surface.
The writing is smooth and straightforward, which makes this an easy and quick read. There are some genuinely creepy moments, and the supernatural elements keep the story moving. The atmosphere is definitely one of its strongest points.
For this reader, the main reason for the three-star rating is that the book feels much more like YA horror than adult horror. The characters and writing style fit a younger audience well, but as an adult reader, both felt a little too simple at times. The premise has plenty of potential for something darker and more disturbing, but the story did not quite reach that level.
That said, readers who enjoy atmospheric YA horror will probably find plenty to appreciate here. The combination of a young protagonist, supernatural danger, a mysterious box and an eerie setting makes for an engaging and creepy story.
A haunting and atmospheric read with a lot of potential, but one that ultimately felt a little too young for this adult horror reader.
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC. This review reflects my honest opinion.
YA Horror | Supernatural Horror | Eleven-Year-Old Protagonist | Creepy Creature | Dark Atmosphere | Mystery Box | Eerie Setting | Emotional Themes
August 24, 2026
Reading a book where the Main Character is an 11-year old girl proved to be challenging at the beginning, as most books usually display more mature characters. But May was not lacking in maturity in many parts. The direct influence and haunting presence of poverty plus the devastating loss of a parent has May on a tightrope between typical preteen behaviour and strong moral values, leading to very logical conclusions and distinct observations. The influence of financial instability on personality and every-day-life was incredible portrayed and hit really close to home, which already gave the whole story a little bit of discomfort - perfect for this type of book.
Partially throughout the book I even thought that the things May sees are imagination and just a trauma response, but they are not. An eerie and intriguing truth lies beneath and May just happens to stumble right in.
If you have enjoyed the books of Aru Shah and following a brave young protagonist, but make it horror and thrilling, with a sidenote of beautiful but dark illustrations, the book is absolutely worth checking out!
________________________________________________
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Partially throughout the book I even thought that the things May sees are imagination and just a trauma response, but they are not. An eerie and intriguing truth lies beneath and May just happens to stumble right in.
If you have enjoyed the books of Aru Shah and following a brave young protagonist, but make it horror and thrilling, with a sidenote of beautiful but dark illustrations, the book is absolutely worth checking out!
________________________________________________
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 14, 2026
May has learned to survive in a world of shrieking subway rails, soot-stained skies, and apartment hallways where silence, caution, and never asking for too much are simply facts of life. But when a hulking stranger in a raincoat the colour of broken promises begins to haunt her steps—on the train, in the tunnels, and at her own door—May realises that keeping quiet will no longer keep her safe.
This wasn't quite what I expected. I went in expecting a horror novel with a strong supernatural element, and while those aspects were definitely there, it also felt very YA to me. I'm not sure if that was due to the writing style or the overall tone, but it wasn't quite the reading experience I was hoping for.
Although it wasn't for me, I still appreciated the story and can see it appealing to readers who enjoy YA-leaning supernatural horror.
Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my review.
This wasn't quite what I expected. I went in expecting a horror novel with a strong supernatural element, and while those aspects were definitely there, it also felt very YA to me. I'm not sure if that was due to the writing style or the overall tone, but it wasn't quite the reading experience I was hoping for.
Although it wasn't for me, I still appreciated the story and can see it appealing to readers who enjoy YA-leaning supernatural horror.
Thanks to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for my review.
August 19, 2026
This is my first Kieran book and I'm now a fan of this author. He writes beautiful crisp prose, even if it's a horror novel. I don't understand the low reviews. The Wednesday Box cannot be appreciated by a younger audience, even if it has a young protagonist. 16 and above maybe. It is tagged as adult horror, and that's what it is. It's not just about monsters stalking a child, it's also about the horrors of real-life --- such as being isolated, fearing things you can't control that might take away your loved ones, the fate of children the world has no time for. At the same time, lovers of dark fantasy will enjoy the creatures that are in the book.
I, for one, loved this book. I was with May all the way. Highly recommended if you want your horror with a lot of heart. It will make you feel and not just fear and dread.
I, for one, loved this book. I was with May all the way. Highly recommended if you want your horror with a lot of heart. It will make you feel and not just fear and dread.
August 6, 2026
This story made me think of a dark fairy tale. Kind of like Caroline or Tim Burton. It follows young May and the creepy man in the yellow raincoat who keeps appearing everywhere. The story is very good, especially towards the end. May is a fun character to follow. It was easy to emphasize with her and her overworked, single mom. The pictures really added to the fairy tale aspect. They are charming while still being a little creepy. My only real complaint was I did think the story was longer than it needed to be. The beginning especially really dragged. I received a free copy of this story and write this review voluntarily.
July 3, 2026
This was such a unique experience! The story felt very original and the illustrations made the visuals even better.
We follow a young girl who sees a being that ends up following her home so her single mother finds an overnight sitter for her while she's working. Needless to say, things are never as tame as they seem.
We embark on a fantastical story with loads of horror themes as May tries to escape The Wednesday Box.
Thank you Netgalley for my arc copy, this was a wicked story and I look forward to reading more from this author.
We follow a young girl who sees a being that ends up following her home so her single mother finds an overnight sitter for her while she's working. Needless to say, things are never as tame as they seem.
We embark on a fantastical story with loads of horror themes as May tries to escape The Wednesday Box.
Thank you Netgalley for my arc copy, this was a wicked story and I look forward to reading more from this author.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 22, 2026
I really wasn’t sure if this was supposed to be adult or JF. The pictures did not go with the story in my opinion. I just couldn’t get into it, it was not for me.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with this free arc in exchange for my honest review.
Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with this free arc in exchange for my honest review.
August 17, 2026
I honestly enjoyed this book quite a lot. It gave me Neil Gaiman horror vibes and a feeling of perpetual dread. Couldn’t stop caring about May everytime she was left alone to deal with things.
The only thing that kept me from giving five stars is the tendency to sometimes over-describe and over analyse things. The dialogue also felt a bit off at some places.
The only thing that kept me from giving five stars is the tendency to sometimes over-describe and over analyse things. The dialogue also felt a bit off at some places.
August 2, 2026
I can't read a book that used AI.
June 21, 2026
I was surprised at how much I enjoyed this Teen/YA horror story. I wish I had a hard copy to place into my Little Free Library.
The story follows an 11 year old girl living within a major city, whose mother is working around the clock to keep them afloat after her father has passed away. As she navigates the subway, city streets, and locking herself into their small apartment each day, she encounters a dangerous individual.
Not to give the story away - crazy things happen and she finds herself living in a nightmare otherworld.
The story starts slow, but becomes one you can't put down. The illustrations are excellent.
The story follows an 11 year old girl living within a major city, whose mother is working around the clock to keep them afloat after her father has passed away. As she navigates the subway, city streets, and locking herself into their small apartment each day, she encounters a dangerous individual.
Not to give the story away - crazy things happen and she finds herself living in a nightmare otherworld.
The story starts slow, but becomes one you can't put down. The illustrations are excellent.
June 18, 2026
Review of a Netgalley ARC.
1.5 rounded down because the illustrations were unexpected.
This promised a dark fable, and in some small way, delivered. We follow May as she is coming home from a subway, but instead of the poor towns in usual fairy tales, this is the dark and hopeless setting of a gray city.
Writing:
The tone is middle-grade and perhaps works for that base, but as an adult reading it, it felt somewhat oddly phrased - reminiscent of an attempt at magical realism territory before bringing me rushing back to whatever thoughts teenagers might end up having. Which is jarring and felt uneven. Also, this is compared to Coraline and Neverwhere which is unfair, because those stories have something for adults too, and that was my primary draw and I ended up disappointed.
The writing itself is convoluted and full of things like: "clad once again in the mottled raincoat the color of broken promises"
Setting:
The tale is set in a dreary cityscape with May and her mother as the primary family unit. Most of the story deals with difficult decisions while navigating youth, but failed to evoke feelings of nostalgia. Every description felt highly padded and rather bordering on repetitive. There is a wrongness that is pervading, and a sense of unease that grows - as we are aware of May's inner monologue as she navigates her world.
Plotting: Felt somewhat all over the place with too many back and forths and unnecessary expositions.
Ending:
The storyline becomes creepy and claustrophobic, but lacks in landing the punch. It went into some random surreal territory and took forever to resolve (if we can call it that). I was slightly interested just for May, to see how it all ends - which took forever to come, with some crazy deviations in between!
Overall verdict:
There are definitely some interesting parts - mainly rooting for May, but my interest kept waning, and I felt that the story would have done better with a stronger edits.
Dark fantasy for kids maybe, not for adults, and not that dark.
Note: The artwork seems AI generated, and not something I was expecting when it says "illustrated".
1.5 rounded down because the illustrations were unexpected.
This promised a dark fable, and in some small way, delivered. We follow May as she is coming home from a subway, but instead of the poor towns in usual fairy tales, this is the dark and hopeless setting of a gray city.
Writing:
The tone is middle-grade and perhaps works for that base, but as an adult reading it, it felt somewhat oddly phrased - reminiscent of an attempt at magical realism territory before bringing me rushing back to whatever thoughts teenagers might end up having. Which is jarring and felt uneven. Also, this is compared to Coraline and Neverwhere which is unfair, because those stories have something for adults too, and that was my primary draw and I ended up disappointed.
The writing itself is convoluted and full of things like: "clad once again in the mottled raincoat the color of broken promises"
Setting:
The tale is set in a dreary cityscape with May and her mother as the primary family unit. Most of the story deals with difficult decisions while navigating youth, but failed to evoke feelings of nostalgia. Every description felt highly padded and rather bordering on repetitive. There is a wrongness that is pervading, and a sense of unease that grows - as we are aware of May's inner monologue as she navigates her world.
Plotting: Felt somewhat all over the place with too many back and forths and unnecessary expositions.
Ending:
The storyline becomes creepy and claustrophobic, but lacks in landing the punch. It went into some random surreal territory and took forever to resolve (if we can call it that). I was slightly interested just for May, to see how it all ends - which took forever to come, with some crazy deviations in between!
Overall verdict:
There are definitely some interesting parts - mainly rooting for May, but my interest kept waning, and I felt that the story would have done better with a stronger edits.
Dark fantasy for kids maybe, not for adults, and not that dark.
Note: The artwork seems AI generated, and not something I was expecting when it says "illustrated".
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
Book Review: The Wednesday Box: A Dark Fable by Jonathan Kieran
Rating: 5 Stars
From the moment I picked up *The Wednesday Box*, I was captivated—not just by its hauntingly beautiful cover but by the world Jonathan Kieran so masterfully crafts within its pages. This isn’t your typical fairy tale beginning with “Once Upon a Time.” Instead, it starts with loneliness—a raw, aching kind that seeps into every corner of May’s life.
May’s world is grim: a city marked by shrieking subway rails, grimy skies, and apartment hallways where silence and caution are survival tools. Into this bleak landscape steps a mysterious stranger in a raincoat, a shadow of broken promises who begins to haunt her every move. But the true heart of the story lies deeper—beneath the supernatural suspense is a powerful coming-of-age narrative about a young girl burdened with adult-sized struggles: poverty, exhaustion, and impossible choices.
What really loved about this novel is how it weaves its dark fairy tale elements with real emotional weight. The story is part mystery, part nightmare, and part poignant exploration of survival and sacrifice. When May’s mother leaves her in the care of someone new, and an ancient box with tempting yet terrifying contents comes into play, the tension ratchets up in ways that kept me utterly hooked. The threat lurking beneath the city, hunting and knowing May by name, lingers in your mind long after the last page.
If you’re craving a story that’s as emotionally stirring as it is chilling, one that challenges you and stays with you like a shadow in the dark, *The Wednesday Box* is a must-read. Jonathan Kieran has delivered a stunning, unforgettable tale that I won’t soon forget.
⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️
Rating: 5 Stars
From the moment I picked up *The Wednesday Box*, I was captivated—not just by its hauntingly beautiful cover but by the world Jonathan Kieran so masterfully crafts within its pages. This isn’t your typical fairy tale beginning with “Once Upon a Time.” Instead, it starts with loneliness—a raw, aching kind that seeps into every corner of May’s life.
May’s world is grim: a city marked by shrieking subway rails, grimy skies, and apartment hallways where silence and caution are survival tools. Into this bleak landscape steps a mysterious stranger in a raincoat, a shadow of broken promises who begins to haunt her every move. But the true heart of the story lies deeper—beneath the supernatural suspense is a powerful coming-of-age narrative about a young girl burdened with adult-sized struggles: poverty, exhaustion, and impossible choices.
What really loved about this novel is how it weaves its dark fairy tale elements with real emotional weight. The story is part mystery, part nightmare, and part poignant exploration of survival and sacrifice. When May’s mother leaves her in the care of someone new, and an ancient box with tempting yet terrifying contents comes into play, the tension ratchets up in ways that kept me utterly hooked. The threat lurking beneath the city, hunting and knowing May by name, lingers in your mind long after the last page.
If you’re craving a story that’s as emotionally stirring as it is chilling, one that challenges you and stays with you like a shadow in the dark, *The Wednesday Box* is a must-read. Jonathan Kieran has delivered a stunning, unforgettable tale that I won’t soon forget.
⚠️This review was written based on personal opinions and experiences with the book. Individual preferences may vary⚠️
June 22, 2026
The Wednesday Box by Jonathan Kieran is an illustrated supernatural horror/dark fantasy novel from Brightbourne Media, released June 18, 2026.
The story follows May, an eleven-year-old girl struggling through a difficult home life when a mysterious box and an unsettling caretaker pull her toward a strange and dangerous world. What begins with loneliness gradually unfolds into something darker, dreamlike, and full of eerie wonder.
What stood out most to me was the atmosphere. Kieran creates a strong dark-fable feeling, with a mix of coming-of-age fantasy, emotional weight, and supernatural unease. The story has shades of Coraline, The Graveyard Book, and The Thief of Always, especially in the way it blends childhood fears with something bigger and more dangerous. The illustrations add another layer and help make the world feel more vivid.
This is more deliberate and atmospheric than fast-paced horror, but that works for the kind of story it is telling. Readers looking for a creepy, heartfelt dark fantasy with a young protagonist, strange magic, and fairy-tale darkness will probably connect with this one.
Overall, The Wednesday Box is imaginative, moody, and emotionally grounded, with a strong sense of wonder and dread. It’s a memorable dark fable for readers who like their fantasy eerie, strange, and a little haunted.
Rating: 4/5
Author Note: Thank you to Brightbourne Media for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
The story follows May, an eleven-year-old girl struggling through a difficult home life when a mysterious box and an unsettling caretaker pull her toward a strange and dangerous world. What begins with loneliness gradually unfolds into something darker, dreamlike, and full of eerie wonder.
What stood out most to me was the atmosphere. Kieran creates a strong dark-fable feeling, with a mix of coming-of-age fantasy, emotional weight, and supernatural unease. The story has shades of Coraline, The Graveyard Book, and The Thief of Always, especially in the way it blends childhood fears with something bigger and more dangerous. The illustrations add another layer and help make the world feel more vivid.
This is more deliberate and atmospheric than fast-paced horror, but that works for the kind of story it is telling. Readers looking for a creepy, heartfelt dark fantasy with a young protagonist, strange magic, and fairy-tale darkness will probably connect with this one.
Overall, The Wednesday Box is imaginative, moody, and emotionally grounded, with a strong sense of wonder and dread. It’s a memorable dark fable for readers who like their fantasy eerie, strange, and a little haunted.
Rating: 4/5
Author Note: Thank you to Brightbourne Media for providing this book for review consideration via NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
Review of advance copy received from Author
I received the ARC for this book and wow! The author can sure write. You know how some stories pull you in? The Wednesday Box completely grips you and refuses to let go.
From the opening pages, Jonathan Kieran builds an incredible sense of unease and momentum. What starts as May’s fearful encounter quickly spirals into something far stranger, darker, and more emotionally powerful. I was hooked immediately.
May is a phenomenal protagonist. Vivid, vulnerable, intelligent, and completely believable. She could have been me when I was younger, with all the same fears, troubles, and yearnings. Because we are so firmly anchored in her perspective, the danger never feels abstract... it feels personal and escalating. Kieran masterfully roots the suspense in character, ensuring the imaginative, unsettling fantasy elements always grow directly out of May’s emotional reality.
The pacing here is confident and deliberate. It builds layers of dread, making the major plot twists hit with real power, and the story never rushes past the emotional stakes just to get to the next dramatic moment. Beneath the dark-fable surface, this is a deeply moving story about fear, loneliness, endurance, and survival.
By the end, The Wednesday Box feels fully realized. It is gripping, eerie, and emotionally grounded. For readers who love dark fantasy with real storytelling muscle, this is a highly recommended read!
From the opening pages, Jonathan Kieran builds an incredible sense of unease and momentum. What starts as May’s fearful encounter quickly spirals into something far stranger, darker, and more emotionally powerful. I was hooked immediately.
May is a phenomenal protagonist. Vivid, vulnerable, intelligent, and completely believable. She could have been me when I was younger, with all the same fears, troubles, and yearnings. Because we are so firmly anchored in her perspective, the danger never feels abstract... it feels personal and escalating. Kieran masterfully roots the suspense in character, ensuring the imaginative, unsettling fantasy elements always grow directly out of May’s emotional reality.
The pacing here is confident and deliberate. It builds layers of dread, making the major plot twists hit with real power, and the story never rushes past the emotional stakes just to get to the next dramatic moment. Beneath the dark-fable surface, this is a deeply moving story about fear, loneliness, endurance, and survival.
By the end, The Wednesday Box feels fully realized. It is gripping, eerie, and emotionally grounded. For readers who love dark fantasy with real storytelling muscle, this is a highly recommended read!
July 16, 2026
What an interestingly haunting story. I have to give it a solid 4* for keeping my attention and highlighting the terror an 11 year old can go through when the world around them feels dangerous and uncertain. It's a YA story which I think is suitable since the main character is young and the story is about her experiences. Without this coming off as demeaning, children who are having a hard time at home often see the world in darker tones with deeper shadows and dangers lurking. I think it's an important perspective to talk about.
May is an eleven year old girl, trying to navigate her city while her mother works herself to the bone to keep them in an apartment. Her mom seems to work nearly 10-12+hours a day in a sweatshop. All the while, May is learning about disappearing children, seeing strange people in the subway and on the bus, and is missing her mom.
I like that this book also says it's a dark fable, as it does seem to point towards a moral lesson of speaking up even in the face of danger and of making sacrifices. At least, that's the moral I perceive from this story. It's written well and has a dark atmosphere looming over the story. It feels unsettling because we are encouraged to feel the same emotions as May. I read it pretty quickly and think this would be a good read on a rainy fall day when the weather is turning and clouds hang heavily in the sky.
May is an eleven year old girl, trying to navigate her city while her mother works herself to the bone to keep them in an apartment. Her mom seems to work nearly 10-12+hours a day in a sweatshop. All the while, May is learning about disappearing children, seeing strange people in the subway and on the bus, and is missing her mom.
I like that this book also says it's a dark fable, as it does seem to point towards a moral lesson of speaking up even in the face of danger and of making sacrifices. At least, that's the moral I perceive from this story. It's written well and has a dark atmosphere looming over the story. It feels unsettling because we are encouraged to feel the same emotions as May. I read it pretty quickly and think this would be a good read on a rainy fall day when the weather is turning and clouds hang heavily in the sky.
June 30, 2026
I was given an advance reader copy of this book.
I like modern fantasy with folklore qualities and this seemed a good fit for my tastes. I was mildly surprised to find it very much suited to me and then some. Spoilers I will not give away but the tale is a dark narrative of how easily people “disappear” from the world, especially neglected children. Sometimes the evil of the world is responsible but in this case a supernatural terror is at work. The main character, May, is a kid who thinks like an adult because life has made her think this way. The rest of the main characters are adult (even ancient) so this is a wonderfully illustrated fable for all ages, except maybe young kids. Reminds me of some Stephen King or John Connolly frightful stories with kids and monsters at odds. Gripping from start to finish and the writing style by Kieran is beautiful. It brings your senses into the eerie world where May and some unexpected friends are imprisoned. Evocative, atmospheric work. I also get the sense that it’s an allegory, but that’s up to the individual reader, I suppose. This haunts. Five stars. And the Grinder is the most grim villain I’ve encountered in awhile.
I like modern fantasy with folklore qualities and this seemed a good fit for my tastes. I was mildly surprised to find it very much suited to me and then some. Spoilers I will not give away but the tale is a dark narrative of how easily people “disappear” from the world, especially neglected children. Sometimes the evil of the world is responsible but in this case a supernatural terror is at work. The main character, May, is a kid who thinks like an adult because life has made her think this way. The rest of the main characters are adult (even ancient) so this is a wonderfully illustrated fable for all ages, except maybe young kids. Reminds me of some Stephen King or John Connolly frightful stories with kids and monsters at odds. Gripping from start to finish and the writing style by Kieran is beautiful. It brings your senses into the eerie world where May and some unexpected friends are imprisoned. Evocative, atmospheric work. I also get the sense that it’s an allegory, but that’s up to the individual reader, I suppose. This haunts. Five stars. And the Grinder is the most grim villain I’ve encountered in awhile.
July 23, 2026
The Wednesday Box was a disappointment from the start. It is sold as horror, but nothing in it feels like horror. Most of the book reads like a children’s fairy tale, simple and almost naïve, yet the writing often shifts into dense and tangled sentences that made me stop to figure out what the author was even trying to say. The mix does not work. It is too childish for adults and too heavy for kids.
The idea itself is not bad. A monster luring children and a hidden world behind the box is actually creative, and the world building has moments that could have been great. But the pacing destroys any potential. The chapters drag endlessly, scenes stretch far beyond their weight, and the whole book feels slowed down to the point of misery. It is not even a long novel, yet reading it felt like a chore. I kept rushing through pages just to reach the end of a chapter so I could put the book down for a while.
There is potential in the concept, but the execution is clumsy, inconsistent, and exhausting. I did not enjoy it at all.
ARC provided by Xpresso Book Tours.
The idea itself is not bad. A monster luring children and a hidden world behind the box is actually creative, and the world building has moments that could have been great. But the pacing destroys any potential. The chapters drag endlessly, scenes stretch far beyond their weight, and the whole book feels slowed down to the point of misery. It is not even a long novel, yet reading it felt like a chore. I kept rushing through pages just to reach the end of a chapter so I could put the book down for a while.
There is potential in the concept, but the execution is clumsy, inconsistent, and exhausting. I did not enjoy it at all.
ARC provided by Xpresso Book Tours.
May 31, 2026
I was absolutely gripped by how this story manages to be both terrifying and incredibly moving. At its heart, it’s a brilliant coming-of-age tale that isn't afraid to get dark, showing the world through the eyes of a young girl dealing with heavy, adult-sized burdens. It feels like a fever dream you don't want to wake up from—part mystery, part dark fairy tale—and the pacing is just perfect. It never rushes; instead, it lets the mystery coil around you until you’re completely pulled in. If you’re looking for a book that challenges you and lingers in your mind long after you finish reading, this is it.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
I received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This is written and reads as if for middle graders in some ways, and in other ways it’s flowery and verbose. I had difficulty getting through this, potentially because of this writing style. Conversations between characters are odd with the strange use of language. The overall story is creepy with descriptive writing that could bring you into the story if I did not find it to be overly done to the point I lost interest and grew bored. I do not think this is bad overall, but more so not my personal preference.
This is written and reads as if for middle graders in some ways, and in other ways it’s flowery and verbose. I had difficulty getting through this, potentially because of this writing style. Conversations between characters are odd with the strange use of language. The overall story is creepy with descriptive writing that could bring you into the story if I did not find it to be overly done to the point I lost interest and grew bored. I do not think this is bad overall, but more so not my personal preference.
Review of advance copy received from Indie Reviewers
Quietly Devastating! From the very first page, The Wednesday Box pulls you into a world of creeping dread and unsettling wonder, masterfully balancing psychological darkness with raw emotional stakes. Thoughtful, tense, and hauntingly beautiful, this is a story whose rich atmosphere and emotional intensity will linger with you long after the final page is turned. You'll feel for May, just as I did. It's quietly devastating in all the right ways.
June 28, 2026
What I enjoyed most about The Wednesday Box, Jonathan Kieran is how the anuthir weaves a sense of mystery without leaning on tired thrillers tropes. Instead, the tension is found in the emotional stakes. The prose is sophisticated and rhythmic, making the slower sections of the book a pleasure to read. At times, the melancholy is heavy, but it is balanced by moments of genuine insight into the protagonist's growth. great read for anyone who appreciates thoughtful, slow-burn literary drama
August 28, 2026
The Wednesday Box (whilst marketed as horror) read a lot more like a semi dark children's fairy tale which unfortunately lacked in both substance within the plot and a proper execution. It was quite obvious that this story was written by AI as opposed to a human author and it did affect the outcome of the story on the pages.
This was sadly a miss for me due to the above but it may appeal to readers who like lighter fiction.
Thankyou to Net galley and the publisher for an arc.
This was sadly a miss for me due to the above but it may appeal to readers who like lighter fiction.
Thankyou to Net galley and the publisher for an arc.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Review of advance copy
Well, as always Jonathan does not disappoint. I just love the way he can give the darkest fable a poetic touch. And the wonderful illustrations just add to the charm of this enchanting book.
Yes it is dark, yet there is always "the thing with feathers that perches the soul - hope"
I could easily see it turned into a film as well - it would be something right down the alley of Tim Burton.
Yes it is dark, yet there is always "the thing with feathers that perches the soul - hope"
I could easily see it turned into a film as well - it would be something right down the alley of Tim Burton.
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
The Wednesday Box: A Dark Fable by Jonathan Kieran
Date Read: 13 Jun 26 - 13 Jun 26
Source: ARC (NetGalley & Xpresso Book Tours)
Rating: ★★★★★
Song: Welcome to the Black Parade by My Chemical Romance ♫
Rating breakdown:-
Atmosphere & Dread: ● ● ● ● ○
Psychological Fear: ● ● ● ● ●
Suspense & Tension: ● ● ● ● ●
Horror Concepts: ● ● ● ● ●
Ending Impact: ● ● ● ● ○
To be honest, reading The Wednesday Box by Jonathan Kieran feels like being pulled into a subterranean nightmare that exists just beneath the surface of the ordinary world. It is a deeply disturbing and masterfully paced horror novel that succeeds in creating a sense of relentless dread, leaving you feeling as vulnerable and isolated as its young protagonist.
The horror concept here is truly genius. Kieran has managed to take the universal fear of being overlooked and transform it into something tangible, ancient, and terrifying. It is one of those rare stories that crawls under your skin and stays there, utilizing psychological fear to amplify the stakes until every shadow in your own life begins to feel like a threat. The tension is relentless, and the way the narrative builds that feeling of being hunted is nothing short of brilliant.
The characters are defined by their isolation. May is a heartrending protagonist who navigates a city that refuses to see her, making her struggle against the forces pursuing her feel incredibly poignant. Her determination to protect her mother while facing an impossible, supernatural threat gives the story a powerful emotional anchor. Seeing May use her own fragile, strange power to fight back against the darkness is what makes the relentless anxiety of the plot so gripping.
The plot is a masterclass in atmospheric horror. The narrative moves with a terrifying inevitability, as the entity that stalks May moves from the periphery of her life into the very walls of her home. The way the visions bleed into her reality creates a constant state of unease, ensuring that the reader is just as uncertain of what is safe as she is. The ending is haunting and leaves a strong, lingering emotional impact that forces you to think about the nature of the dark places we often choose to ignore.
The Wednesday Box is a haunting, top-tier work of horror that proves the most effective monsters are the ones that feed on our deepest insecurities. It is a brutal and imaginative reminder that sometimes, the things that go bump in the night are actually waiting to take us to a place we can never return from.
Thank you NetGalley & Xpresso Book Tours for this eARC
Date Read: 13 Jun 26 - 13 Jun 26
Source: ARC (NetGalley & Xpresso Book Tours)
Rating: ★★★★★
Song: Welcome to the Black Parade by My Chemical Romance ♫
Rating breakdown:-
Atmosphere & Dread: ● ● ● ● ○
Psychological Fear: ● ● ● ● ●
Suspense & Tension: ● ● ● ● ●
Horror Concepts: ● ● ● ● ●
Ending Impact: ● ● ● ● ○
To be honest, reading The Wednesday Box by Jonathan Kieran feels like being pulled into a subterranean nightmare that exists just beneath the surface of the ordinary world. It is a deeply disturbing and masterfully paced horror novel that succeeds in creating a sense of relentless dread, leaving you feeling as vulnerable and isolated as its young protagonist.
The horror concept here is truly genius. Kieran has managed to take the universal fear of being overlooked and transform it into something tangible, ancient, and terrifying. It is one of those rare stories that crawls under your skin and stays there, utilizing psychological fear to amplify the stakes until every shadow in your own life begins to feel like a threat. The tension is relentless, and the way the narrative builds that feeling of being hunted is nothing short of brilliant.
The characters are defined by their isolation. May is a heartrending protagonist who navigates a city that refuses to see her, making her struggle against the forces pursuing her feel incredibly poignant. Her determination to protect her mother while facing an impossible, supernatural threat gives the story a powerful emotional anchor. Seeing May use her own fragile, strange power to fight back against the darkness is what makes the relentless anxiety of the plot so gripping.
The plot is a masterclass in atmospheric horror. The narrative moves with a terrifying inevitability, as the entity that stalks May moves from the periphery of her life into the very walls of her home. The way the visions bleed into her reality creates a constant state of unease, ensuring that the reader is just as uncertain of what is safe as she is. The ending is haunting and leaves a strong, lingering emotional impact that forces you to think about the nature of the dark places we often choose to ignore.
The Wednesday Box is a haunting, top-tier work of horror that proves the most effective monsters are the ones that feed on our deepest insecurities. It is a brutal and imaginative reminder that sometimes, the things that go bump in the night are actually waiting to take us to a place we can never return from.
Thank you NetGalley & Xpresso Book Tours for this eARC
Displaying 1 - 28 of 28 reviews