Narrated in the first person by lawyer Alex, who is unhappily married to bartender Beth, this novel focuses not on Alex & Beth, but on Alex and Michelle, the attractive nurse whom Alex meets in a local coffee shop. Alex was quite a player before her marriage, and her former ways have made Beth incredibly insecure, leading her to overcompensate by being a nag and by trying to keep Alex from socializing with other people. When Alex meets Michelle, then, she is primed for falling for another, especially another with whom she has far more in common than she has with impulsive, working-class Beth.
Throughout most of the novel, Alex and Michelle remain just friends, not engaging in a physically romantic relationship. But it is clear to readers, and to themselves, that they are having an affair of the heart, even if neither will admit it to the other. Told entirely through the first person by Alex, the story features hardly any scenes with Alex and Beth, and thus gives us little of the bittersweetness of falling out of love, or even much of an understanding of how Alex and Beth even ended up married. Instead, we get primarily tortured friendship and unmet longing/desire between Alex and Beth. Though such is typically the grist for the romance mill, with the heavy weight of Alex's guilt and frustrating hanging over it all, it is difficult for the reader to feel much of the thrill of falling in love. The book comes across, thus, as more of a women's fiction than a romance.