Jump to ratings and reviews

Win a free print copy of this book!

12 days and 06:15:20

15 copies available
U.S. only
Rate this book

Peanut

Not yet published
Expected 20 Apr 27

Win a free print copy of this book!

12 days and 06:15:20

15 copies available
U.S. only
Rate this book
From the author of the instant cult classic Catherine House, a story of one woman’s search to find her place in a looming uncanny future.

Crystal Washington—awkward, underpaid, chronically ignored Crystal—has never fit in at Acme, the glossy tech startup where she works as an administrative assistant. Until the day she meets Juliet. Juliet, a magnetic scientist in Acme’s mysterious Social Machines department, is looking for a roommate. And she sees something in Crystal that no one else ever a friend.

As Crystal and Juliet develop a haunted, obsessive intimacy, Crystal realizes she would do anything for Juliet, anything to keep her close. Nothing could possibly get between the two of them—until Juliet is chosen to beta-test Acme’s newest top-secret project, a plush robot “companion toy.” Juliet is instantly enamored. But Crystal senses something sinister about the adorable creature. Is Crystal going crazy? Or is there a menacing gleam in those plastic eyes?

Grounded in a character determined to find some truth in an increasingly artificial world, Peanut is a reckoning with what it means to be human.

Kindle Edition

Expected publication April 20, 2027

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Elisabeth Thomas

2 books1,056 followers
Elisabeth Thomas grew up in Brooklyn, New York, where she still lives and now writes. She graduated from Yale University and currently works as an archivist for a modern art museum. CATHERINE HOUSE is her first novel.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
7 (18%)
4 stars
18 (47%)
3 stars
11 (28%)
2 stars
2 (5%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
Profile Image for Kirsten King.
Author 2 books787 followers
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
November 9, 2026
extremely My Shit.
Profile Image for meg.
24 reviews10 followers
October 30, 2026
Honest Review Provided in Exchange for ARC from NetGalley

I finished reading this book four days ago. In that time, I have started and stopped writing this review no fewer than six different times. So, instead of writing this like a traditional review, I’d instead like to begin by providing a detailed log of my activities upon finishing this book:

Thursday, October 29, 2026
9:52 pm: reads last page
9:52 pm: whispers “what the fuck” to no one
9:53-10:01 pm: sets down kindle, stares at ceiling
10:02 pm: goes to desk, opens laptop, opens microsoft word
10:03-10:10 pm: stares at blank page
10:12 pm: closes laptop
10:15 pm: reopens laptop
10:16 pm: googles “animism”
10:28 pm: googles “marie kondo animism”
10:32 pm: googles “east coast west coast oysters”
10:39 pm: googles “furbies uncanny valley”
10:40 pm-12:31 am: falls down internet rabbit hole
12:32 am: closes article on Guatemalan worry dolls
12:33 am: texts best friend

Me: I finished Peanut
Her: how was it???
Me: I don’t know
Her: what

Ultimately I did manage to finish writing the review, even though, four days later, I’m still not sure what the hell I read. I am, however, sure that I loved whatever the hell I read, and that you should read it too.

Without further ado, I present to you

Meg’s Review:
Peanut, By Elisabeth Thomas


The technofuture is here, and it’s fluffy

Peanut is a deeply weird novel about loneliness, companionship, and the nature of reality - specifically, which experiences are socially sanctioned as real and valid and which are not.

Crystal Washington is awkward to the extreme, socially isolated, and lonely, but hoping for better things ahead. When Peanut opens, we find Crystal, an office assistant at techbro firm Acme Corp., looking at apartment listings, excitedly envisioning a future in which she gets to move out of her uncle Virgil’s dingy apartment and into a gleaming new place of her own. All of that comes crashing down when Crystal is hauled into the conference room by her superiors and placed on a PEP, throwing her plans for the future into disarray.

Following a neat little pivot and a bit of reverse-Uno blackmail, Crystal finds herself the new lead assistant on the Bonkos project, a highly secretive Acme Corp. initiative to develop a companion robot (a “teddy”) that, for all intents and purposes, is basically a machine learning-equipped Furby.

Neat, right? Crystal doesn’t think so!

Especially because in the meantime Crystal has met and befriended co-worker Juliet, a rich kid from Montclair who went to MIT and knows the difference between east coast oysters and west coast oysters. Crystal is enamored with Juliet; they move in together, and Crystal has for the very first time a friend who seems genuinely unbothered by Crystal’s strangeness. But when Juliet is selected to beta-test one of the teddies and bring it home with her, Crystal must grapple not only with her innate distaste for the teddy, but also with her own jealousy over the strong affection that Juliet develops for it, seeming to displace Crystal almost entirely.

Crystal, meanwhile, has a secret: she spends her free time assembling her own little creatures out of discarded wire, buttons, and fabric, all of which, like many of the inanimate objects around her, Crystal experiences as beings with personalities, desires, agency, and the ability to communicate. Crystal struggles to connect with other people, but she inhabits an elaborate object-based social universe that nobody else can access. Ultimately, this leads to Crystal’s greatest creation – Peanut, the foil to Juliet’s teddy.

There’s a fascinating undercurrent of animism at work here, recalling religious traditions (e.g., Shintoism, KonMari, I am kidding that second one was a joke please do not come for me) in which inanimate objects possess spiritual essences or souls. As to how to interpret all of this - is Crystal perceiving consciousness that is already present in the materials, are her acts of creation itself somehow giving them life, or is she projecting personalities and intentions onto inanimate objects as a means of navigating a world she otherwise struggles to understand? - Thomas is deliberately opaque.

Crystal's narration is wry, minimalist, and observational. She reports her experiences with apparent sincerity, leaving the reader to determine whether she's describing a perceivable external reality or a private psychological one. There is certainly enough here to invoke Occam’s razor and conclude that Crystal is simply detached from reality and possibly suffering from some form of psychological disturbance, but every once in a while, Thomas slips a piece of contradictory evidence under the door, so that just about every time you feel poised to embrace the hypothesis that Crystal is simply unwell, you find yourself thinking, “…or?”

Peanut is an utterly mindbending story, presenting not one but two models of artificial companionship, one of which (Acme Corp’s) is socially sanctioned and validated, and the other of which (Crystal’s) is… very much not. And yet Crystal and Acme Corp. are, for all intents and purposes, engaged in the very same exercise: the creation of artificial companionship. In fact, in one of Juliet’s most impassioned speeches in favor of the teddies, she asserts that it doesn’t matter if they’re real or if the relationship is in her head, because her head is all that she has. In doing so, she unwittingly also makes the case for Crystal’s creations, and for Peanut.

I don't think Thomas intended to answer the myriad questions she poses, or even necessarily to ask answerable questions in the first place. She has, however, constructed a wonderfully peculiar, but naggingly familiar, world in which the distinctions between delusion, magic, and innovation ultimately come down to the question of who is given the authority to define them.

4.5/5. I don’t know what the fuck I just read and you should read it too.

Edited to add: whenever a book really fucks me up, I make a playlist to listen to while writing the review/recovering from the book hangover. I’m pleased to report that Peanut easily cleared this bar. HYG: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/1k6...
Profile Image for Mag Piper.
38 reviews16 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 30, 2026
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the advance copy!

What a strange, immersive book this was. I was hooked from the beginning by Crystal's strongly neurodivergent POV and I absolutely love the way she narrated this. I was particularly tickled by her commentary on other people's small talk. Genuinely very relatable and funny and sad all at the same time. Crystal struggles to fit in at her job, and in society in general, and latches onto the dynamic and personable Juliet to the point of unhealthy obsession, but even as Crystal is maddeningly detached from the nonsense of everyday life in the 21st century, there's something so very human about her. There's also a strong backdrop of the ways tech and capitalism influence, exploit, and alter our lives as well, and overall I found it thoughtfully and excellently done with none of the heavy-handedness that's been prevalent in some of my other recent reads (/DNFs).

The pacing did lag a bit in the first half and I wish some of the intensity that comes in later had more grounding earlier on so the ending could have a little more space to resolve, but this was definitely worth the read!
Profile Image for Shefali.
61 reviews
September 1, 2026
3.5 ⭐️

This was a weird little book! I thought it would be more of a science fiction story, but it definitely leans more towards lit fic. Crystal works in admin for a tech company. She’s socially awkward (it read like autism to me, but that’s just my opinion!) and becomes infatuated with Juliet, a scientist at the company. Juliet takes an interest in Crystal as well and they become friends, then roommates. Juliet begins beta testing a pet robot companion, and Crystal is convinced the company is planning something sinister. Crystal’s relationships with other characters and her unique view of the world are the focus of the book. I found myself confused at times but the story was compelling enough to keep going. Thank you to NetGalley and Knopf, Pantheon, and Vintage for allowing me to read this ARC!
Profile Image for gwen.
181 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 24, 2026
thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy in exchange for a review!!

This was so unique and I really loved it. Peanut follows Crystal, a very socially awkward woman, who develops a close friendship with a coworker named Juliet. In the midst of this, the company they both work for is developing some technology that starts to deeply impact the lives of both women.

In a lot of ways this book does not really have a forward moving plot. It’s slow in that way, and much more a character study. I love that and am always into it, but if you’re more into plot-driven books this probably would not be up your alley. That being said, I FLEW through this. I could not put it down. Thomas has a very engaging writing style that sucked me right in and did not let me out until I had finished this story.

I would say this book very much falls into the “weird girl fiction” category. Think authors like Otessa Moshfegh, Eliza Clark, Melissa Broder, etc. Crystal is a weird and often hard character to read about. She is abrasive, awkward, a little delulu. She is smart and talented in her own ways, but those ways don’t really translate to the outside world well. I loved being in her head, truly. She was always a sympathetic character to me and I really wanted her to come out on top.

This book has a fascinating mix of literary fiction and magical realism/paranormal aspects. It never fully decides which one it wants to be. Events occur and you aren’t sure if it’s Crystal going insane or some actual lowkey magic happening. I think this is to the benefit of the story- it’s up to the reader to decide how they want to interpret a lot of things.

I finished this book unsure of how to feel about the technology aspect. As I mentioned, both Crystal and her new friend Juliet work at a technology company called Acme (LOL). Acme develops a kind of… sentient teddy bear companion situation (hard to describe). I feel as if there are some themes here about Generative AI and what it is going to ultimately do to people/the world, and it was interesting, but I was far more interested in the characters and their relationships throughout than the technology.

It’s hard to say much about this aspect without spoiling, but I LOVE PEANUT!!!! Peanut stan #1 here.

I will definitely be going back to read Thomas’ first book and look forward to seeing what else she puts out. Weird girl fiction 4 lyfe 🫶
Profile Image for Carolina.
241 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 29, 2026
so here's the thing. i had a great time reading this but i have no idea what this was about. i think maybe AI but idk what it was saying. i presume AI bad?? i hope.
also i keep having the thought that if this main character were a man, this would be a story about inceldom. the main character is standoffish and does not comprehend social norms, she is stunted, she stalks and coerces her ex, she's friendless, she becomes obsessed with the only person who shows interest in her, she has a warped worldview and constantly comes up with conspiracy theories that consume her life. so maybe it was about that? idk
but again, the story was very entertaining and propulsive, albeit vague and weird, the main character's voice was very well developed and i had a great time being in her head. i'm just waiting for this book to come out so someone smarter can tell me what the central point was.
Profile Image for Micah Riot.
49 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 15, 2026
Thanks Netgalley for the advanced copy.

Review: I’m so very attracted to the way Elisabeth Thomas writes and at once so very unsettled by her characters. And that is her point I believe. She writes tension excellently. I squirm almost the entire time as I read. Yet I cannot stop thinking about her writing during my non reading hours.

I love many of these characters. Peanut. Uncle Virgil. I cringe hard at the thought of Juliet and Crystal. Toby. Everyone at Acme. Acme, the tech company, is at once a very familiar (I live in the Bay Area) and incredibly unpleasant “character” in this book.

This book is weird. It’s deep. It’s casually queer. It’s creepy. It’s raw. Its Black. It’s beautiful. It’s kind of slow. But also so very full. It's almost perfect.

I loved it.
Profile Image for Sam Hughes.
976 reviews116 followers
August 30, 2026
ok, the madness.

I am so thankful to Pantheon Books, Elisabeth Thomas, and NetGalley for advanced access before this speculative nightmare hits shelves on April 20, 2027.

Peanut is a tale of blackmail and obsession like no other, as our MC, Crystal, is literally lacking in lots, but mostly in the fact that she's living in a lala land, and backburnering her job position, putting lots of people in a tizzy and becoming quite the liability as she works at a tech startup that focuses on robotics and AI engines for the future.

After blackmailing her boss to transfer her to a new department, she catfishes her way through meetings, phone calls, and new product drops - growing wearier of the said products and how they're impacting the human workers of Acme.

I giggled. I gaped. I hesitated. I felt a lot of feelings reading this one, but it def felt reminiscent of the tech days we're seeing in this age, irl. so that was a bit scary for me, so that's the reasoning behind the 3.5 rating. Sci-Fi is getting TOO REAL
Profile Image for Anne.
181 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 9, 2026
Despite the title, this book is ok to read if you are allergic! It's a bit like the Greenland/Iceland naming thing because there's only one peanut product in the whole book. Hope this helps :)

The book follows Crystal, a woman in her late twenties who feels like she's fallen behind in life. She's still living with her uncle, her ex-boyfriend wants nothing to do with her, and even at work, her best effort isn't considered good enough. Everything changes though when she happens to meet Juliet, who seems to see Crystal in a way she's never seen herself. Crystal finds herself growing obsessed with Juliet, and, later, the company they are both working for.

This book is intriguing right from the start, and there are distinct shifts that follow the changes in Crystal's life. The author has a very strong voice, and I thought the pacing was well done. The scenes were reminiscent of vignettes, with a lot of external description to display Crystal's thoughts and actions. What I mean by this is that every detail feels incredibly intentional to the overall story. Crystal is constantly pushing people away, but we never explicitly see her reasoning and or justification why. Her goals and motivations are told through her dreamlike repetition of a possible future that we quickly realize will never turn into reality. Crystal is a flawed character, but the author makes her someone you want to root for anyway.

We also quickly learn that Crystal is an unreliable narrator. As the story goes on, the author creates an unsettling tone as the reader can't be sure whether Crystal's perception is clouded by jealousy or if something is actually disturbing. At many points, I picked up on details in other characters' dialogue or behavior that hinted at a perspective confirming or rejecting Crystal's. The thing that makes this book so hard to put down is that you want to find out what Crystal will do: will she act on these outside comments, or will she continue to push people away?

I interpreted the theme to be touching on GenAI: how do you define what is real, and how do you recognize what isn't? What are you willing to risk your own beliefs for in a world so blinded by innovation?

The only reason this book is 4.5 instead of 5 stars for me is because I would have liked a little more explanation for the halfway point of the book. The exposition was only sufficient for a little while, and I still don't entirely get what the roblox-looking thing on the cover was meant to signify.

I requested to read this book early through NetGalley! Thanks!
9 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 31, 2026
Reading Peanut, I spent a lot of time wondering whether something really strange and fantastic was happening, or whether I was seeing the world through Crystal's unreliable perspective as she desperately searched for something more.

I didn't even really like or connect with Crystal, but that worked for me. She is messy, self-conscious, obsessive, full of unhealthy habits, and sometimes frustrating to watch. But I was fascinated by her. Even when I couldn't understand her choices, I wanted to know what she would do next. Going through life from Crystal's perspective felt like I was slowly peering around a door, like in a horror movie, trying to see what was on the other side but also not completely sure I wanted to know what I would find.

Her relationship with her coworker Juliet only adds to that sense of uncertainty. Crystal becomes intensely focused on the people and connections around her, and the book leaves you questioning how much of what she believes is shared by the people on the other side of those relationships. If you've ever wondered how people really feel about you, and whether they reciprocate how you feel about them, this book will provoke some of those awful, sticky, feelings that you want to bury and pretend you cannot feel.

The entire cast is flawed, and the story never seems that interested in giving you an "easy" character to root for. Instead, it lets everyone be complicated, lonely, selfish, hopeful, and occasionally delusional about what they want from other people.

I also loved how contemporary the story feels. AI, social media, cell phones, and the increasingly strange ways technology is becoming intertwined with companionship and intimacy are incorporated naturally rather than feeling like obligatory references to modern life.

It's a strange, gripping, psychologically ambiguous book, maybe veering into weird fiction territory, and I've never read anything quite like it. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Katharine.
638 reviews12 followers
October 1, 2026
3.5
I am so mixed on this novel. I enjoyed the prose quite a bit, and I enjoyed the mystery of it. But so many things left me confused, and the ending left me dissatisfied. It feels like a couple plot threads were started in the beginning of the story, but never got woven into the ending. Crystal is a character you can emphasize with. She's an "awkward" person, and doesn't easily fit into her work place with everyone else. You are told multiple times that she just doesn't think like other people do, which made me really feel like Crystal is meant to be read as a type of neurodivergent. There is a underlying tone that everyone working in the corporate tech world are just fake and vapid. Which, yeah okay I get that. Almost every character from the company Crystal works at is shown to be pretty vapid. There was a few classic tech bro spiels of "We're not just creating [x], we're creating something more." and "This [product] will redefine humanity!", which made me think of every company who makes grand promises but then shill sub-par products. But Crystal herself as a person is so hard to pin down. So many times I couldn't tell if she was actually experiencing something or was suffering from a type of delusion. It also takes so long for the plot to get anywhere it feels like. Also, I never understood why exactly Crystal becomes obsessed with Juliet. They remain strictly friends for the entire novel, and never really hint anything more. I'm confused why this book has the LGBT tag; the only thing queer that happens is a brief mention of Crystal having male and female partners for one night stands. I really did love the style of the prose, it was honestly a huge reason why I kept reading. But the plot left me bewildered, and it feels like it just stopped out of no where.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review!
Profile Image for Brandy Dougan.
65 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 2, 2026
I am a big fan of all weird girl lit and this was definitely weird girl lit at its finest! Truly, I don’t know how else to categorize Peanut by Elizabeth Thomas, because it kind of hit on soo many.

Crystal is a very eccentric, neurodivergent young woman just trying to find her place in life. She sees life in ordinary everyday things, that only no one else can see or understand. I do wish we could’ve gotten more clarification on exactly what or why she has this gift that her, her uncle and family seem to share. That was my biggest draw back of this book, we don’t really get many answers to many of the questions I think we all have. (The whole Toby thing is still bothering me!)

I did truly feel for Crystal and the way she so desperately tries to build connections and fit in. She is one of those ride or die friends, until you give her a reason to step away. The way she fought for Juliet’s friendship, sometimes in an obsessive way, showed just how she truly feels things with her whole heart. On the other end Crystal has a hard time connecting with most people but that doesn’t mean she doesn’t try.

I was very intrigued with the whole evolved Furby toys storyline and wish we got more of the dark side of that. I really wanted Crystal to keep her detective hat on and keep digging for the truth, but we never really get a ton of closure on it.

All in all I highly recommend Peanut to anyone that has felt like an outsider or who is always trying to find the whimsy in life!

Thank you to Elizabeth Thomas, Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor | Pantheon, and NetGalley for the advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for Red Newsom.
29 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
September 17, 2026
What a strange little book. The premise was so appealing that I put my deadline reading aside for a book that isn't published for over six months. Everything about Peanut appealed.


Crystal is on her last warning at work when she moves departments to Social Machines, who are testing prototypes of a plush robot companion. A lifelong outsider, she hovers on the outskirts of the team until the bubbly Juliet brings her into the circle. Soon they are doing everything together.. until Juliet starts testing one of the robots and bonds with it.


I loved Thomas' character work and it felt like I was there in the canteen at times with Crystal and her colleagues. Crystal is an unreliable narrator and you can never quite trust in her interpretation of a moment. She's jarringly weird. I loved the juxtaposition between the sensory, spiritual, personal approach to crafting that Crystal has and the capitalist creation at Acme.


Peanut never quite becomes the book you think it will be. In our current climate, you're expecting an evil corporation and an AI villain. I found myself searching for a mystery and reading into the tone of interactions too much. Whilst there are weird, witchy elements to the plot, the story didn't really come together in the way I expected it to. I don't think that's a bad thing, but I hope the marketing doesn't lean too much on the paranormal elements, it's definitely more of a character-lead lit fic story about obsessive friendship. A big thumbs up from me!
Profile Image for Jamie.
81 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 23, 2026
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for my review. Crystal is struggling with her job at the ACME company when she meets a new co-worker, Juliet, with whom she quickly bonds and soon invites to move in with her. Crystal is socially awkward, introverted, and spends most of her free time making "creatures" out of whatever bits of material she finds. Juliet, on the other hand, is fiercely ambitious and very dedicated to her job - even volunteering to be a tester of a new product the ACME company is developing - a plush, animatronic "teddy" that learns about and bonds to its owner. Crystal quickly notices that Juliet's teddy doesn't like her, and pushes back against Juliet's devotion to it. This begins to drive a wedge into their relationship, and subsequently Juliet becomes closer to a new co-worker, Toby.

This book is told mainly from Crystal's POV and while she's not necessarily always "likeable" it is not hard to sympathize with her as she struggles with fitting in and trying to hold on to a friend who is obsessed with her (very strange) work. The characters were interesting and I enjoyed reading about their relationships. This book would be great for anyone who likes a nuanced character study with some intriguing weirdness thrown in!
Profile Image for Natalie Couture.
39 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 16, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC!
At first glance, I thought this book was going to lean into a sci-fi meets AI-toy-takeover situation. Instead, we got a craft project gone wrong? Or I guess a craft project gone right? Honestly, I am not sure. That is up for you to decide.

The entire book had me questioning if our main character was mentally ill, experiencing the supernatural, or was literally God. The beginning had so much tension and build-up that I was constantly coming up with new theories. Is Teddy malicious? Who - or what - is peanut? Why bring up Crystal's mom? Every time I thought I knew where the book was going, a twist quietly pivoted the entire store line and made me go, wait what? But not in a good way. Without spoiling anything, I just wish we got to know more about Peanut and spend more time with them.

It's a weird read that made it impossible for me to stop trying to figure out what was actually happening. I came for the potential evil AI toy and somehow was made to contemplate creation, reality, and whether arts and craft have gone too far.
Profile Image for Rudi McKay.
203 reviews5 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 28, 2026
This book is WEIRD—and I mean that as the highest compliment. 😂 I went into it expecting something strange, but I wasn’t prepared for just how unsettling and quietly disturbing it would become.

Crystal is such a fascinating character. Her loneliness, her obsession with Juliet, and her desperate need to finally feel seen made her easy to get invested in, even as things around her became increasingly bizarre. And then there’s Peanut…the cute little companion robot that I absolutely did NOT trust. 😳

I loved the creeping sense that something was wrong, even when I couldn’t quite put my finger on what it was. The story plays with friendship, obsession, technology, identity, and what it actually means to be human, but it never feels like it’s simply trying to give you answers.

This was strange, unsettling, smart, and wonderfully uncomfortable. Definitely the kind of book that makes you look at an innocent little robot toy and think, “Yeah…nope.” 😂

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advanced copy!
Profile Image for Sam Beggins.
146 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 30, 2026
I enjoyed this strange little book, but I couldn’t tell you what it was about. I could tell you the plot, but I couldn’t tell you what it was about, really. I was waiting for a payoff that never came. I was taking things at face value, waiting for the “aha” moment to tie everything together and clue the reader into the reality we were stepping into.

There was a line that led me to believe it was a loose criticism on Gen AI/AI chatbots and companions: “The teddy will never be angry, it’ll never be sad… or I mean, even if it seems sad, that’s just because that’s the reaction you want.” But even if that feeling is correct, this being a vague critique on the future of AI companions, the rest of the plot lines and the strange struggles and work Crystal experiences and goes through all lead nowhere.

About 80% in, I thought it was all coming together, Crystal believed something was happening, she honed in on something and realized a “secret” of the Acme labs program, and honestly that (Toby) storyline probably would have made this a 5 star read for me if it had panned out.
Profile Image for Carrot.
204 reviews1 follower
October 31, 2026
I was part of the group of the people who really enjoyed CATHERINE HOUSE when it came out back in 2020, so I was quite excited when I saw this title pop up on Netgalley (and even more excited that it was categorized as LGBTQ+ fiction). The synopsis reads as your typical "weird girl" literary fiction with a speculative bent: a woman becomes obsessed with her coworker (and roommate), but an animatronic companion toy under beta testing threatens to tear their relationship apart.

The story has a solid beginning: we see Crystal, the protagonist, struggle to fit in with her coworkers and learn about her not-so-orthodox approach to landing her job at this mysterious toy company, or at least that's what Acme seems to be on paper. Tension builds as Crystal develops an obsession with Juliet, a scientist on the team testing a new "companion robot," while Juliet grows closer to one of the toy test subjects, which seems to loathe Crystal.

However, the story starts to lose its forward momentum, and Crystal's obsession with Juliet feels like it plateaus, so I quickly disengaged from the narrative. Crystal also seems to have these inexplicable magical abilities which are not really developed, and I felt distant from her for much of the story. I wanted the story to lean even more into weirdness and have more strange behaviors from the robot to ratchet up the tension further. This is most likely a case of this book just not being for me, as it leans a lot of "vibes" to drive the story forward. For any fans of CATHERINE HOUSE, give this one a try, but don't expect a plot-driven narrative.

Thank you to Netgalley and Knopf for the ARC!
Profile Image for Cece.
338 reviews6 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 7, 2026
oooof that was alot of different things in one story. I love WOC-centered weird girl lit, and I love the premise of weird scifi happenings and robot machines and corporate tech environments. I didn't love love the execution here unfortunately, I felt there were too many different directions with the plot and some pacing issues. I liked being inside Crystal's strange mind, her observational obsessions and classic unreliable narrator goodness. I wanted somehow more and less from this delivery though - either a little more weird or a little less detail/plot. Big points for ambiguity and unanswered questions. I wasn't sure how we got some character developments but I was happy to be along for the ride.

Thank you to NetGalley and Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and Anchor for my arc!
Profile Image for Cheyenne.
32 reviews
August 26, 2026
This was a wild, wacky, weird story! Crystal is our main character and while I wanted to root for her, there were just some things that held me back from entirely being on her side! I did feel bad that she had such a hard time making and keeping friends! Her meeting and being roommates with Juliet seemed like fate though cause not matter what Juliet still stayed her friend! She was a real one! It felt like kind of an abrupt ending but with the way the book went it honestly fit! Definitely a fun little read

Thankful to have received an eARC from Knopf, Pantheon, Vintage, and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own
Profile Image for Kit Frey.
28 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 20, 2026
Peanut is an immersive and delightfully strange reading experience that took me a few days to digest after finishing. There's an underlying tension throughout the whole read that had me gripped. Intentional or not, Crystal is a great representation of the neurodivergent experience of navigating socialization. I think that is one of the greatest driving forces that keeps momentum in this story. You're constantly aware of the fact that people are using her, and waiting for a break that just keeps getting further and further away. If you're in the mood for something that will leave you contemplating details and meaning for days, Peanut is the read for you!
Profile Image for ct lydon.
66 reviews3 followers
October 29, 2026
Thank you to Knopf, Pantheon, and Vintage for this eARC! 4.75 stars.

Peanut was a clever novel about neurodivergence, friendships, fall outs and complete chaos.

Crystal is an awkward mid-twenties woman who is working at a corporation that she cannot stand, that is essentially building Furbies on crack. They talk, they follow you, and people eat it up. Crystal is able to see through this facade and truly have a deeper understanding of the deep need humans want for connection. It was a quick paced novel that made me cringe, laugh and really think about how technology has advanced so rapidly in the twenty first century.

If you like weird girl literature, this is right up your alley.
Profile Image for charlie.
70 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 12, 2026
Well written and paced. Crystal is an oddball, but it’s hard not to feel for her, despite her unreliable narration. I enjoyed her character so much.
I thought the author did an incredible job building tension throughout the book, however it fizzled out majorly by the end. The climax didn’t really feel like much.
Overall- this was a quick & entertaining read!

Thank you Netgally and Knopf, Pantheon, and Vintage for the ARC.
Profile Image for briar.
119 reviews1 follower
October 6, 2026
thank you to netgalley & publishers for the e-arc
this was such a fun yet weird book but i really enjoyed it! i honestly had no idea where the story was going to go besides thinking it would have more sci fi, but it ended up being much more of a lit fic than i thought! i love Crystal as a character and being in her head was just so different but fun and i just really enjoyed her thought processes and how she spoke to people and how she is as a person, it was really interesting
Profile Image for Buck.
52 reviews4 followers
September 30, 2026
Thank you NetGalley for an e-ARC!
This book was fun! Everytime I put it down, I wanted to pick it right back up and keep going. I wanted to know more about Crystal. Crystal was such a fun character to me, she read as autistic and I really related to her "outsider"-ness and how strange she seemed to others. It was a weird little book and I really enjoyed it. 3.5 stars rounded up to 4.
Profile Image for Michelle.
19 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 7, 2026
I adored this book! It’s fun, weird, emotional, has sci-fi elements, family dynamics and mystery. And it’s all done so well. I appreciated the prose/writing style. Will definitely be reading Elisabeth Thomas’ other work! Thank you to her for this absolute gift of a book and to NetGalley + the publisher for the advanced copy.
Profile Image for Michelle.
434 reviews13 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 27, 2026
Oh, this was weird and interesting! And even though I didn't find the main character Crystal that likable, the story kept me involved and engaged. Thank you so much to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC!
Profile Image for TheThirdLie.
584 reviews52 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 22, 2026
Crystal is a wonderfully weird character, but she is lost to a divided plot and a weird magical realism beat.i would have preferred this constant grounded and focused on her relationship with Julia and the company they worked for.
Profile Image for Anne H.
56 reviews4 followers
October 4, 2026
Huge thanks to Pantheon & NetGalley for the arc of Peanut, my new favorite AI anxiety read.

Crystal works at a tech company and has a new BFF, Juliet, someone who seems willing to overlook all of Crystal’s flaws & foibles. Only problem is that Juliet also has a new BFF, a stuffed AI companion, who Crystal doesn’t fully trust.

Highly recommended for anyone who feels a constant disquiet about the invasive weed that is AI and how personal tech has ruined everything from interpersonal relationships, to free time, to work.

I feel like this book may not be for readers who want a lot to happen in a book—I was happy to go along for the ride on vibes only, but the main disquiet and sense of unease comes from incremental conversations and slow shifts, not major plot movements. That being said, this book was 100% for me—I love a vibes-only read. I was completely captivated by Peanut and a really excited to see what else Elisabeth Thomas comes up with, as this book has cemented her as an immediate read author for me.
Profile Image for Anna.
2 reviews
September 17, 2026
When I stepped away from reading Peanut, I was hit with the observation that it is such a timely book. Artificial intelligence is ramping up all around us with people using it to create art (writing, music, visual arts, etc.) and for companionship. Peanut deals with both of these uses of machines and makes us reflect on what exactly is "real" in our world.

I found the characters to be wonderfully flawed. Sure, they had some awkward or unlikeable characteristics, but overall Thomas has created realistic people we can root for despite being frustrated with them from time to time.

There was also something about the writing style that made it so easy to get lost in the story. I felt fully immersed from the first page onward, and even though I was swept away by the language, the content provided plenty of opportunities to pause and reflect on the larger message of the book.

Ultimately, this book was *very* weird; there was obsession, jealousy, social awkwardness, and even magical realism. It was a wild ride that I'm still unpacking, and I recommend this to anyone who wants to really chew on a book.

A big thanks to Pantheon and NetGalley for providing this advanced copy for review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews