Thank you to NetGalley and A. S. Keeper for the e- and physical ARCs. This was a VERY easy 5 stars for me. I annotated the heck out of my copy—A Devil So Wicked stole my heart right out of my chest and I'm still in a book hangover weeks later! “What did Wyll do in the carriage?” is officially my new “What did Lorcan do??” ... I can't stop wondering!!!
I went in expecting demons, dragons, and a forbidden romance, and I got all of that. What I didn’t expect was a story about grief that would make me feel this seen. At its core, this is a book about two people doing the heavy work of healing and finding the will to survive when surviving feels like the harder choice.
Emeline is stuck in the fog of depression after an early pregnancy loss (off-page), surviving day-to-day, when she crosses paths with Arsen Seaspire, the Second Prince of Haven. Arsen takes one look at Em, basically says "that one", and proceeds to make it his personal mission to uncover this numb woman's very worst fear. Humans aren’t welcome in Haven, and Arsen should kill her and be done with it... but the tension between them keeps pulling them together, drawing them dangerously close as political upheaval builds (DELICIOUS).
The grief in this book was so well done. As someone who's mom passed when she was little and has carried that loss for almost my whole life, when I say Em and Arsen’s respective grief hit me somewhere deep, I don’t say that lightly. The fog Em experiences, the emotional hollowness and bitterness Arsen feels, all of it was written so honestly. I so appreciate the author for making sure that none of the grief either of them feel is glamorized. It made it wholly relatable and painful. “Her grief wasn’t ugly. It was tragic.” (How dare you read me for filth, A!!!)
Arsen, our sweet bby boy (hardass) demon, is Em’s mirror and her foil. His pain comes from neglect and childhood abuse (all off-page), so it isn’t the same as hers, but the way he guards himself and steels against vulnerability echoes her wounds. “Lucifer was God’s favorite. Arsen had never been anyone’s favorite.” Two incredibly hurt people circling each other is the heart of this book, and it’s why the romance and healing between them is so gut wrenching.
Somehow, a book this heavy is also hilarious. Samael, a sassy, sarcastic, morally grey dragon, bonds with Em immediately and is fiercely protective of her and Arsen. I barked out laughing at him more than once, and Em’s dark humor had me in stitches. There's a certain chapter that opens with one of my favorite Em lines after an incredibly tense cliffhanger... I don't want to spoil it, but it truly sent me into orbit. I couldn't stop laughing at the ridiculousness, it was SO Em and SO perfect for the moment. While Em is sassy and sharp, Arsen is a total smooth-talker, ruthless yet surprisingly Baby Girl at his core. The chemistry and banter between these three characters is through the roof, and although they're all slightly feral and vicious, the emotional payoff when Em and Arsen finally do get together is DIABOLICAL. There were moments where I was blushing so hard I actually felt sweat trickle down my temples... the mouth on that man is just PHEW.
Under all of that steamy banter is a gripping plot with sky-high stakes and no miscommunication trope. God bless A.S. Keeper, because these are adults who communicate like adults, which gets ALL THE POINTS from me. The demonology and history feel fresh instead of recycled, and I couldn’t think of a comparable title, which is incredibly rare in romantasy right now.
TLDR; I’m DYING to get back to this totally unique world. Those cliffhangers at the end were pure evil, and I am SO READY for book two! And hopefully Riven’s story after Arsen & Em’s is completed… you can’t give us a hot bisexual brother and NOT follow up with a little treat of a thousand pages of tragic, sexy, rakish behavior.