Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Sinful Kings #1

Taint My Soul

Rate this book
From debut author Stanley St. Baptiste comes a dark MM mafia romance with incredible world building, mafia politics, power struggles, and complex main characters.

SAINT

Power.

I’ve been bred to be the next King of the Syndicate.

Ruthless. Calculating. Loyal.

Loyalty to the legacy of the family. That’s what should matter to me.

But everything I know falls apart the night I meet him.

Scarred. Defiant. And entirely, ruinously mine.

The man who’s becoming a beacon in the void that I call life.

I want him. I need him.

But a monster should only crave the poison in his veins, the violence, the rage.

Except he’s more like me than I ever imagined.

And what makes it worse is that my obsession with the little devil will lead to my ruin, but I will gladly stand in the furnace and burn.

MASON

Freedom.

That is the only thing that matters to me. Even if the only way is through him.

I have spent my entire life shackled to a man who should have protected me. Now to a monster who’s using me as his weapon.

The job is simple.

Get close to Saint King. Learn his secrets and hand them over.

Except the closer I get, the harder it becomes to remember which side of the war I’m supposed to be on.

Saint doesn’t know who I am. What I was sent to do. What it’s costing me to be here.

And God help me, I’m starting to forget why any of it matters. Because somewhere between surviving and wanting him. I can’t tell the difference.

446 pages, Kindle Edition

Published August 29, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Stanley St. Baptiste

2 books41 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
50 (40%)
4 stars
33 (27%)
3 stars
22 (18%)
2 stars
8 (6%)
1 star
9 (7%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews
Profile Image for Kateryna.
57 reviews7 followers
September 4, 2026
DNF

Absolutely boring and TikTok overhyped. I felt zero connection with any of the characters, there was no tension between the MCs, no high stakes, literally nothing. And the most painful part is that some of the… interactions just make absolutely no sense. I don’t want to spoil anything for those who want to read this, but c’mon, a lot of things just feel very weird and dumb.
Profile Image for Esme The Bookworm.
34 reviews
Read
August 27, 2026
I really liked the premise and could see a lot of potential in the story, but I found the execution confusing in places.

There were several occasions where the stated POV didn't seem to match the character whose perspective I was reading from. I sometimes had to stop and reread sections to work out whose thoughts and experiences I was following. There were also a few instances where information seemed to appear without a clear explanation of how a character knew it, which left me questioning whether I had missed something.

Despite these issues, I found the overall premise interesting and there is definitely potential here. The ending also suggests that the story could continue with another book focusing on a different character, and I would be interested to see where the author takes the series.

As a debut, I think there is room for improvement in terms of clarity, consistency and bringing the different elements of the story together more cohesively. However, I could see the potential in the story and there were aspects that kept me interested enough to finish it.
Profile Image for Ivy.
26 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 10, 2026
Arc Review....😁📖🔥

6⭐
This book was beautiful tbh it fit all the mafia qualities you want in a Mafia .to top it all it's not the normal mafia the fact that it's based on two Nigerian characters . I did not only love Mason and Saint throughout the book I also love their bond and how they connected given one is a mafia Heir and the other is a spy . I also love the ending when Mason decided to change his name to start a fresh and Saint right there to support his man . I really loved this even more since the characters are Nigerian based and there are less African mafia books this is my kind of trope . Definitely recommend.
Profile Image for Litafterdusk.
20 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 27, 2026
ARC REVIEW!

First off, Stanley is getting a therapy bill from me. I went through it with this book. (I should have suspected from that beautiful tearjerking dedication).
Mason and Saint nearly sent me to the afterlife, but I pulled through.

Mason and Saint turned out to be very complex characters and deeply traumatized. I didn’t expect it, but I came to understand the necessity and why it is what makes these characters who they are. The elements of their character personality and background added to the whole experience of the book. These elements of course were responsible for a lot of their choices, understandable, but Lord knows there were MULTIPLE times I wanted to slap sense into the both of them. There was a lot of side-eyeing from me and lots of “really????”.. I went from “Saint is so ruthless and batshit crazy TO protect this man at all costs” and “Oh, Mason, honey TO Mason, DPMO and I don’t know how I feel about you right now TO Mason, I will ride at dawn for you”.

Yeah, it was a rollercoaster of emotions.

But beyond all these are 2 men I wanted to give a hug several times and go to war for. Their love story had its beautiful moments, but it came with lots of trauma, obstacles, pain, betrayal and identity crises. Honestly, there were times I wondered how Stanley would pull off their HEA because these men had to fight for their life and love LITERALLY, and fight they did. One thing I loved about TMS was that it really did give what you would expect from a mafia love story as much as it could. Action, drama and villains. It really felt like watching a tv show and each episode came with its own twist and turn. Also, I love that Mason was not the typical ‘mafia heir love interest’ who sometimes can seem bland as a character, while the mafia guy has all the drama. Stanley leveled the ground here and both MMCs had to fight through life separately and together.

The themes were pretty heavy and the latter end of the book really made me emotional and my heart really broke for Mason and Saint when they started to process everything they both went through individually and jointly. But I am glad they both pulled through and got their HEA after going through hell and back.

I was in a book slump before I got mail from Stanley and this book definitely brought me out of it. I paused multiple times to scream and rant to the imaginary audience in my room at almost every chapter! (sorry to my poor neighbors)

Thank you so much, Stanley, for the ARC opportunity, more importantly, Our Representation. 🥹😊🫶
Profile Image for Shonee.
412 reviews56 followers
Did Not Finish
August 31, 2026
DNF @ 17%

The first couple chapters are confusing AF. Also, making the same guy a sex slave for the target, but also working with the target is lowkey dumb when the target isn't supposed to know they're both the same person. Don't get me started on the ass tattoo.
Profile Image for Lush Persiani Pages.
237 reviews4 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 25, 2026
1000% exactly what MM mafia should be!!!!
Oookkkkaaayyy, yep, I'm a fan! This was my first Stanley St. Baptiste book and TBH, I have extremely high MM dark mafia expectations so I went in with caution! IMMEDIATELY I was sucked into this!!! It must be mentioned first that the plot and complete story line of this book is phenomenal! You are immediately thrown into a dark, violent, sexy, corrupted plot that you know immediately is going to have you hooked by page 1! This was instantly excellent! I feel like the suspense, anticipation and tension were *chefs 💋* ! Now.... let's get to these delicious characters that I am obsessed with! Saint and Mason are delectable! So different, but oh so the same! Saint is hard. He is shut off, cold, strategic and nothing but a beautiful broken boy under it all! He has been so hardened by his life and he is desperately traumatized towards love. Mason is the definition of flight! He is scared; sweet, steady and has had the absolute worst come at him. What I love the most about these two is who you think will be the strong and steady isn't him at all!! These two were made for each other but it's a hard fought and filled with violence and fear!! This was such an incredibly sexy and fun read!! I easily rate this 5 stars but that doesn't even seem like enough!!!! Excellent, excellent read!!!!!
Profile Image for Teigan.
481 reviews87 followers
August 30, 2026
“This world doesn’t play fair, little devil, and neither should you. And no matter what side of the line you’re standing on, you’ll always have my heart.”
^ Page 378.

Started interestingly and kept my interest. But this book did not need to be almost 500 pages, especially when a lot of this plot felt repetitive. 2.75✨

By 50%, I was getting slightly irritated that Elio/Mason still hadn't confessed or asked for help from Saint. But then Saint finds out at like 55% of the book and it's resolved really quickly!

Also it's not "cuming" it is "coming"!

The number of punctuation errors and capital letters missing was horrendous. If you can ignore them it's tolerable but it gets annoying very quickly.

I think this book was over hyped from the many videos I saw on tiktok from this author.
Profile Image for Katie Loz.
34 reviews1 follower
August 30, 2026
This is an ARC review.

4 Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I love mafia romance books. I find the power dynamic so intriguing and this book had that in abundance.

I enjoyed the story and was on page 46 before I even realized. I couldn’t put it down, wanting to read more and needing to know how this story developed.

Was there some hiccups? Yes, it’s a debut novel so I don’t hold that against the author. I think they told a great story, I also think the book could have been about 60 pages shorter than it was but that’s okay I wasn’t disappointed with more to read.

I am excited to read more and see the author grow. I think this was a great debut novel and hope there’s more to read from them in the future.
Profile Image for Nicki Collins.
9 reviews1 follower
August 4, 2026
ARC REVIEW.
This is a brilliantly woven story with two MC’s who are both complex, damaged and perfect for each other. The book is action packed from the get go, I was on the edge of my seat lots of times. Add in the hot chemistry between the MC’s and this is the perfect story with a well deserved HEA 😊
Profile Image for Shai Shaina.
1 review
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 14, 2026
ADVANCE READER COPY REVIEW

I honestly would give this a +6 ⭐

First of all... Omfffffffffffffgggggggggg... I've lost my sanity while reading Taint My Soul more than times I can count... And before I jump into the characters or the plot of the book, I wanna mention how simple, yet elegant and beautiful the writing of the book itself is... For me one thing about reading while fully enjoying and living through all the emotions comes with good writing and easy flow of words which the brain can pick up easily... And Stanley's writing served this requirement so well I literally fell into the flow of the book since the beginning itself so easily... 🤍

Now let's dive into the plot and the beautiful broken boy's of mine from this magnificent book... Gwaaaaaaaaaaaaad I literally finished the book in less than two day's with all of the free time I could dedicate to reading cause this book had me stressing in that good but knee jerky way that I could not sit and rest without knowing what will happen and how it is gonna be ending... Was so hooked and driven into it that I felt like I was somehow living through the books the life's of Mason and Saint... These boy's literally has all of my heart and love... But ISTG the rollercoaster of emotional up and downs I've lived through the book is low-key high-key diabolical that I crashed out so freaking much and hard... But in that good kindda way when you find a book literally written for you with all of your favourite tropes serving you so well... ✨✨

I really loved how the book served so well for the Mafia theme as well as Mason being the spy who came to hunt but lost his heart finding himself all over again with love, healing and someone truly belonging to him after so long... And about Mason... Omfffffffffffffgggggggggg he have all of my heart and even more... I loved how beautifully the crime, suspense, hurt, comfort, power, ruthlessness, yearning, love and every aspect I crave for in such Mafia dark romance was balanced and well written in TMS.... Also not to forget how rare it is to find a book set up in this genre for Dark Mafia romance with black characters and holyyyyyyyyy shyyyyyyyt... Both of them are so beautiful and dear to me... The ups and downs of their beginning, feelings and finally finding love and safety in each other was so hard achieved but oh so beautiful... ISTG I was cussing Stanley so bad throughout the later half of the book gasping so dramatically while screaming, holding my tears or literally crying cause I feared for quite a few times how the effff the book was gonna have a happy ending... But Holyyyyyyyyy Motherfluffing shyyyyyyyt... Stanley is such a talented genius that the ending truly had me so satisfied and fulfilled like hat's off to you Babe... This is a literal masterpiece with so many beautiful elements all added together... 🤍✨

Saint and Mason Babies, you both were hurt, broken and found each other and fought through hell and back for your love and happiness and if anyone deserves a happy ending, it's these two beautiful broken boy's healing and loving each other and finding themselves once again... Love you Stanley and I'm so happy and Grateful to be given the chance to Arc read this beautiful Baby of yours... 🤍
Profile Image for Anthony Gregorey.
226 reviews4 followers
August 31, 2026
🖤 5 STARS | TAINT MY SOUL 🖤

How far are you willing to go for your forbidden love?

Taint My Soul is a riveting debut novel that had my eyes GLUED to the pages from beginning to end. This urban dark romance pulled me in with betrayal, danger, forbidden desire, and a love story that refuses to play by the rules.

✨ Enemies to lovers
✨ Forced proximity
✨ Mafia family drama
✨ Possessive MMC
✨ Betrayal & obsession
✨ Black gay dark romance
✨ Forbidden love
✨ Jaw-dropping twists & thrills

The chemistry was intense, the stakes were HIGH, and there were moments when I genuinely thought all was lost. Just when I thought I knew where the story was going, the plot would hit me with another shocking moment that had me turning pages even faster.

What really stood out to me was the way this story explores a dark, complicated, forbidden love while throwing its characters into a world filled with loyalty, betrayal, power, and consequences. There were moments that were beautiful, moments that were devastating, and moments where I was sitting there thinking, WHAT JUST HAPPENED?! 😭

This was the kind of book where I needed to know how it ended. I couldn’t put it down because I had to see whether love would survive everything thrown in its path.

For a debut, Taint My Soul absolutely delivered an addictive and thrilling reading experience. If you love dark romance with mafia elements, possessive men, enemies-to-lovers tension, forced proximity, and a Black gay love story wrapped in danger and obsession, add this one to your TBR.
Profile Image for Ashley H.
235 reviews18 followers
July 30, 2026
Did it rip my heart out !? Yes.
Was it just hit, after hit, after hit?! Yes.
Was it a 5 ⭐️ debut banger?! YES 😩😩

First the hell off, I wanna say I received this as an arc & am leaving my honest review.

Saint & Mason (Elio) are EVERY THING
two of the SWEETEST broken boys 😩😩

I dont do sad, hurt hurt hurt comfort books. Usually dip as soon as i see sad.. but this one had me from the prologue.

Had me screaming & crying. My heart was ACHING for these two babies. The list of BITCHASS characters for this one was too much. Shittttyy people everywhere, but these two over came so much and had so much growth together, but TO THE END i was unwell 😂😩 the HEA was VERY HARD EARNED.

The sweet tender moments between these two enemies 😩😭 i fkin wanted to cry and scream with happiness anytime they got a sliver of happy..

I don’t wanna give away to much but what an amazing debut and i CAN NOT WAIT for more from this author. Definitely add it to your tbr if you love dark mafia romance & broken boys who find each other
Profile Image for Alyssa V.
110 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 28, 2026
4.5⭐️ 2.5🌶
Debut authors, take notes! This is how you do it! The emotional push and pull of the two characters had me sweatin. The way this book pulled you in from the beginning and held you there was absolutely amazing and to call it an emotional roller-coaster is an understatement!! I, in fact, ATE this up and demolished it in 2 days. I will be reading EVERYTHING ELSE Stanley St. Baptiste writes, especially in this universe!
Profile Image for Bernice Reads.
254 reviews26 followers
September 6, 2026
✎This is such a beautiful debut story,it’s a story about two broken men locked up by trauma and fear,caged by obligation and the fear of being disappointments.They both live with fear,terror,rage,despair,pain and anger.The origin of their trauma may be different but they were both shackled by the same fear and being hurt by the people who was supposed to love them unconditionally.

✎Saint and Mason are two traumatized and complex characters,their upbringing and environment they grew up in and the kind of people and relationship they had,played a very important role in influencing their views on
trust,love,emotions and relationships.These led them into making choices that were not so great,to say the least.

✎ Mason made choices based on his survival,he lied and betrayed but he was just trying to survive in a brutal,dangerous and unfair world.Saint lived his life repressing his emotions and true self because along the way of him growing up and finding himself,someone told him that,who he loved made him
weak,unqualify to be a leader and a big disappointment,so he learned to lock up the truest side of him until he met this beautiful stranger who changed his views and made him want to fight for what he love and live freely.

✎Watching this two characters open up to each other,learn to trust,love and feel was such a beautiful thing to read about,watching both characters choose each other every time even though everything was working against them was so heartbreakingly beautiful,they fought for their love[literally],they stood by each other through the fear, hate and pain and I’m happy they got their happy ending because nobody deserves it more than them.

✎When I tell you both characters are deeply traumatized,I meant it,so I loved that the author showed them both going to therapy and working through their issues,and like I always say,therapy is not a magic healing potion but it’s definitely an amazing process to healing.I’m always grateful when an author doesn’t go the “love heals all” route.
Profile Image for Kayla.
443 reviews13 followers
August 29, 2026
A man on his knees. Let me repeat that. Ahem…A MAN ON HIS MFing KNEES!!! I ate this up y’all! Yeah my man Saint thought that he could just walk out on Mason and thinks he’s not affected in any way shape or form is the wrong answer. Ohhh I love how he got so protective of Mason, even when he was trying to deny the fact that he cared about him. And my sweet baby Mason! Oh my heart! What he has been through has my heart hurting for him. The chemistry was really off the charts and the fact that these two are basically trauma bonding with this hurt/comfort trope has me loving this duo even more. I honestly can’t believe this is a debut novel and I am definitely going to be reading more from this author.

•MM mafia romance
•Touch him and unalive
•Hurt/comfort
•Mafia heir/spy
•Morally gray
•Age gap
•Possessive
•He goes on his knees

*I received an arc and this is my honest opinion.*
Profile Image for Ariel (What’s Ariel Reading).
147 reviews3 followers
September 9, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
🌶️

What to expect:
Secrets, lies, deception
Boss x employee
Age gap
Mafia
Possessive MMC

Check your trigger warnings!!

This is a dark mm mafia romance with non stop action, angst & drama. I really enjoyed that the plot was fast paced & the characters inner monologues showed their internal growth.

I really liked the darker mafia elements, as well as the dynamics between Saint and his family. I do hope we get his siblings books👀😏

This is a slow burn, lower on spice (in MY opinion…remember ratings and spice levels are all subjective) but I didn’t feel like more spice was necessary to the plot.

There were a few scenes I felt I wanted more detail, but for a debut this book was really good! I can’t wait for more from this author & series!

Thank you so much for the ARC Stanley St Baptiste!
Profile Image for Susan.
21 reviews2 followers
August 29, 2026
Overall, this was a good debut novel and MM mafia romance. I liked that it was 2 Black MCs, definitely a fresh change from most romance novels. Both MCs went thru the trauma and worked hard to be together, with a lot of push and pull throughout the book. I struggled a little in the middle of the story but I was so happy to see Saint and Elio get their HEA.

“Pawns can’t become Kings. That’s the rule of the game. But let it be written in history that Elio Layton is the first pawn who became a King.”

*Review of advance reader copy received from the author.
Profile Image for J.
225 reviews4 followers
August 30, 2026
If I could rate this the way I really want to, I'd give it a negative 2, one for it being shoved down my throat as some crazy dark mm romance and the other for lack of anything remotely sexy.

Like this was supposed to be a book about lust? There was nothing lustful in this book, it was boring as hell.

I cidn't understand what the attraction between the two charas was supposed to be, there wasn't anything that made me think "holy shit this couple is hot". There's barely any sex and the 2 times there is anything happening it's very vanilla and brief.

I dunno nothing in the story was memorable to me at all. There was nothing crazy violent or unhinged, certainly nothing that would taint my soul. Another crappy book overhyped by tiktok for no good reason.
347 reviews7 followers
August 30, 2026
MM mafia romance. There is suspense, violence, push and pull between characters. I enjoyed the beginning and the ending but sometimes I had to reread, and the auther did say english was not his first language but the story is good. There is times when i really wanted to smack our characters but then there were times i really felt for them. Overall I enjoyed it. This is my first by this author and I look forward to more.
Profile Image for Sabrina Jürgensen.
5 reviews
August 29, 2026
~Review from an ARC Reader~

I really loved the book. You can feel the tension between the characters. My biggest love in books is a dark character that is obsessed and you will definitely get that here.

The book fits the dark theme so well and I was hooked. It has so much action and so much is happening, it doesn't get boring.

And damn Syn is the best ;)
Profile Image for Chimandbooks.
109 reviews
September 4, 2026
DNF’d at 82%
Okay, I’m rating because I got through a considerable amount of the book. I would have struggled through the end, but I don't like hate reading 🫠, and I really don’t want to be a hater.

For the good things:
I actually liked Mason / Elio for most of the book. He was constantly on the run from his abusive uncle, dealing with dark thoughts, but he still had that fight in him. The way he talked to Saint in the beginning, I was honestly scared for him.
Saint was okay, and I liked that he wanted to protect Mason. His jealousy was a bit much, but I think most of the time it was valid. Finally, I was very happy that Elio started getting therapy like Saint. I thought it was going to be done off the page, and his healing would be fast forwarded like in Loving the Legend (All Shade 🙂).

Despite all these things I liked, I found the romance a bit Insta love, especially from Saint's end. The author mentioned at the beginning that they don’t really know much about Mafia, and it honestly shows. Even though Saint immediately knows that Rose (sex worker) and Mason (his personal assistant) are the same person, he never investigates or does a background check. I felt very worried for Mason when I found out, but it turns out I didn’t need to be because apparently Saint is not smart?! 💀
His brother constantly tells him to watch out for Mason and to look into him, but he doesn’t for some reason. It was giving plot armour because there is no way that you trust a random man you met a few weeks back, especially when everything was pointing to him. Another thing which might be just a ‘me’ issue, I didn’t like how Saint’s internalised homophobia was written. It wasn’t interesting considering his brother and cousin are also gay. I do understand the trauma he went through with his father, but his thoughts felt so repetitive that I lost interest.

With Mason, I got progressively pissed at him as the story went on. I understand that he was scared of his uncle, Neo, Vincent and the rest, BUT he had so many instances to actually tell Saint the truth. Like, I understand he thought Saint would kill him (mind you, Saint doesn’t give that vibe after a while). He unalives a guy that sort of harasses Mason, but apart from that, he does not come off as a scary mafia guy like the author keeps telling us. Him deciding to sleep with him when he wasn’t honest and they were already building trust annoyed me even further. It was very frustrating because both he and Saint's relationship was not interesting to me. They kept having the same thoughts over and over. For example, Mason and how he doesn't want to be a monster like his uncle (I was tired!!!). It loses the impact that it is trying to have.

I don’t know if it’s just me, but I didn’t feel the chemistry between the two of them. Maybe because it felt so fast, but I kind of rolled my eyes so many times when they had emotional or romantic moments. It pissed me off that Mason didn’t think of Bernard getting tortured for betraying Saint when he was the culprit. Honestly, Ali should have been fired because why did it take so long for you to get all that?
The editing needed more work. It took me out of the story because of the number of times the word ‘had’ was in a sentence. It didn’t sound right at all, and I had to read it multiple times. At some point, I couldn’t tell which person’s POV I was reading, and it just made me tired.

This is also another example of a book that did not need to be this long. Even while I was reading, conflicts were being solved a bit too quick. It is also the reason why I had to DNF because the main antagonists are dead and I still had like 7 chapters to go. Their romance is not that interesting for the book to still have those remaining pages.
Overall, I do think I will try this author’s work again because there is potential, but a lot of things fell flat for me.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Shanice.
119 reviews6 followers
July 31, 2026
Okay, so I had the pleasure of reading this as a beta reader, Alpha reader, ARC reader… basically every kind of reader, and I can confidently say that I thoroughly enjoyed this book.

One of my favorite things about this book is that it has 2 Black MMcs. It has been WAY too long since I’ve read a book with two Black MCs, and I honestly cannot think of another dark mafia romance I’ve read featuring two Black MCs. If there are some out there and I’m forgetting them, please forgive me!

In this story, we follow Saint and Mason, and Mason....sheeesh. This man was GOING THROUGH IT.

I remember reading this book for the first time and thinking, "Mason cannot catch a break." Every time I turned around, this man was being abused, battered, beaten, emotionally broken down… EVERYTHING you can think of. And every time I thought, "Okay, things are finally looking better for him!"

Stanley was writing like, "Nope, we need MORE" LOL

Following Mason was honestly difficult at times because of everything he endured. But at the same time, I found myself getting SO frustrated with Saint and their dynamic. I wanted to reach through the book and shake Mason like, "My GUY Saint is trying to help you....eh sorta," lol. Out of all the absolute craziness happening in your life, this man seems to be the ONE person actually trying to be on your side!

Watching both of these men grow throughout the story was one of my favorite parts. Mason especially goes through so much growth, particularly when it comes to finding his voice and finally learning to stand up for himself.

Watching Saint step away from his father and start becoming the person he needed to be for himself and not just his family was probably my favorite part of his story because...he was making me grumpy.

There were definitely scenes that were hard to read because of the torture and everything these men endured, but I appreciated that the story didn't make those scenes the entire focus. There was still so much emphasis on the story, character development, relationships, and moving the plot forward, which I think made the darker elements feel purposeful rather than just being there to be there.

There were parts where I was reading, and I felt like I was watching a horror movie, screaming at the television:

"THE KILLER IS RIGHT THERE!!" But of course they can't hear you, and they walk right by the guy waiting in the closet for them.

When we finally get to that climax, though...I sighed in relief lol

The wait was WELL overdue, and I was sitting there thinking, thank GOD ya'll can hear my thoughts now and are getting it together.

This was such a wild ride. Definitely different from what I'm used to reading, but in the best way.

For a first release, I think Stanley did an incredible job. This is such a strong breakout book, and I'm genuinely happy I got to be a part of this experience from the early stages. It was truly an honor.
I'm excited to see where this series goes and to learn more about these absolutely INSANE mafia men because apparently I love a good amount of emotional damage.
Profile Image for Fany Reads.
186 reviews20 followers
October 1, 2026
This is a FAST burn book, immediate connection. If you are not a fan of that, don't read it. I think it lost me a tiny itty bit at the end due to this, wanted more to be done with Tobias, Virgil, where did he go? I loved the mystery of the first half of the book. And for being a debut book, it's not bad. I like the trauma bond as well. :)
Profile Image for Akeil Espinosa.
3 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 30, 2026
Dark romance is one of those genres where readers often confuse "dark" with "good." Taint My Soul reminded me that those aren't the same thing. What makes this book work isn't the violence, the mafia setting, or the morally grey characters—it's how intentionally all of those elements are written.

The first thing that stood out to me was Stanley's pacing. The story doesn't rush into romance or action for the sake of instant gratification. Instead, it spends time establishing the rules of its world, the motivations behind each decision, and the balance of power between its characters. By the time the stakes escalate, you've already bought into the world enough that every betrayal, alliance, and shift in loyalty feels earned.

One of the book's greatest strengths is its world-building. The mafia isn't just a backdrop used to justify dangerous men in expensive suits. It feels structured. There are consequences for every choice, loyalties that constantly shift, and an underlying political tension that extends beyond Mason and Saint's relationship. It creates the sense that this world existed long before these two characters met and will continue after their story ends.

Speaking of Mason and Saint, I appreciated that neither character was written to fit neatly into the role of hero or villain.

Mason's development is subtle but effective. His arc isn't about becoming fearless or suddenly learning how to fight. It's about learning how to survive without surrendering his identity. He spends much of the novel adapting, observing, and making increasingly calculated decisions. By the end, he isn't simply reacting to the world around him—he's influencing it. That's a much more satisfying progression than watching someone magically become untouchable.

Saint was probably the more fascinating character for me. He's possessive, ruthless, manipulative, and at times incredibly difficult to like. The book never asks you to excuse those traits, and I respected that. Instead of giving him a dramatic redemption arc, Stanley lets his growth happen through restraint. The man at the end of the novel is still dangerous, still morally compromised, but his priorities evolve. He's not softened—he's layered. For a dark romance, that's a far more believable direction.

What I enjoyed most about Mason and Saint together is that their relationship constantly evolves. It isn't built on grand declarations or instant trust. It's built on observation, compromise, manipulation, reluctant respect, and eventually genuine loyalty. Power shifts back and forth between them throughout the novel, and that unpredictability keeps the romance engaging because neither character completely dominates the other for long.

Another aspect I appreciated was the supporting cast.

Rather than existing solely to push the romance forward, many of the secondary characters feel like people with their own agendas. Some alliances are clearly transactional, others are rooted in long histories, and several characters feel as though they're being positioned for much larger roles in future books. Instead of overshadowing Mason and Saint, they expand the world around them and make it feel lived in. That's something I hope the series continues to build on because there's a lot of potential there.

The dialogue also deserves some praise. Conversations rarely feel like exposition. Characters speak according to who they are, and a lot of tension comes from what isn't being said rather than what is. In a story built around manipulation and shifting loyalties, that worked incredibly well.

That being said, I don't think the novel is without flaws.

Some of the larger reveals became fairly easy to predict once enough pieces had been introduced. The foreshadowing is effective, but readers who are familiar with dark mafia romances may identify certain twists before they're revealed.

I also would've liked the ending to breathe a little more. After such a steady and deliberate build, the resolution moves quickly. I wasn't disappointed by where the story ended—I simply wanted a little more time to sit with the consequences before the final page.

If I had one broader criticism, it's that there are moments where the wider mafia politics become so interesting that I actually wanted even more of them. That's not necessarily a negative—it speaks to how engaging the world is—but I would've happily traded a few scenes for additional exploration of the organization's inner workings and some of the supporting players.

Ultimately, what impressed me most was the book's confidence. Stanley never abandons the tone he establishes in the opening chapters. He doesn't soften his characters to make them easier to love, nor does he rely on shock value to convince you the story is dark. Every violent act, every betrayal, and every difficult decision serves the larger narrative instead of existing purely for impact.

Taint My Soul isn't trying to reinvent dark M/M mafia romance, but it understands exactly what readers of the genre are looking for. It delivers layered characters, compelling power dynamics, genuine mafia stakes, and a romance that develops through trust earned in impossible circumstances rather than through convenient plot devices.

For readers who enjoy morally grey protagonists, dangerous relationships, and a criminal world that feels as important as the romance itself, this is a book I'd confidently recommend.

Final Rating: 4.5⭐
Profile Image for Jine.
560 reviews16 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 28, 2026
This was everything I thought it would be! All the teasers on TikTok I knew I would love it! So we have a mafia heir Saint who’s gay but was taught it was a sin so he hates himself for his desires
We have Mason/Elio who’s family was killed and he had to live with his uncle who was absolutely horrible to him but he escaped until 7 years later he was caught David is in debt and he needs mason to get close to saint to get information for him
Mason meets him at a sex club where saint frequents but whoever he sleeps with signs contracts so he can try and control his desires
This book got hot and heavy in the beginning but it tapered down until Saint and Mason became more
Mason slowly falls for saint but saint runs away or he tries too the same with Mason they both are trying to keep it professional
What I loved was even when Mason wasn’t saints he protected him I mean he cut out someone’s 👅 for speaking to Mason wrong LOL
I feel like the turning point for them was when they were captured together Saint had been through this before because his dad locked him up for months then made him kill his boyfriend so when the boyfriends dad captured him they were tortured together
Ugh the begging! I did not think Mr big mafia guy would but boyyyy did he ever! He begged for a kiss from his little devil he begged for forgiveness that man had begging down pat!
I felt so bad for Saint and all his inner turmoil stemming from
His Dads homophobia he was supposed to be king but he wanted him perfect and when Mason found the book where saint wrote about being wrong on the inside it was horrible!
Mason has his own demons too coming from his family issues and the fact that his uncle is a pos
We all know the blowup is coming when saint finds out what Mason did and I was terrified I truly was but relieved when Saint took it easy on Mason but when Mason came back my god!
Saint decided that Mason was worth it he was his and he wasn’t going to let his father ruin them but when his father threw him in that hole again oh my god!
Bernard sweet sweet Bernard saved Mason! But I love how determined Mason was to go and get Saint and he was smart to make the deal with Saints former boyfriends father because saint may have pulled the trigger but his dad ordered it!
No matter what happened no matter how broken each of them were they vowed to stay by each others side no matter what when Mason killed his uncle and thought he was a monster saint was there with him for therapy
When saint got out of the whole and was panicking and then taking over Mason was there right by his side!
I loved their nicknames Mason went back to his own name Elio so Saint called him my Elio my son
Elio called him darling which made saint melt! And he called him my saint my sun!
So many unexpected moments but I loved them all
I loved vulnerable Saint who let Elio take over and he in control during spicy times
I really really enjoyed this book and I know it’s book 1 in this universe so I can’t wait to see what’s next can’t wait to see how they run the syndicate now with the dad gone and Saint in control!!
I did cry the ending got me when he had the rings I was a goner but that last line was incredible
Pawns can’t become Kings that’s the rule of the game
But let it be written in history that Elio Layton is the first pawn to become a king!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Gab Sampaio.
43 reviews
September 1, 2026
For a debut, it's a good book. I like the characters' personalities and the settings, and it has a great premise. However, there are some plot inconsistencies that I find hard to overlook. The narration sometimes gets confusing, and oftentimes I didn't know who was speaking because there were no remarks to indicate it.

And then we have the MCs’ trusting and loving emotions developing way too quickly towards each other, which painted me as a bit unnatural and rushed. You're telling me a mafia boss (Saint) meets for the first time a sex worker (Mason) at a brothel and the next day he is already putting his company on the line trying to protect that person without even checking if he is trustworthy or not? I'm sure Saint is already familiar with betrayals from his years of working with the mobs, but he doesn't bat an eye catching feeling for Mason. Also, Saint is kinda dumb sometimes. Let's see, you have his previous sex brothel partner quit without any explanation, a new one replaces the former and then coincidentally becomes his assistant at work by the next day, traspasses Saint's proprieties and eavesdrops on his mafia business, gets caught while doing so, and Saint simply lets him go, as simple as that without raising suspicions and red flags? For a mafia boss, he sure is trusting people he barely knows very quickly.

Also, I don't buy the love at first sight that happens with Saint. I know he's very lonely and such, but the settings are not favorable for it to be believable. They're meeting on a brothel, and Saint, aka the ruthless mafia boss, becomes enamored by the second he sees Mason. I mean, Mason raises every red flags, but Saint just overlooks it like his life is not on the line. If they had met by coincidence at a bar and had had a lovely time together with Saint rediscovering parts of himself he had buried, then, yes, it would be somehow more convincing. But the set up doesn't help, and Saint doesn't bother to look deeper into it before falling head over heels for Mason.

And lastly [MINI SPOILERS], how the fuck does a mafia billionaire not have security enough to protect his own house? That fighting scene with David at the end made no sense at all. I know Saint's house is supposed to be secluded, but you don't send your lover alone to a house when there are people trying to kill him. And you're telling me you love him? Because to me it seems you just sent him to his certain death.

But if you ignore those things, it's a good reading, and the romance is very sweet. I thought their relationship was going to take the toxic route, but I'm glad the characters are actually lovely to each other and they genuinely care for one another.

Another thing [SPOILERS], I love how the Father is very much homophobic, and his 3 sons are very much gay. That made me laugh a little. It's unrealistic (I think?), but it's funny as hell. I love when karma strikes homophobic parents like that.
Profile Image for Jay T.
86 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
July 26, 2026
Review of Advanced Copy received from Author


I screamed, I cried, I got swooned by this book,it was a long list of an emotional rollercoaster 😭 😭

This book follows two incredibly complex main characters whose lives are shaped by trauma, survival and impossible choices.

Mason has endured years of abuse and manipulation, and even after escaping one nightmare, life continues to pull him into another, as his past refuses to let him go, forcing him into dangerous situations where survival always comes before anything else.

Saint, the heir to a powerful mafia syndicate, is equally complex. Raised to believe that vulnerability is a weakness, he hides both his emotions and his sexuality behind control, discipline, and authority.

Their first meeting sparks a relationship built on tension, curiosity and undeniable attraction. The chemistry between these is immediate, but trust is much harder to earn.

The spice is definitely there 🫦, but what impressed me most was the emotional depth beneath it. Saint's need for control and Mason's quiet resilience create a dynamic that feels natural rather than forced and watching their relationship develop was one of my favourite parts of the novel.

Stanley St. Baptiste also deserves credit for the incredible world-building. The mafia politics, power struggles, financial aspects of the syndicate and constant tension between loyalty and betrayal made the story feel rich and believable.

One thing I especially appreciated was how the novel explored masculinity and identity.

Mason was easily my favourite character. Despite everything he has survived, he remains calm, respectful and remarkably strong. His quiet resilience made me root for him from beginning to end.

I also loved seeing Nigerian characters represented naturally throughout the story. As a Nigerian reader, that detail genuinely made me smile.

The emotional tension between Saint and Mason is what truly carries this novel. There are moments that made me swoon 😍 moments that completely broke my heart 😭 and moments that I genuinely don't know how everything will unfold.

This is a hurt/comfort romance that balances action, emotion, suspense and intimacy beautifully.

Stanley St. Baptiste's writing surprised me in the best way. Blending mafia politics, finance, identity, family expectations and romance into one cohesive story isn't easy, yet every element worked together seamlessly. I seriously can't believe this was a debut work 🤌🏾, it was remarkable 🥹

This was an emotional journey and I loved every minute of it.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Profile Image for Latty|The Creative .
341 reviews15 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 15, 2026
Taint My Soul had a promising start, and the ending was so rewarding; however, the middle is where the story kind of fumbled for me. At times, I forgot the age gap because both main characters were mostly childish. While I can overlook Mason, Saint is grown and supposedly hardcore, but he rarely flexed that power the way I expected him to.

When it came to his possessive and jealous nature towards Mason, sure, he's a beast, but otherwise, Saint was just talk for me. How is it that you don't have much of a spine when it comes to your dad? 🤨 Don't get me wrong, Tobias King is a piece of work, and he traumatized his son, but at times, I wanted Saint to just give off some aura and put Tobias in his place to earn his respect.

Now, Uncle David got what was owed , and while I jumped for joy , his villainous ways could have been more impactful with some foreshadowing. Most of the pieces of how he treated his nephew were just Mason telling , so I couldn't relate to his fear of the man whenever he came up; I just knew he hurt a sweet boy and continued to do so as he grew into a young man who didn't deserve it.

While most people love the push-and-pull trope, I'm one of those who favor it less. It was quite prevalent in the story, and while I empathize with both MCs' circumstances, I didn't particularly feel their chemistry until near the end.

Again, the story started out really well, and I love the ending.

"Pawns can’t become Kings. That’s the rule of the game. But let it be written in history that Elio Layton is the first pawn who became a King."

POWERFUL AND WELL DESERVED!

I'm happy for both MCs' growth and happiness. The middle is where the story got shaky, but that's on me and my own expectations hence my 3.5 star rating.

If you love the cat-and-mouse dynamic where the MCs drive you up the wall, then this is perfect for you.

I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Profile Image for BethanyReadsMM.
83 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 7, 2026
This book summed up in a few words: Wow. Amazing. Intense. Emotional. I could go on and on because this book was so good. I cannot believe it was a debut novel. This is exactly what an MM mafia book looks like!

This book put my through it. All of the emotions that ran through me the entire book was intense. I felt so bad for Mason and what he had to endure his whole life. I felt bad for his whole situation throughout for Saint’s family but in the end, it worked out.

I also felt bad for Saint. He had to be a tough guy and a “monster” but really he was going through it too. All of the expectations from everyone and how he had to be the tough guy and CEO made me so sad for him.

The plot of this book was so good as well. I was on the edge of my seat for most of it and I was in disbelief for all of the twists and turns. This book exceeded my expectations of any MM mafia book, let alone a debut.

As others have said, Stanley has said that English isn’t his first language and there were times the POV would switch or names were mixed up and I did have to go back and reread some sentences. With that being said, I still absolutely loved it.

If you’re looking for an MM Mafia that keeps you on your toes, has many different tropes and overall an amazing store, read this!

**check trigger warnings**
Profile Image for Alexa Ale07.
23 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
August 24, 2026
ARC REVIEW !!!

📖🖤📖 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️📖🖤📖
This was such a strong MM dark mafia romance with a mafia heir and a spy, age gap, boss/employee, forced proximity, and plenty of tension. As an ARC reader, I’m keeping this completely spoiler-free, but I can say that this is easily one of the best dark MM mafia romances I’ve read.😍

🖤 Saint was definitely my favorite. 🙈😁 He’s a mafia heir who is cold, calculated, powerful, and always seems to be three steps ahead. And that touch him and die energy? Absolutely EVERYTHING. There’s something so compelling about the way he carries himself and the control he has over every situation.

🖤 And then there’s Mason/Elio. Despite everything he does and the choices he makes, I found him surprisingly easy to understand and empathize with. He’s trying to survive, and that makes his actions feel much more complicated than simply labeling him as good or bad. I really appreciated that nuance.

🖤 The author also did a great job balancing the darker elements of the story with the character development and relationship dynamics. Nothing felt flat, and the tension between Saint and Mason kept me turning the pages.

❤️Overall, Taint My Soul is easily one of the best dark MM mafia romances I’ve read, and I would absolutely recommend it to anyone who enjoys dark romance with morally gray characters, mafia dynamics, obsession, power play, and intense chemistry.❤️
Displaying 1 - 30 of 66 reviews