Jump to ratings and reviews

Win a free print copy of this book!

0 days and 19:01:39

25 copies available
U.S. only
Rate this book

The Plum Queen

Not yet published
Expected 22 Apr 27

Win a free print copy of this book!

0 days and 19:01:39

25 copies available
U.S. only
Rate this book
'A richly hued and luxuriant time machine that immerses the reader in women’s lives of the century just past, in women’s secrets, and particularly in women’s secret love affairs with each other.' Susan Choi, author of Flashlight

Before she became Howard’s wife and mother to their girls, there were the plum orchards. There was Phoebe.

When the letter arrives in the days after her husband’s death, Lenore instantly knows who it is Phoebe – her best friend, her first love, the girl who once seemed to hold the upper hand in everything – who she hasn’t seen in almost forty years. Is it an olive branch, or will it reopen old wounds that have taken half a lifetime to heal?

As Lenore wrestles with whether to allow Phoebe back into her life, she reflects on the three great loves who shaped it. Each relationship had its own unique pleasures, risks and sacrifices, and in each Lenore made life-changing choices. What will she choose now?

The Plum Queen is a sensuous, richly textured novel of love and loss, that confronts the many versions of ourselves that accumulate over a the person we could have been, the person we once were, and the person we still might become.

READERS ARE LOVING THE PLUM QUEEN:
'Beautifully written, reflective, and full of heart'
'I did not want this book to end. Lathrop did a phenomenal job painting every scene'
'A thoughtful examination of queer identity and queer female friendship'
'A lovely debut, particularly for readers who enjoy intimate, reflective stories about women’s lives'
'Like biting into a sun-warmed plum'

Kindle Edition

Expected publication April 22, 2027

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Laurel Lathrop

1 book14 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
7 (12%)
4 stars
28 (51%)
3 stars
17 (31%)
2 stars
2 (3%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 46 reviews
Profile Image for Meagan (Meagansbookclub).
937 reviews8,375 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 21, 2026
Beautifully written and full of nostalgia, this book captures the feelings of youth, first love, and how love can change depending on the person. While I appreciated the writing and enjoyed following Lenore, some descriptions felt overly long, and I struggled to connect with most of the other characters. Overall, a pleasant but not particularly memorable read.
Profile Image for Lo Lu.
132 reviews
October 1, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley for giving me this ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I often say that a debut novel is a special read because the author has been brewing this story in their head for a long time. For this book, I think there was less of a story and more of a feeling, a feeling of looking back on your youth and naivety, the feeling of falling in love, and how that can feel different depending on who you’re falling in love with. The writing was beautiful, but I do think the descriptions got too wordy at times, which took away from the full immersion of the story. Lenore was a stable and enjoyable character to follow, but I had a hard time liking most of the other characters. I felt very neutral and pleasant towards this book overall, and would definitely recommend it to fans of Ann Patchett or Taylor Jenkins Reid.
Profile Image for Angie Miale.
1,539 reviews239 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 25, 2026
The Plum Queen by Laurel Lathrop
⭐️ 3.75/5 stars
📖 Publication Date: April 20, 2027

Thank you to Random House for reaching out and providing me with an advance reading copy of this lovely debut novel!

I can see why this book was recommended to me based on my enjoyment of novels like The Homemade God and Buckeye. This is exactly that style of historical fiction that focuses intimately on one person, their relationships, and the ways their life unfolds against a backdrop of cultural and historical change.

It’s 1984, and Lenore has recently lost her husband, Howard. As she sits at home watching the Summer Olympics, she begins reflecting on her life and the three great loves who shaped it.

First, there’s Phoebe, her childhood best friend, with whom she shared an extraordinarily close bond before their lives took them in different directions. Then there’s Greta, a wild, angry, bohemian artist who challenged Lenore and helped her emerge from her shell. And finally, Howard, her husband and a professor of classics, with whom she built a life.

But I wouldn’t necessarily describe this as a novel about falling in and out of love. It’s much more about the evolution of one woman over the course of her lifetime, and how the people we love shape who we become.

Lenore is a fascinating character. She’s intellectually gifted, particularly when it comes to translation, but she’s never quite understood her place in the world. She doesn’t form connections easily, but the few relationships she does cultivate are incredibly meaningful. Each belongs to a different chapter of her life, and each reveals something about the woman she was at that particular moment.

I especially appreciated the historical perspective on what it meant to be a brilliant woman whose opportunities and sense of identity were shaped by the expectations of her time. There’s something poignant about watching Lenore, now widowed, revisit her life with the perspective that only age and experience can provide.

Lathrop’s prose is beautifully crafted, although I occasionally felt that it was almost too polished. I sometimes encounter this with debut novels, where every sentence feels so carefully considered and refined that the writing becomes a little more noticeable than the story itself. That’s not necessarily a criticism, just an observation about the reading experience.

Ultimately, The Plum Queen is a quiet, nostalgic, character-driven novel about love, friendship, identity, and the many versions of ourselves we inhabit throughout a lifetime.

It was a pleasant and thoughtful reading experience, with a compelling central character and a lovely sense of time and place. While it didn’t quite reach the emotional heights of some of my favorite literary historical fiction, I appreciated its tenderness and introspection.

3.75 stars. A lovely debut, particularly for readers who enjoy intimate, reflective stories about women’s lives and the relationships that define them.
Profile Image for Valentina Khimich .
102 reviews8 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 6, 2026

Thank you Net Galley for this ARC



This book surprised me. I went into it expecting a story about love and relationships, but it ended up being so much more about life itself and all the different versions of ourselves we become along the way.
We follow Lenore through decades of her life, through friendship, love, loss, marriage, heartbreak and choices that completely change the direction of everything. And I think that was what fascinated me most.
Lenore’s relationships are complicated and very human. Nothing is perfectly romantic or wrapped up nicely. Each person she loves gives her something different, but every new chapter of her life also seems to require grieving the person she was before. I loved that aspect of the story.
I also really enjoyed the historical aspect and seeing how love, identity and relationships that had to remain hidden were experienced during a very different time. It added another layer to Lenore’s choices because freedom didn’t always mean what it means now.
The pacing did slow down for me in places, and there were moments when I felt like I was observing Lenore rather than completely living the emotions with her. And Phoebe… yeah, I definitely had some complicated feelings about her. But somehow even the characters I didn’t particularly like made sense within Lenore’s story.
This is quiet, introspective literary fiction rather than a dramatic, fast-moving romance.
A beautiful and thought-provoking debut
Profile Image for Barb Bullock.
259 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
October 25, 2026
Thanks to @kellydasta and @penguinrandomhouse for the ARC.

Some friendships stay with us for a lifetime, even when life takes us in different directions.

The Plum Queen is a moving story about Lenore looking back on the three great loves of her life and all the ways they shaped who she became. After losing her husband, she revisits a past she’s kept buried, including a friendship that was perhaps her first and most complicated love.

I especially liked how the story explores the lifespan of friendships, the twists and turns they take, and how people who once meant everything to us can become strangers before finding their way back into our lives. A bittersweet, thoughtful debut about love, loss, and the people who leave their mark on us.

📚 Release Date: April 20, 2027
Profile Image for Katie Herklotz.
144 reviews4 followers
September 10, 2026
Such an impressive debut, a look-back book and reflections on our past selves through many stages of life, with themes of friendship and all the ups and downs it can bring. Add this to your most anticipated book lists of 2027!!
Profile Image for megs.
267 reviews5 followers
October 19, 2026
Thank you NetGalley for this advanced readers copy in exchange for an honest review!

A surprisingly lovely story. In some ways definitely felt like a debut novel, I think the organization/structure of the book was a little off & the bouncing of story lines didn't always make sense with the narrator voice, but i loved Lenore. I loved the underlying commentary on lost loves and friendship, and felt the ending was perfect. Intrigued by future novels from this author.
Profile Image for Donna McCaul Thibodeau.
1,531 reviews38 followers
Did Not Finish
October 19, 2026
I read 42% of this book before giving up. It didn't seem to be going anywhere. DNF.
Profile Image for Cecilia Romano.
38 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 10, 2026
The Plum Queen is the kind of book that made me slow down a little.

There’s something really beautiful about a story that looks back at a whole life and asks us to think about all the versions of ourselves we carry with us the person we were, the person we thought we would become, and the person we might still become.

I really enjoyed the way this book explores love and friendship, but especially the complicated ways those relationships can shape us over time. Some people become part of our lives for a season, some stay much longer, and some leave an imprint that never completely disappears.

There’s a quietness to this story that I appreciated. It isn’t just about what happens, but about memory, choices, longing, and the things we sometimes only understand when we have the perspective of looking back.

It left me thinking about how much of a life can be made up of choices we don’t fully understand until years later—and how there can still be room for change, even after so much of life has already happened.

A thoughtful, beautifully written debut that I think will stay with me for a while.
Profile Image for Jana.
76 reviews
October 1, 2026
The only regret I have about reading The Plum Queen by Laurel Lathrop is how long I let it sit on my TBR list!

This book has everything I love in a novel. Deep character development without the story ever feeling like it drags, thoughtful reflections on the life we choose and the paths we didn't take, and whether those other paths were ever even truly possible, particularly given the societal and familial expectations at the time. How often our choices made for the safety, stability, and security of a more traditional life. There is something to be said about quietly looking back at the decisions we've made, though not necessarily with regret, but wondering what might have been. The author strikes a perfect balance of friendship, romance, historical fiction, and those quiet moments of reflection that we’ve all had while moving through life.

This debut is a very strong four star and I look forward to future novels by Lathrop. Thank you to NetGalley, Random House, and the author for the advance e-copy of this book!
Profile Image for karla JR.
556 reviews12 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
September 10, 2026
I would like to express my gratitude to penguin and the author for providing access to this advance reader copy. However, from my perspective, it was not a fantastic read. I appreciated the tones of female relationships and their complexity, but the writing style made it quite boring for me in the long term, and I had to compel myself to finish it.
Profile Image for Stacey O Keeffe.
60 reviews7 followers
Review of advance copy received from Netgalley
August 10, 2026
The Plum Queen was a very introspective look at life from the early 1900s through to old age. Phoebe and Lenore have an all-encompassing friendship when they meet as children, and the book lays out how their relationship was forged, cracked and changed over the course of their lives.
It gave us a dip into life in the LGBTQ+ spectrum in those days, the secrecy of it. It also begs the questions of who chooses their paths in life and what the consequences of those decisions are. It was really well written
Profile Image for Jenni Ogden.
Author 7 books323 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 9, 2026
A beautifully written debut, this reads like a memoir; Lenore, a recently widowed woman working out how to grieve for the sudden death of her academic husband by setting down her own past history of relationships. The title ‘The Plum Queen’ refers to her first important relationship, her childhood friendship with Phoebe, who, unlike Lenore, comes from a wealthy Northern Californian family who have made their fortunes by growing plum trees. Phoebe is their only child and makes her fair share of bad choices as she and Lenore’s relationship breaks down multiple times as they grow older. Yet having read the novel I felt that while the title and cover were striking and intriguing, they felt misleading as this story is centered on Lenore. The opening chapters really drew me in and I was expecting and hoping for a different story than the very detailed descriptions of the relationships Lenore had before she married Howard, the least interesting character of all, a kind and rather boring academic in a rather boring and sexist Stanford. By the end of the book which felt longer than it needed to be, Lenore and Phoebe reconnect although without any promises. Phoebe seems to have finally found the courage to be true to the values she has had since a child; her horror at the way her wealthy family treated the Mexican migrants (who had been an essential part of their success); and her mother especially a Lady Bountiful. I read the author notes after reading the opening chapters, excited by the historical research that had gone into the novel on the Mexican migrant farm laborers, as well as the flu pandemic of 1918-1919 and was disappointed that the novel did not delve more into these areas…what if Phoebe had ‘eloped’ with Carlos, and how fascinating that story would be.

Although the opening line tells us Lenore buried her husband in 1984 I often forgot this was a story set generations ago and had to work out that Lenore was probably about 65 when she was widowed, and thus her almost too perfect mother was of the generation born in the early post WWI era. That is, for me Lenore’s life as well as her mother’s generation sometimes felt much more recent and then a date would pop up and remind me. Of course the sexist society of the 1930s , even in universitIes, including Stanford, reminded me of the time frame and again how much more interesting to me would have been a story where Lenore bucked the trend. Even at the end (ie: 1984 when she ‘wrote’ her memoir) I didn’t fully understand why she kept secret from Howard, the man she had decided she truly loved, so much about her previous life. Now that too would have been an interesting part of her story if she had taken him into her confidence.

Having said all the above, nevertheless I am glad I read this novel and very much look forward to future novels by this author. Perhaps she will do a ‘Kate Aitkinson’ and write some of those alternate paths.. Phoebe joining Carlos’s family as they are forced to flee the US for Mexico; the story of the friendship and love affair between her mother and Phoebe’s (most fascinating) mother in the 1940s; a deeper dive into how she and Howard survived as a couple, and was she fulfilled at the time?

Thank you to the author, publisher and NetGalley for a digital arc in return for an honest review.

Profile Image for thebookaerie.
101 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 6, 2026
The Netgalley synopsis for The Plum Queen immediately intrigued me and I was thrilled to be approved for an early read.

I was instantly drawn into Lenore’s story, the book serving as almost a memoir of her life. It’s a lifelong telling of a woman’s journey in and out of love, and how surprising life can be. It’s an examination of the choices Lenore makes, leading her to new beginnings, and the realization that sometimes maybe our choices are inadvertently made for us by those who come in and out of our life, or circumstances beyond our control.

It’s the story of a woman who has three great loves of her life, and how each of those relationships brought education, growth, love, sadness, and new opportunities. But most of all, a layer of grief at each turn, when moving on from who you were in one relationship, to who you might become in the next. There’s an absolutely beautiful piece that struck me as Lenore is moving in and around a decision to end a relationship and move forward with a new one. It’s written so nicely and gives a potential reader a glimpse inside the book.

“At times the choice seemed obvious: between a love I still could barely name, that however long it lasted could never be more than an open secret, with a younger woman who had an artist's temperament and uncertain future, in a city I was at last, after eleven years, growing tired of; between all this and the kind of love I'd imagined all my life: marriage, a college campus, books. And near my mother. But obvious does not mean easy. It would mean relinquishing a part of myself only just discovered, pulling up strange green shoots before they could flower, because they might overwhelm the garden long planned and already planted. I wasn't sure I could go back to who I had been now that I had lived as someone else, a freer and more expansive self. I wasn't sure I wanted to.”

Some great decisions we think we will make in our lives, or have made, may actually end up being not our own, but the circumstances life brings to each of us, and this book made me think of my own life decisions along the way. The book is beautifully written and I enjoyed it so much.

I loved the pacing and Lenore’s story, some of the characters I liked very much. Greta lived a creative, artistic, and seemingly “free” life in New York, while Howard was more stable, devoted, and serious. Each brought different offerings to Lenore’s life, and I was moved by the love she had for each of them. Although I did not like Phoebe very much, the character of Lenore’s best friend offered a contrasting part and played a critical role from beginning to end.

This was reminiscent to The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo for me and is definitely worth a read. I will be recommending it!

3🌟
Profile Image for Brooklyn.
285 reviews69 followers
October 31, 2026
Thank you #netgalley and Kelly Dasta #randomhouse for this ARC.!

What a lovely debut - lots of feels and beautifully written. Lenore grows up best friends maybe more with neighbor Phoebe in Northern California in a landscape of orchards and thus the title. As Phoebe’s wealthy family runs fruit orchards - with many plum trees. After losing her husband Howard - a professor of classics at Stanford- at the beginning of the novel - Lenore decides the write the story of her life and loves - Howard - Greta and her tumultuous unexpressed love for Phoebe. It’s funny how none of the reviewers so far has mentioned much that Lenore is a queer women mid century - and how that is addressed and experienced in a time and society that was not open to expressing ones sexuality. Many of the women in this book - including Lenore’s and Phoebe’s mothers who have their own surreptitious love affair- are married to men and have children with men. Lenore’s NYC lover is Greta - a butch in the underground and thriving queer life of the 1930s-1940s. All the history and background of Lenore’s life is fascinating and expertly weaved into her life - and the life of a queer woman midcentury. All through the book - I imagined a 1950s Lana Turned movie directed by Douglas Sirk. The drama is borderline camp but Lenore’s life is so heartfelt and well drawn by the author that I couldn’t laugh for crying. But believe me this would make a great high camp movie which also addresses real social issues of the time. A page turner - I loved reading this and couldn’t put the book down - it also reminded me of the seven husbands of Evelyn Hugo and a number of Taylor Reid books. All the characters are sympathetic yet complicated - Phoebe
can be a tough character to like. But I wound up engrossed and empathetic to all even straight Howard and Frank - the unsuspecting husbands. Lenore’s and Phoebe’s mothers have an affair that though at times unbelievable- epitomizes the plight of queer married women in mid century- and the compromises they make (and courage) to keep their love alive. Kudos all around on this first novel and a great choice for an open minded book club. A unique debut that I hope gets more widely read since only 40 people on Goodreads have reviewed. Soon to be published !
52 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 27, 2026
This is a really hard review for me to write fairly because this book was well written, but I just did not particularly like it.

The writing was beautiful and descriptive. I felt like I was alongside Lenore through her life, sharing her experiences. The historical aspects of this book were very interesting, and deftly woven into the narrative. It also really felt like the author understood her characters. They were all humanly flawed and nuanced. Unfortunately, I found them all irritating, Lenore, most of all. We spent the whole book reflecting over Lenore’s life, and yet it never really felt like she learned all that much. The decisions she made in her adult life were the exact same decisions that her childhood self would have made, and that was, I think, my main issue with this book. Lenore just never mentally grew up and it frustrated me because the reader spends most of her life with her.

Reading this book made me feel like an old woman watching a young girl with dreams and talents and aspirations throw it all away with every decision, so, towards the end, when Lenore was the older woman and refrained from giving her daughters the advice that her young self so desperately needed, it was my final straw.

Objectively, this book is actually very good, and I honestly would recommend it if you enjoy literary fiction, but I just don’t think I do. It was hard to separate my frustrations with the characters from the actual book, and that ended up impacting my overall experience.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
13 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 1, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️☆ 3.75 Stars | The Plum Queen

Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC!

What a wonderful debut novel and such a beautiful, heartfelt story!

Life unfolds in seasons, each bringing its own kind of love, heartache, joy, and regret. As we move through these seasons, we change, grow, and sometimes make choices we wish we could revisit. Looking back later in life allows us to take inventory of the women we once were, the women we have become, and the friendships and loves that shaped us along the way.

Sometimes, we don’t have just one true love. Sometimes, there are two, each leaving a different mark on our hearts and our lives. Our choices can bring immense happiness, but they can also bring sorrow, and learning to make peace with our past is part of the journey.

The author does a beautiful job of capturing this journey through Lenore and Phoebe. Their story explores the complexities of love, friendship, regret, and the possibility of reconciliation later in life. Reconnecting with a once-beloved friend isn’t always simple. It requires honesty, vulnerability, and the willingness to look inward and acknowledge the mistakes we’ve made.

This is a lovely, reflective story that reminds us that our past doesn’t define us, but it certainly helps shape who we become. A beautiful debut, and I can’t wait to see what this author brings us in her sophomore novel! 💜
Profile Image for Mocha Beanz.
27 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 5, 2026
Thank you to Random House for this ARC in exchange for an honest review :D

Okay, so I think this was a very good book for a debut. I thought the writing was beautiful. It has a very strong beginning, where I was very excited to turn the page and continue reading. I read this book in about 2 days because it was an easy read. It did read more contemporary rather than historical fiction, so I often had to remind my self that this book was set in mid century 1900s.



I give this book a 3.5/5. I would recommend this book. I was actually thinking about buying this book for my friend who would appreciate once it becomes published.
Profile Image for Joyce Cacioppo stein.
90 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Publisher
November 8, 2026
The Plum Queen by Laurel Lathrop describes to us the life feelings of someone who is aging. Lenore has just buried her husband. Her children are grown and out of the house. She is lonely and thinks back on the life and loves that she has had throughout her lifetime.

The year is 1948. Lenore lives with her mother in CA. The are not wealthy, in fact just getting by. Lenore makes friends in fourth grade with a girl named Phoebe who is well off. They become best friends as well as their mothers. As they grow up, their outlook on adulthood changes. They want different things and find love in different places. Their friendship is on and off throughout the story, their last separation being a number of years before her husband’s death. She receives a letter from Phoebe after his death and that brings us to the tale of her life.

Lenore has had basically three loves in her life. She goes into detail of each one, showing us how she has grown and how her outlook on love has changed throughout the years. The writing is good however I found many areas where the detail was drawn out and found much being skipped over. I also found some things in the story unnecessary. For instance bringing in what was going on with her 2 daughters. I did not feel it added anything to the story.

Thank you Random House and Net Galley for giving me the opportunity to read the ARC.
Profile Image for Paul Moffett.
87 reviews
October 31, 2026
The Plum Queen by Laurel Lathrop

It's 1984, and Lenore is now a widow. She receives a letter from Phoebe, her estranged childhood friend, but refuses to read it. The story then takes us back to the early 20th century, when Lenore and Phoebe first meet in fourth grade.

Much of the book reads like a coming-of-age story, following the girls through their tumultuous friendship as they grow into adulthood. Their lives become intertwined with relationships, marriages, divorces, immigration issues, and questions of sexual identity. Over the years, their friendship experiences its share of ups and downs, eventually leading to a falling out that lasts for decades.

We return to 1984, where widowed Lenore is once again faced with a letter from Phoebe.

Overall, I enjoyed this story. It's relatable because, at one time or another, we all struggle with the choices we make and the friendships that shape our lives.

My one small complaint is that the book didn't quite feel like historical fiction to me. There were a few moments that reminded me of the time period, but for the most part, it read more like contemporary fiction. Still, it was an enjoyable story about friendship, relationships, and the complexities of life.
108 reviews3 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 9, 2026
The Plum Queen by Laurel Lathrop is a story of life, love, friendship, love lost, love reconnected.

The layout of the story started out strong and I was prepared to snuggle in for the entirety of the book.
It lost my interest somewhere along the way.
The author's story telling is very good.
However, I lost interest in the story as it became very verbose and I found myself skimming many of the pages just to get back to the story.

I was also not prepared for the sexual content of the book.
While I usually have no problem with same sex relationships, I probably would not choose this book had I known how much of the content would be focused on those relationships. With nothing in the synopsis of the book to indicate this content, it took me by surprise.
I would prefer that the sexual content remained "behind closed doors" as I don't have any interest in reading what is referred to as "spice" in that genre, even when it is not a same sex encounter.

Again, the writing was good in spite of being too descriptive and wordy in places.
I just didn't care for the content.

Thank you to Netgalley and Random House for the privilege of reading an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Janet Fiorentino.
Author 3 books12 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 28, 2026
"The Plum Queen" is a debut novel about friendship, love, and how the two often intertwine. Opening in the summer of 1984, we meet Lenore, a recently widowed woman reflecting on the three great loves of her life. First, there’s Phoebe, her childhood best friend, with whom she shared an incredibly close bond before life took them in different directions. Then there’s Greta, who introduced Lenore to a different side of herself. Finally, there’s Howard, the man she planned to spend the rest of her life with.

The novel explores who Lenore was during each of these relationships and how they helped shape the woman she became. There’s something poignant about looking back on the people and moments that defined our lives with the perspective that only age and experience can bring.

While "The Plum Queen" didn’t quite deliver the emotional punch of some of my favorite literary historical fiction, I appreciated its tenderness and its thoughtful look at the relationships that stay with us.

A lovely debut for readers who enjoy character-driven stories about women and the people who shape their lives.
Profile Image for Teresa Graber.
28 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 9, 2026
The story was like biting into a sun-warmed plum, with a distinct snap of tartness followed instantly by an explosion of sweet nectar. It features a deeply moving plot that goes much further than just romance, friendships, and the choices we make in our lives. To fully appreciate it, I had to look at the deeper meaning of the story and read with an open mind.
The timeline gracefully transitions from the "current" year of 1984, moving back through many stages of the main character's life, with historical events and changing societal views on alternative lifestyles intertwined seamlessly in the background. Lenore reflects on the many people she loved, all of whom helped shape who she is today. As we progress through the different seasons of our lives, it feels as though we are continually reinventing ourselves—and this book reminds us that it is never too late to do so, no matter your age.
Thank you Random House Publishing and Net Galley for the opportunity to read the early release of The Plum Queen written by Laurel Lathrop and this is my review and opinion only.
Profile Image for Bri.
49 reviews
October 27, 2026
This story opens with the death of the main character, Lenore’s, husband. She receives a letter from her ex-best friend, which prompts her to begin writing the trajectory of their friendship beginning with elementary school.

This book is gorgeously written, with this seed of mystery throughout propelling you to find out where and when the friendship soured. The character depictions felt honest and true to life. They don’t always behave as you would like, make the choices you think they should. And I think that’s what ultimately made Lenore come to life most for me. She doesn’t always do what she should, what is bravest…but neither do I. I’m frustrated with her choices because they’re choices that I have also sometimes made. While the plot of the story was fascinating, this masterful character creation is what really made this a solid read for me.

Genuinely a book that I just loved the experience of reading every time I picked it up. Thank you so much to NetGalley and Random House for the eARC!
Profile Image for cass .
241 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
November 10, 2026
An intimate story of a woman that shares three loves, deep rooted in familial ties and the struggles of being gay before the turn of the twenty-first century. I found myself really loving being in Lenore's head most of the time- there were a select few times however, that I wanted to slap her for being silly, but that almost marks a great MC, since no one is perfect. I found myself really hating Phoebe, however, she was also a super flawed character in herself, as well as potentially some unreliable narrating from Lenore's POV.

That said, it was not a 5-star for me simply because the ending made me wanting more. I suppose for a woman such as Lenore, dealing with all she's dealt with and the regrets, there was no better ending than a simple one. A great debut from Laurel Lathrop and I look forward to more of her novels in the future, if so be!

I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. I would like to thank Laurel Lathrop, NetGalley, and Random House for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.
Profile Image for Nancy Segura .
105 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 17, 2026
I received an advanced reader copy of Plum Queen by Laurel Lathrop, and I really enjoyed this one!

There was something about this story that pulled me in and kept me curious about where it was going. The characters felt real and imperfect, and I loved watching the story unfold and seeing the different layers reveal themselves along the way. Laurel Lathrop’s writing made it easy to become invested without the story ever feeling forced.

Plum Queen had a little bit of everything I enjoy in a good read….emotion, complicated relationships, unexpected moments, and characters who stayed with me after I finished. It was one of those books that I found myself thinking about even after I put it down.

I’m so glad I had the opportunity to read this one early and will definitely be looking forward to more from Laurel Lathrop.

Thank you to the author and publisher for the advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.
Profile Image for B K178.
432 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 4, 2026
I was immediately captivated by the premise of Laurel Lathrop's *The Plum Queen*. The novel thoughtfully explores love, memory, grief, and the many aspects of ourselves that surface over a lifetime.

I didn't feel as emotionally engaged as I expected. I struggled with the pacing; the story's rhythm felt uneven or subdued. Certain sections lingered longer than I would have preferred. The narrative shifted between moments of deep emotion and extended periods of reflection, which created some emotional distance. Instead of feeling swept up, I often seemed to observe Lenore's life from a distance.

Still, I appreciate the novel's ambition and the careful development of its characters and relationships. Although it didn't fully resonate or sweep me away, it will surley appeal to readers who enjoy gentle, introspective literary fiction. Thanks to Random House and NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Jen N.
217 reviews2 followers
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
August 27, 2026
Thank you to NetGalley and Laurel Lathrop for the ARC of this book.

I chose to read The Plum Queen because the description on NetGalley made it sound like it was right up my alley (Literary Fiction, Historical Fiction, General Fiction [adult]). The writing is excellent. The characters are well developed. It starts out strong and intriguing, but somewhere in the middle it fizzles out, causing me to lose interest. It was difficult at times to stay focused.

I was not prepared for the explicit and descriptive sexual references and play-by-play bedroom action, both straight and gay. The descriptive genres LGBQIAT+ and Romance should be added for this book. I read a wide variety of books, but romance is not my thing.

2.75* . A lot of readers will enjoy this well-written book, but unfortunately it wasn't for me.
58 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
September 8, 2026
I liked this debut novel and will look for more from Laurel Lathrop.

After her husband's funeral in 1984, Lenore receives a note in the mail from her childhood friend Phoebe. They have not communicated in almost 40 years, and the note triggers Lenore to consider the three great loves of her life: Phoebe (who she loved since 4th grade), Greta (a brash bohemian artist in New York) and Howard, her kind and loving husband.
I liked the storytelling, and the fact that the novel didn't only revolve around her relationships, but also the life events (and perhaps circumstances) that formed her.
I especially liked the character of her mother. I didn't care for Phoebe and her casual cruelty. I often wondered why she had such a pull on Lenore.

Thank you to Netgalley for the Advance Reading Copy of this not-yet-published book.
28 reviews
Review of advance copy received from NetGalley
October 1, 2026
This book was only OK, hence just 3 stars.

It was coincidentally the 3rd book I read in a row that dealt with female friendship, two of which have bisexual plots lines. The others (The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo, which has both, and The Lion Women of Tehran) did it far better. All three books had another thing in common: long stretches where the main character was alienated from her beloved friend.

Unlike The Plum Queen, these other books had characters I cared about and a plot that had some intrigue.

The writing in The Plum Queen was OK, but there were times I glossed over the long descriptions to get to the plot, to find out where it might go, and see if I might care what happened to the main characters. Ultimately, I did not care.

Thank you to Netgalley for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 46 reviews