Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Penalty : Whitmore U Book 2

Rate this book
One night was never going to be enough.

Margo Ashby doesn't do reckless. She's the flyer everyone trusts to land it, the pre-law junior with a five-year plan and a smile that never slips. So the night she ends up in Theo Mercer's bed — the Ravens' scowling, tattooed, impossible-to-read defenseman — is supposed to be a onetime lapse in judgment.

A secret.

A mistake she can file away and never mention again.

It isn't.

Theo doesn't have room for anyone. He's got one get drafted, get his mom out of the town that broke her, get out. He doesn't need a golden-girl cheerleader who smiles like she's never been let down — even though he knows better than most that the smile is a wall, not a window. He tells himself that once. Then he's back at her door.

One night becomes a standing arrangement neither of them will call by name. The arrangement becomes something they can't stop reaching for.

Now they're hiding a relationship neither of them can explain, bracing for a future neither of them planned, and falling — fast, hard, and completely against the rules — in the space between practices, playoffs, and the family Theo swore he'd never let himself trust again. And when a positive test blows their careful nothing-relationship wide open, there's no more pretending this was ever casual.

Margo's always had to earn love by being perfect. Theo's always known people leave. They're about to find out what happens when two people who don't believe in forever can't stay out of each other's way long enough to prove themselves wrong.

503 pages, Kindle Edition

Published October 5, 2026

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Tamsyn Bester

56 books963 followers
Hi, I’m Tamsyn — a South African author, editor, and professional overthinker who believes the best stories start with a little chaos, a lot of emotion, and characters who refuse to behave.

I write contemporary romance filled with messy feelings, undeniable chemistry, slow burns, banter, heartbreak, and the kind of happily-ever-afters that make you want to throw the book across the room (in the best possible way).

When I’m not creating fictional disasters for my characters to survive, I’m usually editing, plotting my next book, drinking entirely too much coffee, or convincing myself that “just one more chapter” is a reasonable life choice.

I’m building my own little corner of the romance world one story at a time — and I’m so glad you’re here for the ride.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
4 (36%)
4 stars
7 (63%)
3 stars
0 (0%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews
Profile Image for Only.ever.books.
1,707 reviews30 followers
October 8, 2026
Review:
🏒The Penalty🏒
Whitmore U #2

By Tamsyn Bester

🏒 College Romance
🏒 Surprise Pregnancy
🏒 Sports Romance

⭐ 4/5

Margo and Theo

This college hockey romance follows Theo and Margo. A cheerleader who has her life planned out exactly with everything and a hockey player who has his own issues.
They had a one night stand both weren’t really able to leave behind them. And when they have to work on a project together it makes things more difficult of course.
And then the one thing happens that throws both’s lives into a loop.
Theo has goals, caring for his mom by moving her out of the town and becoming a spot in the NHL. In his opinion, nobody stays, sometimes everyone leaves. So he doesn’t want to get deeper into the attraction and connection Margo, it's the least he needs.
Margo has her life mapped out, but she has her mind made up about the belief in forever isn’t.
So these two have to find a way to get over their issues and make their new future somehow possible.
Emotional and with a happy end.
Profile Image for GenReadThis.
48 reviews1 follower
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 11, 2026
“It’s not complicated. It’s not an arrangement or a term or a thing with a box. It’s just: I want to be where she is. I’ve wanted to be where she is since roughly October, and I’ve been calling it something else, and I’m running out of names.”

I received this ARC unexpectedly a few days ago. It’s a series that’s 2 books in now from an author that’s new to me and I can honestly say I’ve fallen in love. With Tamsyn Bester, with Theo & Margo, with Whitmore U and the entire world that’s been meticulously built to house these love stories.

Tamsyn has a unique style of writing that is immersive and engaging. I love how she writes her characters so that you feel like you’re experiencing life through them, not witnessing it alongside them.

The second book in the Whitmore U series is a stand-alone love story featuring Theo and Margo. One, a grumpy hockey player with daddy issues and the other, a cheerleader with her life mapped out and colour coded by the hour.

This is a -

1️⃣ one-night stand

😍 enemies with benefits

🤫 secret relationship

👶🏽 surprise pregnancy

👫🏼 found family

- rollercoaster of a book that will have you smirking, crying and laughing at the unhinged shenanigans of a group of college students, living, learning and making plenty of mistakes along the way.

Another aspect of the writing which I really enjoyed was how 🌶️ spicy🌶️ this book was, without making it the entire storyline. Every scene had a purpose. Every shared moment pushed the narrative forward. You could feel these characters fall in love in real-time and honestly, it was something I didn’t know I was missing until now.

Tamsyn Bester reminds me of Jodi Picoult, a writer that leaves you thinking about your own choices long after you’ve turned the last page.

🏒 If you’re looking for college athlete romance, this is the book.
🏒 If you’re looking for a messy, unvarnished and real love story, this is the book.
🏒 If you’re looking for emotional, heart wrenching trauma and tears at 2am when you have to work the next (same) day but still can’t put it down, this is the book.

If you want to know what I’ll doing at 04:16am on a Thursday morning, it’s downloading Tamsyn Bester’s entire catalogue starting with Whitmore U book 1.

Do yourself a favour and add The Penalty to your TBR because you don’t want to miss out discovering Theo and Margo’s love story for yourself 💜
Profile Image for Alice.
74 reviews2 followers
September 19, 2026
Margo and Theo had me hooked from the start. A one-night stand neither of them can forget, followed by being forced to work together on a class project… cue all the tension!

Margo is the confident, independent cheerleader who’s used to being in control, while Theo is the grumpy hockey defenceman. I loved watching them slowly read each other, break down those walls and become exactly what the other needed.

There were parts in the middle that felt a little slow for me, but it definitely picked back up. I also really enjoyed the family dynamics and the way their past hurts and betrayals shaped both of them.

And that ending, Margo’s dad, their friends’ reactions were top tier. Also, Theo’s mum deserves a special mention because I absolutely loved her!

Definitely looking forward to continuing this series.
15 reviews
October 8, 2026
I received this book as an ARC, thank-you to the author.

I really enjoyed this book.
I loved the main characters and their relationships with their friends and family. The story was interesting and the characters had great development throughout. My only real critique is that the book was LONG and a little slow in the middle. It was incredibly detailed and at times I felt small pieces could be left out in order to reduce the word count, as I found myself drifting at times when the book was slow.

Overall, I would recommend this book to anyone who likes hockey romance novels. The book was spicy throughout which I loved, the characters are interesting and it’s an easy read.
Profile Image for Tanya.
400 reviews
November 4, 2026
I really loved Margo and Theo's story. Margo's relationship with her family is very complicated and I'm glad she was able to make herself heard with Theo's support. The way Theo stood up for her was just chef's kiss. I loved his character and his dedication to his dream as well as to the life he wanted. This author's writing is engaging and I'm always fully immersed in the story and the characters. I can't wait for the next book. Possibly Cash & Wren's story? I can't wait!

Thanks Tamsyn Bester for sending me an ebook. I'm loving the Whitmore U series.
Profile Image for Ashisha Sewpal.
134 reviews3 followers
October 26, 2026
Loved the second novel in the Whitmore U series.

Margo is pre-law and a cheerleader. Theo is on the hockey team. Theo doesn't talk much as seen from the first book. They are always at loggerheads. Thrown together for an assignment, they are forced to discuss and build their argument and something shifts along the way.

I enjoyed getting to know more about Theo and Margo. I loved their story and character development. Can't wait for the next book in the series.
Profile Image for Amber.
1,545 reviews60 followers
Review of advance copy
October 4, 2026
We're back at Whitmore for more fun and spice along with lots of heart. Margo and Theo have an unforgettable one night together. When they are assigned to work together on a class project, the tension sparks high. The more time they spend together, the closer they get and that attraction deepens. Their chemistry and banter was great. I love a grumpy hockey player that is soft only for her.
Profile Image for Taylor.
37 reviews
Review of advance copy received from Author
September 16, 2026
This was the best continuation that made me fall in love with Margo and Theo. The story was perfect and I can't wait for book 3!
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews