A haunting tale of fraught sibling relationships and unreliable narrators, perfect for fans of Mona Awad’s dream-like atmosphere and Lucy Rose’s twisted family dynamics.
Alex Ashford-Black and her twin brother Charlie disappeared when they were fourteen. Upon their return a month later, they told a story no one believed—of a dark world filled with carnivorous beings and a man named Grey who took them there to feed off their burgeoning talents.
Twenty years later, the veneer of normalcy they’ve crafted is falling apart. Alex, a formerly bestselling writer addicted to male validation, is immolating her self-worth in a toxic affair. Charlie, a rising star of the art world, begins to unravel as hallucinations claw at the edges of his reality. And their younger sister Verity drifts through the wreckage of her privilege—recklessly spending her trust fund and listening to the ramblings of their paranoid, reclusive mother.
Then Verity vanishes. And Alex knows, deep in the part of herself she’s spent two decades silencing, that her sister is not just missing. She has been taken—back to the place Alex swore never existed. To save her sister, Alex must return to the Other Place. But it’s not just the monsters waiting for her there. It’s herself.
An unsettling psychological horror full of slow-creeping dread and heart-wrenching family drama, Hunger Pains explores what happens when the things that take us never really let us go.
Samantha Cohoe is an author of young adult and adult literature with a speculative twist. She loves family drama, awful secrets, and complicated women. She lives with her family in Denver, where she must constantly fend off invitations to ski or camp. Her debut adult horror novel, Hunger Pains, comes out in Spring 2027.
I went into this book pretty blind outside of seeing it on a couple Bookstagram accounts that usually have similar taste as me (I think Mother Horror was one but don’t hold me to that lol). I’m also shocked this book was a Read Now, the cover alone would have had me requesting it without any other information. I also don’t know what all goes into “Read Now” vs request soooo anywho.
The book focuses on three siblings who are all struggling with their own demons. The issues seem to have started with what at first glance seems to be a traumatic kidnapping, but as the story unfolds we see this is something even uglier.
The main narrator is Alex, the oldest sister, but it swaps between her twin brother Charlie and her baby sister Ver/Verity. Alex is so easy to dislike as she makes terrible self-destructive decisions that could also hurt those she loves most. But as her trauma resurfaces you begin to empathize with her and see it’s more than what’s on the surface. Hot mess express girlies, you may feel called out or seen and it’s done well.
The book explores religious trauma and familial trauma in a beautiful and haunting way. I keep randomly thinking about something in the book and realizing it was a metaphor for how trauma impacts a child and their view of themselves and the world. There are some parts where Cohoe represents the trauma physically and it’s quite descriptive in a way that made me shudder (which for me is a positive!).
This book had me feeling grossed out that there are truly families and parents who treat children like this. I felt my heart ache so many times learning about the childhood that led to the siblings being who they are now and why they seem to be trying to implode their lives constantly. I felt anger at their decisions melt away into sadness.
While I have so many questions about this book, I know they’re meant for me to interpret and figure out and that’s okay.
Highly recommend judging this book by its cover and picking it up because both are haunting yet beautiful.
Thank you NetGalley, Crooked Lane Books, and Samantha Cohoe for this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
I started reading this book before a flight and finished it just as I was walking up to my front door, eyes locked into the text the entire time. I absolutely enjoyed this book and would welcome a prequel, a sequel or both. Alex’s character is super headstrong and in charge. Charlie is super protective of his sisters but also so sensitive. Verity seemed to be fighting against something that no one truly paid attention to. And their mother, the mess that she is, was so much more concerned about what she felt was right and her heart instead of listening to her children. Alex was constantly making bad decisions and to me, was the center of attention even at times where she wasn’t supposed to be. But, considering her trauma, it felt like that was her way of coping. I also felt like she was smart and wary and was able to catch things that other people did as wrong, even though in her personal affairs, she didn’t want to do that herself. There were a couple characters that I genuinely felt bad for. The way that there were being treated and at times I really felt that Alex’s behavior towards them was very uncalled for… like snapping a risqué photo in bed with someone to send to someone else. The book did a great job at painting her as someone that was pretty self serving. I would have loved a much longer book to explore the other world more, learn more about Grey and what it must have been like growing up with him up until their kidnapping, and exactly who, or what, he is. The end of the book leaves you with an unexpected twist that I would not have guessed but left me hungry for more.
This book started off with a bang. Like that prologue was actually awesome af! I felt myself fly through this book so easily, I became obsessed with this family and their drama / trauma. I felt like I was genuinely part of the family.
The fmc of this book, Alex, plays the most perfect unlikable character. You can’t help but absolutely love her and hate her at the same time. The relationship she has with her brother and sister was the only thing giving her sanity, it felt. She held onto them so tightly so that she wouldn’t fall apart. She was especially close with Charlie, her brother, based on their share trauma.
I loved how this horror pulled on other world vibes and i believe you’d enjoy this if you like the movie “Us” as it had elements that made me think of that. All in all i absolutely loved this book, the unhinged family dynamic, the awful mother and horrible villain, Grey, I did not know what was real and what I had to question which is what I especially look for in a book.
Thank you Netgalley for this arc. I’ll definitely be buying the physical when it’s released!
This has the potential to be the IT Weird Girl book of 2027.
I do not read horror very often, but I am glad I picked this one up. This book felt like I was tripping at a family reunion attended by 100 family members I had never met before. The atmosphere was so creepy, but the plot was heavily comedic, and the balance that Samantha Cohoe was able to achieve between the two was STELLAR. Half the time I wanted to throw up from anxiety, and the other half I was giggling like I knew these characters personally.
Our FMC Alex perfectly portrayed an unlikable, male-centered character, but I also loved her? And her journey of finding her self-worth and standing up for herself was so empowering to read. WE NEED MORE GROWTH IN BOOKS!!! We need more unlikable characters that find themselves along the way!!!
I felt very unsettled reading this book, but in the best way possible. If you want a creepy, funny, strange book that keeps you turning the page, I would highly recommend picking this book up when it comes out. What a WILD ride that was.
Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this book early!
Hunger Pains by Samantha Cohoe Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️💫 3.5 stars
The Ashford-Black family could keep a therapist employed until retirement. Alex and Charlie (twins,) disappeared for a month as teenagers, came back talking about monsters and a man who fed on their talents, and eventually tried to get on with their lives. Twenty years later, Alex is in a toxic affair, Charlie can’t trust what he’s seeing, and their younger sister Verity goes missing. (So that’s going well.) Alex has spent years telling herself the Other Place wasn’t real and now it might be the only place she can find her sister.
Alex is a mess, and there were times I wanted to confiscate her access to men until she developed some standards. I felt for her, though. Her relationship with Charlie gives the story its weight. These two share something nobody else can fully understand, which doesn’t mean they’re particularly good at understanding each other. Then there’s Verity, burning through her trust fund, and their mother, holed up with her suspicions. Money, talent, privilege. Could someone in this family please acquire a coping skill?
The Other Place got under my skin because I could never quite tell how much to trust what I was being told. The pacing was slow in spots, though, and there were stretches where I wanted the story to get on with it already. I like being kept uneasy. I do also like knowing what the hell is happening every now and then.
Grey feeding off their talent was creepy as hell. Alex still looking for approval from people who give her scraps? That bothered me in a whole different way. I get wanting to be wanted, even when you know better. That part got to me. The book as a whole just never really grabbed me. 3.5 stars and a reminder that being called “gifted” as a child really should come with a few follow-up questions.
Thank you to NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books for the digital advance reader copy in exchange for my honest opinion.
THIS WAS WILD Let me preface by saying: there's a lot of trauma in this book, so it might not be for everyone. But you are looking at a horror book, so...
Alex and Charlie are twins. When they were 14 they disappeared for a month to another place of carnivore monsters ruled by a man named Grey. It's not 20 years later and some things they thought they left behind came back to haunt them. Then their sister vanishes, and Alex knows where she has to go to get her back.
I love people's imagination. I could never. This book was a wild ride. In the best yet worst possible way. It was terrible: heart wrenching and maddening and sad. It is honestly one of the only actual horror books I've read recently. I was surrounded by this sense of dread for the whole book, and I was completely blind to what was to come. I would never expect nor imagine where this was going. I was both horrified and terrified and it was exactly what I needed. It's written so well and it really kept me hooked to the pages. I really can't find anything negative to say about it, really. Only one note, and that is that I wished we got to see more of the Other Place and understand its workings better.
It's very good and very thrilling, but beware: it's VERY scary.
Hunger Pains sounds like exactly the kind of twisted, unsettling horror I love. There is something especially disturbing about a childhood trauma that never really stays in the past, particularly when the people who experienced it are left questioning what was real and what wasn't.
I was drawn into the complicated family dynamics, the fractured relationships between siblings, and the mystery surrounding their childhood disappearance. The idea of a place filled with carnivorous beings feeding off people's talents is such a wonderfully disturbing concept. And when Verity disappears, the story takes on an even darker dimension as Alex is forced to confront the one place she has spent twenty years trying to forget.
I especially love psychological horror that gets inside your head, plays with reality, and makes you question what is lurking beneath the surface. The combination of unreliable narrators, buried trauma, family secrets, and something genuinely monstrous makes this a fascinating premise.
A dark and twisted exploration of the things that haunt us, the damage we carry, and the parts of ourselves we can never truly escape.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review this advance copy.
I devoured this book in two days, which feels incredibly fitting given the title. The writing style immediately pulled me in, and I found myself eager to see where this strange, unsettling story would take me.
I particularly enjoyed the otherworldly horror elements and the unsettling atmosphere woven throughout the story. My only real complaint is that I wish we had explored those elements a little more deeply. There was so much potential in that aspect of the narrative, and I would have loved for the book to lean even further into its strangeness.
I also really appreciated the complicated sibling dynamic and the use of an unreliable narrator, which added another layer of intrigue to an already bizarre story. I love when a book makes me question how much of what I'm reading I can actually trust.
Overall, this was a wonderfully weird, compelling read that kept me turning the pages. While I wanted a little more from the horror elements, I thoroughly enjoyed the experience. I will definitely be reading more by this author!
TLDR; an excellent read. especially during spooky season. trauma. body horror. strange vibes. damaged characters. would have liked more from the ending.
Cohoe tells this story through several third-person perspectives, none of them omniscient or fully reliable. The effect is unnerving, and I spent the entire book questioning what was real. This structure suits the novel’s themes of family trauma and guilt.
Alex is a perfectly unlikable protagonist. She is messy and untrustworthy, yet I rooted for her and empathized with her. Her bond with Charlie is the book's emotional core. They're deeply enmeshed and scarred by their shared past. Verity is elusive and inscrutable. I would have liked to understand Grey and his motives better. I felt the lack of detail prevented him from being as terrifying a villain as he could have been.
My main reservation is the final act, which felt rushed and vague after such a deliberate build. It softened the impact of an otherwise gripping story. A few side conflicts also resolved too neatly. Still, this is an unsettling, absorbing read for fans of horror, messy family dramas, unlikable heroines, and unreliable perspectives.
This book is one of the best books I've read in a while. I could not put it down at all and when I wasn't reading it I was constantly thinking about what is going to happen.
The siblings had my heart especially Alex. They are all such complex characters who were well written. I saw myself in Alex alot and I loved that at the end of the day the siblings came together for one another no matter what happened. I was so sad at the end when we found out about the reality of the other place. The author does a wonderful job at breathing life into these characters.
The horror element in this book was terrifying yet I loved every moment of it. That being said I hated their mother and grey so much like genuinely they are so awful and that goes to show just how diverse the author is at character writing.
I'm so glad I was given the opportunity to read this arc and discovering a new auto read author!!
I read this book in one sitting and absolutely loved it!
I was so attached while reading about this family, their trauma, and all of the family drama they had. I LOVED Alex. Even though I couldn't personally relate to how she felt and how she dealt with her trauma, it was handled very well. I think anyone who does relate to her coping mechanisms will find it validating seeing that experience represented on the page.
I also loved the speculative, dreamlike atmosphere! It was executed so well and made hard to stop reading. Im shocked this is a debut because it felt so polished and well done. The only problem with reading an ARC so early is that now I have to wait even longer for Samantha Cohoe's next release!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
I was so invested in this story, you couldn't pry this book out of my hands!!
The premise — chef's kiss! Just from reading the synopsis, I knew this was exactly the kind of thing I was looking for in my fall/horror read. The feeling of unease you get while reading this is truly wonderful.
I loved the complexity of the characters. There were many things about the siblings that would make you dislike them, and yet, you just can't help yourself. You have to hope for the best for each one of them. They were all very strong and well-fleshed-out characters who made believable choices.
The book was a little slower in the beginning, but then it picked up. The final twist was unexpected and made me both gasp and cry, but I wouldn't change a thing about it.
Reading this family's story honestly felt like watching a drama series about some rich family, but make it horror. Just perfect!
I devoured this book! I absolutely loved it! I could quite happily reread it straight away.
The sense of dread kicks in from the get go and keeps you hooked.
The way the siblings are all written is incredibly well done - we get to know them all individually and they all have distinct personalities. The trauma they all share is formed perfectly throughout and at no point was I left feeling it was over the the top. It just kept adding to the sense of foreboding that there was a much bigger picture happening. I found Alex to be my favourite character and incredibly relatable and realistic in how she came across
My only issue is I do wish there was more to the ending. Maybe that it was longer and we got to explore it a little more. Yet at the same time I loved that it still doesn't get fully explained.
I devoured this book. It was unhinged and I absolutely loved that. This book is a wild ride, I loved the characters and the mystery they went thru. The plot is absolutely amazing. I loved the twists and turns and I loved the side characters although the mother got on my nerves because she kept believing a man over her own kids and that always makes me mad. I thought the writing was absolutely amazing, I loved the main characters, not the momma lol The plot was a cool concept thst I ate up I highly recommend
This was such a fantastic read, I was hooked at the end of each chapter and truly struggled to put it down. The characters felt so real and compelling, and the relationship between the three siblings was very well done. I loved Alex as a protagonist in all her messy, problematic glory. A great blend between horror and family dynamics. Truly an addictive read. Wish we had seen a little more of the Other Place and had that built in a bit more detail but overall, highly recommend.
Compulsively readable, deeply felt speculative/surrealist thriller about complicated family dynamics, and the ways in which childhood trauma can have lifelong effects. It has the feeling of a dark modern-day fairy tale. Think Succession meets Jim Henson's Labyrinth, served up a la Mona Awad. I'm excited to see what Cohoe writes next!
Thank you NetGalley for the eARC in exchange for an honest review.
Great read for the spooky season with unhealthy family dynamics, and an FMC who can’t love herself. I hate when the mom is the problem, but here she’s the biggest problem. I honestly don’t know why the kids still talk to her even if it is with disdain.
Read if you enjoyed watching Us (2019) and Stranger Things (2016). Has vibes of both!
Thanks for the Halloween read NetGalley and Crooked Lane Books. Pub date April 27, 2027.
A dark psychological horror story about a fractured family, childhood trauma, and a terrifying alternate world that explores how some experiences never really let us go.
An intriguing premise that combines a childhood disappearance, an unexplained otherworldly experience, and a mysterious figure creates an unsettling foundation for a horror story. The concept of a dark, carnivorous alternate world offers plenty of potential for disturbing imagery, creepy encounters, and psychological tension. The underlying themes of trauma, repression, self-worth, and the lasting impact of childhood experiences also give the story an opportunity to explore something deeper, adding emotional and psychological layers to the horror.
My favorite aspect was the use of unreliable narrators. The uncertainty surrounding what really happened keeps the mystery alive and leaves plenty of room for ambiguity, unanswered questions, and unexpected revelations. However, I found the characters difficult to like, which made it harder to connect with them or root for them. I also thought the balance between family drama, psychological horror, and supernatural elements was a little uneven at times. The story leaned more heavily into the family drama than I would have preferred, as that isn't usually my cup of tea. Still, the intriguing premise, unsettling atmosphere, and layers of mystery kept me engaged, even when the characters and family drama didn't fully work for me.
Ultimately, the novel had the ingredients for a compelling psychological horror story, but the execution didn't quite live up to the premise. While the unsettling atmosphere, layered mystery, and exploration of childhood trauma were effective, the unlikable characters and uneven balance between family drama and horror kept the story from reaching its full potential. There were some genuinely interesting ideas here, but the overall experience fell short of what I had hoped for.
This is firmly a horror book, filled with creepy vibes and tense family dynamics. Our protagonist is a childhood trauma survivor, and we meet her as an adult struggling to cope with the circumstances of her mysterious disappearance years ago. The story unfolds through a wedding weekend, where Alex drags herself to the many surrounding events while unraveling and revisiting the past.
On a scale of scariness, I'd rate this a 5/10. Much of the creep factor comes in through the tone and mood, which is full of dread as the reader begins to untangle the complex relationships Alex has with her twin brother, her sister, her mother, the bride and the mysterious Grey. There are (spoiler/trigger warning) some elements of body horror, including amputation.
I really loved how unlikable Alex is—she's a mess. Fixated on an inappropriate man, acknowledging the wrong choices and making them anyway, saying the worst thing even when it will turn an already-tense situation into something ruinous. She made many wrong turns, but I couldn't help but relate.
The story was full of suspense, and I was eager to find out what happened next. Like other reviewers, I found myself tearing through this one quickly. I was disappointed by the time spent in the "other" place, because I wanted so much more of it, to dive much deeper into that world. That could have been an entire book for me, the lore of this scary unreal dreamworld. I rated the book overall a 3.5/5 as I felt there were opportunities to tie the opening and the otherworldly exchanges more strongly together for a tighter ending. I understood where we ended up, but it felt a bit vague and openended for my taste.
Overall, it was a perfect read for just around Halloween, and I recommend this book to people who are interested in complex sibling dynamics, the psychology of lasting trauma and unlikable/unreliable female narrators.
I received an advanced reader copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.
First off, thank you to Crooked Lane Publishing for the ARC! This is my honest review and is not affiliated with the author or the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.
I finished reading Hunger Pains and I’m honestly a little torn on this one.
I thought the premise was interesting, and there was enough happening to keep me reading because I genuinely wanted to know where the story was going. However, I never felt particularly compelled to fly through it. The plot meandered quite a bit, and it took a long time to get to the climax. The writing just wasn’t engaging enough to make up for the slower pacing.
I also struggled with the world-building and the sheer number of characters and settings. Even though the story takes place in LA, it never really felt like LA. Everything felt just a little off, almost like I was missing some piece of context that would make the world feel more grounded and cohesive. The different settings also felt disconnected from one another, which made it difficult to fully immerse myself in the story.
I think that disconnect extended to the characters, too. There was so much time devoted to seemingly unnecessary details and family interactions (like the cousins’ wedding), but somehow I still never felt like I really knew the characters. I wanted more depth and connection, not necessarily more scenes of them interacting.
Ultimately, this book felt like it was simultaneously too long and like it needed more room to breathe. There was a lot going on, but not enough of it felt fully developed. I was interested in the story, but I never quite connected with it the way I wanted to.
Initially I was slightly unconvinced by the writing style (misspelling of Lana del Rey's name, over emphasis of certain details like car makes etc which didn't feel necessary as the plot progressed), but the narrative and the siblings were deeply compelling and Cohoe carefully unfurls an original and moving tale of childhood abuse and trauma. The effects in "real" life for the siblings as well as the Other World were crafted with sensitivity and what I felt was a realistic depiction of aftereffects of childhood trauma. Cohoe does not grant answers easily for readers, nor does she offer easily likeable characters, but her choices ultimately pay off and serve to heighten the development of the siblings as characters and the suspense around the late depiction of the Other World in its entirety. The final revelations of the Other World had echoes of Jordan Peele's Us, but not in a way that felt derivative or too closely related, and again presented a truly original exploration of trauma and the effects of abuse in childhood.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Big thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read and review Hunger Pains by Samantha Cohoe.
Hunger Pains lives up to it's premise; twins, Alex and Charlie disappear one night from their home and return a month later missing pieces of themselves with stories of another land filled with horror ruled by monsters. No one believes their tales, including their mother ,and the twins begrudging accept that perhaps their memory of that night is not exactly as they remember. However, 20 years later, the monsters are back, their baby sister is missing and Alex and Charlie have to face what really happened that night.
This book is a wild ride, I started out hating the characters and ended fiercly loving them. Full of trauma, this book will not be for everyone but, if you are in the right headspace I highly recommend.
What worked: Character development Atmosphere Unique premise
What didn't: Story started slow and dragged in sections A lot of characters that did not contribute to the overall story.
Thank you to NetGalley, publisher and the author for an advanced copy of this book!!
When I tell you I ate this book up (pun intended), I absolutely mean it. I finished this within two days!
This book was crazy. Start start off with one of my favourites, we have an unreliable narrator, which ends up intermingling with a messy sibling dynamic (which we realize none of the siblings are reliable and everyone is seemingly unstable and unpredictable). I didn't really catch onto what was happening until the last few chapter when I started putting all the pieces together.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book! The writing was easy to read while also being captivating and ensuring you kept turning the page. I wish we would have gotten a little deeper into the world building on the horror side of things, with maybe a little more background on Grey and what his whole deal was, but overall, it hit the mark and I flew threw this one!
Thank you to Crooked Lane Books and NetGalley for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
I enjoyed the complicated family dynamics in this and how our characters’ childhood trauma affected their relationships with each other. Those parts of the book kept me hooked and wanting to know where things were headed (even though I absolutely HATED the mom), but ultimately I wished the story focused more on the family drama because the horror aspects felt a little out of place. Alex was an interesting and complicated FMC, at times unlikable, but I was invested in her and her siblings. Sadly, the horror elements of this story felt underdeveloped early on, so when they finally played a part in the end, it just felt a little confusing and random. The story is clearly a metaphor for abuse, and while the intent is there, it’s not necessarily effective.
This was a very weird book and took a while to get into. It ended up differently than I thought it would but still strange. I would probably recommend it to people I knew were into the strange and weird but would not recommend to people who don’t like books along those lines.