Penalty Box Queens: A Sapphic Why Choose Hockey Romance

by Kaia Rennox

204 pages, Kindle Edition

Published July 29, 2026

Reviews

[H Reads]

Just another AI book. The author claimed to have just used AI for editing but the book is clearly AI generated. No world building, no depths or chemistry to the characters and very little dialogue.

[Laura McNearney]

Couldn't get past the second page, speech doesn't have quotation marks.

[Terka Čeledová]

I found this book on TikTok through the author’s videos, and based on the aesthetic and captions, I thought it would be really interesting. Unfortunately, I couldn't finish it and had to DNF it. The book definitely had potential, but the writing style just didn't work for me at all. Instead of regular quotation marks, the author uses em dashes for dialogue, and everything is just lumped together without proper formatting, which makes it super confusing to follow. Because of that, I wasn't even able to get through the first chapter. Maybe if the author worked on it a bit more, fixed the formatting and dialogue styling—which makes a huge difference—it could be great. Of course, if the author ever releases a revised edition where these things are corrected, I would definitely give it another try.

[Lisa Emery]

Do not recommend. I was very hopeful, because the basic story sounded interesting. But it's so obvious that its AI generated.

[Katie Simpson]

If I could give this zero stars I would