My thanks to Naxos AudioBooks and libro.fm for an ALC of this book to listen to and review.
Warning: Disjointed rant below, enter at your own risk.
I see you Wilkie Collins.
I see you being BFF's with Charles Dickens, the scumbag who tried to have his wife committed to an asylum so he could be with his chicky-bae instead. I'm glad she was able to escape both being committed AND her crappy husband, who ended up with his chicky-bae anyway. Jerks.
Ok, let me back up a bit here. I LOVED the voice narrator for this book. Nicholas Boulton has some CHOPS. British accent and when delivering the parts by the native German speakers, they had a German accent and they all sounded distinct and you could tell who was talking. It was the ONLY good part of this book. The one star is solely for Mr. Boulton.
I was NOT enjoying this book, so rather than force myself to finish listening to this, I looked for synopsis online and found both the ending AND some personal things about Mr. Wilkie Collins, without meaning to. Usually, I can ignore a bad human who writes well, but if I don't like the writing AND they are a bad human, yeah, no, #sorrynotsorry, I'm not ignoring it.
So. What I didn't like about the book was 1) it made the victim the villainess and 2) it had the villainess act in a way that neither she nor ANY woman in 1828 Germany in her position would have done, all to move the plot the way Mr. Wilkie Collins wanted it to.
1828 Germany, woman had little in the way of wealth and power on their own. Usually they derived both through their family before they wed and then their husband's family after they wed. Not getting married without a family to provide for one could very well be a poverty, if not a death sentence, depending on her skill set. Yes, not all women back then were poor, dependent on family/husband or lived in less than positive circumstances, but I would hazard to say a good portion of them did. (Disclaimer: I am not an authority on the 1820s, of any country. If I am wrong, please direct me to books so I can learn more.)
Madame Fonatine came from a high-born family. She married her husband on the belief that he was a doctor and would therefore make money and she would be comfortable. Since she married below her station, against the wish of her father, he disowned her and she was cut off from her family. Her husband then decided to be a college chemistry professor in a podunk little place and he went into debt to fund his chemical experiments. She went into debt to get nice clothes for her and her daughter, the light of her life. She would do ANYthing for her daughter's happiness.
Since she was higher-born than the ladies in the podunk place, she disdained being friendly with them, so rumors of her pride and her debt were spread about by ladies who had nothing better to do with their time.
Her husband died and being left with debt, she cozened an older man to buy up all of her debt into one and she signed an IOU to him. Before he could destroy it, he died and the man who inherited the IOU was a hard man who was going to get what was owed him. She didn't know that until it was too late.
You know who DID know that before it was too late? The narrator of the tale, who DIDN'T TELL HER. He just up and went to England, la-di-da, not my business to tell her something she might want to know.
Anywho, so her daughter fell in love with a young man, who's father was a wealthy business man, with two partners in the business. He heard the rumors about the widow and decided, without getting her side of the story, that while her daughter was a sweet, innocent lady, the mother was a Jezebel and so sorry son, we can't have THAT kind of woman in the family. Find someone else, you aren't marrying her.
Madame Fontaine then abased herself, MULTIPLE times, to try to meet him or send him letters explaining the gossip. He refused all visits and letters. She met his partner Mr. Engleman, who was old, fat and a fool, who was a bachelor until he met her and then he fell in love.
Here is where this book jumps the shark. After things happen, he proposes to her. Yes, he's old and not ideal marriage material, BUT HE IS WEALTHY. And since he is old, he won't last a long time and when he dies, she would get his money. But what does she do?
She spurns him. So badly he leaves and dies of a broken heart. The narrator in England is sad, because Mr. Engleman was his friend, but if he had told the widow about the debt, she would have probably accepted and he would have probably lived longer and died more happy than he ended up doing.
Seriously, what destitute woman in 1828 would have turned down a wealthy older man in his 70-80s, especially when she was in her 30-40s and probably not going to get a better offer???
Not buying it. It doesn't scan.
So I looked up the end and she does more and more things, spiraling out of control, trying to ensure her daughter marries the man she loves. All because she turned down a proposal no woman of that time would have turned down. POPPYCOCK!
Then I found out Mr. Wilkie Collins was never married, BUT he had TWO women, CONCURRENTLY. He had a widow and a Baby Mama, mother of his three children. When he was tired of the widow, he went to Baby Mama. When he was tired of her, he went to the widow.
Must be nice to be a man in the late 1800s. Those poor women weren't forced, but were they? What sort of life could they have without a man in the picture, even if he was only there part-time?
So yeah, I rage purged all of my Wilkie Collins books (only two, but it was like three to four inches on my Classics bookcase, so #WINNING) and I won't be reading him anymore. He treats his female characters as if they are the bad guys and has them do things no sane woman of the time would have done, so I'm OUT.
1, this star is only for the voice narrator, stars.