The Reappearance of Rachel Price meets Yellowjackets in this pulse-pounding thriller about a girl's search for her missing mother and the complicated truths she uncovers.
Sienna Benson doesn’t exist.
At least, that’s what her dream school says when they can’t verify her identity. But Sienna knows exactly who she is—and once upon a time, a quarter-million followers did, too. Her entire childhood was posted on My Little Mini, her mom's old Instagram account, for anyone to see. How is that not proof enough that she's real?
But then a mysterious letter sends her mom running off into the night. Her mom doesn’t return, but the letters keep coming. Letters written by someone named Mallory. Letters that tell a story Sienna’s heard before, about nine schoolgirls who went missing in the wilderness, but only four made it out alive. Letters, Sienna realizes, about her mother.
As Sienna searches for her missing mom, she must confront the truth of who her mother is and what she’s done—not just all those years ago, but with My Little Mini. And if her mother truly is the monster everyone says she is, what does that make Sienna?
Perfect for fans Twisty, layered thrillers Mysteries with a side of social commentary Feminist stories
Meredith Adamo is the critically acclaimed and award-winning author of Not Like Other Girls (April 2024) and the forthcoming You Made Me (May 2027). Not Like Other Girls was the recipient of the 2025 William C. Morris YA Debut Award, the Green Mountain Book Award, and the Southern Book Prize for Young Readers, and it was also selected for the Chicago Public Library Best of the Best, BookPage Best Young Adult Books of 2024, ALA Rise: A Feminist Book Project List, Kids' Indie Next List, and the May 2024 Target YA Book Club, among other accolades.
Meredith is currently based in North Carolina, but she's originally from Rochester, New York, which is her favorite place on the planet. Her non-writing interests include collecting vintage bakeware, crocheting the ugliest blankets you've ever seen, and grocery shopping.
My second child YOU MADE ME is officially Goodreads official! (No, I didn't think through "officially official" before I started typing.)
I can't wait to share more about this book—especially its GORGEOUS cover—but for now, know it's a YA thriller that's The Reappearance of Rachel Price meets Yellowjackets, in which the daughter of a parenting influencer discovers ties between her missing mother and a controversial tragedy decades earlier.
This book has everything... a mean bisexual lead, found family, a himbo jock love interest, road trips, multiple formats and POVs (letters, journal entries, blog posts, social media DMs), one reference to The Grinch, a deeply complicated mother/daughter relationship, and cannibalism. Allegedly.
This is, without a doubt, one of the best thrillers I have ever read. The characterization is off the charts, an entire cast that spans generations fully fleshed out through a singular first person POV. Meredith Adamo writes sharp girls like no other, and paired with the themes of abuse and exploitation, it makes for an undeniable masterpiece. All of this, paired with a Yellowjackets feel, made it so incredibly easy to fall head over heels for this book. I cannot speak highly enough of it.
Thank you NetGalley and Bloomsbury YA for the ARC in exchange for an honest review!
“You Made Me” by Meredith Adamo is a sharp, twisty YA mystery about identity, family secrets, and the terrifying possibility that you might become the person you've spent your whole life trying to escape. This is definitely an upper YA book with content warnings including emotional abuse, childhood trauma, and exploitation of minors on social media. Also, an absolutely boatload of cursing.
Sienna Benson just wants to get into college, escape her emotionally manipulative mother, and build a life that has absolutely nothing to do with the woman who raised her, which is completely understandable. Especially when your entire childhood has been documented on your mother's social media account for hundreds of thousands of strangers to watch. Because nothing says healthy parenting quite like turning your child into an online personality before she can even understand what that means.
But when Sienna's dream college can't verify her identity, things start getting weird. Then her mother receives a mysterious letter and disappears. And suddenly, Sienna is left trying to figure out where her mom went, who she really is, and why someone is so determined to expose her past.
Turns out, Sienna's mother may have a lot more baggage than your average emotionally unavailable parent.
Years earlier, she was one of nine teenage girls who disappeared into the wilderness. Only four survived. Now, letters written under another name begin arriving, revealing pieces of what happened to the girls during those months. And as Sienna digs deeper, she discovers that her mother's past is far more complicated, and much darker, than she ever imagined.
Oh, and apparently her mother faked her own death and assumed a new identity at some point. There is a lot going on, but it was very interesting and unique. I was sucked in immediately.
The mystery itself was really compelling, especially once the letters and journal entries started revealing what happened to the girls in the wilderness. I loved getting those glimpses into the past and slowly piecing together the truth alongside Sienna.
Honestly, I found the mother's journal entries even more interesting than Sienna's present-day investigation at times. There is something especially fascinating about gradually discovering who someone was before they became the person you know, particularly when that person is your own mother. The more Sienna learns, the more she has to question everything she thought she understood about her family.
But what really makes this book work is that it's not just a mystery about a missing mother. It's also about Sienna trying to figure out who she is when the person who shaped her entire life might be a terrible person.
Sienna is definitely not the most immediately likable protagonist. She's prickly, defensive, and sometimes downright mean, while also caring a lot about what other people think of her. But the more you understand her childhood and the way her mother treated her, the more her behavior makes sense. She's learned to keep people at a distance, yet she desperately wants to be liked. She's determined to become successful and escape her mother's influence, but she's also terrified that she might be just like her. She is also a very unique YA protagonist, which I loved.
That internal conflict was probably my favorite part of the book. Sienna isn't simply trying to uncover her mother's secrets. She's trying to determine whether the worst things people say about her mother might also be true about herself. How do you separate your identity from the person who raised you, especially when so much of your childhood was shaped by their choices?
The book also explores the exploitation of children through social media, particularly the way parents can turn their kids' lives into content for an audience. Sienna's childhood was never entirely her own, and the fallout from that becomes another layer of her struggle to figure out who she is. I thought this was an interesting addition, although at times the social media commentary felt a little disconnected from the wilderness mystery. There is so much going on here that I occasionally wondered whether two separate books had accidentally been combined.
Thankfully, Sienna doesn't have to figure everything out alone. A group of friends and almost-friends gradually rally around her, and I really enjoyed the found-family aspect of the story. Kendra was easily a standout for me. I love when a character can bring some humor and personality into an otherwise emotionally exhausting situation, and she was a welcome addition to the chaos.
The pacing took a little while to get going for me. The opening spends quite a bit of time on Sienna's high school life and personal drama before the central mystery really kicks into gear. Once her mother disappears and the letters start arriving, though, I was much more invested. The twists kept coming, and while a couple of the later revelations stretched my suspension of disbelief a bit, I still found the overall mystery satisfying.
I'd also describe this as more of a character-driven psychological drama with thriller elements than a nonstop, action-packed thriller. The investigation is interesting, but the emotional heart of the story is Sienna confronting the truth about her mother and deciding what that truth means for her own future.
And I really appreciated that the story doesn't pretend breaking the cycle of trauma is easy. The characters are complicated, damaged, and sometimes frustrating, but they're all trying to survive their own circumstances. The ending is a little bittersweet, with some things left unresolved, but I liked that it focused more on letting go of the past and moving forward than magically fixing everything.
Overall, if you enjoy messy mother-daughter relationships and stories that make you question how much you can ever really know about your own family, put this one on your TBR.
The way Meredith Adamo writes about girls who deserve more is simply like no other. YOU MADE ME is smart and heart-pounding and such a solid mystery. It’s honestly a crime that I read it this early because now I have to wait even longer for whatever Adamo writes next.
Thank you to Edelweiss and the publisher for the eARC!
Wow, NO ONE is doing it like Meredith Adamo!!! Full disclosure: Not Like Other Girls flayed me open and healed some pretty deep wounds so I was excited but also nervous for her next book? But this was so good, I couldn’t put it down. Meredith writes complicated young women SO well, never pruning their sharper edges to make them more palatable or likable. But they deserve love and respect and dignity too. Thanks for always looking out for the feral girls, Meredith.
I was lucky enough to get an early peek of this book and I was immediately sucked in by the first page and could barely tear myself away. More incredible voice and hard hitting understanding of the experiences of teen girls from the author of one of my favorite ever contemporary YAs, Not Like Other Girls.