From Fabian Nicieza, Edgar Award finalist and co-creator of Deadpool, comes a psychological horror-thriller about one man's darkest secrets and the terrible acts they can inspire in the wrong hands... or mind.
At age sixteen, Grissom Vandermeer lost his memory and his family in a tragic car accident. Twenty years later, hoping to reclaim what he had lost, Vandermeer has developed a revolutionary process to turn memories into images and audio, in essence digitizing life experience into a scroll on your phone.
In his rush to prove its efficacy, Vandermeer experiments on himself and unwittingly unleashes all of the darkest secrets he’s buried inside his own scarred psyche, broadcasting them to the residents of his town. The guilts, mistakes, angers, and prejudices of his misspent youth are broadcast into the innocent minds of the small Pennsylvania town of Eboncross.
Now, Vandermeer must track down and retrieve these scattered memories before the townsfolk become corrupted by them. But what if some of his most violent memories have found their way into people already plagued by their own deadly desires? What if his memories are creating rapists, thieves and killers? In order to stop their escalating violence, Vandermeer will have to first come to terms with his own darkest sins.
Fabian Nicieza is a writer and editor who is best known as the co-creator of DEADPOOL and for his work on Marvel titles such as X-Men, X-Force, New Warriors, and Robin.
His first novel, the Edgar Award-nominated SUBURBAN DICKS, a sarcastic murder mystery, is on sale now from Putnam Books.
The Dicks will return in THE SELF-MADE WIDOW, coming June 21st.
And here I call myself reading an ARC super early because I was told that this book would fall in line with the genres that I typically love to read…
Last time I checked…Sci-fi wasn’t one of them…
According to the email invitation that I received, The Memory Catcher is supposed to be a Psychological Thriller. It’s been 9 hours since I’ve finished this and I am more convinced than ever that The Memory Catcher should be labeled as both Sci-fi and Contemporary Fiction. Oooh. And there should be a list of trigger warnings, especially if the author is looking for a female audience. I honestly don’t know who has been reading my NetGalley profile but, sending me this book was a HUGE mistake. And honestly, I am pretty upset about it. Reading The Memory Catcher didn’t just make me angry. I have found myself beyond pissed off because I feel like I wasted two days worth of reading time. And we all know: Time wasted is something a person cannot get back.
I lost interest in The Memory Catcher upon finishing Chapter 3. At first I just thought that it was all the science (my least favorite subject in school) terminology and difficulty pronouncing some of the words that the author used to describe things. However, the more determination I put into reading this book the worst things got for me. I couldn’t connect with the MMC “Grissom Vandermeer” or any of his friends. His relationship with Sam, The Vet, gave me more anxiety than happiness. Having to read about Grissom’s memories caused me so much anger that I wanted to throw my Kindle across the room. In all honesty, I wish I would’ve listened to my gut and DNF’d this after 6%. Had it not been for the “Read Aloud” option on the NetGalley app, I would still be suffering through this right now (my Kindle told me that it would’ve taken me 22hrs and 15 minutes to finish this and I wasn’t having that.) Had it also not been for the fact that The Memory Catcher was an ARC that I was invited to read, I honestly wouldn’t be picking this up in 2027 no matter how interesting I found the synopsis.
The Memory Catcher is one of those books that has a very interesting premise but should be created as a movie. From my personal experience, I had difficulty not just enjoying this but also following along with each chapter. I wish I could say that it’s the format of the ARC that was the issue but, really it’s the story as a whole. I just didn’t have fun reading this. The writing was too confusing and I found myself severely bored. Each chapter felt too long and lacked coherent explanations. Given the premise of this story, using AI terminology and thinking that big and fancy words are going to suddenly make us regular people understand what in the world is going on is a huge mistake. Some of us need to be talked to like we are between the ages of 5-12 when it comes to science terms and AI functions. This book is written like we should know what the hell is going on and, because it’s 2026, a reader should know that AI is the future end of story. Having this type of attitude or feeling this way while reading a book is going to DEFINITELY result into people losing interest. To be glad that I am done with this book is an understatement. I have this overwhelming need to cancel all of my plans this weekend and read, at least, 3 books just to get this one out of my head.
Given that this story is divided into 3 parts, one would think that I, at least, found one part interesting. But, no. I just found myself starting at the “time left” on my Kindle and worked really hard to get this story over with. Not to throw shade but, just because you create movies and write scripts, it doesn’t mean you should write a book. I am having trouble believing that the editor of this book had a great time reading it.
Were there some parts that were interest?!?! Yes.
Were they enough to keep me focused and wanting to recommend this to my friends and family members?!?! No.
Will this book find its audience?!?! Probably.
Honestly, I think this book is going to experience a lot of 1 star and DNF reviews before anyone truly gives it a chance. I am not saying that The Memory Catcher is a bad book. I am saying that my experience with it was bad. Between my difficulty understanding what in the world was going on to the scientific terminology that was constantly being used, I just couldn’t muster interest in this. Sci-fi is one of a few genres that I avoid at all costs. My main goal while reading a book is to relax, escape, and enjoy the literature. Not spend every 2 minutes googling the pronunciation of each word. I don’t mind being invited to review an ARC. I would just greatly appreciate it if I was given books that I could brag about (in a more positive manner.)
Wishing Fabian Nicieza all the best on his future endeavors, especially his writing career!!!
Thank you to NetGalley and Minotaur Books for the invitation to read this Advance Reader’s Copy in exchange for my honest and personal opinion!!!
Just got a widget from the publisher to read this one, and saw the author is the co creator of... Deadpool? What? I don't know what to think about this, but I accepted so we shall see!
The Memory Catcher by Fabian Nicieza Received as an ARC. Grissom lost his memory in a car accident 20 years ago. He’s been working on a way to save memories as images, etc in a form of AI. He just needs the funding. He is impatient to get results now. But the 5 years of grants come in safety time restraints. His at home unauthorized test on himself works and does not. He saw memories he lost but where they were to be stored is empty. Where were his thoughts sent? Around town people are doing strange things not of their nature. As he retrieves some of his memories and seeing the things others are doing he’s wondering who he was prior to the accident he lost his memories. He wants his sealed juvenile records. He hates seeing who he was before He and a couple loyal friend coworkers try to fix 5⭐️
Fabian Nicieza's The Memory Catcher was a frustrating read as the premise and execution were sometimes at odds. More speculative fiction than sci-fi, the story involves a scientist, Grissom Vandermeer, who is developing a "memory catcher" to retrieve memories he lost after a car accident that killed his family when he was sixteen. While experimenting with the device, his lost memories are accidentally dispersed through his small Pennsylvania town with horrific results.
The premise leads to an interesting non reliable narrative found in stories like Memento, Total Recall (Philip K Dick - don't come at me), Black Mirror - The Entire History of You, etc. but is undercut by slow pacing and some paper thin characters. I found it hard to root for Grissom, especially as his past is slowly revealed. There is an interesting theme that is explored in depth about whether someone's past makes them who they are, but the memory loss aspect does a lot of glossing over of some truly horrible actions that I found hard to ignore or forgive. Grissom's relationship with a local veterinarian who helps him navigate his situation was too shallow for the importance it has to the story. I think more time could have been spent on building that relationship rather than some of the scooby doo mystery reveals and would have made the ending much more impactful. The antagonist of the story is completely shallow and relies on violence, racism and sexual assault to define his badness.
There was a lot I liked about the book. If the issues I mentioned in the previous paragraph were tweaked 10%, this would be an easy 4 star recommendation. There are times when Grissom comes across as a completely different person who is likeable and you want to root for him. There are times when his relationships, especially with his coworkers (and dog) show that Nicieza can develop characters without relying on violent trauma. The slow mystery of Grissom's past and the memory echo concept is genuinely interesting and made me want to read on. The effect of Grissom's memories on the populace made for a terrifying concept that was used to great effect. I just wish the characters lived up to the concept.
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin’s press for this ARC!
4 1/2
First of all, the premise to this book is very interesting and very in tune to the current way technology shapes our lives. While the concept of the Memory Catcher might not be something that could ever exist in the real world, the way it is explained and executed makes it feel almost as if it really could. I also really enjoyed that it showcased consequences to AI use and the impact of datacenters without feeling overly preachy.
I enjoyed the world building, everything was very descriptive, not flowery but written with a very close attention to detail that made every setting easy to picture while reading, which is always important to me. Nearly all characters in this book, even small side characters had their backstories explained and it expanded the world of the book and gave it a lot of life. The only downside to this is that sometimes this would kill tension in a scene with expansive exposition.
Speaking of tension, it never goes away. This book would definitely benefit from a tw list at the beginning since there are several dark and disturbing themes that repeat or persist that could upset some readers. I expected a dark book going into this but I feel like others might struggle with some of the rougher scenes.
This also goes for the MMC, Grissom. I expect him to be very polarizing for readers. Even after finishing it I still don’t really know how I feel about him and I believe that’s intentional. The ending was satisfying, and ultimately I agree with how things wrapped up but honestly it’s a sign of a good book if it keeps you thinking after it’s finished.
Thanks to NetGalley and Kat White with St. Martin’s Press for this advance reader’s copy, in exchange for an honest review. “The Memory Catcher” is scheduled for release on May 18, 2027. There’s science, and then there’s plot and pacing. “The Memory Catcher” had way too much of the former, and far too little of the latter. At least for the approximately one-third of what I read. Marketed as a “psychological horror-thriller,” I found none of that as I attempted to understand all the science jargon that fills the early chapters. I got tired of researching the terminology, and with no enticing storyline to keep me going, I ran out of patience. What originally drew me in was a promising premise. “…one man’s darkest secrets and the terrible acts they can inspire in the wrong hands, or mind.” That sounded interesting. But it just took too darn long to get there, IF it ever got there. Just one star for “The Memory Catcher.” The only recommendation I can offer is for a major re-write prior to its May 18, 2027 publication date. And you can read all my reviews at my Raised on Reading (www.raisedonreading.com) blog site. A new review is posted every Monday.
Thank you St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for this advanced reader copy.
Unfortunately, the writing was really rough and really needs a lot of work to keep the flow. The first chapter ends which over explaining what the main character is going to do. Losing the tension that could've drawn the reader to need to know what they were going to do.
Then we spend a few pages with history of the small town he lives in next to the university city. I found myself skimming as there was a page history lesson of said home town. Followed by a cliché diner scene with the locals "joking with the main character" that felt forced. Then for some reason he has a cleaning lady who felt very stereotypical.
Most of this didn't add anything to the story and lost all of the tension we could've had from this character making a big move to experiment on himself.
I think there could be an interesting story to explore here, but the writing needs a lot of work. Ultimately what I did read felt like a first draft.
I have been a big fan of Fabian Nicieza’s work in the world of comic books. When I saw he had written a novel, I was all in.
Imagine losing your family and your memory in one moment. I imagine you would do anything and everything to remember who you were and the life you had before the accident. That is the situation that Grissom Vandermeer faces.
But as the saying goes…be careful what you wish for.
Nicieza has written a dark mystery. We are piecing together the memories and working through the picture of who Grissom was before the accident. And trust me, the author leads us to some dark places.
I enjoyed (such a weird word considering some of the subject matters involved) this novel and thought the author did a good job for a first time novelist.
Thank you to NetGalley and the Publisher for providing an ARC for an unbiased review.
What if the memories you lost were better left forgotten? Twenty years ago, Grissom survived a tragic car accident that claimed the lives of his parents and sister, leaving him with no memory of his past. Now, alongside his friends and colleagues Mirabella and Pavan, he has developed a groundbreaking invention called the Memory Catcher. But when Grissom brings the device home, he accidentally triggers a mysterious power outage that sends his memories into the minds of unsuspecting strangers. These fragments of his past, known as “echoes,” leave him desperate for answers. Determined to piece together his forgotten life, Grissom sets out to find the people carrying his memories, unaware that some things might be better left buried.
When I received the email from my favorite publisher, St, Martins, I figured I was set to ser in for a fun read. The storyline was promising - it was about forgotten memories. Someone had come up with a plan to retrieve and save the, It made sense, afrwe all the brain is nothing but a computer, right? This should have been fun. Could have.
Shoulda, coulda, woulda but I couldn't get past the 10% mark. The author never got going on the story. He talked about everything else, from funding to testing and wasn't done when I quit.
I'm sorry, y'all for me, there are better books. Do a try before you buy and see if you like his style. I noticed some people love it, but I sure didn't.
Nicieza is up front that this is a failed comic pitch that he developed into a novel instead, and unfortunately, it's real obvious. This is at best overwritten and dark for the sake of being dark. There's also frequent, poorly done info dumps, and overexplanation, and at times gives off the air of an older man trying to understand what the kids are doing these days. The idea he's trying to get across is dark memories in the wrong hands can turn even good people bad, but it largely ends up hamfisted, and in bad need of another editing pass or two. Worth having experienced, but needs some touchups before release.
(2 3/4). This book started out as just weird, one of those stories where science/technology goes sideways and takes on a life of its own. That part was fairly interesting and pretty tolerable. Then we went on to a different track and the story just went downhill. Massive stupidity, and a combination of strangeness and sappiness come to play. It was a little too long to top it off. Not the best but I do appreciate the freebie from NetGalley. Very medium stuff.
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
This book made me feel like I was watching a mediocre 1980s movie or an episode of a CW show. And not in a good way. I really tried to go along with the premise, but the fact it tried so hard to base it in science really lost me. I could not care much for the main character, or any character really. The overall writing is pretty decent though.
I too received an invitation from St. Martin's Press (one of my FAVORITE Publishers) to read the ARC of The Memory Catcher by Fabian Nicieza and I have to say it looks like something that I could really like! I hope to be able to provide a positive review in the coming weeks!! Deadpool is certainly a favorite of mine! I hope that this will become one too! :)
The Memory Catcher by new to me author Fabian Nicieza is a stand alone psychological thriller published by St. Martin's Press. I read the blurb and was intrigued. So I started reading anf pretty quick I learned this book is not for me. I couldn't for the live of me connect with the characters or get into the story. The writing is ok and I liked the cover.